You are on page 1of 6

2019 Prognostics & System Health Management Conference—Qingdao (PHM-2019 Qingdao)

$$<M*GJ.PJK<D8K@:!I8D<NFIB=FI+IF>EFJK@:
(F;<C'@=<:P:C<(8E8><D<EK



5@H@"LF/@E>N<E8F2<ECFE>2L?8F%@E  %8P'<<
$E;LJKI@8C$'89<G8IKD<EKF=+IF;L:K- <EK<I=FI$EK<CC@><EK(8@EK<E8E:<.PJK<DJ$(.
P9<I$EJ@>?K/<:?EFCF>PF'K; 0E@M<IJ@KPF=@E:@EE8K@
<@A@E>+<FGC<XJ-<GL9C@:F=?@E8 @E:@EE8K@*#0E@K<;.K8K<JF=D<I@:8

:?8F
A@E:P9<I @EJ@>?K
:FD


  1 !* (() ()'('**  
-(*  */*+%+! K<:?EFCF>P I<8;@E<JJ C<M<C /-' K?8K :8E 9< LJ<; KF
)%.')# +' )**  $$&* ' -$'(!& & LE;<IJK8E; K?< D8KLI@KP F= GIF>EFJK@:J
 (FI<FM<I
'()+!'&$!0!& %'$*!&%&,+,)!&!&,*+)!*.!+ & .8EB8I8I8D8E 6 7 ;@M<J @EKF K?< @JJL< F= LE:<IK8@EKP
%( *!* '& ()'&'*+!* & $+  %&%&+   D8E8><D<EK N@K? 8E <DG?8J@J FE I<D8@E@E> LJ<=LC C@=<
(($!+!'&* (()*+)+*/!&+)',!&+ )'.!&&' GI<;@:K@FE
 #< @EK<IGI<KJ LE:<IK8@EKP =IFD 8 8P<J@8E
$)+!&   %'$ -$'(%&+ & & &!& !+* $!/$ G<IJG<:K@M< 8E; GIFGFJ<J :FDGLK8K@FE8C 8GGIF8:?<J =FI
)$!!$!+/!&!&,*+)!$ */*+%* )%.')#')!&,*+)!$ LE:<IK8@EKPHL8EK@=@:8K@FE8E;GIFG8>8K@FE
+I<M@FLJNFIBJC@B<
    
-(* !* + & ()'('* .!+  #/ '%('&&+* K?<J<C8PK?<>IFLE;NFIB=FIFLI;@J:LJJ@FE8JN<CC8JDFK@M8K<
!&$,!& !&,*+)!$ + %&%&+ *+)%$!& %'$
K?<E<<;F=8><E<I8C<E>@E<<I@E>=I8D<NFIB=FI@E;LJKI@8C$
+)!&!&)!*#%'&!+')!&&%'$,(+&!*!'&*,((')+
& # +) +!$ !&+)',+!'& ' +  ,&+!'& &
8GGC@:8K@FEJ

()!&!($* '   '%('&&+ & !%($%&++!'& ' +  $E K?@J G8G<I N< GIFGFJ< $$ <M*GJ 8 =I8D<NFIB =FI
*,((')+!&($+')%!*!$$,*+)+')+ ))&'+ ))* GIF>EFJK@: DF;<C C@=<:P:C< D8E8><D<EK N@K? K?< F9A<:K@M< F=
!+ +  $('+   
-(*)%.')#+ ,+ ')*$!- J?FIK<E@E> K?< V>F KF D8IB<KW :P:C< F= @E;LJKI@8C $
+ +!&+)!*!($!&)/&!&)!&+%*&'$$')+++)+' 8GGC@:8K@FEJ N?@C< ?8E;C@E> I<8C NFIC; LE:<IK8@EK@<J
$)++ !%($%&++!'&' */*+%**.$$*)') 8GGIFGI@8K<CP
 /F :FEJKIL:K K?< =I8D<NFIB N< 9FIIFN B<P
!&,*+)!$ (($!+!'&*!&%&,+,)!&!&,*+)!*
:FE:<GKJ=IFD<M*GJ8D<K?F;FCF>P@EJF=KN8I<<E>@E<<I@E>
 
  
=FI:FEK@ELFLJ;<C@M<IPF=8JPJK<D8E;I<@EM<EKK?<D@E
  K?<:FEK<OKF=@E;LJKI@8C$8GGC@:8K@FEJ

/?< I<JK F= K?< G8G<I @J FI>8E@Q<; 8J =FCCFNJ .<:K@FE $$
$
 $)/-*0/$*) 8E8CPQ<J K?< <E>@E<<I@E> :?8CC<E><J @E ;<M<CFG@E> +#(
8GGC@:8K@FEJ8E;=LIK?<I@CCLJKI8K<JK?<E<<;=FIDF;<CC@=<:P:C<
0E;<I K?< =CFLI@J?@E> KI<E; F= ;@>@K8C KI8EJ=FID8K@FE @E
D8E8><D<EK .<:K@FE $$$ GI<J<EKJ K?< 8I:?@K<:KLI< F= K?< $$
D8EL=8:KLI@E>GIF>EFJK@:J8E;?<8CK?D8E8><D<EK+#(?8J
<M*GJ=I8D<NFIB8E;@KJ;<J@>EGI@E:@GC<J@E;<K8@C.<:K@FE
9<:FD<8C<8;@E>LJ<:8J<F=@E;LJKI@8C$@EI<:<EKP<8IJ6 7

$1>@M<J8E@DGC<D<EK8K@FEF=@KJJLGGFIK@E>GC8K=FID.<:K@FE
+IF>EFJK@:DF;<CJ<E89C<K?<8E8CPJ@JF=D8:?@E<;8K8@EI<8C
1 :FE:CL;<J K?< G8G<I 9P JLDD8I@Q@E> @KJ :FEKI@9LK@FE 8E;
K@D< 8E; GI<;@:K GFK<EK@8C =8@CLI< 8E; FI I<D8@E@E> LJ<=LC C@=<
8I<8J=FI=LKLI<JKL;P

-0' F= K?< DFE@KFI<; D8:?@E< :FDGFE<EK
 $EJ@>?KJ
><E<I8K<;9PGIF>EFJK@:JDF;<CJ:8E9<LJ<;KF?<CGFG<I8KFIJ
J:?<;LC< D8@EK<E8E:< 8:K@M@K@<J GIF8:K@M<CP 8E; @DGIFM< $$
 )"$) -$)"#'' )" .$) 1 '*+$)"
FM<I8CCFG<I8K@FE<==@:@<E:P
 +-*")*./$.)# '/#()" ( )/++'$/$*).
CK?FL>? D<K?F;FCF>@<J I<C8K<; KF K?< ;<M<CFGD<EK F= ::FI;@E>KF8JLIM<PGL9C@J?<;9P+N@E 6 7FECP
GIF>EFJK@:DF;<CJ?8M<9<<E8:K@M<CPI<J<8I:?<;@EELD<IFLJ  F= K?<  JLIM<P<; D8EL=8:KLI@E> :FDG8E@<J ?8;
@E;LJKI@<JN@E;<E<I>P6   7)D@CC@E>676 7<K:
 JL::<JJ=LCCP C8LE:?<; GI<;@:K@M< D8@EK<E8E:< @E ?FLJ< N?@:?
C@D@K<; 8GGC@:8K@FEJ ?8M< 9<<E JL::<JJ=LCCP C8LE:?<; @E @JCFN<IK?8ED8IB<K<OG<:K8K@FE
$E><E<I8CK?<I<8I<D8AFI
GIF;L:K@FE8E;;<GCFP<;8KJ:8C<FI8:?@<M<;;<J@I<;I<KLIE F= :?8CC<E><J @DG<;@E> <E>@E<<IJ =IFD ;<M<CFG@E> +#(
@EM<JKD<EK-*$6 76 767
/?<8LK?FIJ9<C@<M<K?8K@K@J 8GGC@:8K@FEJ@EI<8CNFIC;
D8@ECP 9<:8LJ< F= C8:B@E> @E KI8@E@E> ;8K8 8E; C8I>< •  ')+ ' (()'()!+ +)!&!& + $E;LJKI@8C
<EM@IFED<EKM8I@8E:<J6 76 7
/F8;;I<JJK?@J@JJL<%8M<;'4 ;8K8 @E I<8C NFIC; JL==<I =IFD  :?8CC<E><J @
<

#- 67 GIFM@;< 8 :FDGI<?<EJ@M< I<M@<N F= JK8K< F= 8IK 98;HL8C@KP9IFB<E9<CFN JLI=8:<67
)FKFECP;F<J
GIF>EFJK@:J 8C>FI@K?DJ 8E; K?<@I 8GGC@:89@C@KP LE;<I ;@==<I<EK @K I<HL@I< J@>E@=@:8EK <==FIKJ KF :FE;L:K ;8K8 :C<8E@E>
JPJK<D :FE;@K@FEJ
 /?<P 8CJF ;@J:LJJ 8 =I8D<NFIB F= 8E; GI<GIF:<JJ@E> 9LK K?< KI8@E@E> ;8K8 @J F=K<E

 +IF>EFJK@:J.PJK<D#<8CK?(8E8><D<EKFE=<I<E:<U,@E>;8F
978-1-7281-0861-2/19/$31.00 ©2019 IEEE +#(  ,@E>;8F

Authorized licensed use limited to: Pontificia Universidad Catolica Del Peru. Downloaded on August 05,2021 at 04:12:59 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
@EJL==@:@<EK <JG<:@8CCP K?< 8DFLEK F= =8@CLI< C89<CJ
 GIF;L:K@FE <EM@IFED<EK N?@:? D8IBJ K?< KI8EJ@K@FE KF K?<
0EC@B< DFJK :FEJLD<I $EK<IE<K 8GGC@:8K@FEJ N?<I< *GJG?8J<
/?<DF;<CN@CCK?<EGI<;@:KFEI<8C K@D<;8K8KF
K?< MFCLD< F= KI8@E@E> ;8K8 @J F=K<E 8K 8 ?@>? C<M<C GIFM@;<@EJ@>?KJKFK?<LJ<IJ
KK?<J8D<K@D<@KJG<I=FID8E:<
;8K8=FIGIF>EFJK@:DF;<CKI8@E@E>@JLJL8CCPJD8CC
$K N@CC 8CJF 9< :FEK@ELFLJCP DFE@KFI<;
 $E :8J< F= 8E 89EFID8C
:8LJ<J 98II@<IJ <JG<:@8CCP =FI ;<M<CFG<IJ N@K?FLK <M<EK JL:? 8J G<I=FID8E:< ;<K<I@FI8K@FE ;8K8 I<>@D< J?@=K
;FD8@EBEFNC<;><KFFM<I:FD<K?<:FC; JK8IKJK8><
 LJ<I I<HL@I<D<EK :?8E><J <K:
 K?< DF;<C N@CC I< <EK<I K?<
<MG?8J<=FI=LIK?<ILG;8K<
FDG8I<;N@K?8; ?F:DF;<C
• ) )$.')$ ,&)+!&+/ $E D8EL=8:KLI@E> KI8@E@E>GI8:K@:<J/89C<$C@JKJK?<>F8CJK?8K<E>@E<<IJ?FG<KF
I<C@89@C@KP 8E; IF9LJKE<JJ F= 8 JPJK<D @J G8I8DFLEK
 8:?@<M<K?IFL>?$$<M*GJ

#FN<M<I GIF>EFJK@: DF;<CJ C8I><CP JL==<I =IFD
LED8E8><; I<8C NFIC; LE:<IK8@EK@<J JL:? 8J 8
NFIB@E> I<>@D< J?@=K F= DFE@KFI<; D8:?@E<J 8E
LG;8K<@EGIF;L:K@FEI<:@G<8:?8E><@E<EM@IFED<EK
:FE;@K@FEJ FI <M<E ?LD8E @DG8:KJ <K:
 2?@C<
9L@C;@E> 8 DF;<C K?8K @J M8C@;8K<; LE;<I 8CC GFJJ@9C<
:FE;@K@FEJ@J;<J@I<;@K@JM<IPLEC@B<CPKF:FDGC<K<CP
8MF@; LE:<IK8@EK@<J
 2?<E <E:FLEK<I@E> M8I@8E:< FI
LEBEFNE I<>@D<J K?< DF;<C E<<;J KF I<;L:< K?<
GFJJ@9@C@KP F= =@I@E> =8CJ< 8C8IDJ N?@C< 9<@E> 89C< KF
8;8GK KF E<N J@KL8K@FEJ
 /?@J NFLC; I<HL@I< :FEJK8EK
LG;8K<J FI I<9L@C;@E> F= K?< DF;<C N?@C< @KJ
<E>@E<<I@E>:FJK8;;J:FEJKI8@EJKFK?<GIF9C<D
 
•
!!,$+/ !& !&+)!*!($!&)/ '$$')+!'& /?<
JL::<JJ=LC ;<C@M<IP F= 8 +#( 8GGC@:8K@FE I<HL@I<J !@>LI<
 /?<$E;LJKI@8C$$$<M*GJ:P:C<
@EK<I;@J:@GC@E8IP :FCC89FI8K@FE =IFD ?8I;N8I<
<E>@E<<IJ ;8K8 <E>@E<<IJ ;8K8 J:@<EK@JKJ JF=KN8I<
/' $
 * % /$1 .*!$$ 1*+.
<E>@E<<IJ 8E; ;FD8@E <OG<IKJ / / +/ */
E8D<CP;8K8K<:?EFCF>P 8E8CPK@:JK<:?EFCF>P GC8K=FID + "+!-*
K<:?EFCF>P FG<I8K@FE K<:?EFCF>P 6 7
 /?< 
GIF>EFJK@: DF;<C ?8J KF 9< @EK<>I8K<; @EKF K?< =@E8C • +)%$!&(F;<C;<M<CFGD<EK
JPJK<D@E8E8>@C<8E;I<G<8K89C<D8EE<I@EFI;<IKF GIF:<JJ@JJKI<8DC@E<;N?<I<JK8E;8I;
9L@C;@E>9CF:BJ8I<:FEE<:K<;KF><K?<IKF
;<C@M<I8E;FG<I8K@FE8C@Q<K?<DF;<C@EGIF;L:K@FE

=FID8:FDGC<K<KI8@E@E>G@G<C@E<

J 8 I<JLCK K?< :?8CC<E><J C<8; KF 8 CFE> 8E; JFD<K@D<J (F;<C<M<CFGD<EK • ,*!$!+//I8@E@E>G@G<C@E<J8I<9L@CK
<M @E8I<LJ89C<D8EE<I

LE:FEKIFCC89C< ;<M<CFGD<EK :P:C< F= +#( 8GGC@:8K@FEJ
 CJF
• )!$!+/ M<IPLG;8K<FI
;L<KFC@D@K<;8;8GK89@C@KPF=K?<GIF>EFJK@:DF;<CLE;<J@I89C< DF;@=@:8K@FEF=K?<DF;<C8E;@KJ
I@JBJ 8I< 8;;<; @EKF GIF;L:K@FE 8E; LE;<ID@E< :LJKFD<I :FII<JGFE;@E>D<K8@E=FID8K@FE:8E9<
:FE=@;<E:<
 /F 8;;I<JJ K?<J< :?8CC<E><J K?< $$ <M*GJ KI8:<;

=I8D<NFIB @J GIFGFJ<; @E K?< E<OK J<:K@FE KF JPJK<D8K@:8CCP 
D8E8><D8AFIK?<<EK@I<C@=<:P:C<F=8GIF>EFJK@:DF;<CN?@:? 
<E89C<J <==@:@<EK DF;<C ;<M<CFGD<EK 8E; :FDGI<?<EJ@M< I@JB • %$**!&+)+!'&(F;<CJ:8E9<
<8J@CP@EK<>I8K<;@EKFK?<JF=KN8I<JPJK<D
D8E8><D<EK
 N@K?=<N<IIFIJFI=C8NJ

• !*#%&%&+(F;<CJK8KLJ:8E9<
$$$
 -#$/ /0- *!/# $$ 1*+.!-( 2*-& :FEJK8EKCPDFE@KFI<;FE:<;<GCFP<;@E
K?<GIF;L:K@FE<EM@IFED<EKKF<EJLI<
(F;<C*G<I8K@FE I<C@89C<FLKGLK8E;K@D<CPDF;<CLG;8K<J

 6'26+'7 *GJ • &+)()+!$!+/(F;<CFLKGLKJ:8E9<
<M*GJ @J :FDDFECP ;<=@E<; 8J 8 J<K F= JF=KN8I< N<CC <OGC8@E<;KF<E; LJ<IJK?IFL>?
;<M<CFGD<EK GI8:K@:<J K?8K :FD9@E< ;<M<CFGD<EK <M 8E; ;FD8@E @E=FID<;M@JL8C@Q8K@FEKFJLGGFIK
E<8II<8C K@D<;<:@J@FE8E;=<<;98:B

FG<I8K@FEJ *GJ KF J?FIK<E K?< ;<C@M<IP :P:C< N?@C< <EJLI@E>
• $(+!-(F;<CJ8I<<OG<:K<;KF
?@>? HL8C@KP F= K?< JF=KN8I< 6 7
 FDG8I<; N@K? <M*GJ J<D@ 8LKFD8K@:8CCP<MFCM<KF<E89C<
@EJF=KN8I<<E>@E<<I@E>@E;LJKI@8C$$$<M*GJ=F:LJ<JFE <==@:@<EKDF;<CLG;8K<J

D8E8>@E> K?< C@=<:P:C< 8E; LE:<IK8@EK@<J F= $ DF;<CJ
 J 
J?FNE @E !@>LI<  8E $$ <M*GJ :P:C< JK8IKJ N@K? DF;<C 
8I:?@K<:KLI< ;<J@>E N?@:? @J JLGGFIK<; 9P 8 K?FIFL>?
LE;<IJK8E;@E> F= =@<C; I<HL@I<D<EKJ 8E; ;FD8@E BEFNC<;><
 $E FI;<I KF 8:?@<M< K?< 89FM< F9A<:K@M<J K?< =FCCFN@E>
8J<; FE K?8K 8;;@K@FE8C ;8K8 8:HL@J@K@FE ?8I;N8I< D8P 9< =I8D<NFIB @J GIFGFJ<; N@K? B<P :FDGFE<EKJ @E:CL;@E>
@EJK8CC<;
 *E:< KI8@E@E> ;8K8 @J GI<G8I<; ;8K8 J:@<EK@JKJ N@CC @E;LJKI@8C ;8K8 D8E8><D<EK JKI<8DC@E<; DF;<C KI8@E@E> I@JB
G<I=FID <OGCFI8KFIP ;8K8 8E8CPJ@J DF;<C KI8@E@E> 8E; DFE@KFI@E> 8E; DF;<C LG;8K< 8E; ;<:@J@FE JLGGFIK 8E;
M8C@;8K@FE
 =K<I F==C@E< G<I=FID8E:< :I@K<I@8 8I< D<K K?< =<<;98:B
 O8DGC<J 8E; K8:K@:J 8I< 8CJF @EKIF;L:<; @E
DF;<C:8E9<@EK<>I8K<;@EKFK?<JF=KN8I<8E;;<GCFP<;@EK?< :FII<JGFE;@E> J<:K@FEJ =FI 8C>FI@K?D@: @DGC<D<EK8K@FE @E K?<
=LKLI<


 +IF>EFJK@:J.PJK<D#<8CK?(8E8><D<EKFE=<I<E:<U,@E>;8F
+#(  ,@E>;8F

Authorized licensed use limited to: Pontificia Universidad Catolica Del Peru. Downloaded on August 05,2021 at 04:12:59 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
#<CC@E><I C@B<
;@JK8E:<8E;
++!*+!$ !@KEFID8C 
=FI&
&FDF>FIFM
!*+)!,+!'& ;@JKI@9LK@FEF= ;@JK8E:<
=FI
;@JK8E:<F=
),$ M@9I8K@FEJ@>E8C # ;@JK8E:<
<DG@I@:8C8E;
=@KK<;;@JKI@9LK@FE
<G<E;JFE
J8DGC@E>
)LD9<IF=
=I<HL<E:P @E
LE@HL<GF@EKJ@E
('!&+),$ ) GF@EK K?@J:8J<;L<KF
K?<M@9I8K@FE
M<IP?@>?
J@>E8C
J8DGC@E>
=I<HL<E:P
)LD9<IF=
 +FIK@FEF=LE@HL<
('!&+ LE@HL<GF@EKJ@E 
@EK?@J
GF@EKJKFK?<
 # K?<M@9I8K@FE :8J<
!@>LI<
 I:?@K<:KLI<F=K?<$$<M*GJ!I8D<NFIB C<E>K?F=;8K8J<K
J@>E8C
+FIK@FEF=
=FIK?@J
'*!+!-& GFJ@K@M<8E;
 /&5342+#-#4##/#)'.'/4 &+!- E<>8K@M<GF@EKJKF (8O6++[7
:8J<K?<M8CL<
J?FLC;9<:CFJ<KF
/?< @E;LJKI@8C ;8K8 D8E8><D<EK DF;LC< @J I<JGFEJ@9C< =FI ('!&+ # K?<C<E>K?F=
 
GIFM@;@E>8GGIFGI@8K<;8K8=FIDF;<CKI8@E@E>8E;:FDGLK8K@FE
 ;8K8J<K
-(.M8CL<F=
'<8M@E> 8J@;< K?< D<:?8E@JDJ =FI 9@> ;8K8 JKFI8>< @K D8@ECP ;<I@M8K@M<J@>E8C
:FEK8@EJJL9 G8IKJ;8K8 8L>D<EK8K@FE;8K8@EK<>I8K@FE ;8K8
)!-+!- <I@M8K@M<F= ELD9<IF=
=FI-(.
:C<8E@E> 8E; ;8K8 HL8C@KP D8E8><D<EK
 8K8 8L>D<EK8K@FE  # M@9I8K@FEJ@>E8C ;<I@M8K@M<M8CL< ;<I@M8K@M<
8;;I<JJ<J K?< J?FIK8>< F= KI8@E@E> ;8K8 M@8 D@EFI@KP K?8K<O:<<;J
FM<IJ8DGC@E> FI ;8K8 J@DLC8K@FE
 8K8 @EK<>I8K@FE @J KF 8C@>E K?I<J?FC;
;8K8 N@K? ;@==<I<EK =I<HL<E:@<J =FID8KJ 8E; JFLI:<J <
>
 
D8:?@E< :FEKIFCC<I ;8K8 8;; FE J<EJFI ;8K8 D8@EK<E8E:< CF> L<KFK?<C8I><MFCLD<F=;8K8:FCC<:K<;=IFDD8:?@E<@K
D8EL=8:KLI@E> <O<:LK@FE JPJK<D ( . ;8K8 <K:
 KF><K?<I KF @JGI<=<II<;K?8KGFIK@FEJF=K?@JDF;LC<8I<KF9<;@JKI@9LK<;KF
:I<8K< K?< ;<J@I<; ;8K8 JKI<8D =FI DF;<C ;<M<CFGD<EK
 8K8 K?< <;>< KF ;<:I<8J< :FDDLE@:8K@FE 98E;N@;K?
 <IK8@E
:C<8E@E> @J KF I<DFM< ELCCJ 8E; FLKC@<IJ @E @EGLK ;8K8 N?@:? =<8KLI<J :8E 9< =@IJK :FDGLK<; 8K <;>< ;<M@:<J 8E; K?<E J<EK
LK@C@Q<J ILC< 98J<; FI ;@JKI@9LK@FE 98J<; 8C>FI@K?DJ
 8K8 98:BKFK?<:CFL;=FI@EK<>I8K@M<8E8CPJ@J

HL8C@KPD8E8><D<EK8;;I<JJ<JK?<HL8C@KP8JG<:K8J;8K89<@E>
KI8EJD@KK<; 8E; KI8EJ=FID<; K?IFL>?FLK K?< ;8K8 :?8@E
 
"8K<N8PJ D8P 9< J<K 8=K<I ;@==<I<EK JK8><J F= ;8K8 GIF:<JJ@E>
<
>
 ;8K8 @EK<>I8K@FE =<8KLI< <OKI8:K@FE KF 8MF@; @EM8C@; ;8K8  42'#.-+/'&0&'-2#+/+/)
=IFD =LIK?<I GIF:<<;@E>
 "<E<I8C ;8K8 HL8C@KP @EJG<:K@FE .@D@C8IKF8E8JJ<D9CPC@E<@E;LJKI@8C$DF;<CJJ?FLC;9<
>L@;<C@E<J8I<>@M<E@E6 7N?@C<8JG<:@=@:<O8DGC<=FIN@E; ;<M<CFG<; @E 8 JKI<8DC@E<; D8EE<I KF 8:?@<M< ?@>?<I
KLI9@E<M@9I8K@FE;8K8HL8C@KP:?<:B@JC@JK<;@E/89C<$$676 7
 <E>@E<<I@E><==@:@<E:P
$EJK<8;F=?8M@E>FE<G<IJFE;F@E>8CC
)FK<K?8K8?@>? ;<>I<<F=8LKFD8K@FE@EK?@JDF;LC<NFLC;9< K?<NFIB;@==<I<EK<E>@E<<I@E>IFC<J@E:CL;@E>;8K8<E>@E<<IJ
M@K8C KF <C@D@E8K< I<;LE;8E:P 8E; I<;L:< @EGLK LE:<IK8@EKP @E ;8K8 J:@<EK@JKJ 8E; D8:?@E< <OG<IKJ N@CC NFIB KF><K?<I KF
K?<CFE>ILE
 :FEKI@9LK< KF K?< :FEJLDD8K@FE F= K?< =@E8C DF;<C
 /F 9<KK<I
;<:FLGC< K?< NFIB 8E; JK8E;8I;@Q< @EK<IE8C :FCC89FI8K@FE K?<
/' $$
 3(+' *!,0'$/4-$/ -$!*-2$)/0-$)  8LK?FIJ GIFGFJ< 8 JKI<8DC@E<; DF;<C KI8@E@E> G@G<C@E< @E K?<
1$-/$*)/676 7 =FIDF=;@I<:K<;8:P:C@:>I8G?J"8JJ?FNE@E!@>LI<

# M<IP EF;< @E K?< >I8G? @J 8 GI< ;<=@E<; 9L@C;@E> 9CF:B N@K?

+)'**!& #$,  )* '$ I<:FE=@>LI89C<G8I8D<K<IJ8E;@JJLGGC@<;9P;@==<I<EK;FD8@E
+ '
(<8EM8CL<F=
.D8CC<IK?8E <  <OG<IKJ @E K?< K<8D
 8K8 J:@<EK@JKJ N?F 8I< @E :?8I>< F= K?<
& #
M@9I8K@FEJ@>E8C
(<8EM8CL< J?FLC;9< =@E8C;<C@M<IPN@CC:FEE<:KJ<C<:K@M<9L@C;@E>9CF:BJKF><K?<IKF
;<:<EKCPJD8CC =FIDK?<DF;<CKI8@E@E>G@G<C@E<

< T

 #
-(.M8CL<F=
-(.M8CL<
D@E@DLD<E<I>P $EK?<<O8DGC<F=8?@>? JG<<;I8@CN8P9<8I@E>;@8>EFJK@:J
M@9I8K@FEJ@>E8C ILC<8E;;PE8D@: 8 ;8K8 <E>@E<<I ;<M<CFG<; DF;LC<J K?8K JK@K:? ?@>? =I<HL<E:P
I8E><ILC<
/@D<;FD8@E
8E; CFN =I<HL<E:P ;8K8 KF><K?<I 8E; :FE;L:K 98J@: ;8K8
)*-$2*
-(.8E; :C<8E@E>8M@9I8K@FE;8K8<OG<IK;<M<CFG<;EF@J<I<;L:K@FE8E;
+ ')% J@>E8C GIF:<JJ@E> 8C>FI@K?DJ 8 D8:?@E< C<8IE@E> <E>@E<<I
=I<HL<E:P;FD8@E
* -(.OK[ .D8CC<IK?8E
&)/
-(.C<M<CJ?FLC;
-(.3=

GIFM@;<; DLCK@GC< :FE;@K@FE :CLJK<I@E> DF;LC<J
 0E;<I K?<
9<:CFJ< >L@;8E:<F=K?<C<8;<IF=K?<K<8D8ALE@FI;8K8J:@<EK@JKN8J
'&*)-+!'&
:FEJ<IM8K@FEF=
),$ 89C< KF :I<8K< J<M<I8C KI8@E@E> G@G<C@E<J N@K? K?< 9L@C;@E>
<E<I>P=FI!!/
9CF:BJ 8E; :FE;L:K <OG<I@D<EKJ N@K?FLK @EK<EJ@M< KI8@E@E>

(F;LC<J 8E; G@G<C@E<J :8E 8CJF 9< J8M<; 8E; I<LJ<; @E K?<
=LKLI<


 +IF>EFJK@:J.PJK<D#<8CK?(8E8><D<EKFE=<I<E:<U,@E>;8F
+#(  ,@E>;8F

Authorized licensed use limited to: Pontificia Universidad Catolica Del Peru. Downloaded on August 05,2021 at 04:12:59 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
@;<EK@=@<;K?<DF;LC<N@CCEFK@=PK?<;<M<CFG<IJKFI< <M8CL8K<
K?<JL@K89@C@KPF=K?<DF;<C


 0/4+/50530&'- 1&#4+/)


$K@JE<:<JJ8IP=FI@E;LJKI@8C$DF;<CJKF9<:FEK@ELFLJCP
LG;8K<; KF D8@EK8@E K?<@I I<C@89@C@KP
 (F;<C LG;8K@E> :8E 9<
 :C8JJ@=@<; @EKF KNF J:<E8I@FJ FE< @J DF;<C JKIL:KLI8C :?8E><
N?@:? D<8EJ I< ;<J@>E@E> DFJK FI 8CC G8IKJ F= K?< DF;<C K?<
!@>LI<
 .8DGC<(F;<C/I8@E@E>+@G<C@E<
FK?<I @J EFE JKIL:KLI8C :?8E>< @E N?@:? :8J< FECP DF;<C
?PG<I G8I8D<K<IJ 8I< I< FGK@D@Q<; LJ@E> E<N ;8K8 8E;
 0&'-+3,0/+402+/) <OG<I@<E:<

L<KFLE:<IK8@EKP@E@E;LJKI@8CJPJK<DJ8E;K?<@IFG<I8K@E> $E K?< J<:FE; :8J< DF;<C LG;8K@E> @J ?FG<=LC KF 9<:FD<
:FE;@K@FEJ FE< J?FLC; EFK <OG<:K KF ?8M< 8E $ DF;<C K?8K J<D@ 8LKFD8K<;
 C8IDJ =IFD K?< I@JB DFE@KFI@E> DF;LC< FI
NFIBJ N<CC =FI<M<I
 J @CCLJKI8K<; @E !@>LI<  K?< :FEK<OK @E LJ<I=<<;98:BNFLC;KI@>><IK?<JK8IKF=8DF;<CLG;8K<
-<:<EK
N?@:? K?< DF;<C GI<;@:KJ @J C@B<CP KF <MFCM< FM<I K@D<
 /F ;8K88E;C89<CJN@CC9<HL<I@<;8E;GI<M@FLJKI8@E@E>G@G<C@E<J
I<;L:< =8CJ< FLKGLKJ :FEK@ELFLJ I@JB DFE@KFI@E> N@CC 9< N@CC 9< I<ILE N@K? E<N :FE=@>LI8K@FEJ =IFD K?< ;<M<CFG<IJ FI
I<HL@I<;K?IFL>?FLKK?<C@=<:P:C<F=K?<DF;<C
 K?<LJ<IJ
$EK?<:8J<F=8D8:?@E<KFFC:LKK@E>KFFCI<D8@E@E>
LJ<=LC C@=< -0' GI<;@:K@FE =FI @EJK8E:< 8 DF;<C LG;8K< @J
G<I=FID<; 8=K<I 8 E<N NFIB I<:@G< @J <DGCFP<;
 LI@E> K?<
LG;8K<K?<D8:?@E<FG<I8KFI@JGI<J<EK<;N@K?;@8>I8DJF=I8N
M@9I8K@FE;8K88E;KFGKI<E;P=<8KLI<J8LKFD8K@:8CCPJ<C<:K<;9P
K?<KI8@E@E>G@G<C@E<
/?<FG<I8KFIFECPE<<;JKF@EJG<:K@=8EP
D8AFI 8EFD8CP <O@JKJ
 =K<I K?< :FE=@ID8K@FE F= K?< FG<I8KFI
 K?<G@G<C@E<N@CC<OKI8:K:LKK@E>;8K8LE;<IK?<E<NI<:@G<I<=@K
DF;<C G8I8D<K<IJ 8E; :FE;L:K M8C@;8K@FE
 =K<I 8EFK?<I LJ<I
!@>LI<
 $CCLJKI8K@FEF=18I@8K@FE@E(F;<C*G<I8K@E>FEK<OK67 @EJG<:K@FE FE K?< M8C@;8K@FE I<JLCKJ K?< DF;<C N@CC 9<
8LKFD8K@:8CCP ;<GCFP<; FEC@E<
 P <E89C@E> D<:?8E@JDJ C@B<
!FI+#(DF;<CJK?<=FCCFN@E>D<KI@:J:8E9<LJ<;=FI8
K?@J DF;<C LG;8K@E> :8E 9< =@E@J?<; N@K?@E =8:KFIP J@K<J 8E;
I<C8K@M<CP:FDGI<?<EJ@M<<M8CL8K@FEF=DF;<CG<I=FID8E:<8E; K?< :FJK =FI DF;<C D8@EK<E8E:< N@CC 9< :LIK8@C<; 8J N<CC
 /F
LE:<IK8@EKP@EGIF;L:K@FE67
 <EJLI< I<C@89@C@KP ;<M<CFG<IJ N@CC K8B< FM<I @= 8EP D8EL8C FI
8LKFD8K@:@EJG<:K@FE=8@CJKFG8JJ

/' $$$
 '..$!$/$*)*!+-*")*./$.(* '( /-$.67
C>FI@K?D N@J< J<M<I8C I<J<8I:? NFIBJ ?8M< GIFGFJ<;
+')/ +)! D<K?F;J =FI J<D@ 8LKFD8K@: DF;<C LG;8K@E> @E JG<:@=@:
• ::LI8:P J:<E8I@FJ
 !FI <O8DGC< '@L <K 8C GIFGFJ<; 8E 8;8GK@M<
$')!+ % • +I<:@J@FE :CLJK<I@E> D<K?F; =FI =8LCK ;@8>EFJ@J @E I8@CN8P +#(
)')%& • -F9LJKE<JJ 8GGC@:8K@FEJ N@K? J<C= FI>8E@Q@E> D8GJ .*( 67
 /8E> <K 8C
• FEM<I><E:< LK@C@Q<; K?< JKI<E>K? F= 8P<J@8E E<KNFIBJ 8E; GI<J<EKJ 8E
• -<>@D<J?@=K
'$&)+!&+/ @EE<I FLK<I CFFG LG;8K@E> D<:?8E@JDJ =FI DF;<C
• FE=@;<E:<C<M<C
• .L::<JJI8K<
?PG<IG8I8D<K<IJ 67
 28E> GI<J<EK<; 8 KI8A<:KFIP 98J<; -0'
'%(,++!'&$
• /@D<:FDGC<O@KP GI<;@:K@FE 8C>FI@K?D /.+ =FI A<K <E>@E<J K?8K <E89C<J
)')%& J8DGC< 98J<;LG;8K<J67

• (<DFIP$*
• -*$
'*+&!+)!*# $EK?<CFE>ILEDF;<CJKIL:KLI8C:?8E><N@CC9<@E<M@K89C<
• (8@EK<E8E:<:FJKJ8M@E>J
J@E:< @E@K@8C KI8@E@E> ;8K8 8E; JPJK<D BEFN ?FN 8I<

@EJL==@:@<EK
 J ;8K8 8E; C89<C 8::LDLC8K< E<N J<EJFIJ ><K
$EG8IK@:LC8IDFE@KFI@E>D8:?@E<FG<I8K@E>I<>@D<JTJL:? @EJK8CC<; 8E; JKL;@<J FE K?< JPJK<D D<:?8E@JD ;<<G<E K?<
8JCF8;@E>D8:?@E<JK8KLJGIF;L:K@FEDF;<NFIB@E>I<:<@GK DF;<C N@CC 9< I<=@E<; KF G<I=FID 9<KK<I K?IFL>? ;@==<I<EK
<K:
 8E; <EM@IFED<EK =8:KFIJ :89@E K<DG<I8KLI< 8@I ;<EJ@KP <MFCM@E> IFLK<J
 $E K?< :8J< F= N@E; KLI9@E< +#( 8 DF;<C
<K:
T:8E9<:IL:@8C=FI@E;LJKI@8C$DF;<CJ
2?<E8I<>@D< <MFCM@E> IF8;D8G @J GI<J<EK<; @E !@>LI<  8J 8E <O8DGC<
 
J?@=K F::LIJ DF;<CJ D8P JN@K:? KF 8 DFI< :FEJ<IM8K@M< J<I@<J ;@D<EJ@FEJ N@CC 9< :FEJ@;<I<; @E D8B@E> JL:?
GI<;@:K@FE DF;< <
>
 ILC< 98J<; FI FLKGLK 8 GI<J<K :F;< KF KI8EJ@K@FEJ JL:? 8J ;8K8 :FE;@K@FEJ I8K@F 8M8@C89@C@KP F= =8LCKP
N8IE89FLKK?@JKF8MF@;=8CJ<8C<IKJ
$=8E8::LDLC8K@M<I<>@D< ;8K8 DF;<C I<HL@I<D<EKJ @EK<IGI<K89@C@KP J:8C89@C@KP
J?@=K@J;<K<:K<;FEC@E<;<M<CFG<IJJ?FLC;9<EFK@=@<;KFLG;8K< :FDGLK8K@FE8C :FDGC<O@KP ;<>I<< F= ;FD8@E BEFN
K?<DF;<C
 BEFNC<;>< I<GI<J<EK8K@FE @EKF =8@CLI< D<:?8E@JD
BEFNC<;>< I<GI<J<EK8K@FE @EKF JPJK<D ;PE8D@:J <K:

$E 8;;@K@FE K?@J DF;LC< 8CJF DFE@KFIJ K?< F::LII<E:< F= -<=<I<E:<J676767C@JKDFI<<O?8LJK@M<:I@K<I@8=FIK?@J@JJL<

FG<I8K@FE8C <M<EKJ K?8K GFK<EK@8CCP 9I<8B DF;<C 8JJLDGK@FEJ
JL:?8JD8@EK<E8E:<8:K@M@K@<JD8:?@E<G8I8D<K<I:8C@9I8K@FE
8E; E<N GIF;L:K @EKIF;L:K@FE )+$
 2?<E K?<J< <M<EKJ 8I<

 +IF>EFJK@:J.PJK<D#<8CK?(8E8><D<EKFE=<I<E:<U,@E>;8F
+#(  ,@E>;8F

Authorized licensed use limited to: Pontificia Universidad Catolica Del Peru. Downloaded on August 05,2021 at 04:12:59 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
 &)'20&)'0.154+/)0#/#)'.'/4
;><+IF @J 8E <;>< :FDGLK@E> DF;LC< K?8K :8E 9<
@EK<>I8K<;@EKF;8K88:HL@J@K@FE,;<M@:<JKFG<I=FID;8K8
GIF:<JJ@E> 8E; DF;<C :FDGLK8K@FE 8K K?< <;><
 $K @J 8@D<; 8K
<EJLI@E> K@D<CP I<JGFEJ<J 8E; I<;L:@E> KI8EJD@JJ@FE GI<JJLI<
@E GC8:<J N@K? GFFI :FEE<:K@M@KP
 ;><+IF 8CJF J<IM<J 8J K?<
D8E8><D<EKKFFC=FI,;<M@:<JN@K?=LE:K@FE8C@K@<JJL:?8J
I<DFK< I<:FE=@>LI8K@FE F= , G8I8D<K<IJ <;>< DF;<C
LG;8K<<K:


!@>LI<
 +IF>EFJK@:J(F;<C-F8;D8GF=2@E;/LI9@E<"<E<I8KFI<8I@E>  '/20'53#$-'0&'-2#+/+/)
!8LCK+I<;@:K@FE67 "<E+IF @J 8E @EK<>I8K<; ;<M<CFGD<EK <EM@IFED<EK $ 
K?8K:FEK8@EJDF;LC8I@Q<;FG<I8KFIJ8E;DF;<C@E>K<DGC8K<J=FI
 '%+3+0/511024''&$#%,/4'2(#%' I8G@; DF;<C 9L@C;@E> 8E; LG;8K@E>
 *G<I8KFIJ 8I< 8C>FI@K?DJ
8E;D<K?F;J;<M<CFG<;9P;FD8@E<OG<IKJFI;8K8J:@<EK@JKJKF
LJ<I@EK<I=8:<@JI<HL@I<;=FI:CFJ<; CFFG;<:@J@FEJLGGFIK JFCM<=LE;8D<EK8CGIF9C<DJ@E;@==<I<EKGIF>EFJK@:JK8><JJL:?
8E;<O<:LK@FE=<<;98:B
$E=FID8K@FEGI<J<EK<;FEK?<@EK<I=8:< 8J J@>E8C GI<GIF:<JJ@E> =<8KLI< <OKI8:K@FE 8E; J<C<:K@FE
J?FLC;9<@CCLJKI8K@M<=FI<E; LJ<IJ<
>
D8@EK<E8E:<FG<I8KFIJ 98J<C@E<DF;<CKI8@E@E>DF;<CM8C@;8K@FE<K:
*E<:8E;@I<:KCP
KF LE;<IJK8E; N?P K?< DF;<C >@M<J :<IK8@E 8C8IDJ 8E; :FEE<:K K?FJ< 9L@C;@E> 9CF:BJ KF><K?<I KF =FID 8 :FDGC<K<
JL>><JK@FEJ
 J J?FNE @E !@>LI<  @EJK<8; F= 8 J@E>C< 8C8ID DF;<C KI8@E@E> G@G<C@E<
 ;;@K@FE8CCP N?<E J:8C@E> LG FI
C<M<C K?< @EK<I=8:< 8CJF J?FNJ I<:<EK I@JB KI<E;J ;@8>I8DJ F= :FE;L:K@E> LG;8K<J K?< G@G<C@E<J :8E 9< I<LJ<;
 /?< LJ<I
B<P DF;<C =<8KLI<J ;@8>I8DJ F= :FII<JGFE;@E> I8N ;8K8
 @EK<I=8:<F="<E+IF@JGI<J<EK<;@E!@>LI<

.FD<K@D<JK?<;<:@J@FEG8K?F=K?<DF;<C=IFD:FDGFE<EKKF
JPJK<D N@CC 8CJF 9< GI<J<EK<; =FI LJ<IJ KF LE;<IJK8E; @KJ
FLKGLKJ
 $E K?@J N8P K?< DF;<C I<JLCKJ 8I< J<8DC<JJCP :IFJJ
I<=<I<E:<; N@K? K?< FG<I8KFIJX G<I:<GK@FEJ 8MF@;@E> F9M@FLJ
=8CJ<GFJ@K@M<J



!@>LI<
 0J<I$EK<I=8:<F=K?<$$<M*GJ+C8K=FID


 9$'21*'2' 0&'- !#-+&#4+0/ 8'%54+0/ #/&
!@>LI<
 1@JL8C@Q8K@FEF=8+IF>EFJK@:J(F;<C*LKGLK=FI2@E;/LI9@E< 0/+402+/)
"<E<I8KFI<8I@E> P9<I.G?<I< @J 8 :FDGLK8K@FE8C <E>@E< =FI GIF>EFJK@:
DF;<CJ
 <=FI< K?< DF;<C @J ;<GCFP<; @EKF GIF;L:K@FE
CJFFE J@K<@EJG<:K@FEI<JLCKJ8I<:FCC<:K<;J@DLCK8E<FLJCP P9<I.G?<I<LJ<JF==C@E<;8K8KFM8C@;8K<@KJ:FII<:KE<JJ8=K<I
8J =<<;98:BJ @EKF K?< JPJK<D N?@:? :8E 9< LJ<; =FI C89<C K?< DF;<C @J ;<GCFP<; FEC@E< P9<I.G?<I< <O<:LK<J @K N@K?
><E<I8K@FEFI:FEJKIL:K@E>8D8@EK<E8E:<BEFNC<;><98J<
/?< LJ<I ;<=@E<; JKI8K<>@<J 8E; :FEK@ELFLJCP DFE@KFIJ @KJ
BEFNC<;>< 98J< JKFI<J =8LCK :?8I8:K<I@Q8K@FE 8E; D8@EK<E8E:< G<I=FID8E:<
 $K 8CJF J<IM<J 8J 8 :<EKI8C@Q<; ;8K8 GIF:<JJ@E>
GIF:<;LI<J 8CFE> N@K? ;8K8 JE8GJ?FKJ KF JLGGFIK =LKLI< C8P<IK?8KGI<GIF:<JJ<J@EGLK;8K88E;:?<:BJ@KJHL8C@KP
2@K?
D8@EK<E8E:<8:K@M@K@<J8JN<CC8JJL9J<HL<EKDF;<CLG;8K<
 P9<I.G?<I<XJ LE@=@<; FG<I8K@E> <EM@IFED<EK :FEJ@JK<E:P
9<KN<<EF==C@E<8E;FEC@E<DF;<C<O<:LK@FE@J<EJLI<;

$1
 $(+' ( )//$*)*!/# $$ 1*+.+'/!*-(  9$'2'103+40290&'-#/#)'.'/4
!@>LI<GI<J<EKJK?<8I:?@K<:KLI<F=8JLGGFIK@E>GC8K=FID P9<I-<GFJ@KFIP@J8DF;<CI<GFJ@KFIPK?8KJKFI<J;@==<I<EK
F=$$<M*GJ
!LE:K@FEJF=<8:?:FDGFE<EK8I<@EKIF;L:<;8J M<IJ@FEJ M8I@8EKJF=8GIF>EFJK@:DF;<CK?IFL>?FLK@KJC@=<:P:C<

=FCCFNJ
 ::<JJ :FEKIFC @J 8CJF <E89C<; =FI DF;<C 8GGIFM8CJ
 (F;<CJ
JKFI<; @E P9<I-<GFJ@KFIP 8I< :IL:@8C =FI DF;<C KI8:<89@C@KP
8E;BEFNC<;><8::LDLC8K@FE


/?<GC8K=FID?8J9<<ELJ<;KF;<C@M<IJ<M<I8C@E;LJKI@8C$
8GGC@:8K@FEJ @E ;@==<I<EK D8EL=8:KLI@E> J<:KFIJ 8J J?FNE @E

/89C<$1

!@>LI<
 I:?@K<:KLI<F=K?<$$<M*GJ+C8K=FID

 +IF>EFJK@:J.PJK<D#<8CK?(8E8><D<EKFE=<I<E:<U,@E>;8F
+#(  ,@E>;8F

Authorized licensed use limited to: Pontificia Universidad Catolica Del Peru. Downloaded on August 05,2021 at 04:12:59 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
/' $1
 $!! - )/0. . .*!/# $$ 1*+.+'/!*-( 67 5
'@L'4#-V$E;LJKI@8C$ E89C<;+IF>EFJK@:J=FI#@>? JG<<;-8@CN8P
.PJK<DJW @E    /4'2/#4+0/#- 0/('2'/%' 0/ 20)/034+%3 #/&
* * )+)!*+!* '#-4*#/#)'.'/4 

• '8I><=C<<KF=D8:?@E<JN@K?8CFKF= 67 '
 /8E> "
 %
 &8:GIQPEJB@ &
 "F<9<C 8E; "
 18:?KJ<M8EFJ
!&+,)!& :FDGFE<EKJKF9<DFE@KFI<;
/?@JI<JLCKJ V(<K?F;FCF>@<J =FI LE:<IK8@EKP D8E8><D<EK @E GIF>EFJK@:JW @E  
()!+!- $+  @E?LE;I<;JF=GIF>EFJK@:JDF;<CJ9<@E> '2031#%'%0/('2'/%' 

%&%&+ J:8C<;8E;FG<I8K<;FEK?<GC8K=FID 67 /
28E>V/I8A<:KFIP.@D@C8I@KP8J<;+I<;@:K@FE=FI-<D8@E@E>0J<=LC
J@DLCK8E<FLJCP
 '@=< JK@D8K@FEW

• #@>? =I<HL<E:PM@9I8K@FE;8K8N@K?<;><
:FDGLK@E>8GGC@<;=FI;8K8:C<8E@E>8E; 67 
 .8O<E8'4 #- V(<KI@:J =FI <M8CL8K@E> G<I=FID8E:< F= GIF>EFJK@:
K<:?E@HL<JW @E   /4'2/#4+0/#- 0/('2'/%' 0/ 20)/034+%3 #/&
 % !&+''$ =<8KLI<<OKI8:K@FE

'#-4*#/#)'.'/4 

()!+!'& • .<D@ 8LKFD8K@:DF;<CLG;8K@E>@J
8GGC@<;KF8::FDDF;8K<=I<HL<EK 67 %
 '<< !
 2L 2
 5?8F (
 "?8==8I@ '
 '@8F 8E; 
 .@<><C
:?8E><J@ENFIB@E>I<:<@GKJ
 V+IF>EFJK@:J 8E; ?<8CK? D8E8><D<EK ;<J@>E =FI IFK8IP D8:?@E<IP
• 8K8=IFD8M8I@<KPF=D8E8><D<EK JPJK<DJU-<M@<NJD<K?F;FCF>P8E;8GGC@:8K@FEJW'%*#/+%#-934'.3
JPJK<DJ8I<:FCC<:K<;8E;:<EKI8C@Q<;=FI #/&+)/#-20%'33+/)MFC
EF
 TGG
 T%8E
 

&+$$!&+&)/ DF;<C:FDGLK@E>
#LD8E=<<;98:BJ8I< 67 %
 5
 .@BFIJB8 (
 #F;B@<N@:Q 8E; '
 (8 V+IF>EFJK@: DF;<CC@E>
!*(+ !&+')/ :FCC<:K<;LGFE<M<IP<E<I>P8;ALJKD<EK FGK@FEJ =FI I<D8@E@E> LJ<=LC C@=< <JK@D8K@FE 9P @E;LJKIPW'%*#/+%#-
=FIDF;<C@DGIFM<D<EK8E;I@JB 934'.3#/&+)/#-20%'33+/)MFC
EF
GG
  T %LC


DFE@KFI@E>
 6 7 %
 5?FL<K 8C
 V8K8 I@M<E /I8EJ=FID8K@FE "CF98C $E;LJKI@8C $EK<IE<K
 +C8K=FID 8J< .KL;PW 6 7 ?@E8 $E;LJKI@8C FEKIFC .PJK<DJ P9<I
D<I><E:P-<JGFEJ</<8D 

6 7 KC8JJ@8E V2?8K @J <M*GJWKC8JJ@8E  
 6*EC@E<7
 M8@C89C<
1
 *)'0.$*)!0/0- 2*-& ?KKG NNN
8KC8JJ@8E
:FD ;<MFGJ

/?@JG8G<I@EKIF;L:<J$$<M*GJ8JPJK<D8K@:=I8D<NFIB 6 7 V2?8K @J <M*GJWD8QFE 2<9 .<IM@:<J $E:
  
 6*EC@E<7

=FI GIF>EFJK@:J DF;<C C@=<:P:C< D8E8><D<EK
 $K 8;;I<JJ<J K?< M8@C89C<?KKG 8NJ
8D8QFE
:FD ;<MFGJ N?8K @J ;<MFGJ

<E>@E<<I@E> :?8CC<E><J F= ;<M<CFG@E> 8E; FG<I8K@FE8C@Q@E> $ 6 7 V<M*GJ=FI#P9I@;CFL;8E$(+F@EKF=1@<NW$( 

DF;<CJ @E KI8;@K@FE8C @E;LJKI@<J N@K? 8E <DG?8J@J FE +#( 6 7 %
 '<< #
 8M8I@ %
 .@E>? 8E; 1
 +8E;?8I< V$E;LJKI@8C IK@=@:@8C
8GGC@:8K@FEJ
 P @CCLJKI8K@E> K?< 8I:?@K<:KLI< F= K?< =I8D<NFIB $EK<CC@><E:< =FI @E;LJKIP 
98J<; D8EL=8:KLI@E>
JPJK<DJW(8EL=8:KLI@E>'<KK<IJMFC
 GG
 T*:K
 

8E;K?<;<J@>EGI@E:@GC<J=FI@KJ:FDGFE<EKK?<8LK?FIJN@J?KF
6 7 .
 .8EB8I8I8D8E V.@>E@=@:8E:< @EK<IGI<K8K@FE 8E; HL8EK@=@:8K@FE F=
F==<I K?< I<8;<IJ 8 ?@>? C<M<C LE;<IJK8E;@E> F= $$ <M*GJ
 LE:<IK8@EKP @E GIF>EFJK@:J 8E; I<D8@E@E> LJ<=LC C@=<
$E;<<; +#( 8GGC@:8K@FEJ :8E 9< ;@==<I<EK =IFD :8J< KF :8J< GI<;@:K@FEW'%*#/+%#-934'.3#/&+)/#-20%'33+/)MFC
TGG

9LK K?< G?@CFJFG?P =FI K8:BC@E> K?< <E>@E<<I@E> 8JG<:K F= K?< T!<9
 

GIF9C<D:8E9<:FDG8I89C<
2@K?K?<$$<M*GJ=I8D<NFIB 6 7 4
?<E!
5?L8E;%
'<<V8K8HL8C@KP<M8CL8K@FE8E;@DGIFM<D<EK
N< ?FG< KF 8::<C<I8K< K?< ;<M<CFGD<EK 8E; ;<GCFPD<EK F= =FIGIF>EFJK@:DF;<C@E>LJ@E>M@JL8C8JJ<JJD<EK98J<;;8K8G8IK@K@FE@E>
@E;LJKI@8C$DF;<CJK?8K<M<EKL8CCP9I@E>M8CL<JKF<E;LJ<IJ
 D<K?F;W0.154'23+//&53429MFC
EF
GG
 TGI
 

"F@E> =FIN8I; K?< 8LK?FIJ N@CC ;@M< @EKF <8:? :FDGFE<EK F= 6 7 
 %89ZF\JB@ /
 8IJQ:Q 8E; (
 @<C<:B8 VLKFD8K@: M8C@;8K@FE F=
M@9I8K@FE J@>E8CJ @E N@E; =8ID ;@JKI@9LK<; DFE@KFI@E>
K?<=I8D<NFIB8E;JKL;P@KJ;<K8@C<;K<:?E@:8CJ:?<D<J@EK?< JPJK<DJW'#352'.'/4MFC
EF
 GG
 T <:


:FEK<OKF=I<GI<J<EK8K@M<@E;LJKI@8CJ:<E8I@FJ
I<8JN@K??@>?<I
6 7 +
 8D9IFE 
 /8?8E 
 (8JJFE 8E; !
 +<CC<K@<I V<8I@E>
I<J<8I:? GI@FI@K@<J 8I< ;8K8 HL8C@KP @EJG<:K@FE @E:I<D<EK8C K<DG<I8KLI< DFE@KFI@E> F= 8 2@E; /LI9@E< LJ@E> G?PJ@:J 98J<;
C<8IE@E> 8C>FI@K?DJ 8LKFD8K@: D8@EK<E8E:< BEFNC<;>< DF;<CW052/#-0(5#-+49+/#+/4'/#/%'/)+/''2+/)MFC
EF

D8GG@E><K:
 GG
T*:K
 

6 7
'8G@I8
I@JJ<K#
8M8I@I;8B8E@
.@<><C8E;%
'<<V2@E;
KLI9@E< G<I=FID8E:< 8JJ<JJD<EK LJ@E> DLCK@ I<>@D< DF;<C@E>
&)*2' "( )/ 8GGIF8:?W'/'7#$-'/'2)9MFC
GG
T.<G
 

/?< 8LK?FIJ NFLC; C@B< KF K?8EB FK?<I :FCC<8>L<J =IFD 6 7 (
.:?C<:?K@E><E$
!
.8EKFJ8E;.
:?@:?<V2@E;KLI9@E<:FE;@K@FE
$EEFM8K@FE <EK<I 8E; K?< <G8IKD<EK F= +IF;L:K - =FI DFE@KFI@E> 98J<; FE . ;8K8 LJ@E> EFID8C 9<?8M@FI DF;<CJ
 +8IK
.PJK<D;<J:I@GK@FEW11-+'&0(40.154+/)MFC
 EF
 GG
T
K?<@I ;<;@:8K@FE 8E; ?8I; NFIB @E 8::<C<I8K@E> K?< C8E;@E> F=  %8E
 

$ 8GGC@:8K@FEJ @E D8EL=8:KLI@E> @E;LJKI@<J @E:CL;@E> 9LK EFK
6 7 #

(
;<Q<M<;F
(
I8RAF8E;)
FL:?FEE<8LVI<M@<NF=
C@D@K<; KF I
 2<EA@E> %@E #L@D@E <E> 3@8FD@E> 28E> N@E; KLI9@E< 9<8I@E> :FE;@K@FE DFE@KFI@E> .K8K< F= K?< 8IK 8E;
2<@!L-L@"8E'<@5?8E>5?FE>E8E48E!8E>?<E8E; :?8CC<E><JW'/'7#$-' #/& 534#+/#$-' /'2)9 '6+'73 MFC
  GG

I
5FE>:?8E>'@L
 TGI
 

67 2
 48E> +
 %
 /8ME<I 
 %
 I89KI<< 4
 !<E> 8E; 4
 ,@L V2@E;
KLI9@E< :FE;@K@FE DFE@KFI@E> K<:?E@:8C 8E; :FDD<I:@8C
- ! - ) .
:?8CC<E><JW"+/&/'2)9MFC
 EF
GG
TL>
 

6 7 (
 #88ID8E'4 #- V<PFE; K?< ?PG< +;( 
 ;<C@M<IJ I<JLCKJW 67 /
 <EB<;AFL? &
 (<;A8?<I )
 5<I?FLE@ 8E; .
 -<:?8B V#<8CK?
+I@:<N8K<I?FLJ<FFG<IJ
1
8E;(8@EEFM8K@FE 
 8JJ<JJD<EK 8E; C@=< GI<;@:K@FE F= :LKK@E> KFFCJ 98J<; FE JLGGFIK M<:KFI
67 &
%8M<;-
"FLI@M<8L8E;)
5<I?FLE@V.K8K<F=K?<8IK8E;K8OFEFDP I<>I<JJ@FEW052/#- 0( /4'--+)'/4 #/5(#%452+/) MFC
  EF
  GG

F= GIF>EFJK@:J 8GGIF8:?<J KI<E;J F= GIF>EFJK@:J 8GGC@:8K@FEJ 8E; FG<E  TGI
 

@JJL<J KFN8I;J D8KLI@KP 8K ;@==<I<EK K<:?EFCF>P I<8;@E<JJ 67 
 
 /F9FE (<A@8 &
 (<;A8?<I 8E; )
 5<I?FLE@ V) D8:?@E<
C<M<CJW'%*#/+%#- 934'.3 #/& +)/#- 20%'33+/) MFC
  GG
  T KFFCXJ N<8I ;@8>EFJK@: 8E; GIF>EFJK@: 9P LJ@E> ;PE8D@: 8P<J@8E
.<G
 
 E<KNFIBJW'%*#/+%#-934'.3#/&+)/#-20%'33+/)MFC
GG
 T
67 %
 '<< 
 %@E 5
 '@L 8E; #
 8M8I@ I;8B8E@ V$EKIF;L:K@FE KF 8K8 GI
 

I@M<E (<K?F;FCF>@<J =FI +IF>EFJK@:J 8E; #<8CK? 67 (
.:?8CC<?E
.:?FIC@E>+
FN<E8E;*
.KI8<?C<V<PFE;+IFF=J
(8E8><D<EKW20$#$+-+34+% 20)/034+%3 #/& '#-4* #/#)'.'/4 0( F=FE:<GK.:8C@E>K?<$E;LJKI@8C$F/W8@EFDG8EP 

/'2)9934'.3GG
T 


 +IF>EFJK@:J.PJK<D#<8CK?(8E8><D<EKFE=<I<E:<U,@E>;8F
+#(  ,@E>;8F

Authorized licensed use limited to: Pontificia Universidad Catolica Del Peru. Downloaded on August 05,2021 at 04:12:59 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

You might also like