40. aktiv pracovnikov odboru ocefovych konatrukcii
STAV A PERSPEKTIVY ROZVOJA ODBORU
22.— 23. oktober 2015, Hotel Marlene, OSéadnica
EXPERIMENTAL VERIFICATION OF TORSIONAL RESTRAINT GIVEN
TO THIN-WALLED MEMBERS BY SANDWICH PANELS
1. Balazs - J. Melcher - M. Karmazinova - A. Belica - R. Oly - T. Misiek *
Abstract
Sandwich panels have been used in building industry as roof and wall cladding.
Usually they are supported by cold-formed steel members (purlins, girts). Restraint
given to 2 thin-walled member by sandwich panels prevents its deformation and
positively influences its buckling resistance. In case of sandwich panels, it is possible
fo utilize their shear stiffness to stabilize a cold-formed member against lateral
displacement under downward as well es uplift load acting on sandwich panels.
Torsional restraint can be standardly considered for downward load only. In some
applications with cold-formed sections certain value of torsional restraint under uplift
oad can be considered. Determination of this value should be assisted by testing
1, INTRODUCTION
Sandwich panels are in many cases supported by cold-formed steel beams with C-,
Z- or Z-cross-sections. The panels provide restraint to the beam and prevent its
deformation along the span. Fastening of panels of certain stiffness can thereby
increase buckling resistance of a thin-walled beam. The standard [1] provides basic
procedures to consider this influence in structural design
Shear stiffness of sandwich panels can be utilized for stabilization of a beam against
lateral displacement in case of downward or uplift load (e.g. wind) acting on sandwich
panel surface. It applies for beams of hot-olled as well as for cold-formed cross-
sections. Rotational restraint provided by sandwich panels can be generally utilized
in case of downward load only. Uplift load results in reduction of the contact area and
in the locations between fasteners it causes gaps between panel and thin-walled
* Ing. Ivan Bales, Institute of Metal and Timber Structures, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Bro
University of Technology, Vevefi 331/95, 602 00 Bmo, The Czech Republic, balazs.i@fce.vutor.cz
Prof. Ing Jindfich Melcher, OrSc., Institute cf Metal and Timber Structures, Faculty of Civil
Engineering, Bmo University of Technology, Vevefi 351/95, 602 00 Brno, The Czech Republic,
melcher j@foe.vutbr cz
Prof. Ing. Marcela Karmazinova, CSc., Institute of Metal and Timber Structures, Faculty of Civil
Engineering, Bmo University of Technology, Vevefi 331/95, 602 00 Bmo, The Czech Republic,
karmazinova.m@fee.vutbr.cz
Ing. Andrej Belica, PhD., Lindab SA., Route d'Ettelbruck 34, 9230 Diekirch, Luxembourg,
abelica@astron.biz
René Oly, Lindab S.A., Route d'Ettelbruck 34, 9230 Diekirch, Luxembourg, r.oly@astron.biz
Dr. Ing. Thomas Misiek, Breinlinger Ingenieure, KanalstraBe 1-4, 78532 Tuttingen, Germany,
thomas misiek@breinlinger de
23beam. Absence of contact between both beams and panel can result in possibility of
free rotation of the beam between fasteners or even over the complete length of the
beam. Certain values of rotational stiffness given by sandwich panels under uplift
load can be considered in some applicatons with cold-formed beams only [2] and
should be determined by experiments. There is a lack of data of these values. This
problem is currently a subject of research, The standard [1] gives a relatively simple
test setup for experimental determination of rotational stiffness given to a cold-formed
beam by planar members (sheeting or comparable elements used as. building
envelope). As the test setup does not cover the influence of external load acting on
the surface of the planar members, it is not suitable for the problem of torsional
restraint under uplift load in cases where there is an indentation of the fasteners or a
significant transverse bending of the planar member. Document [2] gives a test setup
that takes the external load into account. The test setup is utilized in experimental
program of torsional restraint given to cole-formed beams by sandwich panels under
uplift load which is a subject of this paper.
Rotational stiffness Co is defined as torsional moment that causes unit rotation of the
flange of the beam. The value of rotational stiffness is influenced by stiffness of the
joint between the planar member and beam and by stiffness due to distortion of the
beam cross-section [1]. It is important especially in case of cold-formed members
that are prone to cross-section distortion, Generally, the rotational stiffness depends
also on external load and its direction [3].
2. EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH
A series of tests for experimental determination of rotational stiffness given to cold-
formed beams by sandwich panels under uplift load was ordered by the Lindab S.A.
company. The tests were performed in the year 2015 at the testing laboratory of the
Institute of Metal and Timber Structures, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Brno University
of Technology, Cold-formed beams with Z-cross-section were used. Two different
beam depths (203 mm and 254 mm) and two different thicknesses (1.70 mm and
2.67 mm) were utilized, The tests were performed with two types of sandwich panels:
roof panel HOESCH THERMODACH and wall panel HOESCH ISOWAND VARIO.
Thickness of both types of panels was 80 mm. Their width was 4.0 m, length 4.0 m
and the span was 3.5 m. The panels consist of thin steel facings and insulation core.
Cross-section of the beams and panels are displayed in Fig. 1 and Fig. 2
9 9
4 “4
ra rr a 1
170 201
1 oo
1,70 267
“+ -|- z z
ae, a ous os wt
i x“ /
f rf 1 fu rf
Ley Bea va Be
Fig. 1 Cold-formed beam cross-sections
24HOESCH THERMODACH
HOESCH ISOWAND VARIO.
1000
Fig. 2 Sandwich panels cross-sections
The test setup was based on recommendation in document [2]. The scheme is
illustrated in Fig. 3. Picture in Fig. 4 displays the test setup during one of the tests
FRAME STIFFENER SANDWICH PANELS
SANDWICH PANELS.
BEAM
vyyyVYvVVYY Vy wy vy
\ LEVER ARM \CENTER OF ROTATION \ VACUUM CHAMBER SUCTION
Fig. 3 Test setup scheme
Fig. 4 Performance of a test
2Within the frame of the experimental program each type of sandwich panel was
tested with beams of both depths and thicknesses. Each test was performed twice so
that the whole series consisted of 16 tests.
Vacuum testing method [4] was utilized for the introduction of a uniformly distributed
suction load on the surface of the sandwich panels. The specimen was placed on a
timber vacuum chamber which was equipped with a vacuum pump. Tightness of the
vacuum chamber was ensured by foil.
For each test, two sandwich panels and two cold-formed beams were utilized. The
panels were fastened to the beams by self-drillng screws. In case of the
THERMODACH panel, four self-drilling screws along the width of one panel were
used for fastening to the beam. The ISOWAND VARIO panels (with hidden fixing in
the longitudinal joint) were fastened to the beam at both edges of the panels using
couple of seff-drilling screws together with steel load-distribution plates. The beams
were supported by steel frame with stiffening construction. Steel lever arms were
connected to both ends of a beam to enable it to be rotated. The rotation was rather
prevented by the panels. The restoring moment was measured as a force on a lever
arm by a force transducer. The beam was equipped with inclinometers to measure its
displacement. For the force introduction the bridge crane was used
The rotation of the beam was done at four load levels: under no suction and under
three diferent levels of suction (based on tabled load-bearing capacity of the
sandwich panels). Within the last level of suction seven cycles of rotation was
performed, Three levels of rotation were performed otherwise.
Rotated beam cross-section under uplift load can be seen in Fig. 5. In Fig. 6,
noticeable gap between the beam and the sandwich panel laterally deflected due to
suction is depicted
Fig. 5 Rotation of the beam cross-section (test with the THERMODACH panels)
26Fig. 6 Gap between sandwich panel and beam (test with the ISOWAND panels)
Data obtained from the inclinometers on the beam cross-section and from the force
transducer was used for tests evaluation and calculation of the rotational stiffness.
The torsional moment due to force on the lever arm was transformed to couple of
forces in beam flanges. Knowing the force magnitude together with appropriate
lateral visplavernenit of bear Marige allowed applivalion uf tie procedure acuding
to [1] for tests evaluation. Using these input values, the total lateral spring stiffness K
‘was computed, The total lateral spring stifmess obtained from the test consists of two
components: a spring stiffness corresponding to the rotational stiffness of the joint
between the panel and the beam Kz and lateral spring stiffness due to distortion of
the beam cross-section Ks, The value of Ks can be calculated using formula given by
standard [1], the value of Ks can be then easily calculated as well as the searched
value of rotational stiffness Co,
3. CONCLUSION
The paper focuses on the description of tests performed within the frame of the
experimental investigation of torsional restraint given to cold-formed steel beams by
sandwich panels. During the tests, significant rate of beams cross-sections distortion
was observed.
On the basis of ongoing evaluation of performed tests the utlized procedures can be
preliminarily considered as adequate for tests of this type.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The paper was elaborated with the support of the Lindab S.A. company, within the
frame of the specific research programme of the Bro University of Technology,
Faculty of Civil Engineering No FAST-J-15-2804 and within the research project
No LO1408 “AdMaS UP - Advanced Materials, Structures and Technologies’,
27supported by the National Sustainability Programme | of the Ministry of Education,
Youth and Sports of the Czech Republic.
REFERENCES
[1] CSN EN 1993-1-3 Eurokéd 3: Navrhovani ocelovych konstrukci — Cast 1-3:
Obecné pravidla — Dopliujici pravidla pro tenkosténné za studena tvarované
pivky a plosné profily (Eurocode 3 - Design of steel structures - Part 1-3:
General rules — Supplementary rules for cold-formed members and sheeting).
Cesky normalizaén’ institut, 2008.
[2] European Recommendations on the Stabilization of Steel Structures by
Sandwich Panels. CIB, International Council for Research and Innovation in
Building and Construction, ECCS - European Convention for Constructional
Steelwork, 2013
[3] Vrany, T.: Effect of loading on the rotational restraint of cold-formed purlins, Thin-
Walled Structures 44, 2006, pp. 1287-1292
[4] Melcher, J., Karmazinova, M.: Experimental verification of process of deformation
and load-bearing capacity of structural ferro-cement planar members with
utilization of vacuum testing method. Verified technology. Testing laboratory of
the Institute of Metal and Timber Structures, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Brno
University of Technology, 2009.
28