Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Award of degree of
2008-2010
Jaipur
1
INDEX
3 Research Methodology 52
6. SWOT 83
7. Conclusion 86
9. Appendix 101
2
PREFACE
A good broker system must be able to cope with an extremely complex and dynamic
environment.”
The microstructure of the stock market in which brokers work is highly dynamic and volatile.
Many stocks are available to be bought and sold, each exhibiting its own patterns and
characteristics that are highly unpredictable. With so many options and considerations that
need to be taken into account, it is an extremely arduous task for a broker to investigate
aspects of the stock market and consistently provide effective advice to their clients.
Thus, brokers perform their day-to-day tasks with the aid of a broker system. Such a system
should provide tools for interacting with exchanges and performing analysis. As a
consequence, these broker systems are quite large and complicated by themselves.
This research aims is to analysis Stock broker on the basis of their services, products, growth,
and their subsidiaries. Because Stockbrokers are one of the main participants in stock
exchanges worldwide, they often act as an agent for their clients, making trades on their
behalf. They also act as advisors, providing suggestions to their clients on what stocks to buy
and sell..
3
ACKNOWLEGDEMENT
I express my sincere thanks to my project guide Ms DEEPTI JAIMINI, for guiding me right from
the inception till the successful completion of the project. I sincerely acknowledge them for
extending their valuable guidance, support for literature, critical reviews of project and the
report and above all the moral support they had provided to me with all stages of this project.
MUKESH SHARMA
4
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The competitive nature of the broking sector has altered significantly in the recent years
around the globe. With the emerging new players, it gets even more challenging for the old
stagers to retain their place in the ever vacillating broking sector. Apart from the fierce
competition, the regulatory environment is also more stringent. Hence, different corporate
brokers are providing a larger basket of investment options to their clients and at varied rates
so as to not only survive in the industry, but also to outshine their competitors. Some of these
factors have led HSBC Group acquire the maximum share of IL&FS Investsmart (IIL) as its
corporate broker in India. Hence both HSBC and IIL provide each other the competitive
advantage in the corporate broking industry. The main aim of this study is to evaluate the
potential of IIL to be the best among the Corporate Brokers in the Indian domestic market, on
the basis of the products and services offered, as well as the customer relations, and its
recognition among the investors, especially after its recent acquisition by the HSBC Group and
how the two are mutually benefitting through their wide basket of offerings. Apart from this,
identifying the various competitors for IIL and determine what combination of options makes
the ‘best fit’ corporate brokerage at the right price.
5
6
1. Industry Introduction –stock broking Industry
In most industrialized countries, a substantial part of financial wealth is not managed directly
by savers, but through a financial intermediary, which implies the existence of an agency
contract between the investor (the principal) and a broker or portfolio manager (the agent).
Therefore, delegated brokerage management is arguably one of the most important agency
relationships intervening in the economy, with a possible impact on financial market and
economic developments at a macro level.
In most of the metros, people like to put their money in stock options instead of dumping
it in the bank-lockers. Now, this trend pick pace in small but fast developing cities like
Chandigarh, Gurgaon, Jaipur etc.
As the per-capita-income of the city is on the higher side, so it is quite obvious that they want
to invest their money in profitable ventures. On the other hand, a number of brokerage houses
make sure the hassle free investment in stocks. Asset management firms allow investors to
estimate both the expected risks and returns, as measured statistically.
The emergence of stock market can be traced back to 1830. In Bombay, business passed in
the shares of banks like the commercial bank, the chartered mercantile bank, the chartered
bank, the oriental bank and the old bank of Bombay and shares of cotton presses. In Calcutta,
Englishman reported the quotations of 4%, 5%, and 6% loans of East India Company as well
as the shares of the bank of Bengal in 1836. This list was a further broadened in 1839 when
the Calcutta newspaper printed the quotations of banks like union bank and Agra bank. It also
quoted the prices of business ventures like the Bengal bonded warehouse, the Docking
Company and the storm tug company.
Between 1840 and 1850, only half a dozen brokers existed for the limited business. But during
the share mania of 1860-65, the number of brokers increased considerably. By 1860, the
number of brokers was about 60 and during the exciting period of the American Civil war, their
number increased to about 200 to 250. The end of American Civil war brought disillusionment
7
and many failures and the brokers decreased in number and prosperity. It was in those
troublesome times between 1868 and 1875 that brokers organized an informal association and
finally as recited in the Indenture constituting the “Articles of Association of the Exchange”. On
or about 9th day of July,1875, a few native brokers doing brokerage business in shares and
stocks resolved upon forming in Bombay an association for protecting the character, status
and interest of native share and stock brokers and providing a hall or building for the use of the
members of such association.
As a meeting held in the broker’ Hall on the 5 th day of February, 1887, it was resolved to
execute a formal deal of association and to constitute the first managing committee and to
appoint the first trustees. Accordingly, the Articles of Association of the Exchange and the
Stock Exchange was formally established in Bombay on 3 rd day of December, 1887. The
Association is now known as “The Stock Exchange”.
The entrance fee for new member was Re.1 and there were 318 members on the list, when
the exchange was constituted. The numbers of members increased to 333 in 1896, 362 in
1916and 478 in 1920 and the entrance fee was raised to Rs.5 in 1877, Rs.1000 in 1896,
Rs.2500 in 1916 and Rs. 48,000 in 1920. At present there are 23 recognized stock
exchanges with about 6000 stockbrokers. Organization structure of stock exchange varies.
These exchange do not work of its own, rather, these are run by some persons and with the
help of some persons and institution. All these are down as functionaries on stock exchange.
These are
1. Stockbrokers
2. sub-broker
3. market makers
4. Portfolio consultants etc.
8
1.)Stockbrokers
Stock brokers are the members of stock exchanges. These are the persons who buy, sell or
deal in securities. A certificate of registration from SEBI is mandatory to act as a broker. SEBI
can impose certain conditions while granting the certificate of registrations. It is obligatory for
the person to abide by the rules, regulations and the buy-law. Stock brokers are commission
broker, floor broker, arbitrageur etc.
9000 24,000
2.) Sub-broker
Market maker is a designated specialist in the specified securities. They make both bid and
offer at the same time. A market maker has to abide by bye-laws, rules regulations of the
concerned stock exchange. He is exempt from the margin requirements. As per the listing
requirements, a company where the paid-up capital is Rs. 3 crore but not more than Rs. 5
crore and having a commercial operation for less than 2 years should appoint a market maker
at the time of issue of securities.
9
A combination of securities such as stocks, bonds and money market instruments is
collectively called as portfolio. Whereas the portfolio consultants are the persons, firms or
companies who advise, direct or undertake the management or administration of securities or
funds on behalf of their clients.
Products
The sustained growth of the economy in the past couple of years has resulted in broking firms
offering many diversified services related to IPOs, mutual funds, company research etc.
However, the core trading activity is still the predominant form of business, forming 90% of the
firms in India. 67% firms are engaged in offering IPO related services. The broking industry
seems to have capitalised on the growth of the mutual fund industry, which was pegged at
40% in 2006. More than 50% of the broking houses deal in mutual fund investment services.
The average growth in assets under management in the last two years is almost 48%.
Company research is another lucrative area where the broking firms offer their services; more
than 33% of the firms are engaged in providing company research services. Additionally, a
host of other value added services such as fundamental and technical analysis, investment
banking, arbitrage etc are offered by the firms at different levels.
10
Of the total No of broking houses providing trading services, 52% are based in the West,
followed by 25% from North, 13% from South and 10% from the East. Around 50% of the firms
offering IPO related services are based in the West as compared to 27% in North, 13% in
South and 10% in East. In providing mutual funds services, the Western region was dominant
amounting to 49% followed by 27% from North; The South and the East are almost at par with
13% and 11% respectively.
Financial Markets
The financial markets have been classified as cash market, derivatives market, debt market
and commodities market. Cash market, also known as spot market, is the most sought after
amongst investors. Majority of the broking firms are dealing in the cash market, followed by
derivative and commodities. 27% firms are dealing only in the cash market, whereas 35% are
into cash and derivatives. Almost 20% firms trade in cash, derivatives and commodities
market. Firms that are into cash, derivatives and debt are 7%. On the other hand, firms into
cash and commodities are 3%, cash & debt market and commodities alone are 2%. 4% firms
trade in all the markets.
11
In the cash market, around 34% firms trade at NSE, 14% at BSE and 52% trade at both
exchanges. In the equity derivative market, 48% of the sampled broking houses are members
of NSE and 7% trade at BSE, while 45% of the sample operate in both stock exchanges.
Around 43% of the broking houses operating in the debt market, trade at both exchanges with
31% and 26% firms uniquely at NSE and BSE respectively.
Of the brokers operating in the commodities market, 57% firms operate at NCDEX and MCX.
Around 20% and 21% firms are solely in NCDEX and MCX respectively, whereas 2% firms
trade in NCDEX, MCX and NMCE.
12
Stock brokers deals invarious investments some are:-
Stocks
Broadly, investing in stocks (also known as equities) implies buying a share of
ownership in a company and becoming a shareholder. Companies sell shares of
stock to raise money for start-up or growth. There are two types of stocks, namely,
common stock and preferred stock. Common stockholders have a percentage of
ownership in the company and may or may not receive dividends based on company
profits while preferred stockholders are entitled to dividends at specified times and in
predetermined amounts. Investment returns and risks for both types of stocks vary,
depending on factors such as the economy, political scene, the company’s
performance and the other stock market factors. Stocks are more volatile and riskier
than bonds.
Cash-equivalent investments:
These include passbook savings accounts, certificates of deposit (CDs) and treasury
bills. These investments generally deliver a more stable rate of return. Though, on
the other hand, the rate of return (after taxes are paid) is so low that these don’t
keep pace with inflation. A passbook savings account, money market fund or CD
may give the investor a quick access to his/her cash and may provide more short-
term security. However, they’re not designed for long-term investment goals like
retirement.
13
Debt securities:
This form of investment provides returns in the form of fixed periodic payments and
possible capital appreciation at maturity. It is a safer and more 'risk-free' investment
tool than equities. However, the returns are also generally lower than other
securities.
Derivatives:
These are financial contracts the values of which are derived from the value of the
underlying assets, such as equities, commodities and bonds, on which they are
based. Derivatives can be in the form of futures, options and swaps. Derivatives are
used to minimize the risk of loss resulting from fluctuations in the value of the
underlying assets (hedging). One of the derivative contracts is Options.
Options:
Options give the buyer the right to buy or sell an underlying asset at a certain price
within a specified time period. Selling or buying options involves two parties, namely
a buyer and a seller. The strategy of selling options is popular mostly with traders
who are capable of managing the element of risk that is inherent in such
transactions. Options trading involves understanding market conditions and
predicting where the markets are headed. So, when a trader believes that an asset
will appreciate in the future, he/she is likely to buy the asset at a premium value.The
instrument that gives an options holder this right to buy the underlying asset is called
a call option. A put option gives the buyer the right to sell the asset before the
predetermined date.
14
The various types of options include:
o Exchange traded options: These options have standard contracts that are settled
through clearing houses. Some of the exchange traded options include stock
options, bond options and options in futures contracts.
o Over-the-counter options: These options are contracts between two private parties.
Some of the OTC options are interest rate options and currency cross rate options.
Commodities:
The items that are traded on the commodities market are agricultural and industrial
commodities. These items need to be standardized and must be in a basic, raw and
unprocessed state. The trading of commodities is associated with high risk and high
reward. Trading in commodity futures requires specialized knowledge and in-depth
analysis. Whoever plans to diversify his/her investment portfolio and earn high
returns from price fluctuations should invest in the commodity market. Despite risk
factors, commodity trading is preferred by investors who like to take risks so as to
earn high returns even when trends are unpredictable.
Mutual funds:
A mutual fund is a professionally-managed form of collective investments that pools
money from many investors and invests it in stocks, bonds, short-term money
market instruments, and/or other securities.[1] In a mutual fund, the fund manager,
who is also known as the portfolio manager, trades the fund's underlying securities,
realizing capital gains or losses, and collects the dividend or interest income. The
investment proceeds are then passed along to the individual investors. The value of
a share of the mutual fund, known as the net asset value per share (NAV), is
calculated daily based on the total value of the fund divided by the number of shares
currently issued and outstanding.
Mutual Fund is an instrument of investing money. Nowadays, bank rates have fallen
down and are generally below the inflation rate. Therefore, keeping large amounts of
15
money in bank is not a wise option, as in real terms the value of money decreases
overa period of time.
A common investor is not informed and competent enough to understand the
intricacies of stock market. This is where mutual funds come to the rescue.
On the basis of their structure and objective, mutual funds can be classified into
following major types:
Closed-end Funds
Open-end Funds
Large cap Funds
Mid-cap Funds
Equity Funds
Balanced Funds
Growth Funds
No load Funds
Exchange Traded Funds
Value Funds
16
Money Market Funds
International Mutual Funds
Regional Mutual Funds
Sector Funds
Index Funds
Fund of Funds
Studies have shown that financial services and brokerage firms in India have seen
profits go up by 136% on a sequential quarter basis, i.e. compared to the quarter
ended December’08. The improved bottom line was largely due to IL&FS
Investsmart cutting down on its losses from the previous quarter.
17
18
2. Company Introduction - IL&FS Investsmart Limited
The company is now held by HSBC, one of the world's largest banking and financial
services organisations.
IL&FS Investsmart Ltd has an all India presence through its network of branches and
franchisees over 126 cities. Following a successful Initial Public Offer IPO), IIL has
been listed on both the National Stock Exchange (NSE) and the Bombay Stock
Exchange (BSE). IIL is geared towards understanding and achieving the financial
goals of all its customers, through its specialists in the aforesaid areas.
ORGANISATION STRUCTURE
COMPANY HISTORY
19
The company is providing customized financial management solutions to individuals
and corporate. Their principal activities are to provide brokerage related, investing
and financial services. They also provide loan and credit activities, insurance
products and security dealing services. IL&FS Investsmart Ltd was incorporated as
Investsmart India Ltd on September 1, 1997, as a wholly owned subsidiary of
Infrastructure Leasing & Financial Services Ltd. The company commenced equity
broking on NSE and BSE in February 1998 and August 1999 respectively. In June
2000, the company commenced derivative broking on NSE and in January 2001,
they launched investment advisory products. In January 2002, with the view of
consolidate the IL&FS's interests in the capital markets, IL&FS Merchant Banking
Services Ltd and DebtonNet India Ltd were merged with the company. The company
also forayed into insurance distribution by setting up wholly owned subsidiaries
namely Investsmart Insurance Agency Pvt Ltd and Investsmart Insurance
Distribution Pvt Ltd. In March 2003, the name of the company was changed from
Investsmart India Ltd to IL&FS Investsmart Ltd. During the year 2003-04, the
company acquired 4 branches of Tata TD Waterhouse Securities Pvt Ltd. They
incorporated a wholly owned subsidiary, IL&FS Investsmart Commodity Brokers Ltd
and also acquired IL&FS Academy for Insurance and Finance Ltd during the year.
During the year 2004-05, the company has Inducted two strategic partners namely,
Softbank Asia Infrastructure Fund L P (SBAIF) and E*Trade Financial Corporation.
SBAIF is a large private equity fund with funds under management exceeding USD 6
billion and E*Trade is one of the largest retail broking and banking equity based in
US with the presence in all major world markets. During the year, the company
commenced derivative broking on BSE and also commenced commodity broking
business through their wholly owned subsidiary, IL&FS Investsmart Commodity
Brokers Ltd. During the year 2005-06, the company incorporated a wholly owned
subsidiary namely IL & FS Investsmart Asia Pacific Pvt Ltd in Singapore to
undertake securities services related business. During the year 2009-07, the
company incorporated IL&FS Investsmart Securities Ltd as a wholly owned
subsidiary and transferred their Portfolio Management Services to the subsidiary
company. Also, they acquired 100% stake in Tajir Investment & Properties Ltd, a
Non-Banking Finance Company on a going concern basis. During the year 2007-08,
20
the company transferred Merchant Banking and Underwriting Business to IL&FS
Investsmart Securities Ltd. The company received the 'Best Performing National
Financial Advisor Award' from CNBC for the two years.
HSBC Group acquired 93.86 per cent of IL&FS Investsmart Limited in the year 2008.
The deal was settled for a total consideration of INR 1,311.0 crore (approximately
US$296.4 million). Investsmart gives HSBC access to the world’s third-largest
investor base, with over 20 million investor base.
Under the transaction agreement, HSBC acquired 43.85 per cent of Investsmart
from E*TRADE Mauritius Limited, an indirectly wholly-owned subsidiary of E*TRADE
Financial Corporation, and 29.36 per cent from Infrastructure Leasing and Financial
Services Limited (IL&FS). The decision to acquire a controlling stake in Investsmart
triggered an open offer to public shareholders, through which HSBC accepted
shares equivalent to 20.65 per cent of Investsmart's capital. E*TRADE Mauritius
Limited, IL&FS and those that tendered shares through the open offer received
INR200 per share for their Investsmart shares. In addition, IL&FS was paid, as part
of a three-year non-compete agreement, INR82.0 crore (approximately US$17.9
million). In accordance with local regulations, HSBC paid interest of INR2.3 per
share to the public shareholders who tendered their shares. This amounted to
INR3.31 crore approximately US$0.72 million).
HSBC was advised on the acquisition by the investment banking division HSBC
Global Banking and Markets.
21
OWNERSHIP PATTERN
22
Chart 2.1 A break up of the Equity Shares of IL&FS Investsmart Ltd.
6%
50%
44%
NUMBER OF PEOPLE
23
THE CHAIN OF COMMAND AND DEPARTMENTS
Chief
Executive
Officer
Executive
Executive
Vice President
President
Vice
Vice Vice
Vice
President President
District
District District
Head
Head Head
(Jaipur)
Branch
Branch
Branch
Branch manager
manager
Manager
Manager
(Ashok (Vaishali
(Ashok Marg)
Marg) nagar)
nagar)
Associate Associate
Associate
Operations Sales
Sales
Customer
Customer Customer Customer Sales
Sales
Customer Manager Operations Manager
Manager
Relationships
Relationships Relationships Relationships Manager Manager
Manager
Manager Manager Manager
Manager
Management
Management
Trainess
24
FINANCIAL PROFILE OF THE COMPANY
IL&FS Investsmart is listed on the National Stock Exchange (NSE) and Bombay
Stock Exchange (BSE) and its Global Depository Shares are listed on the
Luxembourg Stock Exchange.
Consolidated net loss after tax of Rs109.43 crore (US$21.54 million) for the year
ended 31 March 2009 – down Rs164.39 crore (US$32.36 million) compared with a
profit of Rs54.96 crore (US$10.82 million) for the previous year.
Operating income of Rs218.91 crore (US$43.08 million) for the year ended 31 March
2009 – down Rs173.18 (US$34.08 million), or 44.2 per cent, compared with
Rs392.09 crore (US$77.16 million) for the previous year.
Loss per share of Rs15.67 (US$0.308) for the year ended 31 March 2009 – down
from earnings per share of Rs7.87 (US$0.155) for the previous year.
Commentary
IL&FS Investsmart recorded a net loss of Rs109.43 crore (US$21.54 million) for the
year ended 31 March 2009. This represents a Rs164.39 crore (US$32.36 million)
decrease compared with the year ended 31 March 2008.
The downturn in the equity markets has lead to a steep fall of 50.5 per cent in equity
broking revenue from Rs134 crore (US$26.37 million) to Rs66.4 crore (US$13.07
million). Financing income has reduced 24.3 per cent from Rs129.4 crore (US$25.47
million) to Rs97.9 crore (US$19.27 million) on account of deteriorating market
conditions coupled with implementation of more prudent credit policies.
Operating expenses increased by Rs10.70 crore (US$2.11 million), or 3.5 per cent,
compared to the previous year mainly due to the costs associated with aligning the
business with HSBC and increased provisions for loss contingencies. In addition, a
goodwill impairment charge of Rs8.8 crore was recognised against one of the
subsidiaries.
25
ASSOCIATE COMPANIES
IISL offers Equity & Derivatives Broking, PMS, IPO Mobilisation, Mutual Funds
Distribution and other Investment Advisory Services to both retail as well as
institutional clients through a network of branches and franchisees across India. IISL
also, has a quality team of researchers that advise the clients across industries on a
regular basis.
The current set up is spread across 11 locations involving dedicated teams doing
retail distribution of insurance products. Within a short span of less than 1 year,
IIRMSL has managed be become one of the top 10 insurance broking companies in
India.
26
IAIFL has till date trained about 40,000 advisors across all the private insurance
companies at various parts of the company. It has implemented a structured
framework for delivery of the 100 hours Agents Training programs, which includes
faculty resources, institutionalised mechanisms for program evaluation, feedback
reports to the clients and ongoing program up-gradation to ensure quality and
uniformity of approach across multiple locations in the country.
27
PRODUCTS & SERVICES
1. Retail offerings
ADVISORY PRODUCTS
At IL&FS Investsmart (IIL), the expert teams of relationship managers interact with
the customers on a regular basis to discern their changing needs, in tune with the
changing environment. Most of us require some assistance in making selections
appropriate to our individual needs. We need sound advice from people who have
expertise to decipher the financial jargon of investment options available today.
The Investment Advisory Team at IIL helps its customers customize and execute
plans, based on their individual needs towards wealth maximization.
28
-About the IIL PMS Options
IL&FS Investsmart offers a choice of two types of PMS schemes since
every investor is unique and has unique investment preferences and risk
appetites. These schemes are:
IL&FS Investsmart (IIL) is one of India's leading companies engaged in the activity
IPO Advisory and Distribution. Its primary markets division does a comprehensive
research before recommending issues to clients. IIL’s pan India reach helps it in
mobilising large number of applications across India during public offerings, this
has ensured that it constantly figures amongst the top ranking performers in the
primary market distribution space.
As a part of the online offering of IIL, customers can invest in IPO's not only through
its branches but also through its website, which also provides its customers with
regular updates on the IPO scenario, Open IPOs as well as all the forthcoming IPO's
at any given point of time. The primary markets distribution division works in
29
conjunction with the retail and wholesale distribution networks, as well as its private
client group.
IL&FS Investsmart (IIL) works as a one stop shop for all Insurance & Retirement
needs. IIL has also been recognized as Best Retail Financial Advisor by CNBC TV
18 for two years in a row 2006-07 and 2007-08.
The solutions include identification, measurement and assessment of the risk and
handling of the risk, of which insurance is an integral part. We deal into both life
insurance and general insurance products for all insurance companies across India.
30
TRADING PRODUCTS
As a part of the Investment Advisory and Broking Services for individuals, IIL offers
end-to-end solutions to its investors, from capital build-up to wealth generation and
retirement planning, starting with value added investment recommendations that suit
their investment objectives, then executing these and finally step-by-step monitoring
to ensure that they achieve their long term financial goals.
IL&FS Investsmart is a full service broking house offering services across both the
Cash and F&O segments. IIL is a member with National Stock Exchange (NSE) as
well as the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE).
IIL’s offerings include 3 different trading platforms to suit the individual needs of its
customers, depending upon their profile. These are:
SmartTrade is an EXE based desktop software designed for active traders who
transact frequently to capture favorable short-term price movements. The platform
offers active traders the tools they need to make critical decisions with confidence.
31
SmartTrade is designed and built from the ground up to address the needs of active
traders. SmartTrade makes the most of state-of the-art technology to deliver power,
speed and reliability. Through an easy-to-use interface, users are provided with the
same tools and advantages that the professionals enjoy. Its features include:
o EOD charts
SmartTrade puts up to 5 years of in-depth market history at the trader’s command
with the power to instantly back-test any trading strategy they design, before risking
one rupee of their trading capital.
32
Tracking all the orders of the trader is made easy through the order status screen.
Further drill down into all details pertaining to an order is available in the order detail
sub report.
o Derivative chain
This feature provides the traders with a list of all derivative contracts available for the
selected security. To view derivative prices of a security, trader just needs to right
click on the symbol and click on derivative chain.
33
SmartINVEST: Trading platform for the Serious Investors
o Instant loading
The browser-based applet system allows the investors instant access to their
account with no wait time, unlike other systems that take a few minutes to load.
34
o Works behind a proxy
This platform can be accessed on any Internet enabled network. Investors can
access it even from their place of work.
35
o Market Depth Window
It gives an immediate "at a glance" info about the stock the investor is following. The
view provides the best 5 bid and offer quotes and the outstanding order quantities.
36
It is a powerful browser based trading system for those who are relatively new to
online investing. A unique integrated account, which integrates the investor’s
banking, broking, and Demat accounts. A comprehensive trading service, which
allows one to invest in equities and derivatives. SmartStart trading platform allows
the investor the flexibility of trading on any internet capable system, with access to
both the NSE and BSE. Its features include:
37
This platform can be accessed on any Internet enabled network. You can access it
even from your place of work.
One additional feature that applies to all the Trading Platforms is SmartCall, where
the investor can enjoy the convenience to trade over the phone.
The experienced team of Research Analysts and Advisory Managers guide the
investors with appropriate solutions, backed by in-depth research, knowledge and
expertise on a regular basis and constantly help them with the strategies for
investment in equities, recommendations for trading on futures and options, hedging
with Nifty and other product opportunities of risk-less arbitrage in various segments.
38
NRI SERVICES
NREquity
Facilitates easy trading in NSE and BSE listed stocks by offering comprehensive
trading solutions to the customers through its web and software based trading
platforms which is equipped with a host of unique features to cater to their trading
needs.
IL&FS Investsmart, offers its customers a smooth online trading experience with
exceptional trading tools, service and client support enabling them to make quick
trading decisions.
Its 3-in-1 Trading Platform enables its customers to do online delivery based trading
at their convenience. This account links their Banking, Demat and Trading account,
thus providing you a seamless platform to trade efficiently and conveniently.
Customers can also place their orders through their dedicated Call & Trade Facility
or contact their Relationship Manager.
iGrowth
It’s a discretionary Portfolio Management Scheme, focusing on investments in
equities with an objective of growth. It aims at creating long-term wealth through
judicious stock selection and asset location.
iPreserve
This scheme invests in a mix of various mutual fund schemes, ideal for investors
who wish to invest in maximizing returns from mutual funds but cannot make the
right choices.
Mutual Funds
IIL offers an opportunity to spend in a broad spectrum of Mutual Funds with more
than 500 schemes to choose from to match individual needs, goals and risk profiles.
Customers can constantly monitor their MF portfolio and make changes according to
their needs as per the market scenario, in order to make their money work for them.
IPO
40
As a part of wide range of offerings, NRIs can also invest in IPOs in India by
applying through any of the branches in India or by calling the customer service
desk. Through the company website, one can receive regular updates on the IPO
scenario, ongoing IPOs as well the forthcoming IPOs at any given point of time.
Insurance
IIL serves as the one stop shop for all the Insurance and Retirement needs. As a
composite Insurance Broker, IIL provides comprehensive risk management
solutions. IIL offers both life insurance and general insurance products for all
insurance companies in India.
IIL’s basket of Wealth Management products includes Real Estate products, Private
Equity Funds and structured products in order to suit varied individual investment
needs.
IL&FS Investsmart through its rich investment solutions and various alliances,
endeavours to provide the services and support that NRIs need to manage their
investments in India. It helps its customers through the entire investment process,
step-by-step with a host of innovative and efficient services.
- Pan Card Assistance - A doorstep delivery of Pan Card at one’s foreign location.
Permanent Account Number (PAN) Card being a mandatory requirement for NRIs
investing in financial products in India, one has to face an additional task of
communicating with PAN processing agencies in India. Being located in a different
41
country with a different times zone makes this task all the more difficult and daunting
for NRIs. IIL provides the convenience of applying for the Pan Card at the comfort of
the customer’s home at the time of availing the service itself.
- Accounting and Income Tax Returns filing in India – Making tax filing in India
easy.
IIL provides assistance and expert guidance in filing of taxation returns to its NRI
customers in India, through its exclusive alliances. This helps in better accountability
and maintenance of tax records.
The Investment solutions offered by IIL are backed by in-depth research generated
by top-drawer research team. Facilitates news and updates on the basis of daily and
monthly market analysis to keep track of the investments of its NRI customers in
India.
2. Institutional Offerings
42
Buyback of Equities
Open Offers
Mergers & Acquisitions
Private Equity Placements
ESOPs
They identify, analyse and respond instantly to the customer’s needs. Since
inception, IIL has been structuring and delivering financial solutions geared towards
its customer’s needs. This is implemented through an understanding of investor’s
business needs and their preferences. IIL’s distribution reach and financial
structuring capabilities of the team ensures a winning combination for the client
company.
Our efficient execution, quality research, top quality human resources and complete
compliance with stock exchange regulations, as well as business standard ethics
lend towards our exemplary services to investors, through IPOs, equities, derivatives
and mutual funds
IIL also focuses on identifying undiscovered value stocks to investors. Through its
gamut of services, this division is well-suited to corporate investors, banks, financial
institutions, insurance companies and FII’s. IIL’s Institutional Equity Business (IEB)
is well positioned to offer support for a complete range of investment banking service
to corporates.
43
IIL has been hosting round table conferences with leading CIOs / Fund Managers
etc. Also, conducts activities like organising of road shows, enabling the senior
management to interact with FIIs, regular conference calls for institutional Investors
etc. This works as a pre-requisite to investing in stocks. Its expertise in this area also
extends to international investors from Singapore, Hong Kong, USA and the UK.
IIL’s institutional debt broking division includes, secondary market broking, primary
market debt placement & distribution and provident fund advisory services.
Secondary debt broking is the principle service provided by this division. The clients
mainly comprise of institutional debt players, such as banks, primary dealers, mutual
funds, large provident funds and in some cases corporate treasuries. The division
empanelled with almost all banks, primary dealers and mutual funds, on whose
behalf it acts either on the buying or selling side. All types of debt papers are
covered, including government securities, treasury bills, public sector bonds,
corporate bonds etc. This desk also provides transacting and advisory services to
various provident funds and HNI clients.
The primary market services cover placement of debt paper issued by corporates,
with institutional segments covering banks, mutual funds etc. These services cover
following activities :-
The debt instrument covered by this division cover both short term as well as longer
term instruments. Commercial paper and MIBOR Linked Bonds are popular among
the short-term instruments. The division uses a proprietary online platform called
“DebtonNet” for online book building of debt issuances.
3. Other Services
Besides the above mentioned services, IIL also provides services like:
Well versed reports on Mutual funds, Market conditions, Share Market etc. on a daily
as well as weekly basis
Free of cost timely updates on advisory services through SMS on the request of its
customers
Providing Market Information and Company Information through an extensive
research team
45
Why Invest with IL&FS Investsmart Linited?
Customisation:
Investment plans are formulated on the basis of customer preference and needs, so
that the best can be brought out of an individual’s or a company’s financial profile.
Expertise:
A huge integrated research team is at work to provide the customers with financial
expertise and thorough understanding of financial markets.
Trust:
Investsmart is spread across the country through more than 300 offices providing
unmatched services.
HSBC advantage:
IL&FS Investsmart bagged the Best Performing National Financial Advisory Award
from CNBC two years in a row in 2007-2008.
One-stop-shop:
46
A BRIEF ABOUT HSBC
Headquartered in London, HSBC is one of the largest banking and financial services
organisations in the world. HSBC's international network comprises around 10,000
offices in 82 countries and territories in Europe, the Asia-Pacific region, the
Americas, the Middle East and Africa.
With listings on the London, Hong Kong, New York, Paris and Bermuda stock
exchanges, shares in HSBC Holdings plc are held by around 200,000 shareholders
in over 100 countries and territories. The shares are traded on the New York Stock
Exchange in the form of American Depositary Receipts.
HSBC India:
The antecedents of the HSBC Group in India can be traced back to October 1853
when the Mercantile Bank of India, London and China were founded in Bombay
(now Mumbai). Starting with an authorized capital of Rs. 5 million, the Mercantile
Bank soon opened offices in London, Madras (Chennai,) Colombo and Kandy,
followed by Calcutta (Kolkata), Singapore, Hong Kong, Canton (Guangchow) and
Shanghai by 1855, the following hundred years where in many ways propitious for
the Mercantile Bank. In 1950 it moved into its new head office building in Mumbai at
Flora Fountain.
HSBC in India has retained the Group's pioneering streak by being an active partner
in the development of the Indian banking industry-even giving Indian its first ATM
47
way back in 1987. The organization's adaptability, resilience and commitment to its
customers have further enabled it to service through turbulent times and prosper
through good times over the past 150 years.
HSBC India is one of India’s leading banking and financial services institutions, with
over 37,000 employees in its banking, investment banking and capital markets,
asset management, insurance broking, life insurance, software development and
global resourcing operations in the country. The India branches of The Hongkong
and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited offer a full range of banking and financial
services to over 2.8 million customers through their 47 branches and 173 ATMs
across the 26 cities of Ahmedabad, Bangalore, Chandigarh, Chennai, Coimbatore,
Gurgaon, Hyderabad, Indore, Jaipur, Jodhpur, Kochi, Kolkata, Ludhiana, Lucknow,
Mumbai, Mysore, Nagpur, Noida, New Delhi, Patna, Pune, Raipur, Trivandrum,
Thane, Vadodara and Visakhapatnam.
The HSBC Group acquired a majority stake in Investsmart to enable itself to offer
retail brokerage services to its customers across a wider geography in the country. It
has also entered into a joint venture with two of India’s leading public sector banks to
establish the Canara HSBC Oriental Bank of Commerce Life Insurance Company.
HSBC Holdings plc, the parent company of the HSBC Group, is headquartered in
London. The Group serves customers worldwide from around 9,500 offices in 86
countries and territories in Europe, the Asia-Pacific region, the Americas, the Middle
East and Africa. With assets of US$2,527 billion at 31 December 2008, HSBC is one
of the world’s largest banking and financial services organisations.
COMPETITORS
ICICI Direct
The URL ICICIDirect is owned by ICICI and managed by ICICI Web Trade Limited.
ICICI Web Trade Limited facilitates trading and related services on the internet
through maintenance of the website. Trades put through ICICIDirect.com are
executed by ICICI Web Trade Limited, which is a trading member of the National
Stock Exchange and The Stock Exchange, Mumbai. Its products and services
include:
HDFC Securities Limited is one of India’s premier broking houses and is promoted
by the HDFC (Housing Development Financial Corporation) Group. HDFC Securities
provides Online Trading in both Equity & Derivatives Segment on NSE & BSE.
Products offered by HDFC Securities include:
Online Trading for Resident and Non Resident Indians
Day Trading at both NSE and BSE
49
Trading on Futures and Options on the NSE
Online IPOs
Telephone-based Broking (Equity & Derivatives)
Cash-n-Carry on both NSE and BSE
On 11th January 2008, Standard Chartered Bank (Mauritius) Limited acquired 49% of
erstwhile UTI Securities Ltd. from Securities Trading Corporation of India (STCI).
Accordingly, the name of the company was changed from UTI Securities Ltd. to
Standard Chartered- STCI Capital Market Ltd. with effect from January 17 th 2008.
Subsequently, on December 12th 2008, SCBM acquired further 25.9% stake in
Standard Chartered – STCI Capital Markets Ltd. to increase its total stake in the
same from 49.0% to 74.9%.
50
IDBI Paisabuilder
AXIS Bank
Axis Bank is a private sector Indian bank. The bank has a net worth of Rs. 2872.19
crores. Public holding of Axis Bank shares stood at 57.60% ending 31st March,
2008.Axis Bank, in alliance with the Geojit Financial Services, provides its customers
the Online Trading facility. The service provides an integrated 3-in-one Savings
Bank Account, Demat Account and an Online Trading Account. Geojit Financial
Services Limited together with its subsidiaries provides stock and share broking
services in India. It offers trading in Equity and derivatives including index futures
and options and stock futures and options. The company was founded in 1987 and
is based in Kochi, India.
51
52
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
STATEMENT OF PROBLEM
Because of the rising competition in the brokerage industry, be it due to new entrants or the
new government policies, there is a need for every broker to adopt strategies to not only
survive in the market but also to stay ahead of its counterparts. In this report, a detailed
comparative study is done on the products and services of six Corporate Brokers in India,
namely IL&FS Investsmart, ICICIDirect, HDFC Securities, IDBI Paisabuilder, Standard
Chartered STCI and AXIS Bank. The focus is mainly on the trading products and the services
related to them. Moreover, the report aims at analyzing the strategies on competitive
advantage for IL&FS Investsmart over the other players in the volatile market, particularly after
becoming a part of the HSBC Group recently.
- Problem Definition / Title Of The Study
Comparative Analysis of the various leading Corporate Brokers and market potential of IL&FS
Investmart in jaipur .
53
Provide suggestions to the company regarding what else it can do to stand apart in this ever
competitive field and thereby emerge as a market leader.
Type of Research
Descriptive Research Descriptive research includes and fact finding enquires of different
kinds. The major purpose of descriptive research is description of the state of affairs as it
exists at present. Researcher has no control over the variables of this type of research.The
methodology of the study is based on primary and secondary data. The secondary data was
gathered from the various brokerage firms so as to establish a comprehensive comparison
with the help of statistical charts and tables.
Data Collection:
Primary Data:Data is collected primarily through personal contact, meeting, interview and
questionnaire with the concerned authority of the organization and respondents
Secondary Data:
A part of the secondary data was obtained from the flyers on the various investment plans of
the brokerage firms that were collected by personally visiting them. Some data was collected
by gathering information from concerned personnel at these firms and the rest was collected
from the various journals and websites.
A random sample of 100 people was taken. I selected the respondents to the survey on the
basis of judgment sampling with convenience taken into account.
54
Scope of the study
This research is useful for the company as it helps the company in its comparative analysis
This research is useful for the company to know their competitive advantage
This research is useful for customers as it the help of this report they can compare the two
option on the basis of brokerage rate & offered services & can select the best one.
This research also provide the information regarding the competitors plans . it helps top
manager in decision making
55
56
FACTS AND FINDINGS
Survey reveals that most of the traders prefer brokerage above all factors while trading online.
ICICI is the most popular online share trading product followed by HDFC but there is a huge
difference between them.
Internet is the most effective medium to know about the online trading account.
Survey reveals that most of the approximately 42% traders prefer IL&FS trading account due
to less brokerage charges.
The brokerage rates for the delivery of shares are the highest for ICICI Direct and the lowest
for IIL, HDFC Securities and Standard Chartered.
Brokerage rates for the Intraday Trading are the highest for HDFC Securities and the lowest
for IIL, ICICI Direct and Standard Chartered.
The annual maintenance charges, are the highest for ICICI Direct, HDFC Securities and AXIS
Bank while the lowest for only IIL
The brokerage rates for futures are the highest for IDBI Paisabuilder while all the other brokers
charge the equal rates.
Minimum brokerage is highest for Standard Chartered and the lowest for AXIS Bank.
57
ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION
58
STUDY IS BASED ON PRIMARY DATA:-
35-50 35
50 and above 15
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
18-35yr 35-50yr 50 and above
Interpretation: As can be seen from above charts, 50% of the people using online share
trading products fall in the age group of 18-35 years, which shows that the popularity of online
share trading products is at its peak in this age group and is the lowest for the age group of 50
years and above. This may be due to the fact that people in the age group of 18-35 years are
well versed with computers, have fewer responsibilities and can afford to take risks. The age
group of 35-50 years shows a little smaller figure, which may be because at this stage some
people use computers while some don t and some are just unwilling to put money into shares
due to increasing responsibilities and hence the question of online trading does not arise.
People above 50 years are nearing retirement and in some cases even retired, so they might
have some excess cash and hence they too are willing to invest in shares through Internet,
which is less cumbersome and tedious as compared to offline trading.
CHART 2: OCCUPATION
59
Student 5
Service 20
Professional 35
Self employed 40
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
Interpretation: Survey was conducted majorly on individuals who are employed. The major
chunk were of self employed people and other professionals from different areas. Quarter of
them were from service sector and rest were students.
60
Online 86
Offline 14
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Interpretation: Out of the 100 respondents, (86%) had invested in shares through any online
trading product. this shows that the penetration of online share trading product among the
populace is high inspite of the fact that it was introduced only 6 years ago. However, this reach
is in a city like Mumbai, which is considered the commercial hub of the country; hence one can
expect the penetration level of online share trading products to be a little low in other smaller
cities/towns
61
CHART 4: Important Parameter While Selecting An Online Share Trading
Account?
Brand name 20
Brokerage 45
Security 5
Location 5
Other facility 10
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
Interpretation:
Survey reveals that most of the traders prefer brokerage above all factors while trading online.
Brand image and security follows next as they got preference by 23% and 13% respectively.
Location of firm and other facilities are least considered while trading online.
62
ICICI 30
KOTAK 10
HDFC 25
IL&FS 15
AXIS 20
30
25
20
15
10
Interpretation:ICICI is the most popular online share trading product followed by HDFC but
there is a huge difference between them. HDFC is at 25% and AXIS with 20%. IL&FS is at the
fourth position with 15% popularity and KOTAK is fifth with 10% popularity. IL&FS s popularity
is quite encouraging from the company s point of view considering the fact that it has begun its
online trading operations only about a year ago
CHART 6: How Did You Come To Know About IL&Fs Online Trading
Account?
63
Print 32
TV 8
Internet 49
Friends 8
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
Interpretation:49% of the respondents came to know about the online trading account
through the Internet itself, hence it may be concluded that the Internet is the most effective
medium as far as getting the customer s attention is concerned. Second most popular medium
turned out to be print (newsletter), which are not much far from the internet.32% of the
respondents, came to know about the online trading account through the newsletter
subscription. The potential of television and print friends of promotion doesn’t seem to have
been utilized fully as they lag behind with only 11% and 8% respectively of the total respondents
interviewed came to know about the online trading accounts them
CHART 7: Why Did You Choose IL&Fs Online Trading Account?
Brokerage 45
64
Advice 25
Efficient 20
Security 10
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
Interpretation:
Survey reveals that most of the approximately 42%traders prefer IL&FS trading account due to
less brokerage charges. 22% prefers IL&FS due to their good advice. Rest adopted online
trading account of IL&FS due to its efficiency and security.
65
Yes 70
No 30
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
Interpretation: Most of the people are satisfied with their choices. However 30 % of the
total respondents were not satisfied with their products, which could be a potential avenue for
consumers waiting to be tapped by the competitors as well as new firms entering into the e-
trading market.
66
Table 3.1 Charges for Opening Online Trading Account
Broker Online Trading Account Opening
Charges
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) Rs. 950
ICICIDirect Rs. 975
HDFC Securities Rs. 750
Standard Chartered – STCI Rs. 499
IDBI Paisabuilder Rs. 499
AXIS Bank Rs. 1050
1200
1000
800
600
Online Trading A/C Opening
400 Charges (Rs.)
200
Chart 3.1 Online Trading A/C Opening Charges of the Corporate Brokers
Interpretation:
An online trading account enables the investors to trade in the stock market through online
trading platforms. According to table 3.1 and chart 3.1,the charges for opening an online
trading a/c are the highest for AXIS Bank and the lowest for Standard Chartered. The charges
at IIL are neither too high, nor too low.
67
Broker Brokerage on Delivery
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) 0.50%
ICICI Direct 0.75%
HDFC Securities 0.50%
Standard Chartered-STCI 0.50%
IDBI 0.65%
AXIS Bank 0.55%
0.80%
0.70%
0.60%
0.50%
0.40%
0.10%
0.00%
Interpretation:
The brokerage rates for the delivery of shares are the highest for ICICI Direct and the lowest
for IIL, HDFC Securities and Standard Chartered.
68
Broker Brokerage on Intraday Trading
0.16%
0.14%
0.12%
0.10%
0.08%
0.02%
0.00%
Interpretation:
Intraday trading refers to opening and closing a position in a security in the same trading
day.Brokerage rates for the Intraday Trading are the highest for HDFC Securities and the
lowest for IIL, ICICIDirect and Standard Chartered.
Table 3.4 Annual Maintenance Charges for Demat A/C (Basic Plan)
69
Broker AMC for Demat A/C
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) Rs. 300
ICICI Direct Rs. 500
HDFC Securities Rs. 500
Standard Chartered –STCI Rs. 400
IDBI Paisabuilder Rs. 350
AXIS Bank Rs. 500
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
150
AMC for Demat A/C
100
50
0
Axis Title
Interpretation:
A Demat a/c holder needs to pay annual maintenance charges, which on a certain turnover
level is refunded by some of the brokers. The charges are the highest for ICICIDirect, HDFC
Securities and AXIS Bank while the lowest for only IIL.
70
Broker Brokerage on Futures
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) 0.05%
ICICI Direct 0.05%
HDFC Securities 0.05%
Standard Chartered – STCI 0.05%
IDBI Paisabuilder 0.055%
AXIS Bank 0.05%
0.06%
0.05%
0.05%
0.05%
0.05%
0.05%
0.05% Brokerage Rates for Futures
0.05%
0.05%
Axis Title
Interpretation:
The brokerage rates for futures are the highest for IDBI Paisabuilder while all the other brokers
charge the equal rates.
71
Broker Brokerage
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) Rs. 25 or 2.5% whichever is lower
ICICI Direct Rs. 25 or 2.5% whichever is lower
HDFC Securities Not Available
Standard Chartered - STCI Rs. 25 or 2.5% whichever is higher
IDBI Paisabuilder Rs. 20 or 2.5% whichever is higher
AXIS Bank Rs. 20 or 2.5% whichever is lower
Interpretation:
The plan for minimum brokerage that is chargeable per executed order value varies for
different brokers, in a way that Rs. 25 is maximum amount chargeable by IIL and ICICIDirect,
Rs. 25 is the minimum amount chargeable by Standard Chartered, Rs. 20 is the minimum
amount chargeable by IDBI Paisabuilder and Rs. 20 is the maximum amount chargeable by
AXIS Bank. The charges for HDFC Securities are not available. Hence, among the 5 brokers,
the highest would be for Standard Chartered and the lowest would be for AXIS Bank.
72
Broker Charges
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) NIL
ICICI Direct Chargeable
HDFC Securities NIL
Standard Chartered- STCI Chargeable
IDBI Paisabuilder Chargeable
AXIS Bank Chargeable
Interpretation:
The brokers provide SMS Alerts Service updating their customers on the share market and
giving advice on investments on a regular basis. Some brokers like IIL and HDFC Securities
provide this facility free of cost. While the others charge some fee.
73
Broker Charges
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) Nil
ICICI Direct Nil
HDFC Securities Nil
Standard Chartered -STCI Chargeable
IDBI Paisabuilder Chargeable
AXIS Bank Chargeable
Interpretation:
Various brokers avail their customers of research reports on topics like trends in the market,
position of mutual funds, IPOs, comparative studies of different companies, investment
opportunities in a particular sector etc. IIL, ICICI and HDFC provide these for free, while the
others charge a certain amount.
Broker Charges
74
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) Rs. 25
ICICI Direct Rs. 30
HDFC Securities Not Available
Standard Chartered- STCI 25
IDBI Paisabuilder 30
AXIS Bank 10
30
25
20
10
0
IL&FS Inv. -HSBC ICICI Direct StanChart IDBI Paisabuilder AXIS Bank
Interpretation:
The Charges in this category are the highest for IDBI and ICICI, while lowest for AXIS. For ILL,
these charges are neither too high nor too low.
Broker Charges
75
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) 35
ICICI Direct 35
HDFC Securities Not Available
Standard Chartered- STCI 30
IDBI Paisabuilder 30
AXIS Bank 50
50
45
40
35
30
25 Demat Charges
20
15
10
0
IL&FS Inv. -HSBC ICICI Direct StanChart IDBI Paisabuilder AXIS Bank
Interpretation:
Demat refers to a dematerialized account. Just as one has to open an account with a bank, if
he/she wants to save his/her money, make cheque payments etc., one needs to open a demat
account if he/she wants to buy or sell and transact sharesDemat Charges are the highest for
AXIS while lowest for Standard Chartered and IDBI. IIL charges are neither too high nor too
low.
Broker Charges
76
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) 25
ICICI Direct 20
HDFC Securities Not Available
Standard Chartered- STCI 50
IDBI Paisabuilder 20
AXIS Bank 50
50
45
40
35
30
20
15
10
0
IL&FS Inv. -HSBC ICICI Direct StanChart IDBI Paisabuilder AXIS Bank
Interpretation:
The electronic holdings can be converted back into certificates if one wishes to get back
his/her shares in physical form. This is called Rematerialisation or Remat. Remat Charges are
highest for Standard Chartered and AXIS and lowest for ICICI and IDBI. IIL charges are
neither too high nor too low.
Broker Charges
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) 25
77
ICICI Direct 30
HDFC Securities Not Available
Standard Chartered- STCI 50
IDBI Paisabuilder 100
AXIS Bank 25
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
Charges for Pledge Creation
15
10
5
0
Interpretation:
Pledge is an activity of taking loan against securities by the investor. The investor is called as
‘pledgor’ and he entity who is giving the loan against the securities is called as ‘pledgee’.
Charges in this category are the highest for Standard Chartered and AXIS while lowest for IIL
and IDBI.
Broker Charges
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) 25
ICICI Direct 30
HDFC Not Available
78
StanChart 50
IDBI 25
AXIS Bank 50
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
Charges for Pledge Closure
15
10
5
0
Interpretation:
After the pledgor repays the loan to the pledgee, the pledgor will submit an instruction to its DP
to initiate the closure of pledge/hypothecation by indicating the option "close the
pledge/hypothecation" in the pledge/hypothecation form. This is known as Pledge Closure.
Here, the charges are highest for Standard Chartered and AXIS and lowest for IIL and IDBI.
Broker Charges
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) 25
ICICI Direct 20
HDFC Not Available
StanChart 50
IDBI 20
79
AXIS Bank 100
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
Account Statement Charges
30
20
10
0
Interpretation:
Here, the AXIS charges extraordinarily high fee while ICIC and IDBI charge the lowest. IIL, on
the other hand, charges just a little above the lowest rates.
Broker Charges
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) 50
ICICI Direct 30
HDFC Not Available
StanChart 50
IDBI 100
AXIS Bank 50
80
100
90
80
70
60
30
20
10
0
IL&FS Inv. -HSBCICICI Direct StanChartIDBI PaisabuilderAXIS Bank
Interpretation:
When a pledgee does not repay the loan amount, the shares pledged with the Bank can be
transferred in their favor. This is similar to the physical shares being transferred in the name of
the lender in the event of a default, who will receive the corporate actions like dividends, bonus
etc in Pledged shares. This is pledge invocation. The charges for these are extremely high for
IDBI, while lowest for only ICICI. IIL, Standard Chartered and AXIS charge average rates.
Broker Turnover
IL&FS Investsmart (HSBC) 4 Times
ICICI Direct 4 Times
HDFC 3 Times
StanChart 3 Times
IDBI 4 Times
AXIS Bank 3 Times
81
4
3.5
2.5
2 Turnover
1.5
0.5
0
IL&FS Inv. -HSBC ICICI Direct HDFC Securities StanChart IDBI Paisabuilder AXIS Bank
Interpretation:
Turnover on the basis of deposit account is the limit which is given by the broker to the
customer for doing intraday trading on his/her deposit amount. The higher it is, the better. The
results of the research show that it is the highest for IIL, ICICI and IDBI.
82
83
SWOT ANALYSIS OF THE COMPANY:
Strengths:
Upgraded product design and development facilities to develop new products and aid
diversification
Diverse Branch Network provides ample opportunities to penetrate deep into the existing &
untapped market.
It does not keep any condition as to collect minimum amount of brokerage from its clients
Trading via branch network, telephones and internet account i.e. both online and offline
Weakness:
84
High brokerage charges from competitors.
Opportunities:
The Capital market in the last few years has turned out to be one of the favorable avenues for
the retail investors
Threats:
86
87
CONCLUSION
According to the study, IL&FS Investsmart takes the lead in the category of Corporate Brokers
with an advantage of HSBC Group at its side. IIL is better service provider than its competitors
because of its value added services like free SMS Alerts and free research reports and expert
financial advice etc.. and other services at minimal charges.
The findings also showed that AXIS Bank charges exceptionally high fee for almost all of its
services, hence stands quite behind as a competitor for IL&FS Investmart, and infact was least
preferred among the respondents.
A large number of people have their Demat and Trading accounts and prefer to invest in
derivatives and securities market. Maximum number of people seeks returns and tax benefits
from their investments. Most of the respondents that had Demat and Trading accounts were
businessmen.
The maximum number of respondents preferred IIL over other Corporate Brokers. However,
IDBI is a close competitor to IIL,be it the quality of service or the charges and fees. Hence,
there is still some room for improvement for IIL. Following recommendations might prove of
some help:
There is a need to actively promote the products and services for IL&FS Investsmart (IIL).
Recent acquisition by HSBC Group can prove a very effective weapon for IIL, since HSBC
Group is one of the largest financial organisations of the world. With merely its brand name, IIL
can build a larger customer base across the country.
Clients need to be acknowledged of the benefits of diversified investments, since most of the
people are reluctant to invest due to the fear of capital loss and lack of awareness.
Trainings and seminars should be constantly held for the staff to improve their strategies and
skills, especially since they face bigger challenge on quality services, being a part of HSBC
Group.
It can be concluded that IL&FS INVESTSMART, although new to the online share trading field,
has been able to build a sound customer base if the survey conducted is to be believed.
IL&FS INVESTSMART has a strong presence in almost every part of the country which can
eventually lead to a very big customer base.
88
The company will find it relatively easy to further introduce its other latest products through its
strong reach throughout the country.
A sound base in almost the entire country and as much as six different mediums used by the
company to reach out to potential customers means that the company is going all out to
increase its market share.
89
90
RECOMMENDATION & SUGGESTIONS
IL&FS should enhance the customers care department, wherein queries of clients can
be timely solved.
More authority should be delegated to the Branch Offices in order to speed up the
working process of opening accounts.
Technical Connectivity at IL&FS should have a proper check and control by the team of
experts from time to time.
IL&FS should organize some cultural events quarterly or yearly basis to increase the
bonding among the employees.
IL&FS should try to make effective pay out system to business partner i.e. franchise
owner.
Company should have to adopt turnover based brokerage rate policy to enhance their
customer’s turnover.
IL&FS should also try and increase its level of presence in certain sections of the media
such as Television and Radio. Tie-ups with business channels such as CNBC, NDTV
PROFIT or ZEE BUSINESS can be of great advantage.
Increase the distribution network for in form of drop boxes and get in tie ups with mobile
phone galleries with reliance web shops or set up drop boxes at railways stations which will
facilitate easy payment opportunities for the client.
Increase after market hours time to benefit of the customers.
The above mentioned steps might increase the company s expenditure initially but it
can be a profitable exercise in the long run.
91
DIFFERENT INVESTMENT PLANS OF DIFFERENT CORPORATE HOUSES
SMART POWER
In both of these plans company can’t provide software . For software customer have to
pay 3000/- p.a.
SMART ELITE
The amount which is given in form of Advance subscription value adjusted only in
brokerage
ADVANCE TRADE
93
Total Eligible turnover per Month Brokerage (%) on each leg
Below Rs 5 lac 0.50%
Rs 5 lac –Rs 10 lac 0.45%
Rs 10 lac - Rs 25 lac 0.35%
Rs 25 lac – Rs 50 lac 0.30%
More than Rs 50 lac 0.25%
Min. charges Rs 25/- or 2.5% whichever is higher
INTRADAY TRANSACTIONS
FUTURES TRANSACTIONS
OPTIONS TRANSACTIONS
96
OPTIONS BASED TRANSACTIONS
In all these plans ICICI bank provides maximum different quarterly free turnover on
the basis of the charges of plans and on this free turnover bank could charge any
amount of brokerage.
If the customer can cross the limit of free quarterly turnover after this bank can be
charge brokerage on the excess amount.
The amount of brokerage can be charge on the basis of the turnover of the customer.
CLASSIC
OPTIONS TRANSACTIONS
According to this plan customer have to pay Rs 700/ - for the account opening
In this plan brokerage is based on turnover per month of the customer .
More the turnover lesser the brokerage
98
INTRADAY BASED TRANSACTIONS
OPTIONS TRANSACTIONS
99
APPENDIX
QUESTIONNAIRE
5) WHAT WOULD BE YOUR LIKELY INVESTMENT OVER THE NEXT ONE YEAR?
1] UPTO RS 1 LAKH 2] RS 1- 3 LQKH
3] RS 3- 5 LAKH 4] RS 5 LAKH AND ABOVE
9) HOW DID YOU COME TO KNOW ABOUT IL&FS ONLINE TRADING ACCOUNT?
1] TV 2] PRINT
3] INTERNET 4] FRIENDS
ICICIDIrect
AXIS Bank
IDBI Paisabuilder
IL&FS Investsmart
Standard Chartered
101
102
.
103
REGISTERED OFFICE : 5th Floor, Mafatlal Centre, Nariman Point, Mumbai 400 021.
BACK OFFICE OPERATIONS : IDBI Building, Ground Floor, ‘B’ wing, Plot No. 39-41, Sector 11, CBD Belapur, Navi Mumbai - 400
614.
1. Basic
2.Classic
104
(A) DELIVERY-BASED TRANSACTIONS
Total Eligible Turnover per Month Brokerage Per Leg (%)
105
Rs. 10,00,00,001 & Above Enquire with us
1% on the premium, subject to a minimum of Rs. 100/- per Lot for options trade. (On both buy & sell)
3. Premium
106
(B) Half yearly Subscription - Rs. 1900 Subscription(Non-Refundable)
Validity - 6 Months
Platform
4. Select
107
Pricing & Features
Franking
A/c Charges at
Brokerage opening Default Platform
Rs450/-
Min Upfront Max Upfront charges
Subscription Subscription to be born by
Intraday &
Delivery Option Trades
Futures
0.75% of premium or
5000 9999 0.120% 0.0120% Rs. 75 per Lot Nil Client streaming+EXE
whichever is higher
0.70% of premium or
10000 14999 0.090% 0.0090% Rs. 70 per Lot Nil ICMS streaming+EXE
whichever is higher
0.65% of premium or
15000 19999 0.070% 0.0070% Rs. 65 per Lot Nil ICMS streaming+EXE
whichever is higher
0.60% of premium or
20000 24999 0.050% 0.0050% Rs. 60 per Lot Nil ICMS streaming+EXE
whichever is higher
0.50% of premium or
25000 Above 0.045% 0.00450% Rs. 50 per Lot Nil ICMS streaming+EXE
whichever is higher
Note:
• The upfront amount paid by the client for availing such benefit will be charged as subscription fee & would be non refundable
• There would be no exposure limits given against such subscription fees paid by the client
• Client can choose to pay any amount above the minimum of Rs. 5000/- plus service tax as applicable from time to time.
• Based on the upfront subscription fee paid by the client, corresponding brokerage rates would be levied as per the table above
• Client's slab would be decided on net value of subscription charges paid by him excluding service tax.
• Applicable brokerage rates would be valid till client reaching a total brokerage equal to the net upfront subscription amount paid by
the client or a period of 1 year from the start of such scheme benefits which ever is earlier
• After the expiry of the validity of the subscription, the client would be charged as per the classic plan of IDBI Capital without any
prior intimation to the client.
• To give effect of the above said benefit of 'Select Plan' to existing clients, IDBI Capital would take at least 2 working days after
receipt of duly filled in & signed documents at it's head office
Terms & Conditions for all the above brokerage plans (Basic,Classic,Premium & Select) :
108
(i) Minimum Brokerage:
In all the above schemes except Premium, the minimum brokerage charged would be: 2 paise per share for Delivery subject to an
overall minimum of Rs. 20 per contract, whichever is higher. Contracts will be separate for NSE and BSE, normal segment and for
Trade-to-Trade segment. 1 paisa per share for intraday square off subject to an overall minimum of Rs. 20 per contract note,
whichever is higher. Contracts will be separate for NSE and BSE. However in Premium, the minimum brokerage charged would be
0.0001% of the applicable turnover.
(ii) General Terms:
• Securities Transaction Tax, Service Tax and other levies would be charged extra on actual
• If DELIVERY transactions are SQUARED-OFF within the same Day / Settlement, INTRA-DAY BROKERAGE will be charged for all
such transactions (both sides).
• For NSE Trades Brokerage is calculated on a per share basis and is rounded off to the second decimal.
• The Final value of the Brokerage and Service Tax is arrived at by multiplying the per share value in four decimals with the Quantity
and then rounding it off to second decimal.
• For Futures intra-day square-off (a contract or a position being entered and squared-off on the same day), brokerage will be
charged only for the first leg of the transaction and for the second leg which is in the nature of square-off or the reversal of the first
leg, no brokerage will be charged.
• In case of same day square off in the options contract, brokerage would be charged on both buy and sell sides.
• It is clarified that brokerage on options contracts shall not exceed 2.5% of the premium amount or Rs 100/- (per lot) whichever is
higher.
• In case of change of brokerage plan for any client, platform charges shall be applicable as per new plan.
• Time validity period will be computed on the basis of the month in which account gets activated for respective brokerage plans.
Annual Maintenance Charge (AMC) for Demat A/c Free for the first Year. AMC Rs. 350 from year twoonwards.
Transaction charges for DP - Buy (only for off market transactions) NIL
Transaction charges for DP - Sell (Online) Rs. 6 per transaction done through IDBIpaisabuilder.in
Dematerialisation/Certificate Rs. 3
Rematerialisation Rs. 20
109
Invocation/Closure of Pledge Rs. 25
110
111
112
113
114
WEBLIOGRAPHY
www.ibef.org/industry/financialservices.aspx
http://www.hdfcbank.com/aboutus/default.htm
http://www.kotaksecurities.com/home/index.html
http://www.idbi.co.in/about_us.aspx
http://www.isnare.com/?aid=308470&ca=Finances
http://www.calicutnet.com/articles/gopinath/online-trading/
http://www.icici.com/aboutus/cg/interim_reports.htm
http://www.moneycontrol.com/stocks/marketstats/index.php
http://www.investopedia.com/university/fundamentalanalysis/
BIBLIOGRAPHY
REFERENCES:
Kristi A Tange, Derivatives operations, Goldman Sachs & Co., New York, USA (2008)
VCCircle analysis of the financials (2009)
Goldman Sachs (May 2009)
Dealogic, the Global Deal Data Provider (2009)
Indian Brand Equity Foundation (June 2009)
News Release by HSBC Holdings plc (April29, 2009)
The Association of Investment Trust Companies (October 2004)
115
BOOKS:
Kothari C. R.: Research Methodology=methods and techniques.
Kotler Phillip: Marketing Management Eleventh revised edition, 2002.
Gupta S. P.: Statistical Methods Thirteen revised edition, 2001.
Khan, M Y , Financial services, Tata McGraw-Hill, New Delhi 2006.
Khan, M Y ,Indian Financial system, Tata McGraw-Hill, New Delhi 2007
116