Login | Register FREE!

| English | Korean | About Us

Search

  Home | Reports | Technical Documents | Tech-Blog | One-Shot Gallery | Korea ICT News | Korea Communica on Market Data | List of Contributors | Become a Contrib
 
Sec on 5G 4G LTE C-RAN/Fronthaul Gigabit Internet IPTV/Video Streaming IoT SDN/NFV Wi-Fi KT SK Telecom LG U+ Network Protocol Samsung Korean Ven
 
Private 5G | Edge Netmanias Private 5G Analysis KT SK Telecom Verizon AT&T Vodafone DT Telefonica China Mobile Optage NEC Fujitsu Microso AWS
HFR Ericsson Nokia Huawei Samsung Mavenir Affirmed Metaswitch Athonet Al ostar Airspan Kyocera Apresia
CHANNELS HFR Private 5G Solu on (my5G) my5G Solu on Components my5G Key Features my5G Resources

HFR, Inc. Announces my5G™, Standalone Whole Network for Private Wireless

NETMANIAS ONE-SHOT GALLERY

Comparison of the SD-WAN vendor solu ons

July 05, 2017 | By Dr. Harrison J. Son @ Netmanias (tech@netmanias.com)

Download Comparison of the SD-WAN vendor solutions

PDF File

Lasted Updated: July 12, 2017 (Juniper added)

Comments (11)

15 Velocloud Viptela Versa Silver Peak Citrix Riverbed Talari Ecessa Nuage/Nokia

Share SD-WAN Solution Cloud- Secure Versa Cloud Silver Peak Netscaler SteelConnect SD-WAN SD-WAN Nuage VNS
Delivered Extensible IP Platform Unity SD-WAN
SD-WAN Network
SD-WAN Controller VeloCloud vSmart SD-WAN Unity NetScaler SteelConnect Network Ecessa VSC
Policy Provisioning Orchestrator controller controller Orchestrator SD-WAN Center Manager Controller Insight
SD-WAN CPE Velocloud Viptela vEdge FlexVNF Unity CloudBridge SteelConnect Talari Edge/PowerLink NSG
Edge EdgeConnect Gateway Appliances /WANworX
Appliance Appliance Appliance Appliance Appliance Appliance Appliance Appliance Appliance
SD-WAN CPE Formfactor
/VNF /VNF /VNF /VNF /VNF /VNF /VNF /VNF /VNF
Zero Touch Provisioning O O O O O O O O O
No. of auto-detect applications
2,200 3,000 2,600 10,000+ 4,000 1,300 N/A N/A 1,400
(e.g., Skype, Facebook,…)
Network Performance O (passive) O (active) O (active) O (passive) O (passive) O (active) O (passive) N/A O (active)
Measurement Proprietary BFD ITU-T Proprietary Proprietary ICMP Ping Proprietary OWAMP
Y.1731

Dynamic Path Switching

O O O O O O O O O

Per-flow load balancing O O O O O O O O O

Per-packet load balancing
(Link Aggregation: Use multiple O O O O O X O O X
links to support the same session)
Unidirectional measurement and
steering (Can be different upstream O X O X O X O X O
and downstream path, Asymmetric)
O X O O X X X X X
FEC Forward Error Control
(dynamic, (TCP
for packet loss
for VoIP) applications)
Packet Duplication O X O X O X O O X
Use multiple links to send (for VoIP) (UDP (for VoIP) (for VoIP) (VoIP, real-time
the same packet. applications) applications)
Data Encryption AES-256 O O O O O O O O O
Segmentation O O O O O O O N/A O
Network slicing Proprietary VPN

/
 VRF at SD- ID in IPsec packet VRF-lite at SD-
WAN CPE header WAN CPE
O O O O O O O O O
WAN Optimization Support
(3rd party) (3rd party)

N/A: Not Announced

O: supported
X: not supported

See Also,

SD-WAN traffic path control and WAN quality enhancement solutions by vendor: (2) Citrix, Netmanias Tech-Blog
Netmanias Interview with Nuage/Nokia - Software Defined WAN (SD-WAN), Netmanias Report
D-WAN traffic path control and WAN quality enhancement solutions by vendor (1): Silver Peak, Netmanias Tech-Blog
Survey - Operator’s Managed SD-WAN Services, Netmanias One-Shot Gallery

SD-WAN TERMS | Netmanias' Definition

/
Ralph Santitoro 2017-07-11 00:56:22

/
 What's the difference between an 'X' and an 'O' in the above table? Would be good for you to add a legend indicating this.

Chris Yoo 2017-07-11 12:41:41

Hi Ralph, my understanding is as follows:

- X : not supported
- O : supported

Nikhil Tambe 2017-09-06 01:51:06

Very nice summary, do you have details on the report ?

e.g - When you say WAN Optimization support what all does it iinclude ?Compression > De-Duplication ?

gsronald 2018-07-17 07:37:12

from my opinion, if dedupe / compression, it may affect the quality of network. If running VOIP, the voice quality may be affected.

Balaji KCS 2017-12-20 00:23:24

Does SD-WAN support scenarios where the Applications accessed are in Datacenters or in cloud dcs where the CPE or any BOX cannot be installed ?. SD-WAN for the enterprise , yes i understand it wo
talking about B-C (Business to CLient) scenarios.
thanks,
Balaji KCS

Gangdharan 2018-08-08 19:04:44

Very nice summary. Really useful for comparing products and getting good reference.

Anil Chaitanya Mandru 2018-10-11 04:18:48

Thank you for this summary. But, its more than one year old (which is an eternity in the SD-WAN old :) ).
Hope we will see a update soon.

Francesco 2019-03-13 23:59:20

Wow very nice summary!

What about Meraki? Why it's not considered in SD-WAN solutions?

Mick Russom 2019-04-27 00:22:10

Looking forward to an update to this excellent material. Add more vendors and add more features! Excellent information.

Bharat 2019-05-09 16:02:13

Hi can you update about merraki in this comparrison

SDWAN-MAN 2019-09-20 02:33:17

Could you please add Peplink / Pepwave to this?

Thank you for visiting Netmanias! Please leave your comment if you have a question or suggestion.

Characters

Related Contents

/
 Shi of Enterprise Business from MPLS to SD-WAN
View All (518)
4G (1) 4G LTE (2) 5G (46) AI (1) ARPU (2) AT&T (1) Akamai (2) Alcatel (1) Backhaul (2) C-

Extending SD-WAN to Wireless LAN RAN/Fronthaul (17) CDN (8) CORD (1) CPRI (1) Carrier Aggregation (2) China (2) Chin
Mobile (2) Cisco(1) D-RAN (1) DHCP (1) FTTH (6) Femto Gateway (2) Frequency (5) GiGA

12/10/2018
Gigabit Internet (19) Google (2) HDS (1) HLS (3) HTTP A
LTE (1) GiGAtopia (1)

Netmanias Blog (31) IoT (9) KT (47) Korea

Streaming (4) Handover (1) HeNB-GW (2) IPTV
Securing zero touch for uCPE deployments ICT Market (28) Korea ICT Service (1) Korea ICT Vendor (1) LG
U+ (32) LTE (57) LTE-A (8) LTE-B (2) MEC (6) MPLS (1) MPLS-TP (1) MWC 20
06/07/2018 2016 (1) Microsoft (1) NAT (1) NTT (1) NTT Docomo (1) Network Architecture (9) Netw
Netmanias Blog Protocol (3) Network Slicing (1) OTT (2) On-Net CDN (3) Openflow (2) Pay TV (1) Private
5G (
Security is a many-layered thing* SDN/NFV (19) SK Broadband (4) SK
WAN (2)

Telecom(40) Samsung (1) Transparent Cache (1) UHD (6) Verizon (1) Video
05/14/2018 Streaming (14) Wi-Fi (4) Wideband LTE (1) eMBMS (6) ePDG (1)
Netmanias Blog

Carrier-Neutral Data Centers are the Key to Lower WAN Costs

11/09/2017
Netmanias Blog

Is vCPE the new future or Cloud CPE? Is our tradi onal physical CPE s ll holding down
the fort?

10/20/2017
Netmanias Blog

Service Providers Are Deploying SD-WAN

10/10/2017
Netmanias Blog

What Is Universal CPE? (updated at May 2018)

09/14/2017
Netmanias Blog

Netmanias Interview with Juniper Networks: So ware-Defined WAN (SD-WAN)

08/01/2017
Netmanias Reports

So ware and Support Op mize SD-WAN for Enterprises

07/31/2017
Netmanias Blog

 
       
Register | About Us | Sponsor Channel Service (Korean Market) | Advertise | Contact Us | LinkedIn | Our Korea
   
 

 
HQ: 201, Hanho Building 33, Nonhyeon-ro 64-gil, Gangnam-gu, Seoul, 06228, Rep. of KOREA
Netmanias USA: 5214 36th Ave. NE Seattle, WA 98105 USA
 
  Netmanias was founded in year 2002, and provides in-depth analysis and overview of 4G & 5G mobile,
IoT, SDN/NFV, Gigabit Internet and video streaming technologies as well as trends in the evolution
of Korean operators’ networks and services
Copyright ⓒ 2002-2018 NMC Consulting Group. All rights reserved.