Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Definitions:
TAX: Compulsory monetary contribution to the state's revenue, assessed and imposed by a government on the
activities, enjoyment, expenditure, income, occupation, privilege, property, etc., of individuals and organizations.
Characteristics of Taxation:
The economist, Adam Smith, in his book 'Wealth of Nations', proposed that a 'good tax' should have the following
characteristics:
a) Equity: the tax burden should be fairly distributed, e.g. a higher rate tax for wealthier individuals.
b) Certainty: an individual should be able to determine the tax implication of their actions.
c) Convenience: tax should be easy to pay.
d) Efficiency: tax should be easy and cheap to collect.
General Principles of Taxation
Characteristics of Taxation:
According to the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants’ ‘Guiding Principles of Good Tax Policy’:
• Equity and fairness • Neutrality
Capital Losses:
Capital losses can be relieved in the following ways:
a) Carried back against previous capital gains
b) Carried forward against future capital gains
c) Offset against current or future trading profits
However, many countries do not allow capital gains to be carried back against previous capital gains or to be offset against
trading profits.
General Principles of Taxation
Rollover Relief:
An entity may sell an asset and realize a capital gain. However, it may then need to replace the asset. If the entity pays tax
on the capital gain, this will reduce the proceeds available for reinvestment. Therefore, some countries allow the tax
charge on the disposal of a business asset to be deferred until the replacement asset is disposed of. If this is a type of
asset that will have to be continuously replaced (such as manufacturing machinery), then this deferral could go on
indefinitely. In some tax jurisdictions, this is known as rollover relief.
Recharacterizing Debt:
Generally interest payments are tax deductible whereas dividend payments are not. Therefore groups may try to reduce
their tax bill by transferring funds between group companies in the form of interest on intragroup loans instead of by the
payment of dividends.
This has an adverse effect on government tax revenue so many countries have limited the amount of interest that is tax
deductible. Any interest which is in excess of the limit is instead re-classified as dividends and therefore will not be tax
deductible. A company may be said to be thinly capitalized when it exceeds this interest limit.
General Principles of Taxation
International Taxation:
Corporate residence:
Entities usually pay company income tax on their worldwide income in the country they are resident in for tax purposes.
Therefore determining an entity’s country of residence is important. There are different ways to determine the residence of
an entity, including its:
a) Place of incorporation (domicile)
b) Place of effective management and control
c) Place of permanent establishment
A permanent establishment means a fixed place of business through which the business of an entity is wholly or partly
carried on. There must be a degree of permanence, for example: (i) Place of management, (ii) Branch, (iii) Office, (iv) Factory,
(v) Workshop, (vi) Mine, oil or gas well, quarry, (vii) A building site or construction or installation project if it lasts more than
12 months
A warehouse is not a permanent establishment, it is just a storage area. A permanent establishment is somewhere where
trade is carried out or decisions are made.
General Principles of Taxation
Double Tax and OECD Deemed Residence:
Each tax authority will have its own rules on how residence is determined. This can sometimes lead to entities being
resident in two countries. For example, suppose a company is incorporated in country X, where residency is determined
on the basis of incorporation only. However, the company conducts most of its activities in country Y, where its board of
directors meet. In country Y, residency is determined based on the place of management and control. In this situation, the
company will be deemed to be resident in both country X and country Y. The company is therefore theoretically subject to
tax in both of those countries and may have to pay tax twice on its income. This is known as double tax.
The OECD Model Tax Convention addresses the issue of double residence.
In the case where an entity is resident in more than one country, the OECD Model Tax Convention suggests that the entity
will be deemed to be resident only in the country of its effective management.
A place of effective management is:
the place where key management and commercial decisions are made
the place where the board or senior management meet
An entity can only have one place of effective management, so using the OECD Model Tax Convention rules means that
the entity would only be taxed in that country, which solves the problem of double tax.
General Principles of Taxation
Payments Remitted from Overseas Subsidiaries:
A group may have overseas subsidiaries which will from time to time pay dividends to the parent company. In this
situation, two types of tax become relevant: withholding tax and underlying tax.
Withholding Tax:
If a company makes payments to an individual or another company or an individual resident in a different country, it may
first have to pay withholding tax (WHT) to the local tax authority. A withholding tax ensures that the local government
gains some income from the dividend payment so that not all of the money earned by the company in that country is
remitted overseas. The rate of withholding tax varies depending on the country. Withholding tax also applies to other
types of payment, such as interest payments, royalties, capital gains and rents.
General Principles of Taxation
Payments Remitted from Overseas Subsidiaries:
Underlying Tax:
Underlying tax (ULT) is the tax which has already been suffered by the profits from which a dividend is paid. This happens
when an entity receives a dividend from a foreign entity when the dividend has been paid out of taxed profits. Under
some tax systems, the entity can obtain relief for the tax levied in the foreign country on the amount out of which their
dividend was paid.
Underlying tax is calculated as follows.
Ad Valorem Taxes: Ad valorem taxes are based on the value of the items, i.e. a sales tax or value added tax.
Excise Duties: Excise duties are a 'unit' tax – they are levied on the amount of the commodity. Governments apply
excise duty to goods that have large sales volumes and are easy to control, i.e. there are a few large producers and
products covered by the duty are easily defined. Excise duty tends to be levied on four major commodities –
alcohol, tobacco, oil products and motor vehicles. The tax is collected earlier in the supply chain than sales taxes.
By the time the product reaches the final consumer the price will already include excise duty.
General Principles of Taxation
Types of Indirect Taxes:
Property Taxes: Taxes on immovable property exist in many countries. The tax base is usually the capital value
of the property although in some countries it is the annual rental value. The tax is usually on land and buildings,
but a few countries also tax other items of personal property such as cars, boats and livestock.
Wealth Taxes: A number of countries levy wealth taxes, either on individuals or on entities or on both. This will
involve measurement and valuation of assets each year. The tax is usually a straight percentage, for example 2%,
of total net worth (total assets less total liabilities).
Consumption Tax: These are taxes imposed on the consumption of goods and added to the purchase price.
General Principles of Taxation
Types of Indirect Taxes:
Value Added Tax (VAT): VAT is not a tax on profits or gains, and is not even eventually borne by most businesses
to a material extent. Nevertheless, it is important to businesses, because its charge and collection enter into many,
even most business transactions. Ultimately, VAT falls mainly on the final consumer of goods or services. However,
all those involved in the chain of transactions between the manufacturer and the retailer are first charged VAT and
then pass it on to the next person in the chain. The standard rate of VAT varies from one country to another.
Cascade Tax: this is where is taken each stage of production and is a business cost. No refunds are provided by tax
authorities.
General Principles of Taxation
Single-stage versus Multi-stage VAT:
A VAT can be single-stage or multi-stage.
Single-stage VAT are applied at one stage in the supply chain, either at the manufacturing, wholesale or retail
level. Most VAT tend to be applied at the retail level (such as the retail sales tax applied in the USA), so the end
user will bear the tax burden.
Multi-stage VAT are applied at several stages in the supply chain. A multi-stage VAT is usually chargeable and
deductible at different points in the supply chain, so the business deducts the tax it pays on purchases and pays
over the balance to the government. The incidence of tax is therefore on the final consumer of the goods or
services. A multi-stage VAT can also be cumulative (known as a cascade tax) where no refund is received for tax
paid in the previous stage and so the tax is a business cost at each stage in the supply chain.
General Principles of Taxation
Multi-stage VAT:
VAT is charged by a business each time a product is sold. However, the business can claim back the VAT it has paid on
purchasing products or raw materials to make the product, which is known as ‘input VAT’. So the effect in the end is that
the final consumer suffers the full VAT amount on the final purchase price, but this amount has been paid to the tax
authorities in several slices by the various businesses in the supply chain along the way. The following example shows how
VAT works.
Price net of VAT VAT @15% Total Price
$ $ $
A. Manufacturer buys raw materials 40 6 46
Manufacturer makes and sells television to wholesaler 200 30 230
Manufacturer pays VAT 24
B. Wholesaler buys television 200 30 230
Wholesaler sells television to retailer 320 48 368
Wholesaler pays VAT 18
C. Retailer buys television 320 48 368
Retailer sells television 480 72 552
Retailer pays VAT 24
D. Customer buys television 480 72 552
General Principles of Taxation
VAT Business Liability:
VAT on sales is called output tax, while VAT on purchases is called input tax. A business owes the tax authority the output
tax it collects but deducts from this liability the input tax it pays.
Inclusive Price
VAT = × VAT Rate
( 100 + VAT Rate)
General Principles of Taxation
Partial Exemption:
Where a business makes both taxable and exempt supplies, partial exemption applies. A number of schemes exist under
which the input tax can be apportioned.
The simplest method is that any input tax wholly attributable to exempt outputs is not deductible, any input tax wholly
attributable to taxable supplies is deductible in full and any remaining input tax is apportioned according to the
percentage of exempt outputs.
For instance, if 30% of outputs were exempt, the trader would be able to deduct 70% (100% - 30%) of unallocated input
tax.
General Principles of Taxation
Employee Taxation:
1. Taxable Income: The amount of tax paid depends on the way that earnings are measured. An employee is taxed
on all income actually received from the employment in tax year including 'non-cash' items (called benefits in
kind). Cash income includes basic and overtime pay, bonuses, commission and redundancy pay. Examples of
benefits in kind include company cars, private health insurance, free accommodation and cheap loans from the
employer.
2. Deductible Expenses: Tax regimes often allow employees to deduct expenses from their earnings before the tax
rate is applied. Types of expenses deductible will vary from country to country.
3. Employer as a Tax Collector: Many tax regimes require the employer to deduct employee tax in instalments
directly from the employee’s pay and pay it over to the tax authorities. If the employee feels that he or she has
paid too much tax, it is up to the individual to deal with the tax authority to obtain a refund. The employer merely
acts as a tax collector.
General Principles of Taxation
Employee Taxation:
4. Calculating Employee Tax: Calculating how much income tax is due for an employee is very similar to calculating
how much company income tax is due for a company. However, individuals are usually given a ‘personal
allowance’ which is an amount they can earn before they have to start paying tax. A standard proforma for
calculating employee income tax is shown below. Standard proforma to calculate capital gain is as follows:
$
Salary X
Plus: Bonuses, commission, benefits in kind X
Less:
Personal allowance (X)
Professional subscriptions (X)
Pension/PF contribution (X)
Business (X)
Charitable donations (X)
Taxable income X