From Dictatorship To Democracy by Gene SharpFROM DICATORWIP TO DEMORACY PUBLIED AND DISTRIBUTED BY © copyright by Gene Sharp, 1993. All rights reserved induding transaton rights All requests should be addressed in writing to Gene Sharp, Albert Einstein Institution, 1430 Massachusets Avenue, Cam- bridge, Hassachusetts 02138, USA FAK USA + 617-876-7954. They wil be sympathetically considered, Reproductions of the indvidval artides, as by photocopying, by Burmese democrats are permitted provided the author is notfied. In order to avoid duplication of work and to ensure the quality of translations these chapters should not be translated without written permision. Xhit Pyaing (The New Era Journal) First Edition January, 1995. — COVER ORT Hann Win TLUSTRATED 2 Kyaw Si Thu PRODFRCADERS Ye Gaung (Hyawadee) Maung Maung Tun Hoe Aung Tay Ta Thuraecraigit of: (2) erenrghogich orcouSens: 9886 208 0208 $0923 22292 veerenre wBSrg84F cgoheody quaScorr moenrd8S:eaSecos: 09: iad BeaSoe Gason ossontgtch seuefocn. agich gSEGE... woof (1) eqodemgrogi Gere mgqreSep eqedeqqrag: Gir comfreygig oysiclGoe: eqodergragiQs ood gohq mgrooroSecoo aqedemgiogiqng’ Bjoomoarag§ onqaeyory SaScayroro8aop$ woa009 SB BErqSioq ia lt03 seocnnn a cgfcofaydgeSer we(GpStqpt mnmnnnnenennnnennninnn nnn waft (2) srcnreh maSerqanges 2qp a8 0929 GE enn a 2 REcoqrmrerggaf wc Gsdadqcdap: “J9 SmeqSmimrial oof oSoup: = . : sof: (5) mrmagih anigabiqeSep... wogje8: (Achilles)e8 aoyo8oR go maenng ER. eh conrgaSiqyeS apr un. mremagbogdah org ahiqeSupich Bob $8... weft (9) macondh ah GiGE Plseqimforch a8 mar GF qG§Scor> 89 wESroodaaphRohgeh asligadguSer mqoSap: wof: (8) eerre Good SoS gqpr Gos oqiai gd ofan; Qa §mSasnes... abmofeniajqrgé 203.woof (6) coScpfodaobeqingdd mEmoscyS ... aSarbeqsSgmeged meGsosiorr(ajonSy HfobySGEqayd OG Eee qypSconieas RaBiaghic§SegeBqprmc§Er BreopSeanf oySemon oft (0) Rsoqimfongey wo}e g8aaSiqpteh og: maaingichmedt 8SecTan9§ comenniGooG emrofogqpiyptdh, $6080 nnn enarnd Boowrannd} Bemrkohs oSmn8 ¢eSimeGGabimcgyp: pS GE. of: (¢) momagfogich qoS86:GE mrargihcodiogbiy wocnoel ouSgo: cgaSeodgap: oRrorcScosqegS .. moenngSogic8 BABE. omnf Eyal: or20§ onaSieyqu_S sof: (20) mg hgaigrore Gogh Eos ... BGmonbepdmeydd qoSGbqeySch: enamgfoméorcurrdd Seoktesepey sonenas Sigel onoic8: (GE REe00059 o_5:}-meGE 0001 BGoreqSmdiqa’ craeges waScoohgogsd Goo goap: wonfmBeqrBeovgs orofog art cqoeB ooSo} B3S:9 Rod gaSzap:8, epSfrongeSog roy § Ee pS geSiofare5 G SlooeSi soooeSelera§ ogSa8:[63: Go} qaS8: agrreanrEcpigkanpS8o5GE:GqlangeSn egooorepto8 erfrda8 rapSrepea.0 woBiq_gpecn o8B61 omydqyoSantnn o¥ espSBEielagp§ GbcTa> p81 ea GSwcS goa aospbaprogé agp fay cgodoo6 gaging maqPhiclep& coSoraded eqsoootcorravpSa8 a09 {§ESqara$z0cgo8e[Fo$conS: cafSel usfRaSogcogep: §8REGorogclaopSu coranogSogSah svosrsc0m0nReanSqin (soy cRooes Aristotle garg aasenaqSogSo8 GGm:c0o§ apap) corcraqyprel aoEvelGoSie8 eanSqfs (zacgionl9§ go8pSoorr008) eapeoa/eiaS[eEroonlGF BogS-Rrqprro8 BoSycSq’BoS got ongar eneqiagoosS ocnag bog cy anngand gSoclEisoean5 Gpo208 ecpeose8: 2 oWTedlobcondleorza9g51 eneq:cgorgs egqpmmgseGpGeqaSgoraSu acogsolazapcogS: Gookgoq@SaopSe sakeocdoanneSeg’ gE Gn(GiR: soooEss\SdqoopSogqpn somsie aSoyqr2 of teas wbotok 8 segbabs ngcht masctgSoabogiogeen a 02 29 sosoaheco005 og Pee cwBrabiog’ cyyprrm op fEygboohiqeh ofespoSgBoSeofeglojo[qoeeo§ gop BorqarpSo008 orspSyprodfesasy Bg) gftav€s sacofrarareTeoodleospeoeSu Byoos Gusgel Ravoemog Eqqrorg “oysouyre apSioFidogqar9h gop! cpoogeh aafGoheoSeg GEreprre§ ofedes Qe5R” uadhcfs “apcRoog cgoSqpcyoSe[abrarogo8 oruSor8aSeR, wigg cBaSqulores” veg cf: [aE :Goro5[aarpSu Baogsqafior SB §olwooSyuSccrrEradpSu eslooGSoqpeopS: cennakicloopSu pro lFp8gSqorer oraqiogareS sorcrrghogS sorSconigSashagad Rogeso:a0p$ ogrieni Geof Ge8i BoroSigf Gf vakESohc8 savgSaovcSoqnoSQscloogSn o8 ofeqp$ arc gcoo5§ emncmngogSeh aboSoBEqo5 aor | oahu géGteSorqoiaagigal oarorasobeapoigeh cahiapfSne$ BoooSaydh $8 Bhooicom qgotREssoremo<85iga8 coher’ woBEagehoSare8 garage o8ma8:q GfcopSorobocorea008 sole|Sx9 gpSiqprefop: Be corogoSoraicke ap o2295{GF socog[aponefeef: G8laopSe BookGEmqrSeqproRBasGEEr oyeyrroR wopogSiG: Bo epopSorohaoe$ arrenogEcRelinrcorogpic§ Bovsarabu sertegqagypioogcBcosSs cog: Bo5 gS dloopSu 1308 qoSoo5 eg SeRoSQarich oop [Sqrreho0dl SoorqagaproR nqerrooaSBooek awocmagéogiah orpSoraS Bo GS avg hge o§.ryoho5.q53 Bares agqeorr€raprofeogs: GroqpsSclorgSu maf saoogpregé conteaganeS soageSagos|BatenpSiga0€ svocnogSoghc8 8 argfooGahgé oRoSgokegang§ angtoron wafao8sqp:03 03 GEGqanaSu avgaigeSeossb:aa$ 2yqpt GBdTa~Su GrpSequaSyo oqjo& urgeBEea0o8 aocmag yor cocdch(RiapSega0-$8E ap: slaogSn cvocnag S09 comeSo&eaoisleosivn oogt8Gopecoran9Si ogorostogl ogbhaqgclegE coSageqsfreran ScSBoorrahegé sBEoooSapx a SeBE eooreqho8Goso:ong5u BgeSiog oogabQEE Bobs Bunfefns9EgE ogoScoByenoge8 goer BebgoblBenvs ergoSomnpErsorranqEsagapin® cagabescadea adepSoos.coarepa(GE cove aff coreqoeBBSgE:cBoSang$aa1 Gfer8ECogeSeQGocSguSeG§ eagoSvocrng fereqBaobiznn qapraigngyS oxnaSc}3 GEooggelorgSu enslond ancqisgangs BBaneqBsabsoxrgoR masbicig SefSuoicReopSi cpebcogS| aah axpSu Bcbifreonien gS GEas[HpxoySofHya0p$ apesic8 corgeSlGS mesroSaroBsarg5 1 eoBsobepion gf:cGeR sofiegSagepicn2: onfi8G: oSa00Sga0—$ BoocBREseGocS$E: couSonegaor oByar28 SbomenBoRobyanoges coScoSguSguS4§ orahrogorBqageprel BSaqo ergeSveconszaaohoR, Géclar—S1 orcragc8, rGrocoqporecyyoo8 naaveSefrabbosSi8Sqo: qobbiabig: oyfaqaleonivyg oplejroqGEBdloogSu RoGoor meogsoleRaprs§ SSyohyapre[HE sorcmagEogSo} [ortoroagad Zé 008 gaSieoSrqp: Qqveiug ogpiooBSaoghu eopicgpEsBico08GoSgeaielGSaan3 wocmaqSogbcR em BEemsin yen meee ch aBiosSoayh i epriod mangtmatypregoy SyaperoReogS: agcofBdloogSn menecypes g28:REsoygaSiesr> gahiGE soocnaqEsGiqup: qSBSrayoiom2E cafSecotecosgc5go8 oBtonrSSpSBcbovghi BeBggSvo8oocB: naqeagen,S 96 evra 08 anncengiogicR eqeoratinn534j wocgsalijupicvs: wacnSQeorsGSar~51 corennbaof cafonehob8o5 geSiqp:cBeogS: goSvatconBEGaogSn coaSayfeqe: §Séeq: eacogteredli Ge saBreoperspanghu soogioof§S coobeog mph soarmaEsrcopSooS$Sug$ of} corfoghenssSiaie® oS:00:09:2088lonpSu neocbilncogimedlsé cof GbogsoqeSapra[ap$ afjooceSah oqiaoar 88cRal oo Goocgqpng$ oBaSeSy §) 08 aBcaorquaSn oBGE opSarahons Goraybefck 880R, Bod Yogé aiokgmnfgSororE wohiGEoaSahorpSr sofrodqfecloopSu qiheoapS(GSeGoofeqesnege8 sonpaogSeux{joepsisoxt soapiemy:qsonéGdloopSn oai$S&i soagizoqa§ Bruce Jenkins o> socgrageBevrdlane$u Goxrgozme Sq ag hlGBr gSiqteoeeo aveanaeclScorezo08 onf{GdlangSu e083 g05§a09§ socogievesTypt (oSan8eq: wuraeyer9) cr8Gqo09& Berjooogr gSrcot:es09$ opSYeqsar>r orf jqoeSe8 gaSseoSrocmnbiqprlGE sole graBcusclorgSu 0r5;5ciso8s008 srcorcooboRoopS: (GEcurdloogSu onaSefGo5: BBennakrys. coremna8 agpSeorsloopiu erongS{goSqin0gE cgpBoa09 Stephen Caiody oBoopS: cagggionsgeh s0a5u m§ror§ao[aipoaSaprg® cow§ayoSqprourears Dr. Christopher Kruegler, Robert Helvey ReBooeS: ooyzgisvogion€Gvlasg$u Dr. Hazel McFerson, Dr. Patricia Parkman ooscopS: em0Rorg cochorkmavsn$Sqpral BoSgaprgfvcSarcSears avorfiooqyaSeocoaSypecR ogeS ofF-EGslorgSn 08:8 SoScagapal aonclooqagatgaptelGaé GSe(Garbgo eqrarar$Eeas oap6 GScarSeo9S: oforpSs coufqSypn: souysrsogan goSqoSyrtaoeS ogfSehon(GE gfSel apaopimedlaocSaoeByprara{GSoxp$c00308 oy§50&009 07208 8loopSx GjorspSegidloEaop§ vpSarp$soofrogey sorcrragEcho} fodqodog frophag Bgores agoSogslangSi eaoresoresoreansp§ qQREa2pSup eaBcorxcln epSoopScRoSgus8 angqroSaodef Gassgos0cogecg Goro8a0g81 sovcmoq Echo sofiayboboSgobay/S aad:agayarqopSu aGeooS aheobcl ecgeorjrabgabaprc vo hire condepfomrs odEsesonE gpg Eichsh Bessa PryrcofEsooagaSreobsypee® cogeoac8SepSi BRE S8ohoo5y sooysoase go5:86 204 geStclioxoaE coypaBEBhugSuq ag{SegpScoSBctoopSu oScorcmaqSogSonqS soajtasSayaianpSgé aalgosoors osogosoasugo8, @SGSroyor epS0y gfoprasd qoSan wa8cGul woBrq one GoSeyagangg§ ecoomBga§ aUTadloScoous$ oupesi qi)erq5d eepessassanSqjaSyptonpS 88g onqpryoresrBEE[PEcosem08 Biystequ £EE0q: anookeljorg§ maGmagGScvrca0r8 son{eftorfordd epSobEqifaop$ SoSeroSyp: me hgaseg exnnk cobigbourcbos GE vEGEarpSi ofGor orgaSrorggSesTeookEane$ vorq arg’ 8RSqeSoaSy p28 oSaqpaB Rep coSte[erErqpick ySooreBobfGEraopSi{GS dloogin oeSooeSagelfi0a8: 09S a2p$oRE:fGahog boss soremragSoheh SRS qy SqySyqprreG Sagqaoahopyyrio095 epoboobye} cBaoor len afjaneeScleaqyeSqpie® Bo gofh: sosceaq bogs KogaySBisearo8 opbicaoat$E se Ge—Sup ca§Sv5(epSogpS cof cloogSu qyseqs exoonBcf}ornco G qos: ogge 998 wScSoro8 SEoo8E: oggahcS 2590 of Bayjicoo8 §So00 enb:orq $1 ef Bayze008 0J020 wevgoriGpSoooréesana§: “c soremagSesSc$ cxoseSox8: g8a88G8: FreariBaoogls egapon egSgarenns ofs8EchoS$oSLeGoofGE srocmrqSo98 cog: Gor 0 GiesagersoopSe cBerpck Rcdogasd[ajone$ wocmagSgricdogé soaiigo GaSeghifjavlos ap BEk medig> REeGorpoysopoSefoSears soacmag Set oxo—S[GE soufeefGclooSu ‘olGopSQQ HBB GoSqc8 og8Ecor9" up cyengpten opsoegleja29§ sooennqSypico gS soqljeao9 95009 gkaprg2 ageper REZoqiong, crohScoo8e8 moscorgem Biysieqa aggeq: soocSucSeo a9 GfeorarphaceR od $E0{GS oSoyagar(eGo[aoErc8 sooSeoos0lGs GELEcloopSu 2000 ee 8yefh: soBecffieom coohSiann cobsyfia Goof: mognapeh are ocfevicBiersn ecG8:$:07011 eaclonnat woc8s BoB:B:er.1 Soo8BE oaoghBEEapiog’ agape nfGSroocSoop$gpSreprre8 soyoradiapir 0289(e¥G cvrcnoq bogSyp: GohqnS8ragardqocoky anfBdrvocins gSc8o58cScGoS SBao\GS SoreqSeySqargcosiclepE(oh: yScororpSoRErGoSaps cop: GuloasrangSn gS:o8yo Sooh ef Busst1 coro8eRQsv2081 Gc8i sooq|ScBrgo1 ovnc8) sq 28 agegn veo8: BEREE apcSeosSerae urfen§ BEvr>1 REG} GS peSoRlGEa095u ogo pp81 HocScoe SurcS Loge cougcls GFreofagaptel woamnrBiry coaontGEsqrgSaoqnSog’ cleiSroacdarg§ gab:eoSiapiem mBmmofry cloFoopSu AGE qrrofZpSor0F orgoS$EEi GhurfEEgE Bored $Esqrr§ GaSagqpclofao~S REcoqrohogygrio} cogqareSu aogGoohoyelGorderes: BofE-GaSapry Gaogo}ores 21 ewo8sBBurcdugfusao0g8ie 2u §&écq:20§ 099 (Political Defiance) sBasg§ oonatsnapizogec8 Mr. Robert Halvey 03 ©0303 cqhc$oS{GEGGSa0g51 BEtoniaosepghanaSy> mEGbreockas oSBobaoshgaSio} oBeBoopSu BEtocypfocboncbann aeSusSqrbupng (nfcg sgl ge oplesmb HG ony Beoqgebocones) aleibwocaneSeeSipiod wabhigeeGEares cobtoormajods cneSmoortacTadleScoacngaSin soaiion solegS:oedSoop$ 405: sBoopSy> efor: 2908 olBSrovdBocongaSivgsigba sora2rcqia0g -leiSroodSansS gab ged: wbyaScpeqsouo8 aqpecgieffocoafajearne|oEGSaoghu FEoq:zahonysBonaSyo aofiqelfSjeozacmac8 oou8 cocBanoS8enfzafapangSeB BGclangSu GEroxsec—5: ooghegodegGEGSaoesn aaSefiqeSap: GScars $EteqisorcmraySREREoaineges soemrBwfenkearss oy6 rrrrr—~—~—C—C;isSCisCzadwssOWCdizs,;s _ .||=—=—SCSC—tr—rC—CiwszOC:CS:S:sz=S;:;i‘ wocgn[aicGor9s: cpoger a§cBa5R eupoSclecoon eneodogé cuifGjeors sooSoo8$sv0011 cvoSSrunst oanphREEqpiog’ zoacnagSogS[Gopagateos oRE:GiaS ene GaSapoRef soGorear> Gaagoaaniofrolyo afGoopSeagaraanrdhn GeSogept aobrgegopfio8s qpoooS gap: ocToonaaSe spSaySeaipiaisiooG@s BeBeqocSoqocS a204) 0095 BEcooicln sv0r00 asuserorugeSiap GPro8iaystongSu 20e8d aodogeSypia098 q aban eAErfHob cpaneS soscrragEm8iqaRch socysogSuyrx ovpoSdleoor eor8 BRSaySqjoS yes Searegqagen: cofjoor, aogpSrceS aoeScorafarcSavo§ayadlangbi SBeanabig ean. FEEeq:=n01 Shonen bangs aneait ggcboacgaeodya§ cyyoraegiorgairs Gabgares cyecra’=0B moSsyyat Gfcog$ one§ coorka§ cobie(GoSra: gfogoroaSu oe cocheocEZeged Gesoger engpsoq SqSeg’ 88orcqSclagl coSeodyancScR ZroxpSegane$ comgenaypec§ og SanpS gpbapigoaro8 cogdelGn argoorofiog€ SEceqsogoScobyapral wmafjmeqi cymgimon: woGaocgaps opSc8hogaopSe8 of pfrlojaSght cp05|GfoopS Freedom House i g808 8q8500 ang, cphdeor aocSgbiaoagés egoSavdfGun ofaBREcas BEfjaSere mryrcrofiajreg’ 8:8 avs000 aptevofGGSe(GaE BqargSi! egoheocon§SS —onBoBorcaa wqgoSeos eee 99 & 85 7Eee 2a R = Boas8eogSs vorq nian SqyS$rGiaQeReh conbesooabegs ayopadayoh§oars Eas cmeGooSanfgor GaganrrayoSuS{GSa0~Su aeee agi ef gclQooac8 ngpep8i0q, oofreulé: cl: scortceorqramsango5y 20 ape ghza095 wagoSoo8ep avoSyoSecTogonntears BEGahi guSeG apiegt opcbEaqoSQadobu? Rogqnypiag’ FEteqsapaiooSgo? aooxt eafaroSaySqeScosrarehu cqnaivoaqrapryrcops: BgaSiqEro8u agoSon8 oraSio&8EE gn BEEE BEGSE GS 3 6gqr0gé oBzooenrrqSypiongés (go0m GFuahSeg§ aahREE): moSeocoreg BRSqSaieS coosng§ apa byt aw8iqaprengés(orqoSSEei Bayfi oGoo5o¥Queva:): BEEGoio9 epyroompofcapeS 86:8o8cos: can Biggie: (Bo081 seq. e8eu>) BiG SqySogaS§arain maa egqrysregScosS: 8: (20001 eaoS8a0>0qs8:0721 2900§) ooloBog8§ BfroBSiapSqyS0095 ‘Ju Freedom House, Freedom in the World: The Annual Survey of Political Rights and Civil Liberties, 1992-1993 (New York: Freedom House, 1993), p.66 (1993 figures are as of Janu- ary 1993). See pp.79-80 for a description of Freedom House’s categories of “free.” “partly free,” and “not free.” gu Freedom House, Freedom in the World, p.4.amgistomeever anckimneg eGofiagsded GSepclangSu BE GaSonqprranlGor oogaoGfogh Sryroqe FEcoargs cggeqiqrym sooyew(Gs affokicdegleielang5: ag Sear souSgbzvegbien agaSandfGepaB§oarn BE Gesu: Sqn Gor Bl malgbeloEicdgqp: orgupcdais oGoEicdayrroophoocge8 soe oBEfG—S gpieg’ cob:el pk rcp: wocmrgEasSonef: atTeoa8Ean9$ coalGroegefe BoScqroSayosk€aopSu odcrbz0nE:a08Exqpa wEABiagqpe spseorsnSonSelGooSSqaos$ soqagapngs covyoog BEE equleBepron agohcSep apREecon8 BEEBE [RroxrfHeucB§or8i sorems8Siyp: G53y:Be eqeogoncSogScogS: (GEcor%Escorao25u sac GScymogiwoaiqniad SEteniagharcqrepsrcR egegedesoies sorBooc8 GrsBcoo:8SoopSu BoSoqSiovsoqpemmakraparp$ woBoSora$ og FSohas Gagadven srrcn9 6 ogSar95 pacreiefeGE wGSogoSeaynSukRoaorarpSu oB6:fGeSa04c0[GorGoS GaSagGpSooorqyo0e8 Ga opkrsoReqencanScksn BE2GGo: opafiGorea§eqerean5qhs gSqaScoqp: BSqySqyeS apSiadagargS cB dortagfqgaopfiv8u ondlorg qappSghG[Br dqarpSn dof dlBooc8 mocmnGEchoH cora0> coovagad ofigozaror0S Barbu so§sqcoeSoxs05s wupoSare$ aygant aovrousmankyot BEdaqrsoapSisnjrapn S:yrronzsogosopSoho§ wGiqon arg pS:ayriecma6lGSoa ffzgeosema& Ghee qSgsSenSGEibngh ancoreqennbrqpcfot qbrorooon Shores 0708 so8iqer cnfruomSorpSige pS qyScon 3 cpSqibaoe$ cydshqare$ soarkiong. xoSyprg§ wanted: cncSaxpSu ap08 socBaonQ workrsagursrg$ canes aSqeScoarfEema& KapSGEfGbarp5n cy eqentanrte8 0805805 woyryaGopogoiesn8 fjapSaopSu cpobe Good yaa fznczeS yrevlEreano8 goy eGREscar8 ZSg5cBoSaoe5u crcwro0hcRorcuro08 wuslejSearé aoabaokefoSansse wpSargSanqoaby opSqieSoSugowr& cpScSoSarpSu at}o398, poabSpoaSgoSso8err0y8 noSerSicRaSahvpSaBor (RooselGaEdlaoeSu cpogsareqppayniag§u B8cRoS0B08 88 cmaaofeipSogoorpe snoSaSaosep5§sBore5y2 coco cots Bo$Barsrqa00g&: SoScogenaSraSraroghiya0& waanogbogich gStoBs0(eoen qgobcody cB goSoBSqpelaqpes vclGog ju efajooS.agleqcorpo0pSu ofefooSaorreg§lGr cygcgeorg§ seven Baofqhc8 g05g0888 oogrobooogidleoor ord GIGS apaySoos8s vox feHobrege cof §Ecora0~51 Bak sr2epSqy§r0a8: qageokrgs[A}qor951 eqpookgoSorErsarg$ aogon08 enneaeh, q888{Bqar95u conbaooenagSogSemoniag’ GSycSogor$ gobepooneGaagaprarss ogie> cond 8Gck:clicgcl 3B coarasgSu orscooBconaEiaa99 cgopsokiny Sai Byaqne og[Gyyst(Syor3|eorSu cyooger ge5 affrocronfGo5 SoS os05 0305 fHoosfEGSEs Soarc8{GSc8$oa6u caslord oreurodhonccom 605 fs cpgabie apSqrracoraparmreanScEn agg hR: 208sqc8 ofeaSaop$urfaogarqa1 congenoyp: GoooS[ajar9Su wc8oSn vaSohuk qpSquSqyeSeor8recra8i{¥E finda, soglaeoo5fGaroopS: qTooglapaflabagodot ofezoaSoncSaxpS8oSn3 sqpaSqaSusg oqeas:ch svcocdaya arfzgore5 209$ soeraEchoh eqproSqoSREcly sorcag bog hah ophiop§REwaSn axoreSor socgechodepare§ JcanrangSs eookcndlapiony cgegston8oSoreac00 sorsophag (GRmam ga shy thm oq ff enepfoveaiBrepavg$ oobi GEdln~Sn gfifear cygeS:par>dlofean wEwacasieSea00 soaQbgeeareslPE 89g) aogonraFagarBEaopSy egpdeofqaSg§ oxorhGEgapiqup$aoaa: woace gGo80o maoebeBof qf gocvaBE clogs oe Ste shigd agSeoky queecon eneocddlosgiugé cuSGoosraapSmel§oh, eqpeScosgavgSQaaS an20p5 GegSpSie “orreqd[HveSe} Boroedn gSroger235" Up ofg[ejoocBSepSu Boas oErane(Goo soa}romye emaceagSohoaSanaSyo QopSjapSraysis pvear orqnrBqSqiadgs cyanel ScSavecrscstea0g5o8 oF moqio85i capSeqygoro5 eI UGEar.6u mocrrg Soha qoSocdleGeRRS aon apS:0§:BE008 gaPH cored yqpi! cgoypodabiyar: oryicy ge[agr§ cpapercogSs so e9S:005 g_$:GE aoocmg 06808 ySBE:oo8EaopSup onrraSqjnSqjorc5[ejarp5i BaaroeSqnSqoroSgoBaopS goxeogSeor REdloogS mGSoohsogqoyn§, eslas(GSava[aqlhe orclor4, S8oRonc5er swoqskSogangSo} 2828 G08 on058Eo09j odc008 gaSeo€soateho8 gasorbsQh: wf SrpSiGGE qabocSapoass sosannqech AD FoF05G, sareyo5{ajovpSu vlejrocmafarc} apypriongs Gogooho5QoSsledfh: aof:ageg ened 800:3 (Bago sosochedlSrapiga corandalajyiaog$u ovdlond Bagapicl gS:ea0xky eyoraop5 awagip cborbro08 GreasSonraSiopslanpSe Boao BgpSighchoSlhs cyoSafgoSyqag 20079 GBREScpATa09Su coc gabaBabis) cole|SvaSaBoSZaSaop$ oSeaSyqrecl—Gp$ BBqoSooS 298 BREqySqySgeyric mBsqroopicor§ Eran oBgabslGE GaSogeyany> egPcofqaSapSn ages epSopog coorabsq3G5Q: wakmrooa8a8io09$ amelGv0ga8, oq zoSayatarcSavgSn aafGSrooS paSi¥E AeSoophcBgag’ worfremyigiyp: Gookoosoroe8 Soornsy gfigé: cobreo€: Seoriqua$ snqjaborsqSQaraSu BaogyaSyo opener a}n33¥, cooSgoSansr08:(G: oahu cBefobareSa§ 88ohc8 BZScos:95 afayqpSgal g_h:Forourg§ coecrqocozs: wepuy Go ofrehSBarnhGokGEG aoaGelgaStaboboiag’ qfogar BoRoreSco08 ssra0ahard8on lQ erbirGorsSu aarcmaqapregl aofeiSrqaSiabapiBs $SpErq§ao0q05 coodgcdaGahzog§are5i BGmaqSqSqer qoofohss RaSedo5 oqqaday[Bio§aSo808 ogooSasregs qoSecSapea0 of endacieR vb §Eu offi) ucgodarr §Sqeora0g81 swoarrqhcRoocSy conBgoSzcbsont so\Gooo angbu S0n8:8:empoo8i eaopoScocd gaS sonia}reorafoxkronpSu avSuyfaaoobaqigacvgs: agokak BoboopZEr oSor6erba0orcBoogS: socofeasrguqi SrroqSooSao1qp0095 vgSqoS sogoo cary moenrnghokg’ Sargon’ Bég og8Eoon anvarfiog oSorSuprBEauag.opStg yfar§ GE:a0g5 w8yuSuhi conScgpsofileos: 0p 8fGScrr20¢h205I svocaagécd Babes fajoopSogqpicos$ ofgoSeypioScBcSgaSianahoBorog BoSaboareosfasGfangSe aan’ elGacSepriobelap§ SESsqpaareS werficoysge Sonia ZEwss ovpoti SGoreqSqezrr6erpS: vopS$Edhi RoleBp$ ofGocSeapieSarp$ soofgyFoupo8u soagsaofs eGoronprr08e[ao§ BBeysoelGooSsoyr soareSahepioy>oroSangSu afigeStelaGob o§:8E chops cpoog8: ax20.08$8dh oGarSeqnrScoboqse8 scoanSsang§ BABA yriaop5: QoopSu qfraSsofeq: cB couf ccoraSssonieur apiorScostarpSypicoopSt woSqanpSi snckeSumdso~n werk speulbacS BaF eoasleorzonehe # YS Begh sorppogeo[ Grr (GboynrGExarre[oG>EGSoraS Grea oreSo5ZEGE: meh oarSogiag agicfaoSapeo 1008 wfGorea0sgpSta98a06:098 81 30908: Sacer agiacesehQ ogSephecso: Bey orBerkg FR goegfecon: aagforeneS exoggofigooqnema€repane$ soBiqooqSo8 [GoSqiqpog o80nS—6 200 caaaBbifiErang8 sofGfaprpSsaqgeSarpeSivp cobe20¢51 afeosS soabcl gpSiogSoopS: Brezap GorpSn aoc ica[B:o}:{Gavog09o 2o§tq, Gouge’ oSor8a00ghi svran2GE1 so 02198 GaSopcyagcheolajar smaamrgeoy socovorp$ Geiv€ GEoopSn wGsqa0—$ codagis€ogon§ion:08 oxpoSdleoon onrdadgrcogS: Boypot (O}:BtayoSGooSu BoogSop:d cprqeh BSaySonrqregig oSuddfobayScogSs sofas sveo.tey “SoSodm 85" aygenoé of aqo8ugeGab§Ecoain soelgoaoar GE cogoodqprro> apSqaSoREgaS aogabicoS8gj grararfaorg cdloSogé edleSegSu oad socokgSeo(GE ogafGororgSo8 cog qaroSapSu enondcrcScroo09§ aafiqen erpSqageGaBoyé ‘oqrrcleoaScR g&[BroBs oypiooo8 AE[B:38:" soo roe ge: GSoroSa0_5u apo8 eo 8B: [HISFoSqcSoo8cor$Ea9sSu cooerogsap: + GScorcre5feoopiu marcRrocoodSagSup ayogar cySco8corropqpio0eS ogoRapSajSqnoy5 agorencd fanabu cymgE seq 8Goreq oq: oareSoRo8 eyayatonc!fajang$u cBelapof aovce09 Gorogoc8 ofgqdicBag’ arfgaStarpSoop$: conSSZEoqn gaStou705H RELeqrmeGaagyp: BBarrar¢HrErayoroq§ ogsoroaoS panes BGfagEcopS: ennceng fcoocavacBog€ opronroaSgagSaly> oG58Edh 2o0rfGqog’ sBBurcSayS:Bic0>:0995 mag qoqostendqenacnrapr§ socragEmiiqen 8$aaq8 Qroourrkous8 of:{Goog5 og aornebgepSargSu shears BagreaoeBgapty> sofForoup0Su sorcrag Econ BoSREresg:gS coniang§ acearsfarearapial ogicnnoaSgarslgarpSu opape® soransqSoGiqahi gohan 1 pope soangSfgayndqesaa€ apScaS/gEra02fgSa0pSu cS:0%oo crkroyige BfrqyScorra09§ ogienroaSgarivn BayScopSs oy2in agisrraeSgopSeur$ oxé: emmS corkseforrangSaacgoS sacmogiypien aeanea(l: BoSecqaqaraSanslepsicogS: § erdSclargSusfear Begremoaigeg& daogyore8 arc8SeqlG ago8[eRia}qo ques qSerr9g5 eslfSoSoovnraptsvs: dou efGorSenprio8 GanogE: dlo8 Gog) cyoScoSangf 959208,m go hy Gm bf anqSavnt § cgqpeviorcSangSu sochoSaosa0n8e8 ogrecnonSgob ysis: 2095 cr0o08 soceSaoaypn epgraSdqaspSansl egreaseSgacoSaon: ogu$oiu agrarooigankiqag . {yore soabsBqSonc8ana81 ogg 948 [§fuak Steg:ennsa5gg§ ogge 8 188 1888 ogsoorsa5goRyo aosomasifgSoop5u sorcmoq SapionaS gio sfGfreonhg egang§ qrevgyedly qfrcReost waSqatogfrhEgSrgooa$ agtemmaeSjypic® apSeoreagessé 8h qibocSozaxg§ sorenagSohciconSesooabog’ gegdeqqagyn qfioRcooSearo8y qqoSemrE agcBefiicdS:aqnbog aiqoyqri279S arqail, BRSagqpiconSemanSy epodefjoos aGcBgnah 8820079 BBay5g qoorpesSouncdup caf f§Esaxeagppoon(eHorgSi oaffatay coreneSy GBeorr_Srp eupoofeor’anahe cpeboaey cobgrreh Gkoyrrarie} soachioyHeseo.f engin B&Eonemadi wmoganpBgEaroag6 soacenqeagScB ogfrop$ apcSasbv8¥EcorpopSup ook GE eoneorp0095n age mBESSegqazeyge> agcRors0000y08 aroehy Boqaaheoré vaySSEcor9u7 Roog8 woogeoson yorarpSupcopS: osBhEr yfoopSancleopS: oopSn aagjfomacoacly> engSaneSu a BoaBapooe§ sorcmagEsaiqeh q&GEqfsooged apohah opSqaSoREqphce vplajeSorrnh:8o5 cnksBeor{Georrx0h souSgareS4eSiGE agoSelGrofear& opSquaSeReogS: 038[eavozd) emencBogl offnaQrorghanc8E: anGjsugir oagoen qcBocBapang$ soscwragaaGieyo? song ScBeoa{ajane$ soslefsogEovo ve smnenagSqp: soameSelp orgSgeg{ Borges GSoges BersorerageogeleapSue GS9Sv GaSagegermevgSe avrenrgisoGiqa’ soen|sisomySodoqraSasor€ apSesns8BEso>: 080 oppS:ago BeosorcaaqpramcogS: corborbuq5o0 cppaSigavndsnogSr§ eqpaSgavg5i 309 2955 REEGrcobiqgpe sorgengSgS mGoSopoS$Ecma&: apo fHevedGusSe Boupes 68 vcus2ne[ pS orgSs cooronypaynEa0~Su ooo'GoxcogSs svocnq Sap 2008 cocboxpS jog SEsy> BaSegEvelGvegarn soocTegSaos wBmerpSanzSu afnqynigo sooqtso Brojesoqed GSor~Su sneSangifandlefjicg’ 8Esoren064 BEro§s8eorzc0xgeR som s0—5 gS: GaSog:og& (GSosTeorcass swFEsoup§[Brvaiepargs FESonsshlBygpioae $ECGornGiqar0 coaoaSsev9 angSaval gfraRch songangon soabienyeonc8$opSn poorclGoqupSbagé GEo8EEqig> s92em998 cabins} SiystoqsBo5e8 a2BcSeyooScBoSoog$s0dh en fonknpfq soosbomogoisoco7 8oS3RcGa5 aopfaoch asorofarcdopeSeoySad ogcGaSoop$anch asonegeqia> GoSeorsaScRaSoopSamoh cgcoaauges goSqcGaSaogSzodl RoReorrmdlefiog’y FEEoomndl Samavry wopfaout: cB corarpSu Beans orcogS: GoSoghs§ mG Saoue$ Brvosean> ah(Bgi FEsoqssofonyeys: vFogé abilREEGraomyngSe qc8husSorpoSevs ong hed gf8GEs egocSsbrelGoqag’ sorcragSogSo8 soGSffoSesonEapia§ cpeSanghig oupoSeloes avcBqjSaaharaSu mrcmaghegSnar omymaprgaSsgasig® Bc8eqnadeqaes ays GSreocagé = earaciclongyed coorqabzon: yobafresont goin §eBoneSu woBZSSoqq2y cyegcor: BuScBRS of(GFpSoorieProrcfarpSBoSeqre Bayo cxonk snoieurqug§u GQeanr8 BoSeg§iquase gSsordoRaS8oSoq: aie ois: enffeoresoo$ 08 RrrcorqepSu 4 w8RSSqogqpr gaulEsQopSicorra99$ cpoScoSears ayysagmopSiypre8 sabsoat com€sconesoc€ (roxteaostgoSeorqeeSt + sobsoxrfBromrareS Gaboghico§n ig vEcooraynccTcvrean08 o$B:oorqogSu 4 cgobcodeqisoegeS aabupy> soeSyrgfupSean> sogeyyer> BobgSSoB$fRo8 gyeqiaGBe opSiegSirsng’ soomaEsooogScoSEcsorE soonklFEsoboorqepSa cgoScodoqisooged oBoSgot[asqneg’ BBuScBcReS sorreBiordS09$ GaSoges sookoS sintsrng RSgQquesi qfroksEsmcmnskrcosesrst RionqepSangifove5: GSon—Su 0098 g§ anno agSqprmogizn sBEurrco$ BEd096 “BSgaro0a808 [§SarpSaod} Charles Stewart Pamell Bogen esvoatleaoREr ofjrrdooeSu “afigeh coichiogc§ mahrooys RoSchoheS of BeSlsaessr Be HAie¥EooSe sqSqungeson€ opS [an of:c8 sgSgcden sorteqpaggouzeR soriercBconec008 sosteoxea) qtBawseusrrenra G Goo SEqeaS Gooog24p1 offcvgS8Eo095 soolGorogeqorSorak}chyars Goongaqpic§ qSicSoSogS anpSao§f veqorboq: soccgpecos”? Siaoghooo¥Es BuScRofSmmarafiorcSaop§ SSaproopSe Bryoicon aysnEsoaroogSe corafork afage’ aSoBEcBoSn§ ligSe8yocar afaokoaseBoopS: gorcvgS: opSienS:eogS: 200081 arghaopS: vgpS:e00 obyfoophmobarrap: Rooogeas arog rays soren29 6045 [GoS exyogoreann& BoB 25 [ey eBSupSu cBear5 waconhogé cui[gzoe$ Saige’ ecorqotn} soggSia}: qesnr8eyi Gacshesse emncangé8, coBesmraby egeSc orb BErBganes GoSopeyepe> 880200088 ages oGorhecnabopS$Evah: eoyS$EvaSBearasaqrSouTyo yorsSonpSe socondogé §EEoqizo§opang$ gaSuchoelh: esvr€ GE ga0pScosleys: Q3o(rEsH8 oy : BBRBaEao:S SEsoqro#ro3ES, oqa083 apioa6 Bs ogoheoSeqssooged oBufaosie oBoS: s: on8{Garg5u BeootengS: oeholgeSreodiqar BBaqpoSeqoo5 cpficortcosangho3 oGEqeao:chn egsoropSsoafrapiog$ onqobe8 soesnrBo5 eopoosfiogSn sBoasS ogs g0Sig6 sorcengogS qySBS:ox008 opSoop$cBgeR 59:0 92{53:8.u0 B:g> apoSesp:§20055 gu Patrick Sarsfield O” Hegarty, A History of Ireland Under the Union, 1880-1922 (London, Methuen, 1952), pp.490-491.orag: _ J secSesgeas:Sied sagqncSup: cxngSosin’ BScRaSqSBEqaopSaosl oeB3gc5§oa0> (oogoaprgé GReoga cnoSanghu (soa§ila)og& coS{Gcortong5)n Baoslefsog’ sociegapiongS 2724) |np58Ei coh Sooo aSegqoorpoaScB§e BoBogor¥EaosSu oxfzgogsroroSfejooasu aah. cvgS: 8GaraqBqeo8: ofGfoorpdlogivn [§Bcor0005 eGaxgSi snocpnoneSlheguahGQorp§ svoan0 gbarhin 8 cpoSeapogielGScorpepSup si(joSooo8lajonin cqaSyife(ggen corso ge oagiogi{GEso8[G§ anqf.soromgSmansqpi8 wvcScocSfEos5i goons [es poSyqp: Giad: agrreo$SepSup oypicoSarsr0205 Bargin soocToseavadSaoaleaahog’ eyqnim BaBBSqn4GS corfearpSyo opgbuloopSi sofgorgaStcoSrymraos: oSrorig oqarpSaoad: cqoSeagiegicBoS avaSanoE envskrareurfevrnt cobeoofeilangSncBgeSin® (RoSaoce8 GScoafBar—Sn concrag Sag6c8 caresoqnap onrvsors: BBeorepSsboyé 8eSqiSrax20q9 Roop epSeugaScln soaroSelp§ Bkckoba$ cBeoosloogaSn soaraSeleioS ayoogm oSsorpoSab: Bi afozsfeGeopSeaook cogragiBgeSteoStqpic® oqoleongeSe epoSespic gil nfGeSiGeSng$ ewrerng Seg Seqproboyniears€ socnba of eapS$EaogaSin sancrragS0R, agoiggaorcosesesE conaksofi§ BRS yqp orso€ Bronso€ eaxypayatesoc€ (-eupes) egacSabiog$’ 88oreqegeoré engSesoocBeqe cobigbeorcorea0o8 cpSREaoe0001 soajmy noSonondhera02 aof§p§angSoupeSup corsemorc5 aveSu “BEeroqSap5g cn sosceraq Ecc socok pares GEiova{GSanghi soc[Goocgsoq aycher coongaoenakig opSog GE GSoons8:GSo8” oargSEE elGoorc8 feGongSu BongSroup§ sosenag ecg cyapen comico: Gi soc yogSaqnkeqeSedog’ BEGSergeqanbogorae3[GSE: goSqoSeorg corfZyavldup copSs cof eaveSu g58:gS2008 cogaboapicgiqnag$ somrfuomasg: sogeSigGsogp: qoama8cyS8E BSoaSugd socrraq Sohn soGieQREelToks ooBeproorg earmina8sopSiqoaSup soEeGora8ogo coc8oog5i BBencqaoorigorahen sfGBSieucdsd oforg GSogoogicBgoR opoSeapiag: ane paSiG§ ofGqSiogS eoroE:a0§1 Byars agaoSBoSques angi oRuSor> sogrdcgncorpee$ cB§ron egeScBSoa8up sno apEGorpSeRevgS: gororgSclavgSu (epaSeogrogiangSeSgegS’ opis: onfagaprel sonqae8o8 GSco1 salGormBsqoRel sorgaepSn8{G8c0 apfEarQS1) onSooS33 oBaS 1 aoGSzoanBa0pS geSsqrreocS cages giong$ geSien w2g23 eqoScagregicboSagt Seema Bvoenrbrcost cof fGoreSu soeSeeqiog GE cvocfionnigigS oqSioG mmgiicor woBcSaodeBgqpi afgqSiqreg’ egeScapragranpSgpSien soap soohton| SlavgSi BESS okegpSie8 apiovfaoaha0s] ajrqupSy cySayogaoss ovvSaohr oor GEes a0g§ Bgorgagizosa BG: me Gsm y0~$ SadqcSyris vBBosay’ we Gacgaq sev: eBeonBon ssnssrmasa eougopSao$en opSqupSu agragis soosrncqa%rlGoS$Eso Su ovrGqoss8 apSooBreqisoogeS aablcSoyooSanpSeBgogé opeSesgiag:GErags aofeoSecypeSucSapaogSn pSecSecp: ap90701 cRoSogo ago SrapifgoS$Eo0p5i soapSoourrqo: gaocors£:aBanp§ gf:a803 voqaats soaySge encoreSaxpSgfreopS: oupe8i soaursougepScSoSQ: g8BroahroopSang$ (oreara0gBqqoSoR a EaogSu soepSghg$ onqpto8opS:cnstean wopSooenravugeRel vBvagl@Saoz$ cBaReoo08g thisad mocmagindingt afctinancs melnegs§ com gmBin socb BiapS8ivoga gs BEdoqicyoScoby gafedloSysrcores008 apSlGEs098 ofGoe 000 o§oengédordy: (gocloopSu 2g) 009d qrBocBopang§ sescw0 smefGberon0s svefRoExaoq aap GEang$ aroarreqisGEqn svecraenstgpoa cpobeoSgl cocqicBgapa sogoncSoyengsroeSiengchisl rooaS gl Bron reBEep Bgqprohog’ g58:gSocSoog: cerjgSecoreSang$ soefgorg qQosnr8 opoScogrogiGeiG ogS:oaor8$Ecls soobdl wvons{ais aoahByqpre? socorageySg epooagragiig’ ofa qariq§eBog$ wrelgZeGaSaySargé oo8ao0if: orrase{Goag’ epedenaason soeursoug vopSarkcun 88meqSapSgao08o8 Bhoos00 ewncjelgo&iyaos soeGGScSanS qr Sqn? apigrooyncsonE arangeScost¥Sc8GopSu q§ean§ oBo5 go8yors GBeosvacns BuSao0SeR efjrksoraue$ [gSangSu epoSespreg( BOGE og$En cpoSesg: opiGéto8 rraScara0dlp veySookup eaBeGalu socReSs08 SheneqBaqSqardher sobsorrelGahGod cpoSeograg:s worcrragEcRaon: (geSqosSsBGErorg8 opgBoopn emrcrngizoGinynr ap eScspicgicneS pahic8 apichoSepSup oSiomay oftonresSn oG oniljapeann moemagSapiangS ayohnes 9§ 729) gofoqpoie ofjg Gog IB: obebn8 8 ence Snigg$ cpoSemgiegiGerolgu GEraofooroE: Giiso§[BeSSophu Rouges epoSeogtog: ohn afabangSg§ S8moqSantsoaigcRoncSen ospiogionSogaps (SoSeqpaSgaSoqpa ogra abine $B og208c08 v>205 yoScoscon9095 oupcSoon agoSsegiagiB: cocbpcde onpioowsSecsor soner2gS0g5c8 coh: spoSooge Groorp GoroSlaoghu soogioolg’ sSiopSiqSonSopar—§ soreragSeobiqed gSqaSeo 29 BSG: svrEGEy vaQorgSaoclefiog’ BEEaqtson aagrogiens og gaSzg boa abroainqscna8 epSaisSSqprecTorrarcSangSu efjnqSc8 cocamnetl§ gorcopSclonpSi so3cm9 gfoec8or BoBar0090 080051 conh goSansaghcglGs coaooSapSgaooges angSaogifoadlefiog$ opoSesyiogig bcbg? S8creq8anEsoopepn of: 8 apiphiqySqpiongeS engoreacg astigiqesos€ opS8iyup ageBeclobo® [FRresigacopSu By 20 aolGfaoep§ cliconaza$r Gapcrepes aaGEsoapFoRabaglejqareS condgnbapEoGoSgleseog soopinedgEcorogsun GEero{a}a0951 smnenag fnn8iqaocion BGeneq8mExmig=ncBc§ egobospre gif BErqSraqrooro,Sup o2{Georpogharm 88 ocrnrcnBsop Ss GEs2098 say faoailGf aerrcSaySoSrcdears cbf pnabaokqeSars GSa0piu oBeS BErogGpSavou aBuScgefecRS 005 fGoSagGErsv2: qSorGera aSchaSaylé sooarsg oR anlage: ocSq cBooS yap qoSaiSeqSorfoyo:BEargSn socayzs00r& ogy epbvegs3 qpSguiqios enraé:ammnbifi§ agohrerrngoyeh, cyooSstogrg$ 7 yneinequpsd cutting Htoaeamgoveneprcf qoteo: 4sneSnaySuofs$SocBony ap? qSorfi0> q8Eaoghu ob S3ZEaopSn swhiqorofy gohogoBoorkEaopSr pope? of eorafiof E058u emeerngbao8ieyrn sabsomeoraforbreqyoSQeorbongSs agoR03 cocBarea0a05 [G6e2008 arsoogoSlug FG Bi afegaSoogiagss oornsend:cySrconcB$upSi ofaoorEie® (Bosqaogfancge$ obiasseqzear? ena sslangSn soarqeoqaeogS:(GSaogSu sBoasS aocBeonie gloved cogrogronSamefiadyo08 anggoSmageSopoSohin egooBcguSy cap fies GopSor0n cnznction fjaSfEBBkBn 200% SxnSancBes ScSarsa0s sofsosreovotiGt soocna9 feofiq, 29 comygisoogiad ScSeqrabegaogSa0sh Boures grpaqpcSaorpeghoR 8:8 Scvs{aanzhaoel epoSeagregia$ o.cfGocoa[oje8$upSe zoareSefejpEaaSan apcRel Goazoocnog$ opaSiogacct or08§Eov09, soBcoSZEBEGoarre[HoEGSar~Su oS GoklGSoo BSiqSreqivpe(Goe(Gor of2r8§.Gs828 88 eraq8voEsorgaras sracroqEsogiqc8 GER aeSpheqyoSo§rc8ERoqacd ea' sxresur20§0ln emoernghoog$ og oScagiagionpSayScfioScoag’s poaiaoflh: mBaSuSiq§ ecooé eqpoaps sofcorerctanSenqcbc8 Soren BarEsrnrqgpronction aockgquasu malGo8E_q: cBgqpig§ ocdaocScoog agodoapiegiogSin mnbieySiGEioneS SbereqSankamigapie® canteen: canroanrgS cond poSqen008 aaqmobcboilgfranalgSanaSu onScdgouE aycRonofon aofZEr008 HARP aocBcocSesvrkgcSeg(qovesSn soocmag Econ: wGEGoSeaie§rGaopSaoslg6 cEro8, soocheony cyoSemnE effredlSqzegeao. soclifiagisrs axbecyfean eqodespiagige: epSegarg$ sofeBcossoungp: Sooras:Ss0e] coobgaBqaoses928 BérqSe ecTeorREoogSe arebsapegsanagl Reoatomeyl eoqpmsogaget wai. opianeS gpSivasT BoSepionSog oogSn opebccgrogiSerBarpSyo vps husSUlGSorciongSaB keg Srcokicv8igs odionkian$ GolargSn cp oSeagrapiSSisSaopSyo wocrambainigSgeqorp§ songSonc8 BEG: alGEarops ecnrtelGeg oGo058 BgoupcSn g80008m0[eGo: oBvnglgSecTaaooy$ oogSqnSapic® ofggesGes cogSt op oSoon goSao:o008G9ng rq gSqqc5 you :bro0e§ cooheSansGSoganghcBgog’ veSagooncn opsoqynSi cBeostqios 1oang51 egSagaroSmeorp vera sraneSoh8 wneZSco01Q: evTeckeBcoo (2) cpoSeage GE: eopoSe (4) eaSareSanc8er Gjeoar2cn008 SapihoopSoopSeaqindco senilahiorgSu qfiaoqio5 cwodlyorgSf§: s2360708 ancanaepepSen ah:(GoSlGE(GEa0—5uBan ssnyrts . 4. nGrroSsoxqu$ soqiScogheosioo gS opoSeagiegi@s coanahen aBoSeGoomiqyoSqp: B ourkEup ESico8ey’ og¢8 ar coaapSlBoaSgpSie ormsEiBy sacomegge a 3Gip coapee> eoBoorghu argrowrcSs cond grSsonichegS apokcGqSoraqyinean’ workimogayScoxgeoo8 sooegSepSgabia cpoSeagrageqnegé vpSorpScRcvctqpougen gfcrpSu epSavpSac0r» gaton98 oovpS BB wood GoSQiy averrseQofaogSagarfGanpS eupoScln gfaopSi garaaaSoR somryeSooo$eor9 espi0gBc8SegSe Boao$ aofGEryrre5 [Ejarp$ noob pSanabagE souSasoSen Gjeowaan.08 Soh: RExogSsBoan0a0q40508 gorpS[hs efGeopSoqarcr05[eGfGuEu SBareqBor0Sa> B88, corakssBareh caadapimoged wPhaprcBooniqSuprRaexasé ooSeboyS [eGueSqaSin swrcrragSs0GsqancopS: giRencBcocSQ: wp5qyS¥Eoan08 S8maqhoSsorghed sooBoSzodqpt eogpel cogeyS E2925: ongpSiso21fsEeLGoqay’ svearm09efGeoeSogr:GABeRlSEiy> ooo Stabs son8 gS sotSoag: onoraighors005 soscmaanianie® opSyioisBEoopSeR (ajpSoogSu Bogan ogysocd HeogoyborgS: vSend:habogS eavgSBf ogeqeeBoogS: oS:02129954 Gry cocara0q009 a8: oxGEGSo095u aeamreg e[GeopSognsfanabBgog® eaSaoaSoocBno vpSaopheors8iaBqjoSqyteR cond egobsZEoog§ BoopSaoqyaSoRoog5: og SoSqueSu cpaSespiegig sma8GEayn{ajoo9$ sos) aptog’ BeSaraBaga008 socussouy aBEEryAarpSu BaaclefeaoaS aveanon}ajgypee® acGoSRe eqo5feGoog$ oS gSorchoc}: BBcRsovaE:cBavp§ BcosrqaSyst orefjoronSqcBoSaxcGh aoa, GooriqsqpicReopS: cooBegoScRaaq(GErootGE ofGooeSBErufeGSoooSn cwoophavebihicloponp$ aang Ss apie eaogSeorrk:BaySerr® cooSqgoSepSgaSen sorc2qR Bakara} soqoSepstody wPSavp$arqaSqyrr8 coo SZEvaSpSuu so§tqaodgorp$00) BBereqs waEaasiqcheo svocnagé A sooRaSaoSdlcBs oBs0Gre, earpScReost ZosSsjeocGSpveamq w[Gor8: qragregqaype coi Socom BBevrayé SereqSupSASregSecoon cbr pofGoopSoymfas Bug 8 (Gel8:n cvreqzar9 aaflecotar,Su coS§ BGereqBeabsoiqc00g {GF sordcocSofaSQobegaay[é (cvp05) soardor0§ Gfcoes Heb YoorkaBropS Bog’ GpSogchehore SGonratiopSecoor SaBsepSocvr" 4§ ogoonmclgoqarpinsl 8mcqdaniaoag eqedong: SEecqocsebaoS emerngSaprangs apSgabat SoSogiondiefig oBEiay GeSaoatcBe8 aSeREcondGE: SarpSu avocxr01 qacges ogaSiggo exopSoReR mBESraEleaendeEn cpogyognR onefsor0e$ ofohrooraé BgeasSqfi: ScSepSog GEGEarcS1 BGEG apchenoSoalcSayé conSadoqacS sg 20gh saghsoaqraparoR gicgoSchoSquaSsfog’ azohal ayy fryodas: Sodaqag§ (GSop2c0 corpuaSu giarqioio® BBoRSquasy apoSespiegisnpboBEexn& socmaqkypionss cf:chel angSmoaiapt! cap fqcSap: eargSc8e8 cocSageSuagriem8 «pS {cSSon5" opaSagragiti: qGarpS svosmoageBqyabaprcdag’ soacmagcReororcSeaxs moBap: AR aocBGabeSare8u soreorgEcRoaSarpS socheSans BereqBapSgarahen oRre§|scons8i0fnies dssmetl enaiscrraqimegad corgtarahenoda cvrchoicSupin cgooSy qoSgooGoEchah: pSqqo eySg§ avemoegGraver modeprcRoopS: cvscSyoSaeBSup5x cooneSg SforeqSardiavargpion BfSqySeyeScortarpScoSeanraSy cyoSelGooSoh envdecboScorpagtsS Gt avcaxseqc¥a53e005 yor{aggq Soorgoonpa0p8u ochabsndlgy qS3cGo5 aophancged BRSqy SeyoS{GEr coyppagargs oGoon GaSaghigG BEtorm09 woh oSordso8aor1gBal cokenargap: oGeorpa0¢handl giarrenaqohane8 GaSopo%soed! wookmoncS GR: qoSoo5 [e362 Gogo B8corcBGvabn cgoparn:corecoreSsear eorsopfoqsmysdiogaiag’ agoRso0g05 oof eaniGé aradephogcogorpS: e§eorpevr agohaS gScostcleos: (eossoena[REusSagecaQogyars aychah qo ooSlGEHOSBESQ gyric8 ongaSta0n1 Gf oB freoarSEcaoia095n [fSoroSugovp$o00) 200 crag Sgpia09§ agoh PSocdaSagapio? cBoSJlohepeorgepSavon sooreSe(MaEahoors “okssSs oip2SqpraraS eorhepfanfnyfaoa: eGoopSagapicRore gogour$aoxtQoog8" up arqSqgacac5 ene §chenSqjoSGavogaqpie8 BBScora9p§ ofongufieg’ cor8epfaq:as Gyan o8 oSchendarhi cqobaagrogiagd) ofGSu GSqSeor8eorSypraptey’ wocragScheR GoSqBE8, aortap fears [Aga soadcocSapSfajquain qsisarss001{g8 ogaScagre, fGSo(ro§ mBEqeSo8Gop vsBREcMn B8ohor0S8Eaayj svaohooySapu soon: apreoun eorbapfaqigadiqric qrloaqeass qEgpSieoic8 socBaoa5 gf cByogoso op: HoH WAP PIBEo[aHE wFEqBEGSarghu BGEG cpoScodyr}qches ofobgo8l}qrrapx ncBoqorBaepaSian.§ 8Seaqyzofogy (Round) wfeSreocda0gh of lBygpravaGbaraSup Gas maortperchdolaa$i oBlgaSiqnio? sqroswaSmafiqpiog€ seax:8o5or’Gulupsu HYPE ABELL sezIar! ‘4 ae [eh EBEiaScqieficts enoneSg wrcnagEmfiag’ Sbmeqdnboorgc} Borg Sreqssoe ap: oom fHoB GoSlGilBu asléegSaq rcomBs oS:orrPScBargSu eoSrorregé gogeqooSayoiGEoog5 Boras: oniaharpioaraich opaporooBEr agoSeo5k: ooqprgiorangS BSraSioqzafio8 BoBangSoupo5u Ges ageyen scortearstrapigadRroaT qrSenSuycSendoxg§ sorenaqtooBiqoReh BESqySqu5Sgrs seramvordsh sopbsagor(gesaneS BérqiSroq: ooSeapfeuncdu unforcorco gS BS:qS:oqzooss: 8 ofGpoen cfrdgingorcvs.05|GbavpSu Boas mpfoomroS Sra) eaghiag BollgEravo{GSarehx sooenagch AroSmogeSoora09§ Bi wu7051 comySic00s81 aganfgady2Rooes BSiqSs eosin pS solGorsogqaoSqrne8 ofan $o98 Georg onclorg soSefeorrqyeBqpie® ncScBes reqscons agoogs008E: copSyo sofGor 298 opioGorgrxav.0€GSarpSu soehx opeSaspicgiogco0—8 opedcapicgidcS 205 fy 10081 og Baapha oBEif§aSerns vorqyicSSiiaSy cgorgnaqid|sournSyge qoSocS ase: ee cof GSy> edgdhs§ cqsopfeosicars avocarg Sa? GahagSicobsoargg§ BEEormacReo onqoro8 98 on Krishnalal Shridharani, War Without Violence: A Study of Gandhi's Method and Its Accomplishment. New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1939, and reprint New York and London:Garland Publishinf, 1972), p.260,ee 20905 of§8Geor Boos GaScgSiooEsoggpra’ EEGory cpoSeapiegiogypien Sovoarag’ AGE cpobengragigg coodScGabfGEra:8 BooqyoSadg6u8 cEroRroadl anqorof wBaoyos jaro eqnoSagaranSu Buf cB8:f§oSoqEav2000 BESoraraaocouS you8 arqrrofsoGiqso(GS eqaoSagze ecoffu gE:cRsocS:09 cRavsegears ooqiokan§iqso(GSaRooqaeSe3 sracmaqSqnior—S 29h anenfsosoo5e§ aocBcoch eGus§ on FEr 8 G5 BSrqiSroqoroniclGolG: soocnaq Syor ob aBrq(GSaqore2008 cpSvavto084 faSSy Sas arco mootbogie anghaoc8Es socBeSaod BBmraqSaoEsorrpapraves corsopfoqseBo59 eg agfeokqoSBoSaySicvr009 ogaeSapro039400005REeor905 apoSasprogtcSeSoonp0¢Sup009 siGrSoro5 agin oos$ sosreccgpanta sostacypaystancSang$BoSc8 ofgotioSqueSu svocto> 480580098 vorp5 [Gu zorcnrg ScRcondaaoa08 eqoodaglqoopbagapry2co; dr oGepfeocbofier GSoogZEr avacmaqScheBonsSs Gif soen§ marching 8 Boob: sofs0> SS o8s0p5 8 Eu soqgcBonuSen “arocnag hg uf:c8 obipoScRan5 woalGspSqSeqsguescocs soo cn8soRa0gSi aoeS08e395 ja wbsoh obtpoSqyuy> (pleas up equcoe(GosopisloogSn ug 0058 sosenngSqpsranaScogs: auypogoSanErogape wugedu apoRcicgprageSqprys BGu€ Bick: coo clogs spch. Bjersoncmach caygfr05 Fares (soficcoieg’ sooenog Sok egppeges gpre8 wes0:808 onkgulegs) efFFpBen enyoan§ BEaUTo000 afGScoxyehapBBSSR: mrocoag Sting’ eapegeBap: Bofotn eanrafentsdapapreuncSe(epls SfSaocSi aychacget aqwyfiobal (Hol BacpSegeqe cu ogno-apgo egSaprorogbion Beo§ 8EZegE cahlGysSarocnrg apr eSryooro! couS gs Gp Red YokSqarzbu Boars mrognpobss qrbcRocfoorBrorarBEsqnrag’y qeSargpo08 0 geSrecSencgbsyo08 wocnrgick GoSeyoydulangSn ag¢¢ 94600 ancScSeoneuiSig’ goc8 erconkFdgrregt omni epson abancongtsafiqe® sovSecoiqoSunegExyoE GoSqycBoSRE erase BF REE0:E oSorbaabsorrg apSeySSers0—S qoinpakoR coBErsnog’ryav8 obey GoBREorgSn age ggbon BeoSBERECORE cpopailGgmntaoarc? vS$EG soocmrogqborscRiSyo qoaogaSicSmeghsy208 Gobmyayndarghn wcScSamScgoyorcion saEsecreorabcos3gSc8 eobcobgnrqrraBGEcora0e§ evden fanbiqas exrchrbch oppSehok w(iaSeorge ogee egsio BBurcSBEEog£ mBrvcSenehaqSgg wrcm ofGgErBSepSup oooklejulgsy BE Sraqig§ cgoScodggSqonsie8 cBaSeg’ oGrdBroa0 GSqSeoorqpig’ soa§ronbog$’ 8G afh:ca09 sonSeavassoenypie8 Baik: oofstgpSteoS:g soot [Bobs BRE vLoogSx o705 gpSte08: GEclaogaSen cofGrroupeSn RESoqeso$onye? sotoogSumm go iy Th mm 8 ane§: -8 spromang oreScoqangel: Sood yg gFoZegoog$ BEqS:oq:qas eopeSoqsle waBooahgSupSor w8a005 apr GEE gapo8 ogSsoySgo gyoScorrquasu s0§.00a5z§quaSu qerreloos BocB§rqyr oqiahqoasu Broa SésorgaproreS 8803, Beamocmagpre8 8 cqpob go soabieffoncSaglé sover gEso§iqe® GoSqEBSogSup vayoof REx SEscascgoSco8y cnpS(GosrrEcogS: oonoS8E BSlGoSSoehn wpSoR[GSREo50R oStonr{ a8 sorcmaqSopSig§ sorcnaq EaoBsqaRel soBor BE: eoBErapi{GBo009 080051 4 aavpSoR yrSBiGoRogrtecosnSang$ we Gaocg ondcrteongapiorogeS vpSsRea0s Beosonernq: hand dlangoSin BEEeqisoremrsBane$ypo ondSoharaich goroarpS {ea wolgpsciec8u §Esaqisrramo0[apobeet Rrog Exo goreopS coreannt cpSGvocisln gSigErecoras BSslooaSu euscEeogsgiSir snoSecoqapg5o oy (Liu-Ji) Bear orgoSuasoqéor$: sa0nrdang§ orgobgGGeoo cooradeg8 arahagapiar,s FEteqianaerrd8 gricopSorcsxrE o a0gS08 esr2o8clena8& oof Goom§cloopSi? itz (Chu) Boog§ GaSguSorqog8 soaBiRoocussaSGanaSu 9700 eqppoBypxoR soGEs0 snaodbegiangSu apyyrior age aig e(eqrrSaoqo)up eal foopSu G5cSo%Er oBSoEiwoghs goorcolh: cyproSao[—Brabs encoarée§ “vdsenedlEreaoak§s w(gareqpoSaeg’, covsEeiTeRagon aSaxSu8dy gSeogon oo 28 cea genate008 13" e a8 §ovrarpSn oypoSoremogghs gigsoo> 8Bigniody aooS$orsh8 038 so0o8yoScostanaSu somuSd ecurdegagé eoogos.eg7000035 sansofin8 SobogSen GStelGooBconra9—5u eqpaSgpicostapien e[GanS Bg sa>qioclGoq Goon WULB:i ScSeyges eorcgesrré sfejqao—Su cnegeaoome) oqpaScSecsroncmatan anjfeapaSagSe8 “SoxSo8eaguvs a038:(8e GoScostersc02¢" upcvrang5i cBandl afoopfeqpaSqpten “ozoRaSclags soors0cocaqooSeuloS 250} soo8eog6l"vp BhoGo(GorpSu eqpeSerecoren anche “adi ScBeBaE waPiBioB gleorsés 00423 ryScRorcag s08a8:a08 jeogeB oBuSoroavodBuS agsrgechuqagicon:” 07 cv:cBoSaopSu on AAG[GEar~eS oogodaggys Liu Ji (1311-1375) Bagoo Ve-li-zi (qEsel saegSoorg) Boo—$ eaqbogbeqsoo2s}c002 “opabypes spqySGE up soo sSQaog$ GGEgSoopSu Sidney Tai Bogen g22020[§$3(: Nonvilent Sanctions: News from the Albert Einstein Institution (Canbridge, Mass), Vol.IV, No.3 (Winter 1992©1993),p.3.028 350543: (gSooa5unm dnincay eel sqpeScoger “upoSor2101 ry ScRsoata}: geREor2ed]" up ofGaraSu eyppSmecoreosoo8 fe “Bch Sa calhoor5oh Sambi (Fee anaeh FGogayaads cvach, opFErorae0g op5fegqycs” vp afGocho5 2oahn eqpaionecoio §o¥ oGadjuadi8uf cqpadqpraostep: aoSqjSraxeaaaccloSogns{BonaSu Raoyoo8 awohr{eBrBbovooragoingS.cocl aqpoSypio> apooRBoSecpa8ensra958 & opSehuypte8 qoS8i08 805 HoopSu sooki[eFrBS:core200 aobabratanmicfec8 opl§: corsad-8 egeBcfGioynifajecocorpoxgSu aoc8i (iad sa Scoxpy feogarGeorpeun agooSabiog€ s0c8s(}: gocoaS: svoscoS i: caaiioysiccoconpa0aSu RGGEsFooSa005g onqcSoara9§ vpSBoo"Becorm [Bigs swafjagecguss cpecTapeas ©35R BSeopSopaSortcn> SaSaySfoau8: aseaaaea8onqnig, pig Seg lov ovpeSi SeGopeog em angele} cqpabanqns, vogagicvat! ayccGogeogura abuboSoRuS coSeavodyoaSo%t0} agecgy fe vo8[Heqzoocr01 9708, cooBesrr08cnqyeog ores, qoSBgScosa€ agc8q.zocBSa0930 cope ro8chy soofazeehgcorays eupotag:” up sfSaraSu Beagioroms afaf oxeRsRoeSqjebejen cyengprcBenrig bcBanpSiy> RigigSsq Sro€ GSa0p5n sorerogbqprane§ BEragGaSan: aaidh aorgengdahebaogsn somgenBovis$ay o§oys ayRelanrcrae8 ach: BfrocorrREx cngSfewa8engSs vagS8Ecorpo0n affavearsenqzic8 goScox4BqupSn aoocmogEmBiqgp: $6 eqarocmant g§$800p5 o8{GSqri098 exvoabclaoqeSyp:clo€aogSu $ Bjooo8ggen 1 ogogar horgiqangS arqorofnBiqGSaeSi RefGoe carga a BEE PAGE moffodin ABSEEE: H cymdmom 1 anhiqclaod§dqo5g giavlEroaonEgobng—Searoagqu RS gap! A meqmregoSg§ magidlqost % caSirSggSmorcSopzon w soqfssos sooassSoSeBgap odTooragy’é ogee cpSefinSioqSagqpa vazaend5 soeySsoungp soasSkeo} gp! H coaiegdcoSoRSgSeGREreSmqaSaam — u s0h:q3 mmgarsBourqEargS BoSypu 208§ podorcSaopSan bays avToooeaes& BoSercSeqsqng§ Slacaeep >: eurrk: exgrecosqaSqpti qdoggerEmom u ogaSinge coudene ogaSiapan egantsvon SiyseqiogS1 cocd ageSequt soeSupQearr8eqroarp5oho8 an8:q00 qi ScREcoor§Ecan> so08E:s00721 aGSeormeqieg Ergin 1 ofrqorpSosSEGoqiooage5 qyotcorrenrsgenc8é: caorkgeSfEoqrmaged aoBfugads grovlEroaon’goS[SEs olGjagayaie® BOralGoo8 wffSeurmaniagy a0gSo8(GSaop5u sna beloquaSshagé REtoqrmnenngdicheatngs meodSdlne Baro} BEimy GES conigpim sa§rqo8 condd,ccmaaBsyas q§SEee5u cyagm Bh grdpa00 GESEaraSu oy>8, wosSieyrrg GaSogoin Ging yrodIBoaonkgaSgaos q8Earp5u aséiBoupoSclon 0,05clu GaSagegoqen wocmngSangiqehonfabyosi gEscRgSgravlEsoansk gods aorgaosSap: