Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Table 1: Split of the data bank into test set and training set results for the 13 cancer cell lines
3
A2780ovarian cancer 27 22 5
ACHN Kidney cancer 31 25 5
NUGC Stomach cancer 24 20 4
Model Development and validation
…………………………………………………………………………
Applicability Domain
………………………………………………………………………
4
Tableau 8 Correlation matrix (Pearson (n)) for the PC-3 cancer cell line, linking the many
variables gathered. The topological descriptor Balaban (which stands for 2D Balaban
averaged distance sum connectivity) has a negative relationship with PIC50 (r=-0.509). The
descriptor ' SlogP VSA4' has a positive correlation (r=-0.572) with PIC50.
PIC50 BalabanJ SlogP_VSA4 Density
PIC50 1
BalabanJ -0,509 1
SlogP_VSA4 0,572 -0,020 1
Density 0,391 0,029 -0,016 1
In bold character we show the variables which are highly correlated.
Figure 7-A The density descriptor is well correlated along the F2 axis (r=0.886), the SlogP VSA 4
descriptor is well correlated along the F1 axis (r=0.651), and the balabanJ descriptor is negatively
correlated along the F1 axis (r=-0.576), according to Figure 7-A, which shows the correlation circle
corresponding to a projection of the variables on a two-dimensional plane.
`A B
Figure 7. CPA of PC-3: A represents a correlation circle of descriptors and anticancer activity
(PIC50g), B represents a biplot of the molecules in the plan of the first two axes F1 and F2, and the
percentages of variance for the two axes F1 and F2 are respectively 46.40 percent and 25.81 percent.
The overall amount of data is predicted to be 72.22 percent.
5
The second group, which included molecules 249, 246, 240, 245, 248, 275, 266, 267,
272, and 250, was found to have moderate anticancer activity. This can be explained
by the negative contribution of the descriptor 'BalabanJ,' which indicates the
topological index of connectivity at distance with a correlation coefficient of r=-0.510.
Indeed, anticancer effectiveness against PC-3 prostate cancer was reduced by drugs
with a high topological index of remote connectivity (BalabanJ> 1.40).
The molecules 251, 252, 254, 256, 258, 261, 268, 269, and 270, which are depicted in
the upper right of the biplot, demonstrated superior anticancer activity because the
descriptor 'density' linked favorably with a correlation coefficient of r=0.391.
1.1.2B16F10 Skin cancer
The correlation matrix depicts the relationship between the six descriptors chosen for this
HepG-2 line (Table 9).
Table 9: A correlation matrix (Pearson (n)) was built for the B16F10 cancer cell line to link
the various factors obtained. The descriptors PEOE VSA+0 and SlogP VSA5 are positively
associated (r = 0.703).
Zagreb is positively linked with SlogP VSA5 (r=0.0616) and PEOE VSA+0 (r = 0.523).
Soother (Stands for 2D VDW another surface area (A**2)) is negatively connected with
SlogP VSA5.
PEOE VSA+0 and Zagreb, respectively, with r = -0.752, -0.715, and -0.768. With r=0.676,
r=0.519, and r=-0.577, SMR VSA7 (stands for 2D Molar refractivity) is associated with
SlogP VSA5, PEOE VSA+0, and soother.
PIC50 1
SlogP_VSA5 0,320 1
PEOE_VSA+0 0,550 0,703 1
Zagreb 0,397 0,616 0,523 1
Zagreb -0,626 -0,752 -0,715 - 1
0,768
SMR_VSA1 0,003 -0,027 -0,267 0,467 0,064 1
SMR_VSA7 0,359 0,676 0,519 0,383 -0,577 -0,293 1
In bold character we show the variables which are highly correlated.
Figure 8-A indicates a positive association between the descriptors SplgP VSA5 and PEOE VSA+0
with r=0.783, SlogP VSA5 and zagreb with r=0.616, and SlogP VSA5 and SMR VSA7 with r=0.676
in the biplot analysis.
6
While there is a negative correlation between the descriptors zagreb and Zagreb (r=0.769) and the
descriptors PEOE VSA+0 and Zagreb (r=-0.715), there is a positive correlation between the
descriptors PEOE VSA+0 and Zagreb (r=0.715).
A B
Figure 8. ACP: Represent Correlation Circle of Descriptors and anticancer activity (PIC50g), B:
Represent biplot of the molecules in the plan of the first two axes F1 and F2, the percentages of
variance for the two axes F1 and F2 are correspondingly 55.37 percent and 20.52 percent. 75.90
percent of the total data is estimated.
7
1.1.3K-562 Leukemia
The correlation matrix below shows the correlation between the four descriptors chosen for
line K-562 (Table 10).
Table 10: Pearson (n) correlation matrix connecting the various factors found for the K-562
cancer cell line. SMR VSA4 (molar refraction) and BCUT SLOGP 2 have a positive
relationship (r = 0.600). SMR VSA4 has a positive correlation (r = 0.459) with a no (number
of oxygen atoms in a molecule). The number of sulfur atoms in a molecule (a ns) is negatively
associated with the amount of oxygen atoms (a no) (r = -0.543). BCUT SLOGP 2 has a r =
0.468 positive correlation with PIC50. The number of oxygen atoms in a molecule (a n6) is
positively connected with PIC50 (r = 0.467). With a r = 0.919, SMR VSA4 (molar refraction)
is highly linked with PIC50.
PIC50 1
BCUT_SLOGP_2 0,468 1
a_nO 0,467 0,095 1
a_nS -0,231 0,384 -0,543 1
SMR_VSA4 0,919 0,600 0,459 0,033 1
In bold character we show the variables which are highly correlated.
A B
8
Figure 9: K-562's CPA: A represents a correlation circle of descriptors and anticancer
activity (PIC50µg), B represents a biplot of the molecules in the plan of the first two axes F1
and F2, and the percentages of variance for the two axes F1 and F2 are respectively 52.13
percent and 32.51 percent. The overall amount of data is expected to be 84.64 percent.
Figure 9-A depicts the correlation circle between descriptors, with a positive correlation
coefficient of r=0.600 between BCUT SLOGP 2 and SMR VSA4, a negative correlation
coefficient of r=-0.543 between descriptors a no and a ns, and a low correlation coefficient of
r=0.459 between descriptors a no and SMR VSA4.
Two groups are identified by the Biplot graph (Figure 9-B).
Compounds 348, 349, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 355, 356, 357, and 358 are part of the
first group, which has stronger anticancer activity (PIC508 M) against the K562 cell
line. Furthermore, with a correlation coefficient of r=0.468, the descriptor 'a no'
(number of oxygen atoms in the molecule a no>2') contributes favorably to the
examined activity. The more oxygen atoms, the higher the value of anticancer activity.
The second group, which includes compounds 322-347, has a moderate anticancer
activity (PIC504) and the descriptor 'SMR VSA4' (gross approximate surface
assessable for van der Waals forces for atoms with an atomic contribution to the molar
refraction), which strongly contributes to the anticancer activity with a correlation
coefficient of r=0.919.
1.1.4MDA-MB-231Breast cancer
The correlation matrix depicts the relationship between the four descriptors chosen for this MDA-MB-
231 line (Table 11).
Table 11: Pearson (n) correlation matrix for the MDA-MB231 cancer cell line's various
obtained factors. Q PC- (2D partial charge that is total negative) has a r=-0.644 negative
correlation with PEOE VSA+1. PEOE VSA+ is closely associated with Q VSA HYD (2D
Total hydrophobic surface area of van der Waals force), with r=0.701. Q VSA HYD (2D total
hydrophobic surface area of van der Waals force) has a negative correlation (r=0.594) with Q
PC- (2D total negative partial charge). PEOE VSA+1 has a r=0.799 correlation with (PIC50).
Q PC- has a r=-0.794 correlation with (PIC50).
PIC50 1
PEOE_VSA+1 0,799 1
Q_PC- -0,794 -0,644 1
Q_VSA_HYD 0,487 0,701 -0,594 1
In bold character we show the variables which are highly correlated.
9
The correlation circle between the descriptors is shown in Figure 10-A. There is a good
correlation between the descriptors 'PEOE VSA+1' and 'Q VSA HYD' with a correlation
coefficient of r=-0.644, but a negative correlation between the descriptors 'Q PC-' and 'Q VSA
HYD' with a correlation coefficient of r=-0.594.
A B
Figure 10: MDA-MB-231 CPA: A represents the Correlation Circle of Descriptors and
Anticancer Activity (PIC50g), B represents the biplot of the molecules in the plan of the first
two axes F1 and F2, and the percentages of variance for the two axes F1 and F2 are 75.46
percent and 13.79 percent, respectively. The overall amount of data is expected to be 89.25
percent.
The Biplot graph (Figure 10-B) allows us to visualize the individuals on a two-dimensional
map, allowing us to classify the molecules into three categories based on their cytotoxicity.
The first group, which includes compounds 369, 374, 375, 376, 377, 387, 388, 393,
and 395, exhibited moderate anticancer activity (PIC50 4M) against the MDA-MB-
231 cell line; this group is distinguished by the descriptor 'Q PC-' (the total negative
partial charge in the molecule 'Q PC'), which contributes negatively to anticancer
activity with a correlation coefficient of r=0.7 We divide them into three groups based
on their cytotoxicity.
Compounds 360, 361 and 362 were shown to have greater anticancer activity (PIC50≥
6µM). This group is distinguished by the descriptor 'Q VSA HYD' (surface area of
total hydrophobic van der waal forces), which contributes positively to anticancer
activity with a correlation coefficient of r=0.487.
10
The remaining molecules in the third group are 359, 363, 364, 368, 370, 371, 372,
373, 378, 379, 380, 381, 382, 383, 389, 390, 391, 392, 396, 397, and 398, which have
moderate to acceptable anticancer activity (4 µM ≤PIC50≤6 µM). These compounds
are characterized by the descriptor 'PEOE VSA+1,' which contribute remarkably with
a correlation coefficient of r=
PIC50 1
PEOE_VSA-1 -0,402 1
SlogP_VSA5 0,411 -0,340 1
TPSA -0,649 -0,041 0,055 1
In bold character we show the variables which are highly correlated.
A B
The correlation circle of descriptors and PIC50 is depicted in Figure 11-A. A positive
association was evaluated in the descriptors 'TPSA' and 'PIC50' with a correlation coefficient
of r=-0.649, as well as the descriptor 'SlogP VSA5' and the 'PIC50' with r=0.411.
Figure 11. CPA of A2780: A represents the Correlation Circle of Descriptors and anticancer
activity (PIC50g), B represents the biplot of the molecules in the plan of the first two axes F1
11
and F2, and the percentages of variance for the two axes F1 and F2 are respectively 48.24
percent and 31.25 percent. The overall amount of data is expected to be 79.49 percent.
We used the study of the Biplot graph (Figure 11-B) to better understand the relationship
between the descriptors and the anticancer activity of the examined compounds.
This allows us to define two groups of molecules based on their cytotoxicity.
The first group, which is represented by molecules 401, 403, 406, 419, 427, 428, and
429 in the top left of the biplot, showed moderate anticancer activity against cell line
A2780 (5.50MPIC506.35M). This group is characterized by the descriptor 'TPSA' (the
topological polar surface), which contributes negatively to anticancer activity with a
correlation coefficient of r=-0.650.
The second group, which is represented by molecules 399, 400, 404, 407, 408, 409,
410, 411, 412, 413, 414, 415, 416, 417, 418, 420, 421, 423, 424, 425, and 426 on the
lower left of Biplot (Figure 11-B), showed better anticancer activity when compared to
the A2780 cell line (6.50µM≤PIC50≤7.00µM) and is Then, with a correlation
coefficient of 0.411, the descriptor 'SLOGP VSA5' (the summation of the estimated
accessible van der Waals surface).
1.1.6ACHN kidney cancer
The correlation matrix created below shows the correlation between the four descriptors used
for this lineage (Table 13).
Table 13: For the ACHN cancer cell line, a correlation matrix (Pearson (n)) was created to
correlate the various variables gathered. (diameter) r=0.540 is positively connected with opr
nrot (denotes 2D Oprea Rotatable Bond Count). PEOE VSA PNEG (denotes 2D Total polar
-ve surface area of Van der Waals force) is inversely linked with Q VSA PNEG (r=-0.484).
PIC50 Diameter PEOE_VSA_PNE Q_VSA_PNE opr_nrot
G G
PIC50 1
diameter -0,419 1
PEOE_VSA_PNE -0,249 0,309 1
G
Q_VSA_PNEG 0,338 0,128 -0,484 1
opr_nrot 0,105 0,540 0,039 -0,193 1
12
In bold character we show the variables which are highly correlated.
A B
The PIC50 and the variables evaluated are correlated, as shown by the correlation circle
(Figure 12-A). The descriptors 'oprt nrot' and 'diameter' have an excellent collinearity
coefficient of 0.540, followed by a negative correlation of r=-0.484 between the descriptors
'PEOE VSA PNEG' and 'Q VAS PNEG,' and a weak correlation between the other
descriptors.
Figure 12: ACHN's CPA: A represents a correlation circle of descriptors and anticancer
activity (PIC50g), B represents a biplot of the molecules in the plan of the first two axes F1
and F2, and the percentages of variance for the two axes F1 and F2 are respectively 39.18
percent and 27.12 percent. The overall amount of data is predicted to be 66.30 percent.
We were able to differentiate three groups based on their descriptors using the Biplot analysis
(Figure 12-B).
The first group, which included molecules 466, 452, 470, 465, 467, 468, 454, and 469,
was found in the upper left of the biplot and showed moderate anticancer activity
against the ACHN cell line. This group is defined by the descriptor 'Q VSA PNEG,'
which contributes positively to the increase in anticancer activity studied with a
correlation coefficient of r=0.338.
The second group included molecules 434, 435, 446, 459, 460, 461, 451, 464, 472,
473, and 474, which were found in the bottom right corner of the biplot (Figure 12-B)
and shown high anti-neoplastic activity (PIC505M). The descriptor 'PEOE VSA
PNEG' (total -ve surface area of Van der Waal forces) has a correlation coefficient of
-0.250, which defines this group.
13
The third set of molecules on the upper right of the biplot, 441, 440, 439, 438, 448,
436, 447, 444, 445, 458, and 475, showed moderate anticancer activity
(4.40µM≤PIC50≤5.50µM). Two descriptions are combined in this group. With a
correlation coefficient of -0.419, one based on the physicochemical descriptor
'diameter' demonstrated a negative contribution to ACHN anticancer activity. The
additional descriptor, 'opr-nrot,' indicates that the number of single bonds in rotation
contributes positively, with a r=0.106 correlation coefficient.1.1.7NUGC Stomach
cancer
The correlation matrix below shows the relationship between the three descriptors chosen for
this NUGC lineage and PIC50 (Table 14).
Table 14: Pearson (n) correlation matrix connecting the NUGC cancer cell line's numerous
obtained factors. balabanJ (desinge 2D Balaban averaged distance sum connectivity) is
inversely connected with b single (denotes the number of single bonds (including implicit
hydrogens) with a r=-0.603. PEOE VSA+1 is positively linked with b single (r=0.469)
14
PEOE_VSA+1 -0,412 -0,129 0,037 1
b_single -0,281 -0,295 -0,603 0,469 1
In bold character we show the variables which are highly correlated.
A B
The correlation between the variables studied and anticancer activity is depicted in Figure 13-
A; most variables have a good collinearity of r> 0.5.
Figure 13: NUGC CPA: A represents the Correlation Circle of Descriptors and anticancer
activity (PIC50g), B represents the biplot of the molecules in the plan of the first two axes F1
and F2, with percentages of variance of 40.04 percent and 28.02 percent for the two axes F1
and F2, respectively. The overall amount of data is expected to be 69.06 percent.
We may divide the molecules into three groups based on the study of the Biplot graph shown
in Figure 13-B.
The first group, which includes molecules 485, 494, 497, 486, 478, and 500 in
the bottom left of the biplot (Figure 13-B), has better anticancer activity
(PIC50≥7.00µM) against the NUGC cell line and is distinguished by the
descriptor 'a ns' (which indicates the number of sulfur atoms in the molecule)
which contributes positively to anticancer activity with a correlation coefficient
of r=0.294.
In the bottom right of the biplot, molecules 477, 479, 480, 482, 483, 488, 487,
489, 484, 498, 499, and 486 are found; these compounds have moderate
Table 16 value of statistical parameters for the thirteen cancer cell lines
Correlatio Cross Q2 R2
n Cross valiadted internal external
Cancer Cell
coefficient RMSE validated RMSE validation validation
Lines
R2 of R2
model
PC-3 0.83200 0.10710 0.76061 0.12826 0.76061 0.669
B16F10 0.82751 0.19496 0.71697 0.25319 0.71697 0.776
K-562 0.98478 0.24926 0.97920 0.29148 0.97920 0.878
MDA-MB-231 0.81342 0.18571 0.76541 0.20896 0.76541 0.798
A2780 0.84065 0.14372 0.73024 0.18770 0.73024 0.647
ACHN 0.87813 0.10311 0.81326 0.12809 0.81326 0.751
NUGC 0.92013 0.19987 0.86062 0.26587 0.86062 0.8078
We expand below more details for each cancer cell line. ==> paraphraser
16
1.1.1Model PLS PC-3
From the equation we notice that the descriptors balabanJ and SlogP_VSA4 could contribute
to the improvement of the anticancer activity.
1.1.2Model PLS B16F10
According to this equation, the descriptors Slog VSA5; zagreb, and vsa other have a negative
impact on anticancer activity, implying that the van der waals surface can help to reduce
anticancer activity in the B16F10 cell line. The descriptors PEOE VSA+0; SMR VSA1; and
SMR VSA7 then showed a positive coefficient, indicating that molar refractivity and the
overall positive van der Waals surface may play a role in improving the studied biological
activity.
1.1.3Model PLS K-562
We can see from the equation that the number of sulfur atoms has a negative coefficient,
which suggests that the number of atoms can help to boost anticancer activity against the K-
562 cell line.
The number of oxygen atoms had a negative coefficient, indicating that the number of oxygen
atoms may play a role in improving the biological activity under consideration.
1.1.4Model PLS MDA-MB-231
The descriptor (Q PC-), which indicates the total negative partial charge, contributes to the
increase in biological activity, as shown in the equation.
In the version, the descriptor (Q VSA HYD) has a -ve coefficient, implying that an increased
amount of partial charge at the surface enhances the anticancer impact.
1.1.5Model PLS A2780
According to the QSAR model equation for this cell line, the descriptors (TPSA) (topological
polar surface area) (PEOE VSA-1) (sum of negative Van Der Waals surface) (PEOE VSA-1)
(PEOE VSA-1) (PEOE VSA-1) (PEOE VSA-1) (PEOE VSA-1) (PEOE VSA-1) (PEOE
VSA-1) (PEOE VSA-1) (This suggests that the pyrazole structure's Van Der Waals surface
charge enhances the cytotoxic activity.
1.1.6Model PLS ACHN
The descriptors diameter (Diameter), partial negative charge (PEOE VSA PNEG), negative
polar area (Q VSA PNEG), and number of rotational bonds (opr nrot) are found to contribute
to the enhancement of antineoplastic activity against the ACHN cancer cell line. This
indicates that the diameter and partial charge of molecular structures have a positive impact
on cytotoxicity.
1.1Prediction of anticancer activity of the new synthesis series
PIC50Cell PIC50 predicted of value in µM of best potential inhibitors for each cell line line
PC-3
M48=5,2647 M55=5,3206 M60=5,2652 M54=5,1415
17
prostate cancer
B16F10
M36=6,7535 M41=6,5148 M42=6,3024 M43=6,7368
Skin cancer
K-562
M1=7,3133
Leukemia
MDA-MB-231
M4=6,3657 M5=5,8921 M32=7,0300 M33=6,5565
Breast cancer
A2780
M4=8,5720 M19=8,5720 M30=8,1494 M32=8,6362
ovarian cancer
M33=6,3643
Kidney cancer M1=6,1061 M5=6,4812 M20=5,8703
2
NUG M32=43,623 M52=36,028
M33=34,4487 M47=34,7843
Stomach cancer 2 6
18
Figure 25 Structure of novel series of pyrazole triazole thiol showing the best PIC50
valuesagainst the PC-3 prostate cancer cell line.
Conjugates 48, 55 and 60 bearing the methyl and Ph-group on the bromo group and pyrazole
ringat benzene ring manifest cytotoxicity against the PC-3 cell line with cytotoxicity values of
PIC50=5.264µM, PIC50=5.320µM and PIC50=5.265µM respectively, and are approximately
similar to those obtained in the literature[74, 75].On the other hand, the conjugate 54 carrying
on the pyrazole ring the phenyl group as well as the electron-withdrawing group
dichlor(2,4Cl) on the benzene ring showed a moderate cytotoxic effect with a cytotoxicity
value PIC50=5.141µM. This suggests that the optimal order of increasing substitutions activity
on the benzene ring is Br>(-N-CH3)2>OCH3>>Phenyl>2,4-Cl>CH3 (Figure 26).
19
Figure 27 Structure of novel series of pyrazole triazole thiol showing the best PIC50 values
against the B16F10 skin cancer cell line.
The pyrazole carbohydrazide conjugates 36, 41, 42 and 43 (Figure 27) shows average to
acceptable antiproliferative effect in opposition toB16F10 line of cell with cytotoxicity values
of PIC50=6.753μM, PIC50=6.514μM, PIC50= 6.302 μM and PIC50=6.736μM. This is explained
by the presence of dimethyl on the pyrazole A ring as well as Br, OH and OCH3groups on the
benzene B ring. Similarly, compounds substituted by dimethyl on the same pyrazole A ring
and substituted by N(CH3)2, NO2, Clone the benzene B ring and furan exhibited a reduced
effect of cytotoxicity against the B16F10 cell line. Hence, the ideal elevated order of the
activity of ring substitutions on ring B is Br>OH>OCH3>Furan>NO2>(-N-
CH3)2>2,4Cl>CH3(Figure 28).
20
Figure 29Structure of pyrazole triazole thiol showing the best PIC50 values against LeukemiaK-562.
This high cytotoxicity can probably be explained by the presence of a methyl group on the
pyrazole ring and a hydrazide group linked to the carbonyl function. The other conjugates
showed a moderate to weak effect against this line.
1.1.4Antiproliferative effect against the MDA-MB-231 cell line of breast cancer
For the line of MDA-MB-231, the results of QSAR prediction show that the conjugate4, 5, 32
and 33 (Figure 30) show the highest cytotoxic activity.
Figure 30 Structure of novel series of pyrazole acetohydrazide showing the best PIC50 values
against the MDA-MB-231breast cancer cell line.
Conjugate 4 and 5 belong to the pyrazole carbohydrazide family showed moderate anticancer
potential against the cell line of MDA-MB-231 with cytotoxicity values: PIC50=6.365 μM and
PIC50=5.892μM this can be explained by the presence of methyl group (CH3) on the pyrazole
ring A as well as the benzene ring B substituted by the dimethylamino(N(CH3)2)
electrondonor group, this group contributes to the enhancement of the activity of this
compound. On the other hand, compound 5 substituted by an electron withdrawing group
21
Nitro (NO2) on the benzene ring contributes decrease the bioactivity. Similarly, compound 32
substituted with dimethyl (CH3)2 on the same pyrazole ring A and keeping the same
dimethylamino(N(CH3)2) group bearing on the benzene ring B exhibited an increased
cytotoxic effect PIC50=7.030μM. This due to the presence of two methyl groups on the
pyrazole ring. Next, pyrazole acetohydrazide compound 33 showed significant
PIC50=6.556μM cytotoxic activity against cell line that has been studied. Our QSAR model
predicted the cytotoxic values that are higher than those obtained in literature [76, 77].
Therefore, on B ring the activity substitution of optimal ascending order is NCH 3)2>OCH3>2-
Cl 2,4-Cl>Furan>4-Cl>F NO2.
1.1.5Antiproliferative effect against the A2780 ovarian cancercell line
Our QSAR study also identified cancer cell line A2780 to explore other conjugates
that may be a potential agent against this cell line. In this regard, the information extracted
from prediction results analysis, indicates that compounds 4, 19, 30 and 32 (Figure 31)
present the highest cytotoxic activity.
Figure 31 Structure of novel series of pyrazole acetohydrazideshowing the best PIC50 values
against the A2780 ovarian cancercell line.
The prediction results show that compound 4 has the highest anticancer potential against this
cell line with a PIC50=8.572μM. This antiproliferative activity of this compound is explained
by the presence of methyl (CH3) bearing on the pyrazole ring A as well as the benzene ring B
substituted by the dimethylamino electron-donor group (N(CH3)2). This group improves the
activity of this conjugate. On the other hand, the conjugate substituted by the nitro group on
the benzene ring, showed low anticancer activity compared to compound 4. Similarly,
compound 19 substituted by phenyl on the same pyrazole ring A and keeping the same
dimethylamino(N(CH3)2) group bearing on the benzene ring B exhibited a PIC50=8 cytotoxic
22
effect.572 μM increased against the A2780 cell line. This can be explained by the presence of
phenyl on the pyrazole ring which increases the anticancer activity of this compound. Next,
compounds 30 and 32 belonging to the pyrazole acetohydrazide family showed significant
PIC50= 8.149μM and PIC50=8.636μM cytotoxicity against the cell line that has been studied
isA2780. The presence of two methyl groups contributes to a slight increase in activity.
Therefore, on the B-ring the substitution activity of optimal increasing orderis
NCH3)2>NO2>phenyl>OCH3>2-Cl,4-Cl>.
23
groups bearing on the benzene ring, show a decrease in their activities. Similarly, compound
20 substituted in this case by phenyl on the pyrazole ring A and benzene ring B substituted by
the Nitro (NO2) group showed a moderate cytotoxic effect (PIC50=5.870μM) against the
ACHN cell line. This is probably due to the presence of phenyl group that is present on the
ring of pyrazole. This phenyl group decreases the activity of anticancer of this compound.
Then, compound 33 substituted with dimethyl on the same pyrazole ring A and benzene ring
B substituted with the same
Nitro group (NO2) showed a high cytotoxic effect compared to compound 20
(PIC50=6.364μM) against the ACHN cell line, this is probably explained by the presence of
two methyl groups on the pyrazole ring which increases the anticancer activity of this
compound 33. Therefore, on ring Bthe substitutions activity of optimal increasing order is
NO2> Furan>OH>OCH3>2-Cl>Phenyl>N-CH3)2>2,4-Cl>.
Figure 33.Structure of novel series of pyrazole triazole thiol and acetohydrazide showing the
best PIC50 values against the NUGC gastric cancer cell line.
24
Conjugate 32 from thepyrazole acetohydrazide family bearing a dimethyl (CH3)2 substitution
on the pyrazole A ring and the electron-donating group (N(CH3)2) on the benzene B ring,
against the NUGC cell line, showed a promising cytotoxic effect with PIC 50=43.623.
Similarly, the conjugate 33 carrying the same dimethyl (CH3)2 electron donor groups onthe
pyrazole ring A as well as the benzene ring B substituted by an electron-withdrawing group
(NO2) showed a slight decrease compared to compound 32 in cytotoxicity against the gastric
cancer cell line with PIC50 = 34.448. It suggests the presence of withdrawing the electron
group decreases the anti-cancer activity. Moreover, compound 47 belonging to pyrazole
triazole thiol family increase the cytotoxicity compared to compound 33 against NUGC cell
line with the value of PIC50=34.784µM, Since the pyrazole ring substituted with methyl group
as well as benzene ring substituted with dimethyl amino(N(CH3)2 suggests a slight increase in
the anticancer activity against NUGC cell line. Finally, the last compound 52 showed a high
cytotoxic activity (PIC50=36.028µM) compared to compound 47. This increased activity is
probably explained by the occurrence of phenyl group carried on the ring of pyrazole as well
as, the benzene ring which keeps the same previous group (compound 47).
Therefore, Therefore, on ring B the substitutions activity of optimal increasing order is
NO2>N-CH3)2>Phenyl>OH>OCH3>Furan>diphenyl>Br>F>4-Cl>2-Br>5-OH>2,4-Cl>2-Cl>.
25
pIC =3.04136 -0.81740 * balabanJ +0.01517 * SlogP_ VSA4+3.32414 * density50
26
Table 24Values of descriptors for the new pyrazole carbohydrazide derivatives and their
predicted anticancer activity PIC50 (Prostate cancer PC-3) calculated according to PC-3
mathematical model.
27
2.2Skin cancer B16F10
The anticancer activity is decreased by the descriptors SlogP VSA5, vsa Other, and zagreb,
while it is increased by the descriptors PEOE VSA+0, SMR VSA1, and SMR VSA7. For
SlogP VSA5, PEOE VSA+0; zagreb; vsa other; SMR VSA1 and SMR VSA7, the t-test values
are 0.338999522; 0.234764212; 0.634176392; 1.275552219; 0.8523506 and 0.267005164,
respectively.
Table 25. Values of descriptors for new pyrazole carbohydrazide derivatives and their
predicted anticancer activity PIC50 (B16F10 skin cancer) calculated according to B16F10
mathematical model.
29
111.258 291.864
41.6416 286.8487 210 19.6490 9,3311
2 2
15
2.3Leukemia K-562
30
In the model equation, the descriptors BCUT_SlogP_2, a_nO and a_nS contribute to the
decrease in anticancer activity against Leukemia, while the descriptor SMR_VSA4
contributes to its increase. The t-test values for our descriptors shown in the model are
37.8029547; 4.478255236; 43.41145941and 2.134318478 for BCUT_SlogP_2; a_nO; a_nS
and SMR_VSA4, respectively.
The compound that served as Template for the substitution is compound 1.
31
Table 26Values of the descriptors for new pyrazole carbohydrazide derivatives and their
predicted anticancer activity PIC50 (K-562Leukemia) calculated according to K-562
mathematical model.
BCUT_SlogP
N° a_nO a_nS SMR_VSA4 PIC50
_2
0.55531985
1 0 65.794373 9,7484
12
9,749
0.55486625 1 0 65.794373
0
13
32
The t-test values for our descriptors are 20.55850184; 0.630735449; and 0.320816843 for Q
PC-; PEOE VSA+1; and Q VSA HYD, respectively, to compare the influence of each
descriptor on the PIC50 anticancer activity of pyrazole carbohydrazide derivatives.
As a result, we can create new compounds by making appropriate replacements that improve
the values of the descriptors Q PC- and Q VSA HYD, resulting in increased activity over the
base molecule that served as Template 32.
33
Table 27Valuesof descriptors for the new pyrazole carbohydrazide derivatives and their predicted
anticancer activity PIC50 (Breast cancer MDA-MB-231) calculated according to MDA-MB-231
mathematical model.
-
248.67508 105.47758 9,9750
4.7010002
15
34
2.5Ovarian Cancer A2780
In the model equation for this line, the descriptor SlogP_VSA5 increases anticancer
activity against ovarian cancer A2780, while the descriptors PEOE_VSA-1- and TPSA
contribute negatively on the activity. The t-test values for our descriptors are 2.232199341;
0.389341486 and 0.264721999 for TPSA; SlogP_VSA5 and PEOE_VSA-1, respectively.
Hence, we can design new compounds by adding appropriate substitutions that can improve
the descriptor values and thus increase the PIC50, the compound that served as Template for
substitution is compound 32.
35
Table 28Values of the descriptors for the new pyrazole carbohydrazide derivatives and their
predicted anticancer activity PIC50 (Ovarian cancer A2780) calculated according to A2780
mathematical model.
14
36
Based on the t-test to compare the relevance of each descriptor on PIC50, the t-test values for
diameter, PEOE VSA PNEG, Q VSA PNEG, and opr_nrot in the model are 9.930449469;
0.726955304; 0.697498886 and 7.576481643, respectively.
As a result, we may create additional compounds by making appropriate replacements to
increase the diameter descriptor's value; the compound utilized as a template is compound 5.
37
115.36006 143.62318 8 9,5478
14
12
CONCLUSION
Cancer is a non-communicable, chronic disease that is rapidly becoming a worldwide health
threat. According to recent evidence, noncommunicable diseases such as cancer are quickly
displacing communicable diseases. Despite the fact that much scientific study has been done
on cancer in recent decades, there are currently a number of innovative medications on the
market and several more in the development phase. Before entering clinical trials, many
methods and approaches are utilized to find chemical compounds and verify their affinity
activity against various targets. QSAR is a strategy for identifying and designing newer
medicines as well as predicting their physicochemical and biological properties. This tool can
help improve the drug's kinetic profile and lower toxicity. We constructed QSAR models
against six different forms of neoplasias in this study, including prostate cancer, ovarian
cancer, skin cancer (melanoma), renal cell carcinoma, leukemias, and stomach malignancies.
The major drugs employed in this investigation are novel Pyrazole derivatives. With pIC50
values of 5.2647, 5.3206, 5.2652, and 5.1415 M, the compounds 48, 54, 55, and 60
demonstrated remarkable cytotoxic action against prostate cancer (PC-3). With pIC50 values
of 6.7535, 6.5148, 6.3024, and 6.7368 M, the compounds 36, 41, 42, and 43 demonstrated
high cytotoxic action against skin cancer (B16F10). Compound 1 then shown strong cytotoxic
action against chronic myelogenous leukemia (K-562), with a pIC50 of 7.313μM Compounds
4, 5, 32, and 33 have significant cytotoxic action against MDA-MB-231, with pIC50 values of
6.3657, 5.8921, 7.0300, and 6.5565μM , respectively.The compounds 4, 19, 30 and 32
showed excellent anticancer activity against ovarian cancer (A2780) with pIC50 8.5720;
8.5720; 8.1494 and 8.6362 μM. Compounds 1, 5, 20 and 33 show high anticancer activity
against Renal cancer (ACHN) with pIC50 6,106; 6.4812; 5.8703 and 6.3643μM.
REFERENCES
38
[1].Rawla, P. 2019. Epidemiology of prostate cancer.World J. Onco. 10, 63.
[2]. Litwin, M.S., Tan, H.J. 2017. The diagnosis and treatment of prostate cancer: A Rev. Jama 317,
2532-2542.
[3]. Schadendorf, D., Van Akkooi, A.C., Berking, C., Griewank, K.G., Gutzmer, R., Hauschild, A.,
Ugurel, S. 2018. Melanoma. The Lancet 392, 971-984.
[4]. Kassahun, W., Tesfaye, G., Bimerew, L.G., Fufa, D., Adissu, W., Yemane, T. 2020. Prevalence
of Leukemia and Associated Factors among Patients with Abnormal Hematological Parameters in
Jimma Medical Center, Southwest Ethiopia: A Cross-Sectional Study. Adv. Hem. 2020.
[5]. Momenimovahed, Z., Tiznobaik, A., Taheri, S., Salehiniya, H. 2019. Ovarian cancer in the world:
epidemiology and risk factors.Intl. J. Women's Health 11, 287.
[6]. McMullen, M., Karakasis, K., Rottapel, R., Oza, A. M. 2021. Advances in ovarian cancer, from
biology to treatment. Nature Cancer 2, 6-8.
[7].Safiri, S., Kolahi, A. A., Mansournia, M. A., Almasi-Hashiani, A., Ashrafi-Asgarabad, A., Sullman, M.
J., Fitzmaurice, C. 2020. The burden of kidney cancer and its attributable risk factors in 195 countries
and territories, 1990–2017. Sc. Rpt. 10, 1-20.
[8]. Barata, P. C., Rini, B. I. 201). Treatment of renal cell carcinoma: status and future directions. CA:
A Cancer J. Clin. 67, 507-524.
[9] Machlowska, J., Baj, J., Sitarz, M., Maciejewski, R., Sitarz, R. 2020. Gastric cancer: epidemiology,
risk factors, classification, genomic characteristics, and treatment strategies.Intl. J. Mol. Sci. 21, 4012.
[10]. OSHI, S.S., Badgwell, B.D. 2021. Current treatment and recent progress in gastric cancer. CA:A
Cancer J. Clin. 71, 264-279.
[11]. Wang, T., Si, H., Chen, P., Zhang, K., Yao, X. 2008. QSAR models for the dermal penetration of
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons based on Gene Expression Programming. QSAR Combn. Sci. 27, 13-
921.
[12]. Akhtar, M. J., Khan, A. A., Ali, Z., Dewangan, R. P., Rafi, M., Hassan, M. Q., Yar, M. S. 2018.
Synthesis of stable benzimidazole derivatives bearing pyrazole as anticancer and EGFR receptor
inhibitors. Bioorg. Chem. 78, 158-169.
39