Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Introduction: Diabetic maculopathy is a leading retinal cause of blindness. This study was conducted using optical
coherence tomography angiography and noninvasive imaging modalities. Microaneurysms were evaluated for location,
flow, and adjacent retinal tissue changes to establish knowledge of possible vision-threatening features.
Methodology: This is a hospital-based, cross-sectional observational study. Eighteen patients with diabetic maculopathy
were included in the study. Fundus photo, red-free filter image, infrared images with shadowgrams, optical coherence
tomography cross sections, and optical coherence tomography angiography were analyzed. Mean, standard deviation,
odds ratio, and 95% confidence interval were used for statistical analysis, and p-value of <0.05 was considered statis-
tically significant where applicable.
Results: A total of 64 microaneurysms were evaluated. Forty-six (71.8%) microaneurysms were identifiable in
all imaging modalities. In total, 53 (82.8%) were high-flow microaneurysms and 11 (17.2%) were low-flow micro-
aneurysms. Thirty-eight of the high-flow microaneurysms (71.6% of the high-flow microaneurysms) were found
in the deep capillary plexus, while only 15 (28.4% of the high-flow microaneurysms) were found in the superficial
capillary plexus. Twenty-seven (71%) of the high-flow microaneurysms in deep capillary plexus were present in the
areas of retinal thickening (odds ratio: 4.5, 95% confidence interval: 1.26–16.0, p ¼ 0.02). A total of 11 micro-
aneurysms were classified as low-flow microaneurysms and identified using fundus photo, red-free filter image,
infrared images with shadowgrams, and optical coherence tomography—cross sections. They had a tendency
to be present in the areas of decreased capillary plexus density (odds ratio: 25.6, 95% confidence interval:
5.09–128.7, p ¼ 0.001).
Conclusion: Noninvasive imaging modalities combined with optical coherence tomography angiography can provide
valuable information regarding microaneurysms. Certain features such as location and flow may help in predicting
impending macular edema or ischemia.
Keywords
Diabetic retinopathy, tomography, optical coherence, macular edema, non-invasive, optical coherence tomography
angiography, microaneurysms, vision threatening, blindness, ischemia
Date received: 25 June 2019; accepted: 14 April 2020
1
Birat Eye Hospital, Biratnagar, Nepal
2
Tilganga Institute of Ophthalmology, Kathmandu, Nepal
3
Department of Ophthalmology, Nepalese Army Institute of Health
Introduction Sciences, Kathmandu, Nepal
4
Diabetic maculopathy is one of the leading retinal ASG Hospitals, Kathmandu, Nepal
causes of blindness.1,2 It occurs either due to the accu-
Corresponding author:
mulation of fluid secondary to leaking vessels or ische- Anadi Khatri, Department of Vitreo-Retina Services, Birat Eye Hospital,
mia due to sluggish blood flow or capillary nonperfusion Biratnagar 55613, Nepal..
near, around, or in the macular area. Email: anadikc@gmail.com
2 European Journal of Ophthalmology 0(0)
Microaneurysms (MAs) have established themselves choice if the pathology needs to be followed in a more
as the first clue for ophthalmologists and general physi- frequent basis.
cians to hint that the visibly evident diabetic retinopa- In such scenarios, whatever information that is avail-
thy (DR) has initiated.3–5 The process and the damage, able from the OCTA might be helpful as an alternative
however, actually begin long before these “retinal for diagnosis and management of such patients. With
lesions” become visible. In microscopic terms, these this in mind, this study was conducted using OCTA
lesions are the result of a continued insult to the and noninvasive imaging to evaluate the MAs of DR
pericytes of the retinal vasculature.6,7 with CSME in terms of their location, flow, and adja-
Pericytes mainly govern the retinal hemodynamics cent retinal tissue changes. By doing so, we aim to estab-
via two mechanisms. They provide the inner blood- lish a knowledge of possible vision-threatening OCTA
retinal barrier via tight junctions. They are also features of MAs in terms of edema and ischemia.
contractile in nature. The latter property is thought
to provide both the supportive and autoregulatory
Methodology
function of these unique cells.8
Due to continuous loss of these cells, the loss of tight This is a hospital-based, cross-sectional observational
junctions tends to make the vessel prone to leakage study conducted at the retina department of Birat Eye
and promote endothelial proliferation9 and result in Hospital, Biratnagar, Nepal. The study was approved
clinically significant macular edema (CSME).10 This by the local ethical committee and adheres with the
ultimately leads to beadings or outpunching which tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki. Both written
become clinically evident as MA. The blood flow in and oral consent were given by the patients. Patients
some of these MA also tends to become turbulent assessed between January and June 2019 were included
and sluggish in nature.11 This, on the other hand, in this study. No sample size calculations were made as
could lead to microvascular stasis, a decrease in perfu- this is an exploratory study.
sion and development of ischemia. Patients with diabetic maculopathy—clinically
The presence of MAs is thought to provide critical diagnosed as CSME who were contraindicated for
information regarding the course of the disease. FFA—were included in the study. Fundus photos
Various studies have been done regarding its distribu- (FPs), red-free filter images (RFIs), infrared images
tion, progression, turn over, shapes, and sizes to predict with shadowgrams (IRIS), optical coherence tomogra-
the prognosis.4,12–15 phy (OCT) cross sections, and OCTA were analyzed.
Various methods of visualizing the retinal vascular The eyes were then classified according to the early
system are currently available. They range from the treatment diabetic retinopathy study (ETDRS).
old yet gold standard—fundus fluorescein angiography Eyes with other retinal or choroidal vasculopathies,
(FFA)—to the more recent noninvasive technique such prior laser therapy, prior intravitreal injections, or
as optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA). media opacities were excluded. The sample was classi-
FFA can detect the smallest of MAs, leakages, and fied into four different levels as per ETDRS grading
nonperfusion. On the other hand, OCTA is a noninva- (Level: 20, 35,43, and 47). Mean, standard deviation,
sive method and also has the advantage that retina and odds ratio, and 95% confidence interval were used for
its vasculature can be visualized in sections or slabs. statistical analysis, and a p-value of <0.05 was consid-
However, as OCTA is dependent on the flow of ered statistically significant where applicable.
blood, areas of sluggish blood flow may not be prop-
erly visualized.12,16
Image acquisition and analysis
This has led to the MAs being classified as low-flow
microaneurysms (LF-MAs) or high-flow microaneur- FP, RFI, IRIS, and swept source (SS)-OCT cross sec-
ysms (HF-MAs).16 By concept, if the flow of the tions along with 3 3 mm OCTA images were obtained
MAs meets the threshold for detection and is registered using an SS-OCTA device (DRI Triton PLUS OCT,
by the OCTA, they are termed as high flow. Those Topcon, Tokyo, Japan). The images were segmented
MAs which are present in the FFA, fundus picture, automatically into superficial and deep retinal capillary
or other imaging modalities but fail up to show in plexi via IMAGEnetTM and OCTARATM (Topcon)
OCTA are termed as LF-MAs.12,14–16 software. FP and RFI images were analyzed first to
The debate on whether OCTA can surpass or locate the MAs and tagged. IRIS was used to detect
replace FFA continues.17 Despite FFA being the gold any missed MAs clinically. This was further confirmed,
standard, there are situations in which it cannot be and other similar artifacts such as blot hemorrhages
used due to the risk of allergies, anaphylaxis, or renal were excluded using OCT cross sections, retinal thick-
function status of the patient.18 It is also an impractical ness mapping, and B-scan from OCTA.
Khatri et al. 3
The image analysis conducted then included identify- Retinal capillary density measurements provided by
ing the location and nature of flow in the MAs. A cross the inbuilt software were used to identify ischemic
wire tracker was used to first identify the MAs using the areas. All locations were checked throughout the rasters
FP which would simultaneously correlate with the loca- of the macula to avoid false negative results by segmen-
tion in the OCTA superficial and deep layers, cross sec- tation errors. If MAs were detected in more than one
tions of the OCT, FP, RFI, and IRIS (Figure 1). capillary plexus, the HF signal in the uppermost layer
Superficial capillary plexus (SCP) slab was automatically where the signal was first noticed was regarded as the
differentiated by the inbuilt software and represented location to minimize projection artifacts.
the capillary network, which are present between the
internal limiting membrane and posterior most elements
Results
of the inner plexiform layer (IPL). Similarly, the deep
capillary plexus (DCP) slab was demarcated between the Thirty-four eyes of 18 patients with CSME were
posterior boundary of the SCP and the posterior most analyzed. We excluded four eyes due to artifacts.
retinal elements of the outer plexiform layer (OPL). Thirty eyes of 18 patients were eligible for evaluation.
MAs that were present in the FP, RFI, IRIS, OCT The demographics of these patients are summarized
cross sections and also showed up in the OCTA were in Table 1.
classified as the HF-MAs. Those which did not appear Seventy-four lesions were flagged from the FP, RFI,
on OCTA while showed up on other imaging modalities and IRIS. Seventeen of such lesions (23%) were exclud-
were classified as LF-MAs. The second step included ed as the corresponding spots were not found in the
analyzing the location of HF and LF-MAs. For HF- cross sections of the OCT as either hyper/hypo reflec-
MAs, a direct flagging of the MAs was done as they tive elements, not detected by OCTA and did not fall in
were clearly visible in the OCTA. LF-Mas were identi- the areas of retinal thickening.
fied with the help of FP, RFI, IRIS, and cross sections Similarly, there were 11 (15%) lesions which were
of OCT (Figure 1). present in the FP, RFI, and IRIS and also detected
These areas were evaluated for any leakages grossly by the cross sections of the OCT but not detected by
via OCT cross sections and retinal thickness map. the OCTA. These were presumed as LF-MAs that had
Figure 1. Image analysis of low-flow microaneurysm. A fundus photo with microaneurysms becomes more distinct with infrared
imaging and shadowgrams. The same area of these microaneurysms is evaluated on OCTA which fails to register a signal but still can
be detected when evaluated on an OCT cross section.
SCP: superficial capillary plexus; DCP: deep capillary plexus; OCT: optical coherence tomography; OCTA: optical coherence
tomography angiography.
4 European Journal of Ophthalmology 0(0)
Age (in years SD) 53.9 11.3 59.2 13.7 61.4 9.8 65.8 7.3
Gender (male) 3/5 2/3 2/5 3/5
Duration of diabetes (in years SD) 12.2 9.1 14.7 7.3 15.1 8.7 15.8 5.6
HbA1C (in gm% SD) 7.2 0.87 7.47 0.63 7.9 0.92 8.5 0.71
Number of eyes evaluated 8 6 8 8
SD: standard deviation.
HF-MA
SCP 2 þ 2* 3 þ 1* 4 3 12 þ 3* 53
DCP 3 6 þ 1* 8 þ 2* 17 34 þ 4*
LF-MA
SCP 1# 2# – 1# 4# 11
DCP – 3# 2# 2# 7#
HF-MA: high-flow microaneurysm; SCP: superficial capillary plexus; DCP: deep capillary plexus; LF-MA: low-flow microaneur-
ysm; OCTA: optical coherence tomography angiography.
The asterisk (*) in HF-MA represents the number of microaneurysms detected by OCTA but missed by other imaging modalities.
The hash (#) in the LF-MA represents the microaneurysms not detected by OCTA but detected with other imaging modalities.
Table 3. Microaneurysm detection by various modalities, their distribution along with their association with retinal thickening or
decreased capillary plexuses density.
Not detected
by OCTA
but via fundus Decreased
Detected photo/OCT/ capillary
by all infrared with Only detected Retinal Cystoid plexuses
Flow Location imaging shadow grams by OCTA thickening changes density
OCTA: optical coherence tomography angiography; HF-MA: high-flow microaneurysm; SCP: superficial capillary plexus; DCP: deep capillary plexus;
LF-MA: low-flow microaneurysm.
blood flows below the registering threshold of the found in the SCP. A total of 32 (60.3%) HF-MAs were
OCTA machine. OCTA was superior in identifying found to be in the area of retinal thickening (Figure 2)
seven (13%) of the MAs that were not flagged in the and 22 (34%) of them were associated with perilesional
FP, RFI, or IRIS. Four of such lesions were present in cystoid changes in the retina (Table 2).
the DCP and three in SCP (Table 2). Only one such Twenty-seven (71%) of the HF-MAs in DCP were
MA was present in the area of the thickened retina. present in the areas of retinal thickening (odds ratio:
These were included in the study (Table 3). 4.5, 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.26–16.0, p ¼ 0.02).
A total of 64 MAs were evaluated, only 46 (71.8%) Nineteen (50%) of such lesions in the DCP were direct-
of which were identifiable on all imaging modalities ly related to perilesional cystoid lesions (Figure 3).
(Table 2). Of the 64 MAs analyzed, 53 (82.8%) were In comparison to DCP, 15 MAs were found to be HF
HF-MAs and 11 (17.2%) were LF-MAs. Thirty-eight in SCP and only 5 of them were in the areas of retinal
of the HF-MAs (71.6% of the HF-MAs) were found in thickening. Only three of such lesions were directly relat-
the DCP, while only 15 (28.4% of the HF-MAs) were ed to perilesional cystoid changes (Table 3).
Khatri et al. 5
Figure 2. A patient with localized macular edema with hard exudates. Microaneurysms (arrows) were predominantly found in the
deep capillary plexuses in areas of thickened retina (area inside green boundary in thickness map).
SCP: superficial capillary plexus; DCP: deep capillary plexus; OR: outer retina; CCP: choriocapillary plexus.
Figure 3. Fundus photo, retinal thickness map, and optical coherence tomography (OCT) angiography along with denoting micro-
aneurysms in the DCP (arrows) in areas of thickened retina (area inside green boundary in thickness map). Note the paralesional
cystoid spaces in the cross sections of OCT cross section.
SCP: superficial capillary plexus; DCP: deep capillary plexus; OR: outer retina; CCP: choriocapillary plexus.
A total of 11 MAs were classified as LF-MAs and structures on OCT cross sections. They had a tendency
identified using FP, RFI, IRIS, and OCT—cross to be present in the areas of decreased capillary plexus
sections. More than half of these MAs were hypore- density (odds ratio: 25.6, 95% CI: 5.09–128.7,
flective and 63.3% were found in deeper retinal p ¼ 0.001) (Table 3) (Figure 4).
6 European Journal of Ophthalmology 0(0)
Figure 4. Decreased summated capillary plexus density in OCTA in areas of undetected microaneurysms (MAs). There are low-flow
microaneurysms (LF-MAs), and decrease in capillary density could denote ischemic changes. The fundus picture on right clearly shows
the image of the scanned macular area with many MAs which were not detected by OCTA.
macular edema. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2016; 57(9): QD Nguyen, LeHoang P, et al. (eds) The uveitis atlas.
OCT348–OCT355. New Delhi, India: Springer, 2016, pp. 1–7.
15. Rodrigues TM, Marques JP, Soares M, et al. Macular 19. Moore J, Bagley S, Ireland G, et al. Three dimensional
OCT-angiography parameters to predict the clinical stage analysis of microaneurysms in the human diabetic retina.
of nonproliferative diabetic retinopathy: an exploratory J Anat 1999; 194: 89–100.
analysis. Eye 2019; 33: 1240–1247. 20. Horii T, Murakami T, Nishijima K, et al. Optical coher-
16. Schreur V, Domanian A, Liefers B, et al. Morphological ence tomographic characteristics of microaneurysms in
and topographical appearance of microaneurysms on diabetic retinopathy. Am J Ophthalmol 2010; 150:
optical coherence tomography angiography. Br J 840–848.
Ophthalmol 2019; 103: 630–635. 21. Dubow M, Pinhas A, Shah N, et al. Classification
17. Garcia JMBB, Lima TT, Louzada RN, et al. Diabetic of human retinal microaneurysms using adaptive
macular ischemia diagnosis: comparison between optics scanning light ophthalmoscope fluorescein angi-
optical coherence tomography angiography and ography. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2014; 55(3):
fluorescein angiography. J Ophthalmol 2016; 2016: 1299–1309.
3989310. 22. Abramson DI. The microcirculation in diabetes. JAMA
18. Khochtali S, Khairallah-Ksiaa I and Ben Yahia S. 1979; 242(23): 2601–2602.
Normal fundus fluorescein angiography. In: V Gupta,