Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: The new understanding for the hydration mechanism of cement has been achieved based on the noncontact electrical resistivity
measurement. The cement hydration process is divided into dissolution, dynamic balance, setting, hardening, and hardening deceleration
stages according to the characteristic points on the electrical resistivity development curve 共t兲 − t and the differential curve d共t兲 / dt − t.
The microstructure analysis corresponding to each hydration stage is conducted with scanning electron microscope, x-ray diffraction,
differential thermal analysis, and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy techniques. This study provides the theoretical foundation for
understanding the relationship between setting behavior, hardening properties, and resistivity development.
DOI: 10.1061/共ASCE兲0899-1561共2009兲21:8共368兲
CE Database subject headings: Hydration; Microstructures; Electrical resistivity; Measurement; Cement.
Mixing M L P1 P2
cement paste was mixed for 4 min and cast in a ring-shaped mold 0 tm tL tp1 t p2 hydration time
to measure the electrical resistivity with time. The measurements Setting time
were taken at intervals of 1 min for a 24 h period, under an am- Electrical resistivity response (ASTM C191)
bient temperature of 20⫾ 2 ° C. The hydrated cement samples tm tL t p1 t p2
initial final
t ini t fin
were prepared by stopping hydration using acetone at designated
ages and the samples were then dried in a vacuum oven for 24 h 0.73h 3.5h 6.7h 12.8h 3.75h 6.28h
for microstructure investigations.
Each sample for Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy
共FTIR兲 spectral observation was ground with potassium bromide
in an agate mortar to produce a homogeneous mixture and a thin 2
slice of the mixture was made by a pressing procedure. The in-
frared spectra were recorded using a FTS 6000 spectrometer 共Bio-
Rad, Calif.兲 in the range of 400– 4000 cm−1. M
L
Experimental Results 0 2 4 6
Characteristic Points on the Electrical Resistivity (Point L is the transition point from linear to curved shape)
Development Curves
Fig. 2. Electrical resistivity development and the rate in resistivity of
A typical electrical resistivity development curve with time the cement paste during 24 h
关 共t兲 − t兴 and its differential curve 关d共t兲 / dt − t兴, which represents
the rate of resistivity development, are shown in Fig. 2. The mini-
mum point M and the level point L, which is in the end of a crystal calcium hydroxide 共CH兲 became significant with time due
relatively flat region after Point M, are marked on the curve to the increase of CH content in the hydrated samples.
共t兲 − t. Peak Points P1 and P2 are marked on the curve The DTA was performed for characterization of the hydration
d共t兲 / dt − t. The times at which the characteristic points occurred products and the quantification of CH in the samples, as shown in
and the paste setting time are listed in the table in Fig. 2. Accord- Fig. 4. The existence of four endothermic peaks was shown in the
ing to the characteristic points, the hydration process is divided detected temperature range. Peaks 1 and 2, located at 85 and
into five stages: dissolution, dynamic balance, setting, hardening, 128° C, mainly characterize gypsum. The shift of the first peak
and hardening deceleration. from 85° C to around 92° C and the reduced intensity of the sec-
ond peak with hydration time indicate that gypsum was consumed
and the AFt formation was at the expense of the gypsum peaks.
Microstructure Observations
The third peak observed at about 165° C represents the decompo-
To investigate the cement hydration mechanism, the microstruc- sition of AFm in the samples hydrated for 12.8 and 24 h. The
ture investigations of the hydrated samples for the designated fourth peak at 465– 470° C is due to the CH. The shifts of the CH
ages, corresponding to the characteristic point occurrences, have peaks to the right with an increase in the ages shows that the CH
been conducted using a scanning electron microscope 共SEM兲 and crystalline becomes denser and larger and an increase in tempera-
X-ray diffraction 共XRD兲, differential thermal analysis 共DTA兲, and ture was needed for the decomposition of the CH crystalline. The
FTIR; the results are shown in Figs. 3–5, respectively. index of the formed CH content, which was estimated by deter-
The XRD patterns in Fig. 3 show the presence of crystalline mining the endothermic area of the CH peaks as an indication of
substances in anhydrous cement and in the hydrated samples at the hydration product contents, is marked in Fig. 4.
the specified ages. At a very early age of hydration, the ettringite The FTIR spectra of the samples at the ages, as shown in Fig.
共AFt兲 phase started to form with the consumption of sulfate, 5, provide information on chemical bonding. CH gives a peak at
which was detected in the sample at 0.73 h. The intensity of the 3643 cm−1. AFt has a strong peak at 3422 cm−1 and a weaker one
AFt peaks decreased and monosulfate 共AFm兲 appeared, as shown at 3545 cm−1, marked as A in Fig. 5. AFm has bands at 3260,
in the hydrated sample for 12.8 h in comparison with that in the 3333, 3402, 3458, and 3527 cm−1, which were separated from a
6.7 h sample. The amorphous hydrates C–S–H cannot be detected broadband of 3200– 3600 cm−1; the broadband was centered at
by the XRD technique. The relative density of the peaks of the 3402 cm−1, marked as B in Fig. 5.
¦ ¤H = 9 . 5 5 J / g
a n h y d ro u s
cem ent
¦ ¤H = 1 1 . 9 4 J / g
0 .7 3 h
¦ ¤H = 1 4 . 5 2 J / g
3h
¦ ¤H = 2 2 . 7 6 J / g
6 .7 h
¦ ¤H = 7 6 .9 8 J / g
1 2 .8 h
A F m fo rm e d
g y p su m co n su m ed ¦ ¤H = 1 0 2 . 4 1 J / g
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by University of Hong Kong on 06/04/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
24h
Fig. 4. DTA results of cement and the hydrated pastes at the ages of
0.73, 3, 6.7, 12.8, and 24 h
Discussions
Fig. 5. FTIR spectra of anhydrous cement and the hydrated samples at the ages of 0.73, 3, 6.7, 12.8, 24 h
formed directly on the surface of the cement grains and was ob- The shift of the band 4 SiO4 during 0.73 h indicates C3S
served in the SEM picture, as shown in Fig. 3共b兲. The picture hydration occurred as mentioned earlier. It has been reported that
taken at a magnification of 5,000 shows that the AFt crystals are a gelatinous layer on the surface of the cement was observed in
not evenly distributed on the cement surface; one possibility is the undried specimen soon after mixing by using an environmen-
that the AFt formed just on the surface of C3A. tal cell and was identified as an amorphous colloidal product
When a certain supersaturation—with respect to CH—is 共Ménétrier et al. 1979; Jennings and Pratt 1980兲.
reached, the CH precipitates from the solution, as detected by the Therefore, during this period, the resistivity decrease implies
DTA technique in the hydrated sample for 0.73 h, and is shown in that the process is dominated by the ion dissolution and identified
Fig. 4. The DTA results show that the index of the CH 共peak 4兲 as the dissolution stage. There are also chemical reaction occur-
content in the hydrated sample for 0.73 h 共⌬H = 11.94 J / g兲 is rences. The formation of hydration products AFt, a gelatinous
larger than that of the CH formed from free lime by chemisorbed substance and CH consumed ions in the solution and also caused
water in anhydrous cement 共⌬H = 9.55 J / g兲 during storage, indi- a decreasing trend in the porosity. This led to the resistivity in-
cating that new CH is formed during the period. crease from point M and ended the dissolution stage.
3 共SiO4兲 peak shift from 922 to 925, which confirms C–S–H shown in Eqs. 共1兲 and 共2兲. The reaction in Eq. 共1兲 共Abo El-Enein
formation during this period. et al. 1995兲 leads to an increasing trend in ion concentration due
to the releasing of SO42− and Ca2+ and a decreasing trend in the
solid volume fraction due to phase AFm possessing a higher den-
Setting Stage „III… sity than phase AFt. The reaction in Eq. 共2兲 共Hewlett 1998兲 leads
From point L 共3.5 h兲 to point P1 共6.7 h兲, the resistivity signifi- to the latter effect only. No matter which way takes place, the
cantly increases, indicating a rapid change in the microstructure consequence is that there is a decreasing trend in resistivity. How-
during this period. It can be seen in the sample hydrated for 6.7 h, ever, the C3S hydration continuously progresses and the forma-
as shown in Fig. 3共d兲, that a great amount of C–S–H is formed in tions of hydrates C–S–H largely increase the solid phase in the
bundles compared with 3 h, and the cement particles are sur- hydration system, which compensates the resistivity decreasing
rounded by the C–S–H bundles. The solid phases in the hydration trend caused by the phase transformation. The phase transforma-
system are closely connected to each other, resulting in a perco- tion slows down the rate of resistivity development, however, it
lation of the solid phase, i.e., a setting in process. The initial does not change the increasing trend of the resistivity. This cor-
setting time and the final setting time of the paste are 3.75 and responds to the resistivity increase at a lowered rate 关d共t兲 / dt兴.
6.28 h, respectively, obtained by a Vicat needle penetration. The When the balance between the phase transformation and AFt for-
inital setting time is close to the end of the dynamic balance mation process is achieved—by releasing and consuming ions of
period, and the final setting time is close to the time of the point Ca2+ and SO42−,—the factors leading to the d共t兲 / dt decrease
P1 occurrence. Thus this period is identified as the setting stage. become minor or disappear. Eventually, a larger increase in
The XRD result at 6.7 h shows a significant increase of the CH C–S–H and the other hydrate contents dominates the resistivity
peak intensity. development and the rate 关d共t兲 / dt兴 increases again
Therefore, the setting of cement paste appears to be a conse- C3A · 3CaSO4 · 32H2O共AFt兲 → C3A · CaSO4 · 12H2O共AFm兲
quence of C3S hydration and the formation of sufficient C–S–H
and CH hydrates. The C3S hydration dominates the setting period + 2CaSO4 共1兲
and the C–S–H formations lead to normal cement paste set.
C3A · 3CaSO4 · 32H2O共AFt兲 + 2C3A + 4H2O
Hardening Stage „IV… → C3A · CaSO4 · 12H2O共AFm兲 共2兲
From Point P1 共6.7 h兲 to Point P2 共12.8 h兲, the resistivity con- When gypsum is insufficient, there is also a trend for forming
tinuously increases at a temporarily reduced rate and then the rate hexagonal plate C4AH19, as shown in Fig. 3共e兲 共Hewlett. 1998兲,
increases again. When the hydration proceeds to 12.8 h, gypsum which belongs to the broad group of AFm. This process leads to a
a decreasing rate. The decreasing rate d共t兲 / dt describes a slow- the Hong Kong Research Grant Council under 616008 is grate-
down in the chemical reaction rate, and the process is controlled fully acknowledged.
by ion diffusion, with the thickness of the hydrates on the cement
particle surface 共Mindess et al. 2003兲.
The hydration proceeds up to the age of 24 h, shown in Fig.
3共f兲, and the C–S–H bundles and long rods of AFt intersect each References
other to form solid networking for strength gain. Meanwhile the
free water space decreases, porosity decreases, and tortuosity in- Abo El-Enein, S. A., et al. 共1995兲. “Electrical resistivity of concrete con-
creases for conduction paths. Hydration product contents increase taining silica fume.” Cem. Concr. Res., 25共8兲, 1615–1620.
Christensen, B. J., et al. 共1994兲. “Impedance spectroscopy of hydrating
with the hydration time can also be represented by the increase in
cement-based materials: Measurement, interpretation, and applica-
CH hydrate content as the endothermic heat of CH in Fig. 4. The
tion.” J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 77共11兲, 2789–2804.
stages of the hydration process are summarized in Table 1. Gartner, E. M., Young, E. M., Damidot, D. A., and Jawed, I. 共2002兲.
From a macro-point-of-view, fresh concrete changes from the “Hydration of Portland cement.” Structure and performance of ce-
fluid to the solid state. From the micro-point-of-view, there are a ments, J. Bensted and P. Barnes, eds., Spon Press, London, 83–84.
series of the physical and chemical reactions occurring and the Gu, P., Xie, P., and Fu, Y. 共1985兲. “Microstructural characterization of
consequence leads to microstructure formation. Microstructure cementitious materials: Conductivity and impedance methods.” Mate-
formation and concrete property time-dependence are essentially rials science of concrete IV, J. Skalny and S. Mindess, eds., American
correlated. Electrical resistivity can dynamically record the mi- Ceramics Society, Cincinnati, 94–124.
crostructure changing process and related concrete properties. Hewlett, P. C. 共1998兲. Lea’s chemistry of cement and concrete, 4th Ed.,
Therefore, the electrical resistivity response 共t兲 can provide an Arnold, London.
indication of setting behavior and strength development as a non- Jennings, H. M., and Pratt, P. L. 共1980兲. “On the reactions leading to
destructive test method. calcium silicate hydrate, calcium hydroxide and ettingite during the
hydration of cement.” Proc., 7th Int. Congress on the Chemistry of
Cement, Vol. II, Editions Septima, Paris, II, 141–146.
Conclusions Li, Z., Wei, X., and Li, W. 共2003兲, “Preliminary interpretation of Portland
cement hydration process using resistivity measurements.” ACI Mater.
J., 100共3兲, 253–257.
The following conclusions can be drawn from the current study:
McCarter, W. J., Chrisp, T. M., Starrs, G., and Blewett, J. 共2003兲. “Char-
1. The hydration process is reclassified as dissolution, dynamic acterization and monitoring of cement-based systems using intrinsic
balance, setting, hardening, and hardening deceleration electrical property measurements.” Cem. Concr. Res., 33共2兲, 197–206.
stages based on the electrical resistivity measurement. McCarter, W. J., Whittington, H. W., and Forde, M. C. 共1981兲. “The
2. During the dissolution period, the ion dissolving process conduction of electricity through concrete.” Mag. Concrete Res.,
dominates the resistivity development. The formation of AFt, 33共114兲, 48–60.
CH, and a gelatinous substance leads to an increase in resis- Ménétrier, D., Jawed, I., Sun, T. S., and Skalny, J. 共1979兲. “ESCA and
tivity and an end to the dissolution stage. SEM studies on early C3S hydration.” Cem. Concr. Res., l9共4兲, 473–
3. The slight increase of the resistivity development marks a 482.
competition process between the ion dissolving and the solid Mindess, S., Young, J. F., and Darwin, D. 共2003兲. Concrete, 2nd Ed.,
phase nucleation in the hydration system. The significant in- Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle River, N.J.
crease of the resistivity signals the start of setting the stage Tashiro, C., Ikeda, K., and Inome, Y. 共1994兲. “Evaluation of pozzolanic
activity by the electric resistance measurement method.” Cem. Concr.
due to the hydration products reaching an intersection.
Res., 24共6兲, 1133–1139.
3. The formation of C–S–H products dominates the set stage,
Taylor, H. F. W. 共1997兲. Cement chemistry, 2nd Ed., Telford, London.
and the first peak on the differential the curve approximately
Taylor, H. F. W., Wei, X., and Li, Z. 共2005兲. “Study on hydration of
identifies the final setting occurrence. It has practical signifi- Portland cement with fly ash using electrical measurement.” Mater.
cance for separating setting behavior from a continuous hy- Struct., 38共277兲, 411–417.
dration process and identifying the setting stage in obtaining Taylor, M. A., and Arulanadan, K. 共1974兲. “Relationships between elec-
information of engineering parameters, such as setting time trical and physical properties of cement pastes.” Cem. Concr. Res.,
and strength gain. 4共6兲, 881–897.