Professional Documents
Culture Documents
日本建築学会計画系論文集 第85巻 第777号, 2437-2445,2020年11月
【カテゴリーⅢ】 J. Archit. Plann., AIJ, Vol. 85 No. 777, 2437-2445, Nov., 2020
DOI https://doi.org/10.3130/aija.85.2437
ジャンウーゴ・ポレゼッロの設計思想とアルド・ロッシとの “ 円柱論争 ”
ジャンウーゴ・ポレゼッロの設計思想とアルド・ロッシとの“円柱論争”
-「ポレゼッロ - ロッシ」の青春時代の協働とテンデンツァ運動への理論的寄与-
—「ポレゼッロ-ロッシ」の青春時代の協働とテンデンツァ運動への理論的寄与—
—「ポレゼッロ-ロッシ」の青春時代の協働とテンデンツァ運動への理論的寄与—
GIANUGOPOLESELLOʼS
GIANUGO
GIANUGO POLESELLO’S
POLESELLO’S ARCHITECTURALIDEOLOGY
ARCHITECTURAL
ARCHITECTURAL IDEOLOGYAND
IDEOLOGY AND“COLUMN
AND “COLUMNDEBATE”
“COLUMN DEBATE” WITH
DEBATE” WITH ALDO
WITH ALDO ROSSI
ALDO ROSSI
ROSSI
-- Collaboration
Collaboration in
in Architect
Architect Adolescence
Adolescence of
of Polesello-Rossi
Polesello-Rossi for
for Theoretical
Theoretical Contribution
Contribution to La Tendenza
to La Tendenza--
- Collaboration in architect adolescence of Polesello-Rossi for theoretical contribution to La Tendenza -
片片桐 桐悠悠自自*1
片桐 悠自 *
*
Yuji
Yuji KATAGIRI
KATAGIRI
Yuji KATAGIRI
Gianugo Polesello
Gianugo Polesello was
was one
one of
of the
the oldest
oldest partners
partners of
of Aldo
Aldo Rossi.
Rossi. They
They collaborated
collaborated each
each other
other in
in early
early 1960s,
1960s, including
including Resistance
Resistance
Monument in
Monument in Cuneo
Cuneo and Centro Direzionale
and Centro Direzionale di
di Torino
Torino in
in 1962.
1962. Published
Published one
one year
year after
after Rossi
Rossi had
had died
died in
in 1997,
1997, Polesello’s
Polesello’s memorial
memorial
monograph testified their common interest in Akira Kurosawa, Stalinist Architecture, De Chirico, Wittgenstein, and Raymond
monograph testified their common interest in Akira Kurosawa, Stalinist Architecture, De Chirico, Wittgenstein, and Raymond Roussel, Roussel,
who urged
who urged them
them to
to use
use metaphor
metaphor in
in designing
designing architecture.
architecture. This
This study
study focused
focused on
on the
the “column
“column debate”
debate” between
between Polesello
Polesello and
and Rossi,
Rossi, and
and
revealed their mutual influence and the contribution of the their adolescence in early 1960s to the origin of La Tendenza
revealed their mutual influence and the contribution of the their adolescence in early 1960s to the origin of La Tendenza..
Keywords :: Gianugo
Keywords Gianugo Polesello,
Polesello, Aldo
Aldo Rossi,
Rossi, Architectural
Architectural Design,
Design, “Column
“Column Debate”,
Debate”, Collaboration,
Collaboration, La
La Tendenza.
Tendenza.
ジャンウーゴ・ポレゼッロ, アルド・ロッシ,
ジャンウーゴ・ポレゼッロ, アルド・ロッシ, 建築設計,“円柱論争”,
建築設計,“円柱論争”, 協働, 協働, テンデンツァ運動.
テンデンツァ運動.
·
· IUAV =
IUAV =DDƶƶƅ
ƅ= = 996 6bb
¨
¨g
g§§j
j¡¡
(Ignazio
(Ignazio
¯ɚĦŀDŕŢ=ŨĴǩǗ]ĈP6`¡§£u(Aldo ROSSI
¯ɚĦŀDŕŢ=ŨĴǩǗ]ĈP6`¡§£u(Aldo ROSSI GARDELLA 1905-1999)
GARDELLA 1905-1999) #
#VVG
Gvv
zz
§
§ss
¨¨
(Giuseppe
(Giuseppe
1931-1997)EƇċǩĴ>/<E 1974
1931-1997)EƇċǩĴ>/<E 1974 ƊÈ̷¦ea`ƔʑŕŢ
ƊÈ̷¦ea`ƔʑŕŢ SAMONÀ 1898
SAMONÀ 1898 -- 1983)DĄDžDV!@Ɯ=ìĨ˩˥]ˎ9<
1983)DĄDžDV!@Ɯ=ìĨ˩˥]ˎ9< 6
6
(IUAV)ADŽŹ/< 6%1997
(IUAV)ADŽŹ/< Ɗ 99 Ȁ
6%1997 Ɗ Ȁ 44 ǵA¾̗¹Ǩ=Ƴ̘/
ǵA¾̗¹Ǩ=Ƴ̘/ ĻƺAVZF¢z£>£uE1958-59 Ɗ͈8U!?#
ĻƺAVZF¢z£>£uE1958-59 Ɗ͈8U!?#
1 1998 Ɗ 10 Ȁ 19, 20
6Ĩå]ƸN̘ĚD 1 ƊƤD 1998 Ɗ 10 Ȁ 19,
6Ĩå]ƸN̘ĚD ƊƤD 20 ǵAv¥d
ǵAv¥d » %ŕŢ]ĒȘ1Y$/@
» %ŕŢ]ĒȘ1Y$/@ $D>&AɯXħ $D>&AɯXħ ȵ ȵ
1960 Ɗ,
1960 Ɗ,
POLESELLO 1930-2007)E̒Ƹu¥v
¨r§¢z£(Gianugo POLESELLO
¨r§¢z£(Gianugo 1930-2007)E̒Ƹu¥v [A¡¨i§¨}(Luca MEDA
[A¡¨i§¨}(Luca MEDA 1936-1998)>
1936-1998)> 33 ĩ=Studio di
ĩ=Studio di
d]̳á/6+Du¥vdE IUAV
d]̳á/6+Du¥vdE IUAV =ƔʑȜǀŢq¨w[il
=ƔʑȜǀŢq¨w[il Architettura (SDA)
Architettura (SDA) ]˩ʆ/< Y
ȵ
ȵ
]˩ʆ/< Y
Dottorato di
Dottorato di Ricerca
Ricerca in
in Composizione
Composizione Architettonica]DǩǗ]̰ƊĈP
Architettonica]DǩǗ]̰ƊĈP
6¢z£]q¨a¨|¨>/<ĝÀ§Ĩå=96i¡
6¢z£]q¨a¨|¨>/<ĝÀ§Ĩå=96i¡
AYMONINO 1926-2010)S¡~`¨§y
£§`b¨(Carlo AYMONINO
£§`b¨(Carlo 1926-2010)S¡~`¨§y
¨(Luciano SEMERANI 1933-)DÄ1968
¨(Luciano SEMERANI 1933-)DÄ1968 Ɗ$W 1972 ƊM=
Ɗ$W 1972 ƊM=
žɼŕŢ=D£uDĄDž#VGēãʸ=96`¥h§
žɼŕŢ=D£uDĄDž#VGēãʸ=96`¥h§
wa£¨ (Antonio MONESTIROLI
wa£¨ (Antonio MONESTIROLI 1940-2019)
1940-2019) ȵ
ȵ
W¥
W¥
La Tendenza
¥_̜ć(La
¥_̜ć( Tendenza)D̵×ʸ%̾M96
)D̵×ʸ%̾M96
+Du¥vdDïŬE5
+Du¥vdDïŬE5 ƊƤA ƊƤACare Archietetture͜˟
Care Archietetture ͜˟
ƽ@YƔʑ68͝D|b¡=̒Ƹǽʓ%ôɊ-Zu¥vd
ƽ@YƔʑ68͝D|b¡=̒Ƹǽʓ%ôɊ-Zu¥vd
˺ɀ]ǬŠč/6ò͋Dn#VGƎǬ]¢z£%ǎ
˺ɀ]ǬŠč/6ò͋Dn#VGƎǬ]¢z£%ǎ
ƛ/
ƛ /6 6 + +DDĻ
ĻƺƺE “Ab initio,
E “Ab initio, indagatio,
indagatio, initiorum;
initiorum; ricordi
ricordi ee
confessioni”(ǿø$WõȈD̳Ŝ͢Ļƺ>Įɠ,
confessioni”(ǿø$WõȈD̳Ŝ͢Ļƺ>Įɠ, 2003) ȵ >͌ 2003) ȵ
>͌
1960 ƊÆø͋D£u#VG¥¥
ƊÆƤđ$WD 1960
-Z1950 ƊÆƤđ$WD
-Z1950 ƊÆø͋D£u#VG¥¥ Fig.1 Gianugo
Fig.1 Gianugo POLESELLO,
POLESELLO, AldoAldo ROSSI,
ROSSI, and
and Luca
Luca MEDA,
MEDA, Centro
Centro
_̜ćDɒ˸ɡ͗ǷȂ]ɯȲǭ>/<̎Ɗɬɥ-Z<
_̜ćDɒ˸ɡ͗ǷȂ]ɯȲǭ>/<̎Ɗɬɥ-Z< Y
ȵ
Yȵ
Direzionale di Torino ,1962, also see Casabella Continuità (278).
Direzionale di Torino ,1962, also see Casabella Continuità (278).
¢z£E1964
¢z£E1964 Ɗ$W IUAV DƔʑ˩˥§ľŢDǩťAɬÊ
Ɗ$W IUAV DƔʑ˩˥§ľŢDǩťAɬÊ
/̖³b| `ŀËD˾Ĵ(1983-87)]ʠ<30
/̖³b| `ŀËD˾Ĵ(1983-87)]ʠ<30 ƊA\6X IUAV
ƊA\6X IUAV £uEŕŢ]ĒȘ/6 1959 Ɗ$Wyn¨DĺȬ]
£uEŕŢ]ĒȘ/6 1959 Ɗ$Wyn¨DĺȬ]
=ǩ͆]>9< 6ɐłD d §¦ea`§v¨ `
=ǩ͆]>9< 6ɐłD d §¦ea`§v¨ ` ˩˥1Y 1965 ƊD̴Av¡v§nu(Giorgio
˩˥1Y 1965 GRASSI
ƊD̴Av¡v§nu(Giorgio GRASSI
di
Žd¨ạ̎Diwah¥w§a§w¨}(Castions di
Žd¨ạ̎Diwah¥w§a§w¨}(Castions 1933-)]ŜP>/<ȝ@Àɋ>ìĨ˩˥]ˎ96ɌA¢
1933-)]ŜP>/<ȝ@Àɋ>ìĨ˩˥]ˎ96ɌA¢
Strada)=ɔMZd¨a>¦ea`]̆ɄA˩˥ȷć]ˎ
Strada)=ɔMZd¨a>¦ea`]̆ɄA˩˥ȷć]ˎ z£¨}>D 33 ĩDēãÓij>/<ɯWZY D~e
z£¨}>D ĩDēãÓij>/<ɯWZY D~e
96Ɣʑū=Y1956 ƊA
96Ɣʑū=Y1956 IUAV =ŢÏ]ğƥ/ĒȘƤ$W
ƊA IUAV =ŢÏ]ğƥ/ĒȘƤ$W Direzionale di
¥£§a¢ah
¨¢(Centro Direzionale
¥£§a¢ah
¨¢(Centro di Torino,
Torino, 1962,
1962, Ȭ
Ȭ
*1
東京理科大学理工学部建築学科 助教・博士
*Ȇ¿ɒɼŕŢɒžŢ̤ƔʑŢɼ Ąǩ§ĕŐ͜ž͝(工学) Assist. Prof.,Professor,
Assistant Dept. of Architecture,
Department Faculty of Science Faculty
of Architecture,
Architecture, and Technology, Tokyo
of Science
Science and University
Technology,of
*Ȇ¿ɒɼŕŢɒžŢ̤ƔʑŢɼ Ąǩ§ĕŐ͜ž͝ Assistant
Science, Professor, Department
Ph.D. of Faculty of and Technology,
Tokyo University of Science, Ph.D.
Tokyo University of Science, Ph.D.
─ 2437 ─
計画系 777 号 4校
─ 2438 ─
計画系 777 号 4校
─ 2439 ─
計画系 777 号 4校
µ³]v"qb
4R.6"dÁC)LRA½%"³¢
¢z£D£u>DēãE1985 ƊA Rizzoli ɷVXôɊ-
Z6£uǿøDêÓij̾ Aldo Rossi: Buildings and Project A̍3W
Z6˥əD!81960-1962 ƊDȂ̴A˩˥-Z6˥ 6 É%˰ƛ1
Y ȵ
5ZWEmhD˨Ʊɳ CD(1962)DÄ
D_ ¨̗XDñ̳ɞ͜1960 Ɗ,[, ¥~ew
q§¥¨ [Francesco TENTORI]>Qēã, Fig.3͝fw
`b¢wDv¨ɷwibwm¢b¨(1960, ¦a¨q§v Fig.4 Ludovico QUARONI, et al, The Project for Barene di
w¢a[Vico MAGISTRETTI]>Qēã)i¢h[Caleppio] S.Giulinano, Venezia-Mestre,1959.
DąãʸÐţ(1961)_j¨Di¥ ¨m(1962)
=X 2ZQŧɐ/< @ £uAV9<ǝ$Z6>ʷ"WZY̕˜ľ(Fig.3)D³ŗAE
D_ ¨̗XDñ̳ɞ(Fig.3)=D¢z£> ̳$Z6ðƘɎDƉͅ]Q:Ɣɋ%̗XßDƔɋʳ>q¥vu
¥¨ >DēãA: <£uE 1969 Ɗ 12 Ȁ 2 ǵDʷŰ= ¥]@/< YFig.3 DſDžAEŘD̤õAðƜD̲0WZ6ƍ
─ 2440 ─
計画系 777 号 4校
®m¼m¬VTaSY³¢"rÁ@LB CDDDZƜDƍŌ=EŔ̴şȚDz˩§̛LjŌ%˩Ŧ-
CDD˩˥A# <ơWDn¡¨E´¬ÞªȆ Zŕˍ-ÀȪ%ƫ˘>1Y£n]ʃșɡAğXéZ<
¿˥ə 1960Dćʫ˥əD˱ʝ(Fig.5)]ěɇ/6ȵ 6+>%Í"Y1960 ƊÆø͋AşȚDz˩>/<D£nAğ
Xʟ^= YDE˂İȼ +!/6£n]Q:Ɣʑ˩˥I
DğXʟNEŧɐ-Z@$96r¡ŌDmdw˥ə
_j¨Di¥ ¨m(1962, Fig.7)=QĞƦ-ZY°D
YǮͅŃAǮͅAņM9< YɑÑ%ɌƩɡ@˥ə=Y
Fig.6 Gianugo POLESELLO, Aldo ROSSI, and Luca MEDA, Centro Fig.7 Gianugo POLESELLO, Aldo ROSSI, Country Club in Fagagna,
Direzionale di Torino ,1962. 1962.
─ 2441 ─
計画系 777 号 4校
a~Dƃƌ˃(1968)=¢z£Ef¥
¨¢b| O<5"g±Á"¨t¤r¤¸¦
`͑(1988)=ñƐđɑƜ¨¡]ɖ 6+DƜƿ˘ʚE¢ ɻ̟E+D+>A̵/<ɰ Ǭ̗]ˎ96ɻD̈́́>`¡
z£>£uA# <ìȁ-Z< 6> "Y $WD̏ʍ7ơE͉ĿAMY=̮Ņ[calchi]DV!AņM9<
YV!@ (:$Df¢¥]ñǞȑ>/<ȦĤD³Aŵ
g·Xqb"ª(% é/6 >˴96ơ%ʮX̏/6LJù§µ˘@˸ɄEơAVZ
g &s"^¡$"FN9<O"i FȬDV!@QD=YƗɖ]ˎ!̽EÀ[si]Ĕȿ]ƮZ
£uE CD(1962)È̷¢z£>Dēã%@$9 < Y>ĨǹAʲ/ ˤˊM6Eawm¨¡]VXɒˢĢʽA
6+>]ȧƱ%9< 6%¢z£DĻƺAVZF±ʸDē 1Y̩˘@ˤˊ]Ôɖ/<#X5ZǨAÔɖE@A$IDɦǙ
ãE 1964 Ɗȵ
Aʞ\X]Į*6V!=Yȵ +DēãDʞɅ ɡ @ ̵ Ǫ - ȡ ʽ = X + + $ W Ȝ ǀ D @ $ = [l’uso è
A̵/<E¢z£DĻƺ=E9&X>Ęļ%Y>̑JW «direttamente fuzionale a», così nelle composizioni]͜Ɣʑ%͝Ģʽ>
ZY¢z£E£uDģƑ]˩)6ðȌ]ɖ 6̙Ɯ]LJ @XƲʷ=&YD7ȵ
ù/<ǽʒ]̓XðȌ˸¸DV!@QD%̆+96 £uDðȌEŊŏ]ɖ Y+>=˘ʚ-ǯɉ[pezzi]>/<
£uÄ́́Dǽʒ]ǽ 6+>]Ʋ ô/6ŧD>+[ơ ˘ʚS̤õ%êÑ$WöX̀-ZYđFeauxɡ@Ŋŏ
AV9<@-Z6ðȌDÔɖAų/<7 IDǑXAȦĤïŬ]ǷưAM>\3YƼľ%96> "Y
ƛǹɻ7)%ơ]ɒˢ/< 6/ơDİDZAʆ9< 67 +ZEơ%ƔʑA: <Ò]ʷ"< YD$ɻAɒˢ-3Y!
%ɻDðȌEǍ́ɡ@ðȌ[la mia colonna era una collona astratta]7 "=ǿQŕ&@ǩ˧796ƔʑEơA>9<̝ĚA@-Z6
96D=Xbh`Ɩ=Qq ¥Ɩ=Q@(h¨}¨]Ǔ $Q/(EûɖĢʽ@QD=ņPWZ6©ʁDƀŕ@`¨ib
6@ ȦĤD³AÏʰ;)Ģʽ@QD=E@ D75ZEȄ̅ ¦[grande archivio]>/<ɶɐ/< YD=XM65+=ûɖ
ɡAE¨¡wÙĥDV!@QD=ȦĤɡ@ǹÆĐõ$Wõ̀- Ģʽ@QDD!8AƔʑE@-ZɞǷ-ZǞȑ-ZYJ&=
Z6QD=9<K/ Ƽİ˸ɡAE5Dɐÿ[sua presenza]7) 96`¡§£uEƔʑE5DV!@QD=@(<E@W
=9<K/ ðȌ>/<́ƩĢʽ@QD7%[Era denotabile @ >ʷ"< 6ȵ
come colonna]5ZEȮ/<ƔʑĤD@$DðȌ=E@ Ɣʑõ̪ÈŒDÀ%ðȌ]ɒˢ1Y̽AĔ@Yðʌ>/
/$/@%W`¡§£uEģƑDYðȌ[colonne con <VXEðʌ͞ģƑDDZ%\$XS1 +Dðʌ͞ģƑ
base]]Ó96ģƑE1@\8ðȌ]ǽ(>&A`im DȦĤɡ-ʣəɡb¨vEƔʑõ̪ŒDÀAVXĆȉɡAÌ̟
@au ¥AV9<®"WZ<&6QD=XÔɖ/ŧɐ Ģʽ@˘ʚ>@X!YǯɉDĤɡ`¨ib¦Děɇ> "Y
ȵ
1YV!AIJÇ/<&6˛þ5DQDA˰ƛ1Y
FN9<O"g±Áz¤´u"»n
£u>EĞųA¢z£DðȌ˘ʚDÔɖEǍ́ɡ
=XŊȄɡAƔʑūD˩˥˸>/<DÌ̟ĢʽƴAĪ)WZ6
̴Ƀ(1994)AVZF¢z£DƔʑ˩˥=EˡȌEŊȄɡA
̢)WZńɦDZĪDȜ̙ÑEðȌ$Ŏ>@9< Y ȵ
1980 ƊAEȦĤɡ=X$:̈́ȦĤɡ@ðȌAˤĜ1Yȵ
++A¢z£DƔʑ˘ʚDȦĤɡ-ǪŢ(ľŢ)ɡº̩ƴ%ʷŰ
-ZYðʌ/ðȌ> !ˑɐɎDº̩ƴ=Y¢z£A
>9<EǍ́ɡ@ðȌ>/<DˑɐEYʁDǪŢɡ˨ĥ
=X˘ʚ]Ǎ́č/ęů@ƔʑȜǀ>/<Ǟɶ1Y+>=
ƔʑĤɡïŬ%ˀ2$Wɔ0<(Y>ʷ"WZY
+D¢z£DðȌˠAEơDdap¥u|b¥ƴ
>QıJYęů-IDƚ Ƅȭ%ˑZ< Y:MXðȌE
ľŢɡ@ðʌ>/<D˨ĥ>/<šł1Y5ZˀÑDN]Ģ
Fig.8 (right) Aldo ROSSI, Fountain in Segrate, 1965-67. ʽ@̸Xˑɐ/@(<E@W@ 5DƼİ=sua presenza(ɐ
Fig.9 (left) Gianugo POLESELLO, Drawing for Project for the ÿ/½͂)Dˑɐ=XƔʑ]Ȝǀ1Y˘ʚ>/<Ƽİ]@-
Office for Chamber of Deputies, Rome,1966. @ ƔʑD˘ʚE¢z£A>9<ǪŢD̵Ǫ˨ĥDV
!Ax=Qy=QV ÊƼDQD=YʟNħ\3AV9
+DLJùE1965 Ɗ,[A˩˥-Z6£uDyn¨Dĺ <ïŬ]Ȝʑ/5DȜǀAVYƼİ]Ì̟1YD=Y
Ȭ(Fig.8)AQƛ<EMYyn¨DĺȬDðȌģƑE g·Xqb"ª(%
15cm D͔-=Xġîɡh¨}¨DðȌD˘ʚ]ƠƢ-3Y ++=D±ʸA#)Y̙Ɯ«DÖÜˠDɧ̠Eŕ&(¢z
¢z£A#)YðȌE£¨¬̹˾Ĵǰƌ˃ȑ(1966, £A>9<ēãDʞ\XDɦǙDĘļ=96> !ʥ(ĻƺE
Fig.9),A˚WZYV!AģƑD@ ðȌ%Ôɖ-Z< YģƑ ȬDV!@QD=Y
DYðȌE¢z£D˩˥ƲƺA#)YðȌ>EǷɴA ɻ̟E5DǪƊ=ēã]SP6Q/ơ%5!=E@$96W
ɝ@X5ZǨA˩˥Ʋƺ«Dųʆ%±ʸAɔ06D=Y >ǹƲ!ȵ
─ 2442 ─
計画系 777 号 4校
¢z£A# <QȦĤɡƗɖEĢ̢ ȵ
=Y%ĸ͌ whf
Fig.1, 6.: Canadian Centre for Architecture (websites, last accessed on 31 July 2020),
E£u>DƼďˑɐDɧ̠AY:MXȦĤɡƗɖ]ˎ!Ō Fig.2.: Gianugo Polesello 1960-1992 (1992), Fig.3.: Aldo Rossi: Buildings and
ħD¢z£%̩˜1YQDEƔʑ˩˥ǩʻA#)YȜǀŢɡß Project(1985). Fig.4.: DEL MONACO (2013), Fig.5,7.: LAMPARIELLO (2017),
Fig.8.: shot by author, Fig.9.: Gianugo Polesello, Progetti di architettura (1983).
ͅ=X˩˥£ywDɒˢD!8AÌ̟Ģʽ@QD=Y£
u%Ƽľ1YV!A˘ʚ[elemento]%ǯɉ[pezzo]>č1+
1) AURELI, P.V.: The difficult whole, Log, No. 9, 2007.
>=5ZˀÑ>/<íÑɡ@ȦĤɡïŬ]ˑ/ÛÀɡDȦĤɡ
2) AURELI, P.V.: The Project of Autonomy Politics and Architecture within against
Ƽİ]eauxɡAʯ!QD=E@ O/[5!/6ǯ Capitalism, Princeton Architectural Press, 2008.
ɉDƼİDó̰E¢z£A>9<ɹƬ=96> "Y 3) AYMONINO, C.: Il significato della città, Marsilio, 2002. (in Italian)
4) CLEMENTE, I.: Lucus: Intorno al significato nell'architettura di Gianugo
Polesello, AIÓN, Firenze, 2016. (in Italian)
«# 5) DEL MONACO, A. I.: Emergence-urban fabric in the urban design of Ludovico
>P?P=)$" ·¤~U Quaroni: morphology vs typology, L'architettura delle città The Journal of the
Scientific Society Ludovico Quaroni, Vol 1, No 1-2, pp.161-185, 2013.
¢z£>£uA#)YðȌˠD̠ Eçô/6w
6) FABBRINI, S.: The State of Architecture, dissertation for the degree Doctor of
a£¨ D !ÀȪ-ŕˍƔʑDˠɄDɧ̠>/<Qǖ"WZY Philosophy in Architecture of UCLA, 2018.
:MX£uEʣəɡ/ƞýɡ@Ì̟ĢʽƴD!8AðȌDÔɖ 7) GHIRARDO, D.: Aldo Rossi and the Spirit of Architecture, Yale University Press,
£
2019.
]˚ô/6D=XðȌAģƑ]Å˩1Y+>EƔʑÈŒDÀȪ
8) GRASSI, G.: Una vita di architetto, Franco Angeli, p.57, 2008. (in Italian)
AVXĆȉɡAÌ̟Ģʽƴ]Q6W1¢z£DŌħE̔A 9) GUTIÉRREZ, V.S.: LAS DISTANCIAS INVISIBLES. ALDO ROSSI Y
£
ÀȪAǞɶ-ZYDEȜǀ=XƔʑ˘ʚ%ɏʆ/<ȦĤ WALTER BENJAMIN, Thémata. Revista de Filosofía. Número 41. 2009.
(in Spanish)
ƴDěɇȿ>/<̤õ]@1+>EŬ˳=&YQD=E@$96
10) KATAGIRI, Y.: WITTEGENSTEIN’S INPACT IN BIRTH OF THE IDEA OF
--$̡ˎɡANY@WF£uDDZ%w}x
CITTÀ ANALOGA -Theory of Città Analoga in Beginning of I Quaderni
Dɂȹ]çğX1Y+>A̰)< 6$Q/Z@ ©DZ=¢ Azzurri of Aldo Rossi through Tractatus Logico-philosophicus-, Journal of
Architecture and Planning (Transactions of AIJ), Vol.84, No.764, pp. 2219-2225,
z£DDZEĔA}w>/<DŝĊ]Ŀʼn/6> !VX
£ 2019.10. (in Japanese)
ÀȪAb¥ p¥~>/<DƔʑūDŝĊ]ɶ1+>Ƌ ɉȒ Ʒˀ: ͍ǚɡ̦ƃDțƱǀʆA#)Ydap¥u|b¥DƟ
ÒŢDg¡>˘ʚDǍ́č> !˛þDßͅ]Ǟɶ1Y+ ͇:˸ɒĵŢ˸ʷ]Â/6£u̓D¨Dʼnʊ̳ŜȂA#)Y
>]æç/6>˚Y+>%=&Y+Dˆ&¢z£DęȐ@ ͍ǚɡ̦ƃDɒ˸, ǵȄƔʑŢË˥əʕ˸Ǭ̾, Vol.84, No.764, pp.2219-
2225, 2019.10.
g¡ w6YßͅEƔʑū>/<ɞŸ̖«D£uA 11) LAMPARIELLO, B.: Aldo Rossi e le forme del razionalismo esaltato: Dai
ƚ Ɵ͇]®"6>ʷ"Y+>%=&Y7[!5DƼİ=¢ progetti scolastici alla «città analoga», 1950-1973, Quodlibet Habitat, 2017.
12) MASE, M.: A Study on Systemization of Process of Architectural Planning and
z£E£uDŧĈ«DǿøD¨
¨>/<ƚ DZȳ˸
Design: Through Analysis of Design Methodology of Gianugo Polesello, Doctoral
ɡƟ͇]®"6> "Y7[! Dissertations, Tohoku University,1994. (in Japanese)
¹²'!oQFN9<O ̴Ƀ ȤƝ:Ɣʑ˩˥˥ə̝ʀDÑʕčA̵1Yɲʄ-v¥d¨r§¢z
1971 Ɗ 10 ȀAE£uE 1972 ƊD~¨ =DŸ˞Ëi £D˩˥DZȳDõȈ]̗/<, ȆĎŕŢĕŐ˸Ǭ, 1994͟
13) MATSUI, K.: Competition for Centro Direzionale of Torino (1962) and Aldo
|£n]ˑʙDsb¥:&=¢z£A˼ĭ/6 Rossi's entry, Summaries of Technical Papers of Annual Meeting, Architectural
˹ˢ$ZBƀď[Maestro dellindecifrabile]v¥d¨r§¢ Institute of Japan, History and Theory of Architecture, pp. 205-206, 2015. 7 (in
Japanese)
z£I+ZAE\2$7%©ʪAù]/6ÓijA¨v%
ȇ¼ ÞŖ : D~e¥£§a¢ah
¨¢D6PD˩˥ʈLj
Ā$Z< Y`¡§£u ~¨ $Wd¨aI (1962)>`¡§£uDƯĉȑ, ǵȄƔʑŢËŕËŢˏ˺ɀȓț̾, Ɣʑ
1971 Ɗ 10 Ȁ 20 ǵȵ
ȦĤ§Ƽď, pp. 205-206, 2015. 7.
14) MONESTIROLI, A.: Forme realiste e popolari, «Care architetture»:Scritti su
wa£¨ AVZF¢z£D˩˥A#)YƋÒŢɡ
Aldo Rossi, Umberto Allemandi & C., 2003.(in Italian)
ǤÓEȤªˡƜȤDZƜðƜ> 96ëƉ/Ȥɴ@Ɯƿ [“la 15) MONESTIROLI, A.: Antonio Monestiroli (intervista) Architettura Razionale,
forma giusta”]]ƭĪ1YQD=Yȵ
─ 2443 ─
計画系 777 号 4校
─ 2444 ─
計画系 777 GIANUGO
号 POLESELLO’S ARCHITECTURAL IDEOLOGY AND “COLUMN DEBATE” 4校
WITH ALDO ROSSI
- Collaboration in Adolescence of Polesello-Rossi for Theoretical Contribution to La Tendenza-
GIANUGO POLESELLOʼS ARCHITECTURAL IDEOLOGY AND “COLUMN DEBATE” WITH ALDO ROSSI
- Collaboration in architect adolescence of Polesello-Rossi for theoretical contribution to La Tendenza -
Yuji KATAGIRI
Yuji KATAGIRI *1
*
*Assistant
*1 Professor, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Science and Technology, Tokyo University of Science, Ph.D.
Assist. Prof., Dept. of Architecture, Faculty of Science and Technology, Tokyo University of Science, Ph.D.
Giaugo Polesello(1930-2007), one of oldest collaborators of Aldo Rossi (1931-1997), was the architect who taught
in Istituto Universitario di Architettura di Venezia (IUAV). Polesello-Rossi group had worked several works in
1960-62. Famously, Polesello, Rossi, and Luca Meda (1936-1998) collaborated in Centro direzionale di Torino and
Resistance Monument in Cuneo in 1962.
Although their contemporaries such as Carlo Aymonino, Antonio Monestiroli, and Giorgio Grassi testified their
ideological similarity and political approach to the architecture, Polesello was almost overlooked in former studies
on La Tendenza.
This study focused on the collaboration between Polesello and Rossi in early 1960’s, in order to reveal Polesello’s
theoretical and ideological contribution to La Tendenza movement. The purpose is to reveal their mutual influence
between Polesello and Rossi in their common ideology and detect when the conflict happened in their architectural
ideology. It mainly focused on Polesello’s memorial document for Rossi, ͆Ab initio, indagatio, initiorum; ricordi e
confessioni” (first presented in 1998 in «Care Archietetture» published in 2003), among the documents concerned
with La Tendenza movement.
In the first chapter, it extracts their ideological and religious background through that memorial document of
Polesello, with those of Monestiroli and Giogio Grassi. According to Grassi, they two took the way “in the opposite
direction”. Polesello recalled their metaphysical thinking style from religious high-school days. That was why they
agreed with Stalinist architecture and consisted counterpart against the main stream of Communist-Modernist
architects, while both joined Italian Communist Party in their youth.
Polesello recalled why he and Rossi had been attracted to Rashomon (⨶⏕㛛, Film directed by Akira Kurosawa).
The second chapter treated their devoting into arts, paintings, philosophy and literature. Polesello was strongly
attracted to Wittgenstein, through whom Rossi found the idea of Analogous City (see also, Katagiri, October 2019,
AIJ). Also their common background was De Chirico’s painting, and they composed the image components,
learning from Roussel’s method of Comment j'ai écrit certains de mes livres (How I Wrote Certain of my Books).
In the third chapter, it traced their collaboration in Project in Via Farini in Milan (1960), Centro direzionale di
Torino (1962) and Country Club in Fagagna (1962). In the chapter, the geometrical combination of sphere and
regular square was shared by them and it was shown that the abstract forms of components are common language
for Polesello-Rossi group.
Then, in the fourth chapter, it reached Polesello-Rossi’s “Columm debate”. According to Polesello’s confession, he
accused Rossi of proposing of column with the base like Monumental Fountain in Segrate (1965). Polesello, in
opposite, insisted on “abstract column”, which should sign “itself ” and could not be direct reference of
architectural historical archive as what Rossi said as “fragment”.
The debate on the column caused the end of their collaboration. However, they kept common adolescence in their
mind. In short, the use of abstract components in primitive geometry gave them the architectural ideological
stance for the design and influenced the architectural design in the origin of La Tendenza.
─ 2445 ─
ウラ白