Confucius ancient China was trapped in a the cosmos, were considered
ruthless cycle of war. Tribal essential goals if life on Earth was
Eastern sage Confucius. He had a invasions from the west, along to continue. The ancient rites that mission. But many people at that with rebellion amongst the lords, young Confucius knew were time did not agree with him. His splintered the empire into performed here, at the Temple of vision was modelled on the power independent states. All vying for Heaven in Beijing, right up until of the past and the family. He power. Spurred on by a kind of the th century. The Chinese had a believed that education could arms race, now that cast iron meant particular religious outlook which transform both individuals and that meant that these rituals weren't society. He is talking about your weapons could be mass produced, directed towards a deity. There is state of mind. Your feelings. But families attacked families. This no creative god. There's nothing Confucius was declared an enemy was total war. This collapse in like the idea of a supreme power of communism. So now, he should society would become the catalyst that dreams everything into being. be out of favour. But that hardly for Confucius' groundbreaking What it posits instead is this notion seems to be the case. This is the philosophy. The oldest record of that there are two cosmic forces. longest continuous civilisation in Confucius' life and ideas, the They're not even really divine, the world, and Confucius has a Analects, were compiled about a they're just natural forces, a bit like huge role in that. It's so amazing to century after his death. These gravity in a sense. And on the be so close to them. My heart is fragments of his conversations, temple here, you have perhaps the beating! In BC, an elderly along with other later histories, most common, the most powerful exsoldier from the ancient state of give us clues to his life story. We symbols of these two great forces. Lu faced a grave predicament. His are told that Confucius was just And that is the dragon, the family line was in danger of three when his father died. Old heavenly force. And the phoenix is ending. He needed a son to aristocracy, he had fallen on hard the female, the cold, the earthly continue his name, someone who times one of the victims of the force. And they are locked in would be able to perform the vital turmoil of the age leaving perpetual struggle. They try to rituals to honour him and his Confucius' mother to raise her son overcome each other. And it's this ancestors. The old man took a on her own in a kind of genteel incredible dance of power out of young wife. We are told that she poverty. Interestingly, it seems that which all life pours. So what's went to a sacred mountain and education was Confucius' lifeline. humanity's role in all of this? prayed hard for a boy. The son she Somehow, probably through a mix We're fundamental to this. You've bore would be known as Master of private teachers and got these two great cosmic forces Kong. In Chinese, Kong Fuzi. In homeschooling and, you suspect, and our role is to keep the balance, the West, we call him Confucius. the sheer grit and determination of and we do this through ritual. And Confucius was born into one of the his mother, Confucius was taught that's what this kind of temple most advanced civilisations in the history, poetry and ritual. While complex was built for. This is world. The ancient Chinese were other children played with toys, where the ruler would come to innovators in art metal work, he's said to have acted out sacred make offerings to rebalance these agriculture and weaponry. And rituals by laying out cups and two forces. And it wasn't just for from around BC, 0000they bowls. Now, these weren't just the rulers, it took place in every developed a sophisticated political empty gestures, a bit of spiritual single temple, every local shrine, system. A network of vassal lords theatre. The kinds of rituals that right down to the household. who bore allegiance to one king. Confucius learned played a crucial Sounds like a potent and a But by the time Confucius was role in the ancient Chinese world pervasive world view that going up, stability had turned to view. A world view in which order Confucius is being brought up chaos. This was an age when all of and harmony, both on Earth and in with. Absolutely. It's the only 1 world view he knows. As he He began to engage in systematic the problems of his day took on a reached adulthood, it looks as philosophical enquiry. One thing I more practical, political dimension. though Confucius grew to like about Confucius is the sense For him, the Way wasn't an appreciate the gaping disparity that you get that he had a kind of intangible cosmic force. Instead, he between the ancient ideal of order natural curiosity, that he felt saw it as the harmony that could be and the reality of life subject to the compelled to explore, and to try to brought about by a perfectly chaos that raged all around him. understand the world. And in his ordered society, something His search for a solution to that early age, he decided to leave his attainable by human action. It was intractable problem at the very home state of Lu, and get on the a claim the Daoists thought the heart of Chinese society would road. Travelling west, he would height of arrogance. This critical prove to be his life's work. have eventually met the great dispute is embodied in one Fortunately, conditions across the Yellow River. I think we have to legendary encounter. Confucius is ancient world were nourishing new imagine him at this point in his life said to have come here, the city of ways of thinking. Improvements in as a kind of ethnographer, going Luoyang. As he was studying in agriculture, increased trade, and from one place to another with the state archives, he met an older growing urbanisation meant that open eyes and an open mind, man and they struck up a some in society were less tied to a gathering together experiences and philosophical discussion. As life of subsistence, creating the encounters. The Analects describe Confucius got up to leave, the old opportunity for men like Socrates, Confucius meeting people who had man chastised him. "Put away your the Buddha and Confucius to renounced civilised society and proud air and many desires, your develop their ideas. The scale of lived amongst nature. These insinuating habit and wild will. change economic and recluses were the forerunners of These are of no advantage to you." technological is reflected in Daoism, that other great belief The enigmatic old man was none archaeological remains, like this system of ancient China. They other than Laozi, credited as the monumental grain store. Advances believed in something known as founder of Daoism. Whether it's in technology from the Iron Age the Way. true or not, this pairing with such a onwards led to an increase in Could you explain to me what great figure reveals the iconic agricultural yields that were stored exactly the Way is? Is it possible status Confucius would later reach. in massive pits like this. for humans to influence or control And it tells us something else. That Suddenly, for ordinary people, the Way? The Daoists believed setting in the archive gives us a because they had enough food, life that developed society diverted us clue to Confucius' methods. For just wasn't a grinding cycle of a from the Way. Society was him, solutions to contemporary kind of hand to mouth existence. artificial, something people problems lay in a close study of Obviously, stores like this imposed on the natural what had gone before. The past provided grain, but they also gave spontaneous way of the universe. was a kind of reservoir of truth. another great gift time to think. Only by reconnecting with the Ever since he was a boy, he had When Confucius was about, we're forces of nature could we achieve been schooled in ancient texts. told he landed a bureaucratic job harmony once again. Confucius Now, as a man, they became the managing grain stores like this. reacted to Daoist belief with a kind inspiration for, and the very But his mind was occupied by the of frustrated indignation. foundation of his philosophy. turmoil of the day. Looking around "We can't go and live with the Recent discoveries have shed new him, it seemed obvious to birds and the beasts." Am I not a light on these classic texts of Confucius that humanity needed man among men? "If the Way Chinese history bamboo slips help. And how he responded is prevailed in the world, there would which contain the earliest evidence considered a first in Chinese be no need for me "to change it." of Confucius's words. They were history. Confucius' search for solutions to found in the tomb of an old noble 2 man. And they date back to when the practices and the examples of step brisk. When with his clasped Oh, these were dated to the the early Zhou, by reviving the hands he bowed to his colleagues roughly years after Confucius. It past, on left and right, his robes moved says something like, "Set your there could be solutions to the evenly in front and back. His mind on the way and be virtuous. problems of the present. It is the hurrying advance was a glide." Do everything in accordance with great thing about golden ages, Confucius set out to transmit the humanity." Not only the earliest they're very comforting. We importance of proper ritual, words of Confucius but beautiful believe that if humanity was promoting his ideas right across words too. And they were so capable of wonderful things in the the land. One account describes his amazing because they provide us past, we can achieve them once rather hostile reception from a new information on early classics again. Confucius believed that government advisor from the state that were very important to early Zhou society was the ideal of Qi. "Confucius lays such stress Confucius himself. And, for manifestation of his concept of the on appearance and costume, example, this particular slip Way. To recreate that harmony, elaborate etiquette and codes of mention about the classics he society needed to return to their behaviour that it would take would have read. The Book Of high standards. Especially in terms generations to learn his rule. One Odes ritual and music. But The of ritual. Confucius was convinced lifetime wouldn't be enough." To Book Of History is very important, that the ancient rites had been this day, Confucius is often because it recorded figures such as corrupted. In order to restore the criticised for his pedantic the Duke of Zhou, and early kings golden age, he would have to attachment to intricate forms of of the Western Zhou that was reinstate proper ritual. Here, in antiquated ritual. But what his about years before Confucius' Confucius' hometown of Qufu, is a critics didn't understand is that he time. And these men were able to temple dedicated to the master. It's had discovered something radically lead a society of harmony. the ultimate place of pilgrimage for new within these ancient rites, Confucius found in the words of many of his devotees. Mr Kong something which marked a critical The Book Of History what he was traces his ancestry back to shift in his thinking. When looking for an ideal model where Confucius and often leads rituals Confucius' was in his mids, his social and political harmony had that his illustrious relative set such mother died. For three years, he prevailed, engineered by the store by. HE CALLS OUT But dutifully carried out ancestral rites almost superhumanely sage rulers ritual here has always meant more in her honour. But he would of the early Zhou dynasty, in than just ceremony. It's an all breathe new life and new meaning particular, the Duke of Zhou. encompassing ethos that shapes into these traditions. Ancient When his brother, King Wu, died, every aspect of people's behaviour, Chinese believed that the ghost and the Duke could have seized the including what we might call spirits continue to exist after the throne. etiquette and customs. It seems that ancestors die. So it's important to But it's reported that instead he Confucius threw himself into offer them food and wine in these acted loyally, ruling as a regent for understanding and perfecting the kind of vessels. In particular, those his nephew, the king's son. And rites of the early Zhou. made of very expensive bronze. then, when the boy grew up, fairly Confucius was nothing if not a And everyone would be really and faithfully, he handed over the stickler for detail. We hear he engaging in the ritual to continue a reins of power. Whether these wouldn't even sit on a mat unless it kind of relationship they had accounts were entirely true is a was dead straight. But there seems before. Do we know what moot point, but Confucius saw to have been a kind of beauty in his Confucius thought about all of huge potential in them. This golden precision. Just listen to these this? Well, Confucius still believed age was robust evidence that social wonderful words describing him. that ancestors were still very order was possible. By following "His expression was serious, his important part, but he started to 3 shift emphasis towards the living, who you are inside, sort of really marks out Confucius, as well by saying that it meant that it's psychologically? Yes, yeah, I think as those other game changing important for us to develop this this exactly. Not only just bring philosophers the Buddha and kind of reverence and the proper order to the social and life, but also Socrates. As a philosopher, you relationship while they are still this to create a new psychological don't just indulge in abstract alive. As he said in the Analects under this meaning there and tried musings, you develop a robust very clearly, that if you don't know to cultivate this good human delivery mechanism for your how to serve the living, how would qualities. Yeah. I mean, it's theories. Ideas have to have you know how to serve the dead? interesting cos he doesn't sell traction, and they have to have He's saying actually focus first on himself as an innovator, but he tangible impact. Confucius was a the here and now and on those who was. Yes, he was, I think. practical man. He had been spurred are still around you in the day Confucius said, you know, he was into action by the bellicose times today before you start to think the only transmitter that into which he was born. His about those who are long dead. transmitted the ancient culture to philosophy would only truly be a You are so right. It's no longer just today, to the future. But actually, success if he it could affect change about objects like this. It's about what he did was innovation. These on a grand scale. Confucius came your state of mind, your feelings, new things that are really coming to think this that shaping and your love and sincerity from inside from his reinterpretation of cultivating moral individuals was that you would have towards these something that already exists, such the key to creating a stable social people around you. Confucius as the ritual. Nourishing virtue lay and political order. By figuring out realised that ritual brought out at the core of Confucius' vision. what made a good person, you positive emotions in us. But his And he saw transformative could make a good society. And so really big revelation was that this opportunities in everyday rituals his mission was this to teach could permanently change who we how we speak, how we dress and people how to be virtuous in a are. Habitually performing the how we eat. But one that was world of political disorder and rituals of history, with the right particularly close to his heart was moral decay. Confucius had given attitude and sincerity, could music. He's said to have played the himself a mountain to climb. transform our mindset. Virtuous zither and the sounding chimes. How to instil virtue in society, feelings could make virtuous This was a time and place where when society's moral contract was beings. music was all around, played on so broken was Confucius' big Ritual for him was not just the way totally wonderful things like this challenge. He was to find you do things, exactly follow the monumental set of bells that date inspiration from a familiar and traditional and this and the rules, to just after Confucius' death. enduring institution. The family. but even more importantly, you've Music was played to accompany Confucius noted how families are got to have something inside. ritual in temples and homes, so if organised along hierarchical lines,' You've got to have a reverence, you listen to these, then you'll be with fixed responsibilities. From respect, because this was the way hearing the sounds that would have birth, we learn our place within to cultivate your inside of surrounded Confucius during his key relationships. Recognising goodness, the inside of this kind of lifetime. Confucius was convinced your place within these and the qualities. And the whole that music had the power to relationships and fulfilling your person would be transformed on harmonise, to transform and mutual responsibilities within that the inside. perfect an individual. Basically, hierarchy taught essential moral But, I mean, that sounds really this is art as therapy, years before values. From the family, we radical. So he's saying you need to we invent the phrase. This practical developed a sense of loyalty, of do things properly, but they're not application of philosophical ideas honesty, of duty, of respect, of just a mechanical action. It affects in day to day life is something that filial responsibility. Basically, to 4 love those around us. Confucius expensive chariots and sacrificial loyalty. And he also said, "And if saw that the concept of family was horses. What kind of connection that fails, you have the right to a potent model and a potential did Confucius see between the overthrow." solution for society's ills. The relationships that he'd observed Confucius' tactic was very direct. family showed how authority could between father and son and the He set out to influence those in be both exercised and submitted to, family, and what's going on here? power by getting a governmental fairly and productively. Not Well, he looked at the fact that if post. One snag was his personality. through intimidation, but through you had a good father, he could He was often seen as arrogant, too mutual assent. The moral values bring up a good son. And a good blunt in the way he delivered his learnt in the family affection and son could then respect the father, advice. But he also faced a bigger care directed downwards, and and this could work. So he said problem. With enemy armies loyalty and obedience directed "Well, look, if it works at this numbering as many as , camped on above had the potential to level, let's just take it to the top." If their borders, and disloyal sons transform everyone. But Confucius the ruler views those beneath him plotting behind their backs, saw that arguably their greatest as his children and treats them with perhaps it's no surprise that the value lay in relation to the glaring love but with firmness, with rulers of the day failed to take problem at the heart of society the compassion but with integrity, then Confucius seriously. Cultivating waywardness of its rulers. This it would it roll down through the moral character and virtuous magnificent sword embodies what, system. And the Confucianist actions in such precarious times for Confucius, was the could say, "Look, you see the was just not a priority. With fundamental problem with Chinese ruler's "living like this, you should rejection upon rejection, leadership. This was made when live like this." And literally, it Confucius' faltering political career Confucius was alive, and it tells us would roll down, like the clouds looked set to fail and his ideas in all about itself. He wasn't from the mountain and bring danger of being lost to history. But puritanical. He enjoyed the good blessing to everyone. So, for him, he was tenacious and resourceful. things of life, swimming in rivers, might in and of itself wasn't a In his early, it looks as though he singing with friends and he problem, but if you had might, then decided to change his strategy. He understood the need for worldly you also had to have a kind of gathered together a few belongings goods. But he did not think that philosophical responsibility to your and hit the road once again to good men should devote their time people? Yes. Confucius continued continue his moral crusade. Only and energy to the pursuit of the Zhou tradition that a ruler has this time, he wasn't alone. He was personal gain. And he didn't the right to rule because heaven travelling together with a group of believe in immoderate action, has clearly given them the power devoted students. His ability to anywhere, anytime, from anyone. and the authority. And that's why attract motivated young men put In Confucius' opinion, kings who the top, top ruler was called the son his mission to transform self and commissioned swords like this of heaven. However, that mandate, society back on track. By all often abandoned virtue if it got in that right to rule, can be taken accounts, Confucius possessed a the way of worldly success. He away by heaven. And a sign that kind of compelling, raw charisma. saw the way to transform society heaven has taken it away is natural Now, combine that with was to instil the values at work in disasters, massive earthquakes, intellectual rigour, with bold, the family in the rulers of his day. floods. Confucius said if a ruler exciting new ideas and inspiring To understand the power they becomes corrupt and people are moral instruction, and you've got a wielded, you only need look at the suffering through this cruelty, then potent mix. Whilst Confucius had way they were honoured in death. the people have the right to rebel. failed alone, a band of around This ruler, from around the time of And so Confucius, at one level, students could infiltrate the Confucius, was buried along with tells you respect, honour, duty, corridors of power at many levels 5 and in many states. They could be made up. Just as with ritual, he "Can you serve a corrupt master if a moral vanguard to advise and took something traditional and you think you can make a instruct rulers on how to rule gave it a potent new twist. Junzi difference?" Confucius encouraged virtuously. And for this vital role, was an aristocratic word meaning a this opened, freethinking Confucius was scrupulously son of the lord, denoting qualities discussion. meritocratic accepting students that could only belong to a Yet his students still looked to him even from the poorest of privileged social elite. Now, as part for definitive answers. Ultimately, backgrounds. In the Analects, of his shift towards a moral elite, they wanted to know what was the Confucius said, "I have never Confucius appropriated it and essence of goodness? For refused instruction "to anyone, if, changed it to mean the ultimate Confucius, there was one all of his own accord, he comes to moral person, a superior man. A embracing virtue, the most me." This in itself was a truly new kind of gentleman, in its most essential to cultivate and yet the innovatory moment marking an literal sense. most difficult to attain. Something historic shift. He was urging that For Confucius, education was called ren. Ren is a very splendid Chinese society should no longer crucial. Drawing on his own life word idea, but what does it be governed by an hereditary elite, experience, he saw an unswerving actually mean? people who owed their positions commitment to critical learning as What quality does it imply? Well, simply to their bloodlines. Rather, the path to self-cultivation. He many people tried to translate it it was those who were most likened the process to polishing differently. It's been translated as virtuous, most concerned about the jade, crafting one's virtuous human heartedness, as good or wellbeing of others, who should character, to become the perfect goodness, but we prefer now to use lead. moral person. You had to know the word simply humanity. His way was open to people from The Book Of History to live by the Because virtually all Confucian any background to rise to positions example of the sage kings and to values are linked to this notion. of authority. Confucius shared his enact correct ritual. But what was Courage with ren, then its real groundbreaking commitment to a essential was to be morally alive to courage rather than just simply kind of egalitarianism with your environment. To understand bravery. Justice with ren, then it's a Socrates and the Buddha. Their how to behave intuitively in any humane justice rather than just solutions were, in theory, available situation. To think for yourself. harsh punishment. Wisdom with to everyone. But, to a greater or Confucius' students joined their ren, then it's being wise not just lesser extent, when it came to master, moving across wartorn being smart. And is this something women, they all seemed to have China to try to influence its errant that you achieve, or is looking for struggled. None of them were rulers. They were attacked, beaten ren a constant quest? exactly model family men. The and almost starved. But these Every person, by definition of Buddha left his wife and child. testing times sharpened their being a person, embodies ren. In Socrates treated his young wife education. The challenges they other words, every human being's pretty cursorily. But at least those faced forced them to engage in capable of sympathetic response to two included women in their urgent moral debate. They the external world. But at the same thinking and suggested they could proposed solutions to their time, to realise ren fully, which be part of a solution to society's problems and then interrogated means human flourishing in the problems. However, when it comes those, provoking the intense most comprehensive sense of the to Confucius, it seems he had next intellectual discussions between term, that requires learning. And to no time for the female of the master and students that you find learning, of course, it's not simply species. The ultimate goal for in the Analects. They asked the acquisition of knowledge or Confucius' students was to become questions like, "Should the junzi internalisation of skills, but a junzi. Now, this wasn't a title he'd accept office in degenerate times?” basically learning to build one's 6 character. And in that sense, it's hometown, Qufu. The great powerfully integrative force in like the highest ideal. At the same transformation he had worked for Chinese history. And of course it time, it's a minimum requirement his entire life had not been was very useful for rulers to have to be human. Do you think that fulfilled. all that emphasis on obedience and Confucius felt that he'd achieved But his devoted students planted respect and topdown structure. ren? And the interesting thing is trees around his grave and kept his Even those who didn't get to go to many students or followers of dream alive. For years, Confucius' school learnt his words. It's Confucius also said no.Ren ideas continued as just one of actually why we've developed that requires continuous process of many Chinese schools of thought. rather crass form "Confucius says," struggling. Even to the end of your Competing with the likes of because for centuries, right across life, this is still a task incomplete. Daoism, it was unable to effect real China, people WERE all quoting So no matter what, the struggle to change in a chaotic world. But Confucius. be fully human continues. There's once China was reunited under all # Confucius say a boy A girl, a something in Confucian powerful emperors, stability moon philosophy a core message, that I changed the political landscape. # Make wedding bells ring out In find really, genuinely inspiring. It's The first emperor of the Han month of June his golden rule taken from the Dynasty was convinced by his # Confucius say when love come Analects. One student said, "Is principal advisor that ruling by Don't delay there a single word that "I should brutality had served his # So, honey, hold me tight use as a rule to live my life by?" predecessor badly. Allying himself # Tonight's the night The master replied, "That would be with Confucianism and its ideal of # Remember what Confucius say. empathy, perhaps. rule by virtue would lend to his But all that changed in the th What you do not wish for yourself, dynasty greater legitimacy. Many century. Confucianism came under don't do to others." It's this focus of the values that Confucius set attack. In , students who wanted on human relations and being great store by the importance of China to modernize and become compassionate that I think comes education, a shared cultural democratic condemned Confucius closest to defining what Confucius heritage, an ethical government for holding them back. But it was meant by the term ren. I do love had seemed an irrelevance during Chairman Mao's Cultural this about all three of the the chaos of his lifetime. But these Revolution that tried to annihilate philosophers whose stories I'm would prove hugely effective in all vestiges of his legacy. His Red investigating. They made it clear holding the new empire together. Guard destroyed statues, temples that none of us operate in isolation. Successive emperors and texts. They even came here, to It isn't that man is the measure of enthusiastically took up Confucian his burial place. In a telegram to all things, but man's relationship ideas, and education was central. Chairman Mao, they wrote, "We with man. Confucius continued to The poetry, arts, and music of the have dragged out the statue of travel, and to teach into his later early Zhou were revived as a Confucius. "We have torn down years. But only a handful of his means of cultivating the goodness the plaque extolling the teacher of , students went on to hold political and virtue within. School children generations. We have levelled office. When Confucius was , he learnt the Confucian canon by Confucius' grave. We have fell ill. Unable to fulfil his mission, heart, meticulously writing it out in destroyed." It is really chilling his final words seem defeated and their best calligraphy. Knowledge coming here to see how a raging, bitterly disappointed. "No of The Book Of History and rituals rigid form of an ideology tried to intelligent monarch arises. "There of the Zhou Dynasty became a obliterate the memory of a man of is none who will make me his prerequisite to be part of the civil ideas. CHILDREN READ master. "It is my time to die." service. Confucian education and TOGETHER But thousands of Confucius was buried here, in his Confucian texts became a years of ubiquitous Confucian 7 education, particularly the exam in our finest form, we are all determined who we are now. Their system, had embedded his philosophers in the true sense of message was inspiring and principles deep within Chinese the word lovers of wisdom. challenging. That the world isn't culture. By the start of the st Across this series, I have examined unknowable, unchangeable. By century, the government began, the ideas of three inspiring minds. engaging with it fully, we can lead once again, to embrace his ideals. Confucius said a ritual is a way to better and more meaningful lives. Today, Confucianism is bring out the inside good qualities, We have agency. Our minds can undergoing a renaissance. And like benevolence, like reverence. shape the world. If the mind of education remains at the forefront. And if more people possess good Confucius has made you think, This is a Confucian school in qualities and they become real then explore further with The Open Qufu. Pupils from the ages of six human, then their social life, University to discover how great to study the Confucian texts and family life, or community life will minds have influenced our world classical arts here. It just one of become peaceful. But, ultimately, today. around , schools in China that what do they have to teach us in teaches Confucian values and the here and now? Although these philosophy. were ideas that were developed It is just fascinating seeing these centuries ago, do you think they kids being brought up with an have as much relevance to our ancient philosophy at the heart of world as they did to ancient China, everything that they think ancient Greece, ancient India? They were confronted with a world and say and do. And actually, they in disintegration. Little rationality. seem to be having a great time. It's Little compassion. And we are in a also even more incredible, though, world that's much more serious. if you think that just a few decades Because it's not simply the human ago, Confucius was considered an world is in trouble, the planet is in enemy of the state and none of this trouble. And we have in our power would have been allowed to the destruction happen. Or if it did, it would've of all civilisations, including the had to have happened in secret, planet itself. So a change has to be behind closed doors and at the risk made. Not just a change of a of really severe punishment. In political system or economic modern China, greater system these are absolutely individualism is seen to have necessary but a change of mindset. undermined a collective sense of And the retrieval of the wisdom of right and wrong. Confucius' Socrates, of Buddha and Confucius resurgence can be explained by the is not a question of relevance, it's a desire for a clearer sense of moral question of human survival. These purpose. But I wonder if extraordinary thinkers aren't Confucius' appeal is very simple. remote historical figures. They're He tells us that whatever our pioneers of human consciousness character, whatever situation we're whose ideas have informed and born into, being good, living a enriched the lives of countless good life is a possibility. And that people to this day. Their radical the root to goodness is wisdom. responses to the social upheaval of Now, that means that as a species, their age have, in many ways, 8