You are on page 1of 8

KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering (2008) 12(4):281-288 Water Engineering

DOI 10.1007/s12205-008-0281-z
www.springer.com/12205

Analysis of Urban Development of Haridwar, India, Using Entropy Approach


Ramakar Jha*, Vijay P. Singh**, and V. Vatsa***
Received January 25, 2008/Accepted March 18, 2008

···································································································································································································································

Abstract

Urban development is a complex process, which should be observed at various levels and in many aspects for full understanding.
The pervasive problems generated by urban development have prompted, in the present work, to study the spatial extent of
urbanization in Haridwar, India, and patterns of periodic changes in urban development (systematic/random) in order to develop
future plans for (i) urbanization promotion areas, and (ii) urbanization control areas. Remote Sensing, using Indian Remote Sensing
(IRS) satellite data, was used to map the spatial extent of urbanization for the 1989, 1998, 2000 and 2002 years. Geographical
Information System (GIS) and Entropy approach, which makes use of mathematical notions related to thermodynamics and is the
disorder of organization or randomness of organization of a system, were used to study the pattern of urban development (systematic
or random) in Haridwar, India during 1989-2002. The distributed entropy and relative mean entropy values were evaluated
considering two location factors: (i) urban development at peripheries of 1000 m each from the centre of the city (Har Ki Pauri), (ii)
urban development at peripheries of 1000 m each from the highway along the upper Ganga canal. The results obtained indicate
significant periodic urban development in Haridwar during 1989-2002, specifically after the 1998 year. However, urban
developments were found to be random in nature, as the distributed relative entropy values formed a zig-zag pattern for the location
factor from the centre of the town. The application of entropy is found to be a better alternative to conventional technique.
Keywords: entropy, urban development, land use change, nonpoint source pollution, point source pollution, pollution
···································································································································································································································

1. Introduction include runoff and/or infiltration of water from roads, industrial


areas, and golf courses. Contaminants include metals, industrial
The ability to develop the land in an urban area heavily organic chemicals, nutrients, and pesticides. Keeping this in
influences economic activity and the quality of life in cities view, evaluation of periodic changes in spatial extent and pattern
(Turkstra, 1996). One direct implication of such an urban sprawl of urban development in different years is essential for planning
is the change in land use and land cover. Due to increasing (i) urbanization promotion areas, and (ii) urbanization control
population and high economic growth in selected landscapes, areas. Remote sensing techniques have been utilized in
rapid urban development and land use changes have occurred in numerous studies to map land use changes and spatial extent of
India during recent years. Further, urban development has both urban development during different time periods (Howarth,
direct and indirect impacts on water resources. Some impacts 1986; Fung and LeDerw, 1987; Eastman and Fulk, 1993; Jensen
result from the direct modification or destruction of streams, et al., 1993, 1995; Li and Yeh, 1988). These techniques include
lakes and wetlands. Other impacts occur primarily offsite due to image differencing (Toll, 1980), image rationing (Nelson, 1983),
changes in the quality and quantity of runoff from urban post-classification comparison (Howarth and Wickware, 1981),
development and construction activities (Dreher and Price, masking method (Pilon et al., 1988), nearest neighborhood and
1992). Urban areas generate both nonpoint and point sources of principal component analysis (Fung and LeDrew, 1987; Li and
contaminants. Point sources that have an impact on surface water Yeh, 1988). Most of the techniques have limited capability in
include industrial and municipal waste discharges; those that capturing the characteristics of urban sprawl as these have been
affect groundwater quality include leaky underground storage developed in the context of image analysis or fractal theory
facilities, as well as miscellaneous accidental spills of organic or (Webster, 1995; Batty and Longley, 1994).
inorganic contaminants. Groundwater contamination by volatile In addition to remote sensing approach, it was found that
organic compounds (VOCs) is more common in urban settings entropy approach can provide information on the pattern of
due to the heavy use of solvents and fuels. Nonpoint sources periodic changes in urban development (systematic/random).

*Scientist-E1, Environmental Hydrology Division, National Institute of Hydrology, Roorkee-247667, Uttarakhand, India (E-mail: rjha@nih.ernet.in)
**Professor, Dept. of Biological and Agricultural Engineering, Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas 77843-2117, USA (Corresponding Author,
E-mail: vsingh@tamu.edu)
***Research Scholar, Gurukul Kangri University, Haridwar, India

− 281 −
Ramakar Jha, Vijay P. Singh, and V. Vatsa

Entropy, which is a measure of disorder or randomness (Miller, preparation of the drainage map and contour map of the study
1969) has been applied to a variety of practical problems in region (see Fig. 1). Further, the soil map and other information
different fields, including physical, biological, and social sciences were collected from various state and central government
(Fast, 1970; Wyatt, 1967 Morowitz, 1970, Kullback 1959, agencies. To study the land-use changes in Haridwar city satellite
Quilstler, 1953 and 1955, Buckley, 1968, Theil, 1967 and 1972, data for the year 1989, 1998, 2000, and 2002 were collected and
Chapman, 1977 Medyedkov, 1967; and Thakur, 1972 and 1979). analyzed.
Contemporary science has accepted it as one of the foundation
stones for empirical research. 3. Methodology
In the present study, the spatial extent of urbanization and
pattern of periodic changes in urban development (systematic/ 3.1 Mapping Spatial Extent Using Remote Sensing Tech-
random) has been done for Haridwar, India, which is an nique
important city along the banks of River Ganga, to develop future Remote sensing data are capable of detecting and measuring a
plan for (i) urbanization promotion areas, and (ii) urbanization variety of elements relating to the morphology of cities, such as
control areas. Remote sensing, GIS and entropy approaches were the amount, shape, density, textural form and spread of urban
integrated to fulfill the objectives of the present work. areas (Webster, 1995; Mesev et al., 1995). In this study, Indian
Remote Sensing (IRS) data for the 1989, 1998, 2000 and 2002
2. Study Area and Data years were used in ERDAS-Imagine software to (i) classify
pixels that are classified as built-up area (urban area), (ii) water
Haridwar is a holy city in the state of Uttarakhand in northern bodies, (iii) agricultural area, (iv) forests, and (v) barren lands.
India. The total area of Haridwar is 1994.0 km2. The district of Separating agricultural areas from urban areas is particularly
Haridwar lies between 77o35' to 78o15' latitude and 30°03' important because past studies have demonstrated its effec-
longitude (see Fig. 1). The city is situated just beneath the tiveness in reducing commission errors in classified imageries
Shiwalik mountain ranges and is part of west Indogangetic plain (Griffiths, 1988; Masek et al., 2000). Vegetation can be indicated
which is composed of Pleistocene and subrecent alluvium by the simple normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI)
brought down by rivers from the Himalayan region. The using multi-spectral data. For Haridwar NDVI was computed
alluvium is made up of sand, silt, clay, Kankar and gravel. There using the equation (Justice, 1986):
is no void features except that the presence of rivers and nallas.
( Rnir – Rred )
Most of the rivers of Hardwar district are flowing from west to NDVI = -------------------------- (1)
( Rnir + Rred )
east.
Survey of India toposheets with a scale 1:50,000 were used for where Rnir and Rred are the reflectance in near infra-red and red

Fig. 1. Study Area, Drainage and Contour Maps of the Study Region

− 282 − KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering


Analysis of Urban Development of Haridwar, India, Using Entropy Approach

frequency bands. 3.2 Systematic/Random Pattern Analysis Entropy Appro-


Now, to detect the urban sprawl in land use/land cover changes ach Integrated with GIS
in the study area, the Principal Component Analysis (PCA) 3.2.1 Geographical Information System (GIS) Approach
image enhancement technique was adopted. PCA is a powerful The maps of spatial extent obtained from PCA in ERDAS-
technique for the analysis of correlated multi dimensional data. Imagine software were input to the ILWIS-GIS software domain
The n-channel multi spectral data can be considered as n- for performing spatial operations. It is accepted that the urban
dimensional data. The PCA builds up a new set of axes, which development is affected by some primary location factors, i.e.,
are orthogonal to each other, i.e., non-correlated. The entire data the distance to urban centers and roads. In the present work, the
set can be represented in terms of these new axes. The data along density of urban development has been evaluated in GIS con-
the first principal component (PC) have a great variance or sidering two location factors, viz., (i) urban development at
dynamic range than the data plotted against either of the original peripheries of 1000 m each from the centre of the city (Har Ki
axes. The data along the second PC have far less variance. This Pauri), (ii) urban development at peripheries of 1000 m each
is the characteristics of all principal components. The principal from the highway along the upper Ganga canal. The thematic
component images can be analyzed as separate black and white layers of buffer zones were created using the buffer functions of
images or any three component images may be combined to GIS and the width of each buffer was considered to be 1000 m.
form a color composite. These techniques are particularly In spatial information systems, a buffer zone or simply buffer, is
appropriate where little apriori information concerning a given a polygon enclosing an area within a specified distance from a
scene is available. point, line or polygon. Accordingly, there are point buffers, line
buffers and polygon buffers. The town of Haridwar had 15
polygon buffer zones for distance from the center of the town
(Har ki Pauri) and 8 polygon buffer zones for the distance from
the road along the upper Ganga canal. The buffer zones created
for both the location factors are shown in Figure 3. The spatial
extent maps for the 1989, 1998, 2000 and 2002 years of the study
area were overlaid onto the buffer zone maps in order to evaluate
the density of urban development in each buffer zone of 1000 m
considering both the location factors as discussed above. Density
of urban development (%) is defined as the amount of urban
development divided by the land area in each buffer zone (Yeh
and Li, 1998).
The distribution of the densities over the buffers was obtained
using the cross function of ILWIS. The cross-tabulation statistics
computed were used to compare class value areas between two
thematic layers, including the number of pixels (or hectare) in
common and percentages.

3.2.2 Entropy Approach


In a classic paper Shannon (1948) developed the concept of'
entropy and proposed a discipline of communication theory
which focused on the study of information theory and entropy.
Fig. 2. PCA Modeling Algorithm
This theory makes use of a basic mathematical notion related to

Fig. 3. Creation of Polygon Buffer Zones (i) from the Centre of the City (Har Ki Pauri), and (ii) from the Highway Along the Upper Ganga
Canal

Vol. 12, No. 4 / July 2008 − 283 −


Ramakar Jha, Vijay P. Singh, and V. Vatsa

thermodynamics. The second law of thermodynamics states that Shannon's entropy E (Theil, 1967; Thomas, 1981). Entropy can
thermodynamic degradation is unalterable over time, e.g., a be calculated as:
burnt log cannot be un-burnt and lukewarm water cannot be n
⎛ 1⎞
separated distinctly into hot water and cold water. Numerous E= ∑ pi log⎝ p----i⎠ (2)
applications of entropy in environmental and water resources has i=1

been shown by Singh (2000).


n
The disorder, disorganization or randomness of organization of where pi = xi ⁄ ∑ xi is the probability or the proportion of the
i=1
a system is known as its entropy (Miller, 1969). So, entropy is a variable occurring in the ith zone, and xi is the observed value of
measure of disorder and information is a measure of order of a the variable in the ith zone, and n is the total number of zones.
system. Since the system changes to a less organized state from a The value of entropy ranges from zero to log(n). If the
highly organized state and to more probable states from less probability distribution of the variable is maximally concentrated
probable states, entropy is maximized and the magnitude of in one zone, the lowest value of the entropy, zero, will be
entropy is described by a set of probabilities. obtained. Conversely, an evenly dispersed distribution of the
As an alternative to conventional nearest neighbour technique variable among zones will give a maximum entropy value of
Medvedkov (1966) has related this notion to the problem of log(n).
settlement pattern analysis. He has suggested that any settlement The relative entropy can be used to scale the entropy value into
pattern has a uniform component and a random component. the range from 0 to 1. The relative entropy Er is (Thomas, 1981):
These components can be measured by the method used for n p i log ( 1 ⁄ pi )
detecting signals in the presence of noise in information theory. Er = ∑ -------------------------
log ( n )
- (3)
Signal is analogous to the uniform component and noise to the i=1

random component. Entropy has been used as a measure of noise If the probability distribution is maximally concentrated in one
in information theory and as a measure of disorder in spatial region, Eq. (3) would yield the lowest E value of zero.
distributions. Medvedkov (1966) suggests that a settlement pattern Conversely, Eq. (3) would yield a maximum E value of 1 for an
is a composite of two superimposed sub-patterns, one random evenly dispersed probability distribution. Eq. (3) was utilized for
and the other uniform. Each of these sub-patterns will have its analysis in this study.
own mean density of points, and the two densities added together Entropy can be used to measure the distribution of a
will be equal to the mean density of the composite pattern. geographical variable and thus a measure of the difference in
Likewise each sub-pattern has its own entropy value, and these entropy between time (t+1) and (t) can be used to indicate the
summed will be equal to the entropy value of the composite change in the degree of dispersal of land development or urban
pattern. However, the entropy value of a uniform pattern is zero sprawl (Thomas, 1981). This can be expressed as:
therefore the entropy value of the random component will be
∆E = E ( t + 1 ) – E ( t ) (4)
equal to that of the total pattern. If the pattern is not perfectly
uniform the entropy function is density dependent and there is no in which E is the change in entropy between time (t+1) and (t).
upper limit to the value of entropy. Entropies for different The dispersal of urban areas from a town center will lead to an
patterns can be compared precisely only when the cell count data increase in the entropy value. The change of entropy can be used
is obtained using the same grid in the same position on the map. to identify whether land development follows a more dispersed
Therefore, for comparative studies in time or space, the size and or compact pattern of sprawl.
form of the grid must not be altered. Using densities of different buffer zones computed in GIS, the
Again, a major difference between entropy and traditional probability of urban development in each buffer zone of 1000m
indices of spatial dispersion is that its value is invariant with the was estimated. Thereafter, Eq. (3) was used to compute the
value of zones and the number of observations (n) (Thomas, distributed entropy for different buffer zones and mean relative
1981). In contrast, the Gini coefficient and the Lorenz curve, entropy for the 1989, 1998, 2000, 2002 years.
which have been widely used in geography to describe location
patterns, are sensitive to the size and shape of the area units 4. Results and Discussion
under observation. The modifiable area units may exert a
significant influence on the results of spatial analysis and lead to 4.1 Mapping Spatial Extent using Remote Sensing Tech-
the loss of detailed information (Openshaw, 1991). However, nique
entropy has no such problems. The IRS 1C images for the 1989, 1998, 2000 and 2002 years
were utilized to delineate the map the spatial extent of urban
3.3.3 Mathematical Formulation development periodically. The results obtained using Principal
Let an urban area be divided into n zones and x represent a Component Analysis of these multi-temporal images is shown in
geographical variable to characterize these zones. Then the Figure 4. It can be seen from the figure that the area for urban
degree of spatial concentration or dispersion of the geographical development has expanded mostly along the highway. Due to
variable in the i-th zone (xi) among n zones can be measured by topographical conditions, initially the development was near the

− 284 − KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering


Analysis of Urban Development of Haridwar, India, Using Entropy Approach

Fig. 4. Principal Component Analysis of Satellite Data of Haridwar

centre of the town (Har ki Pauri) and then it moved far away, dominated by residential, industrial, commercial, and mixed
mostly along the highway. Further, the urban development zone development.
pattern is more clearly noticed on the urban fringes or city Prior to the computation of density in each buffer zone of the
peripheral agricultural areas than in the city centre. two location factors, it was found necessary to compare the
The percentage changes in the spatial extent of urban urban development and corresponding population density data
development were computed by counting number of pixels obtained from various sources in Haridwar. The results indicate a
indicating the urban area of Haridwar, India. significant increase in the development of the urban area during
the period 1989-2002 (Fig. 5(a)). It is found that the density of
4.2 Systematic/Random Pattern Analysis Entropy Approach urban development increased gradually since 1989. However,
Integrated with GIS there was exponential increase in urban development of
4.2.1 Geographical Information System (GIS) Approach Haridwar during 1998-2002 due to formation of Uttarakhand as
In the next step, the outcome of remote sensing analysis in the a separate state, and enhanced industrial development and urban
form of spatial information was transferred to the ILWIS GIS settlements in the surrounding areas for both location factors. It
system. In the analysis, the buffer function of GIS was used to is interesting to see that in Fig. 5(b) there has been only a gradual
define polygon buffers zones for calculating entropy. The buffer increase in population of Haridwar and no exponential increase
zones selected corresponded to different locations in Haridwar is noticed. Also, it is noticed that some new areas of urban

Fig. 5. Urban Development at Haridwar, India, for Two Location Factors

Vol. 12, No. 4 / July 2008 − 285 −


Ramakar Jha, Vijay P. Singh, and V. Vatsa

settlements have emerged after the 2000 year beyond a distance Table 1. Mean Relative Entropy Values for Both Location Factors
of 12 km from the center of Haridwar. Location factor
Year (a) From the centre of the (b) From the highway along
4.2.2 Entropy Approach city (Har Ki Pauri) Upper Ganga Canal
As was discussed earlier, entropy can be used to indicate the 1989 0.64 0.55
degree of urban sprawl by examining whether land development
1998 0.97 0.63
in a city is dispersed or compact. The larger value indicates the
occurrence of urban development. The buffer zones created in 2000 0.96 0.76
GIS for both the location factors and density of urban area in 2002 0.94 0.67
each buffer zone were used for computation of probability and
entropy values for each buffer zone.
The mean relative entropy in terms of urban development of calculated using Eq. (3) and are given in Table 1.
Haridwar for the 1989, 1999, 2000 and 2002 years were From Table 1, it is found that in the 1998 year entropy was

Fig. 6. Entropy Values in Different Buffer Zones of Haridwar Town

− 286 − KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering


Analysis of Urban Development of Haridwar, India, Using Entropy Approach

highest for location factor (a) and thereafter the entropy value Comparison of entropy values for 2000 and 2002 years
started to slightly decrease, which is practically insignificant. It indicates that due to the formation of Uttaranchal as a separate
indicates random development in urban areas. Further, if location state, the land value has increased enormously and has caused
factor (b) is considered, the results substantiate the results scattered development in the 2000 year. Similarly, during the
obtained for location factor. This also indicates that the overall 1998 year, temporary shelters were constructed on the occasion
urban development in Haridwar is random. of holy festival Kumbh in Haridwar and the scattered urban
It was found necessary to evaluate distributed relative entropy sprawl in terms of entropy can be easily visualized in some of the
values in each buffer zone using Eq. (3) for both location factors regions beyond a distance of 5 km from the center of the town
(Fig. 6). From the town center Har ki Pauri, entropy was found to (Fig. 7). Urban development in 1998 and 2000 indicates that the
follow the distance decay pattern (decresing) for the 1989 year, majority of developments are towards dispersed development
whereas in the 1998, 2000 and 2002 years, it follows a zig-zag rather than concentrated development.
pattern. This indicates that random development took place in
the Haridwar town and it is essential to develop future plans for 5. Conclusions
(i) urbanization promotion areas, and (ii) urbanization control
areas. Further, in the case of distance from the highway along the In general, the urbanization has taken place either in a radial
upper Ganga canal, entropy followed the distance decay pattern direction around a well-established city or linearly along
for all data sets. The results shown in Fig. 7 indicate that entropy highways. Entropy is found to be effective for analysis of urban
values are decreasing as we move to farther distances and people development patterns and for future plans for (i) urbanization
prefer to have their industries and residences near the highway. promotion areas, and (ii) urbanization control areas. It enables to

Fig. 7. Spatial and Temporal Variation of Entropy Values

Vol. 12, No. 4 / July 2008 − 287 −


Ramakar Jha, Vijay P. Singh, and V. Vatsa

identify which town area has better spatial efficiency in land Masek, J.G., Lindsey, F.E., and Goward, S.N. (2000). “Dynamics of
development. The criteria used for selecting location factors urban growth in the Washington DC metropolitan area, 1973-1996
having buffer zones provide the primary basis for urban from Landsat observations.” International Journal of Remote
Sensing, Vol. 21, No. 18, pp. 3473-3486.
development in a town.
Medvedkov, Y.V. (1966). “Concept of entropy in settlement pattern
The results of analysis reveal that Haridwar has experienced analysis.” Papers and Proceedings of the Regional Science
random urban development at the dawn of the new millennium Association, Vol. 8, pp. 165-168.
with the lack of proper development control and management. Medvedkov, Y.V. (1967). “The regular component in Settlement Pattern
The dispersed pattern of land development identified by as shown on a map.” Soviet Geography, Vol. 8.
calculating entropy from multi-temporal satellites images shows Mesev, T. V., Longley P. A., Batty, M., and Sie, Y. (1995). “Morphology
a high degree of unplanned urban development and need due from imagery detecting and measuring the density of urban land
attention. use.” Environment and Planning. A-27, pp. 759-780.
Miller, J.G. (1969). Living systems: Basic concepts, Ib W. Gray et al.
(eds.) General Systems Theory and Psychiatry, Boston, MA.
References Morwitz, H.J. (1970). Entropy for Biologists, Academic Press, New
York, NY.
Batty, M. and Longley, P.A. (1994). Fractal cities: A geometry of form Nelson, R.F. (1983). “Detecting forest canopy change due to insect
and function, Academic Press, London. activity using Landsat MSS.” Photogrammetric Engineering and
Buckley, W. (ed.) (1968). Modern systems research for the behavioural Remote Sensing, Vol. 49, No. 9, pp. 1303-1314.
scientist, Aldine Publishing Company, Chicago, IL. Openshaw, S. (1991). A spatial analysis research agenda, handling
Chapman, G.P. (1977). Human and environmental systems: A geo- geographical information: Methodology and potential applications
grapher’s appraisal, Academic Press, London. (I. Masser, and M. Blackmore, editors), John Wiley & Sons, Inc.,
Dreher, D. W. and Price, T. H. (1992). Best management practice New York, NY, pp. 18-37.
guidebook for urban development, Northeastern Illinois Planning Pilon, P.G., Howarth, P.J., and Bullock, R.A. (1988). “An enhanced
Commission, Chicago, IL. classification approach to change detection in semi-arid environ-
Eastman, J.R. and Fulk, M. (1993). “Long sequence time series evalua- ments.” Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing, Vol.
tion using standardized prinicple components.” Photogrammetric 54, No. 12, pp. 1709-1716.
Engineering and Remote Sensing, Vol. 59, No. 6, pp. 991-996. Quastler, H. (1953). Information Theory in Biology, University of
Fast, J.D. (1970). Entropy, Philips, London. Illinois Press, Urbana, IL.
Fung, T. and LeDrew, E. (1987). “Application of principal components Quastler, H. (1955). Information theory in psychology, The Free Press,
analysis change detection.” Photogrammetric Engineering and Glencoe, IL.
Remote Sensing, Vol. 53, No. 12, pp. 1649-1658. Shannon, C.E. (1948). “A mathematical theory of communication.” Bell
Griffiths, G.H. (1988). “Monitoring urban change from Landsat TM and System Technical Journal, Vol. 27, pp. 378-423 and 623-656.
SPOT satellite imagery by imae differencing.” Proceedings of Singh, V.P. (2000).” The entropy theory as a tool for modelling and
IGARSS 1988, Edinburgh, Scotland, pp. 493-497. decision making in environmental and water resources.” Water SA,
Howarth, P.J. (1986). “Landsat digital enhancement for change detec- Vol. 26, No. 1, pp. 1-11.
tion in urban environment.” Remote Sensing of Environment, Vol. Thakur, B. (1972). Entropy studies in Geography. Unpublished paper,
13, pp. 149-160. Department of Geography, University of Waterloo, Canada, pp 1-79.
Howarth, P.J. and Wickware, G.M. (1981). “Procedures for change Thakur, B. (1979). Urban settlements in eastern india, entropy changes
detection using Landsat digital data.” International Journal of and pattern analysis, Concept Publishing Company, Delhi, India.
Remote Sensing, Vol. 2, No. 3, pp. 277-291. Theil, H. (1967). Economics and information theory, Amsterdam,
Jensen, J.R., Cowen, D.J., Althausen, J.D., Narumalani, SX., and North-Holland.
Weatherbee, O. (1993). “An evaluation of the coast watch change Thiell, H. (1972). Statistical decomposition analysis, Amsterdam, North
detection protocol in south carolina.” Photogrammetric Engineering Holland.
and Remote Sensing, Vol. 59, No. 6, pp. 1039-1046. Thomas, R.W. (1981). Information statistics in geography, W.H.
Jensen, J.R., Rutchey, K., Koch, M.S., and Narumalani, S. (1995). Hutchins & Sons, Norwich.
“Inland wetland change detection in Everglades water conservation Toll, D.L. (1980). “Urban area update procedures using Landsat data.”
area 2A using a time series of normalized remotely sensed data.” Proceedings, American Society of Photogrammetry, RS-E-1-17.
Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing, Vol. 61, No. 2, Turkstra J. (1996). “Urban growth and land use options for lower-
199-209. income groups: A case study of Villavicencio, Columbia.” ITC
Justice, C. O. (1986). “Monitoring the grassland of semi-arid Africa Journal, 1996-1, pp. 57-63.
using NOAA- AVHRR data.” International Journal of Remote Wyatt, P.A.H. (1967). “Energy and entropy in chemistry.” New York: St.
Sensing, Vol. 7, No. 11, pp. 1383-1622. Martins, NY, pp. 62-79.
Kullback, S. (1959). Statistics and Information Theory, John Wiley and Webster, C.J. (1995). “Urban morphological fingerprints.” Environments
Sons, New York, NY. and Planning B, Vol. 22, pp. 79-297.
Li, X. and Yeh, G.A.O. (1988). “Principal component analysis of Yeh, A.G.O. and Li, X. (1998). “Sustainable land development model
stacked multi-temporal images for monitoring of rapid urban for rapid growth areas using GIS.” International Journal of
expansion in the Pearl river delta.” International Journal of Remote Geographical Information Science, Vol. 12, No. 2, pp. 169-189.
Sensing, Vol. 19, No. 8, pp. 1501-1518.

− 288 − KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering

You might also like