İĪİĪ ÃĐĚCÉĐĄĚĊÐĐĄD AÐĐĆCÉCĐǼC ÐĐ ÅCǼČĐÐDÐĈĘ ĄĐB ĀÐDĊǼĘ ĊĐ ÁDCǼĚÉĊǼ ĀÐĔCÉ Ì ÁĐCÉĈĘ ĠÃAÅĞĀÁĀĢ

.DTDKNOLDMRN E/KDBRPHB=DGHBKD-G@PFHMF :R@RHNM

5@M@FDLDMR:WQRDLHM<PA@M+PD@Q

A_N`Raf\2WV 5V\[f`Vb`2YQV\[CR[NaN 2QV`N=N_N`NaV

.3C;?>3<,34?A3C?AG8 ?A)>7A9G
'?>E7AB;?>275:>?<?9G&#2+) 
%97>5G8 ?AC:7%BB7BB=7>C3>6
%@@<;53C;?>? 8275:>?<?9G&//2 
3N[aR[":[Q\[R`VN
]_N`Raf\$NWV1O]]a$T\$VQ
.3C;?>3<,34?A3C?AG8 ?A)>7A9G
'?>E7AB;?>275:>?<?9G&#2+) 
%97>5G8 ?AC:7%BB7BB=7>C3>6
%@@<;53C;?>? 8275:>?<?9G&//2 
3N[aR[":[Q\[R`VN
QV\[f`Vb`$NYQV\[1O]]a$T\$VQ
.3C;?>3<,34?A3C?AG8 ?A)>7A9G
'?>E7AB;?>275:>?<?9G&#2+) 
%97>5G8 ?AC:7%BB7BB=7>C3>6
%@@<;53C;?>? 8275:>?<?9G&//2 
3N[aR[":[Q\[R`VN
NQV`N$YN_N`NaV1O]]a$T\$VQ

CVgN
.3C;?>3<,34?A3C?AG8 ?A)>7A9G
'?>E7AB;?>275:>?<?9G&#2+) 
%97>5G8 ?AC:7%BB7BB=7>C3>6
%@@<;53C;?>? 8275:>?<?9G&//2 
3N[aR[":[Q\[R`VN
_VgN1O]]a$T\$VQ

"%231$&3  2M PDBDMR WD@PQ! PDQD@PBG @MC CDTDKNOLDMR NE
DKDBRPHB TDGHBKDQ G@TD ADDM OPNLNRDC HM 2MCNMDQH@ @Q MDU
RDBGMNKNFHDQ" ;GD OPNTHQHNM NE BG@PFHMF QR@RHNM -: 
HMEP@QRPSBRSPD ENP DKDBRPHB TDGHBKD /=  HQ DQQDMRH@K RN DMQSPD
EKDVHAHKHRW" 5@M@FHMF RGD /= -G@PFHMF :R@RHNM HQ BG@KKDMFDC
CSD RN BNLLSMHB@RHMF QDTDP@K AP@MCQ HMRN RGD BDMRP@K QWQRDL"
>D QSBBDQQESKKW CDTDKNODC RGD BG@PFHMF QR@RHNM L@M@FDLDMR
QWQRDL -:5: " +OOKHB@RHNM CDTDKNOLDMR HQ SQDC RN L@JD @
RNNKHMRGDENPLNE@-:5:@OOKHB@RHNMRNLNMHRNP@MCBNMRPNK
-:UHRG RGDM@LD :7624DKDBRPHBTDGHBKD BG@PFHMFNODP@RHNM
QWQRDL " ;GD QWQRDL @PBGHRDBRSPD @MC ODPENPL@MBD NE-:5:
G@Q ADDM QGNUM" ;GD CDQHFM NERGDQWQRDLG@Q ADDM BNMMDBRDC
RN & JHMCQ NE-: HM RGD RGPDD BHRHDQ HM RGD SPA@M @PD@" ;NR@KKW
$))&RHLDQ! -:HMIDBRDCRGDONUDPHMRNRGD/=EPNL3@MS@PWRN
+OPHK %#%#" 0PNL RGD EHKKHMFQ NE RGPDD QR@RHNMQ! RGD ,88;
;G@LPHMQR@RHNMHM-DMRP@K3@J@PR@HQRGDASQHDQRQR@RHNMUHRG@
BNLOKDRD EHKKHMF NE $('( RHLDQ EPNL 3@MS@PW RN +OPHK %#%#"
1HFGSQ@FD@R,88;;G@LPHMQR@RHNMHQ CSDRN@K@PFDMSLADP
NE BSQRNLDPQ EPNL BNMTDMRHNM@K R@VHQ! NMKHMD R@VHQ! OPHT@RD
TDGHBKDQ!@MCNEEHBH@KTDGHBKDQ",DQHCDQ!RGDKDTDKNE@BRHTHRWEPNL
RGD @PD@ @PNSMC RGD QR@RHNM HQ @KQN GHFG! BNMQHCDPHMF RG@R HR HQ
RGDBDMRDPNEFNTDPMLDMR@MCASQHMDQQ"
#(65/1'2X'(4(,/0-(.3 (,(&31+& 4(*+&,( &*$1)+.) 23$3+/.
&*$1)+.)23$3+/.-$.$)(-(.32623(-!
:$ :? E C @ 5 F 4 E :@ ?
:[ _RPR[a fRN_`" _R`RN_PU N[Q QRcRY\]ZR[a \S RYRPa_VP
cRUVPYR`UNcRORR[]_\Z\aRQN`\[R\SaUR [RdaRPU[\Y\TVR`
N[Q[Rd`R_cVPR`V[aURd\_YQ\Sa_N[`]\_aNaV\[ L'M$ 2aaR[aV\[
a\ 6GV` V[P_RN`RQ QbR a\ R[cV_\[ZR[aNY SNPa\_`$ EUR_RS\_R"
aUR ]_R]N_NaV\[\SV[S_N`a_bPab_R dVaU]bOYVP RYRPa_VP cRUVPYR
PUN_TV[T`aNaV\[`ORP\ZRNSb[QNZR[aNYaUV[TL(M$
9N_QdN_R N[Q `\SadN_R QRcRY\]ZR[a \S ]bOYVP RYRPa_VP
cRUVPYR PUN_TV[T NY`\ [RRQ` a\ VZ]_\cR a\ P\YYRPa" a_N[`ZVa"
N[Q ]_\PR`` aUR QNaN ON`RQ \[ aUR QNaN \OaNV[RQ \[ aUR
PUN_TV[T`aNaV\[UN_QdN_R L)M$ EUR_RS\_R"aURQRcRY\]ZR[a\S
b`RSbY 4D ZN[NTRZR[a `\SadN_R UN` N[ VZ]\_aN[a _\YR a\
]YNf V[ V[P_RN`V[T Pb`a\ZR_ P\[cR[VR[PR" V[P_RN`V[T baVYVaf
`R_cVPR`" N[Q V[P_RN`V[T aUR VZ]NPa \S 6G \[ RYRPa_VPNY
`f`aRZ` L*M$
:[ :[Q\[R`VN" aUR QRcRY\]ZR[a \S RYRPa_VP PN_` ORTN[ V[
(&'($ 2aaUNaaVZR" N]_\a\af]R\SN[RYRPa_VPcRUVPYRZNQRV[
:[Q\[R`VNaUNa]_\QbPRQ N[ RYRPa_VP cRUVPYR [NZRQ DRY\ dN`
ReUVOVaRQNaaUR2`VNANPVSVP6P\[\ZVP4\\]R_NaV\[ 2A64!
DbZZVa V[ 3NYV V[ (&')$ :[ aUR `RP\[Q ]R_V\Q \S]_R`VQR[a
;\X\dV` NQZV[V`a_NaV\[" aUR QRcRY\]ZR[a \S RYRPa_VP PN_`
_Rab_[RQ$ :[(&'-" VadN` V[VaVNaRQOf aUR ZV[V`a_f \SR[R_Tf
N[Q ZV[R_NY _R`\b_PR` a\ NPPRYR_NaR aUR T_\daU \S RYRPa_VP
cRUVPYR`V`]YN[[RQ"dVaUaURV[VaVNY`aR]`\SP\[`\YVQNaV[TaUR
`aNXRU\YQR_`" Q_NSaV[T N ]_R`VQR[aVNY QRP_RR" N[Q ]_R]N_V[T
6GV[S_N`a_bPab_R$
EUR]_\cV`V\[\SPUN_TV[T`aNaV\[V[S_N`a_bPab_RS\_6GV`
R``R[aVNY a\ R[`b_R 6G SYReVOVYVaf$ 7\_ aUV` _RN`\[" Va V`
[RPR``N_fa\ QRcRY\]NPUN_TV[T`aNaV\[dVaUNUVTUR_]\dR_"
X[\d[ N` aUR DA<=F ]bOYVP RYRPa_VP cRUVPYR PUN_TV[T
`aNaV\[!" NY\[T dVaU `b]]\_aV[T N]]YVPNaV\[` a\ SNPVYVaNaR aUR
]bOYVP dU\ PUN_TR aUR cRUVPYR$ EUR 2TR[Pf S\_ aUR
N``R``ZR[aN[QN]]YVPNaV\[\SaRPU[\Y\Tf 3AAE!QRcRY\]RQ
aUR P\[SVTb_NaV\[\SaUR 4D `f`aRZ V[ (&'. a\ (&'/$ 3N`RQ
\[aUR _R`RN_PU ZN`aR_]YN[dUR_R 3AAE dN` V[c\YcRQ V[N
P\[`\_aVbZ\SRYRPa_VPcRUVPYR`"3AAES\Pb`RQ\[QRcRY\]V[T
aUR PUN_TV[T `aNaV\[\[6G$ 4D aRPU[\Y\Tf V` `aVYY P\[a_\YYRQ
Of `RcR_NYYN_TR cR[Q\_`%P\Z]N[VR`$ EUR `f`aRZ` QRcRY\]RQ
Of RNPU P\Z]N[f N_R \]R[" N[Q `\ZR N_R [\a \]R[ `\ aUNa
aURf N_R V[P\Z]NaVOYR \_ b[NOYR a\ P\ZZb[VPNaR$ EUR
QRcRY\]ZR[a UN` `bPPR``SbYYf V[aRT_NaRQ `RcR_NY 4D O_N[Q`
N[Q QRcRY\]RQ aUR 4D>D ON`RQ \[ aUR \]R[ PUN_TR ]\V[a
]_\a\P\Y!@4AA$
A_baUcV" E$G RaNY$ L+M UNcR _RcVRdRQaURVZ]YRZR[aNaV\[
\S @4AA V[ 4D>D dUVPU V` QV`]YNfRQ \[ N ]_VZN_f b`R_
V[aR_SNPR$ >RN[dUVYR" dR QRcRY\]RQ 4D>D b] a\ aUR
VZ]YRZR[aNaV\[`aNTR V[P\ZZR_PVNY6GN[Q 4D dVaUN b`R_
V[aR_SNPR aUNa ZNXR` Va RN`VR_S\_\]R_Na\_` \_ZN[bSNPab_R_`
a\ Z\[Va\_ 4D NPP\_QV[Ta\ aUR @4AA]_\a\P\Y$ EUR 4D>D
`f`aRZaUNa dR UNcR QRcRY\]RQ UN` NY`\ N]]YVRQ a\ Z\[Va\_
]\dR_ ZN[NTRZR[a Na aUR 4D Y\PNaV\[ L,M" P\[`VQR_V[T aUNa

KJĴĞĬĞJİĴĬĞĴĴĮIJĞIJĜİĪĜĨĮĬGĪĪ
Authorized ÍİĪİĪ
licensed use limited to: Institut Teknologi $** on May 01,2021 at 21:16:20 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
ÃÁÁÁNopember. Downloaded
Sepuluh
aUR P\[[RPaV\[dVaUaUR `ZN_aT_VQ `f`aRZdVYY NY`\ QRcRY\] P\[[RPa\_dVYY `RaN ZNeVZbZPb__R[ab`NTRcNYbRON`RQ\[
ÁǺ AĂ AĂÄ Ă

ÊCĚ ĎĄĖ ǼËÉÉCĐĚ ĠDĊĎĊĚĢ

ÊĔĊD
ÊĔĊĚǼČ EÐĔCÉ ÐĐ ĠĢ


ĂĚĄÉĚÅÉĄĐÊĄǼĚĊÐĐGÉCÈĠǼÐĐĐCǼĚÐÉÃBG
ÊĚĄÉĚ ǼČĄÉĈĊĐĈ ĠĢ
ĊBÅĄĈF ĎCĚCÉĂĚĄÉĚF ĚĊĎ CÊĚĄĎEF HÉCÊCÉĒĄĚĊÐĐÃÀĤĢ

ĂĚĄÉĚÅÉĄĐÊĄǼĚĊÐĐGǼÐĐĆĠĊBÅĄĈÃ ĐĆÐF ĚÉĄĐÊĄǼĚĊÐĐÃBĢ

?
CĐB ǼČĄÉĈĊĐĈĠĢ

ÊĔĊĚǼČ EÐĔCÉ ÐĆĆĠĢ

ĂĚÐEÅÉĄĐÊĄǼĚĊÐĐGÉCÈĠĎ CĚCÉĂĚÐEF ĚĊĎCÊĚĄĎEF
ĚÉĄĐÊĄǼĚĊÐĐÃBF ÉCĄÊÐĐF HĊBÅĄĈĤF HĚÉĄĐÊĄǼĚĊÐĐÀĄĚĄĤĢ

ĂĚÐEÅÉĄĐÊĄǼĚĊÐĐGǼÐĐĆĠĊBÅĄĈÃĐĆÐĢ

7VT$ '$2`R^bR[PR\S6G4UN_TV[T 7VT$)$EURZNV[ZR[b\S4D>D#D@?:<

AÐĐĚÉÐD ACĐĚCÉ
Ă ĀǺĂĀÀĀÅAÂÈ Ă ĀĀÅ ÅCĄĊĐĆÇÈ
ĂǼĐĎDÇB ǼÇÐĐĄČ ÁĄĈĄĐÐĄ
7VT$($EUR`f`aRZN_PUVaRPab_R\S4D>D
V[aURSbab_R$
:[ aUV` ]N]R_" aUR NbaU\_ dVYY ]_R`R[a N PUN_TV[T
ZN[NTRZR[a`f`aRZaUNaUN`ORR[VZ]YRZR[aRQV[aUR b_ON[
N_RN$ :[ aUR `RP\[Q PUN]aR_" aUR NbaU\_ QV`Pb``R` aUR
N_PUVaRPab_R \S aUR `f`aRZ N[Q YRNQ` a\ QNaN aUNa PN[ OR
NP^bV_RQ" `a\_RQ" N[Q ]_\PR``RQ$ :[ aUR aUV_Q PUN]aR_" aUR
NbaU\_ dVYY `U\d aUR _R`bYa` aUNa UNcR ORR[ \OaNV[RQ
S\YY\dV[T `RcR_NY QV`Pb``V\[` a\ Re]YNV[ aUR PUN_TV[T
P\[QVaV\[` \SRNPUSVYYV[T `aNaV\[$ 4UN_TV[T]R_S\_ZN[PR PN[
NY`\ORQRZ\[`a_NaRQV[4D>D `\SadN_R" `U\d[\[aURV[VaVNY
ZR[bQV`]YNf"OVYYV[T"N[Q_R]\_aV[T$
::$ > 6 E 9 @ 5 @ = @ 8 J 2 ? 5  D4 9 6 > 6
%! 1GBC7=%A5:;C75CDA7
D\?:< V` N `\SadN_R N` N[ N__N[TRZR[a S\_ PUN_TV[T
`aNaV\[` S\_ ]bOYVP RYRPa_VP cRUVPYR` V[ 3AAE$ 2]]YVPNaV\[
QRcRY\]ZR[a V` b`RQa\ ZNXR N a\\Y V[aUR S\_Z\SN 4D>D
N]]YVPNaV\[a\Z\[Va\_N[QP\[a_\Y4DdVaUaUR[NZR D\?:<$
D\?:< UN` P\[[RPaRQ aUR aU_RR 4D Y\PNaRQ V[ D\baU
EN[TR_N[T" 4R[a_NY ;NXN_aN" N[Q 3N[Qb[T$ 7VT$ '$ Re]YNV[`
aUR `R^bR[PR \S6G PUN_TV[T aUNa P\[[RPaRQ a\ 4D>D N` N
PR[a_NY `f`aRZ$ 3RS\_R aUR PUN_TV[T ]_\PR`` ORTV[`" aUR
aURQRSNbYaPUN_TV[T]_\SVYRaUNa]_RcV\b`Yf `]RPVSVRQOfY\PNY
ĄǼÇĞCĐB P\[a_\YYR_$ EUR[" aUR 4D `aN_a` PUN_TV[TaUR 6GN[Q `R[Q` N
ĂCÉĒCÉ
À ĂCÉĒCÉ DaN_aE_N[`NPaV\[$_R^ N` N ZR``NTR a\ aUR 4D>D$ HUR[ aUR
PUN_TV[TR[Q`" 4D `R[Q`N Da\]E_N[`NPaV\[$_R^N`NZR``NTR
a\V[S\_ZVa`PUN_TV[T`aNab`a\aUR4D>D L-M$
ËĚČCĐĚĊǼĄĚĊÐĐ
ĂCÉĒCÉ
EURP\Z]\[R[a`V[N4D `f`aRZN_RP\[[RPaRQa\NPY\`RQ
[Rad\_X$ 5NaN _R`bYa` S_\Z aUR R^bV]ZR[a `R[a \cR_ 7VYR
ĀĄĘĎCĐĚ ÂĄĚCĔĄĘ
E_N[`SR_A_\a\P\Y 7EA! PNOYR a\ 4D>D N_R aUR[ `a\_RQN[Q
]_\PR``RQ\[aUR `R_cR_$ 2dRO#ON`RQZ\[Va\_V[TN]]YVPNaV\[
aUNaV` V[`aNYYRQ\[aUR `R_cR_\[Qbaf a\]_R]N_R N[QQV`]YNf
aURQNaN$ :[7VT$($ 4D>DQR`VT[UN`ORR[V[a_\QbPRQa\ `U\d
ÄÐÆĊDCĜÀCÊÇĚÐE aUR _R`bYa` \S aUR Z\[Va\_V[T$ EUR P\ZZb[VPNaV\[ [Rad\_X
EEDĊǼĄĚĊÐĐ
Ă ĀÅ ÃAÄÈ aUNaUN`ORR[P\[[RPaRQa\ 4DV`NdV_RYR``[Rad\_X L.M$ ?\a
ĄÇÆEÇB \[Yf UN` QR`VT[RQ N[Q `VZbYNaRQ Oba NY`\ VZ]YRZR[aRQ aUR
`f`aRZ `\ aUNa Va PN[ P\[[RPa aU_RR P` V[ _RNY#aVZR N[Q
PR[a_NYYf$
'
&! '1-1% @@<;53C;?>(7B;9>
:[ 7VT$ )$ DU\d` aUR ZNV[ ZR[b$ 7_\Z aUR QV`]YNf"
`RcR_NYObaa\[`PN[ORPYVPXRQa\ R[aR_\aUR_YV`a`aUNa]_\cVQR
Z\_R QRaNVYRQV[S\_ZNaV\[$ 5RaNVYRQV[S\_ZNaV\[PN[OR `RR[
V[ QVSSR_R[a ZR[b` `bPU N` PUN_TV[T `aNaV\[`" Pb`a\ZR_`"
NYR_a`"NPaVcVaf"a_N[`NPaV\[`"_R]\_a`"N[QNQZV[V`a_Na\_`$ 2SaR_
R[aR_V[T aUR ZNV[ ZR[b" aUR NQZV[ TRa` `\ZR V[S\_ZNaV\[
S_\ZaURZNV[ZR[b" `bPUN`_RPR[aa_N[`NPaV\[QNaN" Pb__R[a
4Db`NTR"4DY\PNaV\[ZN]"N[QNPPbZbYNaRQR[R_TfP\`a`$
7VT$ *$ Re]YNV[` aUR b`R QVNT_NZ \SaUR ]_VZN_f ZR[b
]_\PR``$ EUR NPa\_ V[aUV` b`R PN`R V` aUR NQZV[V`a_Na\_$ 2[
NQZV[V`a_Na\_ PN[ NPPR`` NYY aUR SRNab_R` NcNVYNOYR V[ aUR
4D>D N]]YVPNaV\[$ 5NaN ZN[NTRZR[a V[ aUR b`R PN`R
V[PYbQR` cVRd" NQQ" b]QNaR" N[Q QRYRaR QNaN$ E\ NPPR``
RYRZR[a` V[ aUR 4D>D N]]YVPNaV\[" N b`R_ NQZV[V`a_Na\_!
Zb`a Y\T V[ SV_`a b`V[T N b`R_[NZR R#ZNVY! N[Q ]N``d\_Q
aUNaUNcRORR[_RTV`aR_RQ]_RcV\b`Yf$ EURS\YY\dV[TV`NO_VRS
Re]YN[NaV\[\SaURb`RPN`RQVNT_NZNO\cR0
h AR_`\[NY ]_\SVYR ZN[NTRZR[a >f A_\SVYR >R[b V[
4D>D N]]YVPNaV\[!0 V[ aUV` b`R PN`R" aUR NQZV[ PN[
PUN[TR aUR ]R_`\[NY QNaN `bPU N` [NZR N[Q R#ZNVY$
2]N_aS_\ZaUNa" aUR NQZV[V`a_Na\_PN[NY`\ `RaaUR [Rd
]N``d\_Q$

%## on May 01,2021 at 21:16:20 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember. Downloaded
 7VT$ +$EUR2PaVcVaf5VNT_NZ\S5N`UO\N_Q>R[b

7VT$*$F`R4N`R5VNT_NZ4D>D#D@?:<

h 5V`]YNf \S 4D b`NTR \cR_cVRd QN`UO\N_Q ZR[b!0 V[

aUV` `RPaV\[" aUR NQZV[ PN[ \[Yf QV`]YNf TR[R_NY
V[S\_ZNaV\[ _RYNaRQ a\ 4D P\[QVaV\[`" `bPU N` a\aNY
b`NTR" a\aNY R[R_Tf P\`a`" aUR NZ\b[a \S R[R_Tf
Re]R[QRQ"aURYN`ab`R\SRNPU4D"RaP$
h 4D QNaN ZN[NTRZR[a ZR[b PUN_TV[T `aNaV\[!0 NQZV[
PN[QV`]YNf V[S\ _RYNaRQa\ P\[[RPaRQ 4D" NQQ [Rd 4D
QNaN" PUN[TR N[Q QRYRaR ReV`aV[T 4D QNaN" N[Q
Q\d[Y\NQ 4D QNaN _R]\_a` V[ P\ZZN#`R]N_NaRQ cNYbR`
4DG!S\_ZNa$
h 4b`a\ZR_ QNaN ZN[NTRZR[a Pb`a\ZR_ ZR[b!0 aUR
NQZV[PN[QV`]YNf V[S\ _RYNaRQa\ _RTV`aR_RQPb`a\ZR_`" 7VT$,$EUR2PaVcVaf5VNT_NZ\S4D5\d[Y\NQCR]\_a
NQQ [Rd Pb`a\ZR_ QNaN" PUN[TR N[Q QRYRaR ReV`aV[T
Pb`a\ZR_QNaN" N[Q Q\d[Y\NQ Pb`a\ZR_QNaN _R]\_a` V[
4DGS\_ZNa$ 2Y`\" NQZV[`PN[\]R[%OY\PXPb`a\ZR_VQ '! '1-1% @@<;53C;?>/A?57BB*<?F
aNT`$ " (3B:4?3A6
h 5V`]YNf \S4D NYR_a` ZR[b NYR_a!0 V[ aUV` `RPaV\[" aUR 7VT$ +`U\d`aURQN`UO\N_Q]NTR V`NY`\aURZNV[]NTR\S
NQZV[PN[\[YfQV`]YNfUV`a\_VPNYQNaNNYR_a`V[RNPU4D aUR 4D>D N]]YVPNaV\[$ \ [  aUV` ]NTR" aUR b`R_ NQZV[! PN[
P\[[RPaRQ$ 3R`VQR`" aUR QNaN ]_R`R[aRQ PN[ OR cVRdTR[R_NYV[S\_ZNaV\[_RYNaRQa\ 4DP\[QVaV\[``bPUN`aUR
Q\d[Y\NQRQV[4DGS\_ZNa$ [bZOR_ \S4D b`NTR" [bZOR_ \S`f`aRZSNVYb_R`" aUR ]\dR_
h 5V`]YNf \S 4D NPaVcVaVR` ZR[b NPaVcVaf!0 V[ aUV` QRYVcR_RQ" R[R_Tf P\`a`" YN`ab`R \SRNPU4D" N[Q ZN] \SaUR
`RPaV\["aUR NQZV[PN[QV`]YNf UV`a\_VPNYQNaN\SRcR[a` Y\PNaV\[]\V[a\SRNPU4D$
aUNa \PPb_ V[ RNPU 4D aUNa V` P\[[RPaRQ N[Q PN[ # ':3A9;>91C3C;?>
Q\d[Y\NQVaV[4DGS\_ZNa 7_\ZaUR ZNV[ ]NTR \SaUV` 4UN_TV[T DaNaV\[ ZR[b" aUR
h 5V`]YNf \Sa_N[`NPaV\[ 4D a_N[`NPaV\[ ZR[b!0 V[ aUV` b`R_ PN[ NQQ N [Rd 4D" cVRd QRaNVYRQ 4D V[S\_ZNaV\[" N[Q
`RPaV\[" aUR NQZV[ PN[ QV`]YNf UV`a\_VPNY QNaN \S Q\d[Y\NQ4DQNaNV[4DGS\_ZNa$ F`R_`PN[NY`\PUN[TRaUR
a_N[`NPaV\[` aUNa \PPb_ V[ RNPU 4D aUNa V` P\[[RPaRQ QRaNVY`N[QQRYRaR4DQNaNaUNaUN`ORR[V[]baaRQ$
N[QPN[Q\d[Y\NQVaV[4DGS\_ZNa$
$ (?F><?3607@?AC
h 5V`]YNf N[[bNY _R]\_a 4D ZR[b _R]\_a!0 NQZV[ PN[
HUR[aUR b`R_NPPR``R`aUR ]NTR \[aUR PUN_TV[T `aNaV\[
QV`]YNf QNaN _RYNaRQ a\ a\aNY ]\dR_ b`NTR" R[R_Tf" N[Q
ZR[b" aUR `f`aRZdVYY QV`]YNf NYV`a \S_RTV`aR_RQ 4D$ F`R_`
R[R_Tf P\`a` O\aU \cR_NYY N[Q ]R_ 4D S\_ \[R fRN_$ PN[Q\d[Y\NQaURQNaNV[4 D GS\_ZNaV[7VT$,$
CR]\_a`V[aUR4DGReaR[`V\[PN[NY`\ORQ\d[Y\NQRQ$
h 2QZV[QNaNZN[NTRZR[a NQZV[V`a_Na\_ZR[b!0 NQZV[`
PN[ NQQ" PUN[TR" N[Q QRYRaR NQZV[ QNaN$ 2QZV[ PN[
:::$ C 6 D F = E D 2 ? 5 5 :D 4 F D D :@ ?
NY`\ _R`Ra aUR ]N``d\_Q \S \aUR_ _RTV`aR_RQ b`R_`$
3R`VQR`aUNa"dRPN[NY`\Q\d[Y\NQNQZV[QNaNV[a\aUR :[ 7VT$ - N! dR QV`]YNf aUR NPaVcVaf ZR[b dVaU `\ZR
4DG_R]\_a$ V[S\_ZNaV\[\OaNV[RQ"[NZRYfaURNZ\b[a\SdUR[N[QdUR_R
h 5V`]YNf \S_RNY#aVZR `aNab`0 QV`]YNf` aUR `aNab` \SRNPU aUR PUN_TV[T NPaVcVaf a\\X ]YNPR N[Q aUR O_VRS 2PaVcVaf
4DV[_RNY#aVZR$ V[S\_ZNaV\[$ :[ aUV` ZR[b" aUR NQZV[ PN[ `RR `\ZR

%#$ on May 01,2021 at 21:16:20 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember. Downloaded
V[S\_ZNaV\[N[QQ\d[Y\NQQNaNaUNaPN[OR Q\[R N` N_R]\_a$
5NaNS_\ZNQNaNON`R PN[OR Q\d[Y\NQRQV[aURS\_Z\SaRea
SVYR`" RePRY SVYR`" \_ 4DG$ 6NPU NPaVcVaf PN[ OR V[S\_ZRQ
NO\baaURaf]R\SPUN_TR_" PUN_TRO\e:5"aVZR" `aNab`"cR[Q\_"
N[Q aUR YN`a ZR``NTR \S aUR PUN_TV[T NPaVcVaf$ 5NaN
NPPbZbYNaRQS_\ZSVYYV[T\]R_NaV\[` PN[NY`\OR \OaNV[RQOf
TNaUR_V[T QNaN `aN_aV[T S_\Z N[ N[[bNY" Z\[aUYf" QNVYf" N[Q
a\aNY NPPbZbYNaV\[$ :[7VT$ - O! dR `U\d aUR NPaVcVaf ZR[b
V[\b_`ZN_aT_VQ]YNaS\_Z$:[aUR]YNaS\_Z" NYYaURZ\[Va\_V[T
`f`aRZ `bPU N` 4D>D" ObVYQV[T R[R_Tf Z\[Va\_V[T" AG
_\\Sa\] Z\[Va\_V[T" N[Q dRNaUR_ Z\[Va\_V[T UN` ORR[
P\[[RPaRQ$
R[R_Tf PNYPbYNaV\[` ]R_ Pb`a\ZR_$ EUR QNaNON`R QNaN PN[OR
Q\d[Y\NQRQ V[ aUR S\_Z \S aRea SVYR`" 6ePRY SVYR`" \_ 4DG
5NaNNPPbZbYNaRQS_\ZSVYYV[TNPaVcVaVR`PN[NY`\OR\OaNV[RQ
OfP\YYRPaV[TQNaN`aN_aV[TS_\ZfRN_YfN[QZ\[aUYf$
:[7VT$ /$ RYRPa_VP cRUVPYR PUN_TRQS_\Z;N[bN_f a\ 2]_VY
(&(&$ 5b_V[TaUR S\b_ Z\[aU`" 4D b`NTR _RNPURQ N a\aNY \S
',,)$ 5RaNVY`\SVa`b`R N_R '-- V[;N[bN_f" )+) V[7RO_bN_f"
,/* V[ >N_PU" N[Q *)/ V[ 2]_VY ENOYR :!$ 4\[`bZ]aV\[ V[
>Nf dN` aR_ZV[NaRQ" TVcR[aUR RZR_TR[Pf 4\cVQ#'/ V[ aUR
PVafdUR_RaUR4DdN`V[`aNYYRQ$
>RN[dUVYR" 4D b`NTR V` Z\[Va\_RQ Of 4D>D ON`RQ \[
SVYYV[T`aNaV\[`$ 3N`RQ\[SVYYV[T `aNaV\[` `U\d`" b`R Na3AAE

E23=6:$4D>@?:E@C:?832D65@?DE2E:@?D

;NR@K/MDPFW ;NR@K-NQR
;NR@K
/=-: -NMQSLORHNM NE/MDPFW
<Q@FD
J>G 2.9
3N[Qb[T`aNaV\[ (, ')/ ()&'+*
3AAEAb`]V]aRX
/( +/* /.&,))
`aNaV\[
3AAEaUNZ_V[
'+*+ +(*'* .,*.(,-*
`aNaV\[


ĮIJĪĪĪ
ĮĪĪĪĪ

ĞĦGIGIGĦÃĦ

ĬIJĪĪĪ

Y Y
;2 ? F 2 C J 763CF 2 CJ > 2C49

mE @ E 2 = F D 2 8 6

E @ E 2 = 6 ? 6 C 8 J 4 @ ? D F > A E :@ ?  < H 9 !

E @ E 2 = 4 @ D E @ 7 6 ? 6 C 8 J  E 9 @ F D 2 ? 5 :5 C !

O! 7VT$/$F`R\SPUN_TV[TS_\Z;N[bN_fa\2]_VY(&(&

EUNZ_V[ `aNaV\[V[4R[a_NY;NXN_aN V`cR_f UVTUP\Z]N_RQa\

7VT$-$ N!2PaVcVafZR[bQV`]YNf\[4D>DN[Q O!2PaVcVafZR[b\[
DZN_a8_VQ]YNaS\_Z

7VT$ '&$CRNY#aVZRZ\[Va\_V[T\S4D`VaR3AAEEUNZ_V[

7VT$.$CR]\_aZR[bQV`]YNf \aUR_ `aNaV\[`$ CRPN]VabYNaV\[ R[R_Tf P\[`bZ]aV\[ V`

:[ 7VT$ .$ _R]\_a ZR[b QV`]YNf` dVaU `\ZR PUN_TV[T
V[S\_ZNaV\[aUNa UN` \PPb__RQ$ :[aUV` ZR[b" aUR NQZV[ PN[
`RR V[S\_ZNaV\[ `bPU N` QNaN NPPbZbYNaV\[ \S R[R_Tf
PNYPbYNaV\[` ]R_ Z\[aU" R[R_Tf PNYPbYNaV\[` ]R_ 4D" N[Q
QRaNVYRQ0 3N[Qb[T `aNaV\[dVaUaUR a\aNY R[R_Tf P\[`bZ]aV\[
\S ')/ XHU" aUR 3AAEAb`]V]aRX `aNaV\[ D\baUEN[TR_N[T!
dVaU aUR a\aNY R[R_Tf P\[`bZ]aV\[ \S +/* XHU" N[Q aUR
3AAE EUNZ_V[ `aNaV\[ ;NXN_aN! dVaU aUR a\aNY R[R_Tf
P\[`bZ]aV\[+(*'*XHU$

%#% on May 01,2021 at 21:16:20 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember. Downloaded
 9VTU b`NTR Na EUNZ_V[ 3AAE `aNaV\[ V` QbR a\ N YN_TR
[bZOR_ \SPb`a\ZR_` S_\Z P\[cR[aV\[NY aNeV`" \[YV[R aNeV`"
]_VcNaR cRUVPYR`" N[Q \SSVPVNY cRUVPYR`$ 3R`VQR`" aUR YRcRY \S
NPaVcVaf S_\Z aUR N_RN N_\b[Q aUR `aNaV\[ V` NY`\ UVTU
P\[`VQR_V[T aUR Y\PNaV\[ \S aUR `aNaV\[ V[ aUR PR[aR_ \S
T\cR_[ZR[a N[Q Ob`V[R`` V[ aUR PN]VaNY PVaf \S ;NXN_aN
P\Z]N_RQ a\ aUR 3AAE Ab`]V]aRX `aNaV\[" dUVPU V` N
aRPU[\Y\Tf _R`RN_PU N[Q QRcRY\]ZR[a PR[aR_ N[Q 3N[Qb[T
`aNaV\[ dUVPU V` aUR PR[aR_ \S aUR ZN[bSNPab_V[T V[Qb`a_f$
3AAEAb`]V]aRX`aNaV\[N[Q3N[Qb[T`aNaV\[N_RdVQRYfb`RQ
S\_aR`acRUVPYR`N[Q\SSVPVNYcRUVPYR`$
:[7VT$ '& `U\d` N_R SVYYV[T ]\dR_ V[ _RNY#aVZR$ HR TRa
aUV` QRaNVYRQ SVYYV[T Na `aNaV\[` aUNa UNcR UVTU SVYYV[T _NaR`"
[NZRYf3AAE EUNZ_V[`aNaV\[$ 7_\ZaUR `aNaV\[" aUROb`VR`a
SVYYV[T_NaR V`\OaNV[RQQb_V[Td\_XV[TU\b_`" dUVPUV`&.$&&
a\ '-$&&$ EUR PUN_TV[T aVZR NSaR_ d\_XV[T U\b_` V` NO\cR
'.$&&" N[QaUR b`NTR _NaR V` _RYNaVcRYf UVTU$ HR N``bZR aUNa
PUN_TV[T V` PN__VRQ \ba Of aNeV Q_VcR_` dU\ N_R `aVYY
\]R_NaV\[NY Na [VTUa$ >RN[dUVYR" PUN_TV[TV[aUR Z\_[V[T V`
]N_aYf b`RQ Of \SSVPVNY cRUVPYR` N[Q aR`a cRUVPYR` aUNa N_R
b`RSbY N` Sb[PaV\[NY\]R_NaV\[` \ST\cR_[ZR[a" _R`RN_PU" N[Q
aRPU[\Y\TfQRcRY\]ZR[a$
7bab_R d\_X dVYY OR S\Pb`RQ \[ QRcRY\]V[T _R`R_cNaV\[
N[Q `PURQbYV[TSRNab_R`aUNaPN[OR Q\[ROf Pb`a\ZR_`$ EUV`
_R`R_cNaV\[]_\PR``dVYYORPN__VRQ\baV[QRaNVYOfaURZ\OVYR
N]]YVPNaV\[$ EUR Z\OVYR N]] dVYY OR N[ NQQVaV\[NY a\\Y"
R`]RPVNYYf S\_ Pb`a\ZR_` dU\ dVYY PUN_TR RYRPa_VP cRUVPYR`$
EUR QRcRY\]ZR[a \S NYT\_VaUZ` V[ `PURQbYV[T N[Q
_R`R_cNaV\[` V` NY`\ R``R[aVNY V[ L/M" dUVPU QRcRY\]`
_R`R_cNaV\[` ON`RQ \[ 4D NcNVYNOVYVaf" N ]\dR_ _NaV[T \SaUR
cRUVPYR" N[Q PUN_TV[T V[S\_ZNaV\[ ]YbT af]R" YRcRY \S
PUN_TV[T`aNaV\["N[QQb_NaV\[\SSVYYV[T!$
EUR QRcRY\]ZR[a \SN QVSSR_R[a PUN_TV[T NYT\_VaUZ PN[
VZ]YRZR[a N[ V[aRYYVTR[a PUN_TV[T `f`aRZ S\_ aUR P\[QVaV\[
N[QNcNVYNOVYVaf\SR[R_TfNaaUR4DN_RP\[[RPaRQV[N[RN_Of
RYRPa_VPVaf[Rad\_X$ EUV`V`NY`\ V[YV[RdVaUaURQRcRY\]ZR[a
]_\]\`RQ Of 8R[T V[ aUR ]_R`` L'&M" dU\ QRcRY\]RQ N[
V[aRYYVTR[a PUN_TV[T `f`aRZ aUNa V` P\b]YRQ ORadRR[ aUR 6G
PUN_TV[T`f`aRZN[QaUR]\dR_QV`a_VObaV\[`f`aRZ$
3R`VQR`" 4D>D#ON`RQ @4AA PN[ OR QRcRY\]RQ dVaU
_R`R_cNaV\[a\ R[UN[PR aUR NOVYVaf \SVa$ @_PV\[V V[aUR ]_R``
UN`QRcRY\]RQaURQRcRY\]ZR[a\S4D>DdVaUO\\XV[T` L''M"
aNXV[T V[a\ NPP\b[a V[S\_ZNaV\[ `bPU N` PUN_TV[T aVZR"
PUN_TV[T aVZR" Y\PNaV\[" N[Q ]_VPR$ 4b`a\ZR_` PN[ ZNXR
_R`R_cNaV\[`cVNN`ZN_a]U\[RN]]YVPNaV\[aUNaV`P\[[RPaRQa\
aUR 4D [Rad\_X$ HVaUaUR T_\dV[T [bZOR_ \SPb`a\ZR_` V[
:[Q\[R`VN" aUR 4D>D#D@?:< SRNab_R dVYY OR Sb_aUR_
QRcRY\]RQ a\ NQQ P\[cR[VR[PR S\_ Pb`a\ZR_` V[ PUN_TV[T
RYRPa_VP cRUVPYR`$ 7b_aUR_Z\_R" aUR P\[[RPaRQ 4D [Rad\_X
dVYYNY`\OR Re]N[QRQS\YY\dV[TaURNQQVaV\[\S4D [Rad\_X`
OfbaVYVaVR`$
:G$ 4@ ? 4 = F D :@ ?
:[ aUV` _R`RN_PU" aUR QRcRY\]ZR[a \S N[ RYRPa_VP cRUVPYR
PUN_TV[TZN[NTRZR[a`f`aRZUN`ORR[Re]YNV[RQ$6cNYbNaV\[
N[Q]R_S\_ZN[PR \SaUR 4D>D#D\[VP UNcR NY`\ ORR[ `U\d[
a\ ]_\QbPR N _R]\_a NPPb`V[T aUNa PN[ SNPVYVaNaR aUR 4D
\]R_Na\_V[`RaaV[TaUR4D[Rad\_X$
D\[VX UN` P\[[RPaRQ ) 4D V[ aUR aU_RR PVaVR`" [NZRYf
4R[a_NY ;NXN_aN" D\baU EN[TR_N[T" N[Q 3N[Qb[T$ 7_\Z aUR
aU_RR SVYYV[T `aNaV\[`" aUR 3AAE EUNZ_V[ `aNaV\[ V[ 4R[a_NY
%#& on May 01,2021 at 21:16:20 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember. Downloaded
;NXN_aNV`aUROb`VR`a`aNaV\[dVaUNP\Z]YRaRSVYYV[T\S'$+*+
S_\Z;N[bN_fa\2]_VY(&(&$ HUVYRaUR3N[Qb[T`aNaV\[V`aUR
YRN`a`aNaV\[V[dUVPU\[Yf `R_cR`(,$ EURYRcRY\SPUN_TRUN`
ORR[QR`P_VORQOf4DPb`a\ZR_Re]RPaNaV\[`"V[P_RN`V[TdVaU
aUR [bZOR_ \S b`R_` \S RYRPa_VP cRUVPYR` \[ aUR `RPa\_ \S
]_VcNaR cRUVPYR`" ]bOYVP a_N[`]\_aNaV\[" N[Q T\cR_[ZR[a
`R_cVPRcRUVPYR`$ EUR T\cR_[ZR[aUN`a\ V[VaVNaRaUR]_\T_NZ
a\ T_\d aUR RP\`f`aRZ \S6G$ :a dVYY OR `b]]\_aRQ Of aUR
NcNVYNOVYVaf\S4DRY`RdUR_R"aUb`_RQbPV[TaURN[eVRaf\S6G
b`R_` NO\ba aUR b[NcNVYNOVYVaf \S 4D dUR[ aUR ONaaR_VR` N_R
ReUNb`aRQ$
C6 7 6 C 6 ? 4 6 D
L'M 2$?NVa#DVQV#>\U"2$CbgZRa\c">$3NXU\bfN" J$?NVaZNYRX"N[Q;$
8NOR_" i2 ]_RQVPaV\[ Z\QRY \SRYRPa_VP cRUVPYR PUN_TV[T _R^bR`a`"j
A_\PRQVN4\Z]ba$DPV$"c\Y$ '*'"]]$ '(-#')*"(&'.$
L(M J$ 4N\" E$ HN[T" @$ <NVdN_afN" 8$ >V[" ?$ 2UZNQ" N[Q 2$ 9$
2OQbYYNU"i2[6GPUN_TV[TZN[NTRZR[a`f`aRZP\[PR_[V[TQ_VcR_`k
a_V] Qb_NaV\[ N[Q Z\OVYVaf b[PR_aNV[af"j :666 E_N[`$ Df`a$ >N["
4fOR_[$Df`a$"c\Y$*."[\$*"]]$+/,#,&-"(&'.$
L)M J$ KUN[T" >$ KUN[T" N[Q ;$ JN[T" i5R`VT[\SR[R_TfZN[NTRZR[a
`f`aRZ` S\_ Z\OVYR ]\dR_ `aNaV\[ \S RYRPa_VP cRUVPYR`"j (&&/ :[a$
4\[S$ :[S$ >N[NT$ :[[\c$ >N[NT$ :[Q$ 6[T$ :4::: (&&/" c\Y$ *" ]]$
(+&#(+)"(&&/$
L*M >$ 8UN_ON\bV" 3$ >N_aV[V" C$ 3_b[\" =$ GNYPN_R[TUV" >$ 4\[aV" N[Q
A$4N`a\YQV"i5R`VT[V[TN[QRcNYbNaV[TNPaVcVaf#ON`RQRYRPa_VPcRUVPYR
PUN_TV[T V[ b_ON[ N_RN`"j (&') :666 :[a$ 6YRPa_$ GRU$ 4\[S$ :6G4
(&')"(&')$
L+M E$ GR[XNaN A_baUcV" ?$ 5baaN" A$ 3$ 3\OON" N[Q 3$ D$ GN`bQRcN"
i:Z]YRZR[aNaV\[\S@4AA]_\a\P\YS\_RYRPa_VPcRUVPYRN]]YVPNaV\[`"j
6)DHRO4\[S$"c\Y$ .-"[\$(&' /"]]$ .#''"(&'/$
L,M G$ BbN[#5\" 3$ ;R\[T#9f\" =$ ;NR#5bPX" N[Q =$ DR\[T#;\\["
i>\[Va\_V[T \S A\dR_ 2YY\PNaV\[ V[ 4R[a_NYVgRQ 6YRPa_VP GRUVPYR
4UN_TV[TD]\aDf`aRZ"j6[R_TfA_\PRQVN"(&'($
L-M 4$ KUN\ N[QI$ J\b" iCR`RN_PU N[Q :Z]YRZR[aNaV\[ \S@4AA '$,
A_\a\P\Y"j(&'-$
L.M 2$ C\Q_VTbRg#DR__N[\" 2$ E\__NYON" 6$ C\Q_VTbRg#GNYR[PVN" N[Q ;$
EN_VSN#8NYV`aR\" i2 P\ZZb[VPNaV\[ `f`aRZ S_\Z 6Ga\ 6G DR_cVPR
A_\cVQR_ ON`RQ \[ @4AA \cR_ N dV_RYR`` [Rad\_X"j V[ :64@?
A_\PRRQV[T` :[Qb`a_VNY6YRPa_\[VP`4\[SR_R[PR!"(&')$
L/M 3$ GNVQfN N[Q 9$ E$ >\bSaNU" iDZN_a RYRPa_VP cRUVPYR PUN_TV[T
ZN[NTRZR[aS\_`ZN_aPVaVR`"j:6EDZN_a4VaVR`"c\Y$("[\$ '"]]$*#
')"(&(&$
L'&M =$ 8R[T"K$=b"=$ 9R" ;$KUN[T"I$=V"N[QI$8b\" iDZN_aPUN_TV[T
ZN[NTRZR[a `f`aRZ S\_ RYRPa_VP cRUVPYR` V[ P\b]YRQ a_N[`]\_aNaV\[
N[Q]\dR_QV`a_VObaV\[`f`aRZ`"j6[R_Tf"c\Y$ './"(&'/$
L''M D$ @_PV\[V" =$ 3bPP\YV[V" 2$ CVPPV" N[Q>$ 4\[aV" i6YRPa_VP GRUVPYR`
4UN_TV[T CR`R_cNaV\[ 3N`RQ \[ @4AA"j A_\P$ # (&'. :666 :[a$
4\[S$ 6[cV_\[$ 6YRPa_$ 6[T$ (&'. :666 :[Q$ 4\ZZR_$ A\dR_ Df`a$
6b_$666:4%:4AD6b_$(&'."]]$ '#,"(&'.$