2. Tagumpay vs. Moscoso, L-14723, May 29, 1959 3. Banco Español-Filipino vs. Palanca, 37 Phil. 291 4. MRR Co. vs. Atty. Gen. 20 Phil. 523 5. Otibar vs. Vinson, L-18023, May 30, 1962 6. Tijam vs. Sibonghanoy, April 15, 1968 7. Cardenas vs. Camus, L-19191, July 30, 1962 8. Edward J. Nell Co. vs. Cubacub, L-20842, June 23, 1965 9. Serrano vs. Muñoz Motors, L-25547, November 27, 1967 10. Reyes vs. Diaz, 73 Phil. 484 11. Manchester Development Corp. vs. CA, 149 SCRA 562 12. Sun Insurance Office Ltd. vs. CA, 170 SCRA 274 (1989) 13. Tacay vs. RTC of Tagum, Davao Del Norte, 180 SCRA 433 (1989) 14. Filipinas Shell Petroleum Corp. vs. CA, 171 SCRA 674 (1989) 15. Lacson vs. Reyes, 182 SCRA 729 16. Suson vs. CA, 278 SCRA 284 (August 21, 1997) 17. De Leon vs. CA, 287 SCRA 94, March 6, 1998