Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AND THERAPEUTICS
Scorpion envenomation is not an uncommon event in var- reactions, including anaphylaxis 4, 6 and the delayed onset of
ious parts of the world.l"5 Severe autonomic and central rash and symptoms of serum sickness, 18 and it is expensive.
nervous system symptoms and cardiac, respiratory, and In the United States, AV has not been subjected to U.S.
pancreatic dysfunction may Occur, leading to multisystem Food and Drug Administration testing, and its use is not
organ failure and death, especially among children. 61~ The federally approved. At present, AV is available only within
mortality rate after envenomation has declined markedly in the state of Arizona by special action of the Arizona State
some centers during the last few decades. 4,5, 8, 11-19 This Board of Pharmacy, 1618 and its use is controversial. For
improvement has been attributed to treatment in an inten-
sive care setting, 4, 5, 8, 11, !3, 15-17 treatment of symptoms AV Antivenom
with drugs,4,5,11,! 4 and specific antivenom administra- ED Emergency department
tion.4,,5, 11, 13 However, there is no convincing evidence of NAV No antivenom
the value of serotherapy in human beings envenomated by PICU Pediatric intensive care unit
scorpions. 1,2~ MoreOver, AV may cause acute allergic
these reasons and on the basis of our experience, we have
discontinued the use of AV in children with scorpion
Submitted for publication July 16, 1993; accepted Dec. 20, 1993. envenomation since 1989. In this study, we compared the
Reprint requests: Shaul Sofer, MD, Division of Pediatrics, Soroka outcome of scorpion envenomation in children treated in a
Medical Center, PO Box 151, Beer-Sheva 84101, Israel. pediatric intensive care unit with specific AV before 1989,
Copyright | 1994 by Mosby-Year Book, Inc. with that in children admitted to the P I C U after 1989, who
0022-3476/94/$3.00 + 0 9/25/53824 were similarly treated but did not receive AV.
973
974 Sofer, Shahak, and Gueron The Journal of Pediatrics
June 1994
Table I. Demographic, clinical, and laboratory features of children with envenomation on admission
A V g r o u p (n = 52) N A V g r o u p (n = 52)
come, duration of intubation, and duration of PICU stay vere metabolic acidosis, right and left heart failure, and
between the six children in the AV group and the nine chil- pulmonary edema. An 8-year-old boy remained brain dead
dren in the NAV group. However, the median age of the 15 after resuscitation from shock and severe ventricular ar-
children with respiratory failure was lower than that of all rhythmias including ventricular fibrillation. A 13-year-old
children in both groups: 2 versus 3 years, respectively. The boy in the AV group survived but remained handicapped by
site of sting was not identified in nine of the children with aphasia and leg amputation; he had cardiogenic shock, left
respiratory failure and involved the limbs in the six other heart failure with pulmonary edema and ventricular ar-
children. Arterial pH was slightly lower in children in the rhythmias, and multiple brain infarcts, as shown by com-
NAV group, and the blood glucose level was slightly higher puted tomography. On the seventh day of hospitalization
in the NAV group. The frequency of electrocardiographic the patient had signs of right popliteal artery occlusion that
changes, including ST elevations and high T waves, was eventually led to amputation. This patient and the first of
similar in both groups. the two patients who died have been reported elsewhere. 8
Major complications of envenomation that were mani- All four children in the AV group who had severe cardio-
fested after arrival consisted mainly of cardiovascular dys- vascular complications received the maximum dose of an-
function (Table II). Abnormalities were noted in five chil- tivenom (15 ml intravenously) promptly on arrival, several
dren in the NAV group, including one with cardiogenic hours before the onset of complications. The median age of
shock, and in four of the children in the AV group, includ- the children with cardiovascular dysfunction, in both the
ing three who had cardiogenic shock. All children in the treated and the nontreated groups, was significantly higher
NAV group survived without sequelae; two of the children than the median age of all children (12 years vs 3 years, re-
in the AV group died. A 3-year-old girl died of shock, se- spectively; range, 3 to 15 years). Eight of the nine children
976 Sofer, Shahak, and Gueron The Journal of Pediatrics
June 1994
T a b l e II. Severe complications of envenomation during T a b l e III. Duration of stay in PICU and duration of
hospitalization and outcome hospitalization
venomation, and its occurrence is unpredictable; all victims 2. Sutherland SK. Management of venomous bites and stings.
arriving in the ED with signs of systemic intoxication should Medicine International 1981;1:415-22.
3. Amaral CFS, Rezende NA de, Freire-Maia L. Acute pulmo-
be admitted to the hospital, preferably to an intensive care
nary edema after Tityus serrulatus scorpion sting in children.
unit. Am J Cardiol 1992;71:242-5.
The pathogenesis of cardiac dysfunction is not clear. It 4. Bawaskar HS, Bawaskar PH. Management of the cardiovas-
has been suggested that hypokinesia and diminished myo- cular manifestations of poisoning by the Indian red scorpion
cardial performance are the result of increased catechola- (Mesobuthus tamulus). Br Heart J 1992;68:478-80.
5. Goyffon M, Vachon M, Broglio N. Epidemiological and clin-
mine production, causing increased myocardial oxygen de-
ical characteristics of the scorpion envenomation in Tunisia.
mand in excess of oxygen supply. 7, 35-39 Antivenom given Toxicon 1982;20:337-44.
before intoxication may prevent catecholamine excretion 6. Hershkovits Y, Elizur Y, Margolis CZ, Barak N, Sofer S,
but cannot abolish its effect once excreted; this might Moses SW. Criteria map audit of scorpion envenomation in
explain its apparent ineffectiveness in human victims, as Negev children 1974-1980: clinical picture and quality of care.
Toxicon 1985;5:845-54.
shown in our study. Animal studies have shown that it is
7. Gueron M, Yarom R. Cardiovascular manifestations of severe
possible to prevent intoxication and death when AV is ad- scorpion sting. Chest 1970;57:156-62.
ministered before, or concomitantly with, the venom. 3234 8. Sofer S, Gueron M. Respiratory failure in children following
This situation obviously does not apply to human victims. envenomation by the scorpion Leiurus quinquestriatus, heron-
Cardiac dysfunction develops hours after ED arrival and dynamics and neurological aspects. Toxicon 1988;26:931-9.
9. Sorer S, Shachak E, Slonin A, Gueron M. Myocardial injury
thus seems to be potentially preventable. However, our
without heart failure following envenomation by the scorpion
study shows that the frequency of significant cardiovascu- Leiurus quinquestriatus in children. Toxicon 1991;29:382-5.
lar abnormalities was similar in children treated with A V 10. Sofer S, Shalev H, Weizman Z, Shachak E, Gueron M. Acute
and in untreated children, and children treated with AV had pancreatitis in children following envenomation by the yellow
a more difficult course. Although we do not believe that the scorpion Leiurus quinquestriatus. Toxicon 1991;29:125-8.
11. Freire-Maia L, Campos MA. Pathophysiology and treatment
apparently higher mortality rate in the AV group is caus-
of scorpion poisoning. In: Ownby CL, Odell GV, eds. Natural
ally related to AV administration, our data demonstrate the toxins, characterization, pharmacology and therapeutics. Ox-
ineffectiveness of the AV. In addition, 15% of our patients ford: Pergamon Press, 1989;24:139-59.
were already in a state of severe respiratory failure on ar- 12. Amitai Y, Mines Y, Aker M, Goiten K. Scorpion sting in chil-
rival at the hospital; AV therapy could not be preventive in dren. Clin Pediatr 1985;24:136-40.
13. Freire-Maia L, Campos JA. Response to Letter to the Editor.
such cases. In fact, the postintubation course of the children
Toxicon 1987;25:125-30. (Gueron M, Ovsyshcher I. What is
in our study who were treated with specific A V did not dif- the treatment for the cardiovascular manifestations of scorpion
fer from the course of the children who did not receive AV. envenornation? [Letter]. Toxicon 1987;25:121-4).
Thus, despite almost 40 years of use, there is no convinc- 14. Bawaskar HS, Bawaskar PH. Prazosin in management of car-
ing evidence that AV is effective in the treatment of human diovascular manifestations of scorpion sting [Letter]. Lancet
1986;1:510-1.
envenomation. Moreover, no quantitative studies have
15. Rimsza ME, Zimmerman DR, Bergeson PS. Scorpion enveno-
compared A V dosage, route of administration, time-effec- mation. Pediatrics 1980;66:298-30Z
tiveness relation, and titer of the A V used. 29, 40 16. Rachesky IJ, Banner W, Dansky J, Tong T. Treatment for
We believe that the marked decrease in the mortality rate Centruroides exilicanda envenomation. Am J Dis Child 1984;
in our institution is the result of the introduction of inten- 138:1136-9.
17. Curry SC, Vance MV, Ryan PJ, Kunkel DB, Northey WT.
sive care and treatment of symptoms 8'41, 42 rather than
Envenomation by the scorpion Centruroides sculpturatus. J
therapy with AV. Similar results have been reported for the Toxicol Clin Toxicol 1984;21:417-49.
Mahad region of India, where the mortality rate decreased 18. Bond GR. Antivenin administration for Centruroides scorpion
from 30% in the 1970s to 2% to 3% in the 1980s without the sting: risks and benefits. Ann Emerg Med 1992;21:788-91.
use of AV but with intensive care and treatment of symp- 19. Berg RA, Tarantino MD. Envenomation by the scorpion Cen-
truroides exilicanda (C. sculpturatus): severe and unusual
toms.4,14 These data emphasize the need to reconsider
manifestations. Pediatrics 1991 ;87:930-3.
therapy with AV in human victims of scorpion stings and 20. Ismail M, ABD-Elsalam MH. Are the toxicological effects of
the need for a control study regarding its efficacy. Such a scorpion envenomation related to tissue venom concentration?
study may define specific subgroups that may benefit from Toxicon 1988;26:233-56.
therapy with AV. 21. Gueron M, Ovsyshcher I. What is the treatment for the car-
diovascular manifestations of scorpion envenomation? [Let-
ter]. Toxicon 1987;25:121-4.
REFERENCES 22. Sofer S, Gueron M. Cardiovascular aspects of scorpion
1. Efrati P. Epidemiology, symptomatology and treatment of envenomation. In: Gopalakrishnakone P, Tan CK, eds. Recent
Buthidae scorpion. In: Bettini S, ed. Handbook of experimen- advances in toxinology research; vol 2. Venom and toxin
tal pharmacology-arthropod venoms; vol 48. Berlin: Springer research group. Singapore: National University of Singapore,
Verlag, 1978:312-7. 1992:40-9.
978 Sofer, Shahak, and Gueron The Journal of Pediatrics
June 1994
23. Sofer S, Gueron M. Vasodilators and hypertensive encephal- 34. Shulov A, Levy C. Venoms of Buthidae. In: Bettini S, ed.
opathy following scorpion envenomation in children. Chest Handbook of experimental pharmacology-arthropod venoms;
1990;97:118-20. vol 48. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1978;309-17.
24. Stahnke HL, Dengler AH. The effect of morphine and related 35. Gueron M, Adolph RG, Grupp IL, Gabel M, Grupp G, Fowler
substances on the toxicity of venoms. I. Centruroides sculptu- NO. Hemodynamic and myocardial consequences of scorpion
ratus Ewing scorpion venoms. Am J Trop Med Hyg 1964; venom. Am J Cardiol 1980;45:979-86.
13:346-51. 36. Gueron M, Margulis G, Sorer S. Echocardiographic and ra-
25. Gueron M, Ilia R, Shachak E, Sofer S. Renin and aldosterone dionuclide angiographic observations following scorpion en-
levels and hypertension following envenomation in humans by venomation by Leiurus quinquestriatus. Toxicon 1990;28:
the yellow scorpion Leiurus quinquestriatus. Toxicon 1992; 1005-9.
30:765-7. 37. Braun K, Stern S, Werkson S. Sympathomimefic effects of
26. Wang GK, Strichartz GR. Purification and physiological scorpion venom on the cardiovascular system. Isr J Med Sci
characterization of neurotoxins from venoms of the scorpions 1969;5:853-4.
Centruroides sculpturatus and Leiurus quinquestriatus. Mol 38. Moss J, Kasic T, Henry DP, Kopin IJ. Scorpion venom-
Pharmacol 1983;23:519-3. induced discharge of cateeholamines accompanied by hyper-
27. Zlotkin E, Shulov AS. Recent studies on the mode of action of tension. Brain Res 1973;54:381-5.
scorpion neurotoxins: a review. Toxicon 1969;7:217-21. 39. Freire-Maia L, Azevedo AD, Cunha-Melo JR, Almeida AP,
28. La Grange RG. Elevation of blood pressure and plasma renin Silva AB, Alpiom NC. Arterial hypertension, cardiac arrhyth-
levels by venoms from scorpions Centruroides sculpturatus mias and pulmonary edema induced by scorpion toxin in
and Leiurus quinquestriatus. Toxicon 1977;15:429-33. unanesthetized rats. Toxicon 1979;17:51.
29. Ismail M, Fatani FJY, Debess TT. Experimental treatment 40. E1-Ayeb ME, Delori P. Immunology and immunochemistry of
protocols from scorpion envenomation: a review of common scorpion neurotoxins. In: Tu A, ed. Insect poisons, allergens
therapies and an effect of kallikrein-kinin inhibitors. Toxicon and other invertebrate venoms, handbook of natural toxins; vol
1992;30:1257-79. 2. New York: Marcel Dekker, 1984:607-38.
30. Albroug F, Boujdaria R, Belghith M, Nouiza S, Bouchoucha 41. Gueron M, Sorer S. Scorpion envenomation and the heart
S. Cardiac dysfunction and pulmonary edema following scor- [Editorial]. J Wilderness Med 1991;2:175-7.
pion envenomation. Chest 1991;100:1057-9. 42. Gueron M, Ilia R, Sofer S. The cardiovascular system after
31. Stahnke HL. Arizona lethal scorpion. Ariz Med 1972;29:490-3. scorpion envenomation: a review. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol
32. Rohayem H. Scorpion toxin and antagonistic drugs. J Trop 1992;30:235-58.
Med Hyg 1953;56:150-8. 43. Mielke PW. Nonmetric statistical analyses: some metric
33. Balozet L. Scorpion venoms and antiscorpion serum. In: Ven- alternatives. J Statist Plan Inference 1986;13:377-87.
oms. American Association for the Advancement of Science
1956;141-4.