Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Urban Studies
2021, Vol. 58(2) 316–334
Ó Urban Studies Journal Limited 2020
Governing the night-time city: Article reuse guidelines:
sagepub.com/journals-permissions
The rise of night mayors as DOI: 10.1177/0042098019895224
journals.sagepub.com/home/usj
a new form of urban governance
after dark
Andreina Seijas
Harvard University Graduate School of Design, USA
Abstract
The urban night has traditionally been a regimented space characterised by strict policing and sur-
veillance. Early research on the night-time economy documented the expansion of nightlife from
a centrepiece of culture-led redevelopment strategies in post-industrial cities, to the introduction
of a broad governance apparatus to manage the agglomeration of night-time activity. Over the
past two decades, a new actor has emerged: more than 40 cities have appointed night mayors or
individuals responsible for maintaining nocturnal vibrancy, while mediating between those who
wish to work, party or sleep. This article summarises the results of a qualitative study that gath-
ered information on the origins, propagation and geographic variations in the role to provide a
first comprehensive look at this position. Data from 35 night mayors and night-time advocacy
organisations from around the world revealed that, though cities differ greatly in their approach
towards night-time infrastructure and regulation, there seems to be growing consensus on the
need for permanent nocturnal governance structures. By encouraging greater dialogue and
experimentation, these structures are challenging traditional approaches to urban governance
and paving the way for a new wave of studies on the urban night.
Keywords
nightlife, night mayor, planning, urban governance, urban night
᪈㾱
Ր㔏кˈཌⲴᐲᱟањ㻛ѕṬⴁ㇑ǃⴁ᧗Ⲵオ䰤DŽӾਾᐕъᐲѝԕ᮷ॆѪѫሬⲴ
ᔰਁᡈ⮕ⲴṨᗳˈࡠ㇑⨶ཌ䰤⍫ࣘ䳶㚊Ⲵᒯ⌋⋫⨶ᵪࡦⲴᕅˈޕཌ䰤㓿⍾Ⲵᰙᵏ⹄ウ䇠
ᖅҶཌ⭏⍫ⲴᢙኅDŽ൘䗷৫ⲴҼॱᒤ䟼ˈањᯠⲴ㙼࣑ࠪ⧠Ҷ˖40ཊњᐲԫભҶ䍏䍓㔤
ᤱཌ䰤⍫࣋ˈ਼ᰦ൘ᐼᵋᐕǃ㚊Պᡆⶑ㿹Ⲵн਼Ӫ㗔ѻ䰤䘋㹼䈳䀓Ⲵཌ䰤ᐲ䮯ᡆᇈઈDŽ
ᵜ᮷ᙫ㔃Ҷа亩ᇊᙗ⹄ウⲴ㔃᷌ԕ俆⅑ᨀሩ䈕㙼սⲴޘ䶒Ҷ䀓ˈ䈕⹄ウ᭦䳶ҶޣҾ䈕㙼
սⲴ䎧ⓀǃՐ઼ൠ⨶ᐞᔲⲴؑDŽᶕ㠚ц⭼ൠⲴ35ཌ䰤ᐲ䮯઼ཌ䰤ّሬ㓴㓷Ⲵᮠᦞ
ᱮ⽪ˈቭ㇑ᐲሩཌ䰤ส䇮ᯭ઼ⴁ㇑ⲴᘱᓖᴹᖸབྷᐞᔲˈնӪԜլѾ䎺ᶕ䎺а㠤ൠ䇔Ѫ
䴰㾱≨ѵᙗⲴཌ䰤⋫⨶㔃ᶴDŽ䙊䗷啃࣡ᴤཊⲴሩ䈍઼ᇎ傼ˈ䘉Ӌ㔃ᶴ↓൘ᡈՐ㔏Ⲵᐲ
⋫⨶ᯩ⌅ˈᒦѪᯠа䖞Ⲵཌ䰤ᐲ⹄ウ䬪ᒣ䚃䐟DŽ
ޣ䭞䇽
ཌ⭏⍫ǃཌ䰤ᐲ䮯ǃ㿴ࡂǃᐲ⋫⨶ǃཌ䰤ᐲ
Seijas and Gelders 317
Corresponding author:
Andreina Seijas, Department of Urban Planning and Design, Harvard University Graduate School of Design, 48 Quincy St,
Cambridge, MA 02138-3000, USA.
Email: aseijas@gsd.harvard.edu
318 Urban Studies 58(2)
These studies often focused on the ‘negative Moving away from the pessimistic ethos
externalities’ associated with activity after of previous studies, this ‘third wave’ of
dark and tried to quantify the operational research on the urban night encouraged
costs of managing it efficiently (TBR, 2015). more proactive discussions about how to
Powered by media reports of these negative integrate data and planning mechanisms to
consequences, this period demonised certain tackle issues such as the saturation of
night-time practices and behaviours – partic- licensed premises and an alcohol-centric def-
ularly those related to alcohol consumption inition of the night-time economy. In 2012
– while overshadowing residents’ genuine Roberts and Eldridge published their sem-
claims for active but more diverse late-night inal book titled Planning the Night-Time
experiences (Eldridge and Roberts, 2008). City, and in 2015 Urban Studies devoted an
As a result, new forms of video surveillance entire volume to explore the ‘geographies of
such as CCTV proliferated in this period, the urban night’ (Van Liempt et al., 2015).
along with the emergence of new zoning laws These publications coincided with the rise of
and regulations that provided a broader multi-sectoral efforts to reduce binge drink-
range of enforcement options to local police ing and initiatives to encourage nightlife
and city governments (Hadfield et al., 2009). operators to improve their safety and quality
Urban systems of nocturnal governance standards. Examples include the Purple Flag
operate on different levels and range from and Best Bar None accreditation schemes in
laws and state actors like the police, to infor- the UK, which called for greater dialogue
mal agreements and non-state actors like and cooperation between city governments
neighbourhood watches. Aside from having and the nightlife industry.
a common mission to oversee what happens These partnerships and collaborations –
in an area after dark, most of these systems along with the rise of third-party policing in
share a limitation: they often assume the the night-time economy – paved the way for
need to mirror or exacerbate the mechanisms greater consensus around the notion of noc-
of order and control that exist during the turnal governance as a complex responsibility
day, while disregarding the unique features that involves a mix of agencies including the
of urban life after dark. The night has tradi- police, licensing authorities, resident groups
tionally been used as a pretext for strict poli- and public health institutions, among others.
cing and for maintaining structures of social Rather than focusing on restrictive mechan-
exclusion (Straw, 2018). Bianchini (1995) isms to handle night-time crime and antiso-
refers to these structures as ‘regulators of cial behaviour, this broader notion advocates
behaviour’ that range from licensing authori- a networked response that allows cities to
ties to bouncers in a night club. For Hadfield tackle a wider range of social, economic and
(2015), the ‘third wave’ of studies on the environmental factors of life after dark. This
urban night is concerned with studying the new ethos was supported by calls for the cre-
exclusionary outcomes that result from these ation of partnerships and allegiances to exer-
structures, which are based on race and eth- cise order and surveillance and to facilitate
nicity, social class, gender, age and sexual night-time planning (Roberts, 2004; Van
preferences among other factors. This wave Liempt, 2013) and set the stage for the rise of
incorporates new voices and case studies a new role and key actor within cities’ noctur-
from Western Europe, North America and nal governance system: the night mayor.
South-East Asia that come to diversify a Night mayors – also called ‘managers’
field that previously relied heavily on the and ‘czars’, among other designations – are
British and Australian experience. individuals selected by cities to act as a
Seijas and Gelders 319
liaison between nightlife establishments, citi- rise of night mayors and their relevance from
zens and local governments. Though their an urban governance perspective has not
backgrounds and the process by which they been analysed and documented in urban
are selected vary significantly, night mayors’ studies. Nonetheless, night mayors – and
responsibilities can be categorised into three their high journalistic appeal – have been
basic types. The first refers to enhancing recognised as a key factor in the ascension of
nocturnal ‘hardware’, or improving the built the night as a relevant field of study (Straw,
environment in a way that is conducive to 2018). They are also considered a note-
greater vibrancy and quality of life after worthy mechanism that, along with night
dark. For instance, some night mayors have charters and other solutions, promotes med-
been involved in efforts to expand night- iation rather than regulation to solve urban
time transportation services in their cities, or issues after dark (Gwiazdzinski, 2018).
to enhance lighting and basic services such Amid the rapid dissemination of night
as public toilets that are open at night. The mayors around the world, this paper intends
second refers to improving – and often to provide a first comprehensive look at this
updating – nocturnal ‘software’, or the laws new role to assess its relevance as a mechan-
and regulations that facilitate activity and ism to facilitate proactive and collaborative
minimise nuisance at night. This refers to responses to crime, antisocial behaviour and
curfews or policies that establish hours of inequality after dark. In the light of survey
operation for businesses as well as public data gathered from 35 night mayors and
spaces. Finally, the third responsibility refers night-time advocacy organisations and testi-
to mediating and promoting consensus monies from six experts who have been
among the wide variety of actors involved in influential in the dissemination of the role, it
nocturnal governance. will first review the background and origins
These three responsibilities – improving of night mayors within the growing field of
hardware and software and promoting med- studies on the urban night. Second, it will
iation – are at the heart of all private and discuss the variations in the nature and
public strategies to manage urban environ- scope of the position, its propagation, pre-
ments after dark. Though cities differ greatly liminary achievements and future perspec-
in their approaches towards night-time infra- tives. Third, in light of Pierre’s (2011) four
structure and regulation, there seems to be models of urban governance, it will analyse
growing consensus around the need for per- the way the transfer of this role has been
manent nocturnal governance structures influenced by local systems of governance.
responsible for crafting these strategies and Finally, it will provide recommendations for
overseeing their implementation. This con- future research within this new subfield of
vergence of ideas around nocturnal govern- studies on the urban night.
ance is the outcome of a process of policy
transfer that began with the introduction of
Methods
the role in the early 2000s by cities such as
Amsterdam and Berlin and its rapid propa- To obtain information about the nature of
gation around the world. By December the emerging role of night mayors, the
2018, more than 40 cities had incorporated authors of this paper developed a qualitative
the role of the night mayor or had an active survey and a database of 45 individuals who
night-time advocacy organisation. have been appointed or hired for the posi-
The field of night-time planning and pol- tion by city governments, nightlife associa-
icy has grown over the past decade, but the tions or civil society organisations between
320 Urban Studies 58(2)
2004 and 2018. While some cities have not 24-hour public transportation, alcohol cur-
yet designated their first night mayor, sev- fews and noise regulations. To complement
eral cities in the Netherlands have appointed the results of the survey, between July and
more than one. In order to avoid selection November 2018 the authors conducted addi-
bias, only current night mayors of seven tional interviews with six experts in night-
Dutch cities – Amsterdam, Eindhoven, time planning and policy whose work has
Groningen, Zwolle, Nijmegen and The been instrumental to the rise of the night
Hague – have been considered as part of this mayor movement (see Table 1). Interview
analysis. questions assessed the origins of the role, its
The qualitative survey was distributed in current relevance and influence, and predic-
June 2018 through personalised emails that tions of its future significance.
were sent to a total of 45 individuals who Despite the global nature of this study,
work as night mayors or representatives the selection of experts from North America
from night-time advocacy organisations in and the UK should not be seen as a limita-
20 different countries around the world. All tion but rather as a reflection of the reality
emails included a link that led to a 35-ques- of the field. While there is a growing number
tion survey available in English and Spanish. of contributions from scholars focused on
The survey included multiple choice as well the developing world, studies on the urban
as open-ended questions that allowed indi- night continue to be highly focused on issues
viduals to share more details on the origins faced by cities in industrialised countries.
and nature of their roles. Between June and The following section will discuss the find-
October 2018, the survey was responded to ings from this qualitative study in light of
by 35 individuals from a total of 34 cities.1 the historical context and precedents to the
The first section of the survey included appearance of night mayors as a new form
questions directed at understanding the of urban governance around the world.
demographics of the people in the role (their
age, gender, education level), the characteris-
tics of the position (how it was created, its Results
duration, jurisdiction), the resources they
have to support their work (salary, staff,
Background and origins of the role
operating budget, outreach mechanisms), Though Berlin was the first city to create an
and the types of issues they deal with (eco- official night-time advocacy organisation –
nomic or social-cultural). Some of the ques- Clubcommission Berlin – the term ‘night
tions also aimed at gathering information mayor’ has its origins in the Netherlands. In
about cities’ nightlife regulations and infra- the 1970s, Dutch poet Jules Deelder’s promi-
structure, by asking about the existence of nent role in the cultural life of Rotterdam
Seijas and Gelders 321
earned him the nickname of nachtburgemee- scheme launched in 2013 that allows for the
ster or night mayor of the city. In a recent extension of opening hours for nightlife
interview on the global rise of the role, venues located on the outskirts of the city.
Deelder commented: ‘I just learned that Following its successful implementation, in
night mayors are popping up here and there 2017 it became a permanent policy (Van
(.). They sound like politicians, but that’s der Groep, 2017). A second initiative
not how I imagined the role to be!’ (Van that has gained worldwide recognition is
Dommelen, 2018). Though Deelder never the Rembrandtplein Gastvrij (Hospitable
expected night mayors to have a voice in Rembrandt Square) project. This three-year
city planning, the position preserves some pilot was launched in 2015 with support
of his disruptive character and wisdom: from the late Mayor of Amsterdam,
night mayors are individuals who are able to Eberhard van der Laan, to reduce alcohol-
navigate the chaos and contradictions related violence, raise the quality of nightlife
of darkness while working alongside city and make it safer for residents to move
governments to make the night a safer and through Rembrandtplein, a major nightlife
more inclusive space. By doing so, they district where more than 200 violent inci-
become mediators or translators between dents and reports of nuisance were reported
two worlds – nightlife and city government – every year. The outcome of a public–private
that until recently had few devices with partnership, the project involved hiring 20
which to communicate. hosts or stewards dressed in bright red jack-
Over the past 10 years, Dutch cities have ets to patrol the district on Friday and
appointed more than 20 nachtburgemeesters. Saturday nights as a means of creating a
The most notable of these representatives is more relaxed atmosphere, similar to that
the nachtburgemeester Amsterdam, a posi- found in a festival or public event. At the
tion elected for the first time in 2003 and end of the three-year pilot, nuisance reports
later institutionalised in 2014 through the had decreased by 40% and violence reports
creation of Stichting N8BM A’DAM – an had decreased by 20% (Broer et al., 2018).
independent non-profit organisation that Despite its Dutch origins, the night
provides guidance to the mayor and the city mayor concept had also resonated in France
council on how to design policies to promote through the work of scholars such as Luc
a culturally, socially and ethnically inclusive Gwiazdzinski, who proposed the election of
nightlife in the Dutch capital (Stichting a ‘maire de nuit’ as a means to recover the
N8BM A’DAM Amsterdam, 2018). The urban night and avoid the ‘banalization’ of
nachtburgemeester Amsterdam is funded this field (Aghina and Gwiazdzinski, 1999).
both by the nightlife industry and the gov- For licensing specialist and former chair of
ernment and elected for two-year terms by a London’s Night-Time Commission, Philip
tripartite voting process: an online vote, a Kolvin, the idea had also been developing in
town hall vote and a jury vote. While candi- British cities for a couple of decades. As the
dates are expected to have a strong connec- night-time economy expanded in the 1990s,
tion and knowledge of the city’s nightlife town centre managers had to deal with a
industry, they cannot be directly affiliated growing number of bars and restaurants,
with a business or institution in this sector. while also dealing with shops and offices
One of the most successful initiatives (P Kolvin, personal communication, 2016).
implemented by the nachtburgemeester In 2016, Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan,
Amsterdam is the creation of the 24-hour appointed the city’s first ‘night czar’ to facil-
licence, an innovative five-year pilot itate the interaction between citizens, local
322 Urban Studies 58(2)
authorities and nightlife venues. Though this first major challenge is ‘convincing the pub-
new role inherited some of the challenges lic that the night mayor is not only there for
faced by town centre managers, it was the businesses, but also there for the com-
tasked with managing a dwindling rather munity’ (Rafael Espinal, personal communi-
than a thriving night scene. In only a decade, cation, 2018).
London had lost 58% of its LGBTQ +
venues, while nightclubs and other entertain-
ment spaces were closing at an alarming rate Nature and scope of the position
(Campkin and Marshall, 2017). Among the There are three questions that must be
most noteworthy, iconic nightclub Fabric answered in order to lay out the role of the
lost its licence a few weeks before the night mayor successfully (Kolvin, personal
night czar was appointed. Leading the talks communication, 2016). The first question is
that allowed this venue to stay open is con- where the role will be situated: inside or out-
sidered one of the night czar’s main accom- side city hall. While those who work for
plishments during her first year in the local governments must align with political
position (Mayor of London, 2017). interests and voting cycles, those who are
In other cities, such as New York, the independent or appointed by community
emergence of the night mayor figure is the associations also encounter difficulties in
outcome of years of pro-nightlife activism carrying out and funding concrete actions,
(Hae, 2012). Following a decade of zero tol- as well as in gaining recognition from city
erance policies and a severe crackdown on authorities. The second question is whether
nightlife during Rudolph Giuliani’s adminis- the night mayor will have an advocacy or a
tration, in the early 2000s New York City regulatory role, and the third is what the city
activists began to fight for the need to recog- is expecting this position to achieve. Of all
nise the rights of those working the night participants, 75% mentioned safety as the
shift, including nurses, taxi drivers and those primary concern on their agenda and all of
in the hospitality and creative industries. In them mentioned mediation and conflict reso-
the summer of 2017, Brooklyn Council lution as part of their job description.
Member Rafael Espinal led the enactment However, none of these individuals have the
of a bill to establish a Nightlife Advisory authority to change local laws or regula-
Board and an Office of Nightlife (The New tions, making this an entirely advisory role.
York City Council, 2017). The Nightlife For Will Straw, professor of urban media
Advisory Board consists of 14 members studies at McGill University and collabora-
responsible for evaluating the city’s laws and tor on several projects on night-time culture
making recommendations to address com- at the international level, the title of ‘night
mon issues in the nightlife industry. Created mayor’ suggests ‘an alternative city’ that is
in early 2018, the Office of Nightlife serves in need of representation (Straw, 2018). Its
as a liaison between nightlife establishments, appeal lies greatly in its absurd and trans-
residents and the government. Though ini- gressive nature, which experts consider
tially focused on handling complaints and advantageous to raise awareness of the
violations, the office also provides policy urban night as a relevant field for research
recommendations to the mayor and various and practice. Some cities, however, have
city agencies (City of New York, 2019). As been hesitant about using this designation as
opposed to the Amsterdam model, this posi- it is not always linked to an elected position
tion is fully funded by the administration and it sounds too much like ‘nightmare’
and overseen by the mayor. For Espinal, its (City of Toronto, 2018; Straw, personal
Seijas and Gelders 323
local night scene to enable people to meet panacea for tourism and economic growth
and socialise, as well as the opportunities but failed to predict the long-term impact of
that nightlife brings for urban regeneration regeneration over local identity and culture
and to attract the ‘creative class’. Under this (Evans, 2009; Glaeser, 2004). Though
premise, urban development strategies have expanding night-time activity can improve
championed the night-time economy as a individuals’ perceptions of safety after dark,
Seijas and Gelders 325
revitalisation efforts centred on strengthen- particularly in cities such as New York and
ing the night-time economy can also facili- London where they led WorldPride celebra-
tate waves of gentrification in which many tions and awareness efforts in the summer of
nightlife venues are later closed or displaced, 2019 (Abadsidis, 2019; Broadgate, 2019).
victims of their own success (Hae, 2012). Despite women’s greater participation in
For Jim Peters, director of the responsible nightlife, the study revealed that most night
hospitality institute (RHI), cities are seeking mayors are men (73%). However, some of
night mayors as a person who will come to the sample’s biggest cities – such as New
rescue nightlife from all these pressures (Jim York, Sydney and London – have selected
Peters, personal communication, 2018). female representatives. While some of these
While the urban night has acquired a female night mayors are leading gender-
more positive significance in recent years, it sensitive initiatives that encourage nightlife
continues to be a highly regulated space venues and organisations to create safer
where restrictive policies such as curfews and environments for women, the impact of these
drinking bans are implemented to ‘strike the contributions in reducing crimes against
right balance’ between a flourishing and women still has to be assessed.
diverse night-time economy and growing resi- Data on the year that night mayor posi-
dential populations (Jones, 2018). However, tions and night-time advocacy organisations
these policies are also linked to the disappear- were created illustrate the exponential growth
ance of traditional venues in cities such as of this movement (see Figure 2). Though only
London, which lost over half of its nightclubs six night mayors had been appointed by 2013,
between 2005 and 2015 (Wilson, 2019), and ten new positions or organisations were cre-
Sydney, where 176 establishments closed as a ated in both 2017 and 2018, making these the
result of the implementation of the Lockout years with the highest growth in the move-
Laws in 2014 (Taylor, 2018). For Hae (2012), ment. While this article was being published,
the suppression and disappearance of urban six new cities joined the list – Bloomington,
activities and their spaces must be taken seri- Mannheim, Prague, Los Angeles, Toronto
ously as ‘these are invaluable in establishing and Washington DC – and other cities such
the normative ideal of cities’. This context as Edinburgh, Helsinki, Shanghai and Vienna
has further encouraged more cities to appoint have announced interest in creating the posi-
night mayors in an effort to protect their tion. With the exception of Cali and
dwindling night scenes. Valparaiso, all the night mayors and night-
Aside from its cultural and economic con- time advocacy organisations that participated
tributions, the urban night is a key space for in the study remain active today.
social interaction, as well as for trust and
identity building. It is also a highly contested
space, used historically by certain groups to Preliminary achievements
reclaim their right to the city (May, 2014; Survey results revealed that night mayors’
Williams, 2008). The urban night has been of achievements can be categorised in four
particular value to LGBTQ + communities, realms: awareness, policy, mediation and infra-
which historically have been recognised for structure. Of respondents, 15% stated they
their contributions to the vibrancy and have been successful in placing nocturnal
unique character of neighbourhoods and issues on local agendas (advocacy); 29% men-
entire cities. It is therefore not surprising to tioned their positive involvement in updating
find that night mayors have become key local regulations to support nightlife (policy);
mouthpieces for the LGBTQ + community, 44% mentioned they were responsible for
326 Urban Studies 58(2)
Aberdeen
UK
Austin
USA
Budapest*
Hungary
Fort Lauderdale
USA
Iowa City
USA
Kazan
Russia
Madrid
Pittsburgh Spain Bloomington*
USA Orlando USA
Vilnius USA Prague*
Toulouse Lithuania San Luis Potosí Czech Republic
France Zurich Mexico Toronto*
San Francisco Switzerland Valparaiso Canada
Dublin USA Zwolle Chile
Ireland Sydney Netherlands
San Francisco Australia
Berlin USA
Germany
2001 2003 2004 2011 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Amsterdam
Netherlands Geneva*
Switzerland Asunción
Groningen Paraguay Cali
Netherlands Nijmegen Colombia Detroit
Netherlands London USA
Paris UK Eindhoven
France Seattle Netherlands
USA Los Angeles*
Tokyo (Shibuya) USA
Japan Manchester
UK
Mannheim*
Germany
New York
USA
Tbilisi
Georgia
Tel Aviv
Israel
The Hague
Netherlands
Washington DC*
USA
Figure 2. Night mayors and night-time advocacy organisations by year they were created.
Relation to local government: Inside
Outside.
Note: Cities indicated with an asterisk (*) did not participate in the study.
articulating nightlife operators and promoting government (mediation); and 12% mentioned
greater cooperation with neighbours and local their achievements in raising public funds or
Seijas and Gelders 327
Colaboratorio (2014) Night Manifesto: Seeking Hadfield P (2015) The night-time city. Four
Citizenship 24H. Available at: https://issuu. modes of exclusion: Reflections on the urban
com/invisiveisproducoes/docs/manifesto- studies special collection. Urban Studies 52(3):
19_digital/192 (accessed 10 October 2018). 606–616.
Comedia Consultancy (1991) Out of Hours: A Hadfield P, Lister S and Traynor P (2009) ‘This
Study of Economic, Social and Cultural Life in town’s a different town today’: Policing and
Twelve Town Centres in the UK. London: regulating the night-time economy. Criminol-
Comedia. ogy and Criminal Justice 9(4): 465–485.
Delgadillo N (2017) The rise of the ‘Night Mayor’ Hae L (2012) The Gentrification of Nightlife and
in America. Governing, 11 August 2017. Avail- the Right to the City: Regulating Spaces of
able at: https://www.governing.com/topics/ Social Dancing in New York. New York:
urban/gov-night-mayor-economy-america. Routledge.
html (accessed 10 September 2018). Hawthorn C (2017) Berlin government pledges e1
Digaetano A and Strom E (2003) Comparative million to fund noise protection in clubs. Resi-
urban governance: An integrated approach. dent Advisor, 4 December. Available at:
Urban Affairs Review 38(3): 356–395. https://www.residentadvisor.net/news/40553
Eldridge A and Roberts M (2008) A comfortable (accessed 12 January 2019).
night out? Alcohol, drunkenness and inclusive Henley J (2016) The stuff of night mayors:
town centres. Area 40(3): 365–374. Amsterdam pioneers new way to run cities
Evans G (2009) Creative cities, creative spaces after dark. The Guardian, 21 March 2016.
and urban policy. Urban Studies 46: Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/
1003–1040. cities/2016/mar/21/night-mayor-amsterdam-
Florida R (2002) The Rise of the Creative Class holland-mirik-milan-night-time-commission#
and How It Is Transforming Work, Leisure, comments (accessed 7 June 2018).
Community and Everyday Life. New York: Hobbs D, Hadfield P, Lister S, et al. (2003) Boun-
Basic Books. cers: Violence and Governance in the Night-time
Glaeser E (2004) Review of Richard Florida’s Economy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
‘The Rise of the Creative Class’. Available at: Hobbs D, Winlow S, Hadfield P, et al. (2005) Vio-
https://scholar.harvard.edu/files/glaeser/files/ lent hypocrisy: Governance and the night-time
book_review_of_richard_floridas_the_rise_ economy. European Journal of Criminology
of_the_creative_class.pdf (accessed 15 July 2(2): 161–183.
2019). Jones D (2018) ‘This is not a curfew’ – Hackney
Goldhammer K (2019) Clubkultur Berlin 2019: Mayor responds to restrictive new licensing
Standortstudie zur Situation der Berliner Club- laws. NME, 27 July. Available at: https://
landschaft. Report, Goldmedia GmbH Strategy www.nme.com/news/this-is-not-a-curfew-
Consulting, Berlin. Available at: https://spd. hackney-mayor-responds-to-restrictive-new-
berlin/media/2019/11/Clubkultur-Berlin-2019_ legislation-2360253 (accessed 10 October
Folien-02-2019.pdf (accessed 25 February 2019). 2018).
Greater Manchester Combined Authority (2018) Joyce E (2018) Meet your new nightlife superher-
Panel to support Greater Manchester’s night- oes: The City of Sydney announces new panel.
time economy adviser unveiled. 14 December. TimeOut Sydney, 11 May. Available at:
Available at: https://www.greatermanchester- https://www.timeout.com/sydney/news/meet-
ca.gov.uk/news/panel-to-support-greater-man your-new-nightlife-superheroes-the-city-of-
chester-s-night-time-economy-adviser- sydney-announces-new-panel-051118 (accessed
unveiled/ (accessed 1 August 2019). 11 June 2018).
Gwiazdzinski L (2018) The many facets of the Kolvin P (2016) Manifesto for the Night-Time
urban night time. Cities and Lighting, no. 7, Economy. Report, London, Philip Kolvin QC.
July 2018. Available at: https://www.luciasso Available at: https://cornerstonebarristers.
ciation.org/magazine/Cities-Lighting-007/ com/cmsAdmin/uploads/night-time-economy-
(accessed 15 July 2019). final.pdf (accessed 11 June 2018).
Seijas and Gelders 333
van Liempt I (2013) Safe nightlife collaborations: Williams R (2008) Night spaces: Darkness, deter-
Multiple actors, conflicting interests and ritorialization, and social control. Space and
different power distributions. Urban Studies Culture 11: 514–532.
52(3): 486–500. Wilson S (2019) Berlin protects clubs and night-
Van Liempt I, van Aalst I and Schwanen T (2015) life – Why doesn’t London? CityLab, 2 Janu-
Introduction: Geographies of the urban night. ary 2019. Available at: https://www.citylab.
Urban Studies 52: 407–421. com/perspective/2019/01/how-late-are-clubs-
open-london-berlin-nightlife/579169/ (accessed
10 January 2019).