Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Practical
Temperature http://cp.literature.agilent.com/litweb/
pdf/5965-7822E.pdf
Measurements
Application Note 290
DVM A
C
+ + B
i = 1µA/K
To DVM
10mv/K
10kΩ To DVM
J3
Fe
Cu
+ HI J1
+
v v1
-
Ð LO
C
Cu
Fe
J4 J2
Voltmeter
80
Ice Bath E
60
K
Millivolts
J
40
T R
20
S
Introduction 2 The purpose of this application the liquid inside the tube. This
note is to explore the more common “upside-down” thermometer was a
The Thermocouple 4
temperature measurement techniques, poor indicator since the level changed
Practical Thermocouple 11 and introduce procedures for with barometric pressure, and the
Measurements improving their accuracy. tube had no scale. Vast improvements
The RTD 18 were made in temperature measure-
The Thermistor 22 We will focus on the four most com- ment accuracy with the development
mon temperature transducers: the of the Florentine thermometer, which
Monolithic Linear 23 thermocouple, the RTD (Resistance incorporated sealed construction
Temperature Sensor Temperature Detector), the thermistor and a graduated scale.
The Measurement System 24 and the integrated circuit sensor.
Appendix A 27 Despite the widespread popularity In the ensuing decades, many thermo-
of the thermocouple, it is frequently metric scales were conceived, all
Appendix B 28
misused. For this reason, we will based on two or more fixed points.
Thermocouple Hardware 30 concentrate primarily on thermo- One scale, however, wasn’t universally
Bibliography 31 couple measurement techniques. recognized until the early 1700’s when
Gabriel Fahrenheit, a Dutch instru-
Appendix A contains the empirical ment maker, produced accurate and
laws of thermocouples which are the repeatable mercury thermometers.
basis for all derivations used herein. For the fixed point on the low end
Readers wishing a more thorough of his temperature scale, Fahrenheit
discussion of thermocouple theory used a mixture of ice water and salt
are invited to read reference 3 in (or ammonium chloride). This was the
the Bibliography. lowest temperature he could repro-
duce, and he labeled it “zero degrees.”
For those with a specific thermo- For the high end of his scale, he chose
couple application, Appendix B may human blood temperature and called
aid in choosing the best type of it 96 degrees.
thermocouple.
Why 96 and not 100 degrees? Earlier
Throughout this application note we scales had been divided into twelve
will emphasize the practical considera- parts. Fahrenheit, in an apparent quest
tions of transducer placement, signal for more resolution divided his scale
conditioning and instrumentation. into 24, then 48 and eventually
96 parts.
Early Measuring Devices
The Fahrenheit scale gained populari-
Galileo is credited with inventing the ty primarily because of the repeatabili-
thermometer, circa 1592.1,2 In an open ty and quality of the thermometers
container filled with colored alcohol, that Fahrenheit built.
he suspended a long narrow-throated
glass tube, at the upper end of which Around 1742, Anders Celsius proposed
was a hollow sphere. When heated, that the melting point of ice and the
the air in the sphere expanded and boiling point of water be used for the
bubbled through the liquid. Cooling two benchmarks. Celsius selected
the sphere caused the liquid to move zero degrees as the boiling point
up the tube.1 Fluctuations in the and 100 degrees as the melting point.
temperature of the sphere could then Later, the end points were reversed
be observed by noting the position of and the centigrade scale was born. In
1948 the name was officially changed
to the Celsius scale.
2
In the early 1800’s William Thomson Thermocouple RTD Thermistor I. C. Sensor
(Lord Kelvin), developed a universal
thermodynamic scale based upon the V R R V or I
Voltage or Current
coefficient of expansion of an ideal
Resistance
Resistance
gas. Kelvin established the concept of
Voltage
absolute zero, and his scale remains
the standard for modern thermometry.
T T T T
The conversion equations for the four Temperature Temperature Temperature Temperature
modern temperature scales are: Advantages
°C = 5/9 (°F - 32) °F = 9/5° C + 32 ● Self-powered ● Most stable ● High output ● Most linear
°k = °C + 273.15 °R = °F + 459.67 ● Simple ● Most accurate ● Fast ● Highest output
● Rugged ● More linear than ● Two-wire ohms ● Inexpensive
● Inexpensive thermocouple measurement
The Rankine Scale (°R) is simply the
● Wide variety of
Fahrenheit equivalent of the Kelvin
physical forms
scale, and was named after an early ● Wide temperature
pioneer in the field of thermodynam- range
ics, W. J. M. Rankine. Notice the
official Kelvin scale does not carry a
degree sign. The units are expressed Disadvantages
● Non-linear ● Expensive ● Non-linear ● T < 250° C
in “kelvins,” not degrees Kelvin. ● Low voltage ● Slow ● Limited temperature ● Power supply
● Reference required ● Current source range required
Reference Temperatures ● Least stable required ● Fragile ● Slow
● Least sensitive ● Small resistance ● Current source ● Self-heating
We cannot build a temperature divider change required ● Limited
as we can a voltage divider, nor can ● Four-wire ● Self-heating configurations
we add temperatures as we would add measurement
lengths to measure distance. We must
rely upon temperatures established by
physical phenomena which are easily
observed and consistent in nature.
3
The Thermocouple
When two wires composed of Measuring Thermocouple Voltage The Reference Junction
dissimilar metals are joined at both
ends and one of the ends is heated, We can’t measure the Seebeck voltage One way to determine the temperature
there is a continuous current which directly because we must first connect J2 is to physically put the junction
flows in the thermoelectric circuit. a voltmeter to the thermocouple, and into an ice bath, forcing its tempera-
Thomas Seebeck made this discovery the voltmeter leads, themselves, create ture to be 0° C and establishing J2 as
in 1821 (Figure 2). a new thermoelectric circuit. the Reference Junction. Since both
voltmeter terminal junctions are
If this circuit is broken at the center, Let’s connect a voltmeter across a now copper-copper, they create no
the net open circuit voltage (the copper-constantan (Type T) thermo- thermal e.m.f. and the reading V on
Seebeck voltage) is a function of couple and look at the voltage the voltmeter is proportional to the
the junction temperature and the com- output (Figure 4). temperature difference between J1
position of the two metals (Figure 3). and J2.
We would like the voltmeter to read
All dissimilar metals exhibit this only V1, but by connecting the volt- Now the voltmeter reading is
effect. The most common combina- meter in an attempt to measure the (See Figure 5):
tions of two metals are listed on output of Junction J1 we have created V = (V1 – V2) ≅ α(tJ – tJ )
1 2
page 28 of this application note, along two more metallic junctions: J2 and J3.
with their important characteristics. Since J3 is a copper-to-copper junc- If we specify TJ in degrees Celsius:
1
For small changes in temperature tion, it creates no thermal e.m.f. TJ (°C) + 273.15 = tJ (K)
(V3 = 0) but J2 is a copper-to constan- 1 1
the Seebeck voltage is linearly
proportional to temperature: tan junction which will add an e.m.f. then V becomes:
eAB = αT (V2) in opposition to V1. The resultant V = V1 – V2 = α[(TJ + 273.15) – (TJ + 273.15)]
voltmeter reading V will be propor- 1 2
= α(TJ – TJ ) = (TJ – 0)
Where α, the Seebeck coefficient, is tional to the temperature difference 1 2 1
V = αTJ
the constant of proportionality. (For between J1 and J2. This says that we 1
real world thermocouples, α is not can’t find the temperature at J1 unless
constant but varies with temperature. we first find the temperature of J2.
This factor is discussed under
“Voltage-to-Temperature Conversion”
on page 9.)
Figure 2 Figure 3
The Seebeck
Effect
Metal A Metal A Metal A
+
I eAB
-
Metal B Metal B
Figure 4
Measuring
junction
voltage with
a DVM
J3 Equivalent Circuits:
Cu + - Cu Cu
Cu v3
+ Cu + +
HI
-
v
LO
C
+
v
- 1
J1
= J3
+ -
-
v1
J1
= + -
-
v1
J1
Cu v2 v2
Cu C Cu C
J2 J2 J2
Voltmeter
v3 = 0
4
We use this protracted derivation to Figure 5
emphasize that the ice bath junction External
output V2 is not zero volts. It is a reference
junction
function of absolute temperature.
J3
By adding the voltage of the ice
Cu Cu + + TJ
point reference junction, we have now + HI v1
+ J1 1
referenced the reading V to 0° C. This
method is very accurate because the -
v
LO + -
v2
v1
- = v
+ -
-
Cu Cu C - v2
ice point temperature can be precisely
controlled. The ice point is used by J4 J2 J2
Voltmeter
the National Institute of Standards and T = 0° C
Technology (NIST) as the fundamental Ice Bath
reference point for their thermocouple
tables, so we can now look at the
NIST tables and directly convert from
voltage V to Temperature TJ . Figure 6 Figure 7
1
Iron Constantan Junction
The copper-constantan thermocouple couple voltage
shown in Figure 5 is a unique example cancellation
because the copper wire is the same J3 J3
Fe v3
metal as the voltmeter terminals. Cu Cu +- v1 = v
+ HI J1 + + if v2 = v4
Let’s use an iron-constantan (Type J) v +v v v1
thermocouple instead of the copper- - LO - 1 - - i.e., if
Cu C Cu +- TJ = TJ
constantan. The iron wire (Figure 6) Fe v4 3 4
5
Reference Circuit Figure 9a
Eliminating
The circuit in Figure 8 will give us the ice bath
accurate readings, but it would be nice
to eliminate the ice bath if possible. Isothermal Block
Cu Fe
Let’s replace the ice bath with another + HI
isothermal block (Figure 9). v J1
- LO J3
C
The new block is at Reference Cu Fe
Temperature TREF, and because J4 JREF
J3 and J4 are still at the same Voltmeter
temperature we can again show that: TREF Isothermal Block
V = α(T1 – TREF)
TREF
6
Now we can proceed to the next Figure 12
logical step: Directly measure the External
temperature of the isothermal block reference Block Temperature = TREF
Cu
junction - J3
(the reference junction) and use that no ice bath Fe
information to compute the unknown + HI + J1
v v
temperature, TJ (Figure 12). - - 1
1 LO
J4 C
A thermistor, whose resistance RT is a Cu
function of temperature, provides us Voltmeter RT
with a way to measure the absolute
temperature of the reference junction.
Junctions J3 and J4 and the thermistor
Figure 13
are all assumed to be at the same
Switching
temperature, due to the design of multiple
the isothermal block. Using a digital thermocouple
multimeter (DMM), we simply: types
1. Measure RT to find TREF and Fe
convert TREF to its equivalent
C
reference junction voltage, VREF HI
+
2. Measure V and add VREF to find V1 v
- LO RT
and convert V1 to temperature TJ .
1
Voltmeter Pt
This procedure is known as All Copper Wires
Pt - 10%Rh
software compensation because it
Isothermal Block
relies upon software in the instrument
(Zone Box)
or a computer to compensate for the
effect of the reference junction. The
isothermal terminal block temperature
sensor can be any device which has a
reference compensation and software Software compensation is the most
characteristic proportional to absolute
voltage-to-temperature conversion, versatile technique we have for
temperature: an RTD, a thermistor, or
using a thermocouple becomes as easy measuring thermocouples. Many
an integrated circuit sensor.
as connecting a pair of wires. thermocouples are connected on the
same block, copper leads are used
It seems logical to ask: If we already
Thermocouple measurement becomes throughout the scanner, and the tech-
have a device that will measure
especially convenient when we are nique is independent of the types of
absolute temperature (like an RTD or
required to monitor a large number thermocouples chosen. In addition,
thermistor), why do we even bother
of data points. This is accomplished when using a data acquisition system
with a thermocouple that requires
by using the isothermal reference with a built-in zone box, we simply
reference junction compensation? The
junction for more than one thermo- connect the thermocouple as we
single most important answer to this
couple element (Figure 13). A relay would a pair of test leads. All of
question is that the thermistor, the
scanner connects the voltmeter to the the conversions are performed by
RTD, and the integrated circuit trans-
various thermocouples in sequence. the instrument’s software. The one
ducer are only useful over a certain
All of the voltmeter and scanner wires disadvantage is that it requires a small
temperature range. Thermocouples,
are copper, independent of the type of amount of additional time to calculate
on the other hand, can be used over a
thermocouple chosen. In fact, as long the reference junction temperature.
range of temperatures, and optimized
as we know what each thermocouple For maximum speed we can use
for various atmospheres. They are
is, we can mix thermocouple types on hardware compensation.
much more rugged than thermistors,
the same isothermal junction block
as evidenced by the fact that thermo-
(often called a zone box) and make
couples are often welded to a metal
the appropriate modifications in soft-
part or clamped under a screw. They
ware. The junction block temperature
can be manufactured on the spot,
sensor, RT is located at the center of
either by soldering or welding. In
the block to minimize errors due to
short, thermocouples are the most
thermal gradients.
versatile temperature transducers
available and since the measurement
system performs the entire task of
7
Hardware Compensation a wide variety of thermocouples. The compensation measurement. However,
major drawback is that a unique ice today’s faster microprocessors and
Rather than measuring the tempera- point reference circuit is usually advanced data acquisition designs
ture of the reference junction and needed for each individual thermo- continue to blur the line between
computing its equivalent voltage as we couple type. the two methods, with software
did with software compensation, we compensation speeds challenging
could insert a battery to cancel the Figure 15 shows a practical ice point those of hardware compensation in
offset voltage of the reference junc- reference circuit that can be used in practical applications (Table 2).
tion. The combination of this hard- conjunction with a relay scanner to
ware compensation voltage and the compensate an entire block of thermo-
reference junction voltage is equal to couple inputs. All the thermocouples
that of a 0° C junction (Figure 14). Table 2
in the block must be of the same type, Hardware Software
but each block of inputs can accom- Compensation Compensation
The compensation voltage, e, is a modate a different thermocouple type
function of the temperature sensing
● Fast ● Requires more soft-
by simply changing gain resistors. ware manipulation
resistor, RT. The voltage V is now ● Restricted to one
time
referenced to 0° C, and may be read themocouple type
The advantage of the hardware com- per reference ● Versatile – accepts
directly and converted to temperature pensation circuit or electronic ice junction any thermocouple
by using the NIST tables. point reference is that we eliminate ● Hard to reconfigure – ● Easy to reconfigure
the need to compute the reference requires hardware
Another name for this circuit is the temperature. This saves us two com- change for new
electronic ice point reference.6 These putation steps and makes a hardware
thermocouple type
circuits are commercially available compensation temperature measure-
for use with any voltmeter and with ment somewhat faster than a software
Figure 14
Hardware
compensation
circuit
Cu Fe Cu Fe + Cu Fe
+ +
T T T
v C v C
-
Cu Fe
- +
Fe
= -
Cu Fe C
= -
v
Cu RT
Cu
+ Cu
-
e
0° C
Figure 15
Practical
hardware
compensation Cu Fe
+ HI J1
v Cu C
- LO
RH
Cu i
Voltmeter
Integrated
Temperature
Sensor
8
Voltage-To-Temperature Conversion Figure 16 Figure 17
Thermocouple Seebeck
We have used hardware and software temperature vs. coefficient
compensation to synthesize an ice- voltage graph vs. temperature
point reference. Now all we have to
do is to read the digital voltmeter and 80 100
E
convert the voltage reading to a
Millivolts
of a thermocouple is not linear. Output J T J
40 60
voltages for some popular thermocou- linear region
ples are plotted as a function of tem- (See Text)
perature in Figure 16. If the slope of T R 40
20
the curve (the Seebeck coefficient) is S K
plotted vs. temperature, as in Figure
20
17, it becomes quite obvious that the 0 500° 1000° 1500° 2000° R
thermocouple is a non-linear device. Temperature °C S
Type Metals -500° 0° 500° 1000° 1500° 2000°
A horizontal line in Figure 17 + - Temperature °C
would indicate a constant α, in other E Chromel vs. Constantan
words, a linear device. We notice that J Iron vs. Constantan
the slope of the type K thermocouple K Chromel vs. Alumel
approaches a constant over a temp- R Platinum vs. Platinum
erature range from 0° C to 1000° C. 13% Rhodium
Consequently, the type K can be S Platinum vs. Platinum
10% Rhodium
used with a multiplying voltmeter
T Copper vs. Constantan
and an external ice point reference to
obtain a moderately accurate direct
readout of temperature. That is, the
temperature display involves only a Table 3
scale factor. Type E Thermocouple
Temperatures in °C (ITS-90)
By examining the variations in Seebeck mV .00 .01 .02 .03 .04 .05 .06 .07 .08 .09 .10 mV
coefficient, we can easily see that 0.00 0.00 0.17 0.34 0.51 0.68 0.85 1.02 1.19 1.36 1.53 1.70 0.00
using one constant scale factor would 0.10 1.70 1.87 2.04 2.21 2.38 2.55 2.72 2.89 3.06 3.23 3.40 0.10
limit the temperature range of the sys-
0.20 3.40 3.57 3.74 3.91 4.08 4.25 4.42 4.59 4.76 4.92 5.09 0.20
tem and restrict the system accuracy.
Better conversion accuracy can be 0.30 5.09 5.26 5.43 5.60 5.77 5.94 6.11 6.28 6.45 6.61 6.78 0.30
obtained by reading the voltmeter and 0.40 6.78 6.95 7.12 7.29 7.46 7.63 7.79 7.96 8.13 8.30 8.47 0.40
consulting the NIST Thermocouple 0.50 8.47 8.64 8.80 8.97 9.14 9.31 9.48 9.64 9.81 9.98 10.15 0.50
Tables4 (NIST Monograph 175 — 0.60 10.l5 10.32 10.48 10.65 10.82 10.99 11.15 11.32 11.49 11.66 11.82 0.60
see Table 3).
0.70 11.82 11.99 12.16 12.33 12.49 12.66 12.83 12.99 13.16 13.33 13.50 0.70
We could store these look-up table 0.80 13.50 13.66 13.83 14.00 14.16 14.33 14.50 14.66 14.83 15.00 15.16 0.80
values in a computer, but they would 0.90 15.16 15.33 15.50 15.66 15.83 16.00 16.16 16.33 16.49 16.66 16.83 0.90
consume an inordinate amount of 1.00 16.83 l6.99 17.16 17.32 17.49 17.66 17.82 17.99 18.15 18.32 18.49 1.00
memory. A more viable approach is 1.10 18.49 18.65 18.82 18.98 19.15 19.31 19.48 19.64 19.81 19.98 20.14 1.10
to approximate the table values using 1.20 20.14 20.31 20.47 20.64 20.80 20.97 21.13 21.30 21.46 21.63 21.79 1.20
a power series polynomial:
1.30 21.79 21.96 22.12 22.29 22.45 22.61 22.78 22.94 23.11 23.27 23.44 1.30
t90 = c0 + c1x + c2x2 + c3 x3 + ... + cnxn
1.40 23.44 23.60 23.77 23.93 24.10 24.26 24.42 24.59 24.75 24.92 25.08 1.40
where
t90 = Temperature
x = Thermocouple Voltage
c = Polynomial coefficients unique to
each thermocouple
n = Maximum order of the polynomial
9
As n increases, the accuracy of the Table 4
polynomial improves. Lower order NIST ITS-90 Polynomial Coefficients
polynomials may be used over a nar- Thermocouple Type Type J Type K
row temperature range to obtain high- Temperature Range -210° C to O°C O° C to 760° C -200° C to 0° C 0° C to 500° C
er system speed. Table 4 is an example Error Range ± 0.05° C ± 0.04° C ± 0.04° C ±0.05° C
of the polynomials used in conjunction Polynomial Order 8th order 7th order 8th order 9th order
with software compensation for a C0 0 0 0 0
data acquisition system. Rather than C2 1.9528268 x 10-2 1.978425 x 10-2 2.5173462 x 10-2 2.508355 x 10-2
directly calculating the exponentials, C1 -1.2286185 x 10-6 -2.001204 x 10-7 -1.1662878 x 10-6 7.860106 x 10-8
the software is programmed to use the
C3 -1.0752178 x 10-9 1.036969 x 10-11 -1.0833638 x 10-9 -2.503131 x 10-10
nested polynomial form to save exe-
cution time. The polynomial fit rapidly C4 -5.9086933 x 10-13 -2.549687 x 10-16 -8.9773540 v 10-13 8.315270 x 10-14
degrades outside the temperature C5 -1.7256713 x 10-16 3.585153 x 10-21 -3.7342377 x 10-16 -1.228034 x 10-17
range shown in Table 4 and should not C6 -2.8131513 x 10-20 -5.344285 x 10-26 -8.6632643 x 10-20 9.804036 x 10-22
be extrapolated outside those limits. C7 -2.3963370 x 10-24 5.099890 x 10-31 -1.0450598 x 10-23 -4.413030 x 10-26
C8 -8.3823321 x 10-29 -5.1920577 x 10-28 1.057734 x 10-30
The calculation of high-order polyno-
C9 -1.052755 x 10-35
mials is a time consuming task, even
for today’s high-powered micropro- Temperature Conversion Equation: t90 = c0 + c1x + c2x2 +...+ c9x9
cessors. As we mentioned before, we Nested Polynomial Form (4th order example): t90 = c0 + x(c1 + x(c2 + x(c3 + c4x)))
can save time by using a lower order
polynomial for a smaller temperature
range. In the software for one data Table 5
acquisition system, the thermocouple Required DVM sensitivity
characteristic curve is divided into Thermocouple SeebeckCoefficient DVM Sensitivity
eight sectors and each sector is Type at 25° C (µV/°C) for 0.1° C (µV)
approximated by a third-order E 61 6.1
polynomial (Figure 18).
J 52 5.2
of first order equations, they can make tion (the more bits, the better) and
hundreds, even thousands, of internal measurement accuracy from the
{
10
Practical Thermocouple
Measurement
Noise Rejection Analog Filter - A filter may be used Since thermocouple circuits that
directly at the input of a voltmeter to cover long distances are especially
Tree Switching - Tree switching is a reduce noise. It reduces interference susceptible to power line related
method of organizing the channels of a dramatically, but causes the voltmeter noise, it is advisable to use an integrat-
scanner into groups, each with its own to respond more slowly to step inputs ing analog-to-digital converter to
main switch. (Figure 20). measure the thermocouple voltage.
Integration is an especially attractive
Without tree switching, every channel Integration - Integration is an A/D A/D technique in light of recent inno-
can contribute noise directly through technique which essentially averages vations have brought the cost in line
its stray capacitance. With tree switch- noise over a full line cycle, thus power with historically less expensive A/D
ing, groups of parallel channel capaci- line-related noise and its harmonics technologies.
tances are in series with a single tree are virtually eliminated. If the integra-
switch capacitance. The result is tion period is chosen to be less than
greatly reduced crosstalk in a large an integer line cycle, its noise rejec-
data acquisition system, due to the tion properties are essentially negated.
reduced interchannel capacitance
(Figure 19).
Figure 19
Tree switching
C
+ DVM
+ +
Signal C HI Signal Signal
- (20 Channels) - DVM
Tree - DVM
Switch1
= Noise ~
20 C C HI
~= Noise ~
C HI
Stray capacitance to
Source Source
Noise Source is reduced
Noise ~ C nearly 20:1 by leaving
Source
Tree Switch 2 open.
Next 20 Channels
C
Tree
Switch2
Figure 20
Analog filter
vIN vOUT
t t
11
Isolation - A noise source that is Figure 21
common to both high and low meas- Isolation
urement leads is called common mode minimizes
common
noise. Isolated inputs help to reduce
mode current
this noise as well as protect the 220 VAC Line
measurement system from ground Distributed
loops and transients (Figure 21). Capacitance HI
Let’s assume a thermocouple wire has
been pulled through the same conduit LO
as a 220V AC supply line. The capaci-
Distributed
tance between the power lines and the Resistance
thermocouple lines will create an AC DVM
signal of approximately equal magni-
tude on both thermocouple wires. This
is not a problem in an ideal circuit, but
the voltmeter is not ideal. It has some Figure 22
capacitance between its low terminal
240 VRMS
and safety ground (earth). Current
flows through this capacitance and
through the thermocouple lead resist-
ance, creating a normal mode signal
which appears as measurement error.
12
Practical Precautions Figure 25 Figure 26
Soldering a Gradient
We have discussed the concepts of thermocouple produces
the reference junction, how to use a Fe voltage
polynomial to extract absolute temper- 25° C 100° C
ature data and what to look for in a
data acquisition system to minimize C
Solder (Pb, Sn)
the effects of noise. Now let’s look 200
Junction: Fe - Pb, Sn - C ≅ Fe - C 300
at the thermocouple wire itself. The 400
polynomial curve fit relies upon the ~ 500
thermocouple wire being perfect; that
is, it must not become decalibrated
during the act of making a tempera- 500° C Metal Bath
ture measurement. We shall now
discuss some of the pitfalls of
thermocouple thermometry.
13
Shunt Impedance Figure 27 Figure 28
Leakage Virtual
High temperatures can also take their resistance junction
toll on thermocouple wire insulators. (Open) RS RS
Insulation resistance decreases expo-
nentially with increasing temperature, To DVM RL To DVM RL T2
even to the point that it creates a vir-
tual junction. Assume we have a com- RS T1 RS
pletely open thermocouple operating
at a high temperature (Figure 27).
14
Wire Calibration Since channel numbers invariably Event Record - The first diagnostic
change, data should be categorized by is not a test at all, but a recording of
Thermocouple wire is manufactured measurand, not just channel number.10 all pertinent events that could even
to a certain specification signifying its Information about any given measur- remotely affect the measurements.
conformance with the NIST tables. and, such as transducer type, output An example is:
The specification can sometimes be voltage, typical value, and location can
enhanced by calibrating the wire be maintained in a data file. This can Figure 29
(testing it at known temperatures). be done under PC control or simply March 18 Event Record
Consecutive pieces of wire on a con- by filling out a preprinted form. No 10:43 Power failure
tinuous spool will generally track each matter how the data is maintained, 10:47 System power returned
other more closely than the specified the importance of a concise system
tolerance, although their output volt- 11:05 Changed M821 to
should not be underestimated, type K thermocouple
ages may be slightly removed from the especially at the outset of a complex
center of the absolute specification. 13:51 New data acquisition program
data gathering project.
16:07 M821 appears to be bad reading
If the wire is calibrated in an effort
Diagnostics
to improve its fundamental specifica- We look at our program listing and
tions, it becomes even more impera- Most of the sources of error that we find that measurand #M821 uses a
tive that all of the aforementioned have mentioned are aggravated by type J thermocouple and that our new
conditions be heeded in order to using the thermocouple near its tem- data acquisition program interprets it
avoid decalibration. perature limits. These conditions will as type J. But from the event record,
be encountered infrequently in most apparently thermocouple #M821 was
Documentation applications. But what about the situa- changed to a type K, and the change
tion where we are using small thermo- was not entered into the program.
It may seem incongruous to speak of couples in a harsh atmosphere at high While most anomalies are not discov-
documentation as being a source of temperatures? How can we tell when ered this easily, the event record
voltage measurement error, but the the thermocouple is producing erro- can provide valuable insight into the
fact is that thermocouple systems, neous results? We need to develop a reason for an unexplained change in
by their very ease of use, invite a large reliable set of diagnostic procedures. a system measurement. This is espe-
number of data points. The sheer mag- cially true in a system configured to
nitude of the data can become quite Through the use of diagnostic measure hundreds of data points.
unwieldy. When a large amount of data techniques, R.P. Reed has developed
is taken, there is an increased proba- an excellent system for detecting a
bility of error due to mislabeling of faulty thermocouple and data chan-
lines, using the wrong NIST curve, etc. nels.10 Three components of this
system are the event record, the
zone box test and the thermocouple
resistance history.
15
Zone Box Test - The zone box is Figure 30
an isothermal terminal block with a Shorting the
known temperature used in place of thermocouples
at the terminals
an ice bath reference. If we temporari-
ly short-circuit the thermocouple
directly at the zone box, the system Cu TREF
should read a temperature very close Cu Fe
to that of the zone box, i.e., close to + HI
v Copper Wire Short TJ
room temperature (Figure 30). - LO
Cu C
If the thermocouple lead resistance is Cu
much greater than the shunting resist- Voltmeter Zone Box
ance, the copper wire shunt forces Isothermal Block
V = 0. In the normal unshorted case,
we want to measure TJ, and the
system reads:
V = α(TJ – TREF) Figure 31 Figure 32
Burning Thermocouple
But, for the functional test, we have coal resistance
seam vs. time
shorted the terminals so that V = 0.
The indicated temperature TJ is thus:
0 = α(TJ – TREF ) To Data
Acquisition T1
TJ = TREF
Resistance
System
16
The resistance of the thermocouple Figure 33 Figure 34
will naturally change with time as the Cause of the
resistivity of the wire changes due to resistance
change
varying temperatures. But a sudden
change in resistance is an indication
TS T1
that something is wrong. In this case,
the resistance has dropped abruptly, Short Leg-Branched Thermocouple
indicating that the insulation has
failed, effectively shortening the
thermocouple loop (Figure 33).
17
The RTD
18
Metal Film RTD’s Figure 38 Figure 39
Effect of Wheatstone
In the newest construction technique, lead resistance bridge
a platinum or metal-glass slurry film is Lead R = 5Ω
deposited or screened onto a small flat
ceramic substrate, etched with a laser- + DVM
100Ω RTD -
trimming system, and sealed. The film
RTD offers substantial reduction in
Lead R = 5Ω RTD
assembly time and has the further
advantage of increased resistance for
a given size. Due to the manufacturing
technology, the device size itself is Table 6
small, which means it can respond Resistivity Ω/CMF
quickly to step changes in tempera- Metal (cmf = circular mil foot)
ture. Film RTD’s are less stable than Gold Au 13.00
their wire-wound counterparts, but Silver Ag 8.8
they are more popular because of their
Copper Cu 9.26
decided advantages in size, production
cost and ruggedness. Platinum Pt 59.00
Tungsten W 30.00
Metals - All metals produce a positive Nickel Ni 36.00
change in resistance for a positive
change in temperature. This, of
course, is the main function of an
RTD. As we shall soon see, system
error is minimized when the nominal
value of the RTD resistance is large.
This implies a metal wire with a high The most common RTD’s are made average slope from 0° C to 100° C. The
resistivity. The lower the resistivity of of either platinum, nickel, or nickel more chemically pure platinum wire
the metal, the more material we will alloys. The economical nickel deriva- used in platinum resistance standards
have to use. tive wires are used over a limited has an α of +.00392 ohms/ohm/° C.
temperature range. They are quite
Table 6 lists the resistivities of non-linear and tend to drift with time. Both the slope and the absolute value
common RTD materials. For measurement integrity, platinum are small numbers, especially when
is the obvious choice. we consider the fact that the measure-
Because of their lower resistivities, ment wires leading to the sensor may
gold and silver are rarely used as RTD Resistance Measurement be several ohms or even tens of ohms.
elements. Tungsten has a relatively A small lead impedance can contribute
high resistivity, but is reserved for very The common values of resistance for a significant error to our temperature
high temperature applications because a platinum RTD range from 10 ohms measurement (Figure 38).
it is extremely brittle and difficult for the bird-cage model to several
to work. thousand ohms for the film RTD. The A 10 ohm lead impedance implies
single most common value is 100 10/.385 ≅ 26° C error in our measure-
Copper is used occasionally as an ohms at 0° C. The DIN 43760 standard ment. Even the temperature coeffi-
RTD element. Its low resistivity temperature coefficient of platinum cient of the lead wire can contribute
forces the element to be longer than a wire is α = .00385. For a 100 ohm wire a measurable error. The classical
platinum element, but its linearity and this corresponds to +0.385 Ω/°C at method of avoiding this problem has
very low cost make it an economical 0° C. This value for α is actually the been the use of a bridge (Figure 39).
alternative. Its upper temperature
limit is only about 120° C.
19
The bridge output voltage is an indi- Figure 40 Figure 42
rect indication of the RTD resistance. 4-Wire
The bridge requires four connection Ohms
+ DVM Measurement
wires, an external source, and three
- RTD
resistors that have a zero temperature +
coefficient. To avoid subjecting the i=0
i DVM 100Ω RTD
three bridge-completion resistors to i=0
the same temperature as the RTD, the -
RTD is separated from the bridge by a
pair of extension wires (Figure 40). Figure 41
3-Wire Bridge
These extension wires recreate the
problem that we had initially: The
DVM A
impedance of the extension wires
affects the temperature reading. This C
effect can be minimized by using a B
three-wire bridge configuration
(Figure 41).
[ ( )( ) ( ) ( )]
The digital voltmeter measures only 3
the voltage dropped across the RTD RT=R0+R0α T–δ T -1 T -β T -1 T
100 100 100 100
and is insensitive to the length of the
lead wires (Figure 42). Where:
RT = resistance at temperature T
R0 = resistance at T = 0° C
α = temperature coefficient at T = 0° C
(typically + 0.00392Ω/Ω/° C)
δ = 1.49 (typical value for .00392 platinum)
β = 0 T>0
0.11 (typical) T < 0
20
The exact values for coefficients α, δ Figure 43
and β are determined by testing the 16
Resistance Temperature
equation was replaced in 1968 by a .390
20th order polynomial in order to 12
Coefficient - RTD
.344
provide a more accurate curve fit.
.293
Type S
vs. Platinum RTD
4
Practical Precautions 400 600 800
0 200
The same practical precautions that Temperature °C
apply to thermocouples also apply to
RTD’s, i.e., use shields and twisted-
pair wire, use proper sheathing, avoid
stress and steep-gradients, use large Small RTD Large RTD
extension wire, keep good documenta- Fast Response Time Slow Response Time
tion and use an integrating DMM. In
Low Thermal Shunting Poor Thermal Shunting
addition, the following precautions
should be observed. High Self-heating Error Low Self-heating Error
21
The Thermistor
v or R
describes the thermistor is sensitive.
Of the three major categories of
RTD
sensors, the thermistor exhibits by
far the largest parameter change
with temperature. Thermocouple
22
Monolithic Linear
Temperature Sensor
10mv/K
configurations. Both supply an To DVM
output that is linearly proportional to
absolute temperature. Typical values 10kΩ To DVM
are 1 µA/K and 10 mV/K F (Figure 45).
23
The Measurement System
24
The Agilent DAC1000 data acquisition Figure 48
and control system (Figure 48), Agilent DAC1000
another example solution, provides System
high-speed temperature measurements
where point count is high. When
configured for temperature
measurements, it consists of:
● E1419A scanning analog-to-
digital converter (ADC) module with
64 channels that can be configured
for temperature measurements.
Scanning rate is 56,000 channels/s.
Several hundred channel configura-
tions are possible with multiple
modules.
● Signal conditioning plug-on (SCP)
that rides piggy-back on the ADC
module provides input for
thermocouples.
● External terminal block with
built-in thermocouple reference
junction and terminal connections
to the application.
● Four-wire Ohms SCP with offset
compensation for RTD and
thermistor measurements.
This VXI-based system offers much Agilent VEE provides data collection,
● Built-in engineering unit conversions
more than temperature measurements. test reporting and a friendly graphical
for thermocouple, thermistor, and
It provides a wide variety of analog/ user interface.
RTD measurements.
digital input and output capability
required by designers of electro- Agilent also offers other VXI-based
mechanical products and manufactur- solutions for temperature measure-
ers needing stringent monitoring and ments. Product choices range from
control of physical processes. The small compact systems for portable
DAC1000 is a recommended configura- or remote operation to high-speed
tion consisting of the E1419A, 6-slot scanning systems that also provide
VXI mainframe, GPIB interfaces, and advanced control and analysis
Agilent VEE for the PC. Agilent VEE, capabilities.
a powerful time-saving graphical pro-
gramming language, is programmed
by connecting a few icons or objects
resembling a block diagram.
25
Summary
26
Appendix A
Isothermal
in understanding and diagnosing
T1 Block
thermocouple circuits.
27
Appendix B
28
Type T - This is the only thermo- Type T
couple with published standard wire Cu
errors for the temperature region
T1
below 0° C; however, type E is actually Cu
+ HI
more suitable at very low tempera- C
v = a(T1 - T2)
tures because of its higher Seebeck - LO
coefficient and lower thermal Cu
T2
conductivity. Voltmeter Cu
(Ambient
Type T has the unique distinction of Reference)
having one copper lead. This can be
an advantage in a specialized monitor-
ing situation where a temperature
difference is all that is desired.
Tungsten - There are three common
types of tungsten thermocouples. All
The advantage is that the copper
are alloyed with rhenium to make the
thermocouple leads are the same
metal more malleable.
metal as the DVM terminals, making
Type G* W vs W–26% Re
lead compensation unnecessary.
Type C* W–5% Re vs W–26% Re
Type D* W–3% Re vs W–25% Re
Types K & N - Type K has long
been a popular thermocouple.
Tungsten thermocouples are used
It is especially suited to higher
for measuring very high temperatures
temperature applications due to its
in either a vacuum or an inert
resistance to oxidation.
atmosphere.
The type N thermocouple is gaining
popularity as a replacement for type
K. It has a slightly lower output
(smaller Seebeck coefficient) than
type K, but an even higher resistance
to oxidation. The type N thermocouple
output curve is dependent upon wire
size, and there are two distinct
Nicrosil-Nisil characteristic curves
published in NIST Monograph 175,
the differences being wire size and
temperature range.14
29
Thermocouple Hardware
● convenient mounting
†Material range is for 8 AWG wire and decreases with decreasing wire size.
30
Bibliography
1. Charles Herzfeld, F.G. Brickwedde: 8. R.P. Reed: Branched Thermocouple 15.J.P. Tavener: Platinum Resistance
Temperature - Its Measurement Circuits in Underground Coal Temperature Detectors - State of
and Control in Science and Gasification Experiments, the Art, Measurements & Control,
Industry, Vol. 3, Part 1, Reinhold, Proceedings of the 22nd ISA Measurements & Data Corporation,
New York, 1962. International Instrumentation Pittsburgh, PA., April 1974.
Symposium, Instrument Society of
America, 1976.
2. Robert P. Benedict: Fundamentals 16.J.P. Evans and G.W. Burns: A Study
of Temperature, Pressure and of Stability of High Temperature
Flow Measurements, John Wiley & 9. R.J. Moffat: The Gradient Platinum Resistance
Sons, Inc., New York, 1969. Approach to Thermocouple Thermometers, in Temperature -
Circuitry, from Temperature - Its Its Measurement and Control on
Measurement and Control in Science and Industry, Reinhold,
3. Manual on the Use of
Science and Industry, Reinhold, New York, 1962.
Thermocouples in Temperature
New York, 1962.
Measurement, Fourth Edition,
Revision of ASTM Special 17.D.D. Pollock: The Theory and
Publication 470B, Philadelphia, PA., 10.R.P. Reed: A Diagnostics-oriented Properties of Thermocouple
1993. System for Thermocouple Elements, ASTM STP 492, Omega
Thermometry, Proceedings of 24th Press, Ithaca, New York, 1979.
ISA International Instrumentation
4. Temperature-Electromotive Force
Symposium, Instrument Society of
Reference Functions and Tables 18.YSI Precision Thermistors, Yellow
America, 1978.
for the Letter-Designated Springs Instruments, Inc., Yellow
Thermocouple Types Based on the Springs, Ohio, 1977.
ITS-90, NIST Monograph 175, 11.Harry R. Norton: Handbook of
National Institute of Standards and Transducers for Electronic
19.R.P. Reed: Thermoelectric
Technology, Washington, D.C., 1993 Measuring Systems, Prentice-Hall,
Thermometry. A Functional
Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.
Model, from Temperature - Its
5. H. Dean Baker, E.A. Ryder, N.H. Measurement and Control in
Baker: Temperature Measurement 12.C.H. Meyers: Coiled Filament Science and Industry, Vol. 5,
in Engineering, Omega Press, Resistance Thermometers, NBS American Institute of Physics, N.Y.
Division of Omega Engineering Inc. Journal of Research, Vol. 9, 1932. 1982.
31
Agilent Technologies' Test and Measurement
Support, Services, and Assistance
Agilent Technologies aims to maximize the
value you receive, while minimizing your risk
and problems. We strive to ensure that you get the
test and measurement capabilities you paid for
and obtain the support you need. Our extensive
support resources and services can help
you choose the right Agilent products for your
applications and apply them successfully. Every
instrument and system we sell has a global war-
ranty. Support is available for at least five years
beyond the production life of the product. Two
concepts underlie Agilent's overall support
policy: "Our Promise" and "Your Advantage."
Our Promise
Our Promise means your Agilent test and
measurement equipment will meet its advertised
performance and functionality. When you are
choosing new equipment, we will help you with
product information, including realistic perform-
ance specifications and practical recommenda-
tions from experienced test engineers. When
you use Agilent equipment, we can verify that it
works properly, help with product operation, and
provide basic measurement assistance for the use
of specified capabilities, at no extra cost upon
request. Many self-help tools are available.
Your Advantage
Your Advantage means that Agilent offers a wide
range of additional expert test and measurement
services, which you can purchase according to
your unique technical and business needs. Solve
problems efficiently and gain a competitive edge
by contracting with us for calibration, extra-cost
upgrades, out-of-warranty repairs, and on-site
education and training, as well as design, system
integration, project management, and other
professional engineering services. Experienced
Agilent engineers and technicians worldwide can
help you maximize your productivity, optimize the
return on investment of your Agilent instruments
and systems, and obtain dependable measurement
accuracy for the life of those products.
Canada: Australia:
(tel) 1 877 894 4414 (tel) 1 800 629 485
(fax) (905) 206 4120 (fax) (61 3) 9272 0749