Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Archaeology - November-December 2021
Archaeology - November-December 2021
Inside
Egypt’s
Last
Temples
Maya Mural
Puzzle
Discovering
Ice Age
Footprints
Roman
University
Town
PLUS:
Irish Bog Idol
Venice’s Roman Road
Chinese Beer Rituals
Old West Ghost Town
Offer limited to the
B. first 1400 orders
from this
ad only
Effect Pendant for 30 days. If it fails to delight, just send it back † Special price only for customers using the
offer code versus the price on Stauer.com
for a refund of the item price. But we have a feeling happiness is without your offer code.
Rating of A+
in your future.
Stauer… Afford the Extraordi nary. ®
NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2021 • VOLUME 74, NUMBER 6
CONTENTS
38 An artificial pool dating to 1450 B.C. in Noceto, Italy, contained offerings including vases, wooden tools, and deer antlers
FEATURES
archaeology.org 1
Now, THIS is a Knife!
This 16" full tang stainless steel blade is not
EXCLUSIVE
for the faint of heart —now ONLY $99!
FREE
I n the blockbuster film, when a strapping Australian crocodile
hunter and a lovely American journalist were getting robbed at
knife point by a couple of young thugs in New York, the tough
Stauer® 8x21
Compact
Binoculars
Aussie pulls out his dagger and says “That’s not a knife, THIS is a -a $99 value-
knife!” Of course, the thugs scattered and he continued on to win with purchase of
the reporter’s heart. Down Under Knife
Our Aussie friend would approve of our rendition of his “knife.”
Forged of high grade 420 surgical stainless steel, this knife is an
impressive 16" from pommel to point. And, the blade is full tang,
meaning it runs the entirety of the knife, even though part of it is
under wraps in the natural bone and wood handle.
Secured in a tooled leather sheath, this is one impressive knife, with
an equally impressive price.
This fusion of substance and style can garner a high price tag
out in the marketplace. In fact, we found full tang, stainless steel
blades with bone handles in excess of $2,000.
Well, that won’t cut it around here. We have What Stauer Clients
mastered the hunt for the best deal, and in Are Saying About
turn pass the spoils on to our customers. Our Knives
But we don’t stop there. While supplies ÌÌÌÌÌ
last, we’ll include a pair of $99, 8x21 power “This knife is beautiful!”
compact binoculars, and a genuine leather — J., La Crescent, MN
sheath FREE when you purchase the Down
Under Bowie Knife. ÌÌÌÌÌ
Your satisfaction is 100% guaranteed. Feel “The feel of this knife
the knife in your hands, wear it on your hip, is unbelievable...this
inspect the impeccable craftsmanship. If you is an incredibly fine
don’t feel like we cut you a fair deal, send it instrument.”
back within 30 days for a complete refund of — H., Arvada, CO
the item price.
Limited Reserves. A deal like this won’t last
long. We have only 1120 Down Under Bowie
Knifes for this ad only. Don’t let this beauty slip BONUS! Call today and
through your fingers at a price that won’t drag you’ll also receive this
you under. Call today! genuine leather sheath!
Down Under Bowie Knife $249*
Offer Code Price Only $99 + S&P Save $150
1-800-333-2045
Your Insider Offer Code: DUK236-01
You must use the insider offer code to get our special price. Rating of A+
14
10
15
archaeology.org 3
EDITOR’S LETTER
Editor in Chief
Eric A. Powell
Executive Editor
Daniel Weiss
Senior Editor Associate Editor
A archaeological terms, do these words really mean? A number of stories in this issue
vividly illustrate how some sites, artifacts, and even techniques stand out from others
as truly exceptional.
Creative Director
Richard Bleiweiss
Maps
Two articles address the rarity of evidence left by enslaved people—in one case a single Ken Feisel
unique burial of a man in Roman Britain, and in the other, enslaved
Africans in Ghana captured for the transatlantic slave trade. Archae- Contributing Editors
Roger Atwood, Paul Bahn,
ologists often rely on inscriptions and artifacts to help trace the Bob Brier, Karen Coates,
personal histories of people of the past. But since both of these Andrew Curry, Blake Edgar,
types of evidence are often absent for the enslaved, identifying Brian Fagan, David Freidel,
their presence at archaeological sites is a daunting challenge. Tom Gidwitz, Andrew Lawler,
Another story explores the discovery of a massive Middle Stephen H. Lekson,
Bronze Age wooden ritual pool in northern Italy that was created Jerald T. Milanich, Samir S. Patel,
around 3,500 years ago. This tremendous engineering achievement Heather Pringle, Kate Ravilious,
is the only such monument in Europe known from its time. Archae- Neil Asher Silberman, Julian Smith,
ologists can also uncover new evidence of a people about whom much is Nikhil Swaminathan,
Jason Urbanus, Claudia Valentino,
already known, such as a campsite in Michigan used by a band of Clovis hunters, who were
Zach Zorich
not thought to have ventured so far north, or a depiction of the Maya deity Wak Tok, a god
who is only known from a single other reference. Sometimes archaeological evidence can Publisher
properly be called unique because it truly is one of a kind, such as the last known Egyptian Kevin Quinlan
hieroglyphic inscription that has been accurately dated, which you will encounter in our Director of Circulation and Fulfillment
Gerry Moss
not previously possible, as in the case of the redating of the stained glass windows of England’s
Account Manager
Canterbury Cathedral. By using a new application of X-ray technology, scientists were able Karina Casines
to date the windows without dismantling them, and in the process learned that the iconic Newsstand Consultant
glass panels held a surprise. T.J. Montilli
Perhaps the rarest artifact you will read about in this issue is the Roman glass cage cup NPS Media Group
recently found in the ancient city of Augustodunum in France. There are only a dozen or so Office Manager
complete examples of these extraordinarily crafted and delicate glass vessels, and before this Malin Grunberg Banyasz
For production questions
one, the last was found more than four decades ago. This type of cup would have belonged
contact materials@archaeology.org
only to the wealthiest citizens of the empire—and at least in one example, perhaps to an
emperor himself. The cup from Augustodunum is a nearly matchless artifact not only because Editorial Advisory Board
it was owned by an elite member of society, but also because such a fragile masterpiece has James P. Delgado, Ellen Herscher,
survived intact for more than 1,500 years. Ronald Hicks, Jean-Jacques Hublin,
Mark Lehner, Roderick J. McIntosh,
Susan Pollock, Kenneth B. Tankersley
ARCHAEOLOGY MAGAZINE
36-36 33rd Street, Long Island City, NY 11106
tel 718-472-3050 • fax 718-472-3051
NOW “To you, it’s the perfect lift chair. To me, it’s
also available in the best sleep chair I’ve ever had.”
Genuine Italian Leather — J. Fitzgerald, VA
and New Chestnut Color
(as pictured here)
Three Chairs
in One
Sleep/Recline/Lift
ACCREDITED
BUSINESS A+
You can’t always lie down in bed and sleep. prevent back and muscle pain. The overstuffed, oversized
Heartburn, cardiac problems, hip or back aches – biscuit style back and unique seat design will cradle you
and dozens of other ailments and worries. Those in comfort. Generously filled, wide armrests provide
are the nights you’d give anything for a comfortable chair enhanced arm support when sitting or reclining. It even
to sleep in: one that reclines to exactly the right degree, has a battery backup in case of a power outage.
raises your feet and legs just where you want them,
White glove delivery included in shipping charge.
supports your head and shoulders properly, and operates
Professionals will deliver the chair to the exact spot in
at the touch of a button.
your home where you want it, unpack it, inspect it, test it,
Our Perfect Sleep Chair® does all that and more. position it, and even carry the packaging away! You get
More than a chair or recliner, it’s designed to provide total your choice of Genuine Italian Leather, stain and water
comfort. Choose your preferred heat and massage repellent custom-manufactured DuraLux™ with the classic
settings, for hours of soothing relaxation. Reading leather look or plush MicroLux™ microfiber in a variety
or watching TV? Our chair’s recline technology allows of colors to fit any decor. New Chestnut color only
you to pause the chair in an infinite number of settings. available in Genuine Italian Leather Call now!
And best of all, it features a powerful lift mechanism that
tilts the entire chair forward, making it easy to stand. The Perfect Sleep Chair®
You’ll love the other benefits, too. It helps with correct
spinal alignment and promotes back pressure relief, to 1-888-728-9688
Please mention code 115743 when ordering.
Chestnut
REMOTE CONTROLLED Genuine Italian Leather
EASILY SHIFTS FROM FLAT TO classic beauty & durability
A STAND-ASSIST POSITION
Mahogany
Long Lasting DuraLux™ (Burgundy) Tan Chocolate Blue
stain & water repellent
Because each Perfect Sleep Chair is a made-to-order bedding product it cannot be returned, but if it arrives damaged
or defective, at our option we will repair it or replace it. © 2021 firstSTREET for Boomers and Beyond, Inc.
FROM THE PRESIDENT A
I of A
ARCHAEOLOGICAL
LANDSCAPES AT RISK
OFFICERS
PRESIDENT
he story from White Sands National Park in this issue reminds us that our national Laetitia La Follette
T parks and monuments are not only impressive natural landscapes, but also important
archaeological ones.
First Vice President
Elizabeth S. Greene
Vice President for Cultural Heritage
Brian Daniels
As readers of this magazine, you know that the interplay between cultural and natural Vice President for Outreach and Education
Laura Rich
resource management is an area of intense focus for archaeologists. From Indigenous Vice President for Research and Academic Affairs
cultures that have lived successfully in these eco-landscapes for hundreds, if not thousands, Thomas Tartaron
of years, we can learn about ecological resource management, the protection of biodiversity, Vice President for Societies
Sabrina Higgins
and mitigating the effects of climate change. Today these national landscapes are at risk.
Treasurer
David Adam
The Grand Staircase- The Grand Staircase-Escalante and Bears Ears Executive Director
Escalante National National Monuments in Utah have witnessed millennia Rebecca W. King
Monument of human history, from Clovis hunters and Ancestral GOVERNING BOARD
Puebloans to explorers, pioneers, those fleeing Deborah Arnold
religious persecution, and outlaws. More than 10,000 Jeanne Bailey
archaeological sites have been identified within the two Joost Blom
David Boochever
monuments, although less than 10 percent of the land has Jane Botsford Johnson
been archaeologically explored. The sites include ancient Thomas Carpenter
Jane B. Carter, ex officio
quarries and granaries, lithic scatters, camps, shelters, and Arthur Cassanos
villages. Painted rock art and carved petroglyphs record Lawrence Cripe
traces of human activity on the landscape itself. The lands Mathea Falco
Joshua Gates
remain sacred to many Native American groups. Elizabeth M. Greene
Ömür Harmanşah
In 2017, the size of these two national monuments Julie Herzig Desnick
Mark Hurst
was cut by 46 and 85 percent, respectively, removing Alexandra Jones
protection from many known archaeological sites—and countless others yet to be SeungJung Kim
Gary Linn
discovered—and opening the land to commercial development and looting. The reduction Jarrett Lobell, ex officio
of Grand Staircase-Escalante and Bears Ears also fundamentally alters the nature of the Barbara Meyer
monuments, replacing cultural landscapes with a series of disconnected spaces, subverting John Papadopoulos
Paula Paster Michtom
context and continuity. Through the efforts of Brian Daniels, vice president for cultural Kevin Quinlan, ex officio
heritage, the Archaeological Institute of America has joined environmental and Indigenous Betsey Robinson
groups to protest these cuts. A lawsuit is currently under review by the Biden administration Kim Shelton
Thomas Sienkewicz
and we hope the president will act swiftly to reinstate the prior extent of these monuments. Monica Smith
Patrick Suehnholz
Anthony Tuck
Renowned anthropologist Keith Basso famously explored how “wisdom sits in places.” Maria Vecchiotti
The footprints of those traveling across White Sands at least 10,000 years ago bear
witness to the rich archaeological heritage of our national landscapes. These landscapes are Past President
Jodi Magness
fundamental to our understanding of the human past, present, and future. Let us protect
and cherish them both for their natural beauty and for the cultural wisdom they hold. Trustees Emeriti
Faced with devastating floods, forest fires, and other evidence of climate change, we need Brian Heidtke
Charles S. La Follette
this wisdom more than ever.
Legal Counsel
Mitchell Eitel, Esq.
Sullivan & Cromwell, LLP
85% LESS
KNEE PAIN
Maximum Protection
Improved Posture
VersoShock® U.S Patent #US8,555,526 B2. May be eligible for Medicare reimbursement. $20 off applies to orders of $100 or more for a
limited time. Cannot be combined with other offers. 9% CA sales tax applies to orders in California. Shoes must be returned within
30 days in like-new condition for full refund or exchange. Credit card authorization required. See website for complete details.
LETTERS
archaeology.org 9
DIGS DISCOVERIES
tooth marks—which likely would have “The suggestion of slavery, punish- injury or from the repetitive activities
been visible on his bones had his body ment, or something nefarious imme- of an active lifestyle, hard labor, or even
been exposed for any length of time—all diately leapt to mind,” says Chinnock. heavy contact sports,” says Chinnock.
suggested the man was buried quickly and Despite the fetters’ dramatic appear- “Nothing screams that this person was
with little care. Although his skeleton is ance, they do not definitively prove enslaved.” Furthermore, the man was
well preserved, indicating he was five feet that the man was enslaved. This type buried near a thriving Roman town,
five inches tall—average for the period— of shackle has rarely been found any- and there would have been both slaves
his head is missing, likely an accidental where in the Roman world, and never and laborers in the surrounding fields,
casualty of modern construction work. in Roman Britain. When Chinnock farms, and villages.
Marshall and MOLA osteoarchaeologist examined the skeleton to reconstruct Still, says Marshall, the Great Caster-
Chris Chinnock immediately wondered the man’s life based on his bones, creat- ton burial is “about the best evidence you
if the man had been a slave, which ing what scholars call an osteobiography, could have for the social phenomenon
would make him the first Roman slave he found some lesions on his ankles and of slavery.” “We don’t see the physical
to be archaeologically excavated in tibias from infections or trauma, but evidence of enslavement very often, so
Britain. But in the absence of a clear nothing that conclusively linked them it evokes an immediate response,” says
methodology for recognizing Roman to the fetters. He also found a bony spur Chinnock. “This was an actual person,
slavery in the archaeological record, how on the man’s left femur. “The spur is of and he is valuable as an individual.”
would they know? a type that can occur from a traumatic —Jarrett a. LobeLL
IN FULL COLOR
n unusual painted sculpture of a
A.
Moissanite clarity
Jewelry shown is not
is exceptional &
exact size. Pendant comparable to a
chain sold separately.
VVS1 diamond
Along with winning a Nobel prize, he gave the world a stone that enabling us to price 2
surpasses even the finest diamond in virtually every aspect that carats of moissanite in
makes a woman go weak in the knees. Today, you can own 2 precious sterling silver for
total carats of this swoon-worthy stone for a down to earth price less than $100. It’s pure genius. Our Nobel
of $99. Prize-winning chemist would be proud.
The most brilliant fine stone on earth. According to the GIA Satisfaction guaranteed or your money back.
(Gemological Institute of America), Moissanite outperforms all
jewels in terms of its brilliance, fire, and luster. Moissanite has
“double refraction”–– which means light goes down into the
stone and comes out not once, but twice. No diamond can do
this. The way the light dances inside Moissanite is something to
behold. MOISSANITE COLLECTION
A. 3-Stone Ring (2 ctw) $599 † $99 Save $500
The genius of affordability. A one-carat diamond of this color
and clarity sells for more than $5,000. Two years ago Moissanite B. Solitaire Pendant (2 carat) $599 † $149 Save $450
was over $1,000 a carat. Now, for the first time in history, our C. Solitaire Earrings (1 ctw) $399 † $99 Save $300
BEST DEAL- Ring, Pendant & Earrings Set (5 ctw)
UNIQUE PROPERTIES COMPARISON $1,597 $299 Save $1298
Refractive Index Dispersion Luster † Special price only for customers using the offer code versus the price on
(Brilliance) (Fire) Stauer.com without your offer code. Pendant chain sold separately.
*Double Your Money Back Guarantee requires proof of purchase to
Moissanite 2.65-2.69 0.104 20.4% include purchase date and original sales receipt of equivalent item.
Mined Diamond 2.42 0.044 17.2% Only one claim may be submitted for each purchase. Price comparisons will
be made net of taxes.
Lowest price•you’ve ever seen! If not, we’ll double your money back.*
Exquisite moissanite in .925 sterling silver setting • Whole ring sizes 5-10
The Moissanite Three-Stone Ring celebrates your past, present and future with unsurpassed fire & brilliance for less.
Set also available in gold-finished sterling silver. Call now 1-800-333-2045
Offer Code: MOS184-03. You must use the offer code to get our special price.
Stauer ® 14101 Southcross Drive W., Ste 155, Dept. MOS184-03. Burnsville, Minnesota 55337
TYPING TIME
bout 1,600 blocks of metal movable type from the movable type blocks from the period ever discovered in Korea.
Type blocks,
side view
Actual size
E W N
is 40.6 mm
N S IG
DE
GovMint.com • 14101 Southcross Dr. W., Suite 175, Dept. NRE197-03 • Burnsville, MN 55337
GovMint.com® is a retail distributor of coin and currency issues and is not affiliated with the U.S. government. The collectible coin market is unregulated, highly speculative and involves risk.
GovMint.com reserves the right to decline to consummate any sale, within its discretion, including due to pricing errors. Prices, facts, figures and populations deemed accurate as of the date of
publication but may change significantly over time. All purchases are expressly conditioned upon your acceptance of GovMint.com’s Terms and Conditions (www.govmint.com/terms-conditions
or call 1-800-721-0320); to decline, return your purchase pursuant to GovMint.com’s Return Policy. © 2021 GovMint.com. All rights reserved.
DIGS DISCOVERIES
OTTO’S CHURCH
Felix Biermann of the State Office for Heritage Management
and Archaeology Saxony-Anhalt. “Because they had no capital
cities, they would move from place to place every month or two.”
It’s unclear how much time Otto spent at this particular palace,
though an eleventh-century chronicle mentions that he was at
least present for the church’s inaugural services.
The settlement was abandoned in the thirteenth century,
but the church continued to be used until its destruction in the
fifteenth or sixteenth century. Inside and around the building,
archaeologists have already excavated more than 300 buri-
Aerial view als, many of them belonging to members of noble families,
of church
including children. Several graves contained earrings, pins,
excavations,
Helfta, Germany and enameled brooches. Among the arti-
facts recovered from the church are a
n a hill overlooking the village of thirteenth-century enameled bronze
AN IRISH IDOL
uring a road construction project in County Roscommon,
A FAMILY’S FINAL
RESTING PLACE
rchaeologists have unearthed a well-built and exquisitely decorated family
archaeology.org 15
DIGS DISCOVERIES
T
wo women buried in monumental four-millennia-old her in some way—a lesion on her ankle could have impacted
tombs located near water towers in ancient Arabia likely her mobility,” Gregoricka says.
enjoyed special status. The tombs are associated with the The other woman, who was buried in a similar type of tomb
Umm an-Nar culture, which lasted from about 2700 to 2000 at the site of Tell Abraq, was likely paralyzed from the waist
b.c., a time when pastoralists began to shift to oasis-based down. Strong markers where the muscles attached to her shoul-
agricultural systems in what is now the United Arab Emirates. der, forearm, and upper arm bones reveal a great deal of strain,
One woman was buried alongside a dog in a tomb at the site indicating she likely dragged herself around. Like the woman
of Shimal. The canine, says bioarchaeologist Lesley Gregoricka from Shimal, this woman was buried on her own. It is unclear,
of the University of South Alabama, appears to have been a though, whether her special treatment in death represented a
companion or work animal, rather than a food source. While type of tribute or ostracism, says Gregoricka.
many of the other human remains in the tomb were cremated —JosHua rapp Learn
A TRIP TO VENICE
cholars have long debated whether the Romans inhabited founded in the fifth or sixth century A.D. Since much of the
B
April 25 – May 9, 2022
fourth centuries b.c. and continuing up until CYPRUS, RHODES & MALTA
the late twentieth century A.D., members of rural With Professor John France
April 27 – May 12, 2022
communities sporadically worked the Chehrabad salt mine CENTRAL MEXICO
in northwestern Iran. Since 1993, archaeologists have With Dr. Stanley Guenter
uncovered the remains of eight ancient miners whose April 30 – May 10, 2022
bodies were mummified by the mine’s salt-rich and low- EASTERN TURKEY
With Professor Jennifer Tobin
moisture environment, along with mummified animal May 13 – 28, 2022
remains, including a sheep’s leg that was discarded some ITALY: TUSCANY & UMBRIA
1,600 years ago. “The mine’s extremely dry conditions With Professor William R. Cook
May 16 – 27, 2022
quickly desiccated the sheep’s soft tissue,” says Trinity
THE VIKINGS:
College Dublin geneticist Conor Rossi. “Its DNA was DENMARK, NORWAY & SWEDEN
extremely well preserved.” With Dr. Steven Ashby
July 10 – 24, 2022
Examining the sheep’s DNA has allowed Rossi and
ENGLAND’S CASTLES
his colleagues to envision what the animal looked like. & GREAT HOUSES
The scientists identified a gene associated with a fat With Professor Patrick N. Allitt
June 24 – July 7, 2022
tail, a characteristic still present in sheep raised for their
meat in the area today. They also determined that the …and much more!
Bolivia • Indonesia • Sri Lanka • USA • Egypt • Peru
sheep did not have the genetic mutation associated Baltics • Georgia & Armenia • Ethiopia • Greece • Iran
with woolly fleece, which was an important commod- The Maya World • Iceland • Scotland • Ireland
ity starting in the mid- to late fourth millennium b.c. Cambodia & Laos • Turkey • Bulgaria • Wales • England
Central Asia • Ireland • Sicily • Sri Lanka • France
Scanning electron microscopy of hair fibers preserved Cyprus & Malta • Jordan • Easter Island
on the animal’s leg confirmed that this particular sheep
likely had a hairy rather than a woolly coat. Given these
traits, the researchers believe ancient miners consumed
the sheep for its meat. Says Rossi, “This sample builds
up a bigger story about how ancient people used special- Sheep
ized breeds of animals in thoughtful ways.” leg after 1-800-552-4575
—benJamin LeonarD cleaning www.farhorizons.com
archaeology.org 17
DIGS DISCOVERIES
G R E AT
NEW
FINDS
AVA I L A B L E W H E R E V E R B O O K S A R E S O L D
© 2021 National Geographic Partners, LLC
NatGeoBooks @NatGeoBooks
archaeology.org 19
OFF THE GRID BY MARLEY BROWN
BODIE, CALIFORNIA
Bodie Standard Mining Company Stamp Mill, Bodie, California
N E VA D A
Yosemite National Park
San Francisco
0 75 150 miles
archaeology.org 23
When Isis
Was Queen
At the ancient Egyptian temples of
Philae, Nubians gave new life to a
vanishing religious tradition
By I’ K
archaeology.org 25
W
HEN THE ROMANS conquered Egypt the river-which marked the historical border between
in 30 B.C., the country’s system of ancient Egypt and Nubia, also known as Kush. In this
temples, which had sustained religious region of Kush, called Lower Nubia, the temple complex
traditions dating back more than at Philae was just one of many that were built on islands in
3,000 years, began to slowly wither the Nile and along its banks. Throughout the long history
away. Starved of of Egypt and Nubia, Lower Nubia was a
the funds that pharaohs traditionally sup- First Cataract kind of buffer zone between these two
plied to religious institutions, priests lost EGYPT lands and a place where the two cultures
their vocation and temples fell into disuse D am Lower heavily influenced one another. “Often
w Nubia
throughout the country. The introduction Lo official Egyptian texts were demeaning
wan Temple
As of Dakka
of Christianity in the first century A.D. only Second Cataract
to Nubians,” says Egyptologist Solange
hastened this process. But there was one Philae Temples Kerma
SUDAN
Ashby of the University of California,
Biga
exception to this trend: In the temples on Island Upper Meroe Los Angeles. “But this cultural arro-
Nubia
the island of Philae in the Nile River, rites gance doesn’t reflect the lived reality of
Temple of
dedicated to the goddess Isis and the god Musawwarat Egyptians and Nubians being neighbors,
es-Sufra
Osiris continued to be celebrated in high intermarrying, sharing cultural and reli-
style for some 500 years after the Roman gious practices. These were people who
conquest. This final flowering of ancient interacted for millennia.”
Egyptian religion was only possible because From 300 B.C. to A.D. 300, Nubia was
of the piety and support of Egypt’s neigh- h D am ruled from the capital city of Meroe. The
ig
bors to the south, the Nubians. an H Meroitic kings took a special interest in
Asw
Philae lies just south of the Nile’s 0 1 2 miles Philae, where the most important Egyptian
first cataract-one of six rapids along temple dedicated to Isis was located. In
The island of Agilkia is now home to Philae’s temple of Isis and a number of other sacred structures that were moved there when
the island was flooded by the Aswan High Dam, whose construction began in the 1960s.
T
These are mainly in the form of ODAY, THE ISLAND OF
prayers offered to the gods. These Philae lies submerged as a
inscriptions were written mostly result of the construction
in Greek and Demotic, a script of the Aswan High Dam. All the
used for writing ancient Egyptian, complex’s structures were moved
though some were also written in to higher ground on the nearby
the Nubians’ own Meroitic script, island of Agilkia in the 1960s and
which remains largely undeci- 1970s. These include the island’s
phered. Ashby expected the main temple, dedicated to Isis, and
inscriptions to have been com- its entryway of two monumental
missioned by Nubian pilgrims to sets of pylons, as well as a number
Philae, but she found that many of smaller temples dedicated
were left by Nubians who had to other gods. Archaeological
a much deeper connection to excavations on the island prior
the island. “High-ranking priests, to the flooding showed that, for
temple financial administrators, much of Egyptian history, Philae
and officials were sent to Philae was not a major Egyptian religious
as representatives of the king site along the lines of Thebes or
in Meroe,” says Ashby. “Those Memphis, but that it did seem to
Nubians eventually held power in have long-standing significance to
the temple administration.”
By exploring the millennium- A relief in Philae’s temple of Isis
long presence of Nubians at Phi- depicts a Ptolemaic queen (left)
lae, Ashby and other researchers following the goddess Isis (right).
archaeology.org 27
Nubians. This may have had to do with its proximity to the Lower Nubia who is often depicted as a desert hunter and
island of Biga, where Nubians worshipped Hathor, a goddess companion of Isis, and who sometimes appears as a lion.
who took the form of a cow. Hathor was especially revered in Another small temple, in the form of a kiosk, or a colonnaded
Nubia, where many people were pastoralists. pavilion, was built at Philae during the reign of the pharaoh
The earliest clear evidence of the Nubian connection to Nectanebo I (r. 380–362 B.C.), founder of the 30th Dynasty,
Philae dates to the reign of the Kushite kings who invaded the last native-born Egyptian dynasty. Cruz-Uribe proposed
Egypt in the eighth century B.C. and ruled it for nearly a that the building was used as a shrine for a hybrid Nubian-
century as the 25th Dynasty. One of the dynasty’s mightiest Egyptian god known as Thoth Pnubs, whose name links him
pharaohs, Taharqo (r. 690–664 B.C.), oversaw the construction to the ancient Nubian city of Kerma, which was known as
of new temples and a revival of ancient Egyptian culture in the Pnubs to the Nubians. There was also a small temple at Philae
Nile Valley. This included commissioning a complex at Philae dedicated to the Nubian deity Mandulis, a sun god associated
dedicated to Amun, a chief ancient Egyptian and Kushite with the nomadic people known as the Blemmyes, who lived
deity closely associated with kingship. Blocks from this temple in the deserts to the east of Egypt and Nubia. “There are all
inscribed with Taharqo’s name were unearthed in the twentieth kinds of Nubian religious activities that happened before the
century before the island was submerged. Ptolemaic Isis temple was erected,” says Ashby.
A number of extant small temples in the forecourt of the
A
temple of Isis that were dedicated to Nubian gods provide NOTHER PIECE OF EVIDENCE linking Nubian religious
further evidence that Philae was significant to Nubians. practices to Philae is found on some of the massive
One such temple was devoted to Arensnuphis, a local god of reliefs in the island’s temples that depict Ptolemaic
pharaohs and other important religious officials offering liba-
tions to gods, often Isis and Osiris and their son Horus. In
Egyptian mythology, Osiris was killed and dismembered by
his brother Seth. Their sister and Osiris’ wife, Isis, managed
to reassemble his body and he was brought back to life as
the god of the underworld. The Egyptians offered libations,
usually water or wine, to Osiris during rituals intended to
symbolically aid in his rebirth. At Philae, depictions of this
ritual include examples that show Ptolemaic pharaohs offer-
ing Osiris water in two small bottles, as was customary in
Egyptian practice. However, others appear to show them
offering Osiris libations of milk, which they pour out before
the god from a situla, a long narrow vessel with a looped
handle. This, Ashby believes, was a distinctly Nubian prac-
tice. “What we see at these temples is this different type of
libation, which is to pour out a stream of milk that goes over
offerings laid out on an offering table,” she says.
Egyptologists have debated for a century whether or not
these scenes are intended to depict milk libations or offerings
of wine or water. “I say this is milk,” says Ashby. She points
to a scene inside the temple of Isis at Philae depicting Ptol-
emy VIII (r. 170–116 B.C.) offering a libation to
Osiris, with Isis standing behind the god. “The
hieroglyphs around him say this milk comes
from the breast of the goddess Hesat,” Ashby
explains, referring to a celestial cow goddess.
Some scholars have argued that even if
the depictions show milk libations, they
must represent an Egyptian tradition. For
Ashby, even though the depictions of the
milk libation occur in Ptolemaic
temples, the ritual is a purely
A relief (above) at the temple Nubian practice. “I sug-
of Musawwarat es-Sufra gest they adopted it from
in Sudan shows the Nubian
lion-headed god Apedemak. A granite
Nubian worshippers,” she
sphinx statue (right) depicts the Nubian pharaoh says. She points out that
Taharqo, who commissioned an early temple at Philae. the earliest depictions of
A relief (above left) at the Kiosk of Nectanebo depicts a pharaoh offering libations to Isis in two small bottles. Another relief
(above right) at Philae’s Gate of Hadrian shows a pharaoh pouring a milk libation to the gods over an offering table.
ideal offering to aid in the rebirth of Osiris. in Demotic, the inscriptions were left mainly on the walls of
Milk libation rituals would have been performed during temples dedicated to Nubian gods. They record mandatory
annual funerary rites for Osiris. Known as the Festival of donations to singers at temples or to specific temples,
Entry, this ceremony was held during the month of Khoiak, including those honoring the Nubian gods Arensnuphis and
in the early fall, when the Nile flooding reached its peak. Thoth Pnubs. During this period, the forecourt of the temple
Gilded statues of Isis and Osiris were taken from the Isis of Isis was expanded, probably to accommodate the numbers
temple at Philae to boats moored outside a structure known of Nubians coming to worship on Philae. While there do
as the Gate of Hadrian. They were then rowed across the not seem to have been Nubian priests at Philae during the
Nile to the island of Biga, where Osiris was thought to have early Roman period, Nubians were involved in the temple
been buried. There, at a sanctuary known as the Abaton, milk administration, and were perhaps in a position to monitor
libations were offered to the god. how their tithes were being spent.
Ashby notes that, until quite recently, milk played a A second group of inscriptions Ashby has identified date
central role in rituals surrounding death in Nubia. Within from A.D. 175 to 275 and reflect the pinnacle of Nubian influ-
living memory, a widow would traditionally pour milk on her ence at Philae. Many of these inscriptions were commissioned
husband’s grave on the second day after his death, a distant by Nubians who, by this point, were active as priests at the top
echo, perhaps, of the milk libations offered to Osiris. of the religious hierarchy. The inscriptions, which were made
archaeology.org 29
A 26-line inscription (above left) on the Gate of Hadrian records the Nubian envoy Sasan’s participation in rites held on the island
in A.D. 253. A figure (above right) near the inscription may be intended to represent Sasan.
in the most restricted areas of the temples, show that Nubians and statues depicting Isis and Osiris.
were claiming the loftiest religious titles, such as prophet or The inscriptions are not just filled with pious expressions.
purity priest, as well as Meroitic titles such as the King’s Son They also detail particulars of the annual voyage made by
of Kush and the Royal Scribe of Kush. The inscriptions also envoys from the kings of Meroe to the Festival of Entry, such as
refer to the Nubian priests’ astronomical knowledge and imply the amount of gold the Meroitic rulers sent to Philae. The lon-
that they were fluent in Egyptian, Greek, and Meroitic. Most gest such inscription was written on behalf of one of Meroe’s
prominent in the inscriptions are five generations of a Nubian envoys to Rome, a man named Sasan. Dating to April 10, A.D.
family known as the Wayekiyes, who were powerful priests and 253, this is not just the longest Demotic inscription at Philae,
who had both religious and military obligations. but the longest known in Egypt. Its 26-line text suggests that
Many of the inscriptions in the most sacred spaces refer to Nubian pilgrims and priests journeying to Philae played both
the annual Festival of Entry celebrations that honored Osiris political and religious roles at the temples. In the inscrip-
and Isis. While some Egyptian names do appear in references tion, Sasan discusses how he was commanded by the king
to the festival, most of the participants appear to have been of Meroe to set aside funds and throw a party for the entire
Nubian, in particular members of the Wayekiye family, says district. “When these Nubian priests came, the local popula-
Egyptologist Jeremy Pope of the College of William and
Mary. “In addition to being a focus of sincere piety, theological
reflection, and communal bonds,” he says, “the worship of Isis
would also have been important to elite Nubian families like
the Wayekiyes as an occupation, a mark of social status, and
thus a source of political power.”
Ashby says that Nubian inscriptions tend to be clustered
together at Philae in particular buildings, such as the Gate
of Hadrian and a room in the temple of Isis known as the
Meroitic Chamber. She notes that Nubians seem to have been
especially interested in leaving inscriptions near depictions of
milk libations, reinforcing their importance in Kushite rituals.
The Nubian expressions of piety also differ from those left
by Greeks, which are short, often one-line inscriptions, and
by Egyptians, which tend to be dry and repetitive. “They are
much more heartfelt, longer, and more reverent toward Isis,”
says Ashby. “They often have very dramatic phrases, such as ‘I A depiction of the Nubian crocodile god Ptiris was scratched into
am bending my arm, I am calling out to you, Isis!’” It’s likely a colonnade outside the Isis temple by some of the last priests
that Nubians recited these prayers aloud in front of the reliefs who practiced traditional Egyptian religion in Philae’s temples.
N
UBIAN SPONSORSHIP OF the temples at Philae ensured
the continued survival of the worship of ancient
Egyptian gods for centuries. But by the fourth
century A.D., Christianity had begun to win many converts in
the region. Around this time, Meroe fell to the Axum Empire,
based in modern-day Ethiopia, ending Nubia’s contribution
to the rites at Philae. Christians and adherents of traditional
archaeology.org 31
32 ARCHAEOLOGY • November/December 2021
Piecing Together
Maya Creation Stories
Thousands of mural fragments from the city of San Bartolo
illustrate how the Maya envisioned their place in the universe
By Z Z
S
OME 2,000 YEARS AGO, Maya leaders in the city which was located at the base of the temple, known today as
of San Bartolo entered a temple chamber with the Pyramid of Paintings.
vibrant murals depicting supernatural beings and Many of the figures painted on the chamber’s south and
mythical humans painted on its walls. Then they east walls were broken by hammer blows, and the plaster frag-
destroyed them. ments containing their faces were removed. The walls were then
Although the murals—painted exclusively with knocked down. The chamber, which was just above ground level
black, red, yellow, and white pigments—had and opened onto a public plaza, was sealed off
been executed by three master artists, some Fragments (facing page) by a new wall. Builders faced the entire pyramid
cycle of time known only to the city’s priests of a destroyed mural from in a new layer of stone, and a new structure was
the Pyramid of the Paint-
had ended, and so too had the murals’ life span. ings in the Maya city of San built. Most of the chamber, which had been
The artwork had probably been commissioned Bartolo in Guatemala date created during the sixth such renovation of
by the city’s rulers and had been on display for to about 100 B.C. A recon- the pyramid, was left relatively intact. But its
50 to 100 years, but the time had come to build structed image (above) remaining murals were hidden from view until
a new temple over the old one. This renovation from the mural depicts the 2001, when University of Boston archaeologist
god Wak Tok.
meant tearing down part of the mural chamber, William Saturno discovered the chamber during
archaeology.org 33
a survey in Guatemala’s Petén rain forest. cal compositions. The reassembled
Until then, the site had been known only MEXICO
fragments are now on display at the
to the local Maya community. National Museum of Archaeology and
Close study of the intact San Bar- BELIZE Ethnology in Guatemala City.
tolo murals revealed that the narrative San Bartolo
GUATEMALA
By the end of the process, the team
they told is an ancient version of the had reassembled enough painted frag-
creation story Maya people were still ments from the beginning and end
recounting when the Spanish arrived of the murals’ narrative to more fully
0 5 10 miles
in the sixteenth century. This story was re-create the experience of viewing the
recorded in an eighteenth-century text murals as they appeared 2,000 years
known as the Popol Vuh. These murals are among the earliest ago. “You would have entered the room and been immersed
known Maya wall paintings, but their style and iconography in a series of stories,” says Hurst. She believes the painted
seem to researchers to reach even further back in time. “One of chamber may have been a place where young initiates to the
the beautiful things about the discovery of San Bartolo is that priesthood learned how the cosmos was created.
it’s a distillation of a lot of key concepts of Maya cosmology in Stuart sees the murals as a creation story in four acts that
one place,” says archaeologist David Stuart of the University not only lays out humanity’s place in the universe, but also
of Texas at Austin. “We’re looking at a system of iconography establishes the basis for the rulership of the ajaw, or king,
that’s already quite developed and quite old by 100 B.C.” and the proper way to make sacrificial offerings to the gods.
The chamber’s destruction initially obscured the narrative’s Reassembling the mural fragments has allowed Stuart, Hurst,
beginning and end. According to Skidmore College archaeolo- and their colleague Karl Taube of the University of Califor-
gist and National Geographic Explorer Heather Hurst, who nia, Riverside, to glimpse a creation narrative that is at once
codirects the San Bartolo Project with her colleague Boris familiar from the Popol Vuh and features previously unknown
Beltrán, also of Skidmore College, the destruction was not or obscure Maya deities and religious concepts. These four
simply part of the building’s renovation. It was also part of a scenes, each of which seems to be linked to one of the first
ritual that commemorated the end of one cycle of time and four days of a ritual calendar, function as a sort of picture book
the beginning of another. Since painting the chamber had that expresses ancient Maya ideas about community and the
imbued it with supernatural significance, destroying some of role of humanity in the cosmos.
the murals to clear the way for the renewed temple without
acknowledging and managing the paintings’ power could have I: CREATION OF THE WORLD
meant angering supernatural beings. “You can’t just bury it,”
T
says Hurst. “As the new temple is built, you are honoring the HE CENTER OF THE FIRST scene is a fragmentary image
temple that came before it.” from the demolished east wall that depicts a four-lobed
Not all the fragments from the destroyed murals were shape representing a cave. As reconstructed by the
removed from the chamber during this ritual. About 3,400 of team, this section of the mural shows two humanlike creator
them remained piled on the floor. It took 10 years, beginning gods seated within the cave and implies that the gods are in
in 2002, to excavate and col-
lect them all. It took another
six years for the team to reas-
semble them under the watch-
ful eye of the University of
New Mexico’s Angelyn Bass,
who has been the project’s
principal conservator since
the first mural fragments were
collected. This painstaking
process involved fitting the
plaster fragments together
like jigsaw puzzle pieces and
studying them using X-ray
fluorescence, a technique that
allows the researchers to iden-
tify subtle variations in the
amount of the element bari-
um in the plaster. They used This reconstructed partial image from a destroyed mural at San Bartolo shows two creator gods
this information to match sitting inside a four-lobed shape that represents a cave in the underworld. Between them is a
pieces with similar chemi- gourd marked with glyphs that read “blood of humanity.”
A
one of the foundations of life. T THE CENTER OF THE second scene, an image depicts
The rest of the scene continues on the intact north wall, Earth as a turtle floating in primordial waters, reflect-
where the mural depicts the mountain god known as Witz, ing the ancient Maya belief that they lived on the
whose gaping mouth also represents a cave. Animals, includ- back of a turtle swimming in the ocean. Inside the image of
ing a jaguar, an iguana, snakes,
and birds, emerge between
flowers and other plants sur-
rounding Witz’s mouth. This
imagery suggests that the
cave is an opening into a
supernatural paradise known
as the Flower Mountain, a
sacred place in the cosmology
of many cultures throughout
Mesoamerica. For the Maya,
the Flower Mountain was a
place of creation. The sun god
emerged from the mountain
each morning, while the maize
god emerged once a year. It
was also where, in a distant
time, the ancestors of the
Maya originated.
In this scene, four human
couples, who may have been
the founders of lineages of This intact mural from San Bartolo shows an unidentified god watching infants burst out of a
families who lived in San Bar- gourd, symbolizing the birth of humanity.
archaeology.org 35
the turtle, the maize god dances and plays a turtle-shell drum. the images, Hunahpu is shown carrying animals that he has
Immediately to the right of Turtle Earth, a human ruler is hunted, which he offers as a sacrifice. The three animals are a
shown being enthroned. To the right of the throne, two sets fish representing the underworld, a deer representing Earth,
of infant twins burst out of a gourd, which may be the same and a turkey representing the sky. In the fourth depiction of
one that holds the blood of humanity in the first scene. A the hero, Hunahpu has sacrificed aromatic flowers. In each
fifth child emerges from the gourd with arms raised. “With of the four images he is shown impaling his genitals as an act
that exploding gourd and the infants, now we’re looking at of ritual bloodletting. Hurst says this scene, on the chamber’s
the birth of humanity,” says Stuart. west wall, establishes the basis for the Maya’s negotiations with
To the left of this scene, a series of partially intact images supernatural powers through sacrifice.
shows the maize god’s enthronement as a mythical ruler,
and his birth, death, and rebirth. This image of the god’s IV: ENTERING THE UNDERWORLD
enthronement establishes a basis for Maya rulership. The
T
researchers believe the scene would have impressed on HE LAST SCENE is from the destroyed south wall and has
ancient Maya viewers that the rulers of San Bartolo received been entirely reconstructed from fragments. It takes
their authority from the maize god. viewers into the underworld and though it is the least
complete scene, it has several identifiable figures. The most
III: WORSHIPPING THE GODS complete image depicts an aspect of the sun god known as the
solar eagle, according to Stuart and Taube. The deity has the
T
HE NEXT SCENE is the best preserved of the narrative. glyph for “sun” painted on his cheek. Above the sun god is a
It shows four young men standing and offering sacri- depiction of an obscure god named Wak Tok. Stuart believes
fices in front of supernatural trees that anchor Earth that Wak Tok is related to the rain god Chahk, but very little
at its four cardinal directions. At the top of each tree sits a is known about the deity. There is only one other reference to
monstrous bird scholars have named the Principal Bird Deity. Wak Tok, which dates to A.D. 700 and was found on a stone
According to Taube, the bird deity has a dual nature—it is panel at the site of Palenque in southern Mexico. “We are
associated with creation and the sun but also with darkness. missing much of this mythical religious knowledge,” Stuart
The tree closest to the center of the scene has the twisted says, adding that it was probably kept in books that have not
trunk of a gourd tree. The bird deity is shown descending survived. “We just happen to see little pieces of this lost world,
from heaven to land in it. and Wak Tok Chahk is a great example of a Maya deity who
All four of the young men making sacrifices, says Taube, was important enough to be in the murals, yet there are only
are depictions of Hunahpu, one of the mythical hero twins two mentions of him anywhere in the Maya region.”
who are the protagonists of many Maya stories. In three of Two figures stand behind the sun god. One is a depiction
of an unknown male deity who has
star markings on his legs, indicat-
ing that he has some connection
to the night. The other wears a
headdress made of a bloody femur
and an eyeball that sprays blood.
Taube has identified this grim
individual as the god Akan. “He
is the god of alcohol and drunk-
enness,” says Taube. “He’s also
a very unpleasant death god.” A
long curving forelock of hair, one
of the identifying marks of the
maize god, also features on Akan’s
headdress. Taube believes these
different iconographic elements
suggest that the figure of Akan also
represents the dead maize god,
whom the Maya imbibed in the
form of maize beer. The maize god
is a central cultural hero in Maya
stories. He sets the world in order,
In this intact mural from San Bartolo, a mythical hero named Hunahpu makes a sacrificial
says Taube, and even in death he
offering of his own blood. An image to the left of Hunahpu depicts a supernatural tree; to provides something. “When you
his right is an image of a turkey being offered as a sacrifice. drink fermented maize beer,” he
T
HE CHAMBER AT THE BASE of the Pyramid A fragment from a destroyed mural in the
of the Paintings isn’t the only space Ixim chamber in San Bartolo’s Pyramid of
in the building that was furnished Paintings depicts leaves.
with such rich visual narratives. During the
same construction phase in which the lower by San Bartolo’s rulers. “The Ixim chamber
chamber was built, another chamber was is another set of murals that could have a
constructed at the top of the temple. Its revolutionary impact on our understanding
interior was once decorated with its own of Maya religion and politics,” says Hurst. It’s
finely painted murals. The archaeologists likely that the Ixim chamber murals told stories
have named this chamber Ixim, which is one that the Maya understood on many different levels,
of the Maya’s words for maize. much like the narrative in the lower chamber. The
These murals feature blue-green, dark green, people of San Bartolo probably understood that the
brown, and purple pigments in addition to the different stories the murals told were much greater
lower chamber’s simpler color palette. They also have a large than the sum of their parts. For instance, says Stuart, once
number of hieroglyphic inscriptions. The style of some of viewed all together, the murals of the lower chamber seem
the motifs in these murals is identical to that of those in the to follow a cycle of solar movement. “Sun emergence, zenith,
lower mural chamber, but they are painted with a much finer sunset, nadir,” says Stuart. “It’s like they’re grafting a grand
hand. These paintings were also destroyed in the same ritual narrative onto that cycle. It’s a perpetual story.” Q
during which the murals of the lower chamber were smashed.
About 3,200 mural fragments have been recovered from the Zach Zorich is a contributing editor at Archaeology.
archaeology.org 37
ITALIAN An artificial pool constructed of
sturdy wood beams on a hilltop
near the town of Noceto on
northern Italy’s Po Plain has been
MASTER
dated to around 1450 B.C.
O
N A HILLTOP AT THE EDGE of the town of
Noceto on northern Italy’s Po Plain, a 2004
construction project had gotten just a few
feet into the ground when a wooden struc-
ture began to emerge. A team of archaeolo-
gists led by Mauro Cremaschi and Maria
Bernabò Brea was called in to investigate. “At the beginning,
we thought it was probably some sort of residential building,”
says team member Andrea Zerboni, a geoarchaeologist at the
University of Milan. “But soon after we started the excavation,
we noticed that the sediments inside the structure weren’t
related to domestic activity.” Rather than material such as ash
and charcoal, typically found where people lived or worked,
the structure was filled with natural sediments of the sort that
would be found in a lake. The structure they were excavating
was not a building at all, the researchers realized—it was an
artificial pool. What they have learned about this pool in the
years since has provided surprising new insights into the social
organization and ritual practices of a culture that thrived in this
fertile region for centuries during the second millennium B.C.
before disappearing. “The Noceto pool is unique in Italy—it’s
unique in the world,” says Zerboni. “Building such a structure
implies very careful planning, coordinating the work of many
people, and a very clear architectural plan. We don’t expect to
find such majestic structures from prehistory.”
When they reached the bottom of the pool after several
years of careful work, the archaeologists marveled at the feat
of ancient engineering before them. Twenty-six wooden poles
were arranged vertically to form a tank measuring roughly 40
feet long, 23 feet wide, and at least 16 feet deep. More than
240 interlocking boards lined the pool’s earthen walls and were
held in place by the poles. The poles, in turn, were pressed
against the walls by two networks of horizontal beams that
crossed the pool perpendicular to each other. And, for good
Milan
IT
A
LY
Po River
Noceto
Apennine Mountains
D
ply couldn’t withstand the pressure of the earthen walls or URING THE MIDDLE BRONZE AGE, farmers belonging
whether one of the area’s frequent earthquakes contributed to to a culture known as the Terramare settled the Po
its demise. In any case, the upper tank, whose design included Plain, which is bordered by the Alps to the north and
additional supports, held strong for millennia. west, the Apennine Mountains to the south, and the Adriatic
The team found no indication that the pool had served any Sea to the east. The Terramare completely cleared the area’s
practical purpose. There was no sign of a mechanism for chan- forests and intensively cultivated the land. The landscape
neling water in or out, and the fine-grained sediments had accu- proved bountiful, producing bumper crops of wheat, barley,
mulated slowly at the pool’s bottom without the sort of regular and other cereals, and supporting plentiful herds of livestock
disturbance that would have occurred if it had served as a reser- including sheep, goats, and pigs. To further their agricultural
voir. Their excavations did, however, uncover an extensive array endeavors, the Terramare embarked on extensive irrigation
of material in the pool. The finds include around 150 complete projects. They located their settlements along the Po River
vases and 25 miniature vessels, which pottery experts dated to and its tributaries, and dug a large number of wells. These
this region’s Middle Bronze Age (ca. 1600–1300 B.C.). Zerboni settlements were surrounded by moats, which were at once
notes that the pottery found in the pool is of a type that would defensive features and additional sources of water. The
have been highly valued and used only for special occasions. Terramare built their houses on wood piles, using timber
The excavators also uncovered seven small clay votive figurines harvested from the rapidly depleting forests.
depicting horses, pigs, cows, and, in one instance, an anthropo- Over time, the remains of Terramare villages grew into
morphic figure. Similar examples from the period in Europe mounds that became stores of rich organic material. This
are known, but are quite rare, says Zerboni. A large number phenomenon is the source of the culture’s name—from
terra marna, which means “rich land” in the local
A number of clay votive figurines were found in
the pool, including, from left to right, a cow, an
Emilian dialect. In the eighteenth and nineteenth
anthropomorphic figure, and a pig. centuries, the decayed contents of many of these
mounds were used to fertilize the fields of the Po
T
O DETERMINE WHEN EXACTLY the tanks were built, the “Creating the thing means people have to gather together, work
University of Milan team recently collaborated with together, create a common purpose, and then it becomes a sort
Sturt Manning, an archaeologist and dendrochronology of venue to come and visit afterwards.” Those members of the
expert at Cornell University. The tanks were built primarily from community who climbed the hill to gaze into the pool’s waters
oak, which meant that conventional dendrochronology was not might have been rewarded with a transcendent experience. “You
an option—there is not a continuous securely dated sequence of could almost see this as a mirror in which you would have been
oak tree-ring records that goes back as far as the Middle Bronze both looking at the reflection of the world around you, but also
Age in northern Italy. Instead, Manning used a technique called looking through it to see some form of netherworld or under-
tree-ring radiocarbon wiggle matching. This involved measuring world,” Manning says. “I wonder if this wasn’t symbolic of con-
the amount of radioactive carbon in samples drawn from a nections between the divine and the earthly for these people.”
number of rings in wood from the tanks. Given that the baseline Around 1150 B.C., the Terramare culture collapsed, and all
amount of radiocarbon in the atmosphere fluctuates over time their settlements on the Po Plain were abandoned. This was
based on factors such as the level of sunspot activity, the amount most likely a result of a strain on resources due to increasing
of radiocarbon in a sequence of tree rings does not decline at a population, exacerbated by declining rainfall. According to
steady rate that corresponds to the rings’ ages. Instead, a graph Zerboni, the Terramare likely moved to the Apennines or the
of the rings’ radiocarbon content includes a series of “wiggles,” southern edge of the Alps. The plain was resettled around
or fluctuations in the amount of radiocarbon. By 200 years later, and, when people
comparing these wiggles with measurements of returned, they once again
radiocarbon in trees whose precise ages are known, cultivated the region, employ-
Manning was able to estimate the age of the wood ing Terramare tools and tech-
from the tanks. The presence of the tree ring niques, which continued to be used until quite recently.
immediately below the bark in one case along with Among the tools excavated in the Noceto pool, Zerboni, who
two groupings of “sapwood rings,” which are close himself grew up on the Po Plain, recognized a small piece of
to the bark, helped establish that the timber used bent wood used to poke holes in the soil in which farmers
to build the tanks was felled at two different points. would then plant seeds. “I remember my grandfather used the
According to the results, the lower tank was built same tool to cultivate his garden,” he says. “In the Noceto pool,
around 1444 B.C. and the upper tank was built about 12 we have the roots of the traditional culture of the Po Plain,
years later, around 1432 B.C. There is some uncertainty in which probably dates back almost 3,500 years.” Q
This wooden implement, which was used to poke holes in Daniel Weiss is executive editor at Archaeology.
soil before planting seeds, was recovered from the pool. To see additional images, go to archaeology.org/noceto.
archaeology.org 41
T
HE SUN SHINES NEARLY 300 days a year over nie Leno and Kim Charlie, sisters from Acoma Pueblo, about
southern New Mexico’s Tularosa Basin, 175 miles north, found the fossilized tracks of a giant ground
where bright white sand ripples across the sloth and two humans, all of whom lived at least 10,000 years
desert. Here, in White Sands National Park, ago, at the close of the Pleistocene Epoch.
the world’s largest gypsum dunes abut the Leno and Charlie didn’t expect to uncover a piece of late
dried-up bed of prehistoric Lake Otero, Pleistocene history at the park, but there they were, the
which once covered 1,600 square miles. In the summer, park kidney-shaped footprints of a 10-foot-tall, 2,000-pound long-
temperatures can reach 110°F. One’s eyes sting in the intense extinct mammal and the imprints of human toes—evidence of
sunlight. It was just such a sunny day in May 2021 when Bon- two species that coexisted thousands of years ago. “I was down
GHOST
OF WHITE
42 ARCHAEOLOGY • November/December 2021
on the ground, brushing everything off,” says Leno, recalling pueblos and tribes affiliated with that site are asked to consult
the adult human footprint she found not far below the surface. on the research and preservation. Acoma is one of six Native
“I was ecstatic.” Just inches away, she spotted the giant sloth groups currently studying and protecting the park’s prehistoric
track. “There were a lot of prints in that area,” says Charlie, trackways, says David Bustos, White Sands’ resource program
who uncovered the tiny footprint of a child nearby. manager. He invited Charlie to accompany scientists and park
Charlie is a member of the Acoma Tribal Historic Preserva- staff on one of the first field trips to the park since the pandemic
tion Office (THPO) board and participates in a consultation began in 2020. She in turn asked Leno, an Acoma cultural moni-
program with the National Park Service. Any time park employ- tor who works with the THPO to study and assess archaeologi-
ees conduct studies that might affect a Native cultural site, cal sites in culturally sensitive areas. It’s a role that the sisters say
TRACKS
SANDS
Scientists are uncovering fossilized footprints in
the New Mexico desert that show how humans
and Ice Age animals shared the landscape
By K C
archaeology.org 43
tracks are the best direct evidence of late
Pleistocene interactions between humans and
megafauna found anywhere in the world, and
it seems likely they were made by two hunters
confronting their prey, though whether they
or the sloth prevailed isn’t clear.
But that’s just one finding. White Sands
has the world’s largest collection of fossilized
Ice Age footprints, numbering in the hun-
dreds of thousands. “Each of these trackways
will have its own story to tell,” says Cornell
University archaeologist Tommy Urban, who
has worked with a multidisciplinary team of
archaeologists, geographers, geologists, envi-
ronmental scientists, and tribal members to
find and record scores of White Sands track-
ways. The geological makeup of the area has
led to the preservation of prints from not just
sloths and humans of all ages, but also mam-
Acoma Pueblo tribal members Kim Charlie (left) and Bonnie Leno (right) are among moths, bison, camels, dire wolves, and saber-
the Native people consulting with researchers working in White Sands National Park.
toothed cats. And from those ancient steps,
is akin to retracing their ancestral footsteps. scientists are able to discern an array of mammalian behaviors.
No one knows who the early human trackmakers were or “This gives us a rare window into a world that’s mostly lost to
whether they were genetically related to Native groups in the time and beyond our current reach,” Urban says. The length
region today. But for Leno and Charlie, there’s no denying their and breadth of the trackways at White Sands open a range of
sense of connection to these trackways. “Even though it’s been questions about early hunting practices, the lives of Ice Age
thousands of years,” Charlie says, the tracks “are still a part species, and what the world was like when humans and Pleis-
of us.” Her people have centuries-old roots in this Southwest tocene megafauna shared this landscape.
landscape. Acoma Pueblo is one of the oldest continually occu-
T
pied communities on the continent, founded atop a sandstone ODAY THE WHITE SANDS landscape, with its crests of
bluff around A.D. 1150. But the history of the people of Acoma glimmering dunes, forms a panorama of snow-white
Pueblo is even older. Charlie says she grew up learning stories land in a summer broil. There are no trees, save for
about a long migration that took Acoma ancestors from the a few solitary invasive species that suck all moisture from
far north of what is now the United States south into Mexico. the dunes. Miles of undulating sands give way to the crisp,
“We did a lot of traveling,” she says, pointing out that her flat surface of the dried-up ancient Lake Otero, dotted with
ancestors traded with people across the region, and possibly iodine bush, a desert shrub adapted to sandy, salty, alkaline
around White Sands. And the Acoma are not alone in their soils. To the east and west of the park, a heat haze distorts
connection to this vast open landscape, which features in many the peaks of towering mountains; to the north is White
Native oral histories. “Our tribal partners have stories about Sands Missile Range, the U.S. Army’s largest land-based
the ‘white sands’ and coming down for hunting parties,” says open-air testing site. But the ancient trackways know no
White Sands archaeologist Clare Connelly. modern borders—footprints crisscross both
UT CO sides of the fence dividing the national park
I
N 2017, RESEARCHERS HAD discovered from the missile range.
AZ NM
possible evidence of just such an ancient Acoma
At the time the tracks were made, research-
hunting party: a trackway of human Pueblo ers think Lake Otero had already begun to
TX
footprints directly inside the tracks of a giant MEXICO
evaporate and a series of small seasonal bod-
ground sloth. Every indication suggests one ies of water covered the area. “Many of the
person followed quickly behind the sloth. footprints actually have layers of algae, which
Their tracks were left in precisely the same would have required moisture to grow,” Urban
ground conditions. The person matched says. People and beasts slipped and slid across
the sloth’s stride—which was much longer a Basin a muddy surface, evidenced in the tracks they
Tularos
than a comfortable human stride—for more left behind. As the water evaporated over
than 10 paces until the sloth, it seems, rose White Sands National Park
time, it formed a playa—the flat bottom of a
on its hind limbs and flailed in defense. desert basin that occasionally fills with water.
Meanwhile, a second person approached 0 50 100 miles About 15 years ago, a rare flood filled
the animal on tiptoe from the side. The the playa with so much water that waves
archaeology.org 45
E
ACH DAY IN THE FIELD is different for the research team,
partly because weather conditions have to be just right
in order to discern the tracks—too wet or too dry, and
nothing is visible. For this reason, the White Sands prints are
often called ghost tracks. “They can be very clear on the surface
one day, and then another day, you can barely see anything,”
Bennett says. “They’re quite mercurial.” That makes the work
of identifying the trackways even more challenging. “It’s hard to
orient yourself,” says
Connelly, “because the
Sloth site is never the same.”
Human
An image created by
a ground-penetrating
radar survey
conducted at White
Mammoth Sands National Park
shows tracks left by a
sloth, a human, and a
mammoth.
Bustos unearths a footprint at White Sands National Park. Not only are the tracks difficult to identify, but one by
one, the White Sands archive of Pleistocene life is steadily
peoples were hunter-gatherers who lived in small groups and disappearing. Wind erodes the fine surface that covers the
are known today for their distinctive tools. Characteristic footprints and, once exposed, they quickly vanish. “We’re not
flaked Clovis spearpoints have been found with the bones of sure if it’s climate change, or what’s happening,” Bustos says.
megafauna such as mammoth, and smaller worked Folsom “We’re losing them.”
points are often associated with bison kill sites. Although sci- The team is documenting trackways as rapidly as they can,
entists haven’t drawn conclusions about who the White Sands using an array of tools to locate new prints and quickly gather
people were, their tracks indicate they definitely followed, information from those already identified. While erosion
stalked, harassed, and possibly hunted big game. constantly exposes new trackways, the team also searches for
The footprints tell other tales, too. Bennett says he and those that are less visible. Urban has spent most of his time in
the team have uncovered evidence of many children jumping, the park conducting geophysical surveys using magnetometry
skipping, and sloshing in the mud, their horseplay preserved in and ground-penetrating radar, which allow researchers to cre-
time. As a father himself, these findings spark his imagination. ate images of tracks that lie below the surface. The team then
“Every kid loves to jump in a puddle,” he says. “Prehistoric uses traditional tools to carefully remove sediments and expose
children were no different.” the prints and record them. They make plaster casts and 3-D
Footprints (above left) at White Sands National Park were left by a woman or adolescent male accompanied by a child, whose
footprints are shown above right. Analysis of the tracks shows that the child was occasionally carried during the journey.
National Park Service researcher Patrick Martinez surveys Tracks left by a mammoth between 15,500 and 10,000 years
the landscape at White Sands National Park, where wind ago were recently identified at White Sands National Park.
continually exposes and erodes human and animal prints.
people who left them. When the Acoma people visit a cul-
asks. When they look across White Sands, they think it must tural site, they always ask permission from the spirits of those
have been a hunting ground with nearby campsites where who passed, akin to asking permission to enter somebody’s
the community gathered. “You see the footprints, you see home, explains Leno. “If they want to let you know some-
children’s footprints,” Charlie says. “So you’ve got to think…” thing, find something, they will,” she says. “They will show
Leno finishes her sister’s thought: “…that was family.” you,” adds Charlie.
The team is further scouring the area, searching for the The sisters count themselves lucky to have seen these foot-
remains of hearths or other clues to how people lived, camped, prints, which appear and disappear so quickly. Most people
and hunted in the area. They’ve also found perplexing grooves will never have that opportunity. The National Park Service
in the ground that might be related to the human tracks. is creating replicas of the trackways for visitors to view and
“We’re not sure exactly what’s going on,” Connelly says, but touch, but the experience isn’t the same as being under that
the team suspects the people dragged something on a large blazing sun, in the precise locations where so many thousands
stick. “We only see these where we see human footprints, so of people and animals made their marks ages ago. “I wish we
we just call them drag structures,” she adds. could keep those tracks intact for everybody to see,” Charlie
After examining the grooves, Charlie and Leno think these says, but she accepts that she has no control over their survival.
abrasions could be additional evidence of hunting. “You take “That’s really up to Mother Nature.” Q
down the mammoth, there’s no way you’re going to carry that
big carcass on your back and take it home,” Charlie says. Per- Karen Coates is a contributing editor at Archaeology.
archaeology.org 47
GAUL’S UNIVERSITY
New excavations have revealed the wealth and
prestige of an ancient center of learning
By J A. L
T
HE ROMAN ORATOR AND rhetorician Eumen- hard times. In A.D. 269, its residents had taken sides against
ius delivered a speech to the Roman governor Victorinus, the emperor of the ill-fated breakaway state now
of Gallia Lugdunensis in A.D. 298 advocating known as the Gallic Empire (ca. 269–271 a.d.), and the city
for the restoration of the famous schools was besieged for seven months. Access to the high level of cul-
called the Maeniana in the city of Augusto- ture and education that had been central to Augustodunum’s
dunum, at the center of the province. At the identity fell victim to a combination of circumstances, perhaps
time of Eumenius’ speech, the once-thriving city had fallen on including damage to the Maeniana, funding diverted to the
conflict, or a diminished student population. exception of a brief defection in 52 B.C. when they joined an
Augustodunum (modern Autun) had been founded around unsuccessful rebellion led by Vercingetorix, the doomed chief
13 B.C. by the emperor Augustus (r. 27 B.C.–A.D. 14) as a new of the Arverni tribe. The capital of the Aedui had been located
capital for the Aedui, a Celtic tribe that was—mostly—allied at the settlement of Bibracte, but when the tribe became a
with the Romans. By 121 B.C., the tribe had been awarded the civitas foederata, or allied community, of Rome, it was moved
title of “brothers and kinsmen of Rome.” The Aedui largely 15 miles east to its new location. It was given a name that com-
supported Julius Caesar in his campaigns in Gaul, with the bined its Roman and Gallic identities: Augusto- for Augustus,
archaeology.org 49
Christianity was well established in Augustodunum by the
early fourth century A.D. In A.D. 313, its first recorded bishop,
Reticius, was honored with an invitation to Rome to help
Bibracte Augustodunum
(Autun) resolve the schism in the church caused by the Donatists,
a North African sect of Christians. One of Gaul’s oldest
Christian inscriptions was found in a city cemetery in 1839.
According to INRAP archaeologist Michel Kasprzyk, it dates
FRANCE to the late third or early fourth century A.D. The document’s
Greek text, he explains, includes the name of a Christian man,
Pektorios, and an acrostic of the Greek word ichthys, or fish,
an early Christian symbol of Christ.
Another rare text included in a set of panegyrics called the
Lugdunum nnel
lish
Cha Laudes Domini dates from A.D. 290 to the 310s and describes the
(Lyon) Eng
FRANCE
city’s appearance in antiquity. This collection of speeches was
made by delegates from Augustodunum to the imperial court at
Augusta Treverorum (modern Trier). From about A.D. 250 to the
middle of the next century, Trier was one of the largest cities in
the empire and served as a residence for the Roman emperor.
0 50 100 miles The texts mention many monuments in Augustodunum, some
rebuilt after the crisis of the late third century A.D., including
and -dunum, the Celtic word for “hill,” “fort,” or “walled town.”
From the start, Augustodunum was a city with a status and
appearance befitting the prestige of the Aedui and their Roman
governors. The provincial capital city of Lugdunum (modern
Lyon), a little over 100 miles south, was its only superior in
architectural splendor, economic prominence, and population
in the region. “Augustodunum was one of the most important
cities in Gaul,” says archaeologist Carole Fossurier of France’s
National Institute of Preventive Archaeological Research
(INRAP). For most of the nearly three centuries preceding
Eumenius’ oration, it was a thriving university town and one of
the most Romanized in Gaul. It was encircled by a stout 4.5- A set of pins was found at the feet of the deceased in the
burial ground’s largest sarcophagus. They are the only known
mile city wall that enclosed an area of about 500 acres, with
Roman pins of this style made of amber.
straight Roman streets laid out on a grid plan. It was also home
to Gaul’s largest theater, an amphitheater, shops, manufactur- baths, aqueducts, houses, and the schools of the Maeniana. One
ing quarters, public baths, luxuriously decorated residences, a describes a visit to Augustodunum by Constantine at the end
forum, numerous temples, and, eventually, places for Christian of A.D. 310 during which he was shown “all the statues of their
worship. The city was traversed by a major Roman road built gods,” a clear indication, says Kasprzyk, that the city was both
by Augustus’ son-in-law Marcus Vipsanius Agrippa for military pagan and Christian at the time.
use and to encourage trade by connecting the province to the
A
English Channel. Under the emperor Claudius (r. A.D. 41–54), RCHAEOLOGISTS HAVE EXPLORED Autun periodically for
who was born in Lugdunum, the Aedui became the first Gal- decades. Still, very little of Augustodunum—perhaps
lic tribe whose members were allowed to serve as senators in only 3 to 4 percent—has been investigated, and only
Rome. In Augustodunum, writes the first- and second-century through small surveys, limited excavations, and sometimes acci-
A.D. Roman historian Tacitus, “the noblest youth of Gaul dental discoveries. Researchers have unearthed the remnants of
devoted themselves to a liberal education.” ancient structures, including possibly the Maeniana, as well as
aqueducts, marble sculptures, and finely crafted mosaics that
A
FTER THE SIEGE BY Victorinus that damaged the city, once covered the floors of the city’s wealthiest residents’ homes.
the emperor Constantius I (r. A.D. 293–306) became Some of these mosaics depict scenes from Greek mythology,
Augustodunum’s benefactor. He promised to restore such as the story of the hero Bellerophon, who killed the mythi-
the city to its former status and appearance, an effort that cal beast the Chimera. Others include portraits and sayings of
was continued by his son, the emperor Constantine I (r. A.D. Greek philosophers. These are testaments to the influence of
306–337). “Augustodunum wanted to be a provincial capital,” Greco-Roman high culture in Augustodunum and to its well-
says University of Kent archaeologist Luke Lavan, “and to educated citizenry. Part of Augustodunum’s fourth-century A.D.
become one, it competed with other provincial centers in Gaul church was excavated in the 1970s, and several acres of one its
for the emperor’s patronage.” largest ancient cemeteries were dug in 2004.
E
A tremendous surprise awaited the team in a sarcophagus UMENIUS WAS BORN IN Augustodunum to a family of
belonging to one of Augustodunum’s richest citizens. In it they educators—his grandfather came to Gaul from Athens
discovered an example of one of the most luxurious artifacts and was a teacher of rhetoric. It is likely Eumenius
from the Roman world—a type of late Roman glass vessel attended the Maeniana, where he perfected the skills that led
known as a cage cup, of which very few examples survive. These him to a career as Constantius’ private secretary, a position
cups have intricate three-dimensional openwork designs in deep in which he was responsible for answering all petitions on
relief, usually geometric and much less frequently figural. “Cage the emperor’s behalf. In his A.D. 298 speech, Eumenius
cups are incredibly rare,” says ancient glass expert Carolyn Nee- praised Constantius—no doubt to secure his patronage
dell of the Chrysler Museum. “You almost never see them, of Augustodunum and funds for its restoration. He
and never in the ground.” In fact, the vessel found at pledged to donate half of the enormous salary of
Augustodunum is among the 10 best-preserved 60,000 sesterces the emperor had awarded
examples of Roman cage glass and the first him as the schools’ newly appointed
complete vessel found in Gaul. head—twice what he had earned as
The cage cup from Augustodunum his secretary—for the effort. This
represents the pinnacle of Roman set in motion the restoration not
glassmaking. “What makes this only of his prestigious alma mater,
cup extraordinary is the manufac- but also of his hometown. Most
turing technique,” says Tisserand. of the burials discovered by the
“It was probably carved from a INRAP team date to after the
single block of blown glass using late third-century siege, and the
techniques similar to those used extraordinary grave goods likely
by goldsmiths.” In fact, says Nee- provide evidence of the city’s
dell, cage cups are so difficult to recovery and its return to the
make that scholars still debate how thriving center of learned culture
Roman glassmakers accomplished it. it had once been. Q
A view of the Roman cage cup after cleaning, Jarrett A. Lobell is editor in chief at
before recent reassembly Archaeology.
archaeology.org 53
“Peter Sommer Travels continue to excel. The tour was a fantastic
couple of weeks of history, archaeology and mythology combined
with beautiful scenery, wonderful food and fantastic wine.”
PETER SOMMER
TRAVELS
CRUISING THE LYCIAN SHORE CRUISING THE COAST OF DALMATIA: WALKING & CRUISING SOUTHERN
FROM SPLIT TO DUBROVNIK DALMATIA
www.petersommer.com
Escorted Archaeological Tours,
Tel: 855 4433027 (US toll free)
Gulet Cruises and Private Charters
info@petersommer.com
Christiansborg Castle,
constructed in 1661 as a Danish
transatlantic slave trade fortress
and renovated throughout the
centuries, can be seen from Osu
Beach in Accra, Ghana.
long a stretch of the West now the city of Accra, Ghana, where women they married, and the children
archaeology.org 55
LETTER FROM GHANA
Excavations at Christiansborg Castle are revealing the foundations of a structure associated with a Euro-African settlement dating to
the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Many team members are Danish-Ga descendants of the original Euro-African community.
dungeons before being taken to the of modern Ghana alone. This terri- which stretched from roughly modern
Danish West Indies, which included tory represents a fraction of the entire Senegal to modern Gabon.
the Caribbean islands of Saint Croix, region of West Africa where Euro- In the late fifteenth century,
Saint John, and Saint Thomas. At peans traded with African groups Europeans encountered a diverse
least 100,000 captives were and acquired captives, a massive and ancient sociopolitical landscape
transported during the Danish area Europeans called Guinea, in West Africa. “You are looking at
transatlantic slave trade. a region that had developed a very
Europeans began formally TOGO NIGERIA
BENIN
sophisticated organizational network
Lagos
trading with West African GHANA
Lomé
of cities, kingdoms, emerging states,
peoples in the last quarter of IVORY COAST
Porto-Novo and full-fledged states,” says archaeolo-
the fifteenth century, nearly 200 gist Akin Ogundiran of the University
Abidjan
years prior to the construction of Elmina Castle of North Carolina at Charlotte. “Peo-
Christiansborg Castle. The Portu- ple had extensive political structures,
guese built Elmina Castle, the first and the region was thriving and bus-
permanent European trading post in tling politically.” West Africans were
West Africa, on the same stretch of Accra accustomed to interacting, and even
coast as Christiansborg Castle, some Osu intermarrying, with people who looked
85 miles west, in 1482. Over the next Christiansborg Castle
different from them and spoke dif-
300 years, European nations, including (Osu Castle) ferent languages, including Arabs and
Portugal, the Netherlands, England, Berbers. “The only difference is that
France, Spain, Sweden, and Denmark, Europeans were coming across the
0 1 2 miles
constructed around 80 castles, forts, ocean instead of across the Sahara,”
and trading lodges within the borders says Ogundiran.
Archaeological
Inutitute of America
CREATE YOUR
LEGACY
WITH THE AIA &
THE CHARLES ELIOT
NORTON SOCIETY
An eighteenth-century illustration of Christiansborg Castle shows both European- n their seven years of digging,
and West African–style buildings. Sailing ships wait in the harbor, possibly to
transport enslaved people to the Americas.
B illionaires have billions because they know value is not increased by an inflated price.
They avoid big name markups, and aren’t swayed by flashy advertising. When you look
on their wrist you’ll find a classic timepiece, not a cry for attention–– because they know
true value comes from keeping more money in their pocket. The Jet-Setter Chronograph
can go up against the best chronographs in the market, deliver CLIENTS LOVE
more accuracy and style than the “luxury” brands, and all for STAUER WATCHES…
far, far less. $1,150 is what the Jet-Setter Chronograph would
cost you with nothing more than a different name on the face. ÌÌÌÌÌ
Your satisfaction is 100% guaranteed. “The quality of their
watches is equal to many
Jet-Setter Chronograph $299† that can go for ten times
Offer Code Price $29 + S&P Save $270 the price or more.”
You must use the offer code to get our special price. — Jeff, McKinney, TX
1-800-333-2045 Limited to the first 1900 responders
Your Offer Code: JCW423-01 to this ad only.
Stauer ® 14101 Southcross Drive W., Ste 155, Dept. JCW423-01,
Burnsville, Minnesota 55337 www.stauer.com
† Special price only for customers using the offer code versus the price on
Stauer.com without your offer code. Rating of A+
• Precision crystal movement • Stainless steel case back & bracelet with deployment buckle • 24 hour military time
• Chronograph minute & small second subdials; seconds hand • Water resistant to 3 ATM • Fits wrists 7" to 9"
archaeology.org 59
LETTER FROM GHANA
that they would not have been able to that allowed Europeans to establish a of the seventeenth- and eighteenth-
acquire otherwise. Intermarriage could permanent commercial presence on century mercantile world. “We know
also be a useful tool for the Ga to exert the coast. The greatest concentration that many Danish men traded on their
social control. “Europeans in West Afri- of these outposts was along the coast own private accounts,” says Engmann,
ca during [the precolonial] period were of what is now Ghana. Among them “including trading captive Africans,
not settlers, they were tenants, and was Christiansborg Castle, which, in to supplement their salary.” She says
those Ga families who the late seventeenth it’s difficult to establish through the
decided to give their and eighteenth archaeological record alone which
daughters to these centuries, contained objects were used by the Danes, Afri-
European men were a courtyard, a cans, or Euro-Africans in particular
being strategic,” says chapel, a school because everybody used objects made
Ogundiran. “When you for educating both locally and abroad. “They had
have visitors who have the children of European-made wardrobes, they had
certain kinds of power European men writing desks, pots, pans, Chinese
porcelain, and Danish ceramics and
pipes,” Engmann says. “But we can’t
say it was just Danes that used them.”
The team has uncovered the foun-
dations of several houses that were
part of the settlement, including those
of what is thought to be a kitchen
containing charcoal and three stones
for balancing a cooking pot. They’ve
also discovered what are commonly
called African trade beads, which were
manufactured in Italy and Holland,
and cowrie shells used as currency. A
large assemblage of ceramics found at
the site includes Chinese porcelain, as
well as English, Dutch, and local pot-
tery. The team has uncovered an abun-
dance of Dutch, German, English, and
Danish pipe bowl and stem fragments,
as well as some local African smok-
A mix of ceramics, including locally made earthenware (top) and Chinese porcelain and ing pipes, evidence that tobacco was
English transfer-printed pearlware (above), has been discovered at the site. widely consumed at the castle. These
artifacts speak to the importance of
and knowledge that you don’t have, but and African women, a warehouse, trade in imported tobacco, particularly
you want to acquire, intermarriage is an storerooms, residential quarters, from Brazil, in the area at the time.
effective way of bridging that gap, and dungeons, and a bell tower. “As soon as the slave trade really
also of domesticating outsiders, keeping Contemporaneous records show took off in the early seventeenth
a close eye on them.” that among the personnel were a century, the materials from the
governor, a bookkeeper, a physician, a tropical world coming in—tobacco,
uropeans first traded with West chaplain, a full garrison of Danish and rum, aguardiente, and other kinds
archaeology.org 61
ARCHAEOLOGICAL INSTITUTE OF AMERICA
UNcOVERING
PYLOS
In 1939, an archaeological team led Mycenaean palace complex ever exca-
by University of Cincinnati professor vated in Greece, and the hundreds of
Carl Blegen unearthed the first traces inscribed Linear B tablets found there
of what would soon be recognized as have provided archaeologists with a
the ancient Greek city of Pylos and the unique window into how these Bronze
fabled Palace of Nestor. Celebrated as Age centers functioned.
one of the greatest discoveries of its Almost eight decades later, the
time, it would forever change the study legendary site continues to reveal its
of Aegean prehistory. The -,100-year- incredible hidden treasures. Additional
old ruins are the best-preserved discoveries in 1015 and 1017 would
once again indelibly change the field of
Aegean Bronze Age archaeology: the
grave of the so-called Griffin Warrior
The AIA has created Uncovering Pylos, and two monumental tholos tombs.
a special publication highlighting the history The burials contained a trove of finely
and archaeology of this ancient site. crafted objects that have provided even
more new information about the people
To receive your copy of Uncovering Pylos, who lived and died in Pylos thousands
of years ago. These new discoveries
make a $25 donation to the Annual Fund. continue to prove what an exceptional
Go to archaeological.org/donate place ancient Pylos once was, and
that, although the site has been inves-
Or, please send a check, payable to: tigated by archaeologists for more
than three-quarters of a century, there
The Archaeological Institute of America is still much to be learned today while
uncovering Pylos.
Attn: Development Department
44 Beacon Street, Boston,
MA 02108
The AIA thanks Richard C. MacDonald for his generous support of the Uncovering Pylos Project.
LETTER FROM GHANA
Huge numbers of cowrie shells (above) were imported from across the Indian Ocean to
West Africa by Europeans, where they were used for currency. Europeans also produced
glass beads called African trade beads (top) in Italy and Holland to exchange with Afri-
cans, along with other luxury goods such as silk textiles, gold bracelets, and carpets.
archaeology.org 63
LETTER FROM GHANA
As we approach the end of the year, the AIA remains in high gear. September saw the start of the 126th season of our
Lecture Program. We celebrated International Archaeology Day in October. Currently, we are promoting our grants
and fellowships in advance of the November application deadlines and, of course, we are getting ready for the Annual
Meeting in January. To stay up to date on all that is happening at the AIA, be sure to visit archaeological.org frequently.
65
DISPATCHES
FROM THE AIA
EXCAVATE EDUCATE ADVOCATE
66
AIATours.org
Archaeology-focused tours, for all levels of interest...
WHAT IS IT
housands of tablets in multiple languages spanning millennia confirm that ancient
T
Flask
Near Eastern scribes were tireless record keepers. But errors were bound to happen. CULTURE
Middle Bronze Age
Scholars have recently become aware of a type of vessel called an aluārum in DATE
texts from central Turkey dating to the nineteenth century B.C. More than 200 ca. 1650 B.C.
MATERIAL
years later, inscribed tablets from cities far to the south near Babylon refer to a type of vessel Clay
FOUND
called an “alluharum” pot, which was thought by modern scholars to hold a white dye known
by that name. But according to historian Seth Richardson of the University of Chicago, the
Babylonian scribes were actually misspelling alu)rum, the name of the flasks, which sounded Ankara
TURKEY
similar to their word for dye. “It evokes a picture of Babylonian scribes sitting on the docks Zincirli
with boatmen coming down the Euphrates River transporting hundreds of these jars,” says
Richardson. “The scribes don’t know how to spell the word they’re saying, so they just use
DIMENSIONS
the spelling for a word they know.” The Babylonian vessels mistakenly thought by scholars to 14 inches tall, 12.8 inches
in diameter, volume of
hold dye were in fact full of wine. 3 gallons
Alu)rum flasks such as this pot unearthed at the city of Zincirli
in modern Turkey are found at Middle Bronze Age (ca. 2000–1600
B.C.) sites across the Near East. Their identification as vessels used
to transport and store prized wine changes how scholars
understand the region’s economy. “It’s giving us insight
into the complexity of long-distance trade in the
seventeenth century B.C., a time that is not
well known in this region,” says archaeologist
Kathryn Morgan of Duke University and
assistant director of the Chicago-Tübingen
Expedition to Zincirli. This network
extended from modern Iraq to central
Anatolia, a distance of more than 800 miles
along which merchants transported not only
wine, but also other commodities including
scented and flavored oils.