Professional Documents
Culture Documents
in the vasa vasorum, bleeding from the latter cannot oc- sy cases of aortic dissection, respectively. In a histological
cur. The question of which occurs first, intimal tear or study of autopsy material from 111 patients with aortic
medial dissection, has not been fully resolved to date. dissection, we observed CMN in a high percentage (82%)
What is pathologically important is that both events as- of patients with inherited connective tissue disease
sume the pre-existence of a medial weakness. In other (ICTD) typified by Marfan syndrome, but in only 19% of
words, there is a common recognition that no extensive non-ICTD patients, and the degree of CMN in non-ICTD
aortic dissection occurs without an aortic medial weak- patients was milder than that in ICTD patients.12) A recent
ness, whether an intimal tear or bleeding from the vasa study of surgical specimens has also reported a differ-
vasorum occurs first. Thus, various studies focusing on ence in the incidence of CMN between ICTD and non-
medial weakness have been conducted to date. In the fol- ICTD patients.13) This strongly suggests that CMN is a
lowing paragraphs, we will present the results and con- major factor involved in the development of aortic dissec-
cepts derived from these and our studies. tion in ICTD patients, and that it is difficult to fully ex-
plain the pathogenesis of aortic dissection in non-ICTD
Cystic Medial Necrosis (Degeneration) patients by CMN alone. Then, what changes are observed
and Limitations of Histological Examina- in the media of aortic dissection in non-ICTD patients?
tion Unfortunately, histological examination is useless for this
question, and often fails to detect significant changes.
For many years, it has been reported that cystic medial Close examination under a high magnification seems to
necrosis (CMN) is observed in the aortic media of pa- show fewer dark brown-stained elastic fibers in the aorta
tients with aortic dissection. As shown in Fig. 1, CMN is of aortic dissection patients than in that of normal sub-
a pathological condition characterized by the local disap- jects (Fig. 2 a & b); however, unfortunately, these figures
pearance of elastic fibers in the arterial media, a reduc- give no more than an impression, indicating the limita-
tion in smooth muscle cells (SMCs), and an increase in tions of light microscopy. In such a case, detailed electron
proteoglycans. The histological appearance suggests a microscopic examination may provide useful informa-
medial weakness,9) but the incidence of CMN is not as tion. The following paragraphs describe the ultrastruc-
high as expected. Wilson and Hutchin 10) and Larson and ture of the aortic media of normal subjects and aortic
Edwards 11) identified CMN in only 10 and 18% of autop- dissection patients, and discuss the difference in aortic
function inferred from ultrastructural observations. nected by interlaminar elastic fibers (running vertically
in the figure).17) We can clearly see that elastic fibers,
Ultrastructure of the Normal Aortic which appear to be a mere overlapping of layers on a
Media two-dimensional image as obtained by light microscopy
microscopy, actually assume a three-dimensional frame-
Electron microscopic studies by the research group of work or network structure. In addition, transmission elec-
Glagov showed et al. showed that the normal aortic me- tron microscopy has shown that smooth muscle cells
dia consists of lamellar units comprising concentric elas- present in this framework structure are densely adherent
tic laminae and intervening smooth muscle cells, elastic and connected with elastic fibers.18, 19) The aorta receives
fibers, collagen fibers, and ground substance.14, 15) The la- blood from the heart and dilates passively during systole,
mellar structure apparently gives the impression of and, conversely, contracts passively during diastole to
weakness, but, actually, the tunica media is very tough. smoothly pump the blood accumulated in the lumen to
For example, it has been reported that a pressure as high the periphery (Windkessel effect). Moreover, as described
as 600 mmHg is required to tear the media, that is, to below, the thoracic aorta moves up and down and twists
cause dissection by infusing physiological saline into the during systole and diastole. In other words, the aorta re-
media.16) Much of the structure that confers the medial peatedly expands and contracts passively like rubber in
strength remains unknown, but it is believed to be de- rhythm with the heart beat. It seems that the integrity of
rived from the interconnection of the components of the the media is preserved against the repeated motion of the
lamellar units. First, let us focus on the most important aorta because elastic fibers and smooth muscle cells are
components, elastic fibers and smooth muscle cells. strongly interconnected to function as a whole structure.
When the human aortic media is treated with formic acid Such interconnections between elastic fibers and between
to remove the components other than the elastic fibers, elastic fibers and smooth muscle cells (Fig. 4) are observed
and the structure of the remaining elastic fibers is exam- not only in humans but also in other animals; therefore,
ined by electron microscopy, the elastic laminae (running this structure seems to be a universal one necessary to
horizontally in Fig. 3a) can be seen to be mutually con- maintain medial integrity against various forces.15, 20)
a b
Fig. 4 Interconnections between elastic fibers and smooth muscle cells. Black-
appearing elastic fibers (E) and the processes of smooth muscle cells are
connected with one another at many sites. The rat aortic media was exam-
ined by transmission electron microscopy after tannic acid staining. Scale
bar = 1 µm (Reproduced from Ref. 17).
Fig. 5 The architecture of elastic fibers in experimental aortic dissection. a & b: Normal rat. a b
c & d: β-aminopropionitrile-treated rat. a & c, The aorta was treated with formic acid
c d
to remove the components other than the elastic fibers, and then examined by scanning
electron microscopy. Scale bar = 20 µm. b & d, The aorta was examined by transmis-
sion electron microscopy after tannic acid staining. Scale bar = 5 µm. Upper, intimal
side. Lower, adventitial side (Reproduced from Ref. 20).
Changes in the Architecture of Medial showing the presence of many black interlaminar elastic
Elastic Fibers in Aortic Dissection: Im- fibers between horizontally running black elastic lami-
plications for the Mechanism of Aortic nae, as shown in Fig. 5b. On the other hand, in the aortic
Dissection media of BAPN-treated rats, scanning (Fig. 5c) and
transmission (Fig. 5d) electron microscopy showed that
As shown in Fig. 3b, a three-dimensional scanning the structure of concentric elastic laminae was almost
electron microscopic study of the structure of medial normal, but interlaminar elastic fibers were markedly re-
elastic fibers in aortic dissection patients using the same duced. Thus, the observation of similar, species-indepen-
method as that for the normal aortic media revealed no dent changes strongly suggests that changes in the archi-
significant changes in concentric elastic laminae (running tecture of elastic fibers play a very important role in the
horizontally in the figure) compared with those in nor- development of aortic dissection.
mal subjects (Fig. 3a), but a marked reduction in inter- We can extrapolate interesting mechanical changes
laminar elastic fibers (running vertically in the figure) .17) from the structural changes of elastic fibers. That is, a re-
Identical findings were observed in rats with aortic dis- duction in interlaminar elastic fibers may result in the
section induced experimentally by β-aminopropionitrile weakening of the connection between elastic laminae and
(BAPN).20) Fig. 5a shows the structure of elastic fibers in that between elastic fibers and smooth muscle cells, thereby
the normal rat aortic media, composed basically of con- reducing the integrity of the tunica media. In extreme
centric elastic laminae with connecting interlaminar elas- terms, this architecture can be likened to a deck of cards,
tic fibers, as in the normal human aortic media. Trans- that is, a structure with no vertical interconnection. Such
mission electron microscopy confirmed this structure, a structure has little resistance to a tearing (Fig. 6a) or
shear force (Fig. 6b). Little resistance to a tearing force ficiently great to cause aortic dissection. In other words,
means little resistance to a dissection-promoting force in- it is possible to extrapolate that, in the presence of archi-
volved in aortic dissection. Blanton et al. developed a dog tectural changes in elastic fibers, as shown in Figs. 3b
model of aortic dissection by creating an artificial inti- and 5c, a force associated with the motion of the aorta or
mal tear in the normal dog aorta to cause medial dissec- that of blood flow in the aortic lumen produces a strain
tion.21) This model shows that medial dissection can occur (Fig. 6b), which causes medial dissection. What is im-
even when the architecture of the aorta is normal, that is, portant is that this extrapolation applies to both classic
the components of the lamellar units are normally inter- aortic dissection and IMH. So, we consider that if medial
connected. However, a review of the literature shows that strain affects the intima, dissection with intimal tear occurs,
the dissection is narrow and localized. On the other hand, resulting in classic aortic dissection. On the other hand,
in humans, aortic dissection is often extensive, probably when medial strain tends to extend in the lateral direc-
as a result of the weakened connection between the elas- tion, medial dissection alone may occur, leading to IMH.
tic laminae in the tunica media, as described above. At
autopsy on patients with aortic dissection, we often acci- Elastic Fiber and Elastin Abnormalities
dentally increase the extent of medial dissection by in Aortic Dissection: Literature Review
touching the aorta, which also suggests that the tunica
media has little resistance to tearing forces. Studies using other animal models have also reported
On the other hand, what we should think of the de- that abnormalities in elastin, the main component of elas-
creased resistance to a shear force is a difficult question. tic fibers, have an important significance in the develop-
First, let us consider the force sustained by the aorta. The ment of aortic dissection. The research group of Daugh-
thoracic aorta is known to move in the long axis direc- erty et al. reported that the administration of angiotensin
tion on every heart beat, and it has been noted that this II to apolipoprotein E-deficient mice resulted in the de-
force may play an important role in the development of velopment of localized aortic dissection, followed by the
dissection.9, 22) In a recent analysis using a finite element dilation of the lumen and subsequent development of an
model, the largest stress increase due to aortic root dis- aneurysm.24) The importance of this report is that medial
placement was identified approximately 2 cm above the elastic fiber degeneration and macrophage accumulation
sinotubular junction,22) which, interestingly, is the most were observed before the development of aortic dissec-
common site for the development of an intimal tear.12) On tion, suggesting that the structural abnormalities of elas-
the other hand, Anagnostopoulos noted the possibility tic fibers induced aortic dissection. Also, it has been re-
that the medial strain produced by stress from blood flow ported that, in fibrillin-1-deficient mice, elastic fiber
in the aortic lumen strongly influences the development fragmentation occurs, and aortic clamping results in the
of an intimal tear.23) These points of view are very attrac- development of dissection.25) Since fibrillin-1 is required
tive in suggesting that the stress on the aortic wall is suf- for the assembly of microfibrils around elastin, their
findings suggest that microfibril abnormalities are in- of elastin and myofibrils, but much of their cellular and
volved in elastic fiber fragmentation. In addition, aortic molecular biological mechanisms is unknown.
dissection was also reported to occur in biglycan-defi- In addition to elastic fibers, other extracellular matrix
cient mice26); however, unlike human aortic dissection, components such as collagen fibers and glycosaminogly-
the aortic dissection in this model occurred between the cans are present in the aortic media, and are involved in
media and adventitia, and no histological changes were maintenance of the aortic wall integrity. Abnormalities
observed in elastic fibers. However, since biglycan is be- in these components have also been noted in aortic dis-
lieved to be involved in elastogenesis and elastic fiber section patients. For example, the composition of colla-
stabilization, the possibility cannot be excluded that ul- gen fibers has been reported to vary with the location of
trastructural abnormalities of elastic fibers were pro- the aorta.31) Among glycosaminoglycans, the content of
duced, leading to the development of aortic dissection. dermatan sulfate and hyaluronate has been reported to
On the other hand, it has been suggested that, in hu- be increased in the areas of aortic dissection, suggesting
mans, some molecules induce abnormalities of elastic fi- that these localized increases are related to the develop-
bers and elastin, thereby being involved in the develop- ment of aortic dissection.32) In electron microscopic and
ment of aortic dissection. It is well-known that aortic dis- immunohistochemical studies of cases of aortic dissec-
section occurs in Marfan syndrome, in which microfibril tion, Ishii et al. observed the presence of spirally thick-
abnormalities due to fibrin-1 gene mutations are believed ened collagen fibers, thinning and loss of the basement
to cause abnormalities in elastic fibers.27) The research membrane of smooth muscle cells, and marked expression
group of Wang et al. reported that fibulin-5 expression in of MMP-1, -2, and -9 and tissue inhibitors of metallopro-
the aortic wall was down-regulated in patients with aortic teinase (TIMP)-1 and -2, suggesting that overall changes
dissection.28) Fibulin-5 is known to have an important in extracellular matrix components have an important
function in elastin polymerization, and the possibility has significance in the development of aortic dissection.33)
been suggested that decreased fibulin-5 expression is as-
sociated with abnormalities in elastin assembly. Peng et Conclusion
al. reported that the amount of medin-derived amyloid
deposited in the aortic media was lower, and that of non- Despite marked advances in the diagnostic imaging
amyloid medin was higher, in aortic dissection patients and treatment of aortic dissection, pathological research
than in a control group.29) Medin amyloid is commonly is lagging behind. This seems to be mainly due to the
found in the aortic media of individuals older than 50 fact that pathological knowledge is not necessarily re-
years of age, and is a molecule in close contact with elas- quired for the diagnosis and treatment of acute aortic dis-
tic fibers. Medin, an immature amyloid, has been sug- section. However, basic pathological, biochemical, and
gested to be cytotoxic, and the possibility has been noted physiological knowledge lay the foundations for better
that medin may act on smooth muscle cells to increase diagnosis and treatment. Needless to say, when consider-
the expression of matrix metalloproteinase (MMP)-2 in ing disease prevention, it is necessary to recognize abnor-
aortic dissection patients, thereby promoting the degrada- malities in the aortic wall before the occurrence of the
tion of elastin and collagen. Koullias et al. investigated catastrophic event of aortic dissection, and address them.
MMP expression in thoracic aortic aneurysm and aortic Undoubtedly, medial weakness forms a basis for aortic
dissection patients, and reported that MMP-2 and -9 ex- dissection, and the weakness is most likely to be due to
pression levels in the aortic media were higher in the aor- the structural abnormalities of elastic fibers, the main
tic dissection than in the thoracic aortic aneurysm pa- component of the media. In the future, it will be impor-
tients.30) Since MMP-2 and -9 are involved in the degra- tant to conduct a detailed study of the pathogenesis of
dation of both collagen and elastin, these results suggest their structural abnormalities. For example, considering
that elastin degradation is increased in aortic dissection. the close association between aortic dissection and hy-
In addition, aortic dissection patients are often compli- pertension, it is an important problem to elucidate the ef-
cated by hypertension,7, 10, 11, 12) suggesting that hyperten- fects of hypertension on elastin and microfibrils and their
sion is closely involved in the development of aortic dis- mechanism employing pathological methods. In addition,
section by causing abnormalities in the architecture of the pathophysiological study of the force generated by
elastic fibers in the aortic media.17) These abnormalities blood flow, blood pressure, or the motion of the aorta is
may have resulted from some changes in the metabolism also necessary.
32) Cattell MA, Hasleton PS, Anderson JC. Glycosamino- matrix metalloproteinases and tissue inhibitors of matrix
glycan content is increased in dissecting aneurysms of metalloproteinase in aortic dissection. Hum Pathol.
human thoracic aorta. Clin Chim Acta. 1994; 226: 29–46. 2000; 31: 640–646.
33) Ishii T, Asuwa N. Collagen and elastin degradation by