Yale University Sterling Memorial Library Interlibrary Loan
Borrower: CWR
ILL Number:
62125597
INE
Patron: Spadoni, Robert
Journal Title: Film intemational.
Volume: 6 Issue: 6
Month/Year: dec 2008Pages: unknown
Article Author:
Article Title: spadoni, robert ; Tracking the
Werewol, review of Chantal Bourgault du
Coudray, The Curse of the Werewolf; Fantasy,
Horror and the Beast Within
Imprint: [Goyteborg, Sweden) ; Film
Intemational
ILLiad TN: 41429;
‘i
Ra 2
cai: PN1993 F557213 -
v.6 ISSUE 6 2008 DEC.
Location: SML STACKS LC
CLASSIFICATION =
DTBLSS
(216) 368-4272
216-368-3517:
‘smithill@case.edu
Emai
Shipping Address:
Case Westen Reserve University
Keivin Smith Library, ILL
Access Services
11056 Euclid Avenue
Cleveland, OH 44108
Charge
Maxcost: 351FM
RESEND REQUESTS must be submitted within four (4) WORKING DAYS
of original transmission,
Thanks!
2/1/2010 2:29 PM.
via ARIEL (130.132.80.19) or FAX (203-432-2257),Book Reviews
Book Reviews
Tarkovsky, Nathan
Dunne (ed), (2008)
London: Black Dog Publish-
ing, 464 pp, ISBN-13:
978-1-906155-04-8 (nb),
$49.95
Black Dog’s new compendium
of essays on the great Russian
film-maker, Andrei Tarkovsky,
belongs in a fairly recent cat-
egory of film studies titles,
intellectual coffee-table books
or prestige books, which offer
themselves as comprehensive,
even definitive works. These
are literally and figuratively peer and contemporary, the timeline of contextual events
Weighty tomes, labours aflove, | body of works dauntingin its | “completes he volume
critical essays expensively ‘Profound beauty, grandeur and | Complementing the scope of
errr ——rs—~—“™=‘EEUCrsCNrtCM
tion values throughout their
range of film stills, contex-
tual artworks and cinematic
images. Like Taschen's The Stan-
a8 one of the most significant | breadth of its contributors’
in the history of the moving expertise, with an obvious slant
image'(p.6).Dunne's method- | given towards European and
ology, in response, is to group | Russian scholars familiar with
Hey Hubrick Archives 2005) and | the set ofeiical treatments | the particular contexts of
‘The Ingmar Bergman Archives | into, four encompassing seg- | Tarkovsky's career and his
(2008), and Phaidon’s Hitchcock | ments: ‘Russia and Religion’ often-troubled productions. The
at Work (2003), Fransois Mufaut | (situating Terkovsky's free in methodologies, by consequence,
‘at Work (2005) and Orson Welles | proximate moments of Soviet vary from Jean-Paul Sartre's
at Work (2008) the end prod- polities and culture), art and eloquent defence of lvan's
vucts of such an approach are | Nature’ stylistic discourses Childhood (1962) on the grounds
physically impressive as well | and’ their relationship with of its defamiliarizing art-cinema
36 analytically productive, _| landscape and rmise-en-scéne), | treatment of war, to Evgeny
ihavsky's introduction by | "Music and Modemity” (Tark- | Tsymbal's application of
the editor Nathan Dunne, wie | ovsky as an auteur of seuna Tarkovsky's famous ‘sculpting
slso contributes four ofthe | design and interiority) and in time’ principles to the design
of Stalker (1979); to analyses of
book's twenty-four essays (plus | ‘Memory ‘and Awakening’
appendices), notes up front that | (which foregrounds colevo- adaptation (literary and
objective assessment of the rators’ memoirs, illustrating painterly) in essays by Mikhail
Russian auteur has long proved { the evolution of Tarkovsky’s Romadin (mainly on Solaris
a challenge. Despite the paucity | approach to cinema). Acollec- | (1972)) and Dunne (on The
of Tarkovsky’s output just tion of useful supplementary ‘Sacrifice (1986)), The best of the
seven features and three shorts texts - ranging. from Tarkovsky's | essays here, and none is
‘ina lifetime of work - like father’s poetry, toa rather spare | without ‘interest, strike a good
Reberr Bresson, an arthouse” filmography ard index, te balance - always difficult with
86 | film international iesne 38,Pie
Book Reviews
Tarkovsky, Nathan
Dunne (ed)), (2008)
London: Black Dog Publish-
ing, 464 pp, ISBN-13:
978-5-906155-04-9 (hbk),
Black Dog's new compendium
of essays on the great Russian
film-maker, Andzei Tarkovsky,
‘belongs ina fairly recent cat-
gory of film studi
intellectual coffee-table books
cor prestige books, which offer
themseives as comprehensive,
even definitive works, These
are literally and figuratively
‘weighty tomes, labours of love,
critical essays expensively
packaged with lustrous produc-
tion values throughout their
range of film stils,contex-
tual artworks and cinematic
mages. Like Taschen's The Stan
ley Kubrick Archives 2006) and
The Ingmar Bergman Archives
(2008), and Fhaidon's Hitchcock
at Work (2003), FrangisTrufaut
at Work (2005) and Orson Welles
«at Wor (2008), the end prod-
‘ucts of such an approach are
Physically impressive as well
as analytically productive.
Tarkovsky’s introduction, by
the editor Nathan Dunne, who
also contributes four of the
book's twenty-four essays (plus
appendices), notes upfront that
objective assessment of the
Russian auteur has long proved
«a challenge. Despite the paucity
of Tarkovsky’s output -just
seven features and three shorts
ina lifetime of work -like
Robert Bresson, an arthouse
peer and contemporary the
body of work is daunting in its
‘profound beauty, grandeur and
[which] today stands
as one of the most significant
in the history of the moving
image’ (p.¢). Dunne’s method-
logy, in response, is to group
the set of critical treatments
into four encompassing seg-
ments: ‘Russia and Religion’
(ituating Tarkovsky's Slme in
proximate moments of Soviet
politics and culture), Art and
Nature’ (stylistic discourses
and their relationship with
landscape and mise-en-scine),
‘Music and Modemity’ (Parke
ovsky as an auteur of sound
design and interiority) and
"Memory and Awakening’
(which foregrounds collabo.
rators’ memoirs illustrating
the evolution of Terkovsky's
approach to cinema).A collec
tion of useful supplementary
ts ranging from Tarkoveky’s
father’s poetry, to a rather spare
Slmography and index, to a
86 | Slm iterations enue 36
Below Stalker
timeline of contextual events
~ completes the volume
Complementing the scope of
Tarkovsky’s structure is the
breadth ofits contributors’
‘expertise, with an obvious slant
siven towards European and
Russian scholars familiar with
the particular contexts of
‘Tarkovshy’s career and his
coften-troubled productions. The
‘methodologies, by consequence,
vary from Jean-Paul Sartre's
eloquent defence of van's
Childhood (1962) on the grounds
of its defamiliorizing art-cinema
treatment of war, to Evgeny
‘Taymbal’s application of
Tarkovsiy’s famous ‘sculpting
sn time’ principles tothe design
‘of Stalker (1973); to analyses of
adaptation (literary and
painterly) in essays by Milkhll
Romadin (mainly on Solaris
(0972) and Dunné (on The
Sacrifice (1986), The best ofthe
essays here, and none is
‘without interest, strike a good
Dalance— always difficult with
Book Rev
mes
Tarkovsky =.
undoubtedly }
the flm-make
practice, and
logistical cine
that make his
undiluted by¢
time, On this»
piece (What\
Do?) is suppl
people, the Su
Foster, whe pz
homage to Tar
on his career!
achievements
‘magisterial lo
ovsky as the a
sequence-sho
but paradoxic
protagonists a
of form in wh:
bears repeatin
tive and perve
nicative films,
by noting that
cr fathom con
director’ text.
ing, but nonet)
comes to expl:
‘unique artistic
I shall continu
Is anice sum
landmark volt
wally elusive
films never se
from the cano
Contributor
‘Tim Palmer
Professor of
at the Unive
Carolina Wil
most recent
City of Shad
Crime Ciner
New Wave’,
lished in the
issue of New
and TelevisionBelow Stalker
tual events
lume.
the scope of
teis the
butors’
sbvious slant
‘pean and
smiliar with
ats of
and his
luctions, The
garcinema
Evgeny
mnet
‘sculpting
a the design
nalyser of
and
ay Mikal
Solaris
in The
>estof the
ke a good
fcuk with
Book Reviews
—_—_.
‘Tarkovsky - between the :
undoubtedly lofty ambition of | Tracking the Werewolf
the film-maker’ theory and The Curse of the
practice, and the applied, Werewolf: Fantasy, Horror
logistical cinematic minutiae nd the Beast Within,
that make isms so striking. | Chantal Bourgault
undiluted by the passing of
me. On this note, astrong nal | AY Coudray, (2006)
Piece (What Would Tarkovsky |” London: 18 Tauris, 224
Do?’ is supplied by, ofall
people, the Swiss director Mare
Foster, who pays practical
pp. ISBN 1645111583
(obi, 37.96, 1s6N
| 3a4s1a2575 (now, £540
homage to Tarkovsky's impact
on his career by citing his
achievements in the areas of | Werewolves offerrich possibili- |
‘magisterial long takes (Tark- | ties to storytellers and inter-
ovsky asthe anti-Eisenstein | preters looking for monsters to
Sequence-shot devotee), opaque | charge with symbolic mean.
but paradoxically mesmerizing | ings. The cooperative shape.
rotagonists and the spirituality | shifter hes accommodated a
of form in what are often, it wide variety of philosophies
Dears repeating, counterintul- | and critical perspectives. Guy
‘ve and perversely uncommu- | Endore, for example, in his
nicative films. Foster concludes | novel The Werewolf of Pars, inds
by noting that he probably can | in the figure an apt metaphor
ever answer his own question, | for the deadliness and scale
or fathom completely this of modem warfare: Instead
directors textual decision-mak- | of thousands, future ages will
ing but nonetheless, when it | Jill millions. It will go on, the
comes to exploring Tarkovsky's | figures will rise and the pro
unique artistic process,'Tknow | cess will accelerate! Hurrah
shall continue to ask’ (p. 405). | for the race of werewolves!’
1s a nice summary for a (Endore 1933: 260-91). For
landmark volume on aperpet- | James Twitchell (1985: 221-25),
Lally elusive film-maker whose | the film The Wol) Man (George
films never seem torecede | Waggner,1941)~in which
‘rom the eanon, on Chaney's confused Larry
Talbot finds himself prone to
Contributor details convulsive bodily tansforma-
= ~~ | tions involving hair sprout-
Tim Palmeris Associate | ingin unexpected places, and
Professor of Film Studies | new, raging, carnal appetites
at the University of North | ~ dramatizes the changes that
Carolina Wilmington. His” | wrack every adolescent boy in
‘mostrecent essay,’Paris, | the throes of puberty. Others
City of Shadows: French’ _| note the figure’ enslavement
Crime Ginema Before the | to the moon's monthly eycles
New Wave’, was pub- and see the werewolf emulat-
lished in the August 2008 | ing the sexual awakenings not |
issue of New Review of Fm | of boys but gils (vans 1596.
and Television Studies, 56), Perhaps second only to the
vampire in semantic versatiity,
the werewolf services innu-
erable agendas on a range
that includes Endore's march-
{ing millions and Twitchell,
psychosexualized teenagers,
Now, Chantal Bourgault du
Coudray has provided a fas:
cinating study of this endur-
ing figure, paying particular
attention to the werewolfs
shifting and complex relation-
ship with notions of self-
hood, gender and nature.
Bourgault du Coudray begins
by considering accounts of
‘Werewolfism running back to
antiquity. She describes how
in the nineteenth century
this figure, ike the vampire,
began to reflect distinctly
modem anxieties. Gothie
literature, lashing back at the
sunny claims of the Enlighten-
ment, included werewolves in
its catalogue of figures who
illustrate the perennially dark,
uncontrollable and passion-
ruled underside of human
nature. Also in the nineteenth
century, new ideas began to
be elaborated that would find
Tesonance in werewolf stories.
Darwin's theory of evolution
inspired some to speculate,
with dread, that if humanity
was ever creeping forward, it
might at any moment slide in
the opposite direction. Such
‘worries found expression in
accounts ~ some in Gothic lit-
erature, others in case studies
of ‘actual’ lyeanthropes - of,
individuals who transformed,
or believed they did, into rav-
ening wolves. Others viewed
wolf bodies as astral projec-
tions, thus updating the myth
to suit the popular spititual-
ist movement of the century,
Bourgault du Coudray shows,
inher second chapter, how the
‘werewolf reflects a number
‘weve na | 87Book Reviews Below An American Werewolf in London
of ambivalences bound up in
notions of the self and other.
For one's sense of identity to be
stable, that against which itis
defined must be construed as
external, Many stories depict
werewolves attacking from
‘without, rising up out of the
lower classes, or taking the
form of racially or ethnically
foreign invaders. However,
werewolves just as easily can
bbe seen to emerge from within.
‘The figure renders subjectivity
{n spatial terms, visualizing an
inside/outside schema in which
normal-looking exteriors har-
bour dangerous, wild and secret
cores. Werewolves embodied
new models of thinking about | Important to her argument —_| notions of masculinity with
‘entity in a cenrury thatsaw | is that Freud's theory of the | new intensity. Bourgault du
1 revolution in conceptions of | human psyche so thoroughly | Coudray notes, however, that
| mentalitiness,and one that | intertwipen with nee concep: | contradictions inherent in
1 envisioned outwardly civilized | tion of masculinity that to the werewolf must come to
‘ ‘human psyches built on lower | study one is, simultaneously, | bear in considerations of this
| Stata—buried butnevererased | to study the other. Marked | rampaging hyper-masculin-
~ consisting of earlier and men in werewolf stories - tor- ity, for, as Barbara Creed and
more savage stages ofhuman- | tured, divided, able to contain | others show, the figure can,
‘ty Signallingits main theme, | their perversely ibidinous | be understood to embody
the author titles this chapter inner selves for only so long | feminine qualities as readily
‘Upright Citizens on AllFours’. | and violently aggressive, with | as it does masculine ones,
Bourgault du Coudray next | a demonstrated taste for ‘The fourth chapter continues
introduces one of the book's | female victims ~ thus become | the focus on masculinity but
Sentral topics, which is gender. | spectacular embodiments of | rums to Jung's model of human
This she situates within the | Freud's dualistic conception _| psychology. While the author
‘ongoing reflection on reigning | ofa specifically masculine | highlights similarities between
discourses of the nineteenth | psyche, Films like The Wolf Jung's and Freud's conceptions
century, which, she continues | Man represent ‘case stud. of the beast within’, she con-
to show, intersect the were- | ies’ that are easily rendered _| centrates on differences, ung,
‘wolf figure in many ways, In in psychoanalytic terms. In | interested in evolutionary his-
particular she focuses on how | the 1980s, new innovations in | tory more then personal history,
figud redefined existing dual- | special effects technology and _| provides the philosophical bes
istic accounts of subjectivity in | the rise of the "body horror’ for Robert Fisler's study Man
{erems of the conscious and the | subgenre, yield such films a9 | into Wolf (1953), which argues
Unconscious. The unconscious, | The Howling Yjoe Dante, 1981) | that modem human atrecites
of course, became the domain | and An American Werewolfin | such as those perpetrated by
of the beast’, which, though | Londen John Landis, 1981), the Nazis are possible because
one might repress it,continu- | in which extended transfor | the ancestral memories of men
ously works on~andindeed | mation sequences featuring | (and the gender matters to
undergirds~the conscious |! rippling, Popping sinews and | Bourgault du Coudray), hunting
Self This beast might atany | grotesquely over-articulated | in packs with lupine ferocity,
moment erupt to the surface, musculatures dramatize still live in the modern psyche.
88 | im i al issue 36
SS emer tear TanerBook Reviews
of ambivalences bound up in
notions of the self and other.
For one’s sense of identity to be
stable, that against which its
defined must be construed as
external, Many stories depict
Werewolves attacking from
‘without’, rising up ou of the
lower classes, or taking the
form of racially or ethnically
foreign invaders. However,
werewolves just as easily can
bbe seen to emerge from within.
‘The figure renders subjectivity
{n spatial terms, visualizing an
inside/outside schema in which
normal-looking exteriors har-
our dangerous, wild and secret
cores, Werewolves embodied
new models of thinking about
Identity in a century that saw
a revolution in conceptions of
‘mental illness, and one that
envisioned outwardly civilized
human psyches built on lower
strata ~ buried butnever erased
~ consisting of earlier and
‘more savage stages of human-
ity, Signalling its main theme,
the author titles this chapter
‘Upright Citizens on All Fours’
Bourgault du Coudray next
introduces one of the book's
central topics, which is gender.
This she situates within the
ongoing reflection on reigning
discourses of the nineteenth
century, which, she continues
to show, intersect the were-
‘wolf figure in many ways. In
particular, she focuses on how
Freud redefined existing dual-
istic accounts of subjectivity in
terms of the conscious and the
unconscious. The unconscious,
of course, became the domain
of ‘the beast’, which, though
‘one might repress it, contimu-
ously works on ~ and indeed.
undergirds ~ the conscious
self. This beast might at any
moment erupt to the surface.
88] frm international issue 35,
Important to her argument
is that Freud's theory of the
human psyche so thoroughly
intertwines with his concep-
ton of masculinity that to
study one is, simultaneously,
to study the other. Marked
men in werewolf stories - tor
‘ured, divided, able to contain
their perversely libidinous
inner selves for only so long
and violently aggressive, with
a demonstrated taste for
female victims ~ thus become
spectacular embodiments of
Freud's dualistic conception
of a specifically masculine
| psyche. Films like The Wolf
‘Man represent ‘case stud-
ies' that are easily rendered
in psychoanalytic terms. In
the 1980s, new innovations in
special effects technology and
the tise of the ‘body horror’
subgenre, yield such films as
The Howling Yoe Dante, 1983)
and An American Werewolfin
London Yobn Landis, 1921),
in which extended transfor
‘mation sequences featuring
ppling, popping sinews and
grotesquely over-articulated
musculatures dramatize
Below An American Werewolf in London
Dew intensity urge du
Coudray notes, however, that
contradictions inherent in
the werewolf must come to
bear in considerations ofthis
"rampaging hyper masculin
iy, foras Barbara Creed and
others show, the figure can
be understood to embody
feminine qualles as readily
aeitdoes masculine ones.
The fourth chapter continues
the focus on masculinity but
tur to jung’ model of human
psychology While the author
Dighlightssimarties between
Junge and Freud's conceptions
of te’beast within’, she con
centrateson differences jung
interested in evoltionay his-
tory more than personal history,
provides te pilosophical basis
for Rober filers study Man
ino Wolf (195), wich argues
that moger human atecbes
such a5 those perpetrated by
the Nazis ae posetble because
the ancestral memories of men
(ond the gender matters to
Bourgaulé du Coudray), hunting
in packs with lupine ferocity,
| sate in the modern payee
| notions of masculinity with
Book Review
Ey
‘These memories, E
only need the right
cobeabalenediey
geringresidues can
in superstitions, pe
and cross-eultura,
who turn into woly
galt du Coudray a
Texts, from Jack Lor
Call ofthe Wid (180:
Nichals's fim Wolf
construe the ‘call
wolf in positive an:
terms. These and ot
present idealized vi
turn to a truer,
nal, more ‘natural (
‘With her fifth ch
gault du Coudray
to consider female
wolves. Female we
tend to be characti
differently than th
common male cou
Often ravenously b
ic, and drunk witt
these werewolves
stories that make ¢
these femmes fata
pelled by the pleae
the flesh’, in the er
Jess than what the
Attention to the lw)
ets of such 1920%-1
magazines as Weir.
(some of which are
Guced in the book),
‘werewolf stories th
make this one of tk
liveliest chapters.
also notes how, in
stories, the close id
tion of femininity ¥
hhas moved some at
construe femsle we
in a more positive |
wolf fictions that es
explore issues of fe
include Angela Cart
‘Company of Wolves
partial inspication f
Jordan's 198¢ fm, ¢nity with
rgault du
vever, that
srentin
come to
ons of this
xreed and
yhre can
body
as readily
rontinues
inity but
of human,
xe author
ss between
anceptions
she con-
dees. jung,
nary his-
>aal history,
phical basis
iy Man
te argues
atrocities
rated by
because
{es of men
rsto
1} fnunting
ferocity,
n poyche
Book Reviews
Sen eS
‘These memories Eisler wars,
only need the right conditions
tobe awakened, and their lin.
geting residues can be glimpsed
in superstitions, persistent
and cross-cultural, about men
‘who tum into wolves. Bour-
gault du Coudray also considers
tents, from Jack London's novel
Call of the Wit (1908) to Mike
Nichols’ film Wolf (1996), that
construe the ‘call to become
‘wolf in positive and even noble
terms. These and other texts
Present idealized visions of a
return to a truer, more origi-
nal, more ‘natural’ (male) self,
With her fifth chapter, Bour-
geult du Coudray shifts gears
to consider female were-
wolves. Female werewolves
tend to be characterized
differently than their more
common male counterparts
Often ravenously hedonis-
tic, and drunk with power,
these werewolves appear in
stories that make clear that
‘these femmes fatales, com.
pelled by ‘the pleasures of
the flesh’, in the end get no
Jess than what they deserve
Attention to the lurid cove
ers of such 19203-1930s pulp
magazines as Weird Tales
(Some of which are repro-
duced in the book), and the
werewolf stories therein,
make this one of the bock’s
liveliest chapters. The author
also notes how, in more recent
stories, the close identifica-
tion of femininity with nature
has moved some authors to
construe female werewolves
in a more positive light. Were-
wolf fictions that explicitly
explore issues of femininity
include Angela Carter's ‘The
‘Company of Wolves’ (1979,
partial inspiration for Neil
Jordan's 1984 film, co-written
| by Carter, of the same name)
and the Ginger Snaps films
(various directors, 2000-04).
‘The book keeps the focus on
female werewolves as, in the
final chapter, it turns from hor-
ror to fantasy. Here the book
also veers into postmadern
territory taking as inspira-
tion - for this chapter's title,
Manifesto for Werewolves’, and
central methodological thrust
Donna Haraway's exsay'A Man-
ifesto for Cyborgs’. Haraway
inspires Bourgault du Coudray
to devise an escape from a trap
into which many werewolf
stories written with the most
progressive and revisionist
intentions have fallen, Ener
ed by philosophies that valo-
Tze femininity for its closer
(than male) connection to
nature, some authors of fernale
werewolf stories unwittingly
reinforce the same polarities
~ between nature and culture,
self and other, male and female
= that one finds asserted in
‘much less progressive werewolf
fictions, Bourgault du Coudray
Gescribes authors who, instead,
imagine hybrid subjectivities
that, rather than merely revers-
Ing the old, limiting polarities,
explode these distinctions alto-
gether. She convincingly argues
that the werewolf, particularly
as depicted in fantasy narra-
tives, serves, like Haraway's
cyborg, as a means to explore
alternative, freeing conceptions
of human identity. Fantasy nar-
ratives in recent years depict
werewolves as sympathetic
figures with whom readers
ccan identify. (She also notes
that sympathetic werewolves
ccan be found in stories dat-
ing back to the 1930s) These
werewolves proliferate in
leven greater numbers in such
recently emergent phenom-
na as werewolf role-playing
games and Internet blogs.
Fantasy thought by many
exitics to be politically and
formally rewograde, remains
uunder-theorized compared to
the horror genre. These nega-
tive views, the author argues,
hhave led critics to miss the
transformative potentials
fnherentin the fantasy genre.
One such potential concerns a
‘heightened sense ofthe human
‘connection tothe naeural
world and, with tis, greater
sensitivity to ecological issues.
‘Werewelves in horror stories
are tormented by thei secret
natures, Ones in fantasy stories,
by contrast, are more likely to
embrace their inner wolves and,
writes Bourgault du Coudray,
‘understand the pleasures of
embodiment’ (p. 140) These
characters choose alterna-
tive lifestyles, showing by
example thet itis possible to
break free of older templates
that have been defined along
rigid gender lines. They chal-
lenge the same bifurcated,
masculinized conception of
subjectivity that werewolf
fictions at earlier times have
just as vigorously supported.
‘Sometimes, in the effort
tw istoricize and theorize a
subject that spans centuries,
‘media, forms and genres, the
book glosses too many texts
when it might have singled out
a few and lingered. More close
analysis of individual texts
would have allowed the author
toreflect on meaningful differ
ences; formal ones, for example,
between, say, fms and print,
fiction, This sort of distinction
is something the book does not
consider. More close reading
also would have softened the
weil | 89Book Reviews
book's pervasive tendency to | Also impressive is the range of
see werewolves illustrating vari- | kinds of texts she merges into
ous trends. While some of this | her analysis~ from litera-
is helpful for situating the were- | ture to court cases to films to
wolfin larger contexts, indulg- | intemet usemet groups. Her
ing the impulse too often comes | study spans disciplines, from
at2 price. Here is an example of | anthropology to psychiatry
‘an overused rhetorical strategy:, | to literary criticism, Together,
In the context of such shifts ' | with Brian Frost's essential
in linguistic and authorial stan- | The Essential Guide to Were.
dards, the mingling of romantic | wolfliterature, Bourgault du
language, moral instruction | Coudray’s book should stimu:
and scientific intent in [Sabine] | late further scholarly enquiry
Baring-Gould's monograph on | on a fascinating subject.»
the werewolf can be under-
stood as a direct reflection.
of the transitional period in .
which it was published. (p.30) | Contributor detail
sis as though the werewolf | Robert Spadonihelde’y
figure on its own cannot be Ph.D. from the Universit
peaced to justify the weight of | ofchicago. He tencher
| Bourgoult du Coudray's study. | fim stues ce Case
| When the figure gets swamped | Western Reserve U ver.
| 8 Context, an opportunity is | sity in Ohio, and se the
| missed to explore more fully | Sayin of Uncanny Bod-
j {Re werewolf phenomenon in | ies: The Coming of Sound
allits vividness, complexity | Film and the Origins ofthe
| and idiosyncratic specificity, Horror Genre (University
: Another problem is the of California Press, 2007)
book's unreflective and uneriti-
cal invocation of Slavoj Zizek, | Refer =
He tends to appear at the Endore, G. (1933), The
ends of chapters, where he Werewolf of Paris, New
unfailingly resolves contradic.
tons and suggests solutions
to conundrums elucidated
York: and Rinehart,
Evans, W, (1996 (1973),
‘Monster Movies: A Sexual
in the preceding pages. The Theory’ in B.K. Grant (ed),
application of his ideas seems, | plane of Reason: Essays on
in places, too facile, and the the Horror Fitm, Lanham,
results are less compelling MD and London: Scare-
then, for ‘example, the won-
derful insights yielded by the
tum to Haraway's cyborg,
Still, the book remains a valu-
able contribution to an impor |
tant field of study. Bourgault du I Nersity of Wiscon:
Coudray is a natural ‘explainer, ‘Twitchell, J.B, (1985),
Tippingly, she defines terms as | Dreadful esse vn
Frost, BJ. (2003), The
Essential Guide to Werewolf
Literature, Madison: Uni-
she goes (positivism, ontogeny), | Anatomy of Modern Hor-
bringing along the uniniti- ror, New York and Oxford:
ated without annoying read- | Oxford University Prese
ets already versed in the lingo. :
90] film international issue 36
Saree
f
}
iit
DEBATE
DISCUSS
DISCOVER
PASSION | |
IN MOTION |
(PICTURES)
TOTAL P.23