Professional Documents
Culture Documents
minima S Klein-
Contents
New Aloe Cultivars from the USA, South Africa & Australia. Peter Schedler ........................................................... 2-4
A new book on Aloes. Peter Schedler………. ................................................................................................................ 4
Up-to-date news. ............................................................................................................................................................. 4
Nomina Nova recorded for the Asphodelacea for 2010 in the
Repertorium Plantarum Succulentarum published by the I.O.S. 2011....................................................................... 5-6
A rationalization of names in Haworthia. A list of species with new combinations and new synonyms
M.B. Bayer and J.C. Manning ................................................................................................................................. 7-17
Bruce Bayer’s Haworthia Update No. 7...................................................................................... 17, front & back covers
Free to everyone. International Code of Nomenclature for Cultivated Plants .............................................................. 17
Seed List 2012 .............................................................................................................................................................. 18
Haworthia or The Art of Camouflage. Jean -André Audissou ................................................................................. 19-23
Aloes have long been popular amongst succulent otherwise green leaves. It grows to a maximum 20 cm
growers and have been available from specialist in height and is only partly frost hardy.
growers, succulent interest groups and nurseries Aloe ‘Green Sand’ (formerly ‘Vito’) KG ( Fig. 3 )
throughout Europe and the USA as small indoors A Kelly Griffin hybrid (‘Vito’) which was registered
”window-sill” plants, generally with novel leaf forms by the tissue culture nursery under the name ‘Green
and textures. In recent years breeders, particularly in
the USA, have been striving to create dwarf flowering 2
cultivars so adding colour to their unusual leaf features
(see Miniature A loes by Brian Kemble, A lsterworthia
International, Vol. 5, Issue 2 July 2005, pp. 14-16).
More recently other American succulent breeders
have released a number of new miniature aloes (John
Trager, Kelly Griffin, Karen Zimmerman, etc.) many
through the annual succulent introduction program of
the Huntington Botanical Gardens in San Marino,
California. Huntington’s renowned Desert Garden
holds some 200 of the 589 currently known and
described natural aloe species in the world.
The aim of the ISI (International Succulent
Intr oductions) pr ogr amme is to pr opagate and
distribute new or rare succulents to collectors,
nurseries and institutions. Propagation of new cultivars
is by grafts, offshoots or rooted cuttings produced
under nursery conditions, and in some cases by sterile
in vitro laboratory tissue culture techniques. In line
with sound conservation practices, no field collected
species are sold.
Some of the recent introductions from this and
similar sources in the USA are now available in Europe Sand’ to obtain Plant Breeders’ Rights for commercial
through tissue culture propagation and distribution by sale.* It has a rosette comprising leaves of a soft,
the Netherlands based STC (Succulent Tissue Culture) “furry” and warty texture and appearance, which
company. appeals to many succulent collectors and is
Aloe ‘Christmas Carol’ KG ( Fig. 1 ) characteristic of many of the recent miniature A loe
A small A loe of very striking appearance, from the hybrids coming from this source.
rosette’s central lime green colour to the brilliant red/ * private communication
orange leaf margins. In addition, it has thick, serrated On the outdoors front, two South African breeders,
succulent leaves with raised spines on them. Andy de Wet and Leo Thamm, have each long been
Introduced in 2010 by Rancho Soledad Nurseries and producing a range of larger flowering cultivars for
Xeric Growers, both in California. garden display with the emphasis on colour and
Aloe ‘Guido’ KG ( Fig. 2 )
Another miniature A loe comprising rosettes with 3
white edgings and elongated white markings on the
1
4a
x 300 mm in size.
Aloe ‘Copper Shower’ LT ( Figs. 7)
Another recent release in South Africa, this cultivar
produces a mass of coppery orange flower clusters. Of
medium height, it is a complex hybrid with A .
4b 4c
Note: most of the cultivars mentioned above have been Figs. 5 - 6. Andy de Wet
granted Plant Breeders’ Rights in their country of
origin, which protects them from unauthorised
propagation for sale.
7a 7b
Peter Schedler.
Up-to-date news.
Bruce Bayer has recently reported on FaceBook that he has been asked to submit his species
classification for consideration of inclusion in a revision of The illustrated Handbook of Succulent Plants
and that a DNA study in South Africa is recommending that Haworthia be included in Aloe.
The DNA study deals only with taxa above the rank of species and has to be “peer reviewed” for publication.
Only species named in accordance with the International Code of Botanical Nomenclature will be eligible
for inclusion in a revised Handbook.
J.C. Manning, SANBI, has arranged for Bruce Bayer’s informal names, which do not comply with the
ICBN, to be brought into line with the provisions of that code. The results are on pages 7-17.
With the impending revision of the IOS Succulent Lexicon Among botanical circles, species names carry a great deal of
and a growing awareness that the current classification of the weight. In most instances they imply that individuals that share
genus Haworthia is unnatural, the time is ripe to propose a list a name also share a common ancestry and can interbreed to
of species names that I (MBB) consider worthy of recognition. produce viable seeds. Species with different names will not. Is
My considered opinion is that there are at most about 60 this philosophy applied in Haworthia? The process of
species in Haworthia and that a better and more critical recognising species in botanical circles is generally top-down,
treatment would reduce this still more. This contrasts markedly with genera being first split into component species and the
with Breuer (2010), who lists 368 ‘accepted’ species and species then into subspecies or varieties according to the
reports the even more startling claim that Hayashi recognises particular patterns of variation shown by the constituent
550! Some of this increase is due to the tendency for these populations. This does not seem to apply in Haworthia. Here
authors to treat my varietal names as full species but they have the process is largely bottom-up, with individuals or
also described many new species de novo. They, as well as populations being given names and then shuffled into or
Gerhard Marx, who recently also entered the fray with some among species. This is patently absurd.
very harsh words for me, have my considerable respect for
their talents and enthusiasm, but I am unable to accept all of In general terms, botanical names largely reflect similarities
their proposed taxa in the context of my extensive field whereas horticultural names highlight differences. This is most
knowledge of the genus and my practical experience of evident in the extensive use of varietial names among
patterns of variation among wild populations. horitculturally interested groups. This level is relatively
infrequent in purely botanical circles. The two systems are thus
Species concepts in the genus have always been idiosyncratic, not always congruent and little is to be served by confusing
driven primarily by a propensity to recognize variation over them. We therefore recommend that growers exploit the
similarity and fostered by a general ignorance of the extent of advantages of the International Code of Nomenclature for
intra-population variability in the wild. The recent almost Cultivated Plants, which is aimed at specially selected or
exponential proliferation of names has succeeded in human-altered plants. Here the level of cultivar is appropriately
surrounded the genus with a thicket of nomenclatural twigs employed. We also urge the Editors of popular journals to
that is almost impossible to penetrate and which obscures encourage the use of this system among their contributors. The
rather than illuminates any real understanding of the genus. great advantage of this system is that it removes the
The very appeal of the genus is its almost infinite capacity to hierarchical constraints that are inherent in the Linnaean
vary, and it is a tragedy that they are no longer appreciated for system and that have already created problems with the
their individuality, but are instead pushed into or pulled out of placement of varieties and forms of Haworthia.
taxonomic boxes almost willy-nilly. It is very difficult not to
suspect the motivation behind some of this bedlam. Professional botanist in general together with the majority of
amateur botanists seem intent on reducing or increasing
While we in no way wish to proscribe anybody from species in accordance with the ICBN in the light of their own
expressing their opinions, we issue an urgent plea for restraint. species concepts which results in diverse classifications with
The nomenclatural flood that has all but submerged the genus vastly different numbers of species. In general they pay little
will only be exacerbated by floating additional formal names attention to the ICNCP which does provide for species names
and combinations on the turbulent waters. In fact, we go so far to be recycled and for habitat plants to be given cultivar names
as to recommend a moratorium on the publication of any new under appropriate circumstances e.g. i) species names no
taxa in the genus that are proposed without an extensive survey longer regarded as being justified may be converted to cultivar
of relevant variation patterns in the wild. Scientific journals names when those species are absorbed into another species,
reduce the chances that inadequately researched papers will see ii) for newly discovered population to be absorbed into an
the light of day by sending all submissions to competent existing species but given a cultivar name to recognise any
referees for comment and evaluation. Popular journals that distinctive features that population has, iii) that individual
transgress into the scientific arena by accepting descriptions of clones or groups of clones with horticultural merit can be
new taxa should do the same and the responsibility for this lies selected from a variable population and brought into
firmly with the editors. cultivation with a cultivar name . This would help to reduce the
number of new species names being published and recycle
Every scientific name that enters currency has to be accounted existing species names when they are no longer considered
for by botanists in their lists and publications. To remove them acceptable for scientific purposes.
from circulation requires a separate, formal act for each and
every name. Dealing with the many dubious names in
Haworthia is a taxing task that can be ill afforded. Numerous
invalidly published or illegitimate names have also entered
circulation through non-adherence to the International Code of
Botanical Nomenclature, which aims to regulate scientific
names. This adds to the confusion and to the work.
Printed copies of the ICNCP have been issued at €20 - see www.ishs.org/pub/scripta.htm
The International Society for Cultivated Plants wishes to make the provisions of the ICNCP better known and
understood and has now made the full text of that Code freely available from their web site. All who have any
form of interest in cultivated plants should have a copy. Please take this opportunity to down-load one now.
Cactus Aventures
Catalogue dynamique, constamment actualisé avec de nouvelles espèces.
The catalogue is constantly actualized with new species when they arrive.
Catálogo dinámico, constantemente actualizado con nuevas especies.
Les graines CITES1 ont été récoltées en serre / The CITES1 seeds are artificially propagated
Las semillas CITES1 han sido recolectadas en invernadero, sobre plantas madre.
La liste n'est désormais plus numérotée, ce n'est pas un oubli. Mettez vous-mêmes vos numéros
Now, the list is not numbered. Please add your own - La lista no tiene numerotación, ahora es normal. Ponga su propia
numerotación.
The volume of seeds and the number of orders is so great that Joel Lode needs all the available time to fulfil
orders. He is unable to deal with seed enquires and correspondence. Please do not write to him to ask if any
particular seed is available. Decide what you want from the list, order in list order and pay by credit card.
You will receive all the seed that is available and pay only for the seed supplied.
Harry Mays.
Editor Alsterworthia International
hmays@freenetname.co.uk
cactus-mall.com/alsterworthia/index.html
http://www.audissou.com
3 4
7.
9.
10.
14
13
17
20.