“Obligatio” CIVIL OBLIGATION and NATURAL OBLIGATIO – means tying or binding. OBLIGATION DISTINGUISHED Obligation- means it is a tie or bond Civil Obligation (ART. 1156) recognized by law by virtue of which one is is based on positive law; hence, it is bound in favor of another to render enforceable by court action. something- and this may consist in giving a It give the Creditor or Obligee a right thing, doing a certain act, or not doing a under the law to enforce performance in certain act. the courts of justice. It stresses the duty of Debtor or obligor (he who has the duty of giving, or not ART. 1156 doing) when it speaks of obligation as a – An obligation is a juridical juridical necessity. necessity to give to do or not to do. Natural Obligation is based on natural law; hence, it is not JURIDICAL NECESSITY enforceable by court action. The obligation, however, exist in equity Means that the court may be asked to and moral justice, such that if the debtor order the performance of an obligation if voluntarily performs, the latter may not the debtor refuses to perform it. If an recover what he has given, delivered or obligation cannot be enforced through rendered by the reason there of (ART the courts, it may be disregarded with 1423). impunity. Ex: Under a building contract, PRINCESS bound herself to build a house for WILFA Ex: M (Dr. Payor) is a maker of promissory for note with P (Cr.) as a payee for ₱20,000. ₱ 1,000,000 If M does not pay on due date: Debtor: (Princess) when the construction of Civil Obligation: P can enforce payment by the building is not finished. filing a court of action. Debtor: (Wilfa) after the construction of the If P does not file a court on action against M build. Wilfa is the debtor to princess to pay within 10 yrs. from the due date witch is the after the construction is finished. PRESCRIPTIVE PERIOD (10yrs.) for a written contract. P loses the right to enforce NOTE: DEDTOR can be a CREDITOR when payment by the court of action. the obligation (object or prestation) is done. Natural Obligation: If M voluntarily makes the payment to P although the obligation has prescribe, M will no longer be allowed to recover the payment because in equity and moral justice M still owed P the amount of ₱20,000. FORMS OF OBLIGATION Refers to the manner in which an OBLIGATION, RIGHT, AND WRONG obligation is manifested or incurred. DISTINGUISHED. IN THE FORM OF: OBLIGATION Oral Is the act or performance which the law Writing will enforce. Partly Oral RIGHT Partly writing 1. GENERAL RULE! On the other hand, is the power which a - The law does not require any form in person has under the law, to demand obligation arising from the contracts for from another any prestation. their validity or binding force (ART. 1356) WRONG 2. Obligation arising from other sources (cause of action), accordance to its legal (ART. 1157) do not have any form at all. meaning, is an act or omission of one party in violation of the legal right or ART.1157 rights (i.e recognize by law ) of another. In law, the term injury is also used to Obligation arise from: Law, refer to the wrongful violation of the Contracts, Quasi- contracts, Acts or legal right. omissions punished by law and Quasi delicts. ESSENTIAL ELEMENTS OF LEGAL WRONG OR INJURY ARE: LEGAL RIGHT - in favor of a person that demand the performance. - ( Creditor/ Plaintiff)
CORRELATIVE LEGAL OBLIGATION
- on the part of a person to respect or not to violate said right. - ( Debtor/ Defendant)
An act or omission by the latter in
violation of said right with resulting injury or damage to the former. NOTE: A WRONG OR CAUSE OF ACTION ONLY ARISES AT THE MOMENT A RIGHT HAS BEEN TRANSGRESSED OR VIOLATED. Ex: Under a building contract, X bound himself to build a house for Y for REQUISITES OF OBLIGATION ₱1,000,000 ACTIVE SUBJECT (Creditor or obligee ) PASSIVE SUBJECT (Debtor or obligor ) LEGAL RIGHT PRESTATION (Object) EFFICIENT CAUSE (juridical or legal : Y has a legal right to have his house tie) constructed by X : X has a legal right to be paid the agreed compensation provided the house built according to the terms and condition of the ACTIVE SUBJECT (Creditor or obligee) contract. The party who has the right to demand obligation. CORRELATIVE LEGAL OBLIGATION PASSIVE SUBJECT (Debtor or obligor) : X has the correlative legal obligation to build the house of Y. The party who is obliged to perform the obligation. : Y has the correlative legal obligation to paid X the agreed compensation based on the PRESTATION (Object) contract agreed. The object or subject matter of the NOTE: obligation. It may consist of giving, doing or not doing something. -THE FAILURE OF EITHER PARTY TO COMPLY WITH SUCH TERMS AND EFFICIENT CAUSE (Juridical tie or Legal CONDITIONS GIVES THE OTHER A CAUSE tie) OF ACTION FOR THE ENFORCEMENT OF The vinculum or the legal or juridical tie HIS RIGHT AND OR RECOVERY OF which binds the parties to an obligation. INDEMNITY FOR THE LOSS OR DAMAGE The efficient cause of an obligation may CAUSED TO HIM FOR THE VIOLATION OF be any of five sources of obligation. HIS RIGHT.
Ex: Under a building contract, X bound
himself to build a house for Y for ₱ 1,000,000. Active Subject: y Passive Subject: x Prestation: Building of the house Efficient Cause: the agreement of the contract, is the source of the juridical tie.
Supposed: the building is constructed.
Active subject: x Passive Subject: y
KINDS OF OBLIGATION ACCORDING TO
UNILATERAL & BILATERAL THE SUBJECT MATTER. Unilateral From the viewpoint of the subject matter, obligation may be Only one party is required to perform a particular conduct. REAL OBLIGATION PERSONAL OBLIGATION Bilateral o Positive personal obligation Each party is required to perform a o Negative personal obligation particular conduct. Ex: D is obliged to give ₱50, 000 with REAL OBLIGATION interest at 12% per annum on Dec. 31, Obligation to give 2015 pursuant to a contract of loan. Is that in which the subject matter is a The obligation here is UNILATERAL, thing which the obligor(dr.) must deliver only one party (D) is required to perform to the obligee(cr.) a particular conduct. Ex: X(seller) Binds himself to deliver a Because only D is the only one to piano to Y(buyer). give and there is no reciprocal. D is obliged to transport the goods of C from Manila to Cebu, and C is obliged PERSONAL OBLIGATION to pay D ₱1,000,000 as transport costs, Obligation to do or not to do under a contract of carriage. In which the subject matter is an act to The obligation here is BILATERAL, done or not to be done. each party is required to perform a particular conduct. o POSITIVE PERSONAL OBLIGATION As regards the with the giving of Obligation to do or to render ₱50,000 with 12% interest service. (ART 1167) Active Subject (C) and the Ex. X binds himself to repair a piano Passive Subject (D) of Y.
As regards the Payment of transport
costs witch the Prestation o NEGATIVE PERSONAL OBLIGATION Active Subject is (D) Obligation not to do Passive Subject is (C) (includes obligation “not to give”) (ART 1168) The obligation to support one’s family (Art. 291) Ex. X obliged not to build a fence on a certain portion of his lot in favor of Y The national Internal Revenue Code who is way over said lot. which provides for the payment of taxes. The Anti- Mendicancy law which prohibits the giving of alms to beggars. SOURCES OF OBLIGATION (ART 1157) ART.1157 CONTRACTS Obligation arise from: Law, ART 1305 Contracts, Quasi- contracts, Acts or - A contract is a meeting of the minds omissions punished by law and Quasi between two persons whereby binds delicts. himself with respect to the other, to give something or to render some service. LAW ART 1159 CONTRACTS - Obligation arising from contracts have QUASI-CONTRACT the force of law between the contracting o Negotiorum Gestio parties and should be complied with a o Sulotio Indebiti good faith. ACTS OR OMMISSIONS PUNISHED BY LAW When they arise from the stipulation of QUASI-DELICTS or (Torts) the parties (Art. 1306) ART. 1306 LAW - The contracting parties may establish (According to SANCHEZ ROMAN) means a such stipulation, clauses, terms and rule of conduct, just and obligatory, laid down conditions as they may deem by legitimate authority for a common convenient, provided they are not observance and the benefit. contrary to law, morals, good customs, When they imposed by law itself. public order, or public policy.
ART 1158 Ex: The obligation to repay a loan or
indebtedness by virtue of an Obligations derived from law are not agreement. presumed. A contract of lease which provides Only those expressly determined in for the payment of rental by lessee. this code or in special laws are demandable and shall be regulated by A contract of sale which requires the the precepts of the law has not been seller to deliver the thing sold and foreseen, by the provision of the book of the buyer to pay the price. obligation. Ex. The obligation to pay taxes: necessary and useful expense. Ex: D and C are the owners of adjacent vegetables farms. One day D was not around to tend to his farm. When C notice that D has not been around for almost a week, he himself cultivated the soil and placed fertilizer on it, watered the plants, removed the weeds and wilted QUASI-CONTRACT leaves. C incurred necessary and ART. 2142 useful expenses in the process
- They refer to a certain lawful, D must reimburse C for such expenses.
voluntary administration of property, Otherwise, he will be unjustly enriching business or affairs of another without himself at C’s expense the consent or authority. - It creates the obligation to reimburse the gestor for necessary and useful . expenses. o Solutio Indebiti - Juridical relation which is There is no consent but the same created when something is supplied by fiction of law unlike received when there is no contract itself that there is a meeting right to demand it and it was of the minds or consent or the parties duly delivered through entered into a formal agreement. mistake. There are unjust enrichment “when a - This refers to the payment by person unjustly retains a benefit to mistake of an obligation which the loss of another, or when a person was not due when paid. retains money or property of another - It creates the obligation to against the fundamental principles of return the payment. (ART. justice, equity and against 2154) conscience” (ART.1160) treats of obligation Ex: D the payee of the check for arising from quasi-contract or ₱5,000,000, cashes it with the drawee contracts implied by law. bank, but the teller gives him ₱6,000,000 by mistake. D duty bound to return the excess o Negotiorum Gestio ₱1,000,000 to the bank. - This refers to voluntary administration of the property, Otherwise D will be unjustly enriching business or affairs of another himself at the bank’s expense. without his consent or Ex: D owes C ₱1,000; if D paid T authority. believing that T was authorized to - It creates the obligation to receive a payment for C. reimburse the gestor for The obligation to return on the part of T arises. If D paid C ₱2,000 by mistake. C must return the excess of ₱1,000 COMPLIANCE IN GOOD FAITH -means compliance or performance in accordance with the stipulation or terms of the contract or agreement. -Sincerity and honesty must be observed to prevent one party from taking unfair advantage over the other. -Non-compliance by a party with his legitimate obligations after receiving the benefit of a contract would constitute unjust enrichment on his part. Ex: If S agrees to sell his house to sell his house ACTS OR OMMISSION PUNISHABLE BY QUASI-DELICTS (TORTS) LAW Also known as ART. 1161 “torts” or “Culpa Aquiliana” - When they arise from civil liability which is the ART. 2176 consequence of a criminal offense. - When they arise from damage caused to another ART.100, REVISED PENAL CODE through an act or omission, - These are crimes or there are being fault or felonies. The commission negligence, but no of a crime makes the contractual relation exist offender civilly reliable. between parties. ART. 104, R.P.C To a Quasi-Delicts case to prosper, the compliant must established: - Such civil liability includes restitution, reparation of the Damage to compliant damage caused, and Negligence, by act or omission of the indemnification of defendant or by some person for whose consequential damages. act the defendant must, respond, was guilty: Ex: The connection or cause and effect The obligation of the thief to return the between such negligent and damages. car stolen by him; The negligent act or omission must be the proximate cause of injury The duty of a killer to indemnify the heirs of his victim. Ex: -If a person was cleaning his window, causes a flower pot to fall through his negligence there by injuring someone passing by, the former is liable for damages to the latter. (ART. 2193) -the obligation of the possessor of the animal to pay for the damage which it may have caused (ART.2183) LEGAL OBLIGATION (ART.1168)- refers to legal obligation or Contractual Obligation obligation arising from law. They are not Below article speaks of contractual presumed because they considered a obligation or obligation arising from burden upon the obligor. They are the contracts or voluntary agreements. It exception, not a rule. To be presupposes that the contract entered demandable, they must be clearly set into are valid and enforceable. forth in the law, (i.e., civil code or special laws) ART. 1159 ART. 1158 Obligations arising from contracts have the force of law between the Obligations derived from law are not contracting parties and should be presumed. complied with in good faith. Only those expressly determined in CONTRACT this code or in special laws are demandable and shall be regulated by -is a meeting of the minds between two the precepts of the law has not been persons whereby one binds himself, with foreseen, by the provision of the book of respect to the other, to give something or to obligation. render some service (ART.1305) Under the Article 1158, special laws refer to BINDING FORCE all other laws not contained in the Civil Code. -Obligations arising from contracts have Example: Corporation Code, Negotiable force the law between contracting parties Instrument Law, National Internal Revenue Code, Revised Penal Code, Labor Code & etc. -They have the binding effect of obligations imposed by laws. -However, that contract is superior to the law. As a source of enforceable obligation, contract must be valid and it cannot be valid if it is against the law. REQUIREMENT OF A VALID CONTRACT -A contract is valid if it is not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order and public policy. (ART.1318) -It is invalid or void if it is contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order, or public policy (ART. 1306). NOTE: -IN THE EYES OF THE LAW, VOID CONTRACT DOES NOT EXIST. (ART. 1409) -NO OBLIGATION WILL ARISE. -A CONTRACT MAY BE VALID BUT CANNOT BE ENFORCE. THIS IS TRUE IN THE CASE OF UNENFORCEIBLE CONTRACTS (ART 1317, 1403) BREACH OF CONTRACT -A contract may be breach or violated by partly in whole part or in part. -A breach of contract takes place when a partly fails or refuses to comply, without legal reason or justification, with his obligation under the contract as promised.