You are on page 1of 5

Protection of Metals, Vol. 38, No. 1, 2002, pp. 17–21. Translated from Zashchita Metallov, Vol. 38, No.

1, 2002, pp. 22–26.


Original Russian Text Copyright © 2002 by Andreeva, Bulgakova, Kuznetsov, Sokolova.

Adsorption of Monoethanolamine on Iron


from a Carbon Dioxide Atmosphere
N. P. Andreeva, R. A. Bulgakova, Yu. I. Kuznetsov, and N. P. Sokolova
Institute of Physical Chemistry, Russian Academy of Sciences,
Leninskii pr. 31, Moscow, 117915 Russia
Received June 20, 2001

Abstract—The adsorption of carbon dioxide on Armco iron at a pressure of 1 atm was revealed and studied by
ellipsometry and IR spectroscopy. The conditions of the formation of adsorbed VCI layers were found to be
important for steel protection. The surface preliminarily exposed to an atmosphere of CO2 is covered with a thin
(about 2 nm) adsorbed layer which significantly changes its properties. The layers of VCI adsorbed from a CO2
atmosphere differ only slightly in thickness from those formed in air. However, the adhesion of the former is
better, as evidenced by its lower Kd.

Lower amines and amino alcohols are well known the specimen center and the cell bottom was 30 mm.
as neutralizing agents for steel protection from carbon The cell cover was equipped with a manometer and
dioxide corrosion in power generation and in oil and ground openings for gas inlet.
gas industry [1, 2]. However, now it has been shown
that they contribute to metal protection not only by reg- Changes in the ellipsometric angles during the
ulating pH of the medium, but also by their adsorption experiments, δ∆ = ∆ – ∆0 and δψ = ψ – ψ0 (where ∆0 and
[3]. Although a great number of such compounds are ψ0 refer to the initial specimen surface), were attributed
known to be volatile corrosion inhibitors (VCIs) [4], to the adsorption or desorption of the test compound
their adsorption on iron from a vapor phase is studied alone. As a rule, δ∆ < 0 when a film grows. For small
inadequately [5]. For this reason, we investigated the film thicknesses (d < 10 nm), the thickness is a linear
adsorption and desorption of a known VCI, namely, function of ∆ [6]: d = – α(∆ – ∆0) = – αδ∆, where α is a
monoethanolamine (MEA), on iron from an atmo- proportionality factor. The δψ values can be both posi-
sphere of carbon dioxide at p CO2 = 1 atm. tive and negative. The thickness d and the complex
refractive index N = n – ik (n and k are its real and imag-
inary parts, respectively) of the adsorbed film were
EXPERIMENTAL determined using the McCrackin program. The initial
data were the medium refractive index n0 , the angle of
The adsorption–desorption kinetics of VCI was light incidence (68.5°), the radiation source wavelength
studied ellipsometrically. The ∆ and ψ angles charac- (540 nm), and Ns of the base (2.7 – 2.9i).
terizing a surface under study were measured on a Gart-
ner manual ellipsometer. A halogen lamp with a Three sets of experiments were carried out: (1) the
540-nm filter was used as a radiation source. The ellip- adsorption and desorption of VCI in air, (2) the adsorp-
someter scheme included a polarizer, a compensator, a tion and desorption of VCI in an atmosphere of carbon
surface, and an analyzer. The ∆ and ψ angles were dioxide, and (3) the same as in (2) with preliminary
determined using a zero scheme, i.e., the polarizer and exposure of an iron specimen to a CO2 atmosphere for
the analyzer were rotated alternately to minimize the 14 days.
intensity on the recording device. The ∆ and ψ values To determine a desorbed portion of VCI in an atmo-
were calculated from the angles of the polarizer and the sphere of carbon dioxide, the cell was opened and, after
analyzer in a suppression position. removal of the drop of the inhibitor, closed again and
An Armco iron specimen was ground, polished with filled with CO2 to p CO2 = 1 atm.
alumina, kept in a dry atmosphere for two days to sta-
bilize the oxide film, and placed in a hermetically The Armco iron plate surface exposed to the corro-
sealed Teflon cell for ellipsometric measurements. The sive medium was examined by diffuse reflection IR
specimen surface was oriented perpendicular to the cell spectroscopy. Spectra were recorded on a Perkin-Elmer
bottom containing a drop of VCI. The distance between 1720 Fourier spectrometer equipped with a Harrick

0033-1732/02/3801-0017$27.00 © 2002 MAIK “Nauka /Interperiodica”


18 ANDREEVA et al.

+δ∆, deg the absence of VCI (Fig. 1, curve 3). Carbon dioxide
adsorbs in such a way for nearly two days, whereupon
δ∆ begins to decrease.
4 To interpret the experimental data, the specific fea-
tures of the adsorption of carbon dioxide on iron should
2 be considered. The adsorption on a polycrystalline iron
film was studied by volumetric and resistometric tech-
niques [9]. Along with measuring work function data at
3 T = 196, 273, 300, and 370 K. They revealed a low con-
tent of adsorbed CO2 . Molecular adsorption of carbon
dioxide occurs only at low temperatures (196 K), while
0 at T ≥ 273 K adsorption involves dissociation. It was
10 20 30 assumed in [10] that CO2 reacts with iron to give the
τ, days – –
following species: CO2 + CO 2 , CO 2 , CO + O, and C + O.

The CO 2 ion is detected on polycrystalline iron films
even at 120 K, while CO2 dissociates into CO + O at
1
180 K. The vibrational frequencies for carbon dioxide
chemisorbed on different faces of an iron single crystal
–4 are reported in [11]. Bands at 1232 and 1634 cm–1 (car-
– δ∆, deg bonates) are observed on Fe(100) face and bands at
800, 1064/1160, and 1360/1600 cm–1 on Fe(111).
Fig. 1. Changes in the ellipsometric ∆ angle during the Using Fourier IR spectroscopy, we compared the
adsorption and desorption of MEA on Armco iron (1) in air, interactions of CO2 and MEA with the air-oxidized iron
(2) in an atmosphere of CO2 , and (3) during the adsorption
of CO2 on a scattered iron film. surface under different conditions. Thus, the spectrum
of an iron specimen exposed to an atmosphere of CO2
for eight days shows, along with interference bands
attachment for diffuse reflection in a range of 400– caused by a small film thickness, bands from adsorbed
4000 cm–1. CO2 molecules (2213 cm–1) and from the carbonate ion
coordinated in a mono- and bidentate manner (Fig. 2b,
curve 4) [11, 12].
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Comparing spectra of MEA itself (Fig. 2a, curve 1)
The kinetics of the growth of an adsorbed film can with those of the iron surface having adsorbed MEA,
be determined from changes in ∆ (Fig. 1). Earlier, such one can easily see that the adsorption changes both
measurements revealed that MEA adsorbs on iron from stretching and deformation vibrations in MEA and
air to form a 2.5 to 3-nm film during the first two to gives rise to a new adsorption band at 2700–2000 cm–1
three days; its final thickness reaches 6 nm [5]. For characteristic of amino salts [13]. When MEA adsorbs
comparison purpose, we also determined the film thick- from a carbon dioxide atmosphere, the spectrum con-
nesses for other, more effective VCIs, namely, tains a number of weak bands at 1740–1680 cm–1,
IFKhAN-70 and amine A (3 and 6 nm, respectively) which can be due to the formation of carbamates
[7, 8]. When VCIs were removed from the cell, the (1739–1719, 1728–1722, 1722–1705, and 1691–
films always became thinner, suggesting the desorption 1683 cm–1) (Fig. 2a, curve 3). However, the adsorption
of VCI from specimens. The ability of VCI to adsorb of MEA on a specimen preexposed to an atmosphere of
irreversibly can be judged from the desorption factor pure CO2 changes this spectral range only slightly, i.e.,
Kd, which is the fraction of the desorbed amount of VCI no carbamates are apparently formed.
(in percent). Thus, in air, Kd was found to be ≈80% for On the other hand, the band of adsorbed CO2 mole-
MEA, 30% for IFKhAN-70, and 10% for amine A. cules, which is observed after an 8-day contact with the
In an atmosphere of CO2 , the adsorption of these gas, disappears once such a specimen interacts with
VCIs changes. As can be illustrated with MEA (Fig. 1), MEA in a carbon dioxide atmosphere. Its spectrum
δ∆, in the initial segment of the curve increases rather shows, along with bands characteristic of adsorbed
than decreases with time. Insofar as the same effect was MEA, new bands at 2140 and 1880 cm–1. Although they
also observed in the adsorption of IFKhAN-70 or can be interpreted ambiguously, one can suppose that
amine A from a carbon dioxide atmosphere, it can obvi- the band at 2140 cm–1 is related to physically adsorbed
ously be attributed to a specific interaction of CO2 with molecules of carbon monoxide, while the band at
the iron surface. Indeed, such an unusual dependence of 1880 cm–1 is either to a carbonyl complex on the elec-
∆ on time (δ∆ > 0) for film growth was also obtained in trode surface or to an organic carbonate yielding from

PROTECTION OF METALS Vol. 38 No. 1 2002


ADSORPTION OF MONOETHANOLAMINE ON IRON 19

(a)

3
2140.05 1644.75

2929.97 2873.94

1641.95
2

2128.85

1600.00

4000 3600 2800 2000 1600 1200 800 400


ν, cm –1
(b) 4
1015.38

2212.88
1655.94

1913.28
3165.26

1888.11
2145.65
3

4000.0 3600 3200 2800 2400 2000 1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400
ν, cm –1

Fig. 2. IR spectra of (1) MEA, (2) iron in an atmosphere of MEA, (3) iron in an atmosphere of both MEA and CO2 , (4) iron pre-
liminarily exposed to an atmosphere of CO2 for eight days, and (5) iron preliminarily exposed to an atmosphere of CO2 for ten days
and then to an atmosphere of MEA.

the reaction of MEA with CO2 [12]. This assumption is iron specimen. A model in which carbon dioxide is
also supported by the previously mentioned formation assumed to form a homogeneous adsorbed layer with a
of CO in the reaction of CO2 with metallic iron [10, 11]. real refractive index 0.2 < n < 4.8 does not describe the
experimental dependence of δ∆ on the exposure time.
Our spectroscopic data offer a clearer view of how The change in δ∆ could be influenced by a variation of
the adsorption of CO2 changes the surface state of an the medium refractive index n0 as the cell is filled with

PROTECTION OF METALS Vol. 38 No. 1 2002


20 ANDREEVA et al.

+ δ∆, deg this model, our ellipsometric measurements revealed


that the thickness of an adsorbed film of CO2 on natu-
2 rally oxidized iron is ≈2 nm.
2 The thicknesses of adsorbed VCI layers were calcu-
3 lated using a model of multilayer film. The refractive
indices of N-containing VCIs usually fall in the range
of 1.5 to 1.6 [16]. A light beam comes from a medium
5 with n0 , passes through homogeneous layers, and
1 reflects against the base: n0/N(inhibitor)/N(carbonate
1
complexes)/N(CO2)/N(air-formed oxide)/N(base). The
thickness of the VCI film in an atmosphere of carbon
14 dioxide reaches 5 nm for MEA, 3 to 70 for IFKhAN-70,
and 7.5 nm for amine A.
VCIs adsorbed from an atmosphere of CO2 adhere
0 0.2 0.4 more strongly than those formed in air. The desorption
+δψ, deg factor Kd was found to be ≈14% for MEA, 21% for
IFKhAN-70, and 7% for amine A, suggesting their
Fig. 3. Changes in the ellipsometric ∆ and ψ angles of the
iron surface in an atmosphere of CO2 . The experimental enhanced adsorption on the iron surface with pread-
curve is given in solid line. The points (䊉) and (䊊) refer to sorbed CO2 .
theoretical curves for Nf = 2.2 – 3.8i and Nf = 1.7 – 0.4i,
respectively. The numbers at the points indicate the days
when the corresponding measurements were performed. CONCLUSIONS
(1) The conditions of the formation of adsorbed
CO2 . However, its value (1.0029, 1.0043, and 1.0083 at MEA (and other VCIs) layers can play an important
p CO2 = 1.00, 14.84, and 28.58 atm, respectively [14]) is part in steel protection from carbon dioxide corrosion.
According to the IR data, the iron surface preliminarily
virtually independent of the pressure, approximating to exposed to CO2 provides an enhanced adsorption of
the refractive index of air (1.000). Such changes in n0 VCI.
are too little to affect δ∆ and cannot cause, by them-
selves, the reverse of its dependence in time. (2) An increase in the angle phase shift during the
adsorption of CO2 on iron cannot be described by the
In connection with this, attention should be given to model of non-absorbing homogeneous layer, but the
a study [15], in which the specific adsorption of carbon problem is solved by using an optical model of a multi-
monoxide on ruthenium was explained by a complex layer film with complex refractive indices. According
refractive index of the adsorbed layer. We also consid- to this model, the thickness of an adsorbed layer equals
ered the possibility of using such an interpretation of ≈2 nm.
ellipsometric data for the adsorption of CO2 and MEA. (3) The VCI layers adsorbed from an atmosphere of
For this purpose, the experimental and theoretical CO2 differ insignificantly in thickness from those
adsorption curves of CO2 were drawn in δ∆ vs. δψ formed in air, but the former adhere to the surface more
coordinates (Fig. 3). firmly.
With time as a parameter, the experimental curve is
given in solid line (the numbers at the points denote the REFERENCES
days of the corresponding measurements) and shows a
1. Trace, W., Mater. Perform., 1981, vol. 20, May. R. 46.
breaks point indicating that the film changes its refrac-
tive index at this δψ value. Such changes are often 2. CO2 Corrosion Control in Oil and Gas Production, Ker-
attributed to structural changes in films. The best theo- mani M.V. and Smith, L.M., Eds., London: Inst. of Mate-
rials, 1997.
retical fits are obtained on the assumption that CO2
adsorbs on the surface to give a film with Nf = 2.2 – 3.8i 3. Kuznetsov, Yu.I., Andreev, N.N., and Ibatullin, K.A.,
Zashch. Met., 1999, vol. 35, no. 6, p. 586.
(see Fig. 3, dotted curve to the left of the breaks point).
This film is covered by surface carbonate complexes 4. Rozenfel’d, I.L. and Persiantseva, V.P., Ingibitory atmos-
with Nf = 1.7 – 0.4i [15], which is shown by the theo- fernoi korrozii (Atmospheric Corrosion Inhibitors),
Moscow: Nauka, 1985.
retical curve to the right of the inflection point.
5. Andreev, N.N., Andreeva, N.P., and Vartapetyan, R.Sh.,
Thus, the supposition of a complex refractive index Zashch. Met., 1997, vol. 33, no. 5, p. 470.
of an adsorbed film provides a good agreement between 6. Gorshkov, M.M., Ellipsometriya (Ellipsometry), Mos-
a theoretical model and experimental data. Based on cow: Sov. Radio, 1974.

PROTECTION OF METALS Vol. 38 No. 1 2002


ADSORPTION OF MONOETHANOLAMINE ON IRON 21

7. Kuznetsov, Yu.I., Andreev, N.N., Ibatullin, K.A., and icheskikh i koordinatsionnykh soedinenii, Moscow: Mir,
Oleinik, S.V., Zashch. Met., 2000, vol. 36, no. 3, p. 266. 1966, p. 274.
8. Kuznetsov, Yu.I., Andreev, N.N., Ibatullin, K.A., and 13. Bellamy, L.J., The Infra-Red Spectra of Complex Mole-
Oleinik, S.V., Zashch. Met., 2002, vol. 38 (in press). cules, London: Methuen, 1958. Translated under the title
9. Dziembay, R. and Wedler, G., Surf. Sci., 1983, vol. 134, Infrakrasnye spektry slozhnykh molekul, Moscow: Inos-
no. 1, p. 283. trannaya Literatura, 1963.
10. Bauer, R., Behner, H., Borgman, D., et al., J. Vac. Sci. 14. Born, M., Optik, Berlin: Springer, 1933. Translated
Technol., 1987, vol. 5, no. 4, part II, p. 1110. under the title Optika, Kiev: Otd. Nauchn. Tekh. Inform.,
11. Freund, H.J. and Roberts, M.W., Surf. Sci. Rep., 1996, 1937, p. 454.
vol. 25, p. 225. 15. Carroll, J., Madey, T.E., Melmed, A.J., and Sand-
12. Nakamoto, K., Infrared Spectra of Inorganic and Coor- strom, D.R., Surf. Sci., 1980, vol. 96, p. 508.
dination Compounds, New York: Wiley, 1963. Trans- 16. Spravochnik khimika (Handbook of Chemist), Lenin-
lated under the title Infrakrasnye spektry neorgan- grad: Khimiya, 1971, vol. 2, p. 62.

PROTECTION OF METALS Vol. 38 No. 1 2002

You might also like