Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1.) Crespo v. Mogul, G.R. No. L-53373, (June 30, 1987), 235 PHIL 465-477
1.) Crespo v. Mogul, G.R. No. L-53373, (June 30, 1987), 235 PHIL 465-477
01
123456575623 859575
4
756
44793
4 76
6944793
4 5
44793
4 7647
3
35
3956239
9
427
4 8
746
23!4536
73
789:;<=
>??@2?AB77=7
CD?18E9!*)+"+"F)&'!
G#H
I@?J>?C>9E
46637
911K1C@1KD1@1KL9;576
69
J645?9KIEEDKIEIEE@89
4
35
MN5
81K>@91JOK8K9
K?9!&)#*F)F+#H
>@1L19PQR
$)!"##%)!&"#)!"F!+$"#!)#)!"#!S$)+$)&!+$)!+&"T!U%&+!U+"FV!F!!,+"F!+!"#,"##!!U&","FT!U#)!W"T)!-!+$)
X&G"FU"T!Y"#UT!%*F!"F#+&%U+"F#!W!+$)!()U&)+&!W!Z%#+"U)!+!S$,!+$)!U#)!S#!)T)G+)!W&!&)G")S'!,!&)W%#)
+!V&F+!+$)!,+"F!F!"F#"#+!F!+$)!&&"VF,)F+!F!+&"T!F!+$)!,)&"+#H
[F!5*&"T!1\'!1/]]!5##"#+F+!Y"#UT!X&U)#!^H!)!_T!S"+$!+$)!**>!W!+$)!X&G"FU"T!Y"#UT!W"T)!F!"FW&,+"F
W&!)#+W!V"F#+!`&"!YTH!6&)#*1!"F!+$)!6"&U%"+!6&","FT!6%&+!W!a%U)F!6"+!S$"U$!S#!Ub)+)!#!6&","FT
6#)!3H!666cdef0!gh%)iFj!k]]H!l$)F!+$)!U#)!S#!#)+!W&!&&"V,)F+!+$)!UU%#)!W"T)!!,+"F!+!)W)&
&&"VF,)F+!F!+$)!V&%F!+$+!+$)&)!S#!!*)F"FV!*)+"+"F!W&!&)G")S!W"T)!S"+$!+$)!()U&)+&!W!Z%#+"U)!W!+$)
&)#T%+"F!W!+$)![WW"U)!W!+$)!X&G"FU"T!Y"#UT!W&!+$)!W"T"FV!W!+$)!"F0W&,+"FH!cF!F!&)&!W!5%V%#+!1'!1/]]'!+$)
*&)#""FV!m%V)'!n"#!nF&'!a))V&"!aH!`V%T'!)F")!+$)!,+"FH!!5!,+"F!W&!&)UF#")&+"F!W!+$)!&)&!S#
)F")!"F!+$)!&)&!W!5%V%#+!f'!1/]]!-%+!+$)!&&o"VF,)F+!S#!)W)&&)!+!5%V%#+!1\'!1/]]!+!WW&!+",)!W&
*)+"+"F)&!+!)T)G+)!+$)!,++)&!+!+$)!**)TT+)!U%&+H!
5!*)+"+"F!W&!U)&+"&&"!F!*&$"-"+"F!S"+$!*&)&!W&!!*&)T","F&!S& "+!W!"Fm%FU+"F!S#!W"T)!-!+$)!UU%#)!"F!+$)
6%&+!W!5**)T#!+$+!S#!Ub)+)!#!65e_HpH!(X!3H!.q/]\H!r!cF!F!&)&!W!5%V%#+!1]'!1/]]!+$)!6%&+!W
5**)Tf#!&)#+&"F)!Z%V)!`V%T!W&,!*&U))"FV!S"+$!+$)!&&"VF,)F+!W!+$)!UU%#)!%F+"T!W%&+$)&!&)&#!W!+$)
6%&+H!!cF!!U,,)F+!+$+!S#!W"T)!-!+$)!(T"U"+&!_)F)&T!$)!&)U,,)F)!+$+!+$)!*)+"+"F!-)!V"G)F!%)!U%&#)H
q![F!`!1f'!1/]\!!)U"#"F!S#!&)F)&)!-!+$)!6%&+!W!5**)T#!V&F+"FV!+$)!S&"+!F!*)&*)+%TT!&)#+&"F"FV!+$)
m%V)!W&,!)FW&U"FV!$"#!+$&)+!+!U,*)T!+$)!&&]"VF,)F+!W!+$)!UU%#)!"F!+$)!U#)!%F+"T!+$)!s)*&+,)F+!W!Z%#+"U)
#$TT!$G)!W"FTT!&)#TG)!+$)!*)+"+"F!W&!&)G")SH!
[F!`&U$!00'!1/]\!+$)F!tF)&#)U&)+&!W!Z%#+"U)'!nFH6+T"F!`U&"V'!Z&H'!&)#TG"FV!+$)!*)+"+"F!W&!&)G")S
&)G)&#)!+$)!&)#T%+"F!W!+$)![WW"U)!W!+$)!X&\G"FU"T!Y"#UT!F!"&)U+)!+$)!W"#UT!+!,G)!W&!",,)"+)!"#,"##T
W!+$)!"FW&,+"F!W"T)!V"F#+!+$)!UU%#)H!!5!,+"F!+!"#,"##!W&!"F#%WW"U")FU!W!)G")FU)!S#!W"T)!-!+$)
X&G"FU"T!Y"#UT!+)!5*&"T!1.'!1/]\!S"+$!+$)!+&"T!U%&+'!/!++U$"FV!+$)&)+!!U*!W!+$)!T)++)&!W!tF)&#)U&1).+&
`U&"V'!Z&H!cF!F!&)&!W!5%V%#+!0'!1/]\!+$)!*&"G+)!*&#)U%+&!S#!V"G)F!+",)!+!W"T)!F!**#"+"F!+$)&)+H![F
3G),-)&!0r'!1/]\!+$)!Z%V)!)F")!+$)!,+"F!F!#)+!+$)!&&"VF",)F+!#++"FVu
[!p!s!2!p
Y&!&)#T%+"F!"#!!,+"F!+!"#,"##!+$"#!&#)!W"T)!-!+$)!*&U%+"FV!W"#UT!*&),"#)!F!"F#%WW"U")FU!W
)G")FU)'!#!#%VV)#+)!-!+$)!tF)&#)U&)+&!W!Z%#+"U)'!)G")F+!W&,!5FF)v!w5w!W!+$)!,+"F!S$)&)"F'
,FV!+$)&!+$"FV#'!+$)!Y"#UT!"#!%&V)!+!,G)!W&!"#,"##T!W&!+$)!&)#F!+$+!+$)!U$)Ub!"FGTG)!$G"FV
-))F!"##%)!W&!+$)!*,)F+!W!!*&)e)v"#+"FV!-T"V+"F!+$)!n-"T"+!W!+$)!&S)&!UF!FT!-)!U"G"T!F!F+
U&","FTH
$)!,+"Fk#!+$&%#+!-)"FV!+!"F%U)!+$"#!6%&+!+!&)#TG)!+$)!"FFU)FU)!W!+$)!UU%#)!F!)G")FU)!F+!-)W&)
"+!-%+!F!+$+!%U)!-)W&)!+$)!tF)&#)U&)+&!W!Z%#+"U)'!!,++)&!+$+!F+!FT!"#&)V&#!+$)
&)x%"&),)F+#!W!%)!*&U)##!-%+!T#!)&)#!+$)!6%&+k#!"F)*)F)FU)!F!"F+)V&"+'!+$)!,+"F!"#!UF#")&)
#!S"+$%+!,)&"+!F!+$)&)W&)!$)&)-!s23c2sH
012324532689
9
9
96
9
99
999
6
8
9
!
"553232!
#9$9%
989%&9
9
6&
%%$'
&9
9$9
&
98
'
&
/
%(
9&
9
%9
9)$
*&&98
'%9
9%)*+
,!3!-!".+! 50$
/16
9
%9
'$9%
9)$
*&&98
9
9
99%
9
9$9%$
8$
9
%9
9)$
!12%95
49
/36
9)$
*&&98%9%
9&9
%8
9%
9
9
%9
0$
/16! *
9%9
%%989%
9$9%'%99%
98$
49
$
6!3
199
&9
959'%%9'89%$9%'9
9&9
9
&
%%99
959
9%%9
%96
9&%9
6$%99&9
&9
$88969%
9
9
&
99%'
9
9
%
8&9
9
%
896%98
9
89%
58%%898
9
%979
6
%9
9&%9
0$%9
%
9%96%%98
98
&9
9
&$
98
58!
2
98$
866
9"9%5
)$
'
$
5%$9$
9
9&9
99$
9%
9
9&%9
9
9&9
6
89
%
%6'
9:;%
9!2
9
9
89%
9"8
,99
89
99%
9&9
959%$9$
96
99
$!
.
5
9
9&%9
$$9889%
9&8
99
%9&
9$9
9&9
9&9
9%9%!2
9
98$
49
$
366
9"9%5
)$
9859%
9
9
9)$
<=>?@=A!2
9
98$
49
$
/766
9)$
<=>?@=A
9859%
59
%$9$
9
9&9
!
.9
9
%&
5
9
9&%9
89%
9
9&9
59
9'89
9"8
,99
889%89
89$
9
9
9
9%9
9
9&%9
)$
*&&989
959
9%%
9&%9
0$%99
%9
9%
%
9
!
2
%8&
&89
8
9
9
99%&8
889
&
9$
9%$%9
9%
9
%
8
98! #9
$
8
%9&9%$&
9
$%%
9
98!19
89
9&8
688'
'
&
99
9%
99%9%&
6
%
' 9
9
995%99&6$9
9
8
9$8
9
$9%9%
989%$
!#9
9
&8
9
8&
9$
$%9
9%
9
%
8
98
&
959
8$
$$%9%&
9$
&
5
9&9
! 2
9
889%
9
&8
!/.
9$
9
$%9
9&'9
59
9%
98'6
859
9$
$
8
9
%$
&
9$
&9
'6
%
995%9/9
9959%
9&8
6
9'
9$8
9
9%'
96$
%
9
9! #95999$88
9898%$
&
9$
9'9
9
//59
99959%
995%99%%$9%
$9
9
8BCDE@>F@ADG
9!
2
$
9%$
&
98
59
/1
98%9
9
9
99H
99&$9
9
'$8%'
9&
9$
9!#9)$
9
9
9'
98%
9
%
8
9
8&
9$
!2
&
$%9
959&9
89
)$
&98
98
&
9$
9
&
99%
88/
4
9%
69%
995%99
989%$&
$9
5
! -9
9
9)$
&'9
%9
98
&
9$
9
89
'
9
&9
%
969
'$8%
9
9
9'
98%
9
%
8
8
&
9$
!/3#$68'
9%/78
99
$995%99$
%
6%)$
99
9
!#98
9+59
99%$99$9
859
9%8$8%
9
9+59
/
'9
9
9%99%
9
$8
9
9
89%9%
989%$
!2859'9
'99
96$%9'%%
59
9%
98
'
/
%%6
9
'99
98%
99%9%&
9%99%
6
9
948$8%
88&
958!
5
9
9
%69
9
/6$
6&
98
8
'
&
9$9%
9$
9
8&
9$
9H9&
99H
999'9
9
99
9)$
%
9
%9
81%
6$
9
&
959
9$9
9
98'&&
959%5%
59
9
!
1'959
6
9
98
&
9$
'
$
8
8!#99$69
9
&&
58
9&
58
8
99
9&
9$
999%
99895
9%
959'
9"9
9
0$
9'
9&'9
6%
959
9
9
&
98!
)99$9
8
9"9
9
0$
19%
9
%
9
9989%)$
9
'96
989%)$
!
#98&8
)$
9
8
1/!#9)$
9
99$
96$
%
59
996'
9$
9
%%9
9
9
99! 09
9
98
9&8
'
9
9
9$9%$9%
9
8$
%
9$9%9
9
58$
8
$
9%1198
9)$
'%$8
9
9%6
9)$
9
99$
9%6$
%
59
9&9
9
$9%!
#9&
98
59
%$
9%
98
9&$
&9%9
9
'9
9
BCDE@>F@ADG9
9H
'
9&
9$
9$9%
9
9%$&
98
9
9&
&9
$
!
2
$
659
9%6
98%
9
9
8
9$9%)$
!
"$8%
98%
&
&9
%$
959
996
$
96
9&9
9)$
0123562671869
368217
8662333
6998670069323
6272
1956215033693
3
61838883673
63238163
33
627
23
6!"#92786339636806
$
63
68837807262
195669718383%763
6726
9869&566581
33183
$
366892233
627'0&662
19568683
68263
6863682
19569986226983
6
7296833
6183% (
6&)17323
33
6733
618301233083
6215233
8
323
6771269
*83
68
33
6+66391687622$
*
63
683
6771269
95668869839$
63
683$291638662335&3
6278866$
5&3
6,678638&-12376$
6865&03392022$22150336933
6183%3
61833
66.6872632
9278630&833
603896&3986)1863
33
6383
6068328766983
6868
96368033
6726
(
62$682206
(
6863
62788267138260$232663
371237629693
676228&32671863
67733
668277126956863
61832
(
12%236
233
6
234562
:89683
686839217
2313$
6865&3
63
6,678638&-12376$
866$693
673
3
6270&56928689695&3
6387183%3
6,678638&-123762
19%282873756%86880
636836338866$86803
6733
627%$
63
67038803
2
869&56669183
(
6033682
1956636386&83
696368033
6183
,>><?;<;?
A5BCDEFFBGEHBID#DF"JKLDEEDEBMNDEEDOBPEQBREOBSEBCD#"FJBS!##BT!FBUEVDFNJF!
RJENDBPPQB"JF"EQ
WDD6FXDDRQPQBNJJXFJ5ENQ
YZZ[\Z[]^
_&803%6.36.;`
'a''%<
b6.36.;`
8ca8_%<
6.?36.;`
8b%5EQ
6.;36.;`
8a_c9%5EQ
'6.=36.`
_cd%5EQ
*6.e36.;`
__ca__9%<
86./36.;`
__da_bd%5EQ
96.:36.;`
_ca_b%218
d6.-36.;`
_a_d%5EQ
_c6.f36.;`
_c%5EQ
__
6.g36.;`
__a_b%5EQ
01
344567899
1
9
0
0
0
344563954899
11
0
3445699
0
0
9
10
0!
"5#4$%500&'5$%5&(4)"5#4
$%500&0*+
$%54(,4%#5-5
59%5.
/%-5,01"($30!
0+041%5.
(&2344#5'%
+
0*4
"
.
5.0'%
0
159%5.
"95!
'%
+0859%5.
6778*!8'6+
89%5.
5#%01'%
*859%5
.
510
$
6+*0!5#
00*
10:7.
$5.%%0
$
6011!3710*
+
119%5.
5#%
1"5#404-1&$%5001&'5$%5&(85-54%5#55*008"5#40$%5001&'5
0*+
$%54(,4%#5-5
159%5.
5;%%+'%
1
1
3
.4#%2#%&:4.
%%550'%
*0859%5.
45-0
$
5
61111<%810
0*!1"($3!+
159%5.
518474.
#%40
$
601
0!;80*0*
+
1!59%5.
<,%5
61!15.
1+0**859%5.
3747'%
0+1
1+59%5.
45-
1*=)47"47.
(8&;4%0'%
0001
,87.
2544-51'%
+!844.58&'5'%9945.
(82#%&>514(8
0
$
5
60+
1<%800*0
1B55.
:51
'%
1
84
"
.
6,47#0'%
*85%(1.
;A5'
108
"5#40$%500$%5&(4)"5#40%$%5000*+
$%54(,4%#5-5
10(
<
"
018(474
4
"
.
:51'%
3
.4#%2#%&:4.
%%55C
59%5.
9@%
+?
0
1+
0%,4.
"4-74@840"($300
!59%5.
:5%5!"($30D0*!E
+4
"
.
59@%-51'%
184
"
.
0%%57!'%
1+*859%5.
B544-51*'%
!184
"
.
6@%1!'%
+184
"
.
2544-51'%
*859%5.
/5%51!!'%
01
F'56)9'%A5#35%%46)24-4