Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Building the New Cambodia: Educational Destruction and Construction under the Khmer Rouge,
1975-1979
Author(s): Thomas Clayton
Source: History of Education Quarterly, Vol. 38, No. 1 (Spring, 1998), pp. 1-16
Published by: History of Education Society
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/369662
Accessed: 30-11-2015 17:16 UTC
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/
info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content
in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.
For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
History of Education Society and Wiley are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to History of
Education Quarterly.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
the New Cambodia: Educational
Building
Destruction and Construction under the
Khmer 1975-1979
Rouge,
Thomas Clayton
HistoryofEducation
Quarterly Vol. 38 No. 1 Spring1998
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
2 History of Education Quarterly
sFor discussions, see David Ayres, "Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge Leaping Forward
into the Past" (draft chapter for Ph.D. diss., University of Sydney, 1996); Vickery, Cambodia,
1915-1982.
?Vickery,Cambodia,1915-1982, 187.
7Governmentstatisticsfrom the People's Republic of Kampuchea,cited by Grant Cur?
tis, Cambodia:A CountryProfik(Stockholm, 1989), 6. The communistPeople's Republicof Kam?
puchea, established in 1979, was extremely hostile toward the Khmer Rouge.
8Mysliwiec,Punishingthe Poor, 1.
9Kimmo Kiljunen, Kampuchea:Decadeofthe Genocide(London, 1984), 8.
10Kiljunen,Kampuchea,8.
"Chandler, History,211.
"Kiljunen, Kampuchea,17.
BReragee account cited by Chandler, Kiernan, and Muy Hong Lim, Early Phasesof
Liberation,9. Indeed, childrenwere not spared.For refiigee accounts of such incidents, see Ken-
neth Quinn, "The Origins and Development of Radical Cambodian Communism" (Ph.D.
diss., University of Maryland, 1982).
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Building the New Cambodia 3
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
4 History of Education Quarterly
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Building the New Cambodia 5
While Khieu Samphan's dissertation is far from a revolutionary traet, its advo-
cacy of Cambodia's indigenous economic development as a means of alter-
ing the country's peripheral and exploited status in the world capitalist
system has considerable resonance in Democratic Kampuchea's policies of
self-reliance and international isolationism.28
Unfortunately for the Cambodian people, Khmer Rouge develop?
ment plans were almost total failures. As refugee accounts attest, antici-
pated agricultural yields were not realized, industrialization did not occur,
and international self-sufficiency was achieved only briefly and only at the
cost of mass starvation.29 Indeed, many Cambodians characterize the 7 Jan-
uary 1979 Vietnamese invasion, which ended Democratic Kampuchea, as
a "liberation" from the Khmer Rouge.30 Nevertheless, it is clear that dur?
ing his tenure in power Pol Pot intended to accomplish more than the
destruction of the old society. No matter now reprehensible we may find
his methods and objectives, it is important to realize that Pol Pot's vision
for Cambodia also included the construction of a new society. Education
under the Khmer Rouge was integrated with, and can provide a case study
of, this cycle of destruction and construction.
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
6 History of Education Quarterly
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Building the New Cambodia 7
cational facilities which were not demolished were refitted for other pur-
poses. As Phnom Penh itself was remade into a Democratic Kampuchea
administrative center for perhaps 50,000 party members, cadres, and sup?
port staff, the Royal University was turned into a farm.38 The Khmer-Sovi-
et Friendship Higher Technical Institute in Phnom Penh, a 1964 gift from
the Soviet Union,39 was turned into the Khmer Rouge's Central Political
School40; this school also served as a prison for Cambodians returning from
abroad after the communist victory, many of whom were ultimately killed.41
The infamous Tuol Sleng Prison in Phnom Penh in which tens of thousands
of Cambodians were tortured and killed in Khmer Rouge purges was for?
merly a high school.42
Educators and potential educators were intentionally targeted by the
Khmer Rouge. Scholars suggest several reasons for the systematic elimina-
tion of students, teachers, and professors. Perhaps most simply, these indi-
viduals were products of feudal-capitalist institutions and were thus seen as
barriers to progress in the new Cambodia. As Quinn comments, by "elimi-
nating the intellectual class, the Khmer communists were apparently hop-
ing to ensure that the direction ofthe new social order would be irreversible."43
Chandler suggests further that students, teachers, and professors were killed
because they, as beneficiaries of the previous social order, were generally
hostile to the changes sought by the Khmer Rouge.44 A punitive explana-
tion was offered by Pol Pot himself in 1977. Echoing Marx, the Khmer
Rouge leader argued that teachers, in the "pay ofthe oppressor classes," had
actively obscured the inequities in the old social system and had, in the pro?
cess, turned worker-peasants away from revolution toward acceptance of
exploitation.45
Whether because of future threats or past sins, Cambodia's students,
teachers, and professors were killed in large numbers in Democratic Kam?
puchea. According to the Ministry of Education ofthe State of Cambodia,
"75% ofthe teaching force, 96% of tertiary students and 67% of all [ele-
Vice Minister of Health, State of Cambodia (Phnom Penh, 15 July 1992). On the destruction
of educational equipment, see my interviews with Chan Nareth, Vice Director, Chamcar
Duang AgriculturalInstitute (Phnom Penh, 23 July 1992); Seng Lim Neou; Om Nhieu Sarak,
Director, Khmer-Soviet Friendship Higher Technical Institute (Phnom Penh, 17June 1992).
38Barronand Paul, Peacewith Horror.
39Myinterview with Om Nhieu Sarak.
'^Timothy Carney, "The Organization of Power," in Cambodia 1975-1978: Ren?
dezvous with Death; Kiernan, The Pol Pot Regime.
41Myinterview with Om Nhieu Sarak,Director ofthe Institute in 1992. The Director
described the Institute during the Khmer Rouge regime as a prison, not an educational facility.
42Chandler,BrotherNumber One.
43Quinn,"The Pattern and Scope," 188.
^Chandler, History.
45PolPot's 27 September 1977 speech, cited by Quinn, "The Pattern and Scope," 188.
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
8 History of Education Quarterly
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Building the New Cambodia 9
"See Chandler, Kiernan, and Chanthou Boua, Pol Pot Plans the Future.
549April 1976 Khmer Rouge radio broadcast by Khieu Samphan, cited by Ponchaud,
CambodiaYearZero, 122; Vickery, Cambodia,1915-1982, 171.
"For discussions of primary education based on refugee accounts, see Ayres, "Pol Pot
and the Khmer Rouge"; Peter Gyallay-Pap, "Reclaiming a Shattered Past: Education for the
Displaced Khmer in Thailand,"Journal of RefugeeStudies2 (no. 2, 1989): 257-275; Kiernan,
The Pol Pot Regime; Orla Quinlan, "Education Reform in Cambodia" (Master's thesis, Uni?
versity of London, 1992); Stuart-Fox and Ung Bunheang, TheMurderousRevolution-, Vickery,
Cambodia,1915-1982.
56"PreliminaryExplanation Before Reading the [1976 Four-Year] Plan," in Chandler,
Kiernan, and Chanthou Boua, Pol Pot Plans the Future, 159.
"Refugee accounts cited by Roel Burgler, The Eyesofthe Pineapple:RevolutionaryIntel-
lectualsand Terrorin DemocraticKampuchea(Saarbriicken, 1990); Gyallay-Pap, "Reclaiming a
Shattered Past";Quinlan, "Education Reform in Cambodia";Vickery, Cambodia,1915-1982.
58Kiernan,"The Survivalof Cambodia'sEthnic Minorities";Kiernanand Chanthou Boua,
Peasantsand Politics.Curiously, the 1976 Four-YearPlan calls for the organization of "print-
ing in foreign languages, especially English, starting from mid-1977 onwards"("The Party's
Four-YearPlan," 114). As there is ample evidence that bi- or multilingualism was severely dis-
couraged for the Cambodian population at large, it is likely that English language skills were
intended to support the international publication of government statements.
59"PreliminaryExplanation Before Reading the [1976 Four-Year] Plan," in Chandler,
Kiernan, and Chanthou Boua, Pol Pot Plans the Future, 159.
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
10 History of Education Quarterly
cratic Kampuchean schools; the only surviving examples are a geography text
and an arithmetic text, and these books have not been analyzed.60
In spite ofthe professed focus on educational fundamentals, academic
achievement was very low in primary education, as most children were
reported to have been illiterate when the Khmer Rouge were overthrown
in 1979.61 Part of this academic failure can probably be explained by the
poor quality of teaching in Democratic Kampuchean schools. Though the
ranks ofthe Khmer Rouge included former teachers who had joined the rev?
olution before 1975, most teachers in Democratic Kampuchea were cho-
sen from among the worker-peasant population on the basis of their
"revolutionary attitude"62 and "often [had] minimal education . . . and no
real teaching experience."63
Academic failure may also have been related to the significant atten?
tion given in schools to the singing of revolutionary songs, identified by
the Khmer Rouge as an ideal method of teaching students "good models
. . . of socialist revolution and [for] the building of socialism"64 and thus
integrated with the second main goal of education, that of "cultivating good
political consciousness."65 According to several refugee accounts, students
spent the bulk of school time learning songs which "praised the sacrifices
ofthe revolutionary fighters; exalted the national cause; exhorted ideolog-
ical vigilance; and incited the [listener-singer] to class vengeance."66 In "The
Red Flag," for instance, children were enjoined to continue the revolution
until not a "single reactionary imperialist [was left alive]," and in "The
Beauty of Kampuchea" students were reminded of "Khmer children strug-
gling [for social change] until blood flows out to cover the ground."67
A final goal of Khmer Rouge education was to gain knowledge of
"technology [by means of] work and practice."68 Though again there was great
regional variation, students attended school only in the morning, after
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Building the New Cambodia 11
[Ojur children in the rural areas have ... very useful knowledge.... They had
practdcallymasterednature.They know the differentstrainsof rice like they know
their own pockets. . . . Only this should be called natural science because this
type of knowledge is closely connected with the reality of the nation, with the
ideas of nationalism, production, national construction, and national defense.71
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
12 History of Education Quarterly
came to fruition, the new system of post-primary education was again to have
employed affirmative action policies intended to increase the educational
participation of previously marginalized worker-peasants.78
Beyond education at the national level, some Cambodians may have
received specialized training abroad. A1976 document indicated that around
20 "combatants" were to be sent to China to learn how to make gunpow-
der,79 and in a speech on 27 September 1978 Pol Pot stated that several
Cambodians had gone to China to study petroleum refining.80 Very little
is known about these international educational ventures; in his discussion
of gunpowder training, for instance, Kiernan acknowledges that there is
no evidence that Cambodian combatants were in fact sent to China for this
purpose.81
Finally, in Democratic Kampuchea there existed programs of politi?
cal education for the general population, training for Khmer Rouge cadres
and party members, and at least some reeducation for the bourgeoisie of pre?
vious regimes. In the cooperatives, political education meetings were held
frequently, sometimes as often as every day and sometimes on the final day
of Democratic Kampuchea's 10-day work week.82 In these meetings, Khmer
Rouge cadres sought to improve the production and morale of worker-
peasants, urging people "to be self-reliant, to work harder, [and] to be hum-
ble."83 At least upon occasion, such admonitions were integrated with
revolutionary class analyses and critiques. A Cambodian refugee recon-
78Vickery,Cambodia,1915-1982.
79"30March 1976 Decisions ofthe Central Committee on a Variety of Questions," in
Chandler, Kiernan, and Chanthou Boua, Pol Pot Plans the Future, 6.
80Citedby Burgler, The Eyesofthe Pineapple,83.
81Footnoteto the translation of "30 March 1976 Decisions ofthe Central Committee
on a Variety of Questions," in Chandler,Kiernan, and Chanthou Boua, Pol PotPlanstheFuture.
Indeed, it is difficult to understand why a regime as dedicated to self-sufflciency and inde-
pendence as the Khmer Rouge would send students overseas.Though they did maintain diplo-
matic relations with China and North Korea and did accept assistance from these countries
(see Kiernan, ThePol Pot Regime-,Chandler, BrotherNumberOne;Stephen Heder, "The Kam?
puchean-Vietnamese Conflict," in The Third IndochinaConflict,ed. David Elliott [Boulder,
1981]: 21-67), the Khmer Rouge perceived all forms of international aid as threatening to
Cambodian sovereignty. In his dissertation, for instance, Khieu Samphan had argued that
international assistance, including educational assistance, had the effect of drawing recipient
countries into the economic spheres of influence of donor countries (Khieu Samphan, Cam?
bodia'sEconomyand IndustrialDevelopment).Khmer Rouge planners similarlycautioned against
internationalaid in the Four-YearPlan, statingthat "withoutfail"such assistancewould be accom-
panied by the imposition of "political conditions" ("The Party's Four-Year Plan," 47). It may
be that the Khmer Rouge, forced to choose between independent nondevelopment and devel?
opment with the possibility of externalconditions, were willing to gamble with their sovereign?
ty in order to gain certain technical knowledge, including that related to gunpowder and
petroleum production.
82Fordiscussions, see Burgler, The Eyesofthe Pineapple;Kiljunen, Kampuchea.
83Accountgiven by Cambodian refugee Peang Sophi, cited by Chandler, Kiernan, and
Muy Hong Lim, Early Phasesof Liberation,11.
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Building the New Cambodia 13
structed one such presentation from memory after escaping from Demo?
cratic Kampuchea. "In the old days," the refugee remembered a Khmer
Rouge cadre saying,
the big people told us we had independence. What kind of independence was
that?What had we built? Well, they build an Independence Monument. Where
did they build it? They built it in the capital. Who saw the thing? The big peo?
ple's children. Did country people see it? No they didn't; they only saw pho-
tos. The big people's children went in and out [of Cambodia], going to this
country, that country, and they came back, to control our kind of people. And
now what do we do in contrast?We don't build Independence Monuments like
that. Instead, by lifting up embankments, digging irrigation canals, and so on,
the children of Cambodia can see [that] they build their own independence.84
84PeangSophi, cited by Chandler, Kiernan, and Muy Hong Lim, EarlyPhasesof Liber?
ation, 11; emphases in the original.
852June 1976 Khmer Rouge radio broadcast cited by Ponchaud, CambodiaYearZero,
99. Political meetings were referred to as "miting," a loan word from the Vietnamese "mit-
tinh" (Chandler, Kiernan, and Muy Hong Lim, EarlyPhasesof Liberation).Chandler, Kiernan,
and Muy Hong Lim comment that such borrowing was "[i]ronic...for a regime that ha[d] so
ruthlesslyprunedforeign words from its vocabulary"{EarlyPhasesofLiberation,10). Highlightdng
the significance of the changes that the Khmer Rouge sought for Cambodian society, lin-
guistically and otherwise, Ponchaud (Cambodia Year Zero) explains that the use of words
such as "miting" and "fasciste" was made necessary because there were no equivalents in
Khmer for these concepts.
86Carney,"The Organization of Power," 87.
87Carney,"The Organization of Power," 87.
88LawrencePicq, BeyondtheHorizon:Five Yearswith theKhmerRouge(New York, 1989),
37. Lawrence Picq was the only Westerner to live through the Khmer Rouge regime.
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
14 History of Education Quarterly
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Building the New Cambodia 15
96Forother examples, see quotes from Khmer Rouge documents in this article; Khmer
Rouge documentscollected by Chandler,Kiernan,and ChanthouBoua in PolPotPlanstheFuture;
and Khmer Rouge radio broadcasts, a number of which are included in Jackson, "The Ideol?
ogy of Total Revolution," and Ponchaud, CambodiaYearZero.
97Burgler,The Eyesofthe Pineapple,83; Carney, "The Organization of Power," 88.
98EkSam Ol, "The Situation of Higher and Technical Education," 2.
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
16 History of Education Quarterly
dians contact with people and ideas in other countries and, thus, to isolate
the country more fully from the rest ofthe world. Paradoxically, as in much
of the socialist world, an important new component of education was pro-
ductive work, itself conceived as integral to national development.
As they passed through Democratic Kampuchea's new schools, train?
ing programs, and reeducation camps, Cambodians were indeed influenced,
or molded, or "constructed" for participation in the new Cambodia. While
some may have become genuinely infused with revolutionary spirit, hatred
of class-based oppression, and willingness and ability to work for national
agricultural development and Cambodia's subsequent freedom from inter?
national economic subordination, others may simply have become con-
vinced of the efficacy of adopting such postures. A great many others,
particularly those who had possessed power, status, and knowledge in the
previous regime, apparently proved to be unreeducable or "unconstructible."
Judged by the Khmer Rouge to be unprepared for the exigencies of the
new society, these Cambodians were killed.
Democratic Kampuchea itself expired on 7 January 1979 when, in
response to repeated attacks across the border, the Vietnamese invaded
Cambodia, drove the Khmer Rouge into Thailand, and established the
People's Republic of Kampuchea. Fortunately for the people of Cambodia,
the cycle of destruction and construction set in motion by the Khmer Rouge
in 1975 was halted with the change of regimes. Even before the invasion,
however, another social change cycle was signaled for Cambodia. In their
first international statement, dated 2 December 1978, the Cambodian exiles
who would become the leaders of the People's Republic of Kampuchea
dedicated themselves to "abolishing the reactionary culture of the Pol Pot
clique" and to reestablishing such social institutions as markets, religion, and
personal liberty.99 Hinting toward the important role that education was
to play in the process of social change in the 1980s, Cambodia's new lead?
ers additionally pledged to "liquidate illiteracy, to develop a national edu?
cational system, and to construct establishments of general, higher, and
professional education."100
This content downloaded from 200.16.16.13 on Mon, 30 Nov 2015 17:16:52 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions