Professional Documents
Culture Documents
applications
Part 1: Operating strategy and modification of the power diagram
Abstract— Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESSs) are more and more attention in the current global energy
gaining more and more attention in the current global energy landscape, thanks to some peculiar characteristics such as the
landscape, thanks to some peculiar characteristics such as the versatility, modularity, scalability, fast response time, etc..
versatility, modularity, scalability, fast response time, etc.. BESSs BESSs can advantageously be used in the ancillary services
can advantageously be used in the ancillary services market, in market, in order to provide all the services necessary to ensure
order to provide all the services necessary to ensure the stability the stability and the reliability of the power system.
and the reliability of the power system. Among other Furthermore, battery costs are coming down and performance
applications, BESS can also be used to shift electricity demand are improving, although several problems remain to be solved,
from on-peak to off-peak periods, also contributing to relieve
such as safety issues, regulatory barriers and utility acceptance
peak demand charges, thus ensuring a saving for the customers.
The BESS is charged when the electricity prices are the lowest
[7]. Although their significant advantages, BESSs are still too
(during the night) and discharged when the prices are the expensive, and their deployment in different countries is
highest (during the daily hours), contemporary achieving a mainly driven by favorable policies and supporting measures,
leveling of the daily usage pattern. This paper is the first of a two- especially at the household level [8, 9]. As a consequence of
part series, aiming to evaluate the economic feasibility of their favorable performances and decreasing costs, battery
electrochemical storage systems in peak load shaving projects are being deployed across countries, for different
applications. The sizing and the operating strategy of the BESS applications [10]. Custom devices need always to be used to
are defined, so as to obtain, at the same time, the flattest daily ensure a proper interconnection and a reliable control system,
usage pattern and the maximum benefit for the customer. A case according to national technical specifications [11-14].
study is analyzed, showing the modification of the power diagram
when the BESS is added. The simulation results show a customer The excess of electricity consumption during peak periods
daily power profile perfectly leveled in shoulder seasons and a turns out to be expensive for transmission system operators
peak shaving effect in all other days. (TSO) and distribution system operators (DSO), affecting the
stability and the reliability of the electricity grid. Among other
Keywords— battery energy storage; peak load shaving; TOU applications, BESS can also be used to shift electricity demand
tariffs; peak demand charges; case study from on-peak to off-peak periods (energy arbitrage), also
contributing to relieve peak demand charges, thus ensuring a
I. INTRODUCTION saving for the customers. The customer electricity bill is
The deployment of renewable energies in the power grid normally composed by two main components, an energy
has seen a strong uptake in the last decades, mainly driven by charge component (€/kWh), proportional to the consumed
advantageous support policies implemented around the world energy, and a capacity charge component (€/kW), proportional
[1-4]. Especially photovoltaic (PV) and wind energy to the maximum power draw. Peak demand charges are
experienced the strongest growth among all renewable energy typically calculated based on the maximum demand during a
sources (RESs) and this expansion is expected to continue in given month. Thus, if the BESS is operated so as to smooth the
the future [5]. However, the integration of increasing shares of customer load diagram (peak shaving effect), peak demand
RES energy into the power system creates challenges to the charges will be reduced.
stability and reliability of the electricity system [6]. Indeed, Energy arbitrage consists in buying inexpensive energy at
production and consumption of electricity need to be in balance off-peak hours, through battery charging, and reselling it back
at all times, and the fluctuating nature of the energy produced to the grid a few hours later, at a higher price, through battery
by RESs makes this task difficult, creating stability issues to discharging. If the difference between on-peak and off-peak
the power system. Stationary energy storage systems (ESSs) prices, added to the saving from the reduction of peak demand
can advantageously be used in the modern electricity networks, charges is enough to compensate for the BESS losses and for
providing the necessary flexibility to the power system. Among the cost of the storage system (initial investment cost, O&M
ESSs, battery energy storage systems (BESSs) are gaining cost, replacement cost), the use of the battery will be profitable
Shoulder seasons
2000 Summer BESS operational parameters
Winter
1500 Capacity (kWh) 3700
1500 Summer
1000
1000
500
500
0
0 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 Hours (h)
Hours (h)
700
400 Winter
Summer 200
200
0 Shoulder seasons
-300
-200 (b) Winter
Summer
-400 (b)
-800
-600 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 Hours (h)
Hours (h)
Fig. 5. (a) Facility power diagram when the storage is operated; (b)
Fig. 3. (a) Facility power diagram when the storage is operated; (b) corresponding BESS power profile, on Saturday.
corresponding BESS power profile, for each of the reference seasonal periods,
on weekdays. 2000 Shoulder seasons
Power diagram (kW) Winter
As can be observed in Fig. 3a, the facility power diagram in 1500 (a) Summer
a shoulder season day is now completely leveled, as a results of 1000
the proposed sizing and operating strategy of the BESS.
Otherwise, a peak shaving effect is produced in all summer and 500
winter season days. The corresponding BESS power profiles
0
are shown in Fig. 3b. Positive values of the BESS power
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23
profile mean energy stored, negative values energy discharged. Hours (h)
Fig. 3b shows that the BESS is operated at variable power,
within its energy and power constraints. 400
BESS power profile (kW)
200
Fig. 4 shows the customer hourly power diagrams with and
0
without BESS and the BESS power profile, in a weekday
-200
summer day, under the above mentioned sizing conditions. As
-400
Fig. 4 clearly shows, the BESS is charged from 7:00 p.m. to Shoulder seasons
-600
6:00 a.m. and discharged from 8:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.. The (b) Winter
-800
BESS operates at variable charging and discharging power. Summer
-1000
The energy absorbed from the BESS during the charging phase 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23
is greater than that supplied to the grid during the discharging, Hours (h)
because of the roundtrip losses. The BESS parameters and cost
components for each electrochemical technology are reported Fig. 6. (a) Facility power diagram when storage is added and the billing
in the part 2 of the two-part series. period is chosen according to the hourly facility power profile; (b)
corresponding BESS power profile.
The daily power profiles on Saturday and the corresponding
BESS power profiles are reported in Fig. 5a, b, respectively. As it is clearly shown in Fig. 5a, the power profile is not
perfectly flattened on Saturday shoulder seasons. This is
4000 Facility power diagram without BESS because the billing periods are not correlated to the customer
3500
3000
BESS power profile daily consumption, on Saturday. Indeed, the BESS would need
Power profile (kW)