Professional Documents
Culture Documents
on
I, Barnini Chatterjee, student of BBA (5-2018-2021) hereby declare that the project titled “THE
Management Amity School of Business, Amity University Kolkata, West Bengal, in partial
fulfillment of requirement for the award of the degree of Bachelor of Business Administration,
has not been previously formed the basis for the award of any degree, diploma or other similar
title or recognition.
The Author attests that permission has been obtained for the use of any copyrighted material
appearing in the Dissertation / Project report other than brief excerpts requiring only proper
Date: __________________
BARNINI CHATTERJEE
A90606418023
BBA 5 (2018-21)
1
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that Ms.BARNINI CHATTERJEE, student of BBA has carried out work
presented in the project of the Term paper entitle “THE IMPACT ON INDIA’S
_________________________
Department of MANAGEMENT
ASBK, Kolkata.
2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The satisfaction that accompanies the successful completion of any task would be incomplete
without the mention of people whose ceaseless cooperation made it possible, whose constant
guidance and encouragement crown all efforts with success. I would like to thank Prof
me the opportunity to undertake this project. I would like to thank my faculty guide MR.
SUVOBROTO BANERJEE who is the biggest driving force behind my successful completion
of the project. He has always been there to solve any query of mine and also guided me in the
right direction regarding the project. Without his help and inspiration, I would not have been able
to complete the project. Also I would like to thank my batch mates who guided me, helped me
BARNINI CHATTERJEE
3
ABSTRACT
Jio Platforms’ (a subsidiary of Reliance Industries) fund-raising blitz has raked up c. $20.2bn over
the past three months by divesting nearly 33% stake to an eclectic mix of 13 investors, including
Facebook, Silver Lakes, Vista, General Atlantic, ADIA, and the latest to jump on the bandwagon
- Google. But the biggest and perhaps the most significant investment remains the very first one
announced on April 22nd - the one by social media giant Facebook. Facebook’s $5.7bn
investment in Jio for 9.99% stake makes the social media giant the largest minority shareholder in
the Indian telecom sector and the biggest foreign direct investment (FDI) in India’s tech space.
The deal also marks the largest investment for a minority stake by a tech company in the world.
Needless to say, Facebook sees a lot of potential in this collaboration. India is the world’s largest
user base for Facebook. It is also the largest market for Facebook-backed messaging service,
WhatsApp, with over 400m monthly active users. And with 80m users, India is second only to the
US in terms of the number of users for its photo-sharing app, Instagram. Reliance Jio is the largest
telecom operator in India, both by subscriber base (369.93m users as of January 2020) as well as
revenue market share. And in due course, the “confluence of forces with common interests” could
create a behemoth. Facebook’s investment worth 5.7 billion dollars in Jio Platforms was the
largest deal in the first half of 2020. It highlighted India’s maturing e-commerce space and
attracted the interest of several global investors who then jumped on the bandwagon.
4
CONTENTS
DECLARATION……………………………………………………………………………………………1
CERTIFICATE…...………………………………………………………………………………………...2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT……………………………………………………..……………………….…..3
Abstract…………………………………………………………………………………………………….4
Introduction………………………………………………………………………....…………………6 - 10
Conclusion………………………………………………………………………………………………...55
Reference…………………………………………………………………………………………..56 - 57
5
INTRODUCTION
E-commerce (electronic commerce) is the activity of electronically buying or selling of products on online
services or over the Internet. Electronic commerce draws on technologies such as mobile commerce, electronic
funds transfer, supply chain management, Internet marketing, online transaction processing, electronic data
interchange (EDI), inventory management systems, and automated data collection systems. E-commerce is in
turn driven by the technological advances of the semiconductor industry, and is the largest sector of the
electronics industry.
Modern electronic commerce typically uses the World Wide Web for at least one part of the transaction's life
cycle although it may also use other technologies such as e-mail. Typical e-commerce transactions include the
purchase of online books (such as Amazon) and music purchases (music download in the form of digital
distribution such as iTunes Store), and to a lesser extent, customized/personalized online liquor store inventory
services. There are three areas of e-commerce: online retailing, electronic markets, and online auctions.
● Online shopping for retail sales direct to consumers via Web sites and mobile apps, and
● Gathering and using demographic data through web contacts and social media
6
● Marketing to prospective and established customers by e-mail or fax (for example, with
newsletters)
Closures:
Though the sector has witnessed tremendous growth and is expected to grow, many e-commerce
ventures have faced tremendous pressure to ensure cash flows. But it has not worked out for all
the e-commerce websites. Many of them like Dhingana, IndiaPlaza.in, eBay-India, Rock.in,
Seventy MM amongst others had to close down or change their business models to survive. In
March 2020, the Government of India restricted online sales of all goods except for critical items
including food, pharmaceuticals, and medical equipment. Many Indian startups including Urban
Company, BookMyShow, Pepperfry and Nykaa, which do not feature in the government’s list of
Collaborations:
In light of the Covid-19 pandemic, the Indian government issued a directive to stop delivery of
collaborate and sell essential goods. For e.g. Myntra partnered with Wildcraft to sell protective
face masks. McCoy Mart partnered with Rossari Biotech Ltd to sell hand sanitizers. Flipkart
partnered with Uber for last mile delivery of essentials to its customers.
Infrastructure:
7
There are many hosting companies working in India, some of which offer SaaS for hosting web
stores. India has got its own version of Cyber Monday known as Great Online Shopping Festival
which started in December 2012, when Google India partnered with e-commerce companies
Monday" is a term coined in the US for the Monday coming after Black Friday, which is the
Friday after Thanksgiving Day. Most recent GOSF Great Online Shopping Festival was held
during Dec, 2018. In early June 2013, Amazon.com launched their Amazon India marketplace
without any marketing campaigns. In July 2014, Amazon had said it will invest $2 billion (Rs
12,000 crore) in India to expand the business, after its largest Indian rival, Flipkart announced $1
billion in funding. In June 2016, Amazon agreed to invest another $3 billion to further pressure
rivals Flipkart & Snapdeal Amazon has also entered the grocery segment with its Kirana now in
Bangalore and is also planning to enter in various other cities like Delhi, Mumbai and Chennai
and faces stiff competition with Indian startups. A large proportion of traffic towards e-commerce
Funding:
Examples of venture capital firms having invested in e-commerce companies in India are as
follows: Flipkart.com raised about USD 2.3 billion. On 10 July 2013, Flipkart announced it had
received $200 million from existing investors Tiger Global, Naspers, Accel Partners, and
ICONIQ Capital, and an additional $160 million from Dragoneer Investment Group, Morgan
Stanley Wealth Management, Sofina, Vulcan Inc. and more from Tiger Global. In February 2014,
online fashion retailer Myntra.com raised $50 million from a group of investors led by Premji
Invest, the investment company floated by Azim Premji, Chairman of Wipro. May 2014 also
8
witnessed an acquisition of Myntra by Flipkart reportedly for 2,000 crores. In September 2015,
PepperTap raised $36 million from Snapdeal and others. In July 2020, Purplle raised $30 million
Niche retailers:
The spread of e-commerce has led to the rise of several niche players who largely specialize their
products around a specific theme. As many as 1,06,086 websites are registered daily and more
than 25% are for niche businesses. During 2014, Royal Enfield sold 200 bikes of special series
Online. Online apparel is one of the more popular verticals, which along with computers and
consumer electronics make up 42% of the total retail e-commerce sales. Niche online
merchandising brands like Headbanger's Merch, Redwolf and No Nasties partner with and even
help sustain independent musicians. Some established brands like Arvind are now creating
clothing lines just for the e-commerce markets. Some of the bigger online retailers like VoxPop
Clothing have secured multiple rounds of funding, the last round raising $1 million from Blume
Ventures in 2014. As these niche businesses get popular, they are slowly getting acquired by the
big players. BabyOye was acquired by Mahindra Retail, part of the $17 billion Mahindra Group.
Ekstop was acquired by the Godrej Group to complement their offline chain of Nature's Basket
stores.
Regulation:
Foreign e-commerce is subject to regulations in India; under local law, foreign companies are to
serve solely as marketplaces between vendors and their customers, and are forbidden from
holding inventory in the country. Under new regulations effective 1 February 2019, foreign
9
companies will be forbidden from selling any products from vendors that they control or have
equity stakes in, and it is forbidden to enter into exclusivity deals between vendors and websites.
This regulation is seen as a counter to Amazon and Walmart's influence on the market, which
10
COMMENCEMENT OF THE ECOMMERCE INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Over the past few years, India has been going through a digital revolution of sorts. Over 50% of
the country’s populace, now has access to internet enabled devices, and owing to our massive
population, it translates to a user base of over half a billion people. These staggering numbers
have made India a hotbed for internet-based businesses, the largest gainer of which, has been the
e-commerce industry. A report by the India Brand Equity Foundation (IBEF), projects that the
revenue generated from the e-commerce industry in the country is well on its course to breach the
US$100 billion mark by the year 2020. However, this was not always the case with online
businesses in India. In fact, there was almost some kind of reluctance among the masses, in
The concept of e-commerce first formally came forth in 1991, a time when the internet practically
did not even exist in India. Even worldwide, very few could fathom that the act of buying and
selling goods and services over the internet, would be as widely accepted a practice, as it is today.
By the late ’90s, people became aware of this thing called the internet, but for a majority of them,
it remained a luxury they did not particularly need. In a truly Indian manner, it was only in 2002,
when the IRCTC introduced an online reservation system, that the public widely accepted the
internet as something fruitful, by which time a company named Amazon, was already beginning
The first real stepping stone towards setting off the e-commerce juggernaut, was perhaps the
creation of Flipkart, when two engineers from IIT Delhi decided to sell books online from an
11
apartment in the Koramangala area of Bengaluru. A business idea not too dissimilar to that of
Amazon. Little did they know that a decade later, US retail giants, Walmart, would acquire their
business in a US$ 16 billion-dollar deal, after a fierce bidding war with none other than Amazon.
However, even when Flipkart came into being, the internet still didn’t have the accessibility it
needed for such businesses to blow up. Reliance industries frontman, Mukesh Ambani, corrected
that in one stroke when he announced the arrival of Reliance Jio. If there is one thing Indians, or
anyone of any nationality unabashedly likes, it is free stuff. Perhaps, in what was one of the
greatest marketing strategies ever, Mr. Ambani handed out free sim cards as if he had stumbled
onto a secret dungeon with an endless supply of them, or at least a few months’ worth. He was
offering data services at a fraction of the cost compared to what his competitors were charging.
However, even when Flipkart came into being, the internet still didn’t have the accessibility it
needed for such businesses to blow up. Reliance industries frontman, Mukesh Ambani, corrected
that in one stroke when he announced the arrival of Reliance Jio. If there is one thing Indians, or
anyone of any nationality unabashedly likes, it is free stuff. Perhaps, in what was one of the
greatest marketing strategies ever, Mr. Ambani handed out free sim cards as if he had stumbled
onto a secret dungeon with an endless supply of them, or at least a few months’ worth. He was
offering data services at a fraction of the cost compared to what his competitors were charging.
Naturally, this move of Ambanis’ had several implications. For starters, all other network
operators were forced to slash down their prices to a significantly more affordable range. All of
this together culminated in the aforementioned fact, wherein the user base in the country just
exploded. At this time the e-commerce industry was already doing quite well in India. However,
12
they were about to receive a massive push. ‘Data is the new oil’, screamed journalists and
newspapers. Of course, this also birthed a whole new set of cybersecurity risks, but as we have
witnessed, it’s a risk people are willing to take if they can have anything from milk to even a new
What followed was a host of new policies, constructed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi. He
allowed for a 100% FDI cap, in B2B e-commerce businesses. Suddenly almost every business
had an online projection of itself. The existing e-commerce businesses were now worth their
weight in gold. India emerged as an e-commerce powerhouse, which will only grow in stature in
13
ENTRY OF SOCIAL MEDIA IN INDIA
India has embraced the internet with open arms, and its digital population has been rapidly
growing in the past decade with over 680 million active internet users . What started with simple
email correspondences, has expanded to a digital universe with social networking giants like
Google, Facebook and Twitter becoming a part of everyday life for millions of Indians.
Orkut was one of the first, big social networking websites in the country, owned by Google and
named after the employee who created it. In 2008, it was one of the most visited websites in the
country until its closing was announced in 2014. Not that this stopped Indians from keeping
socializing virtually – the country simply transitioned to Facebook. As of 2020, India had the
highest number of Facebook users across the globe with close to 300 million users.
As data packs get cheaper and the internet becomes more accessible, more Indians are embracing
the digital lifestyle. At the same time, smartphones are increasingly becoming the primary screen
for Indian customers. In fact, it seems that India entirely skipped the desktop generation and went
straight to mobiles. In 2019, a whopping 99 percent of the rural internet users in the country
primarily used mobile phones to access the internet. This means mobile phone applications are a
As a gregarious country, Indians love their social networking apps. In 2020, the highest number
of WhatsApp and TikTok mobile app downloads in the world were from India. The average
internet user in the country spends over three hours per day on social media. And a large
14
proportion of this user base were millennials and gen Z. In 2018, over 73 percent of Facebook
Apart from social networking apps, video sharing platforms, specifically YouTube was widely
popular in India. YouTube consumption in India sky-rocketed with the Indian Premier League
streaming matches in 2010 with over two billion views per day. Of course, this doubled with each
season of the IPL thereafter. Around the same time, a relatively unknown (to the outside world)
Indian music record label, T-Series, was slowly but steadfastly making its way on YouTube by
sharing old Bollywood and indi-pop music. The content took off and today, T-Series was the most
Estimates indicate that by 2023, there will be almost 450 million social network users in the
country, from a little over 326 million users in 2018. This rapid growth in the sector has also
given stimulus to the advertising industry. Today, India’s digital advertising industry is worth
over 160 billion Indian rupees, and it was estimated to reach 560 billion rupees by 2023.
15
SOCIAL MEDIA TRENDS IN INDIA
Just 41% of India’s population is online, but it’s still one of the world’s largest social media
markets. There’s potential for growth as well. Thanks to developing infrastructure, many rural
India has more Facebook users than any other country. YouTube’s Indian audience has grown
85% in the last year. And WhatsApp reached 400 million users. The subcontinent is now the
That’s not all. Instagram boasts 69 million Indian users, and LinkedIn has racked up 56 million
users. Twitter and Snapchat have relatively small audiences (though Snapchat is growing in
popularity). The relatively new platform TikTok was banned by Indian courts in spring 2019,
lasting only three months. As of May 2020, India is the largest market for Tiktok, though it’s once
Hyperlocal competition is growing, too. As Indian audiences diversify, the demand for local
language content is increasing. Apps like LocalPlay, Local, and Awaaz are becoming popular.
They create video content focused on specific locales. Because of this, it’s best to plan your
Indian social media strategy on a city or state basis. This allows you to address local trends and
There’s a lot to consider around social media in India. Here’s how to make the most of it.
60% of brands add an interactive element to their social media content. It’s an essential way to
stand out.
Take Samsung, for example. They launched a nationwide campaign called “Real India,” aimed at
Gen Z and millennials. The campaign encouraged users to share 60-second videos that break
16
Indian stereotypes. The result? 161.8 million engagements on Instagram and Facebook over four
weeks. This set the company up well for smartphone sales during the festive season.
Facebook’s been paying attention to the success of this approach. They’ve launched new
interactive ad formats in time for India’s festival season. (There are thirteen national and religious
festivals in October alone.) This includes augmented reality, poll ads, and stickers.
To stand out on social media in India, don’t just talk at your customers – interact with them.
The average Indian online user’s monthly data usage is 8 GB. Over 70% of that is used for
entertainment. In fact, Indians are among the biggest fans of online video in the world, spending
This is why social media in India has such a cinematic feel. Take British Airways’s “Fuelled by
Love” story about an airline stewardess discovering India. Full of heartwarming moments, it’s an
Facebook has also gained exclusive digital rights for ICC (International Cricket Council) events.
It will promote match recaps, key in-play moments, and other features.
Placing locally relevant and authentic storytelling at the heart of your content will delight your
customers. To turn conversations into conversions, some brands link social campaigns to their
physical locations.
For example, Burger King launched a successful #SayCheese campaign. Customers who sent in
Social commerce is also booming, especially outside the big cities. Startups like GlowRoad and
Meesho support female sellers with services in local languages. In the last year, 1.8 million
women sold $8 billion worth of goods in India. And the number of resellers is set to grow to 30
million by 2022.
17
Currently, social media in India is overwhelmingly male. Reaching a female audience can mean
supplementing social strategy with other channels. But this is starting to change. So connecting
with female sellers to turn them into brand ambassadors puts brands in a great position to reach
the growing female audience. In 2015, Epigamia launched India’s first Greek yogurt with a
five-part original series called “What the folks.” It was “a journey of modern families breaking
stereotypes, overcoming generation gaps, and growing to love one another, despite starkly
different world views.” And a great example of two strong themes in Indian social content: family
Politics isn’t off-limits in India either. During the 2019 general election, many brands campaigned
on the importance of voting. For example, United Colors of Benetton launched #UnitedByVote.
The campaign video featured politicians making promises. Then, an “inked” finger appears in the
WhatsApp launched a campaign against misinformation, called “Share Joy, Not Rumors.” The
If your brand has a clear social purpose, shout about it. It could be the key to connecting with
your customers on social media in India. Social media is a crucial way of building brand
awareness in India. Go big and interact with your audience with locally relevant, authentic,
cross-platform content if you want to be heard. Win over customers by championing your brand
purpose. And prepare for the future by embracing India’s ever-changing digital demographics.
18
MOST POPULAR SOCIAL NETWORKING SITES IN INDIA
1. Facebook
Hands down Facebook has been ruling on the top for quite a long time now. Almost the third of
the world’s population uses Facebook, which is 2 million users using it every month. This is only
the active user count, the user base is as big as 400 million users and it keeps on increasing day by
day. It is super easy to sign up and use. The user interface is very convenient to learn and
nowadays it is also the base for the new-age trend of digital marketing as you can create ads and
run promotions too. You can feature your business page on Facebook.
2. Whatsapp
This app has become the lifeline of Indians. This app was launched in 2010 and it managed to
have a user base of above 250 million users from India alone. A lot of people now totally depend
on WhatsApp for being connected to the world. It allows you to exchange messages, send
pictures, call, video call, put up statuses, and even send documents and attachments. No matter
how huge the database is, it is used to be in touch with your loved ones.
3. Instagram
Another social network that became popular in a short span. It has become a haven for influencers
and also businesses. You can make an account of anything and everything on Instagram. It allows
you to share a wide range of content such as photos, videos, stories, and live videos. It has also
recently launched IGTV for longer-form videos. An Instagram business profile will also offer you
rich analytics that will help you get your target group and customer base.
19
4. Twitter
If you are a fan of news, entertainment, sports, politics, and more, then the most popular social
networking site is Twitter. Every little news becomes super-viral and the view count increases
tremendously on Twitter. Another unique characteristic of Twitter is that it only allows 280
characters in a tweet (140 for Japanese, Korean, and Chinese), unlike most social media sites that
have a much higher limit. So, if your style of portraying messages is in a short and a crisp way,
5. LinkedIn
All of us need a professional website too, so for all your job searches and corporate connection,
the perfect site is LinkedIn. It has also become a place for businesses to establish their thought
leadership and authority in their industry and attract talent to their company. It also allows other
people to observe you in a professional way. It’s also a way to be open with your audience and
allow LinkedIn users to see a simple description of what your company does, what it stands for,
and how it’s run. It also lets you put details of your entire educational background, experience
1. Amazon: Amazon is an American based eCommerce web portal founded by Jeff Bezos in
1994. According to Alexa, Amazon.in is a 3rd rank website in India based on global
2. Flipkart: Flipkart is an Indian based eCommerce web portal founded by Sachin Bansal and
Binny Bansal in 2007. Now Flipkart is a part of Walmart. Walmart acquired Flipkart in
20
2018. According to Alexa, Flipkart.com is a 6th rank website in India based on global
3. Myntra: Myntra is an India based eCommerce web portal founded by Mukesh Bansal and
Vineet Saxena in 2007. Later, Mintra was acquired by Flipkart in 2014. According to
Alexa, Myntra.com is a 78th rank website in India based on global internet traffic and
engagement.
4. Paytm: Paytm is an India based eCommerce online payment app founded by Vijay
Shekhar Sharma in 2010. According to Alexa, Paytm.com is a 122nd rank website in India
5. SnapDeal: SnapDeal is an India based eCommerce web portal founded by Rohit Bansal
and Kunal Bhal in 2010. According to Alexa, Sanpdeal.com is a 159th rank website in
6. AJIO: AJIO is an Indian based eCommerce web portal founded by Mukesh Ambani and
7. Alibaba Group: Alibaba Group is a Chinese based eCommerce web portal founded by
Jack Ma in 1999. Alibaba Group is one of the oldest companies in the eCommerce
8. ShopClues: ShopClues is an India based eCommerce web portal founded by Sanjay Sethi,
is a 424th rank website in India based on global internet traffic and engagement.
21
9. Paytm Mall: Paytm Mall is an Indi based eCommerce platform founded by One97
10. Tata Cliq: Tata Cliq is an Indian based eCommerce web portal founded by Ashutosh
Pandey in 2016. According to Alexa, Tatacliq.com is a 2477th rank website in India based
22
TOP E-COMMERCE COMPANIES IN INDIA
Now, I'm continuing to list the top 10 eCommerce websites in India in 2020. All the eCommerce
websites we will contain according to the traffic ranking given by Alexa Internet. Here is a list of
1 Amazon.in 3rd
2 Flipkart.com 6th
3 Myntra.com 78th
4 Paytm.com 122nd
5 Snapdeal.com 159th
6 Ajio.com 189th
7 Alibaba.com 267th
23
8 Shopclues.com 424th
9 Paytmmall.com 565th
10 Tatacliq.com 2477th
Now, I'm proceeding to list the top 10 eCommerce apps in India in 2020. All the eCommerce apps
we will contain according to the traffic ranking provided by Google Play Store. Here is a list of
1. Amazon
2. Flipkart
3. Myntra
4. AliExpress
5. Paytm
6. Shein
7. Ajio
8. Snapdeal
9. Jabong
10. ShopClues
24
MOST POPULAR E-COMMERCE COMPANIES
Typically, the sharing economy was meant for voluntary sharing of resources (for eg.
Couchsurfing) but has now transformed into powerful platforms shaping entire markets and even
E-commerce in India makes up only 1.6% of retail sales as of today. But this market is going
through significant changes, particularly through the impending merging of online and offline
retail with Big Tech investments in retail networks. We are looking at a future where digital
technology through e-commerce platforms can determine the future of all commerce in India.
This report looks at two phenomena. One is the tendency of e-commerce platforms to
infrastructuralism: that is, to become ubiquitous, accessible and reliable in a way that resembles
infrastructure. The other is the tendency of e-commerce to platformise existing infrastructure: that
The key characteristics of infrastructure as ubiquity, accessibility and reliability, among other
parameters. E-commerce in India does not as yet fit these descriptors. In 2019, e-commerce made
up only 1.6% of retail sales in India. The corresponding global figure was 14%. On accessibility
too, e-commerce falls short. India has 504 million active internet users, which is about 36.5% of
the population. These users tend to be young, urban and male. Since Covid- 19 lockdowns, the
25
It is much more helpful than to look at the tendency of Indian e-commerce towards
the relevant market is retail in general, e-commerce is not a significant proportion of this market.
Within the e-commerce market itself, there exists a duopoly. As of 2018, Walmart-owned Flipkart
(with Myntra and Jabong) controlled 38.3% of the e-commerce market, and Amazon controls
about 31.2%.
grows outwards into all retail. In 2019, Amazon announced a billion-dollar investment in India to
help small and medium-sized businesses come online. This naturally means that these businesses
will be supported to sell on Amazon’s own platform. Amazon is also working on turning
neighbourhood shops into e-commerce delivery centres. Facebook’s investment in Reliance Jio is
meant to primarily bring small businesses online via WhatsApp. Google’s $10 billion Google for
India Digitization Fund to help accelerate India’s digital economy involved a significant
From these recent developments in investment, it is safe to assume that the share of e-commerce
in retail will continue to grow through ‘new retail’, a term coined by Alibaba founder Jack Ma to
denote the blurring boundaries between online and offline retail. It involves the digitalisation of
physical stores among other ways of integrating online and offline shopping. Investments from
Amazon, Facebook and Google described above are examples of new retail.
26
With this growth trajectory of e-commerce in mind, we now look at some of the existing
platforms, that is, sellers and customers. We analyse these economic relationships in terms of
Key findings:
E-commerce adds value to third-party sellers’ business by providing access to new domestic
markets (84.6% of Amazon sellers, 77.6% of Flipkart sellers) and improving price discovery
(67.7% of Amazon sellers, 58.6% of Flipkart sellers changed their price after going online). It
adds value to consumers with helpful product reviews (70% of consumers), lower prices (79% of
27
Chart 3: Motives for shopping online
E-commerce creates dependence, with a majority of sellers (92.3% of Amazon sellers, 84.5% of
Flipkart sellers) making fundamental changes to their business practices to accommodate the rules
of the platform or optimise operations on the platform. On average, sellers depended on Amazon
for 50.4% of their total revenue and on Flipkart for 39% of their total revenue. Most sellers did
28
not feel “locked in” to a particular platform, but the indication was that they were locked in to
e-commerce in general. Most sellers also felt that the commission they paid platforms was low or
adequate (93.9% for Flipkart, and 87.5% for Amazon), showing that e-commerce in India is still
Policy recommendations:
Policymakers can choose among the three recommendations below. The choice must be such that
1. Allow concentrated e-commerce markets to continue, but then undertake one or more of the
below:
Disallowing the fusion of online and offline retail, or limiting the growth of this fusion under
monopoly conditions;
Regulating platforms to minimise chances of breakdown, because third-party sellers also have an
Restricting the change of policies on platforms that may adversely affect platform participants
2. Maintain a minimum level of competition to allow switching between platforms for third-party
sellers;
29
3. Promote public ownership or democratic control of e-commerce platforms to correspond with
Key findings:
Platformization of the marketplace is taking place through control over market conditions –
e-commerce firms both regulate and act as participants in the marketplace, thereby exerting
In the survey, most sellers did not have an issue with their appearance in search rankings. This
indicates that despite the platformization of the marketplace, it is perhaps premature to ask for
30
The survey also found that over 70% of consumers now search for goods they are buying directly
on the platforms instead of using search engines. This makes it clear that if there were to be an
issue with algorithmic fairness in search results in the future, it would affect nearly all of online
When you decide to buy a product online, where do you usually first search for it?
Platformization of the marketplace also takes place through private labels. Both Amazon and
Flipkart use sales and other data generated on their platform to introduce their own products
(private labels) for sale on the platform. This is egregiously anti-competitive as third-party sellers
do not have access to the data generated by themselves and which is used to develop and market
private labels. A majority of sellers (63.1% for Amazon and 58.6% for Flipkart) said that they
31
one platform market captures users in another platform market by bundling its services or
functionalities. It is able to do this by gaining network effects in a new type of market with its
existing user base. E-commerce providers in India use such bundling often. In fact, telecom
provider Reliance Jio’s bid to enter e-commerce is itself an example of an attempt at platform
envelopment. Logistics is perhaps the sector that is most vulnerable to platform envelopment
e-commerce firms’ own entities. Amazon Transportation Services, in particular, has a strong
presence in the sector. In 2018, KPMG estimated that 70% of the deliveries of large e-commerce
platforms were made by their in-house delivery arms. Platformization of logistics is evident in
over half of surveyed sellers (63.1% for Amazon and 53.4% for Flipkart) claiming one of the
reasons for selling online is shipping provided by the platform. Sellers and consumers both
preferred bundled services (sales and shipping provided together by the platform), showing that
such platformization of logistics is likely to continue. About 20-25% of the e-commerce logistics
Policy recommendations:
Third-party sellers must have access to the same sales data that is used by the platform to compete
against them. Mechanisms for mandated sharing of non-personal data sharing should be built for
e-commerce.
Currently, platforms with FDI are effectively disallowed from selling their own products as well
as third-party products. This separation of intermediation and sale has to be imposed on domestic
32
e-commerce entities in multi-brand retail above a certain firm size as well. It should not remain
Third-party sellers should be able to know why their products have a certain rank in search results
on the platform. Algorithmic regulation should include a minimum level of transparency about
how algorithms rank results on e-commerce sites, with evolving standards for fairness. To
regulate broader economic effects, lending rules in the logistics sector should account for the
33
FLIPKART- WALMART DEAL
Walmart announced over the weekend that it has completed a $16 billion investment in Flipkart
that sees it become the majority owner of the Indian e-commerce company.
The deal was first revealed back in May and now it has closed after receiving the necessary
approvals. It sees Walmart take a 77 percent share in the company, buying out a number of prior
investors in the process and expanding its rivalry with Amazon to a new horizon. The investment
capital also includes $2 billion in new equity funding which will be used for growth while the
transaction was structured so that Flipkart itself can still go public. That latter point could mean
that the Indian firm must go public within four years, as TechCrunch previously reported.
Flipkart will continue to be run by its leadership with Tencent and Tiger Global retaining board
seats. Those two have remained investors in the business, alongside others that include Flipkart
co-founder Binny Bansal and Microsoft. Walmart previously suggested that other allies would
come aboard as investors. Google was strongly mooted, but so far there have been no strategic
additions.
Walmart said that its plans for India will include investments that “support national initiatives
and will bring sustainable benefits in jobs creation, supporting small businesses, supporting
As we previously reported, it also plans to use Flipkart as a “key center of learning” for the rest of
its business across the world, and that includes its home market.
“Not only is [Flipkart] innovative [with the] problem-solving culture that they have, but they are
doing some great work both in the AI space, how they are using data across their platforms but
34
particularly in terms of the payment platform that they’ve created through PhonePe. All of those
things we can learn from for the future and see how we can leverage those around the
international markets and potentially into the US as well,” Walmart COO Judith McKenna said
Flipkart’s business could also get a whole lot more transparent since its quarterly results will be
reported as part of Walmart’s earnings. Although they will be part of its international business so
35
RELIANCE JIO - FACEBOOK DEAL
Facebook’s purchase of a nearly 10% stake in Reliance Industries’ digital business unit Jio
Platforms brings one of the world’s largest Internet companies on the table with India’s largest
telecom player. The $5.7-billion deal, which values Reliance’s digital operations at around $66
billion, pushes the Indian conglomerate ahead in its plans of de-leveraging its balance sheet while
accelerating the launch of its new commerce business.
Further, it not only marks Facebook’s long-pending formal entry into India’s telecom sector but
also catapults it to a place among the biggest foreign investors in India’s technology space
Back in August 2019, while addressing the company’s shareholders at the annual general
meeting, Reliance Industries Chairman Mukesh Ambani had said the group had prepared a
roadmap for becoming a zero net-debt company within 18 months. The Facebook deal
significantly contributes to that plan by paring about Rs 43,574 crore from its outstanding debt as
of September 2019 of Rs 2.92 lakh crore. The other primary contributors to the debt-reduction
plan will be a potential $15 billion (around Rs 1.05 lakh crore) deal with Saudi Aramco for a 20%
stake in Reliance Industries’ refining and petrochemicals business and Rs 7,000 crore from a 49%
sale in its fuel retail joint-venture to British firm BP. However, experts believe the Aramco deal to
be under threat on account of the oil prices crash caused by the COVID-19 outbreak.
Besides the balance sheet deleveraging, the timing of the deal with Facebook is significant for
another reason: online platforms selling essential goods have suddenly witnessed an upsurge in
demand. For example, before the outbreak, just 1% of the Rs 80,000-crore grocery market in
India was represented by online players. After the lockdown, online platforms started to account
for 50% of the grocery demand in the country by some estimates before it was corrected. “We’re
36
one of the few industries that has got more than enough business but not enough resources,” said
Experts have said the arrangement among Reliance Retail, Jio Platforms and Facebook-owned
WhatsApp to offer consumers the ability to access the nearest kiranas, or grocery stores, which
can provide products and services to their homes by transacting with JioMart using WhatsApp,
has come at a very opportune time. WhatsApp boasts 400 million users in India. Further, using
WhatsApp’s base also allows Reliance Retail to promote its services to users of Jio’s rival
telecom players.
Facebook has been trying for years to get its finger in the Internet pie. In 2015, it experimented
with Free Basics, which provided free access to basic Internet services as a partnership with
service providers. However, criticised for being a walled garden, it soon pulled out of the idea
after differential pricing was disallowed by the telecom sector regulator.
It had even looked at the possibility of beaming free Internet from the air using a solar-powered
drone called Aquila, and enabled low cost high-speed Wi-Fi in some remote parts of India with an
initiative called Express Wi-Fi. But data was expensive in those times, and free access to the
Internet was envisioned as the easiest way to bring the next billion users online. Then, Reliance
Jio happened. It launched with data rates so low that they became the industry standard in one of
the largest online markets in the world. Jio alone helped bring 388 million users online, well over
a third of what Facebook had planned.
The partnership with Reliance could also help Facebook navigate the regulatory environment in
India, where it has had several skirmishes with the authorities, including for its major initiatives
such as WhatsApp Pay.
37
The deal also marks Facebook’s entry among elite investors in India’s technology space, joining
the likes of SoftBank, Amazon and Google that have together poured in billions of dollars in
Indian tech startups and their own ventures over the years. Prior to Jio Platforms, Facebook had
invested around $20-25 million in social commerce platform Meesho in 2019, and participated in
a $110 million funding round for edu-tech company Unacademy earlier this year.
The deal with Reliance also gives Facebook access to the latter’s bouquet of digital apps. These
include in-house apps such as Jio Money, Jio TV, etc in addition to the young startups acquired
by Reliance or its subsidiaries across categories such as logistics, e-commerce and artificial
intelligence.
In January last year, speaking at the Vibrant Gujarat Summit, Ambani had stressed that India’s
data “must be controlled and owned by Indian people – and not by corporates, especially global
corporations”. “For India to succeed in this data-driven revolution, we will have to migrate the
control and ownership of Indian data back to India – in other words, Indian wealth back to every
Indian,” he had said. While some have raised the red flag over Facebook’s track-record on data
privacy issues, executives of both companies said Wednesday that data sharing was not a part of
the deal. “There will be areas that we will collaborate in but there will be areas where we will
potentially not agree with each other,” a Jio official said. Facebook, on the other hand, maintained
its stance in favour of an open ecosystem for data to flow across boundaries.
Earlier launched in May, RIL’s online gross merchandise value (GMV) will reach $35 billion in
FY25 with a 31% share of the e-commerce market from around 1% now, according to Goldman
Sachs. Here GMV represents the total value of merchandise sold over a given period and
considered as a measure of growth. In the second quarter of this fiscal, RIL’s retail business
38
recorded a robust growth across consumption baskets. They have posted a sales of Rs 41,100
crore, which definitely shows the growth from Rs 31,620 crore which was reported in the June
quarter. During the pandemic-induced lockdown, 85% of the country's grocery stores were shut.
For Jio Mart, the grocery segment, staples and processed food drove the growth.
In a 2 November note, UBS said, “JioMart is evolving into a multi-segment e-commerce play. It
will not be restricted to just food and grocery but would also include electronics, fashion and
lifestyle and pharma products. This would make JioMart a full-fledged ecommerce player with an
assortment comparable to or even wider than Amazon and Flipkart,”RIL’s own infrastructure of
‘Trends, Digital and Jewels’ stores, as well as acquisitions such as Netmeds, Grab and Fynd,
would help in a seamless integration and faster ramp-up of JioMart, the note said.As per the
SensorTower data, the company is witnessing strong app downloads for JioMart (grocery) and
Ajio (apparel). In addition to that, Ajio’s revenue increased four times. On the other hand, the
contributions from digital electronics sales and grocery e-commerce through JioMart have also
become sizable. RIL’s e-commerce is the approval for WhatsApp Pay to go live on the UPI
platform will also aid its growth.Additionally, WhatsApp’s integration with JioMart will
strengthen the offering for the 60 million small merchants.It will also strengthen the telecom
Goldman Sachs said the COVID-19 pandemic is the key driver for the acceleration in the
adoption of numerous technologies and consumer behaviours, mainly e-commerce.It said, “What
started at first with panic buying, hoarding and nest feathering out of necessity has turned into an
39
array of adaptations that have driven e-commerce penetration from 16 per cent of retail spending
in the US in 1Q19 to over 40 per cent in May driven by year- over-year growth of nearly 70 per
cent.” The report ‘Global Internet: e-commerce’s steepening curve’ formulated by Goldman
Sachs said the COVID-19 pandemic and the resultant lockdowns has been a driving force for the
penetration of e-commerce globally with categories such as consumer packaged goods driving as
much as 3 years of penetration growth in 3 months. It said, “We forecast India e-commerce will
reach USD 99 billion by 2024, growing at a 27 per cent CAGR over 2019-24, with grocery and
fashion/apparel likely to be the key drivers of incremental growth in our view.”As per the study,
the e-commerce penetration in the country is expected to reach 10.7% by 2024 compared to 4.7%
in 2019. The firm said that the penetration into grocery or Fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG)
will be the contributing factors for growth in India’s e-commerce. It is also expected to improve
the payment ecosystem and ease of shopping through WhatsApp among others. Goldman Sachs
said adding the last 500 basis points of the increase took 4 years, “We expect non-grocery
e-commerce penetration to see a sharp increase of 500 basis points over the next two years to
reach 16.1 per cent by 2021.” As of 2019, the online extent in India for consumer electronics was
high at 40%. Though there has been significant growth in online penetration in other categories
like apparel, appliances, health and personal care, India is far behind from its peers like China.It
said, “As far as incremental growth in e-commerce is concerned, we expect grocery to be the
biggest driver with 40 per cent contribution to incremental e-commerce GMV (gross merchandise
volume) between 2019 and 2024.” “However, online penetration currently stands at less than 0.5
per cent (absolute size USD 2 billion), one of the least among categories,” it said. While giving a
silver lining the report also stated that the online grocery market in India to grow by 20 times over
the next 5 years, to reach USD 29 billion in value (5.1 %penetration) by 2024. The firm said that
40
it is forecasting online grocery orders to grow from 300,000 per day in 2019, to more than 5
million per day by 2024. On a global scale, e-commerce would grow 24%, the firm forecasts.
Facebook-Jio Deal A Key Driver For the Growth In Online Shopping In India?
Amidst the coronavirus outbreak, Facebook, world’s biggest social network bought 9.99% stake
in Reliance Jio, the telecom wing of Reliance Industries Limited (RIL). RIL’s e-commerce
venture, JioMart plans to use Facebook’s WhatsApp to connect local grocery stores with the
consumers. The report also said, “The biggest near term theme in India internet, in our view, is
the foray of Reliance Industries (India’s largest market-cap company with presence across sectors
such as energy, telecom, and retail) into e-commerce, and the company’s tie-up with WhatsApp
for online grocery.” Online grocery has been escalating at over 50% year-on-year (Y-O-Y) for the
last couple of years. The report stated with the COVID-19 lockdown coupled with JioMart, more
customers have shifted to online grocery shopping and the growth is expected to accelerate to
81% CAGR during 2019-24. RIL’s foray into the e-commerce space via JioMart by using its
large of?ine distribution capabilities and also with the Facebook-Jio deal, ability to order
groceries through WhatsApp – a platform with more than 400 million users in India.Goldman
Sachs said, “We believe RIL’s partnership with Facebook could result in the company becoming
a market leader in the online grocery space, with more than 50 per cent share by 2024.” It added,
“Having said that, we do see grocery as a large category for two or more players to co-exist over
time.”In the Facebook FDI in Reliance Jio deal, the benefit and cost calculations show that both
partners gain, adding to our foreign reserves, and so it’s commercially a sensible deal.That is why,
on the same principles, the BJP government at the Centre has permitted Amazon and
Walmart-Flipkart to function in India, but unfortunately so far and till now, there was no other
competitor. This has led to some allegations of under and over invoicing in their local
41
transactions. Such irregularities, if any, can be efficiently blocked only by deep-pocket
competitors. The collateral benefits of the Reliance Jio-Facebook deal are many. Firstly,
Facebook, which includes WhatsApp and Instagram, caters to about 400 million users. Reliance
Jio also has about the same number of clients, with some overlap. But since JioMart has been
formed by RIL, the company is planning to enter in a big way to start the e-commerce business
and e-payment services. Thus, besides the private gain to RIL of being able to use the fund
infusion of Rs 43,570 crore to vastly reduce its debt (Jio by itself has Rs 40,000 crore as debt), the
Jio-Facebook combine can compete with others in the e-commerce and e-services areas for which
the vast WhatsApp and Instagram subscribers will add to JioMart’s reach to compete, reduce
margins, and, therefore, prices for the consumers. Secondly, already JioMart has begun trial runs
in Navi Mumbai, Thane, and Kalyan besides RIL ownership in 6,700 big and small cities of
10,900 retail stores, employing 1,25,000 people. WhatsApp is also connected to small businesses,
taking orders from customers, and promoting offerings through the internet and cellphones. Thus,
Facebook and Jio combined will have huge market reach and consumer convenience. Thirdly,
households will be able to reach by cellphones the nearest kirana stores and place orders for home
delivery, Here too, Jio-Facebook can reach this way millions of traders and kirana merchants on
the cellphones and internet and thus save consumers from having to make the trip physically for
purchase. Fourthly, the Jio-Facebook combine can now easily explore, with government
concurrence, the introduction of a cryptocurrency network. The government of India has already
approved blockchain technology. The final step of digital currency may have to wait because the
regulatory infrastructure has not yet been set up. When that happens, black money will become
impossible to use as legal currency in circulation. Illegal transactions via cryptocurrency and
blockchain will be impossible without detection. A word of caution though: the United States has
42
very strict laws about national security implications arising from lack of privacy and data security.
At present India does not have any such reciprocal law on privacy, and hence the huge data that
would be generated by the Facebook-Jio collaboration would travel just one way: from India to
the US. The government of India ought to have passed a Privacy Act long ago as well as on the
security of the servers when Amazon and Walmart’s Flipkart were permitted to operate in India.
Now is another opportunity to show greater sensitivity about data protection and privacy, which
the government has not shown since Aadhaar was introduced. For a comparison, we may examine
the US Export Control Reform Act of 2018, whereby the US Congress directed the American
essential to the national security of the United States”. The Facebook-Jio alliance is within the
the Reliance-Facebook FDI decision as good for both, and, subject to fulfilling the legal
43
CONSUMER PERCEPTION ON RELIANCE JIO - FACEBOOK DEAL
Here is a detailed survey report analytics on the consumer perception on the Reliance Jio-
Facebook deal:
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
CONCLUSION
While retailers and e-commerce platforms may feel intimidated by the biggest cross-country deal
of this year between Mukesh Ambani’s Reliance Jio and Mark Zuckerberg’s Facebook,
homegrown digital payments platform Paytm founder Vijay Shekhar Sharma claims that this
could actually be beneficial to the firm. The Jio-Facebook deal may mark a change in consumer
behaviour, and the whole industry will benefit from this, Vijay Shekhar Sharma told CNBC
TV-18. “It takes a huge amount of capital to change customer behaviour and it took us tens of
thousands of crores to make users pick up the phone and scan a QR code. We spent more money
However, one thing that Paytm hasn’t been able to do is business around online-to-offline, he
said. On the other hand, JioMart is incepted on the premise that an item will be sourced from a
local store and will be later shipped to a customer’s home. “Jio-Facebook partnership may be
calling the country where consumers start to place orders to neighborhood stores. Once this takes
off, everyone in the industry will benefit and we will also be a beneficiary,” Vijay Shekhar
Sharma added. After the announcement of Facebook-Jio deal, Paytm had also later announced its
plan to bring kiranas into play as the company looks to ramp up hyperlocal deliveries in about 100
Indian cities.
Limitation - This is a subjective and descriptive research, I further intend to analyse as per
55
REFERENCES
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ui=2&ik=f22b0066d1&attid=0.2&permmsgid=msg-f:16651459
92588529285&th=171bc9753b678e85&view=att&disp=inline&realattid=f_k9ipygbh1
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ui=2&ik=f22b0066d1&attid=0.3&permmsgid=msg-f:16651459
92588529285&th=171bc9753b678e85&view=att&disp=safe&realattid=f_k9iq0srl3
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ui=2&ik=f22b0066d1&attid=0.4&permmsgid=msg-f:16651459
92588529285&th=171bc9753b678e85&view=att&disp=inline&realattid=f_k9iq0sqi2
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ui=2&ik=f22b0066d1&attid=0.6&permmsgid=msg-f:16651459
92588529285&th=171bc9753b678e85&view=att&disp=inline&realattid=f_k9iq5sdi6
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ui=2&ik=f22b0066d1&attid=0.7&permmsgid=msg-f:16651459
92588529285&th=171bc9753b678e85&view=att&disp=inline&realattid=f_k9iq5sct5
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ui=2&ik=f22b0066d1&attid=0.8&permmsgid=msg-f:16651459
92588529285&th=171bc9753b678e85&view=att&disp=safe&realattid=f_k9iq5sex8
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ui=2&ik=f22b0066d1&attid=0.9&permmsgid=msg-f:16651459
92588529285&th=171bc9753b678e85&view=att&disp=inline&realattid=f_k9iq5sc44
56
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ui=2&ik=f22b0066d1&attid=0.10&permmsgid=msg-f:1665145
992588529285&th=171bc9753b678e85&view=att&disp=inline&realattid=f_k9iq7whz12
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ui=2&ik=f22b0066d1&attid=0.11&permmsgid=msg-f:1665145
992588529285&th=171bc9753b678e85&view=att&disp=inline&realattid=f_k9iq7wg09
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ui=2&ik=f22b0066d1&attid=0.12&permmsgid=msg-f:1665145
992588529285&th=171bc9753b678e85&view=att&disp=inline&realattid=f_k9iq7wgk10
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ui=2&ik=f22b0066d1&attid=0.13&permmsgid=msg-f:1665145
992588529285&th=171bc9753b678e85&view=att&disp=inline&realattid=f_k9iq7wh911
https://www.news18.com/news/opinion/why-reliance-jio-facebook-deal-is-commercially-sensible
-and-good-for-india-subramanian-swamy-writes-2595979.html
https://libertatem.in/articles/jiomart-paves-its-way-to-online-shopping/
57