Professional Documents
Culture Documents
James DiNicolantonio:
Thanks for having us.
Siim Land:
Yeah, I'm glad to be here again.
James DiNicolantonio:
That's a good question. So it stems sort of from me when I was publishing several academic
papers on what seems to be going wrong with people who are suffering from worse COVID-19
outcomes. So we had published several nutraceutical strategies and what seems to be happening
is, essentially, people aren't producing as much Type 1 interferons and there's also a reduction in
their adaptive immune system. So essentially, you don't clear the virus quickly and then you end
up having to rely on a more pro-inflammatory killing of the virus in your own cells.
James DiNicolantonio:
Sure, so essentially we have broken it down in the medical immunity, our immune system is
much more complex than this, but there is the innate immune system, which is your first-line
defense and that's made up of natural killer cells and macrophages and white blood cells like
neutrophils. And then you have something called the adaptive immune system, which is
essentially your B cells which produce antibodies and your T cells. And we used to think that the
adaptive immune system is sort of like this system that takes a while to kick in, and once you
have immunity from your adaptive immune system, then you sort of have a longer-term
protection, which is true. However, the adaptive immune system also seems to have cross-
sensitivity. Meaning if you've been exposed to previous coronaviruses, your T cells seem to have
some cross-sensitivity to SARS-CoV-2.
James DiNicolantonio:
So essentially what we see is you have these people with a reduction in their T cells, in their
cytotoxicity of these CDAT killer cells, which kill in the nice, apoptotic, controlled way. Now
when you have a reduction in those type of immune cells, now you have to have your pro-
inflammatory innate immune system kick in. Things like neutrophils, white blood cells,
macrophages. They kill in a much more pro-inflammatory, non-specific way, and they end up
killing healthy bystander cells.
James DiNicolantonio:
What we think is going on, Joe, is essentially you have this reduction in Type 1 interferons,
which, again, our immune system produces these interferons which helps us interfere with the
virus. And at the same token, you have a reduction in B cells and T cells. So what ends up
happening again is you don't clear the virus, and you end up having this pro-inflammatory
killing. To your point, Siim and I collaborated because these things are complex. We need to get
this in layman's terms. And essentially what our book boils down to is your diet and your
lifestyle control those types of things, and there's things that you can do to boost your own
immune system.
Siim Land:
Yeah. I do. I want to add maybe like that let's say for example, the T cell function also declines
with age and chronic diseases. So you see a lot of these commonalities that the people who are
experiencing the worst outcomes from COVID-19 are the elderly or someone who has these
comorbidities like diabetes, hypertension, metabolic syndrome, cardiovascular disease and all
those things. They definitely worsen the pro-inflammatory response that you get from the virus,
but it also just weakens the immunity in general. So yeah, the book is going to talk about how
can you maybe sidestep that process or prevent against that, and yeah, we draw not only on a
dietary strategies but everything starting with saunas, intermediate fasting, exercise and sleep. It's
a very holistic approach to looking at the immune system.
James DiNicolantonio:
Just to say one thing, Joe, on this topic of reduced T cell killing, which we believe to be a
primary cause of severe COVID-19. If you look at people with genetically low magnesium levels
in their cell, the ionic free magnesium, which is actually the magnesium that's active in the body.
So you can have normal, total serum magnesium, but if you're ionic free magnesium is low, you
actually have magnesium deficiency. Well what we see is occurring potentially is a deficiency in
this free ionic magnesium in our immune cells. So people who have genetically low magnesium
in their natural killer cells and their CDAT killer cells, their cytotoxicity of their immune system
is down. They have chronic activation of Epstein-Barr, which 95% of us are infected with, and
they're at a much higher risk of lymphoma and that's just one nutrient, being deficient and one
nutrient can cause this immunodeficiency essentially. So we go through the book on how
nutrients in your immune system interact and why nutrient deficiencies are probably leading a lot
of these poor COVID-19 outcomes.
James DiNicolantonio:
And you make a good point. Because it's so complex, and-
James DiNicolantonio:
There are so many different contributors.
James DiNicolantonio:
And I guess let's go from the highest to the lowest in my opinion. Number one would be vitamin
D deficiency because-
James DiNicolantonio:
Well, of course, from a mechanistic [crosstalk 00:08:57]-
James DiNicolantonio:
Well, I mean, let's talk about how it works in the body. It activates over 2,000 genes, including
vitamin K-dependent proteins and repair genes. So it's extremely [crosstalk 00:09:13]-
James DiNicolantonio:
Oh, I know. Joe, I know.
James DiNicolantonio:
So I guess from a risk perspective, age, being over 60 might increase your risk of dying by
ninefold. Being profoundly vitamin D deficient increases your risk of dying from COVID-19 by
up to fifteenfold. So you can't change your age, but you can certainly change your vitamin D
status. In my opinion, that's number one.
James DiNicolantonio:
Number two would have-
Dr. Joseph Mercola:
See, that's a beautiful pearl, and if you read your book, you don't get that message, at least I
didn't get it from reading it. [crosstalk 00:09:53] perspective is just so useful because that's what
people need. They need to understand how to focus their limited time, effort, energy and
resources.
James DiNicolantonio:
The book came out almost a month ago, and unfortunately most of these studies have just come
out on vitamin D.
James DiNicolantonio:
Well, the really good ones. Not the pre-prints, Joe. I'm talking about the actual peer-reviewed,
academic, BMJ and these gold standard ones have just recently come out. And I can cover some
of those, which are pretty intriguing, and I haven't seen you cover these studies yet.
James DiNicolantonio:
But however, so vitamin D helps us produce these antibacterial, antiviral cathlocedons, which is
extremely important, how we naturally fight infections.
James DiNicolantonio:
[inaudible 00:10:46]. Alpha and beta defenses too and nucleocapsids and all these other types of
things. And essentially though it's calcitriol that's doing all the work. It's the active of vitamin D,
and in order to activate it, you need magnesium for the enzymes to convert it. So in my opinion,
magnesium would be number two, not only from the fact that you can't activate vitamin D
without magnesium, but also from the fact that if you have low magnesium in the cell of your
immune cells, that makes them immunodeficient essentially.
James DiNicolantonio:
It still requires magnesium, those enzymes.
Dr. Joseph Mercola:
No, of course. But we didn't even know that that activation – we thought we had to go to liver
first and then to kidney and then go to the cells. But the cells themselves actually make the
conversion.
James DiNicolantonio:
Correct. Yeah, you're right. I mean, even prostate cells synthesize their own active vitamin D. So
essentially, again, it's one of the largest risk factors, poor vitamin D status with worse outcomes
increase in mortality as well. And then obviously magnesium.
James DiNicolantonio:
Going down from there is zinc. Zinc is just from the clinical studies on common cold, we know
that if you get the dose right, you take within 24 hours, zinc has been shown to cut the duration
of the common cold by six to seven days if you get – and there are some complex things with
zinc. You got to get the form correct. If you're using lozenges, you have to take it every two
hours. You got to take it within 24 hours of symptom onset. You have to take about 18
milligrams per dose, and you have to get the total dose over 75 milligrams. So some of these
things are complex, but when you do it correctly, you can see basically complete elimination in
the duration of the common cold. So that would be probably by third.
James DiNicolantonio:
Fourth would be selenium simply because not only is selenium deficiency associated with a
fivefold higher risk of dying from COVID and a thirtyfold higher risk of having a poor COVID
outcome. But the fact that if you look at other RNA viruses that are nonvirulent, like coxsackie
virus, which can cause hand, foot and mouth [disease]. If you're deficient in selenium, that leads
to Keshan disease, which is cardiomyopathy. So if you're deficient selenium, that can take a
nonvirulent RNA virus and make it virulent and cause induced cardiomyopathy, and you treat
these patients by simply giving them selenium.
James DiNicolantonio:
So I think selenium is a huge player not only from that perspective, but a lot of these studies have
shown that most COVID patients are [vitamin] D deficient, selenium deficient, zinc deficient,
vitamin C deficient. And then of course-
James DiNicolantonio:
In my opinion, the primary benefit from selenium would be thioredoxin reductase and
methionine self-oxide reductase, which is required to essentially reduce oxidized methionine
residues on oxidized protein. So if you want to heal an oxidized protein, you need thioredoxin
reductase, which requires selenium, then, of course, glutathione peroxidase also requires
selenium. And you're correct that if you want to boast glutathione levels, selenium needs to be
sort of improved, and then from a thyroid perspective, in order to activate thyroid hormones, you
need selenium.
James DiNicolantonio:
And the thing is our foods are becoming more deficient in selenium as well. There's been a
depletion of selenium in our foods, and that may be contributing as well to why so many COVID
patients maybe deficient in selenium.
James DiNicolantonio:
And then from a personal theoretical perspective, in my opinion, things that would really move
the needle in several COVID patients would be inhaled nitric oxide, inhaled molecular hydrogen,
melatonin.
James DiNicolantonio:
No. Well, inhaled hydrogen peroxide potentially, but I'm talking about inhaled hydrogen at 2%
to 3%.
James DiNicolantonio:
Correct, at 2% to 3% because all the animal models show that in hypoxic or hyperoxemia, when
you throw a patient on a ventilator and just give them oxygen, that is a super-oxidative stressed
state. Melatonin is interesting because I kind of view it like molecular hydrogen but actually with
some additional advantages. So like molecular hydrogen, melatonin can freely pass into any cell
membrane, so that's very key. If you want to get to the oxidative stress, you have to be able to
access it and get into the mitochondria. Melatonin and molecular hydrogen are your two
molecules that can really do that and really do that well.
James DiNicolantonio:
Inhaled molecular hydrogen seems to activate NRF2, whereas oral seems to primarily work
through ghrelin and activating ghrelin receptors. But melatonin is not just this hormone we
secrete in the brain. We synthesize it. We synthesize it from serotonin, and it can be produced in
many cells. So it's active throughout the entire day.
James DiNicolantonio:
But what's interesting is that it's one of the only molecules that seems to increase the
transcription of NRF2. So most plant polyphenols and all these other NRF2 boosters, they only
inhibit the inhibitor of NRF2, which is KEAP1, and essentially they're making the current NRF2
levels more active. Well, when you add melatonin, that increases the transcription of NRF2, very
few molecules can actually do that. And NRF2 is how we boost our endogenous antioxidant
enzymes. Really that's the key. If you have acute respiratory distress, you want to boost your
overall endogenous antioxidant systems, and the best way to do that probably is through NRF2
activators, particularly melatonin. But we had a whole slew of other molecules that can-
James DiNicolantonio:
Well, I can't recommend anything. But if we look at the most recent case series published on 10
patients who had COVID pneumonia, they were given 36 to 72 milligrams of melatonin total per
day in four divided doses. The study actually said it was given by mouth. It's a PO. In those
studies, so essentially you're looking at 10 to 20 milligrams of melatonin four times per day, and
typically-
James DiNicolantonio:
It is, but back to the molecular hydrogen point is it's so safe. I mean, doses of melatonin up to
1,000 milligrams per day in humans have shown virtually no side effects besides grogginess and
sleepiness. And what the studies, the observation on them – I want to be clear on this, these are
observational studies. So can't prove causation. However, melatonin use is associated with an
83% reduction in mortality from COVID, a 30% to 50% reduction in testing positive for SARS-
COV-2, and in a case series of 10 COVID pneumonia patients, it cut the duration of hospital stay
by five days. And none of those patients who got melatonin ended up on a mechanical ventilator
or died. Whereas similar severe COVID cases that were hospitalized at the same time, 25% to
40% of those individuals ended up on mechanical ventilators or died.
James DiNicolantonio:
So there's really good observational and mechanistic information that this very, very safe
compound at an appropriate dose may have some significant utility.
James DiNicolantonio:
Well, what's really cool about melatonin, we didn't really realize this until maybe 10 years ago.
Not only is it actively produced throughout the day and that it's this master antioxidant, meaning
it can actually scavenge free radicals. It binds to melatonin receptors which also upregulate
antioxidant defense systems, and melatonin actually seems to concentrate in the bone marrow
and that's important because your immune system comes from your bone marrow, comes from
stem cells produced from your bone marrow. And then from those stem cells, you get your
immune cells. Now your immune cells can even produce melatonin, some of your immune cells.
And we think that it's being concentrated in the bone marrow to protect immature stem cells and
immune cells from damage, which actually makes a lot of sense.
James DiNicolantonio:
Well, we're talking about in the hospital. I'm talking about if there-
James DiNicolantonio:
Oh yeah, yeah. Sure, sure.
James DiNicolantonio:
Well, I think you make a good point that while it might be somewhat difficult to make an inhaled
hydrogen peroxide at home-
James DiNicolantonio:
[inaudible 00:23:18] and I are a little stubborn.
James DiNicolantonio:
Well, I think it makes a lot of sense to do an actual clinical study and test these things because if-
James DiNicolantonio:
Yeah. I mean, ultimately it comes down to for the easiest things for people to do, of course.
James DiNicolantonio:
The optimal diet, make sure your nutrient status is optimal, exercise, and then we go through
some other strategies too, sunlight and things [crosstalk 00:24:37]-
Dr. Joseph Mercola:
Let's hand it over to our other guest, Siim, who can complement what you just shared because he
is the really widely viewed as having enormous wisdom at his young age of mid-20s of what
physical biological strategies you can employ that are historically effective that can be so
powerful in optimizing the immune response. So Siim, why don't you give us your perspective?
Siim Land:
Yeah, absolutely. And I do agree a lot with James that optimizing your nutrient status is one of
the kind of key things that we should all focus on, at least preventing those deficiencies. That is
very easy to do as well. But as we are talking about nutrition, I would maybe also add that one of
the best preventive let's say toolkits for preventing the severity of any infections and
strengthening your immune system is just take care of metabolic health. Like research does find
that metabolic syndrome and obesity and diabetes, all those things, they worsen the outcomes of
COVID-19 as well as other infections, like influenza and other diseases. Especially it's quite bad
because obesity also increases the duration that you can carry the virus and share it for longer. So
it's especially negative in a society that tends to be not in good metabolic health.
Siim Land:
One interesting thing that we did discover doing the writing of the book is that one of the
molecules that gets activated during an infection is called HMGB1, which stands for High
Mobility Group Box-1, and that gets activated during an infection. And stress and it's one of
these key molecules that kind of offsets the cytokine storm by activating NFKB and NLRP3
inflammasome and eventually causes this massive pro-inflammatory cytokine response. The
thing that we discovered was that HMGB1 uses different receptors to get into the cell, one of
them being [inaudible 00:27:03] like receptors but others is the receptor for advance glycation
end-products. So what we theorized based upon this research would conclude is that
hyperglycemia, insulin resistance, elevated blood sugar will make it more likely that HMGB1 is
going to get into the cell and turn on NFKB and these other pro-inflammatory cytokines that will
just eventually lead to the cytokine storm.
James DiNicolantonio:
That's a great point, and I think from a COVID-19 perspective, that the biggest thing that you
want to do is increase the resilience of your cells to oxidative stress.
James DiNicolantonio:
Fortunately if you're consuming a diet high in linoleic acid, if it doesn't get burned, the half-life
of linoleic acid is 680 days.
James DiNicolantonio:
I'm sure if we were to actually look at the blood levels of oxidized linoleic acid in these severe
COVID patients, they would be sky high. And what people don't [crosstalk 00:34:19]-
James DiNicolantonio:
What most people, too, don't appreciate is we used to target and be really concerned with things
called eicosanoids. Aspirin kind of inhibits these inflammatory molecules, but OXLAMs, which
you had mentioned, are oxidized linoleic acid metabolites are orders of magnitude much higher
than those, like a hundredfold. And in disease states, we see they're even higher than that. So
yeah, it's totally a huge driver of overall inflammation.
Dr. Joseph Mercola:
Yeah, yeah. So good. So any comments on this, Siim?
Siim Land:
Yeah. I want to mention that these oxidized omega-6 fats are really bad, but it's also, like you
alluded to, that even healthy omega-3s can become oxidized. So it's not necessarily the fat itself
that is causing the damage. It's the oxidation of the fat and oxidation of the lipids that is going to
cause this inflammatory response and promote DNA damage and other things. So you have to
also be careful with the omega-3s, like salmon and fish. If you overcook it, over-fry it or cook it
in vegetable oil or something, then it's going to be harmful for you because the fats in them, the
polyunsaturated fats in the fish are going to get oxidized, and like most stuff, the fish oil
supplements in the market, they are probably oxidized because they are sitting on the shelf for
too long underneath the heat and light. So yeah, you want to consume fats that haven't been
oxidized regardless of what the source is coming from.
James DiNicolantonio:
I would like to make one point on omega-3s and cardiolipins. So it's actually the DHA
(docosahexaenoic acid) in the cardiolipin that if a cell becomes damaged, that is the signal for
apoptosis to essentially prevent it from turning into a cancerous cell. So if you don't have enough
DHA in the cardiolipin because not all oxidized omega-3s are bad. We actually use oxidized
omega-3s as signaling molecules to kill damaged cells. So what I want to tell people so you don't
have enough DHA in your cardiolipin, that's a big problem.
James DiNicolantonio:
Well, I think number one, taking a step back, there are two different types of oxalates. There are
soluble, which are the actual harmful oxalates. Then there's insoluble, which you don't absorb
and you just poop out. So that's number one. Number two, the amount of calcium is going to
determine how much oxalate you absorb. So if you have a food like spinach that's really high in
oxalates but it's also extremely high in calcium, you don't absorb much of that oxalate. And I'll
give you an example from a randomized-
James DiNicolantonio:
I mean, you don't need to consume a ton of, and I don't really eat a ton of seeds. I do eat some
nuts, particularly like pecans. I like pecans for the manganese. Nature packages these foods with
antioxidants in coatings on the linoleic acid. So I get it. You don't want to overconsume these
foods to get a level of linoleic acid, like 10 grams per day. But if you're only getting a couple of
grams of linoleic acid, it's probably not a huge deal. I just [crosstalk 00:41:42]-
James DiNicolantonio:
I just want to say one thing too about the oxalates because some people – this whole story of
oxalates depends on a lot of things. Your B6 status, what type of microbiota you have, what type
of oxalate it is. I mean, there have been clinical studies that have given 20 times a normal oxalate
intake, and as long as the calcium intake is about 3,000 milligrams, there [crosstalk 00:42:24]-
James DiNicolantonio:
There's no increase in oxalates in the urine, and no increase in oxalates still in formation. So it's a
very nuanced topic, and I just don't want people to demonize plants simply because they contain
oxalates. That's my kind of little bit of a pushback.
James DiNicolantonio:
Yeah. That was a [crosstalk 00:42:46]-
James DiNicolantonio:
I agree.
Siim Land:
I can talk about it. So NAD needs a very important enzyme involved with virtually all processes
in the body, including immunity. So it can also just regulate the immune cells and enhances the
activity of interferons, which have like antiviral effects. Like I mentioned, a lot of the NAD that
your body produces is being recycled through the salvage pathway. Very little of it is going to
come from food, especially tryptophan or niacin.
Siim Land:
Yeah. Yeah. But if you're, let's say-
Siim Land:
For sure.
Siim Land:
Yeah. Absolutely. And the easiest way to prevent losing your NAD as you get older or as you get
immunocompromised is to promote the salvage pathway, and one of the activators of this
NAMPT enzyme that is governing the salvage pathway is AMPK, which is AMP-activated
protein kinase, and AMPK gets primarily turned on by these catabolic stressors in the body, like
exercise, sauna, colds, as well as fasting. So what I've kind of come to the conclusion is that
doing this regular intermittent fasting or timed eating is a very efficient way of keeping our
energy levels high and preventing the lowering of the other things that lower NAD like
inflammation and oxidative stress. But the problem is also that NAMPT is controlled by sirtuins
and sirt-1 especially. So sirtuins are longevity genes that Sinclair researched. Sirtuins also are
controlling the circadian rhythms.
Siim Land:
So what I think is that if your circadian rhythms are misaligned, your experiencing shift work or
you're jet lagged or something, then sirtuins are not going to be expressed, and you will also then
inhibit NAMPT, which will then shut down NAD resalvage, and that maybe explain also why
people who have circadian mismatches, they experience these chronic diseases, especially
[crosstalk 00:47:16]-
Siim Land:
Yeah, I think so because the NAMPT requires sirtuins to work.
James DiNicolantonio:
Right. That's the key message. It's not we're telling people to take NR like that's necessary.
James DiNicolantonio:
That's in the margin. It's sort of like [crosstalk 00:48:17]-
Siim Land:
I think the supplemental NR and NMN are very useful if you're in an NAD-deficient state
because the problem is that if you're already low in NAD, then it's hard to raise that bar so to say
because you're already so low and depleted. Whereas if you're high NAD, then you experience
the less negative side effects from inflammation oxidative stress because your body can repair
and deal with it. Whereas if you're immunocompromised, you're very old or you are just nutrient-
deficient, and you have low NAD, then it's a vicious feedback loop that you're going to be going
down in a downward spiral. So using something like an NAD precursor or a booster can be just
the way of let's say getting a quick fix and maybe getting yourself back on the right track.
Siim Land:
Yeah. If you're taking NMN or NR by itself alone, then you could probably combine it with
some methyl donors like trimethylglycine, glycine, B12, creatine itself or something to prevent
that loss of methyl donors.
James DiNicolantonio:
Yeah. I would just say a key message could be figure out what is causing your NAD depletion
rather than just trying to supplement because [crosstalk 00:50:21]-
James DiNicolantonio:
Well, ultimately it's going be an underlying root cause of any type of oxidative stress is going to
deplete NAD. So fix your metabolic dysfunction, improve your nutrient deficiencies first, and
ultimately your NAD need is going to go down. Fix the things that are causing you to burn
through your NAD.
Dr. Joseph Mercola:
I agree. And the most common one, the one I actually wrote my last book on was EMF exposure
because there are two primary enzymes that consume it. One is PARP, poly ADP-ribose
polymerases, more recently transformed their name to ARTD, adenosine ribosyl transferase. But
that is the one that is used to repair DNA damage, and for every time PARP is activated are using
150 molecules of NAD. So that's a big one, and CD38 is another one that's an immune response.
So if you have all these immune exposures as a result of being metabolically unhealthy, you're
going to consume it. But I think you're right, those are the two things.
Siim Land:
Yeah, and they can also lower inflammation, which will preserve more NAD.
James DiNicolantonio:
One would be to fix hyperinsulinemia, which affects 75% of U.S. adults. Essentially cutting out
refine carbs, sugars and seed oils because again, it's about demand when it comes to nutrient
status. So when you have high levels of insulin, you're kicking out more magnesium and
calcium, and when your cells are insulin-resistant, they don't utilize the nutrients as well because
in order to get magnesium or potassium into the cell, the cell utilizes insulin signaling. So if your
cells are resistant to insulin, again, that's increasing your need for nutrients.
James DiNicolantonio:
So fixing hyperinsulinemia, which is completely underdiagnosed. No one does a Kraft insulin
assay, but when you do that, about 75% of U.S. adults have hyperinsulinemia.
James DiNicolantonio:
A Kraft insulin-
James DiNicolantonio:
Most clinicians do know what an oral glucose tolerance test is. You simply just add an insulin
assay to that same test. It's very simple to do, and we know that 50% to 75% of people with a
normal oral glucose tolerance test will actually have an abnormal insulin assay. So essentially
you have so many people with undiagnosed diabetes in the common general population.
James DiNicolantonio:
The other thing you had touched on-
James DiNicolantonio:
Yeah. 100%. That message needs to get out there more for sure.
James DiNicolantonio:
Two other key factors would be things that disrupt your melatonin production throughout the
day. Not getting adequate sunlight in the morning, throughout the day, in the evening because
you need that. We evolved with very bright days and very dark nights, and now we're living in a
society of dim days, dim lights. And try to turn off your lights at night or if you need to use blue
blockers, fine, because those things help you to inhibit the melatonin suppressors throughout the
day.
James DiNicolantonio:
And then sauna. I have an infrared clear-light sauna, and I use it about five times a week. And
what's interesting is first of all, mammals for the past hundreds of millions of years have utilized
fever as a first line of defense against infections, and a sauna can mimic that. So what was
interesting when they were first researching this, they took cold-blooded animals, and they put
them in essentially a sauna, raised their temperature, heat-shocked them, and then gave them
lethal viruses, and their mortality was significantly reduced.
James DiNicolantonio:
We can increase our own response, our own internal temperature when we have an infection, but
cold-blooded animals, it's determined on exogenous. So they wanted to just strictly test if
literally heating them from the outside could have this type of effect, and it was shown to do it
not only obviously in mammals but also cold-blooded animals, which is really interesting.
James DiNicolantonio:
And then the real magic happened when they started heat-shocking mice, giving them lethal
avian or bird flu, which is what caused the 1918 Spanish flu. And when they heat-shocked these
mice essentially throwing them in sauna prior to infecting them with lethal bird flu, the lung
pathology mortality and viral replication was significantly lower if they got heat-shocked first.
James DiNicolantonio:
And then the real great mechanistic studies that determined how this all works started coming
out, and essentially what happens is the reason why we induce a fever to fight an infection is
because that allows our cells to secrete heat-shock proteins. And in order for a virus to replicate,
it has to infect your cell, hijack your machinery, and it has to export its ribonucleoprotein
complex out of the cell. In order for that complex to get exported out, the M1 protein has to dock
onto it. Heat-shock protein 70 combined to the complex, prevent M1 protein from docking, and
essentially inhibit the export of that viral ribonucleoprotein complex, essentially inhibiting viral
replication.
James DiNicolantonio:
And we've seen through numerous prospective studies that people who go into the sauna four to
five times a week, get about 20 to 25 minutes a session, are at a much significantly lower risk of
the common cold, influenza, pneumonia, and there's even a clinical study in people where they
divided – one group got some sessions; the other didn't. And there was a 50% reduction in the
common cold. So even human studies have sort of tested this theory out. People will ask me,
"Well, can I just jump in a hot tub?" But you need to activate heat-shock proteins in the sinuses,
the nasal passages, and the throat because that's where viruses like to initially infect and
propagate is, in cooler areas. You don't get that benefit in a hot tub.
James DiNicolantonio:
You don't even need a sauna. You can exercise in the heat or you can put on multiple layers of
clothes and exercise to boost your whole core body temperature. The key is to activate heat-
shock proteins throughout the entire body. And you can even go and sit in your car on a hot
summer day if you don't have a sauna.
Siim Land:
Yeah.
James DiNicolantonio:
Siim's going to have to run about 3 miles really fast in about 12 layers of clothes.
Siim Land:
Yeah. A few burpees is going to do it.
Siim Land:
No, no, no. It's not.
Siim Land:
Not yet, but it's getting slightly chilly. So I think maybe like 19. No, no, 9 degrees Fahrenheit,
something like that.
Siim Land:
Well, yeah. Maybe I'll also add the sauna, doing regular sauna and exercise are one of the best
things for just strengthening your immune system and increasing your resilience. And maybe one
thing that we also discovered from writing the book is that the exercise itself also causes this
hormetic effect. It's called preconditioning hormesis so that if you are exercising beforehand or
getting heat-shocked before experiencing some infection or stress, then you do definitely bolster
yourself against that and the studies show that. So you shouldn't be afraid of this small amounts
of oxidative stress that's coming from the beneficial sources, like exercise or the heat because
it's-
Siim Land:
No, I mean, both of them are going to be beneficial for bolstering yourself against the infections
that you may come across or other viruses.
Siim Land:
Yeah, that's how I do it because the heat can also promote recovery from the exercise, like
boosting growth hormone, repairing the damaged proteins and just getting a reduction in the
inflammation as well. So I personally do the sauna after exercise, especially if it's resistance
exercise.
James DiNicolantonio:
No, I introduced that into the book.
Siim Land:
But I personally still do the cold after the sauna sometimes, but I don't do it all the time.
Personally, I just enjoy it. I do believe maybe getting this alternative effect, you condition your
body to swap back and forth between these two extremes. But if you don't have access to the
cold or something, then a regular sauna is also definitely very beneficial.
James DiNicolantonio:
That's okay. So essentially what the studies show, if you exercise and then you do cold therapy,
that can prevent and blunt the benefits of exercise. Whereas sauna seems to have the opposite
effect. But in the same token, you don't want to do sauna-
James DiNicolantonio:
Let me finish.
James DiNicolantonio:
I'll get to the point here. I kind of lost my train of thought. So the studies show, but the same flip
side, if you go into the sauna, that's the worst thing to do the day before an event. You never
want to do sauna the day before a triathlon because it takes more to recover from that event. So
numerous studies have shown if you sauna the day prior to an event, it definitely worsens your
competition and how well you do in any type of performance. It's good to do it after the event
because it's enhancing the benefits of exercise.
James DiNicolantonio:
Now the reason why I don't think you want to do cold therapy after sauna is because the heat-
shock proteins are elevated for a long time. They don't just instantly fall down. Instead of
allowing your body to deal with that high heat, you're instantly giving it an easy way out. You're
automatically now going into the cold, and not fully, in my opinion, getting the full benefits of
the sauna. So I don't like to alternate because I don't like to make it easy on my body after I've
gone into the sauna.
James DiNicolantonio:
That's a great point. To keep the pores open essentially, what you're saying-
James DiNicolantonio:
Right. So people who don't know, there have been several good studies, particularly on infrared
sauna that you do eliminate phthalates, which are these flame retardants. Well, flame retardants
too, but phthalates, which are plastic linings in cups and stuff, like in coffee cups, and you
eliminate heavy metals through sweating and a bunch of other-
James DiNicolantonio:
Yeah, and BPA (bisphenol A) you can even eliminate too through sweating through sauna. So
that's a good point as well that we are living in this environment where we accumulate heavy
metals, cadmium and all these other types of persistent organic pollutants, and we store them in
our fat as well, which can be released through fasting. So binding those seem to be important,
and essentially fasting can have a downside. If you have stored a ton of these persistent organic
pollutants and then you just fast, you get a tremendous release, and some of these are neurotoxic.
So there are strategies, potential binding strategies if-
James DiNicolantonio:
Yes, yeah.
James DiNicolantonio:
No, I don't think so. I think though if you're jumping in an ice bath for a couple minutes, I think
that will inhibit-
Siim Land:
Yeah, that's a good point. Maybe if you want to optimally maximize the benefits from the heat-
shock proteins, then do the cold bath maybe like an hour or two later where your body has
already kind of processed the heat-shock proteins. Then you can cool down because you don't
want to be constantly activating these stress responses as well because the heat-shock stress is a
stress response, and let's say if you're not cooling down afterwards, then that can also be
problematic if it's chronically elevated.
Siim Land:
You too.
James DiNicolantonio:
Good seeing you, Joe.
Siim Land:
Yeah.
James DiNicolantonio:
Yeah, DrJamesDinic.com. And Twitter and Instagram is @DrJamesDinic D-I-N-I-C.
Siim Land:
Yeah. My YouTube and social media channels are all Siim Land, and my website is
SiimLand.com.
James DiNicolantonio:
Thanks, Joe.
Siim Land:
Thanks.