You are on page 1of 6

2012

International Symposium on Power Electronics,


Electrical Drives, Automation and Motion

Five-Axis Magnetic Suspension with Two


Conical Air Gap Bearingless PM Synchronous
Half-Motors
Gabriel Munteanu*, Andreas Binder** and Stefan Dewenter*
* Institute of Electrical Energy Conversion, Darmstadt University of Technology (Germany)
** Senior Member IEEE (Germany)

Abstract--A novel type of “bearingless” permanent


magnet (PM) synchronous motor is presented. The motor
consists of two conical air gap bearingless PM half-motors,

RMB

RMB
MOTOR AMB CMB MOTOR CMB
mounted on a single shaft. Each conical stator houses two
separate three-phase distributed AC windings with different
magnetic pole pair counts. The motor winding has the same
a) b)
pole count as the PM rotor for the generation of the torque
and the axial force. For time invariant radial levitation
forces, the second winding (the levitation winding) must CBM
BM BM AMB CBM CBM
have one pole pair more or less than the rotor PM field. It
must be fed with the same electrical frequency as the motor
winding. With this drive arrangement all six degrees of
freedom of the rigid rotor can be actively stabilized and c) d)
controlled without using any further active magnetic Fig. 1. Schematic representation of a five-axes magnetically levitated
bearings. A prototype with a rated mechanical output power drive using: a) two radial magnetic bearings (RMB) and one axial
magnetic bearing (AMB), b) two conical air gap magnetic bearings
of 1 kW at a rated speed of 18 000 rpm has been designed (CMB), c) two bearingless half-motors (BM) and one axial magnetic
and built, in order to validate the theory. bearing (AMB) or d) two conical air gap bearingless motors (CBM)

Index Terms—Conical air gap, magnetic suspension, PM Fig. 1b), can be used in applications, where modest axial
bearingless motor loads occur.
The discovery of the field oriented control, the
I. INTRODUCTION advances in power electronics and in digital control have
The idea of magnetic levitation goes back more than permitted the development of the “bearingless motors”
150 years, but its real tangible applications have been as an alternative to the magnetic bearing levitated drives.
developed only in the past two decades. Technical With bearingless motors the radial magnetic suspension
breakthroughs in the sensor, digital signal processor, is integrated into the motor active part. So, they produce
power electronics and control areas have made the the torque, suspend and position magnetically the rotor
magnetic levitation economically feasible. Many on two axes. Consequently, instead of two radial
magnetic bearings, two parts of bearingless motors with
applications (turbo-molecular vacuum pumps, turbo-
half the mechanical output power can be applied.
compressors, machine tool spindles, etc.) from different
However, the axial magnetic bearing is still necessary for
industry sectors have profited from an increase in a fully five-axes magnetically supported rotor [4]
performance due to the numerous advantages offered by (Fig. 1c)). The thrust magnetic bearing, as a separate
the magnetic suspension [1]: no lubrication and no component, is no longer required, if the two bearingless
mechanical wear, controlled air gap, higher possible rotor motor parts are built with conical air gap instead of
circumferential speeds, vibration control and on-line cylindrical air gap, as depicted in Fig. 1d). The latter
process monitoring, increased reliability and increased drive arrangement is investigated in this paper, based on a
maintenance intervals. 1 kW prototype with a rated speed of 18 000 rpm.
Usually, the five-axes active magnetic suspension of
rotors is technically implemented as a combination of one II. RADIAL FORCE, AXIAL FORCE AND TORQUE
axial and two radial magnetic bearings [2] as shown in GENERATION IN A CONICAL AIR GAP BEARINGLESS PM
Fig. 1a). The radial bearings are placed on each side of MOTOR
the motoring unit and the axial bearing is integrated either The basic principle of the motor and the mathematical
at the drive-end (DE) or at the non-drive end (NDE) of expressions of the torque, the radial and the axial forces
the shaft. The overall length of the machine can be are derived here for PM bearingless motors. The
reduced, if the radial magnetic bearings are replaced by analytical calculations are based on the Maxwell’s stress
two conical air gap magnetic bearings [3]. This modality tensor for a conical air gap. In continuum mechanics the
of a five-axes active magnetic levitation, depicted in stress is defined as force per unit area of a surface within

978-1-4673-1301-8/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE


1246
a deformable material. In the same way the components system ( x, y, z ) via the transformation matrix (6) from
of the Maxwell’s stress tensor signify a force density of the cylindrical coordinate system (r , α , z ) .
magnetic origin. The tensor is diagonal symmetric and
has the following matrix expression as an only function
G ª x º ªcos α − sin α 0º ª r º
of the vector field strength H components in an arbitrary « y » = « sin α cos α 0»» ⋅ ««α »»
« » « (6)
orthogonal coordinate system, defined by the unit vectors
G G G «¬ z »¼ «¬ 0 0 1»¼ «¬ z »¼
e1 , e 2 , e3 :
The forces per area (5) for each axis have then the
ª μH 2 − μH 2 / 2 μH1H 2 μH1H 3 º expressions (7) as a function of the normal and tangential
I « 1 »
f = « μH 2 H1 μH 2 − μH / 2
2 2
μH 2 H 3 » . (1) component of the air gap flux density:
« μH 3 H1 μH 3 H 2 μH 32 − μH 2 / 2»¼
¬ ª fx º ª Bn2 cos α cos γ − 2 Bn Bt sin α º
In order to calculate the forces, a differential area « f » = 1 « B 2 sin α cos γ + 2 B B cos α » .
« y » 2 « n n t » (7)
element is chosen as a part of the conical surface in the 0 « »
«¬ f z »¼ Bn2 sin γ
air gap of the motor, e.g. at the stator bore. The normal ¬ ¼
G
unit vector n on this surface, expressed in cylindrical The normal component of the magnetic field, generated
coordinates, consists of a component in the radial by the motor winding or the levitation winding in the air
direction and one in the axial direction, given by the air gap at stator bore, is calculated either with Finite Element
gap cone angle γ . A cylindrical rotor has the angle (FEM) software or analytically according to [5]:
γ = 0.
2 0 mk wi N si I i
Bˆ in = ⋅ k ci ,
ª n r º ªcos γ º  pi δ (8)
G « » «
n = « n t » = « 0 »» (2) i = 1 : motor winding, i = 2 : levitation winding,
«¬n z »¼ «¬ sin γ »¼
where m is the winding phase count, k wi is the
G
The magnetic field strength H in the conical air gap fundamental winding factor, N si is the number of turns
has a normal and a tangential component, regarding to the per phase and k ci is a curvature effect factor (9) due to
chosen area element. The normal component decomposes
the big effective air gap, composed of the mechanical air
itself into a radial and an axial component with respect to
gap, the bandage and the magnet height:
the chosen cylindrical coordinate system:
δ = δ 0 + hB + hM = rsi − rro . In a conical motor rsi is the
ª H r º ª H n cos γ º average stator bore radius and rro the average rotor back-
G
H = «« H t »» = «« H t »» . (3) iron radius.
«¬ H z »¼ «¬ H n sin γ »¼
p i 1 + (rro / rsi )2 pi
k ci = δ (9)
Using (1), (2) and (3), and according to B =  0 H the rsi 1 − (rro / rsi )2 pi
force components per area on the air gap area element,
G The expression of the amplitude of the PM rotor field
determined by the normal component n , become:
can be found in [6] for surface-mounted parallel and
ªf º
G « r» 1 «
( )
ª Bn2 − Bt2 cos γ º
»
radial magnetized rotor topologies.
f = « ft » = « 2 Bn B t ». (4) A. Radial Force Generation
«¬ f z »¼ (
2 0 « 2
¬
)
Bn − Bt2 sin γ »
¼
For rotating field bearingless motors an additional
three-phase winding is necessary, which is placed in the
The flux lines in the air gap of a low saturated PM same stator slots with the motor winding, which has 2p1
electrical machine are nearly perpendicular to the stator poles as the PM rotor. This levitation winding of different
iron at the stator bore surface. This implies that pole count 2p2 generates in the air gap one magnetic pole
B t2 << Bn2 , hence the force densities simplify further to: pair more p2 = p1+1 or less p2 = p1-1 than the motor
winding.
S
ªf º ª Bn2 cos γ º N S
G « r» 1 « » N N
f = « ft » ≅ « 2 Bn B t » . (5)
2 0 « 2
B sin γ » N N FX
«¬ f z »¼ FY
¬ n ¼
S S S N
In the bearingless motors the rotor position in space is
S
measured axially and in two perpendicular directions at a) b)
each radial suspension point. For this reason it is useful to Fig. 2: Principle of lateral force generation in a 2-pole bearingless PM
express the force densities in the Cartesian coordinate motor: a) vertical force, b) horizontal force

1247
In Fig. 2 the levitation winding excites four poles, as amplitude B̂ 2n is expressed, using (8), as a function of
only one pole pair more is possible with a two-pole rotor:
the current loading amplitude A2 = 2mN s2 I 2 /(2rsi ) . If
p2 = p1+1 = 1+1 = 2. The interaction between the four
pole levitation field wave and the two-pole PM rotor field only the maximum force in the x- or y-direction is
wave leads to a resulting lateral force Fy or Fx, depending considered, i.e. ϕ 0 − ϕ 2 = 0 or  / 2 , the necessary current
on the phase angle of the current in the levitation loading A2 for a desired lateral force F is given as
winding, which is used for the rotor magnetic suspension. follows:
Tangential forces also occur, but their sum in
circumferential direction is zero. The direction and the 2F
amplitude of the lateral bearing force are controlled via A2 = .
§ rsi · (15)
the relative position between rotor d-axis and levitation ˆ ¨
rsi l Fe,γ k w2 B0n ¨ ¸
k c2 cos γ ± 1¸
field d-axis and via the levitation current value, © p 2δ ¹
respectively. The necessary condition for time
independent rotor forces is the feeding of the motor and With (15) the levitation winding of the conical
the levitation winding with three-phase AC sinusoidal bearingless motor is designed. Due to the conical air gap
currents, having the same electrical frequency. Hence the the radial force generation in one half-motor is inherently
levitation field wave rotates asynchronously to the rotor accompanied by an undesired axial force. In the particular
field, e.g. with half the speed in Fig. 2. Theoretically, any case, when the rotor is axially centered and both half-
2p1/2p2 pole count combination, which fulfils the motors produce equal radial forces, the net rotor axial
force is however zero.
condition p 2 = p1 ± 1 , is a possible solution.
For the lateral force calculation it is considered that the B. Torque and Axial Force Generation
normal component of the PM field wave For the torque generation, a three-phase winding with
the same number of magnetic poles (2p1) as in the PM
B0n (α , t ) = Bˆ 0n cos( p1α − ω1t − ϕ 0 ) , (10) rotor is applied, like in conventional AC machines. An
example with a two-pole PM motor is schematically
the normal component
shown in Fig. 3a). If no rotor eccentricity occurs, the sum
B2n (α , t ) = Bˆ 2n sin ( p 2α − ω 2 t − ϕ 2 ) (11) of the radial forces acting between stator and rotor is
zero. Only tangential forces, via Lorentz forces, are acting
and the tangential component of the magnetic field wave on the rotor and stator respectively, thus producing the
required torque. Without saliency, the torque is
B 2t (α , t ) =  0 Aˆ 2 cos( p 2α − ω 2 t − ϕ 2 ) , (12) maximized, if a phase shift of 90 electrical degrees exists
between the stator and the rotor field waves (16) and (10).
produced by the p2-pole pair current loading
These statements are both valid for conical and
A2 (α , t ) = Aˆ 2 cos( p 2α − ω 2 t − ϕ 2 ) (13) cylindrical air gap bearingless motors.
The rotor active axial suspension is usually achieved
of the levitation winding, are present simultaneously in with thrust magnetic bearings. Shorter drives are possible,
the motor air gap ( α : mechanical angle; ϕ i , i = 0, 2 : if two conical magnetic bearings are employed.
Alternatively, two conical bearingless half-motors with
phase angles). In order to obtain simple design formulas half of the necessary total iron active length can axially
for bearingless motors, only the fundamental field waves support the rotating motor part. The conical bearingless
are considered. The iron saturation is neglected. Hence, in motor parts should be identical and oriented axially with
(7) Bn can be replaced by B0n+B2n and Bt by B2t. the smallest bore diameters at the outside as depicted in
Afterwards, each force per area component is integrated Fig. 3b). So, the generated axial forces in each half-motor
over the conical surface at stator bore. If the motor and are acting on the rotor in opposite directions, which
the levitation winding are fed with sine currents, having means that for equal flux densities in both half-motors no
the same angular frequency ω1 = ω 2 , and the pole pair resulting axial force will occur.
count is p2 = p1±1, all three perpendicular force For torque and axial force calculation the magnetic
components are non-zero and independent of time: field wave normal component
§ § ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ·
¨ l r ¨ B0n B2n cos γ ± B0n A2 ¸ ⋅ sin(ϕ −ϕ ) ¸
· B1n (α , t ) = Bˆ1n sin ( p1α − ω1t − ϕ1 ) (16)
¨ Fe,γ si ¨ 2 0 2 ¹ ¸ 0 2
¸
©
§ F2x · ¨ ¸ and the tangential component
¨ ¸ ¨ § Bˆ0n Bˆ 2n Bˆ Aˆ · ¸
¨ F2y ¸ = ¨ ± lFe,γ rsi ¨¨ cos γ ± 0n 2 ¸ ⋅ cos(ϕ 0−ϕ 2 ) ¸ ,
¨F ¸ ¨ © 2  0 2 ¸
¹ ¸ (14) B1t (α , t ) =  0 Aˆ1 cos( p1α − ω1t − ϕ1 ) , (17)
© 2z ¹ ¨
¨
(
lFe,γ rsi Bˆ0n
2
)
+ Bˆ 2n
2
⋅ sin γ
¸
¸ produced by the p1-pole motor winding current loading
¨ 2 0 ¸
© ¹
"+" ⎯⎯→ p2 = p1 + 1; "−" ⎯⎯→ p2 = p1 − 1, A1 (α , t ) = Aˆ1 cos( p1α − ω1t − ϕ1 ) , (18)

where l Fe,γ = l Fe / cosγ is the equivalent stator iron length. and the p1-pole rotor PM field wave (10) are active in the
motor air gap at the same time.
In (14) the normal component of the levitation field wave

1248
the direction of the field strengthened half-motor, as it is
N shown graphically in Fig. 3b) according to:
N M S 2l Fe,γ rsi
Fz = F1z,DE − F1z, NDE = Bˆ 0n Bˆ1n ⋅ sin γ . (20)
S
0

a) In (20) B̂1n is replaced with its expression given by (8)


Field weakening Field strengthening
for the p1-pole motor winding to obtain the design
formula for the axial force:
§ 2 2 m k w1N s1Bˆ0n,1 lFe,γ rsi ·
NDE DE
Fz = ¨ kc1 sin γ ¸ I1d . (21)
¨ p1δ ¸
© ¹
PM field The value of the axial force depends, besides of the
Motor d-field
F1z,DE motor geometry, on the PM air gap flux density, on the
F1z,NDE
F1r,DE F1n,DE air gap cone angle and on the d-component of the motor
F1n,NDE F
1r,NDE winding current.

III. CONICAL AIR GAP BEARINGLESS MOTOR PROTOTYPE


Fz = F1z,DE - F1z,NDE
NDE DE
The conical air gap bearingless motor prototype with
the axial cross section from Fig. 4a) has a mechanical
output power of 1 000 W at a rated speed of 18 000 rpm.
The geometry and electrical parameters of the built
prototype are provided in Table I. The drive is composed
b) of two 500 W conical air gap half-motors, each
Fig. 3: Principle of a) torque and b) axial force generation with two generating half of the drive torque and power (Fig. 4b)).
conical air gap bearingless PM motors On the solid steel shaft two high-strength aluminium
rings are shrink-fitted as radial position measurement
If the stator iron saturation is neglected, in (5) Bn can
surfaces for eddy current distance sensors. These rotor
be replaced by B0n+B1n and Bt by B1t. The forces in
components limit the axial movement of the rotor
cylindrical coordinates per conical half-motor are
between the two auxiliary ball bearings, protect the
calculated by integrating the three components of the
carbon fibre bandages against axial sliding due to the
Maxwell’s stress tensor over the conical surface at stator
rotor conical shape and contain the holes for the
bore:
balancing masses. The PMs of the two-pole rotor are
¨
§ F1r · ¨ 2 0
(
§ lFe,γ rsi ˆ 2
B0n + 2 Bˆ0n Bˆ1n sin(ϕ 0−ϕ1 ) + Bˆ1n
2

⋅ cos γ ¸
¸
made of sintered NdFeB (VACODYM890TP,
Vacuumschmelze, Germany). They have conical outer
¨ ¸ ¨ ¸. and inner surfaces.
F =
¨ 1t ¸ ¨  l r ˆ
B ˆ
A cos(ϕ −ϕ )
Fe,γ si 0n 1 0 1 ¸ (19)
¨ F ¸ ¨ lFe,γ rsi
© 1z ¹
¨ 2 ( B0n + 2 B0n B1n sin(ϕ 0−ϕ1 ) + B1n ⋅ sin γ ¸
ˆ 2 ˆ ˆ ˆ 2

© 0 ¹

In (19) F1r and F1t represent the radial and the


tangential force in cylindrical coordinates, which lead to
zero total forces in Cartesian coordinates. If F1t is
multiplied with the mean radius rsi , the torque of each
half-motor is obtained. Furthermore, if ϕ 0 −ϕ1 = 0 , F1t is
maximum. This means that the motor winding is fed only a)
with q-current. A resulting variable axial force can be
applied on the rotor by changing the air gap magnetic
field density in the two conical half-motors via the d-
component of the motor winding current. The change in
air gap flux density leads to a change of the axial
component F1z of Maxwell’s magnetic pull between rotor
and stator. In order to maximize the axial force value, the
magnetic field in one half-motor is weakened
( ϕ 0 −ϕ1 = − /2 ) and in the second one it is strengthened
( ϕ 0 −ϕ1 = /2 ) by the same amount. So, no torque will be
generated. The difference of the axial forces, produced by b)
Fig. 4 a) Axial cross section of the prototype; b) Conical air gap
each half-motor, gives the net rotor axial force, acting in bearingless motor prototype together with its PM rotor

1249
TABLE I. MAIN DESIGN PARAMETERS OF THE CONICAL IV. MEASUREMENTS
BEARINGLESS PM MOTOR PROTOTYPE
A. Radial and Axial Rotor Position
Parameter Symbol Value
The accuracy of the radial and the axial rotor
Rated power PN 2 x 500 W
positioning depends mainly on the rotor residual mass
Rated speed nN 18 000 rpm
imbalance, the sensor accuracy, the roughness and the
Cone angle  10°
concentric run-out of the measurement surface for the
Min. stator bore diameter dsi,min 32 mm
distance sensors and on the control parameters. In Fig. 5
No-load air gap flux density (calculated) B̂ 0n,cal 0.523 T
the digitally measured rotor positions of all five axes at
Rated radial / axial force Fr,N / Fa,N 10 N / 15 N no-load motor operation and rated speed are shown. All
Motor / levitation winding pole pairs p1 / p2 1/2 five signals vary with the mechanical rotational frequency
Stator slot count Qs 12 and have amplitudes lower than 5 μm. Hence, the rotor is
Active iron length per half-motor lFe 40 mm kept safely within the maximum auxiliary bearing radial
Nr. of turns per phase of motor winding Ns1 30 gap of ±150 μm and within the maximum axial gap of
Nr. of turns per phase of lev. winding Ns2 20 ±400 μm.
Rated motor / levitation winding current I1 / I2 8A/6A
B. Radial and Axial Force Measurement
PM remanence flux density at 20°C BR,20 1.177 T
Variable axial loads can be applied to the rotor using
PM height hM 3 mm
its weight force, just by mounting the motor under
Mechanical air gap length 0 1 mm
different inclination angles as shown in Fig. 6a). An
Carbon fibre bandage height hB 2 mm
increased axial load is achieved with additional calibrated
Rotor mass mr 1.12 kg
weights, attached to the shaft, when the rotor is in a
Cooling method with air - Natural
vertical position. The measured and the analytically
The diametrically magnetized magnets are glued with calculated axial forces versus the motor winding d-
DELO-DUOPOX AD895 (Delo, Germany) to the steel current are compared in Fig. 6b). The measured axial
shaft. They are protected against centrifugal forces by force-current factor kia,mes = 2.37 N/A is close to the
2 mm thick carbon fibre bandages, which were axially expected one kia,cal = 2.59 N/A.
pressed and also glued onto the rotor magnets. The stator 15
iron sheets have different inner diameters, the same slot 10
x −position
DE

cross section area and a constant outer diameter. They yDE−position


/ μm

5
were individually laser-cut from the high-frequency sheet
DE

material M270-35A. Each conical stator has twelve slots 0


,y
DE

and houses the motor winding as well as the levitation −5


x

winding as distributed single layer windings. −10


The conical bearingless PM motor has twelve −15
electrical phases in four independent star-connected 0 10 20 30 40 50
three-phase AC-windings. This means that an inverter t / ms
a)
with twelve legs would be necessary for the PWM 15
voltage supply of the windings. The PWM voltage power x
NDE
−position
10
converter must be able to supply and evaluate the eddy yNDE−position
/ μm

5
current position sensors, the temperature sensors, the
NDE

rotor position angle and the rotational speed transducer. 0


,y
NDE

Such an inverter does not exist as a commercial product. −5


x

However, power electronics for magnetic bearings are −10


commercially available and can also be used to supply −15
small power electrical motors. The bought PWM voltage 0 10 20 30 40 50
t / ms
converter has a power stage, consisting of ten legs, and
b)
therefore it cannot alone feed the four windings of the 15
bearingless motor. Hence, two power converters are 10
needed to supply the conical bearingless motor. The two
5
drive windings, three of the special KTY84-130
z / μm

temperature sensors (in the winding slot and winding 0

overhangs) and the axial position eddy current sensor are −5


connected to the first inverter. The two levitation −10
windings, the other three temperature sensors and the −15
eddy current radial position sensors are connected to the 0 10 20 30 40 50
t / ms
second inverter. The rotor d-axis position angle and the
c)
rotational speed information are needed by both inverters Fig. 5: Measured rotor position of all five axes at rated speed
for the implementation of the field oriented control of the n = 18 000 rpm and no-load motor operation: a) x, y-position at DE,
drive. b) x, y-position at NDE, c) z-position

1250
15 120 60
measured up−DE Up−DE
12 calculated
90
u UpLL−DE

up−DE , upLL−DE / V

Up−DE, UpLL−DE / V
60 pLL−DE
9

Fa /N
30 40
6
0
3
−30
0 20
−60
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
I /A −90
1
−120 0
a) b) 0 2 4 6 8 10 0 6 000 12 000 18 000
Fig. 6: a) Axial loading; b) Measured and calculated axial force t / ms n / rpm
a) b)
15
measured Fig. 10: a) Measured line-to-line and phase back-EMF waveforms at
12 calculated n = 18 000 rpm of the DE motor winding; b) Measured line-to-line and
phase back-EMF r.m.s. values
FrDE /N

6 The arrangement from Fig. 9 will be also used for load


measurements. At rated speed the measured induced
3
phase voltage is nearly sinusoidal (Fig. 10a)) and has a
0 r.m.s. value of 30.1 V (Fig. 10b)). With this value the
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
calculated flux density amplitude at the stator bore is
I /A
2DE
b) Bˆ = 0.49 T , which fits well to the analytically
0n, mes
a)
Fig. 7: a) Radial loading using calibrated weights attached to the shaft; calculated value from Table I ( Bˆ 0n,cal = 0.523 T ).
b) Measured and calculated DE radial force
FrDE = 5.2 N FrNDE = 5.8 N
V. CONCLUSIONS
With two conical air gap bearingless motors all six
degrees of freedom of a rigid rotor can be actively
G = 11.0 N
controlled. This drive arrangement is an alternative
Fig. 8: Weight force distribution between the two bearingless half- concept for electrical machines, levitated with radial and
motors axial magnetic bearings. Only three-phase inverter units
are needed for driving as well as for suspension for all
In order to measure the lateral forces, calibrated degrees of freedom. The electrical power of the motor
weights were attached to the shaft as depicted in Fig. 7a). winding can be used to generate either a higher torque,
The resulting forces in each bearingless half-motor are when low axial loads occur, or a higher axial force, when
calculated from the force and momentum equilibrium low torque is applied to the shaft. The measured
equations according to Fig. 8. The additional weights are performance parameters (rotor radial and axial position,
attached to the shaft drive end (DE), which means that the back-EMF, axial and lateral forces) of the built 1 kW
non-drive end (NDE) half-motor experiences a vertical prototype fit to the calculations. The prototype is still
force decrease and the DE half-motor a vertical force under testing, thermal and loss measurements will be
increase. For this reason in Fig. 7b) the measured DE presented in the near future.
lateral force is compared with the calculated one. The
ratio of the measured to the calculated radial force- REFERENCES
current factor is kir,mes/kir,cal = 2/2.19. [1] G. Schweitzer and E. H. Maslen, Magnetic bearings-Theory,
design, and application to rotating machinery. Berlin Heidelberg:
C. Back-EMF Springer-Verlag, 2009.
[2] P.-K. Budig, "Magnetic Bearings with DC Bias: Design and
The back-EMF measurement delivers useful Optimum Material Choice," in SPEEDAM, Ischia, Italy, 2008, pp.
information regarding the winding and the rotor magnetic 1346-1350.
circuit design, e.g. a check of the air gap magnetic flux [3] C.-W. Lee and H.-S. Jeong, "Dynamic Modeling and Optimal
density. For this test the conical bearingless motor was Control of Cone-Shaped Active Magnetic Bearing Systems,"
Control Eng. Practice (Elsevier Science Ltd.), vol. 4, pp. 1393-
coupled with a PM machine with a rated speed of 1403, 1996.
24 000 rpm (Fig. 9). [4] N. Miyamoto, T. Enomoto, M. Amada, et al., "Suspension
Characteristics Measurement of a Bearingless Motor," IEEE
Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 45 (6), pp. 2795-2798, June 2009.
[5] Z. Q. Zhu and D. Howe, "Instantaneous magnetic field distribution
in brushless permanent magnet dc motors, Part II: armature
reaction field," IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 29, pp. 136-
142, January 1993.
[6] Z. Q. Zhu, D. Howe, E. Bolte, et al., "Instantaneous magnetic field
distribution in brushless permanent magnet dc motors, Part I:
Fig. 9: Conical bearingless prototype (right) on the test bed, coupled via open-circuit field," IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 29, pp.
two elastic couplings and a torque measurement device with a 124-135, January 1993.
24 000 rpm PM load machine (left)

1251

You might also like