Global market risks in ’22, Part I
Key Takeaways
jing earnings relate to
forward earnings growth, beat rte
m.revisons, and earnings
+ Also watching spreads between
earrings yields and bond vies
and correlations between yilds and
+ Moving to neutral on rising US. dolar
but natexpecting a break of 2020,
igh
As we consider here the markets willbe heed
ing n 2022 it can hep to review the progress in
202% in addressing the curent yar, our 2021
Global Outock applied the of used Goldlocks
‘analogy masking whether the macro infuences
would be Yoo cold with dfiatonary disappoint
ments, "toa hot with faonary pressures or
"justright with improving real growth globally.
Soaninto the new year itstated to become
ear thatthe markt outlook incuded ‘sn-
le-digt correction risk’ but not “double-digt
bear markt rik wth the indicator improve
‘mont warranting an equity exposure upgrade to
the maximum. And by mid-year we coud say
thatthe ust ight’ scenario had prevailed
But we aso waned that "Yao good" could
become the batter description. The risk we
‘exhined is that the deal conditions lead
Peak in forward earnings growth
SCI AI Country Word ie Leal Currency
to dsapporement” Itcannow be said thet “t0@
900d" lin fact the relevant description for
the isk ws 2022 approaches, Wo have con
tinued to se similares to 2077 year of ow
volatity and person oamings growth that
held multiple expansion in check even as equity
benchmarks reached record highs. Compacen:
.yfolowed a set-up for dsappointment and 3
dourshit in eorings expectations when global
‘ecenomic condtions wersaned in 2018
There ae enough differences fr doubting
that 2022 willbe a replay of 2018 among them
the magnitude of the moves this yea. As
shown above the year-to-year chango of ACM
‘earings has rebounded more dramatically
thant id during the earlier year. Butrow as
then the earnings growths raising @ potentially
‘markot-treatening question ~ lth as good
asit gets?
‘Year to-year comparsons alone make that
ley. But the market performance may have
‘lotto dowth the extent ofthe fture growth
soudiown, inthe postive scenarig the chart
soli ine remains above its dashed ine asthe
earings growth remains above the foward
growth ofa year earl. nthe nogatve scenario,
earings growth crops more sharly than theforward growth, crossing below it
‘As indecated in our Global Earnings Summary
report the earnings growth pictures consistent
{across the regions in our sever-way framework,
with the forward growth pointing to earnings
‘growth downtrends in all ofthe regions.
‘Among the 50 ACW component markets sbout
three quarters ofthe markets have positive
year-to-year earrings growth (ight third cp)
while 92% have postive forward growth (sec-
fond clip). That's down from 100% And ifthe
forward breacth percentage drops further with
the taling earings breadth percentage rong
‘over as wel the chart wil lok ike did entering
2018.
‘Another recent development isthe slawdown
‘and negative momentum ofthe earnings
beat rates. After71% of the ACW earings
reports beat expectations in the second quarter,
Earnings beat rates losing momentum
Forward earnings growth exceeds trailing in fewer markets
tanta
eeuee
tt
Geen SSS ESESE EES
‘the beat rate stands at 68% with reports from.
about haf ofthe companies Goft) At this rate,
the year-to-year point change will be negative
forthe third quarter. Thats also the case forthe
US. Canada, Japan and Emerging Markets as,
indicated in our report on Earnings Beat Rates
“Tho boat rato pictures thus consiston with
anvearings cyt that’ far mare metue thant
was in May. We explained then tat eventualy
ad inevitably.vestrs would come to expeet
the postive best rates in which case postive
surprises woud ro lnger be suprising.
Whereas the beat rate momentum of May was
consistent with a sustanabie global bull market,
the chart shows thatthe beat rate momentum
has tended to recede as the builshave matured
‘and turn negative with global bear markets
underway. While watching to see whether the
‘talings earings come through better or worse
‘than the previous year’s forward earnings in2022, we will see lf beat rates stabilize or Rate of positive earnings revisions rolling over
contunterecede with mgrtve momen | Aco Wai ig ann onwinh ean
tum thoy i re dob bx met ai
a8
Nectar tang steno omg
‘Alto turning downward are the percent-
ages of companies with postive earnings
revisions Tho percentages have dopped rom
thai highs forthe ACW and for al seven indoes
in our regional tamework
Demonstrating how the revision trends tend to
lead the eamings trends, the chars in our Earn-
ings Revisions Summary report move the revi-
sion percentage foward by a year. The chat at
right shows that the ACW percentage appeared
‘ohit aceling in 207, leaing the earings
‘momentum peak of early 2018 (as shown on
Page 1 and the 2019 downturn the earrings
level. The revisions rate continued to lead the
‘eamings lover until the upturn last year.
PEPER E EE EEEESEESEESERIETEE
Trailing and forward earnings yields starting to fall
We willbe watching to see ifthe revisions rate
‘MSC ACW Tralng an Forward Ernngs Vela BARDOT
‘remains stable, increasing the chances that
the trailing earings growth remeins above the
‘previous year's forward growth, oii instead
‘continues to fall with negative implications not
only for earings growth, but also forthe level
ofeamings.
Inthe later case, valuations would worsen soon-
corthan they would otherwise even without price
‘appreciation But the more likely outcome is
‘earnings stability with dropping earnings
‘momentum and rising disappointment,
similar tothe setup for the market challenges
n208
‘As shown at lf the idle conditions of 2017
sent earings yields higher even asthe ACW!
‘reached record highs keeping valuation
Te ee EE ae Te ‘concer inthe background and complacency
TSa—aieintashtveasnasawerenarse Widespread. That left the market at risk in early
a Steere
ay wor ‘Simtsaimeraecsncsmsn” 2018 when valuations started to worsen atthesame ime that a global economic slowdown
was geting started wth negative implications.
‘The market was vulnerable to disappoint-
‘ment in late2017 and early 2018 and that's
Also ask for 2022
How equities respond to future earnings
‘news should also be influenced by interest
rate trends. The 2021 uptrend in earnings
Yields has improved relative valuations ver-
sus bonds globally. Based on 43 markets, the
‘median spread between the earnings yield and
the bond yield is 300 basis points even after the
(October bond yield advance (right. bottom clip).
The spread was also wide and rising in 2017,
‘and it continued to rise in 2018 due to market
woakness instead of earrings strength. Then as
‘now, bond yields were trencing higher Cbelow,
‘middle clip) A difference today, however is that
the 260-day correlation between the equity
‘benchmark and the global aggregate bond
Earnings yields still much higher than bond yields
ay nor
Stock prices and bond yields now uncorrelated
‘Global Stock/Bond Veld Correlation
Sepp tata
DEAT TERRE
yield has dropped to zero,
‘As 2022 progresses, we willbe watching the ex-
tent to which the valuation gap narrows and the
Correlation inverts. In the worst case, runaway
inflaton and spiraling expectations would send.
‘bond yields sharply higher, closing the valua-
tion gap and leading to an inverse correlation
‘between the aggregate yield and the colapsing
‘equity benchmark. That would be the back
drop for a decisive cyclical bear market,
potantaly raising the secular risks as well
Inthe more favorable transitory infation
scenario, the yield rise would be moderate
‘and tolerated by the market, as real economic
{growth would continue to come through The
valuation g3p would remain elatvely wide and
the corelation would be flat or postive. The
market risk would be limited toa reset of ean-
ings expectations, the catalyst for increased
volatility and potentially a shallow cyclicalbear within the ongoing secular bull, That
currently appears more likely than the worst
One of aur expectations for next years that
the gold uptrend wll persist, forthe reasons
reviewed last week Yet even though gold has
ben rallying since November, the US. Dollar
Index has now broken tits highest levls since
last summer, bucking the tendency for gold and
the dollar to move in opposite directions.
(Our short-term andlong-term technical com-
posts have both returned to buy signa. And
respecting the trend evidence, we aro moving
‘rom bearish to neutral. uw cout thst
long-term uptrend is underway. The dola’s
strength versus the euro may berated tothe
relative case counts in Europe where new cases
have been ising more apy than they haven
the US. The chara ight shows that the EUR
USD trend has generaly moved in tandem with
EUR/USD moving with relative COVID cases
in
By nor
Strengthening breadth among equal-weighted currencies
the spread between new cases in the US.and
Eurozone countries excluding rence due to
ata issues),
‘The dolar also appears tobe responding to
the risen US 10-year yield relative to non
US yields in nominal terms. But the real yield