(a5) A RELEVANCIA DA LEI PENAL INCONSTITUCIONAL DE CONTEUDO MAIS FAVORAVEL AO ARGUIDO Rui Pereira Asset da Faculdade 8 Dirsto (4 Universidade Clie de Lisbon 1.4 jurisprudéncia do Supremo Tribunal de Justia ma jurspréncia recente Jo Supremo Tribunal de Iustiga firmada pelos Aconlioy de 2 de Fevereiro, 10 de Feverciso ¢ 2 a Maryo de 1988, sustenta que o principio da apicagdo da lel pont ds §onteddo mals favordvl ao arguido, consagrado nos amigos 26% 44, da Constiuigio ¢ 2°, n.* 4, do Cédigo Penal, obriga ss tabunets plicarem normas inconstitucionais — ainda que hajt sido declan, com forga obrigatéra geral, a sua inconstitutonalidade Em todos 0s arestos referides, se confrontou © Supremo Tribunal & Juniga com 0 mesmo quadro legislativo: os artigos 35%, 362, ne | ¢.37* do Decteto-Lei n? 31.668, de 22 de Novembro de’ 194) (Contencioso Aduanciro), previa 0 crime de «contrabando de ct, culagdo.; tai disposigbes foram revogadss pelo artigo 9 n* 1 2, lise c), do Decteto-Lei n° 187/83, de 13 de Mair estes precevor or seu tumo, foram declaradosinconstitucionss, com Tore obige ria gel, pelo Acérdéo n> 187/87 do Tribunal Consttuciorals { Posteriomente, © «contabando de crculagdo» passou a se regu 1 BMI 22 374. 18E © 661960 an € 375, p08 a, reapectvamene » DR. Si, eV de Too de 1581 etm By‘dary “pnag 5827 9 ‘> sp "ra a spepytevorsmnsuoou: pwn wo> eomy8i0 apepseuoromnsuoout wun ‘soperrutsse soseD sou ‘seuouuos oF “eSnsnr ap fungi, owaning jooped suUuOU sesso anb 3p ‘aAel# souaUT no ‘8 opSefar ur nou Sun} Wp feaju oe 8 € 9 «T #081) spepredoy ep 2 culanp ap opesy op S0p Pempsouud opSeisiuew wun ae-opurenpen “(ops = 802 9 1902 sof) 11 orSeurpiogns ens ‘paca ‘puss oussour ou 25-uriounue: ‘opbimmistoz sreungun sop wepaun opSrafne “opou: 0 oper ct 30 VaNv2 2 gvaNveN aOWOK SOU amy “OpINaL O opeores ff apepqroomtinason 9 oxSuxoop ep “Ripon ene ww ousunpuny wo sion ap opteéevaomoas BE cupnt un “ond youleals's fgvewis vovivo aesrioney pea gab steeopypsin! senso sep eunquy. aga ered oumnoas Jods MP Ssine sod “nso apuBages om is ootaee “onsen 9p 82 o8hxe ou xodsp 0 opunae opine JF ooneng ousismyy0-onb zon un evoommmueD, ong) © wiougadivoo p opSutsu eum sivauitzdo “rjsai op ing] . fin ‘sopnauqns wesoy 9y) an sose> u end ‘anb nowsasgo wénsng op yeungn4}. atusudns ,s""085 “6c oBtue op Tuo}arang40 Sopaynoun wefaise son tad suUOU Wade wonap steungen $0 96 wsne> wa yiso onb ots “yidum sew > tudpid spor env ‘nb ‘upiod ‘ouao 3 "jH98 supyeBugo elioy woo apepeuoronstiony 2p oxSeze10p ep” eopoy2 ¥ :opeMUN cuQUUY UME opmE4ap Opts {War jruoroansuoody jeuad rot ep apspinqeande wp wuaigond uargoad op onSeanpg *Z "TEAYRONYs SM OaBANCD 90 MOIDRLUSNO2N TRY fn rNTes o8P5> op 2 08am op » (miorupoct ssa 9p 22 Sopa» sad ep apes $op sae us “opal onto op nape |S eons ers op Spar xa 0 ‘cpitiesopesaaa + an oy “paseo "be esse ope oping Wp va see chim lap naps pe pepigonons = Oey ap speprroenioe¥ eeu TMMRONYA STN 2021409 30 eKSNaOM MEH I~” Moma Yade ep soumyasossoroguoes sopessd sop opSisodut wpe otto | ‘Vas Of eUPIEL We ‘anb ¥ wyfatUode OLdjoud a3 "oeIUD ON ‘omaurmen 9p apeprena so seuuoyal “Tee Us vSuain8o8 9p sep soxdjouud sop “onion pepengeonde @opisap snononal opbeoyde w "eeH wo "epepan tunis Spe uo sordjauud Janbstenb 2p optisyn os auidas nos © Spuaped wou “euDg oBtp9> op 1 7 2 oRSeMNsUED ep "E> | wt “6G So8nsx sop sarisuoo saghsodip se opumnsrr9 ofu — apepteaat 1p olgjomd o sssedraysod jetad extanp ossou 0 “opmmage tod "eg = “nfo 1 spepranoeonas 2p o35iq aad § ape udu 9f anpsonny stew usd [9 4p SpEpIatindnes 9p oped © nay} woo ‘apuatald 9s ott0> auojodsoxe v ofu wipqum ‘apepranceonain sp 0% * s€5200 ‘opuas Ogu anpsonny sw ad ‘SepypNELop e128 “pepe RS, ep ound soyad supsjin "searsisodva seu opine op owuspos04yy op otdsoutsd o> “Tayeoara sm oanaiso> 90 WWoIDauSHODM Bade "9 vB cera)is ee 2 OESN|OS ED “PULOF- oon 3p s0199 0 anb ap ‘und oN 2 Zeman oxyua0 op oppose: 9 TL 2 614 s08nr 50 "Wad wp owuatsduino josqe no) oxbrvpuoy wu ‘oraiouo) wa sepaex® O25 — coSuanaid’ 2p sapepissaoou se sepot Sordjouyd a1yu0 tyuod wn 's ‘0peS a wo onsuger ‘ansodsas op orSspuo> ep oduay sited an op ‘ioAos sow op 0d “ust 20d fanpuoney 2 speprensi Ponsa 08 apy suo tod “te TeanoAnssocRsNaD 20 TMC. ALUSNN TEs THAT Ytuna ze an op 2 opworpnfoud 9 “isd Wa soypept> 80 Or ‘wa ‘opinre 0 anb 2p Owain 0 sepisuo3 ‘oper wn ous apeparg &epuajal 25° fo Se}ouguaspeut se "S019 $0 03ed W2K9p ins ® woo optmu0a ‘pod 96 ogy qu ORY epepre8a; ep otdjouud jad souloo y “onsap oF auuojuo> optwinionep (ou) ens Bu meg ‘ot snuouuoursod sepianbpe seaneioadyg ‘quate Op seanioedes tno ‘9 ois! — ont) nas op seaupiodtatvo9 opuenb soap 98 seaeoodxo sts sxyy “opm ov seasioodeo sB0opod [oan ‘seu opnardon ap jrboromnsuooutjeusd ta © an etaepes “xs ef OU2g of Se owen “spe 9P'€ 07 Off) maupziowo ap » seupsodua "araonva sim conzinoo 30 TOI nwISNooN THE IT. « MonYAPT¢NY0 2 651 61 sev ap sam ong RETA 2 opps yous Sp wap 2 Of ube) se oppo. “Soom aut nb osteo ee 0p apepiaei v axgos ous un vena wo uouredoid opera 2ugos oa wi 2p 238 ‘urouud eu os “eanmund apeprusrp ens © PAHON Seu oppattos 9p steUaIy pb me A -S1opEe PIouEsa.am & aap -Sv0our eOU bad Epes: ‘59p ompuruoruny "ayes feuag O8po5 op ‘J0p 0 opsnjoxa nb Speremseu ta vpn QPwRS “pnUISIT ep wiouR.osuaD rewON 9p apodan 6 fu» op opsenais vised 9p wafendur wu ‘otiugp, 1 BroueAotan» & Fapusdspur svi Juana © sujpreduns aya 0 oper ooquod $9583 opuenb seu} sea oa: ‘TaAyIONY SH oapaLNOD 0 THDIDRAUENEON TNR va MONAT Yteuod (91 ep apepreuorompsuosuy ap oxsesepop y °% eapurstn wplagp 2p oseo ou opine © opussasoaey 9 " rand ops sonry ou od suse un ue 2 "pou! un no wind wun wun oppap wok ‘suOUMsayUEW % y eossod eno tenb © owenb ufau oon On ob sd snot nb oi “tur med sopnotond suena op euojomnsu05 yeungu ‘Fed somajo =p ‘tuaura1opuadapt evoargasy oueqens wn wionbop ‘ans = anb ousam ‘opinjos 9s tian aiduios yu “on ® 2S-opumi20 “BaIpun! orSnjos wrurdo euunus Wa ‘3 2 — erent 7 “atv assemsod 9s 2 1374 Jod ‘aaytonvs Sm oanain0> 90 rDNA THEME a MowVAEE +aw 2 esos 2 est 9p ‘oxbez|s9p 2p 2084 wo oped ores ‘pnaiues ap tot) 2p 3p ope 8 suo2u! 9p of: 9 OP apepitgue Bp ‘0S wo “zetnenapod ay and civ 0 “yWANVaW a0¥or 1u38he soared OuO> “opepruoTS 3 & anb “sagzes ap apep % eZee oBtur op ¢ .u op sued “open Bun ¥ anb woo epioouad 28 vonod- oF) Waigos oui aod "sued ep — yeiads 10 2pm “orraruoo aisau “(soanspuzoid sous) us) udpid vp sopuadp apod opine ot ef wn 30g Su oppanios ap reuod 4 ep apepite HeAIp opSimNsUO.) ¥ nb ¥ opunds ‘epuapue> aan ap tanedsod tun gOKWANVD 30 VAIVL. od 9p ~wosatde eisodaud e z2raiosqns 9p 498 soared ogu pf ovoed apa duos seep IPH 9 opteunuosep 2p oN ep orteiop =p U6 ‘sudgud ep sows sopeonesd soroey 8 opSefar wo zeat ugpuodsauies Sp ou Wun fot ep ena} eu» ryan fououi opnoive> ap euuou sp opSeurstidas e anb ¢ naxdioya © anb ou s¥Ul Jo4oul w wfse O85 Sp dpbemee iri BmsIOo ap feusd euuow ep apepieuoronusuoou ME dass op ¢ cop opSarpary ob soveou ce " 24m x9 ogous seen aiuouNpeUstSSp 9pod ler ‘OUpAUDD WI OEFIAAP # mP z of Lo (souede vzuoine ogu 8) ¥8uq0 jopnaiio> 2p 205 2 (eio0s opseuapuo wi 2p yeved eusirur © seredsas puou ® opuenb yeu 85 $0 spe anb depuciua seg “nue wd oxsumop ep ‘mapionys SN CaneLi0> 0 sMoIDNALENOONT WAM - iokyarN . mmOf awa 0 apna “sipar 2 uuol © opuenb 9 2pepr WOU ep wlouzisire © opuacequs "ais Opacnh oP stuBip ons 2 wors¥2 oF tonpz0%ej si oppotucs ap ume oom wuou ap oRSeoyde eu opinaie op swaneioatns houndos 9p seppour idioutd Sop opbesoy 01 ®P 9 orp 3p opeisg op send iioadxa ap eaam e oquense 9 (ons ie op owvousoasovey op ovo SpeBIANGE ep JAyU oF (oxdmHUOD ep vg a Bc gCiMe 2 oMteT op soidsined sop inigouH > wap 8 td “sreungin so welos son (8 Teapuoaey seu oppanwoa” op seesnjsuoc TENON BN OANENGD 30 MMODALEBION THE MARIA Y‘sp opSeayide 2p sopepinaiip maureoe opu nu — 9 0 aluoueatanb offe 0 vom