Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(GXFDWLRQDO6FLHQWL¿FDQG
Cultural Organization
© UNESCO 2012
All rights reserved
ISBN 978-92-3-001076-8
This publication Shaping the Education of Tomorrow: 2012 Report on the UN Decade of Education for Sustainable
Development, Abridged is a condensed, adapted and edited version of Shaping the Education of Tomorrow:
2012 Full-length Report on the UN Decade for Education for Sustainable Development authored by Arjen E.J. Wals,
Wageningen University, The Netherlands, and commissioned by UNESCO. This abridged version was prepared by
Cathy Nolan.
The designations employed and the presentation of material throughout this publication do not imply the
expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of UNESCO concerning the legal status of any country, territory,
city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.
The ideas and opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors; they are not necessarily those of
UNESCO and do not commit the Organization.
Cover photos:
©UN Photo/Eric Kanalstein
©UN Photo/Milton Grant
©UN Photo/Kibae Park
©UN Photo/Kibae Park
Printed in France
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Our appreciation goes to Arjen Wals, UNESCO Chair in Social Learning and Sustainable Development,
Wageningen University, The Netherlands, for reading hundreds of Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E)
survey responses and other sources of information about Education for Sustainable Development
and writing the 2012 Monitoring and Evaluation Report on the UN Decade of Education for Sustain-
able Development. His full-length report Shaping the Education of Tomorrow: 2012 Full-length Report
on the UN Decade for Education for Sustainable Development is available on the UNESDOC database at
http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0021/002164/216472E.pdf [Search the title.]
Our appreciation also goes to Cathy Nolan who prepared this abridged and edited version of the 2012
Report.
We extend our appreciation and thanks to the Monitoring and Evaluation Expert Group for their advice
throughout the M&E process and their review of the documents related to the 2012 M&E report. The
members of the group include: Abelardo Brenes, Rangachar Govinda, Alex Michalos, Yoshiyuki Nagata,
Roël van Raaij, Overson Shumba, Konai Thaman, Pierre Varcher and Alcyone Vasconcelos. Special thanks
go to the Chair of the group, Daniella Tilbury, University of Gloucestershire, United Kingdom.
We extend our gratitude to the Japanese Government for providing the financial support to the M&E
process for the UN Decade of Education for Sustainable Development through the Japanese Funds-In-
Trust for ESD (JFIT).
3
© UN Photo/Eskinder Debebe
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
As the lead agency for the UN Decade of Educa- (ESD). What kinds of learning processes have
tion for Sustainable Development (DESD, 2005 – emerged in the course of the DESD? What is the
2014), UNESCO is responsible for monitoring and role of ESD in supporting them? What changes
evaluating progress during the DESD. UNESCO in ESD have occurred since the early years of the
is publishing three reports during the DESD – in Decade? The report is informed by a broad con-
2009, 2012 and 2014. This second report focuses sultation process that includes input from hun-
specifically on processes and learning in the con- dreds of policymakers, scholars and practitioners
text of Education for Sustainable Development engaged in ESD around the world.
Findings
ESD is emerging as the unifying theme for many occurring. It appears that as the sustainability con-
types of education that focus on different aspects tent of the curriculum evolves, pedagogy is evolv-
of sustainability, (e.g. climate change, disaster risk ing simultaneously.
reduction or biodiversity).
More research is needed to document that ESD is
ESD is increasingly perceived as a catalyst for in- quality education. Much anecdotal evidence ex-
novation in education. ists that ESD is related to academic gains as well
as boosting people’s capacities to support sus-
Boundaries between schools, universities, com- tainable development. Research will provide a
munities and the private sector are blurring due solid evidence base and firmly establish that ESD
to a number of trends. ESD is often at the heart is quality education.
of new, creative multi-stakeholder configurations
involving these ESD stakeholders. Within the UN system, ESD‘s role is much bigger
than it was two years ago.
As ESD progresses, a co-evolution of pedagogy is
Looking ahead
With the challenge of sustainable development as spondents cautioned, however, that the P for Pros-
considerable as ever, recognition is growing that perity (or Profit) could dominate the other two P’s
technological advances, legislation and policy of the “triple bottom line”: the P for Planet and the
frameworks are not enough. These need to be ac- P for People.
companied by changes in mind-sets, values and
lifestyles, and the strengthening of people’s ca- As the DESD goes into its final phase, it will be
pacities to bring about change. crucial for UNESCO, its Member States and other
stakeholders to ensure that promotion, support
A noticeable difference from the early DESD years and evolution of ESD continues beyond 2014.
is the private sector’s interest in sustainability and
capacity-building for a green economy. Some re-
5
© UN Photo/Kibae Park
6
CONTENTS
Acknowledgements 3
Executive Summary 5
1. Background 9
The UN Decade of Education for Sustainable Development 10
ESD in a Changing World 18
2. New Forms of Teaching and Learning for Sustainable Development 25
General Trends 25
Learning in Specific ESD Contexts 30
3. Emergence of New Partnerships in Support of ESD 55
Multi-stakeholder Interaction 55
Whole-institution Approaches 59
4. Concluding Remarks and Ways Forward 65
Acronyms 70
References 72
Appendix 1 – The UN Contribution to the DESD 75
Appendix 2 – Data Sources 81
Appendix 3 – Monitoring & Evaluation Expert Group (MEEG) 87
7
© UN Photo/Eskinder Debebe
“Sustainable development?
It means that everybody does
something for the world.”
(Six-year-old boy from Poland)
BACKGROUND
Introduction
In December 2002, the United Nations took on an point. (UNESCO, 2009a.) ESD, it concluded, was
ambitious task. It declared a Decade of Education finding its place in education communities. Nearly
for Sustainable Development (DESD, 2005-2014), 100 countries across the world had set up national
naming UNESCO the lead agency for its imple- coordinating bodies. Networks and structures
mentation. The DESD promotes a more sustain- existed in schools, universities, communities and
able world through different forms of education, the private sector to develop ESD, viewed as a rel-
training and public awareness activities. It is an evant approach to global problems.
opportunity to rethink considerably our approach
to global challenges. The second report, summarized in this publica-
tion, focuses on learning and learning-based
The Decade is now in its eighth year. What differ- change towards sustainability. What kinds of
ence is it making around the world? This publica- learning processes are emerging in the last stretch
tion presents highlights and key findings from the of the DESD? What is the role of ESD in support-
latest report on the DESD’s progress: “Shaping the ing them? What changes have occurred since the
Education of Tomorrow: 2012 Full-length Report early years?
on the UN Decade for Education for Sustainable
Development”. The report includes input from hundreds of poli-
cymakers, scholars and practitioners engaged
UNESCO is publishing three reports on the De- in ESD around the world. The evidence base was
cade, in 2009, 2012 and 2014, using relevant generated through Member State surveys, key in-
methodologies and indicators to gauge results. formant surveys, regional synthesis reports, and
case studies. Anecdotes, case study excerpts and
The first report in 2009, “Learning for a Sustain- reflections capture the richness and diversity of
able World: Review of Contexts and Structures ESD in practice.
for ESD”, reviewed achievements at the halfway
© UN Photo/Milton Grant
Chapter 1
9
The UN Decade of Education for Sustainable
Development
world through a lens of concern for sustainability.
Despite unprecedented economic growth in the
20th century, persistent poverty and inequality
still affect too many people, especially those While we can draw upon experiences of the
who are most vulnerable. Conflicts continue past to solve the problems of today and tomor-
to draw attention to the need for building a row, the reality is that citizens of the world will
culture of peace. The global financial and eco- have the task of learning their way towards
nomic crises highlight the risks of unsustainable sustainability. Education is therefore central
economic development models and practices to learning and to a more sustainable future.
based on short-term gains. The food crisis and (UNESCO, 2012b)
world hunger are an increasingly serious issue.
Unsustainable production and consumption The DESD is working to provide countries with
patterns are creating ecological impacts that opportunities to incorporate ESD into education
compromise the options of current and future reform efforts to contribute simultaneously to SD
generations and the sustainability of life on and educational quality by:
Earth. (Opening Statement, Bonn Declaration,
generated by the participants of the UNESCO • facilitating networking, linkages, exchange and
World Conference on Education for Sustainable interaction among ESD stakeholders;
Development) (UNESCO, 2009b) • fostering increased quality of teaching, learning,
research and capacity building in ESD;
• supporting countries in realizing the Millen-
nium Development Goals (MDGs) through ESD
The UN DESD promotes the vision of a more sus- efforts;
tainable and more just global community through • offering ESD as an umbrella concept for emerg-
different forms of education, public awareness and
ing educations (e.g. climate change, disaster risk
training activities. It highlights the critical role of
reduction);
education and life skills programmes in enabling
communities to create sustainable local solutions At the beginning of the Decade, UNESCO and
to problems related to poverty and vulnerability. countries around the world concentrated on fur-
ther developing ESD and prioritizing strategies. In
The DESD is intended to have broad scope and far-
the second half of the DESD, the emphasis shifted
reaching effects. It offers national governments
towards achieving visible results. This is where we
the chance to reorient education, training and
are today, twenty years after the 1992 Rio Earth
even governance to enable everyone to view the
Summit.
HISTORY
1972 Stockholm United Nations Confer- (UNCED), also known as the Earth Summit,
ence on Human Environment was the first held in Rio de Janeiro (Brazil).
major UN conference on environment and
10
© UN Photo/Martine Perret
The Earth Summit’s landmark document, Agenda 2009 UNESCO’s mid-Decade World Conference on
21, mapped out a comprehensive plan of action to Education for Sustainable Development in Bonn
be taken globally to reduce human impact on the (Germany) was a major milestone, attended by about
environment. Agenda 21 and the Rio Declaration 50 education ministers and vice-ministers. The Bonn
on Environment and Development were adopted at Declaration gave the world an action plan for ESD
the Earth Summit by more than 178 Governments. and outlined steps for implementing the remainder
See: hp://www.un.org/esa/dsd/agenda21/ of the Decade. The knowledge, technology and skills
already exist to turn around unsustainable develop-
UNESCO was designated task manager of Chapter ment models, the declaration said. It was now impera-
36 of Agenda 21 on education, training and public tive to act to bring about long-term change.
awareness, with four overarching goals:
Promote and improve the quality of education: The aim is ‘In March 2009 I had the opportunity to attend the
to refocus lifelong education on knowledge, skills and UNESCO World Conference for ESD in Bonn Ger-
values citizens need to improve their quality of life; many …. One thousand representatives from 150
Reorient the existing education programmes: From countries were together for three very intense days
pre-school to university, education must be re- evaluating the progress of the Decade of ESD at
thought and reformed to be a vehicle of knowledge,
its midpoint. No one could have left this gathering
thought patterns and values needed to build a sus-
without feeling inspired to go home and do his or
tainable world;
her best to promote ESD, and further this work. The
Raise public awareness and understanding of the con-
cept of sustainable development: This will make it pos- Bonn Declaration was a call for action… for me;
sible to develop enlightened, active and responsible (Belton, 2012)
citizenship locally, nationally and internationally;
Train the workforce: Continuing technical and voca- Immediately following the Bonn Conference, the
tional education of directors and workers, particular- Ministry of Education in Zambia undertook to:
ly those in trade and industry, will be enriched to en- • develop a National Framework for the implemen-
able them to adopt sustainable modes of production tation of EE [environmental education] and ESD,
and consumption. This includes a social component
(e.g. equity, human rights). • integrate EE and ESD at all level of formal edu-
cation,
September 2002: World Summit on Sustainable De- • launch a National EE and ESD campaign,
velopment, Johannesburg. Global stakeholders re-
viewed the outcomes of the 1992 Earth Summit and • prod the University of Zambia to spearhead the
made recommendation for future actions including, implementation of EE and ESD,
“recommend to the United Nations General Assem-
• involve other line ministries, civil socie-
bly that it consider adopting a decade of education
ties, Universities and NGOs to improve
for sustainable development, starting in 2005” (UN,
2002, para. 124 d). their working in favour of EE and ESD.
(Report to UNESCO Chair on Reorienting Teacher
Education to Address Sustainability, 2010).
December 2002: At its 57th session, the United Na-
tions General Assembly adopted Resolution 57/254
that declared the period between 2005 and 2014 as Other UN initiatives and reports recognizing the
the United Nations Decade of Education for Sustain- continued importance of ESD at the international
able Development (DESD). UNESCO was named lead policy level include:
UN agency.
The Human Development Report 2011: Sustain-
2005-2014: DESD, a decade for change ability and Equity: A Better Future for All, published
by UNDP, mentions the role of ESD in promoting sus-
tainable consumption;
2007 The 34th session of the UNESCO General
Conference adopted a resolution on ESD recogniz- The report of the United Nations Secretary-General’s
ing that further substantial initiatives have to be taken High-Level Panel on Global Sustainability, pub-
by Member States and by UNESCO in order to reorient lished in 2012, refers to the importance of ESD;
teaching and learning towards sustainable develop-
ment worldwide.
Chapter 1
11
ESD is far more than teaching knowledge and
principles related to sustainability. ESD, in its
broadest sense, is education for social trans- In a dynamic world
formation with the goal of creating more sus-
tainable societies. ESD touches every aspect of facing old and new
education including planning, policy develop- sustainability challenges,
ment, programme implementation, finance,
curricula, teaching, learning, assessment, ad- ESD itself is on the move.
ministration. ESD aims to provide a coherent
interaction between education, public awa-
reness, and training with a view to creating a
more sustainable future (UNESCO, 2012b).
© UN Photo/Albert Gonzalez Farran
proximation of the rate of adoption of ESD tion to green societies and economies.
(IBE National Reports Analysis, 2012).
12
At least four lenses of ESD can be distinguished: A transformative lens – moving from awareness
to incorporating real change and transformation
An integrative lens – taking on a holistic perspec- through empowerment and capacity building to
tive that allows for the integration of multiple lead to more sustainable lifestyles, values, com-
aspects of sustainability (e.g. ecological, environ- munities and businesses;
mental, economic, socio-cultural; local, regional
and global; past, present and future); A contextual lens – recognizing there is no one
way of living or doing business that is the most
A critical lens – questioning predominant, taken- sustainable everywhere and forever. We can learn
for-granted patterns that are or may be unsus- from each other, but places and people around
tainable (e.g. the idea of continuous economic the world are different and times will change.
growth, dependency on consumerism and associ- Therefore, sustainability needs to be re-calibrated
ated lifestyles); as realities change.
13
Report objecves Chapter 3 focuses on the emergence of new
partnerships in support of ESD. It highlights
The purpose of this report of ESD learning and processes of multi-stakeholder action that
processes is to highlight trends in education and seek to create systemic change. Such multi-
learning around the globe that show the potential stakeholder interactions cannot be confined
and the challenges of ESD at all levels of education to one particular ESD context. They tend to
and in other less formal learning contexts (e.g. be cross-boundary: they involve people rep-
communities and businesses). The purpose is not resenting different sectors in society and are
to rank, label or judge countries or regions. not confined to one particular form of learn-
ing. The second part of Chapter 3 focuses on
The report seeks to strike a balance between the the growing ‘whole system engagement’ ap-
universal (to generate general guidelines that can proach to ESD.
be used in other contexts) and the contextual (to
do justice to local realities, histories and political Chapter 4 closes with key findings and sug-
contexts). The report recognizes that all countries gestions for the way forward to the end of the
have their own unique challenges, perspectives DESD and beyond.
and histories, all of these affecting the way ESD is
perceived and implemented. Appendix 1 highlights the UN contribution to
the DESD, particularly UNESCO’s role.
Reviewing a UN Decade in progress is highly com-
plex, considering the geographical scope (the
globe) and the time-frame (10 years). The level of
ambition is also very high: the DESD seeks to af-
fect multiple levels of governance and to engage
multiple stakeholders, including marginalized
ones. Yet one thing is certain: across the world,
people are indeed engaged in ESD.
14
MORE ON THE M&E P R OCE S S
The Decade of Education for Sustainable De- Learning is approached from two perspec-
velopment is guided by an International Im- tives: 1) learning as it engages people, young
plementation Scheme (IIS), which provides a and old, in formal, informal and non-formal
broad framework for contributions. It defines settings, in sustainability issues and 2) learn-
the DESD’s goals and objectives and its rela- ing as it enables various stakeholders at vari-
tionship to other key campaigns such as the ous levels to create better opportunities for
Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), Edu- ESD and to begin to re-orient entire systems
cation for All (EFA) and the United Nations Lit- (e.g. schools, communities and companies) to-
eracy Decade. wards ESD.
Processes refers to engagement opportuni- The review also looks at changes and trends
ties, pedagogical approaches or teaching in ESD engagement within the UN system
and learning styles adopted to implement itself.
ESD at different educational levels and in
varied educational settings.
15
© UN Photo/UNICEF/Marco Dormino
DATA
To focus on the actual learning taking place National ESD-journeys (NESDJ) – Eight detailed
in schools, universities, communities and reviews from countries in different regions of
workplaces, as well as on the processes the world. These National Journeys were com-
used to engage multiple stakeholders in missioned to give an overview of ESD at the
supporting ESD, a range of data sources national level. The chapters have a specific for-
were used to get a more complete picture mat that includes one section on learning and
of what is happening on the ground. They processes.
include:
Internal review of ESD contributions by various
Literature review - In 2010, UNESCO commis- UN agencies (UNIR) – UN Agencies involved in
sioned an expert review on processes and ESD and connected through the Inter Agency
learning for ESD. The resulting report (Tilbury, Committee (UNECE, UNCCD, UNEP, UNICEF,
2011) identifies which commonly accepted UN-Habitat, UNESCO, and UNU) filled in ESD
learning processes are aligned with ESD and surveys. They described their contribution to
can be promoted through ESD-related activi- ESD and their links with other UN Agencies to
ties. It also examines which learning opportu- strengthen and/or use ESD to achieve their
nities contribute to sustainable development, own educational and sustainability-oriented
providing an important entry point and back- tasks. In a focus-group discussion with some
drop for this report. of the agencies (including UNICEF, FAO, UNEP,
UNECE, UNU, UNESCO, UNCCD, UNCBD and
Global Monitoring & Evaluation Survey (GMES) UN-Habitat) these responses were rearticu-
- An on-line survey was created and sent to lated and shared.
UNESCO National Commissions of UNESCO
Member States to get a better sense from Key Informant Survey (KIS) – Key ESD infor-
countries of the various types of learning mants around the world represent a range
employed and/or emerging under the ESD of local, regional, national and trans-national
umbrella in the various educational sectors organizations active in ESD. They included
(from Early Childhood Education to Vocational international and national NGOs as well the
Education and Training to Community-based DESD Reference Group, an advisory body to
and Corporate Learning) at the national level. UNESCO. Forty-four key informants received
Respondents could also identify obstacles and the KIS electronically. The letter requested
opportunities regarding ESD development in that the recipient “query the members of their
their country, with the option of more open- organization” to complete the questionnaire
ended narrative responses. In total 216 re- so that the response would be more broadly
spondents from 102 countries participated in informed than a perspective of one indi-
the survey. Many countries returned multiple vidual. A number of organizations returned
surveys covering multiple education sections. more than one response to the questionnaire.
UNESCO regional offices used the surveys to
write regional synthesis reports, providing Reports from UNESCO ESD-Chairs – two consul-
more input for this review. In some cases, con- tations took place among the UNESCO Chairs
sultants or bureau staff members writing the engaged in ESD: they consisted of an informal
reports engaged in further telephone, email on-line questionnaire initiated by the global
and internet research. report coordinator, and one more formal on-
line questionnaire commissioned by UNES-
Case studies (CS) – All five UNESCO Regions pro- CO’s ESD section.
vided learning-based case studies: Arab States
(2), Africa (2), Asia Pacific (2), North America Appendix 2 shows an overview of the data
Europe (2), and Latin America Caribbean (4). used and the countries and UN agencies that
Using a template, these looked at learning and contributed.
processes in ESD programmes and at changes
over the last five years.
Chapter 1
16
The report seeks to strike
a balance between the universal
and the contextual.
© UN Photo/Basile Zoma
LI
LIM ITATIO NS
MITATIO NS O
OF THEE GGLOBA
F TH LOBALL MMON I TOR I N G
ONITORING
AANND
D EEVA LUAT I ON
VALUATIO N PR
P ROC
O CES
E SSS
The Global Monitoring and Evaluation While the surveys (i.e., of Member States,
Framework was developed to assess imple- Key Informants and UN Agencies) were in-
mentation of the DESD. In reality, it is more tended to encourage broad consultation,
likely to capture the changes occurring this process did not always take place. In
during the ten-year period marked by the some participating countries, a number
DESD, and not just initiatives developed of people with specific ESD knowledge
under the DESD label. interacted to produce responses, thereby
strengthening their validity. In others, how-
Using a universal template and question- ever, data were not validated by multiple
naire promotes uniformity in reporting and sources. Furthermore, the involvement of
helps make sure all respondents report on NGOs, considered key players, and youth is
the same ESD components and issues. Yet underreported, whereas much of the data
despite a glossary of key terms, it is clear coming from UN related sources is from
from the data that not everyone grasps UNESCO Headquarters and Field Offices.
concepts in the same way. Even within the
same country, organizations or officials may
have different understandings of “problem-
based learning” or “multi-stakeholder en-
gagement”.
Chapter 1
17
ESD in a Changing World
Countries most at risk of climate change may be more readily willing to include disaster risk reduction
(DRR) and climate change education (CC) in their national education strategies compared to other
countries. ESD is also less seen as a separate form of “education” and more easily mainstreamed in
educational strategies. Finally, an increasing number of actors recognize the value and necessity of
ESD work… (UNIR, UNICEF).
18
On 29 March 2005, in the DESD’s first year, a 2012, it found 1,550,000 sites: over 7 times the
Google search for “Education for Sustainable De- number found in 2009 and over 17 times the num-
velopment” came up with 89,000 websites. On 29 ber in 2005. (Of course, this rapid growth is also a
January 2009, after almost four years, the same result of the spread of digitalization in all fields.)
search yielded 215,000 websites. On 28 January
8,000
6,000
n of Google hits x 1000
March
2005
4,000 January
2007
February
2012
2,000
0
ESD EE Peace Ed. Aids Ed. Climate
change Ed.
Figure 1.1 ESD growth according to Google compared to other ‘adjectival’ educations.
19
Climate change education is being mainstrea- Bansunkong draws upon the “Sufficiency Eco-
med into school curricula. The introduction of nomy” philosophy of Thailand’s King Bhumibol
climate change education includes the science Adulyadej as a foundation and common-cultu-
of climate change, the social and human as- ral reference point for its ESD processes; howe-
pects, policy responses and sustainable lifes- ver it also draws upon the traditional knowle-
tyles among other issues. From the M&E data, dge and practices of the Akha people where
59% of the respondent countries report action possible. In particular, both wisdoms are reflec-
on Climate Change Education. At the different ted in the school’s applied agricultural science
educational levels or modalities, 35% of those programme, and are used as inspiration for
countries have action in primary education, the development of solutions to sustainability
50% in secondary education, 80% in higher issues of local concern as part of the CSA acti-
education, 88% in teacher education, 60% in vities. The school also focuses upon the Akha’s
TVET and 56% in non-formal education (Email cultural heritage within its arts subjects, and
survey). makes use of Ahka performance arts within the
CSA as a means of increasing the effectiveness
of community outreach and consultation ef-
forts. This use of common cultural reference
X Meanings and interpretaons of points, as with the school’s pedagogy based on
applied participatory teaching and learning,
ESD has succeeded in making an education seem
more relevant to the circumstances of, and thus
“The progress of ESD remains of more value to Bansunkong’s students and the
unevenly distributed and local community. In this way, Bansunkong has
succeeded in increasing students’ and parents’
requires different approaches enthusiasm for education, with consequent
impacts upon attendance and completion rates
in different contexts.” (CS, Basunkong School, Thailand).
Bonn Declaration (UNESCO, 2009).
As noted in Chapter 1, ESD is interpreted in dif-
ferent ways around the world. In the second half In many responses on the nature of ESD, there are
of the DESD, there is less push for a uniform view references to the importance of consumer educa-
of ESD that can be prescribed to all countries and tion and the need to encourage values other than
regions. Instead there is more recognition of the material ones.
need for locally relevant interpretations, learning
processes and change mechanisms.
Chapter 1
© UN Photo/Kibae Park
20
The Partnership for Education and Research Learning for sustainable development enables
about Responsible Living (PERL) is an interna- everyone to get back into complex and chan-
tional network of experts, researchers, teachers ging society by appropriating the mechanisms
and policy-makers (from over 140 institutions in of thought and action, allowing it to unders-
more than 50 countries) that encourage people tand the interactions between the local and
to contribute to constructive change through the global perspective of the consumerist
the way they choose to live. PERL is based on six approach, based on our materialistic society
years of experience under the Consumer Citi- and to envisage a lifestyle grounded on ethi-
zenship Network. PERL develops educational cal conduct involving equality and solidarity
approaches which are values-based, holistic, (UNESCO Chair Report, France).
interdisciplinary, active, personal and practical
(KIS, Norway).
The Centre for Environment Education (CEE) in
India has run the campaign “CO2 Pick Right” on
climate change and individual lifestyle choices
in over 70,000 schools in India. Centre for Envi-
ronment Education, CEE was created in reco-
gnition of the importance of environmental
education in India’s overall environment and
development strategy. The result is a unique
partnership between government and a non-
governmental institution. The programme
made it possible to raise awareness on the
importance of choices and daily practices for
sustainability (Centre for Environment Educa-
tion, India). See: http://www.ceeindia.org/cee/
pick_right_cce.html
© UN Photo
Without a doubt the biggest change [that has The way we learn is equally important to
occurred since the start of the DESD] is a result what we learn; process is just as important as
of including the issue of “quality education” as content; theory is meaningless without practi-
a major part of the discussion. The discussion of cal applicability in real people’s lives. A revolu-
quality has moved ESD from the realm of ano- tion is underway within learning communities,
ther adjectival to the heart of the education re- a revolution with many new names: Liberatio-
form debates (UNESCO Chair Survey, Canada). nal Pedagogy, Relational Learning, Partnership
Education, Transformative Learning, Experien-
tial Learning, Action Learning, And there is
This report focuses essentially on the ‘E’ in ESD the Living and Learning Pedagogy promoted
while recognising that the meaning of SD varies by Gaia Education. One central motive that
around the globe. There is no universal consensus all these pedagogies – that is, principles and
on how to become more sustainable. Yet in vari-
methods of instruction – have in common is an
ous educational contexts and within UN agencies
effort to make the educational process directly
supporting ESD, we see new emphasis on the ca-
relevant to people’s lives, to focus learning on
pacities and skills people need to create a more
sustainable world. The question of what are the the solutions to real problems that people are
appropriate learning processes for developing experiencing (KIS, United Kingdom).
these qualities in citizens, young and old, is now
part of the conversation.
Underlying is a basic question about
This is a key change since the early years of the education itself: Is education above all about
DESD. social reproduction or about enabling social
Chapter 1
21
same way everywhere, and educators therefore
have different visions of how the educated citizen Reorienting education to address sustaina-
interacts in society. bility requires understanding local contexts,
including traditional knowledge and ensuring
The way that education, especially formal educa- democratic participation (UNIR).
tion, is interpreted and implemented clearly has
implications for the way ESD is interpreted and im-
plemented. The amount of space allowed for par-
ticipation, self-determination and autonomous
thinking influences the kind of ESD that emerges
or is possible.
22
In Ukraine we decided to create a new, in- In Mongolia, UNESCO supports the Govern-
tegrative and inclusive curriculum for ESD, ment’s efforts of mainstreaming ESD in educa-
rather than offering additional material for tion system through curriculum development
existing school subjects: and to implement it and ESD institutionalization in teacher educa-
within the current model of state school. tion. A course outline on ESD targeting pros-
pective teachers attending the State University
Ukrainian educators, like those in many other of Education, and a learning resource book has
countries, are used to linking SD with the been developed. Based on relevant modules
sphere of natural science. And there is cer- and key resources provided in the UNESCO ESD
tainly something in this. For example ESD
Lens, an ESD training handbook for education
students can definitely benefit from their
planners and managers has been developed
classes in chemistry (composition of water,
and disseminated to relevant departments in
air), physics (measuring of energy and pow-
er intensity), biology and other knowledge the national and local governments, universi-
about nature. However, ESD also demands ties of education, UNESCO ASP Net schools and
great attention to social aspects, because a education research institutes (GMES, UNESCO
sustainable society cannot function without Field Office Beijing).
democracy, on-going dialogue, participation
and the empowerment of people – individu- ESD resources may have to be
als and groups. Also SD is only possible when
human relationships are based on respect, authorized by governments
tolerance and intercultural cooperation, so
from the perspective of the standard school
before they can enter the
curriculum this is already ‘social studies’ and formal education system.
even social psychology, social ‘engineering,’
or even philosophy (Mehlmann, McLaren China’s “Environment, Population and Sus-
and Pometun, 2010 ).
tainable Development for Education” (EPD-
ESD) Programme, an initiative of the Beijing
UNESCO’s 2011 Leaders Forum also concluded Academy of Education Sciences, UNESCO, and
that youth as the “democratic pulse of today’s the Chinese Ministry of Education, seeks to:
world” must be empowered as actors for peace “demonstrate the role of education in facilita-
and inclusive sustainable development, using the ting sustainable development; to build young
new internet communication tools. The UNESCO people’s scientific knowledge; to increase their
Offices in Beirut and Doha echo this idea: learning capacity; to impart upon them the
values and lifestyles required for sustainable
The focus is on youth involvement in ESD/DESD development; to teach students more about
and the uses of their experiences in community energy conservation, environmental protection
development (UNIR, UNESCO Regional Bureau and cultural diversity; to expand the construc-
of Education, Beirut). tion of energy-efficient and emission-reducing
schools; and to engage students in activities
that mitigate social, economic, environmental
and cultural problems for sustainable deve-
The increased use of the internet, and its ability
lopment” (Gendong, 2010: p.2, quoted in (CS,
to spawn large voluntary networks at very low
China).
cost, can create low cost knowledge networks
and peer reviewed content suitable for wide
distribution (UNIR, UNESCO Field Office Doha).
23
© UN Photo/Ky Chung
X Summary Notes
In various educational contexts and within UN
agencies supporting ESD, we see new emphasis
on the capacities and skills qualities people need
to create a more sustainable world.
24
NEW FORMS
OF TEACHING
AND LEARNING
FOR SUSTAINABLE
DEVELOPMENT
© UN Photo/Albert Gonzalez Farran
General Trends
processes of collaboration and dialogue (includ-
More types of learning [have] evolved since ing multi-stakeholder, and intercultural dialogue).
ESD is being taught in different types of voca-
tional and technical schools. Sometimes ESD is In the global monitoring and evaluation survey
being taught through different projects which (GMES), nine types or forms of learning associated
combine different types of learning…and with ESD were distinguished. Some can be con-
connect more than one subject area (GMES, sidered conventional (e.g. transmissive learning
Croatia). and disciplinary learning) and some more cutting-
edge (e.g. multi-stakeholder social learning and
A noteworthy pedagogical shift seems to be oc- systems thinking-based learning). They are de-
curring in ESD as the DESD unfolds. It is marked by scribed briefly below:
a rise in alternative/innovative forms of teaching
and learning. • Discovery learning – learners are immersed in a
rich context where they encounter some ele-
The M&E literature review (Tilbury, 2011) identified ment of mystery; they become curious and be-
four key processes underpinning ESD: processes gin to make sense of their experience through
which stimulate innovation within curricula as their own exploration.
well as through teaching and learning experienc- • Transmissive learning – using didactic skills (e.g.
Chapter 2
es; processes of active and participatory learning; presenting, lecturing, story-telling) and sup-
processes which engage the ‘whole system,’ and porting materials (e.g. workbooks, instruction
25
forms, visuals) a body of knowledge, set of rules Figure 2.1 below shows the number of times GMES
or code of conduct is transferred to the learners. respondents (n=213) from 102 countries ticked
• Participatory/collaborative learning – although the forms of learning described above. Discovery
not identical, both emphasize working together learning, systems thinking-based learning, critical
with others and active, not passive, participa- thinking-based learning, interdisciplinary learning,
tion in the learning process, which tends to fo- problem-based learning, and participatory/collab-
cus on resolving a joint issue or task. orative learning were mentioned the most.
• Problem-based learning – focused on solving Times mentioned (n=213)
real or simulated problems, to better under- No new learning
stand the issue or find ways to make real-life im- Disciplinary learning
provements. Issues are either identified by the Transmissive learning
learners, or pre-determined (e.g. by teachers,
Social learning
experts, commissioning bodies).
• Disciplinary learning – taking questions of a dis- Discovery learning
26
© UN Photo/Milton Grant
© UN Photo/Eskinder Debebe
[E]ducation that students can participate in
Sixteen respondents also mentioned other forms and feel empowered. Take for example when
of learning: philosophical enquiry at all ages, ex- my school (Pre-School through grade 6) de-
ploring values, self-learning, experimental learn- cided we had way too much Styrofoam go …
ing, inclusive pedagogy, education for empower- in our dump and along our roads. We [assem-
ment, community-based learning, action-based bled] a complete array of eco-utensils made
learning and livelihood skills training. from corn starch. We obtained samples and
had a nearby hotel try them. Then we went all
The Bhutanese schools also focus on mind- around the island with samples showing them
fulness and care/compassion for the learners. to restaurants and asking them if they would
So there is an attempt to address all abili- use them instead of Styrofoam. The kids felt
ties within an inclusive school environment they were making a difference! We engage in
(GMES, Bhutan). that type of education often (GMES, Bahamas).
Three languages were used in the GMES: English, French and Spanish. Table 2.1 shows how different
forms of learning were ranked per language area, from 1 (most mentioned) to 9 (least mentioned). A
high level of agreement is indicated on the importance of participatory/collaborative forms of learn-
ing. Notable differences can be found in rankings for transmissive learning (1st-2nd for French-language
respondents, 8th for Spanish and English) and critical thinking-based learning (ranked 3rd and 4th respec-
tively for Spanish and English, but 9th for French). These findings may point to cultural differences as well
as educational and schooling traditions.
Table 2.1 Rankings of various forms of ESD-related forms of learning by language of the response.
27
A UNESCO Chair from France expressed a senti- dence that they, their community and human-
ment heard not only in French-speaking countries kind have a worthwhile future that they can help
but in many parts of the world. shape” (Mehlman et al., 2010).
© UN Photo/J P Lafonte
28
In some contexts, the development and inclusion Preliminary results showing increased student en-
of SD or ESD in curricula seems to be causing a co- gagement (i.e., intellectual, academic, and social
evolution of pedagogy. ESD’s presence goes hand- engagement) in school are pointing to evolution
in-hand with a rethinking of the kind of learning or co-evolution of pedagogy and sustainability
necessary to address sustainability issues. ESD is content. Their exact relationship, however, is not
thus becoming a catalyst of educational reform. yet known.
Education for Sustainable Development has “It’s a bit of a chicken and egg situation - some-
in general re-shaped the way we teach and times sustainability initiatives start because
learn at all levels. . . . Specifically . . . pedagogy they are addressing a particular issue (e.g. ra-
for teacher education becomes community- cism) and we do have some students that are
centred as in-service teachers are motivated really passionate about these issues. Generally
and encouraged to attend closely to the envi- though, our students know that teachers will
ronment. Consequently a new relationship support their voice and interests and they will
between the university and the community is go with it – whether their interests are related
developed. Teaching and learning become ‘si- to sustainability or not.” (CS, Canada)
tuated’ in community with both in-service tea-
chers and community members teaching and
learning from each other. There is an empha- “It’s tough to say and probably too soon to
sis on active and participatory learning and know.” (CS, Canada)
on problem-solving as these teachers learn
and are motivated to take action to address
problems in the community. Paralleling and “I would like to think there is a relationship”
complementing the work in community are (CS, Canada).
reflection and research. Equally important,
there is the development of a global view and
a heightened moral purpose which form the So far, the research capturing the co-evolution of
foundation for this approach (CS, Jamaica). sustainability content, pedagogy and increased
student engagement is on a limited scale although
there is a growing amount of anecdotal evidence.
In contrast another response indicates that this co- The evidence base is still not solid enough to draw
evolution of pedagogy may not be ‘driven’ by ESD. firm conclusions, but it is a promising direction for
further study.
I do not believe that ESD has necessarily led to
these changes. The changes in learning styles ESD’s presence goes hand-in-
and the development of ESD have happened
together, but without direct causality, as there hand with a rethinking of the
are many other reasons for university teachers kind of learning necessary to
developing newer and more active styles of
learning (GMES, United Kingdom). address sustainability issues.
X Summary Notes
The discourse concerning ESD has shifted. ESD is that allow for the development of the whole hu-
viewed as a mechanism for transforming educa- man being.
tion and learning, not simply as an addition of sus-
tainable development-related content to curricula. Although data indicate the presence of ESD trig-
gers the emergence of these new or alternative
The responses collected in the DESD M&E exercise forms of learning, more research is needed to
all seem to point to a need for well-rounded, inter- prove a causal relationship.
active, integrated and blended forms of learning
Chapter 2
29
Learning in Specific ESD Contexts
This section looks at the various ESD contexts: number of respondents than others in the Global
Early Childhood Care & Education (ECCE), Pri- Monitoring and Evaluation Survey (GMES), there-
mary Education, Secondary Education, Higher fore providing more data. Higher education and
Education, Technical & Vocational Education primary education were the most represented;
(TVET), Non-formal Education, and Education education in the commercial/private sector and
in the Commercial/Private Sector. in early childhood education and care, the least
(Figure 2.2).
Some ESD contexts were represented by a larger
60
Times ticked by respondents (n=216)
40
20
0
Early Primary Secondary Vocational Higher Non-formal Commercial/
Childhood Education Education Education Education Education Private
30
There are 313,656 children aged 0 to 5 years old in Jamaica. The orientation Law on Natio-
Statistics indicate that there is enrolment of 96.4% of chil- nal Education enacted in 2008
dren from the relevant age cohort in early childhood insti- stipulates in Article 39 that
tutions. There are 2,137 basic schools in the island, the vast Preparatory Education aims
majority of which are community-run institutions. Although include: support for children
enrolment is high, the quality of education, stimulation and through fun activities, the de-
care offered in some of these facilities leaves much to be de- velopment of their personali-
sired. In some institutions, staff is untrained, classrooms are
ty, making them aware of their
crowded, there is a lack of resource material and curricula
bodies, especially through the
are inappropriate. Currently there are moves to implement
acquisition of sensorimotor
and enforce uniform standards and curricula under an Early
Childhood Commission. skills through play, the crea-
tion of good social skills by
ECCE in Jamaica. UNICEF: http://www.unicef.org/jamaica/children_1568.htm engaging them in social life.
A formal programme of Pre-
paratory Education is syste-
Why do kindergartens offer more for moving towards a more matically applied in all classes
sustainable world than many of our universities? Kindergar- of preparatory education
tens ideally are places where young children live and learn, through the national terri-
explore boundaries, in a safe and transparent world without tory. This programme aims to
hidden agendas. Kindergartens are places where conflict develop in children a number
emerges every day and is used as a ‘teachable’ moment. Kin- of basic skills related to sus-
dergartens today often are multi-cultural places where kids tainable development, inclu-
with different backgrounds come together and get to know ding: confirming their own
each other as they are, not as they are portrayed by others. identity and self, communi-
Kindergartens are also places where different generations cating using different means
meet and interact (children, parents, grandparents). They are and tools, seek strategies to
often located in the heart of the community. There are no
discover the components of
dumb questions in kindergarten and there’s always time for
the surrounding environment,
questions and questioning. The life-world of the child forms
and interacting with others
the starting point for learning, not a disciplinary problem.
There is room for exploration, discovery and multiple ways of (GMES, Algeria).
expressing oneself. It’s a place filled with energy. And there
are some basic rules, principles, and skills needed to function
in an organic whole. The level of formal commitment
to integrating ESD in ECCE varies
Kindergartens as a learning context for ESD (Finnish UNESCO Series on greatly around the world.
ESD).
To create ECCE conducive to the type of learning environment ESD has become an integral
described in the example above from Finland, policies and frame- component of ECCE: As ECE is
works must exist that recognise the importance of such an envi- one of the key factors to meet
ronment and its benefits for a child’s development. the EFA goals and MDG goals;
trainings for ECE interven-
tions held everywhere covers
ESD (GMES, Myanmar).
© OMEP 2010
31
OMEP (Organisation Mondiale pour l`Éducation
Préscolaire), with the UNESCO Chair Early Child- OMEP promotes the rights of the child to
hood Education at the University of Gothenburg, education and care worldwide and supports
has developed a method to get children to think activities that improve access to high quality
and talk about sustainability. It uses images, often education and care; they report 9142 children
the children’s own drawings. involved in their programme with an impact
on 385 preschools, schools and other settings
for small children in 241 cities and regions
around the world (KIS).
32
Unlike in ECCE, primary and secondary schools
have a history of engaging in topics related to More than a thousand schools in Tabasco have
ESD. Often these are labeled environmental edu- been subject to repeated flooding in the past
cation or health but also, more recently, global five years, and the schools that are not flooded
citizenship, disaster preparedness, climate change are pressed into service as refuges or emer-
and consumerism. gency shelters. This throws into sharp relief
the close relationship between DRR and school
performance prejudicing the sense of norma-
The Canadian province of Manitoba is re-
lity and having a powerful effect on the qua-
orienting its schools to address sustainable
lity of the process as a whole. The school as a
development. ESD is part of the mission
centre of refuge becomes a mediator between
statement of the Ministry of Education of
Manitoba, stating: “To ensure that all Mani- the different forms of inclusive education. ESD
toba’s children and youth have access to an and risk management must be designed as in-
array of educational opportunities such that clusive elements in their coexistence strategies
every learner experiences success through in contexts of religious and cultural diversity
relevant, engaging and high quality educa- and other situations that may challenge inclu-
tion that prepares them for lifelong learning sivity (CS, Mexico).
and citizenship in a democratic, socially just
and sustainable society.” The first overarching
goal of the ministry is to ensure education in ESD is mentioned in official curricula of se-
Manitoba supports students experiencing condary schools. However, most educational
and learning about what it means to live in projects on SD are undertaken outside the
a sustainable manner. The province of Mani- framework of formal curricula, in collabora-
toba has a total of 181,862 students who will tion with environmental NGOs, institutions
be able to grow up as key actors in building a and other local organizations. These mainly
more sustainable society. See: Manitoba Edu- foresee an active involvement of students in
cation, http://www.edu.gov.mb.ca/edu/ participatory/ interactive/open air activities.
…climate change/biodiversity/risk reductions
Around the globe there are literally tens of thou- are seen as aspects of the broader issue of SD.
sands of ESD projects, some school-based, some As an example, hundreds of schools partici-
extracurricular through school clubs, and count- pate every year at the ESD WEEK, promoted
less teaching materials, many in print and many by the Italian Commission for UNESCO in the
more in digital form. framework of the DESD campaign, with a wide
range of activities such as seminars, lessons,
laboratories, role games, exhibitions... (GMES,
ESD is becoming a part in ‘Creative Experience
Italy)
Activity’ of 2009 National Curriculum – ESD
is often integrated in related thematic areas
– environmental education, green growth ESD is appearing in primary and secondary educa-
education, energy education, climate change tion as part of the curriculum.
education, multi-cultural education, etc. Sur-
vey Results in 2010 showed that teachers were
conducting ESD in their education programs All schools were required to draw up a SD plan
including curricular, extracurricular, and alter- by the end of 2010. This plan must contain the
native activities, as well as school-wide ap- following: implementation of ESD, account on
proaches such as model school projects. Most how the school will change its operations and
schools that participated in the survey 2010 everyday activities so that these correspond
had education programs on SD-related themes to the targets set in the plan as well as who is
such as climate change, energy, cultural diver- responsible for the implementation. The pro-
sity, democratic citizen, etc. but it was seen that motion of sustainable development has been
a lot of ESD programs were conducted based incorporated into the national curricula in
on the enthusiasm of teachers or the interest basic education and in general and vocational
of principals in model school projects, etc. ESD upper secondary education. National Board
training for teachers was conducted by Seoul of Education works in close cooperation with
Office of Education in 2011 with the coopera- schools and communes to enhance the ESD
tion with UNESCO (GMES, Republic of Korea). (GMES, Finland).
Chapter 2
33
ESD has become a key and/or integral compo- After the new education standards have been
nent of primary education . . . this is evidenced developed and new textbooks are being writ-
in some disciplines like social studies, science ten, ESD is becoming more and more a part of
and out of class activities. Teachers make sche- Primary Education. Still, there is certainly hope
mes of work, and it’s examinable at national for more (GMES, Armenia).
levels of primary (GMES, Uganda).
© UN Photo/Shareef Sarhan
34
Yet more is needed, respondents said.
ESD has become a key and/or integral compo-
nent of secondary education. In our associa-
ted schools, more than 150 schools, we tried There is need for government and key line
that our work plan and project focus on ESD in ministries to prioritize ESD as part of primary
each program during this 5 years, 2010/2015 education; building on some of the existing
(GMES, United Arab Emirates). school based ESD approaches that have pro-
ven appropriate in given pilot schools and tea-
cher training institutions (GMES, Uganda).
ESD is a integral part of Tonga Curriculum Re-
view although ESD is not put through as a pac-
kage. In our current curriculum review activi- So in the future, we hope for more attention
ties, ESD is included in all Key Learning Areas. to ESD in underdeveloped regions, especially
They are English, Maths, Science, Tongan, providing more ESD trainings to teachers and
Movement and Fitness, Tongan Society and principals (GMES, China).
Cultures, Design and Technology (GMES,
Tonga).
More teacher training, vocational develop-
ment, more guides for teachers... (GMES,
We have adopted a consistent integrated ap- Egypt).
proach to ESD. The better and broader oppor-
tunities, in our opinion, [stand to] achieve bet-
ter outcome results. ESD is part and parcel of Pre-service and in-service teacher educa-
all curricula by grade, by subject [with] explicit tion on ESD and ESD approaches needs to be
interdisciplinary links stated apart from the conducted - Good practices need to be shared
specific study content. Besides, by choosing to encourage teachers and students - Quality
their core curriculum and free elective courses, Criteria or Guidelines for ESD implementation
schools and students can decide on their own needs to be distributed for teachers - Compe-
[to go] deeper into particular topics (GMES, tencies for ESD of teachers need to be fostered
Bulgaria). (GMES, Republic of Korea).
ESD is already taken on board in many Primary Curricula Framework programs are theoreti-
Schools. This is set to increase in the future cally oriented and treat the contents of ESD,
(GMES, Malta). but there is not sufficiently practical co-or-
dination at local level (GMES, Bosnia and
Herzegovina).
The recently revised programmes have in-
cluded the concepts of ESD in every subject
such as protection of the environment, citi- There are two main strategies for ESD. One is the
zenship education… (GMES, Burundi). add-on and integration strategy (Table 2.2); the
other is the whole system redesign strategy. The
first seeks to widen the space within existing, of-
ten national, curricula for ESD; the second chal-
Japan has included ESD into its national lenges the entire system by reorienting:
curriculum guidelines and promotes ESD
through more than 300 UNESCO Associated Educational content structure (traditionally
Schools. The project was launched to en- disciplinary-based, conceptually abstract and
hance the overall learning process in support separate from the real world, now moving
of new attitudes and action for sustainable toward exploration of community problems
development and to enable students to un- through interdisciplinary studies);
derstand the concept and, in a practical way,
to become actively involved in it. Students Learning processes (traditionally teacher-
took a real interest and not only grasped centred stressing transfer of knowledge and
many of the issues facing the world today but the development of cognitive skills, now
began to understand, on their own, how to moving toward student-centred participatory
Chapter 2
deal effectively with them. learning that uses analytical thinking and
decision-making); and
35
School organization (traditionally hierarchi- Both strategies are used simultaneously in many
cal with limited teacher, parent and student countries. But in countries that provide more
participation and without connection to the space for participation and community engage-
surrounding community, now moving toward ment, and also in countries where entrepreneur-
more participatory decision-making involving ship is becoming an important part of education
school and community). and training, the opportunities for a whole system
redesign appear much greater.
Chapter 2
© UN Photo/Kibae Park
36
© UN Photo/F Charton
Schools engaged in ESD try to model sustainability
Demonstraon of ESD Changes needed to make
Country Status of ESD
becoming integrated ESD stronger
Bahamas Being integrated • ESD being included in • Build capacity for teachers to in-
the curriculum of many fuse ESD within core curriculum
schools through eorts of • Integrate ESD into the Ministry of
NGOs which incorporate Educaon’s curriculum with suf-
ESD into their educaon cient funding
programmes that include
eld trips, school presen-
taons and environmental
summer camps
• Existence of a naonal cur-
riculum for environmental
educaon, in which stu-
dents are engaged in sev-
eral iniaves relang to
island sustainable develop-
ment
• Schools learning from oth-
ers which are including ESD
Guyana Being integrated • ESD infused in primary cur- • Provide beer training for teach-
riculum ers in the government schools
• Primary curriculum being • Increase science literacy require-
revised to ensure that it ments in primary schools
is aligned with Guyana’s
Low Carbon Development
Strategy
• Establishment of health
and environmental clubs
• Promoon of “culture
days” in schools
• School compeons fo-
cused on SD issues
Jamaica Being integrated • ESD part of primary cur- • Encourage greater collaboraon
riculum, e.g. within aain- with associate agencies such as
ment targets and objec- the Naonal Environment and
ves of the Social Studies Planning Agency (NEPA) to en-
and Science sure that the objecves for sus-
• Values, skills and atudes tainable development are real-
learnt provide a frame- ized
work for the applicaon of
knowledge, leading to SD
37
Some respondents are indeed seeing movement
toward re-orienting teaching, learning and the When schools look specifically at their grounds
school itself towards sustainability. This ‘whole they are often looking at different aspects of
school approach’ takes everything into consider- ESD. Growing their own fruit and vegetables
ation: day-to-day operations (energy use, cater- is one of the most popular ways of doing this
ing, staff and student mobility, decision-making) and there is a range of organizations, initia-
curriculum, pedagogy and community links (in- tives and support programs to help them do
volvement of parents and other stakeholders and this. Therefore this is proving very popular
resources, using the community as a living learn- with all age groups and abilities of children.
ing laboratory). Increasing biodiversity within grounds is also
popular and many schools develop habitats
The most significant learning processes have within their grounds allowing for study inside
been collaborative, whole school develop- and outside of lessons e.g. through clubs and
ment processes that involve all members societies (KIS, United Kingdom).
of the school staff and the students. The in-
fluence of these processes goes beyond what
is achieved in terms of learning SD contents. In the Asia Pacific region, there has been
The processes have had impacts at the social great progress in both implementation of
level generating participatory skills that are programmes at the school level and in the
crucial in promoting SD and which are also reforms needed to include sustainability into
transferable to be used in other contexts out- education. China has designated 1,000 scho-
side the school. The use of the SD criteria and ols as experimental schools for Education
self-evaluation conducted before applying the for Sustainable Development (ESD) and has
certificate have also had remarkable impacts included ESD in the National Outline for Me-
in the development of school curriculum and dium and Long-term Education Reform and
learning methods like active and participatory Development (2010-2020). These changes
learning (KIS, Finland). have allowed (exploring) school reform and
the inclusion of sustainability practices in the
educational system (GMES).
[M]uch more emphasis [is placed] on imple-
menting an holistic and comprehensive ap- As schools work more closely with community
proach towards understanding, contextuali- groups and open up to the wider society, connec-
zing and developing ESD issues at the school tions are made with higher education.
level, engaging diversity of stakeholders from
inside and outside the educational system lin-
Universities play a significant role in training
king school and community . … a rethinking of
and development of local resources for the
the school model as more open to community
participation of the project, managing the in-
expectations, demands, and participation and
terrelationship of health care, education, civil
not solely understood as formal provisions and
defense, Red Cross, among others. Interven-
settings, could lead to a better understanding
tion activities and actions of the project are
of ESD issues at the school level and to their
developed, depending on the territorial, in the
effective development as part of the school-
schools, health centers, houses of family doc-
based curricula (UNIR, UNESCO IBE).
tors and clinics and institutions, workplaces,
factories, industries, cooperatives agricultural
production, basic units of cooperative produc-
PERL and many other actors in the field have
tion, video halls, houses of culture, commu-
focused on providing active, practical ways of
nities, neighborhoods and other places that
learning, methods involving the local commu-
were eligible to have as many people to parti-
nity around the school in learning processes,
cipate (GMES, Uruguay).
and methods which open for input from elder-
ly citizens (KIS, Norway).
Another trend seen in formal education (K-12) is
that concepts like global citizenship, inter-cultural
dialogue and life-skills are becoming part of the cur-
riculum. These concepts are not always explicitly con-
Chapter 2
38
In addition to academic subjects, co-curricu-
ESD school recognion and
lar subjects such as moral and civic education, cercaon
human rights and Life Skills contain ESD rela-
ted topics. For example, Life Skills includes les- There are networks of recognized schools, school
labels and certification schemes in place that can
son topics related to the following seven areas:
help schools realise their sustainability ambitions.
environmental and sanitation, emotional
Sometimes these are supported by a national ed-
intelligence; disease prevention and nutrition;
ucation authority and sometimes by a sustainabil-
drug use; social skills; reproductive health, HIV/ ity-oriented NGO.
AIDS… (GMES, Myanmar).
39
Eco-schools has over 11.7 million students Government’s initiatives for mainstreaming
engaged in its programmes in 52 countries of peace, moral, human rights, environment,
and works to empower students to be the etc. relating issues in school education can be
change our sustainable world needs by enga- considered as evidence in this direction. The
ging them in fun, action-oriented learning. In socio-cultural problems, economic situations
30 countries their activities include corporate and the increasing effect of globalization have
sponsored programmes worth approximately compelled us to re-orient our education to ESD
1.7m USD annually. The relevance and effi- (GMES, Nepal).
ciency of their energy-saving programmes are
outstanding: in England, a 20% reduction in
CO2 over the last three years, in Australia ener-
gy savings for up to 71%. The global average is
around 8-10% (KIS, Denmark).
Eco-schools incorporates seven elements for
schools to adopt as a methodology. These
elements have been designed to be the core
of the Eco-schools process, yet the structure is
flexible enough to be adopted in any country, © UN Photo/Eskinder Debebe
and at any level of schools’ previous environ-
mental achievement. Student involvement
throughout the process is an integral factor. Summary Notes: Primary and
A committee organizes and directs Eco-scho- Secondary Educaon
ols activities and consists of the stakeholders
from the school environment: pupils, teachers, ESD in primary and secondary schools around the
cleaners, caretakers, parents and governors. world manifests itself in many forms, sometimes
The sense of democracy involved, and the under different names.
motivation in resolving initiatives brought Recognition is growing that its value is greater as a
forth by the students themselves are products source of innovation in teaching and learning than
of this process. Each school produces its own as simply another subject to add to the curriculum.
‘Eco-code’ or statements of intent, outlining
what the students are striving to achieve (KIS, Countries and regions are paying greater atten-
Denmark). tion to threats to future wellbeing (e.g., tsunamis
and extreme weather events). This coincides with
a call for innovation in education and for stronger
ties between schools and communities. Whether
Coping with changing polical or not a causal link exists between these trends
climates is not known. The possible co-evolution (or co-
evolution with some interaction) of these three is
While the trends reported all seem favorable to a point of departure for further study.
the expansion of ESD, there are systems in place
especially in formal education that can be resis- Yet it must be stressed that conditions and for-
tant to innovation. Also, a change of government mal educational systems differ widely around the
can open more opportunities for ESD or it can world. The more autonomy allowed to schools,
mean a shift to other priorities and a lack of sup- teachers and students to shape curricula, the
port for ESD, as some respondents reported. greater the likelihood of education innovation
and cross-boundary learning in and with society.
There are systems in place Where the space for self-determination is limited,
the development of quality educational material
especially in formal education that can be linked easily to existing mandated cur-
that can be resistant to ricula will remain necessary.
synergy to a host of social issues competing for learning and processes, teachers, their preparation
space in schools’ already overcrowded curricula. and continued professional development, are im-
40
portant to primary and secondary education. With ment across all sectors: for teachers/educators,
this in mind, the UNECE published Learning for the managers and leaders; governing and managing
future: Competences in Education for Sustainable institutions; curriculum development and monitor-
Development. This document makes recommen- ing and assessment. It also identifies a framework
dation to policy makers on professional develop- of core competencies in ESD for educators.
Achieving transforma-
Holisc approach Envisioning change
on
The educator The basics of systems The root causes of Why there is a need
understands thinking unsustainable deve- to transform the edu-
... lopment caon systems that
support learning
The educator is Work with dierent Facilitate the eva- Assess learning out-
able to . . . perspecves on dilem- luaon of potenal comes in terms of
mas, issues, tensions consequences of dif- changes and achie-
and conicts ferent decisions and vement in relaon to
acons sustainable develop-
ment
The educator Acvely engage dif- Encourages noons of Help learners clarify
works with ferent groups across alternave futures their own and others
others in ways generaons, cultures, worldviews through
that . . . places and disciplines dialogue, and reco-
gnize that alternave
frameworks exist
The educator is Is inclusive of dierent Is movated to make Is a crucially reecve
someone who disciplines, cultures a posive contribu- praconer
... and perspecves on to other people
including indigenous and their social and
knowledge and world- natural environment,
views. locally and globally
Table 2.3 UNECE Competencies in ESD for Educators
See: hp://www.unece.org/leadmin/DAM/env/esd/6thMeetSC/Learning%20for%20the%20Future_%20
Competences%20for%20Educators%20in%20ESD/ECE_CEP_AC13_2011_6%20COMPETENCES%20EN.pdf
X Higher Educaon
quirements (ISCED 5A) or programmes that are
more practical, technical and/or occupationally
specific (ISCED 5B). The second stage of tertiary ed-
ucation (ISCED 6) comprises programmes devoted
to advanced study and original research and lead-
ing to the award of an advanced research qualifi-
cation (Global Monitoring Reports, UNESCO).
© UN Photo/Fred Noy
An analysis of the International Journal of Sustain-
Higher education covers programmes with more ability in Higher Education (IJSHE) reveals that be-
advanced educational content than is offered at tween 2001-2010 most articles focused on such
secondary levels. The first stage of tertiary edu- topics as environmental management, university
cation is composed of largely theoretically based greening and reducing a university’s ecological
programmes intended to provide sufficient quali- footprint (Table 2.4). The number of articles on
fications for gaining entry to advanced research pedagogy, learning, instruction, community out-
reach and partnerships increases in later volumes.
Chapter 2
41
Area n. arcles %
Environmental management/ecological footprint/campus greening 44 25
Integrang sustainability in exisng disciplines 31 17
Pedagogy, learning & instrucon 31 17
Philosophy/principles/concepts 19 11
Community outreach/partnerships 15 8
Policy/organizaonal learning/instuonal commitment 15 8
Course development/curriculum 7 4
Auding, assessment, quality assurance 10 6
Research 3 2
Competencies, professional development 3 2
Total: 178 100
Table 2.4 Thematic focus of articles published in the first nine volumes of IJHE (Wals and Blewitt, 2010).
Today there are still many examples of universi- In many places too narrow a concept is taken
ties seeking to reduce their own environmental
and emphasis is placed solely on environ-
footprint by ‘greening the campus’ initiatives,
mental or technical aspects. Thus, chemical
often led by students. In the curriculum, the ap-
engineers may rebrand their classes on pinch
proaches known as ‘bolt-on’ (adding new courses
and modules that have ESD elements) and ‘built- technology as ESD without considering the wi-
in’ (integrating sustainability in existing study and der societal implications. The future emphasis
research programmes) can be found as well. must be on embracing the wider field of global
societal responsibility, preferably in an inter-
Recently, a growing number disciplinary manner (GMES, United Kingdom).
of universities appear to
Recently, a growing number of universities appear
be engaging in a more to be engaging in a more fundamental makeover
fundamental makeover task. task. They are reorienting teaching, learning and
research in a way that will lead to new mental
models, competencies and innovations that can
At the University of Guyana (UG), teaching, contribute to sustainable living. Such engage-
research and outreach activities support ESD. ment is also leading to alternative views of science
Specifically, the School of Earth and Environ- itself and of the role of the university in society.
mental Sciences (SEES) offers specialised pro- Empirical, analytical and reductionist ways of un-
grammes, such as their BSc in Environmental derstanding the world are being complemented
Studies, which offer a wide knowledge and with more integrative and holistic approaches,
skills base. The programme also includes a and with methodologies better suited to cope
course specifically dedicated to environmen- with complexity, uncertainty and contested
tal education: Introduction to Environmental knowledge. New forms of learning are emerging
Education. SEES also is actively engaged in in the process:
awareness raising and educational activities
among the University populace as well as the Interdisciplinary learning, project-based learn-
general public through the organisation and ing, gaming, computer simulations, distance
hosting of events such as seminars, field trips learning, backcasting, case-studies, policy-lab-
and activities in recognition of international oratories, problem-based learning, bootstrap-
environmental days (e.g., International Bio- ping, values education, ecological footprint
diversity Day, International Ozone Day, etc.), analysis, transdisciplinary learning, experiential
and the formation of a student environmental approaches, reflective journal writing.
club (GMES, Guyana).
Chapter 2
42
Many respondents from various regions point out
The most important change is the fact that ESD how difficult it is to reshape deeply entrenched
is now taken up in a transversal and transdisci- routines, structures and practices. Nonetheless,
plinary way in institutions. It fosters increased there are examples of universities beginning to do
interest at all levels within higher education so, often in partnership with other universities and
institutions (KIS, International Association of the local community.
Universities).
43
University Sains Malaysia (USM) was selected by USM has executed a rebranding and advocacy
the Malaysian Ministry of Higher Education to programme that deepens and translates its main
implement the Accelerated Programme for Ex- mission as “a pioneering university, trans-disci-
cellence (APEX) program. USM has built its edu- plinary and research-intensive that empowers
cation, research and community engagement future talents and enables the bottom billions to
programs around sustainability. USM’s APEX pro- transform their socioeconomic well-being.” USM
posal is called, “Transforming Higher Education is also part of the UNU-recognized RCE-system.
for a Sustainable Tomorrow”.
Figure 2.5: University Sains Malaysia as an example of university re-orienting itself entirely towards sustainability
and receiving national recognition for doing so (KIS, Malaysia and www.kck.usm.my).
© UN Photo/Eskinder Debebe
44
IHE performance indexes like the Times Higher Education Index, the QS-index and the Shang-
hai Index focus on ‘research output’ and ‘internationalisation’ but pay no attention to Ranking
universities on a sustainability scale. In contrast, the Green League Table is compiled us-
ing sustainability indicators by People and Planet (P&P), which is a coalition of UK students.
See: hp://peopleandplanet.org/green-league-2011/table
IHEs are contributing to the development of sustainability competence (see Table 2.5) inside and
outside the higher education community through their courses, professional development pro-
grammes, community outreach activities, etc.
• Competence to think in a forward-looking manner, to deal with uncertainty, and with predic-
tions, expectations and plans for the future.
• Competence to work in an interdisciplinary manner.
• Competence to see interconnections, interdependencies and relationships.
• Competence to achieve open-minded perception, trans-cultural understanding and coopera-
tion.
• Participatory competence.
• Planning and implementation competence.
• Ability to feel empathy, sympathy and solidarity.
• Competence to motivate oneself and others.
• Competence to reflect in a distanced manner on individual and cultural concepts.
Table 2.5 Generic Sustainability Competences’ based on the ideas of Gestaltungskomptenz developed in Ger-
many (de Haan 2010; Adomssent and Michelsen, 2007).
Finally, more than 200 universities have signed the UNESCO-endorsed Earth Charter as an ethi-
cal framework for guiding education and research (www.earthcharterinaction.org). The Talloires
Declaration, a ten-point action plan for incorporating sustainability in all IHE activities has been
signed by 437 university leaders in over 50 countries.
See: http://www.ulsf.org/talloires_declaration.html
Ranking universities on a sustainability scale.
45
© UN Photo/Ariane Rummery
reduction and a support to socio-economic de- towards the needs of the labour market and, more
46
broadly, of the community. The UNESCO-UNEVOC
International Centre for Technical and Vocational ESD has become a key and/or integral compo-
Education and Training assists UNESCO’s Member nent of technical and vocational education.
States in upgrading their TVET systems but also in Now in Egypt we take in our consideration to
aligning them with the principles of sustainable implement the sustainability management in:
development. See: http://www.unevoc.unesco.org 1- Development the curricula 2- Training the
teachers. 3- Equipment (GMES, Egypt).
In comparison to the early DESD years, we see an
important shift. Before, ESD advocates were the
ones pushing for TVET engagement in sustainabil- In some places ESD is taken on board. He be-
ity. Today, the push is coming from business and came an integral part of the new modular cur-
industry. Confronted with environmental crises, riculum this item through entrepreneurship,
resource scarcity, policies requiring reductions of
democracy and human rights and increased
carbon-prints, changing consumer demands plus
the fund of practical training. They expect the
new green technologies, the private sector is keen
reports and results analysis (GMES, Bosnia and
to update workers’ capacities to better respond to
these changes. Herzegovina).
Today, the push is coming ESD has become a key and/or integral compo-
from business and industry. nent of technical and vocational education.
The promotion of sustainable development
Ministries of Education but also of Ministries of has also been incorporated in the national
Economic Affairs around the world appear to be curricula in upper secondary vocational edu-
pushing for a TVET upgrade that includes pre- cation (GMES, Finland).
paring people for a ‘greener’ way of producing.
In 2010, the Minister of Higher Education Technical and vocational education official
made an urgent commitment to integrating guidelines mention SD aspects such as cultural
training towards a green economy into Tech- and natural heritage conservation, environ-
nical and Vocational colleges in South Africa. mental impact assessment, eco-architecture,
Green jobs and occupational training within agriculture and rural development, lands-
the Further Education and Training (FET) sec- cape preservation, cost-benefit analysis with
tor is a state priority. Following this there have environmental and social costs included. As
been attempts to institutionalise ES- related far as art school is concerned, an “architec-
training within state institutions as illustrated ture and environment” curriculum is available
by the following example: (GMES, Italy). See: http://www.istruzione.it/
The Central Johannesburg College (CJC) is getOM?idfileentry=217468
training youth towards artisan opportunities in
the green industries. Training of the first group In some countries, vocational education is part of
of twenty youths in solar geyser [hotwater sys- secondary education and ESD is linked to compe-
tems] installation started in May 2010 at the tencies any student needs to be successful after
Alexandra Campus spurred by the Department leaving school.
of Minerals and Energy’s project to install one
million household solar geysers by 2014. Train-
ing has been developed to provide innovative The Life Skills Curriculum addresses many to-
solutions to workforce development needs, by pics related to sustainable development with
promoting green career and business in the its various dimensions. In grade 11 there is a
vocational opportunities to youth as part of its unit about vocational and career training. It
mandate. CJC initiated a business plan compe- addresses the impact of work of individuals and
tition for 50 youth around the theme of green society and the need to respect the work and
innovation. The scope of green retrofitting workers as well as to realize the value and bene-
includes installation of photovoltaic technol- fits of working. In grade 9 there are units that
ogy, solar geyser, water harvesting, low energy address the election process and how one can
lighting and cooling systems among other exercise it within the school society. Themes of
built environment adjustments to meet inter- critical thinking and self-employment are also a
national compliance standards (Source: NJESD, focus in these subjects (NJESD, Oman)
Chapter 2
South Africa)
47
In contrast, ‘business as usual’ is reported in some
countries, where TVET is not responding to sus-
tainability challenges.
• To promote methods for the identifica- The demand for a workforce capable of working in
tion, forecasting and provision of skills such an economy is clearly on the rise. Vocational
to support the greening of products and schools are responding by reorienting their curri-
services, the growth of green sectors and cula.
to improve overall competitiveness in a
low-carbon future. From an ESD perspective, it is important to follow
this promising trend critically, to make sure the P
• To make TVET schools agents for local sus- for People and the P for Planet receive at least as
tainable development and stakeholders much attention as the P for Prosperity. The social
in coping strategies for climate change. pillar of sustainability needs to be added to the
• To integrate sustainable development TVET curriculum so that workplaces are equitable.
into entrepreneurial learning and busi- The new learning arising from this interest in
ness education. ‘green’ and ‘corporate social responsibility’ tends
• To include the dimension of sustainable to be competence-based. Students address real
development in the analysis of partner issues related to sustainability challenges faced
countries’ human resource development by a business. This form of learning coupled with
policies, with a focus on identifying and competence-based assessment can also be of in-
applying adequate indicators. terest for ESD in other contexts.
(Sustainable Development and Education and The idea of TVET schools as agents for local sus-
Training, ETF Position Paper, Turin 2011. p. 17). tainable development merits further exploration
Chapter 2
48
X Non-formal learning
In the GMES, non-formal learning was described and NGOs use media, including social media, to
as all learning initiated by community groups, civil highlight ESD-related topics. Here too, linkages
society organisations (CSOs), non-governmental with formal education are considered crucial.
organisations (NGOs) and networks that seek to
engage citizens (young and old) in sustainability-
The Tabasco state government generated a
related issues. Some of these activities may also
work programme that contributed to eve-
involve schools, colleges and universities, but are
not part of their curriculum. ryday presence of the issue in the mass media.
Notwithstanding a need to improve infor-
It is generally recognized that these learning forms mation quality, this initiative has played a
are linked and occur simultaneously, as illustrated key role in providing information for society
in the previous chapters. stakeholder and being the ESD issue to a broa-
der agenda tending towards responsible citi-
Much of the ESD non-formal learning is generated zenship (CS, Mexico).
by local municipalities and organizations like mu-
seums, environmental education centres, national
park systems etc., seeking to enrich their core ac-
Sustainable development has more so than
tivities with ESD. Many such initiatives see formal
other years been a topic for frequent reports
education institutes as natural partners, which
and debates in Swedish media during 2010.
results in blended learning – a mix of formal, non-
formal and informal. The independent national public service ra-
dio, television and the Swedish educational
broadcasting company, as well as commercial
ESD in Italy is largely carried out as non-formal television have of their own accord broadcas-
education at the local level. Many educational ted documentaries, critical societal reports
projects are conducted- in a synergic action - and debates in order to raise public awareness
by NGOs, regional/local institutions, parks, about sustainable development. One example
schools, universities, regional environmental is the radio program “The Globe” (Klotet)
agencies, and other local actors (GMES, Italy). which has discussed topics such as global
warming and biodiversity. Earth Hour is the
biggest global environmental campaign and
The institutions in jurisdiction of the Ministry in 2010 it engaged 128 countries. In Sweden
of the Environment (Environmental Board, two-thirds of the municipalities signed on,
State Forest Management Centre and Museum about 2,000 companies and more than 800
of Natural History) provide non-formal lear- schools participated in the event. In the end 53
ning activities for different age groups, mainly per cent of all Swedes turned out their lights
for pupils and they also organize SD related during Earth Hour. Teaching materials were
training and schooling activities for specific produced by the WWF for preschools, primary
target groups like land owners, small scale and secondary schools. Schools registered
entrepreneurs, administrative authorities, tea- their participation on the Internet, as well as
chers etc (GMES, Estonia). reported the plans and actions that had been
implemented over a longer period of time
(GMES, Sweden).
In Egypt, ESD is becoming part of the non-for-
mal education through community learning
centers. The number of NGOs participating When formal education and non-formal
in ESD has been increasing over the past four education are made complementary there is
years (Regional Synthesis Report, Arab Re- greater reciprocation and cohesion between
gion). the school and the community. Incorpora-
ting local community perspectives and ways
of social learning such as cooperative action
Media plans and group solidarity, intergenerational
learning processes, e.g. storytelling and dance
GMES respondents and case studies also refer and song, in formal education enhances rele-
to national campaigns and the use of media as a vance (CS, Mali).
Chapter 2
49
The Italian Commission for UNESCO orga- [M]ore than 30 media made special reports on
nises every year the «national week» on ESD ESD (KIS, China)
that gathers hundreds of entities and orga-
nisations that are engaged on the ground on
educational projects. The UNESCO campaign
There is a recognized (by media, business and
[provides] a clear picture: there are a signifi-
government and education) national trend
cant number of actors (local administrations,
toward the inclusion of sustainability in edu-
NGOs, regional environmental agencies,
cation. It is strongly related to real world pro-
parks..), that are engaged in education and
blem solving and active/applied learning and
programs focusing on SD. Educational and
includes foci on impacts on human health and
cultural events, including seminars, shows, ex-
quality of life as well as ecosystem health. The
hibitions, workshops, cinemas are organised
local and national media (magazines, news-
in the framework of these programs during
papers and some television news and youth
the ESD weeks. Schools collaborate with all
oriented media and online media) and the
above mentioned actors outside the “core”
education specific media (Chronicle of Higher
formal national curriculum, in accordance
Education, Inside Higher Education, newslet-
with their “scholastic autonomy”, i.e. their op-
ters and magazines and journals from educa-
portunity to create self-directed educational
tion associations/organizations) have repor-
paths (GMES, Italy).
ted on this trend. (KIS, USA)
50
At UN level, UNESCO and UNDP Lesotho colla- In October 2010, the UNESCO Office in Phnom
borated in the organization of the workshops Penh supported the Institute of Humanities
on “Media as Partners in ESD”. With this pro- and Social Sciences of the Royal Academy of
ject, UNESCO and UNDP contributed together Cambodia to organize the 4th National Confe-
towards the implementation of the Lesotho rence on Cambodia towards Decade of Edu-
ESD policy framework and addressed speci- cation for Sustainable Development (CDESD)
fically the important role that the media can 2005-2014: Lifelong Learning.
play to strengthen its lobbying/ advocacy role
The conference concluded by presenting some
of the UN Decade of Education for Sustainable
practical recommendations to the government
Development (2005-2014). (ESD Section Re-
and ESD concerned stakeholders. There is a
port to 187th session of the Executive Board of
need of media and communications strategy
UNESCO)
to increase awareness of lifelong learning pro-
grammes among young people. The Ministry
of Education Youth and Sport and the relevant
The UNESCO office in Bamako organized a work- ministries should strengthen and expand more
shop to support media production on sustainable related lifelong learning programmes for out
development for journalists from Mali, Burkina, of school youth to provide them the second
Guinea, Niger and Senegal. The main objective chance of education for career developments.
was to multiply media quality content produced The practical concepts of ESD and lifelong
on sustainable development. The workshop in-
learning should be integrated into the educa-
cluded:
tion system- formal and non-formal. There is
• Clear and simple information to understand cli- a strong need to conduct more research and
mate change, its causes and consequences and studies on ESD to inform the review of related
how to orient teacher training towards sustain- policies and the development of ESD and life-
ability. long learning strategies. (ESD Report to 186th
• Actions for adaptation and attenuation. Executive Board.)
• Basic language on climate change.
• Tools to create better quality of content on cli-
mate change. Private Sector
Recommendations from conferences are also
The programs and activities with regard to ESD
calling for media.
done by the Directorate General of Non-formal
and Informal Education are done inside “Com-
© UN Photo/Albert Gonzalez Farran
51
© UN Photo/Stuart Price
52
Learning in non-formal learning In the Dutch ‘Learning for Sustainable Deve-
Information on the type of learning taking place lopment’ programme the government itself is
in the non-formal context was noticeably scarce. considered a key stakeholder in ESD. Govern-
Few country case studies, national ESD journeys, ments are viewed as a learning organization
key informants and GMESD respondents were but are often forgotten as such in ESD. After
able to articulate the key characteristics of this all, they are responsible for educational and
learning. sustainability policies. Equally important, go-
vernmental organizations need to learn in or-
One conclusion we can draw nonetheless is that der to break out of the same disciplinary and/
much of this learning considers participation in lo- or sectoral silos that characterize schools and
cal development, use of local knowledge and rec- universities, in order to allow for more holistic
ognition of local realities to be crucial. Also, much
approaches (The Netherlands).
of this non-formal learning takes place at the in-
terface of school-community-private sector and is
cross-boundary in nature.
Summary Notes:
One of the secrets behind these successes lies Non-formal learning
in the way in which the ESD processes at Ban-
sunkong have been structured to appeal to the Nearly all respondents and case studies indicated
ethno-cultural and socioeconomic contexts that ESD in the context of non-formal learning is
of its students and its local community, and in vital and happening across the globe at various
levels.
the seamless nature of the transitions between
the formal, non-formal and informal teaching The review, however, yields little information
and learning activities that take place at the about the type of learning involved, the way such
school. In addition, the number and variety of learning can be designed, or the competencies re-
structured, ESD-relevant extra-curricular acti- quired to facilitate it.
vities that have been made available by the
school to both students and the local commu- Nonetheless some trends are worth noting:
nity all year round has seen Bansunkong be-
The boundaries between non-formal, informal
come a “life university” for people of all ages. and formal learning are becoming increasingly
The school offers an integrated community vague due to:
learning centre, which provides community-
sponsored courses and continuing education • schools and universities orienting themselves
classes for adults, as well as an on-site laun- more towards society and the learning around
dry and kitchen available free-of-charge with ‘real issues’ in rich contexts,
a view to improving hygiene and nutrition • the presence of media, particularly ICT-based
amongst the student body (CS, Thailand). media,
• increased emphasis on life-long learning,
• increased involvement of the private sector in
Research designs adopt participatory methods education and learning.
to promote partnership, equity, and reciprocal It remains to be seen how conducive these trends
dialogue and exchange between researchers, will be to strengthening ESD. Some are driven
educators, and community people. Communi- by economic rather than sustainability interests,
ty people are assisted to identify their environ- which may be conflicting.
mental and cultural ‘strengths’ that then serve
as entry points for learning for sustainability. Finally, what type of learning appears most appro-
Case studies and artefacts from the local com- priate in this ESD context? Social learning, discov-
munities are becoming part of learning pro- ery learning and problem-based learning seem to
cesses in formal education. In the case of com- have much merit, but more research is needed.
munities that identified, handicrafts, artworks
and curio shops, opportunities for non-formal
education and entrepreneurship are increased
(CS, Zambia).
Chapter 2
53
© UN Photo/Eskinder Debebe
EMERGENCE OF NEW
PARTNERSHIPS
IN SUPPORT
OF ESD
Multi-stakeholder Interaction
Multi-stakeholder social learning is essentially
The inter-sectoral and interdisciplinary dimen- about bringing together people of various back-
sion of education for sustainable develop- grounds and with different values, perspectives,
ment… is bound to engender new ways of knowledge and experiences, both from inside
thinking, new social and ethical attitudes, and and outside the group or organization, in order
innovative responses aimed at fostering sus- to move creatively towards the resolution of an is-
tainable development and low-carbon green sue for which no ready-made solutions exist. Such
practices (UNESCO Leaders Forum, 2011). learning is a means to involve people actively in
deep or fundamental processes of change.
Around the world, ideas like the ‘green economy,’ In the GMES, social learning was listed as one of
‘the digital age,’ ‘the knowledge society,’ ‘commu- nine options of ESD-related learning. Although it
nities of practice,’ and ‘lifelong learning’ are lead- ranked low among the nine, it ranked higher than
ing to a reconfiguration or at least a rethinking of the more traditional disciplinary and transmissive
how groups in society can connect and become learning (Figure 2.1 in Chapter 2).
more innovative, creative and resilient.
55
© UN Photo/Fred Noy
• assumes that we can learn more from one another if we do not all think or act alike:
people learn more in heterogeneous groups than they do in homogenous groups;
• requires the creation of trust and social cohesion, precisely in order to become more ac-
cepting and to make use of the different ways in which people view the world;
• cultivates ‘ownership’ with respect to both the learning process as well as the solutions
that are found, which increases the chance that things will actually take place;
56
the revived university science shops as desks,
both virtual and real, where members of the
community with limited resources can com- The UNEP–led Global Universities Network
mission research (http://www.livingknowledge. for Environment and Sustainability (GUPES)
org); was developed to support the mainstream-
ing of environment and sustainability con-
the networks of community-engaged univer- cerns into teaching, research, community
sities, for example: engagement and management of univer-
• Centro Boliviano de Estudios Multidiscipli- sities globally, by building on the African
experiences under MESA. Mainstreaming
narios (hp://www.cebem.org/)
environment and sustainability concerns
• ACU University Extension Network, (hp://
for sustainable development - which under-
www.acu.ac.uk/member_services/profes-
pins GUPES, involves a transformative learn-
sional_networks/extension/Extension) ing process and new ways of thinking about
• Imagining America (hp://imaginingameri- teaching, research and community engage-
ca.org/) ment.
• Campus Compact (hp://www.compact.
org/) A striking feature of the initiatives being
• Global Alliance of Community Engaged Re- developed particularly within the MESA
search hp://communityresearchcanada.ca) programme, is what can be described as a
• Global Universities Network for Innovation ‘new kind of teaching and research’, which
(hp://www.guni-rmies.net/) is aimed at community development and
• Global Universities Partnership on En- problem solving. This feature seems to per-
vironment and Sustainability (GUPES) meate all disciplines involved in the MESA
(http://hqweb.unep.org/training/pro- framework (e.g. law, engineering, science,
grammes/gupes.asp) education, journalism). Evidence of this
• PASCAL International Observatory (hp:// ‘new kind of teaching and research’ can be
found in the way that participating universi-
pascalobservatory.org/)
ties are:
• Society for Participatory Research in Asia
(hp://www.pria.org/) • Enhancing participation in research de-
• Talloires Network (hp://www.tus.edu/ sign and in the conduct of research that
talloiresnetwork/?pid=35;) benefits communities, and in paying
attention to the way that research out-
the transition town movement in the United comes are used for community benefit.
Kingdom and elsewhere; hp://www.transi-
onnetwork.org/ • Engaging students in service learning
and problem solving projects in ‘real life’
the centres of expertise focusing on sustain- contexts.
ability issues, such as the Regional Centres of
Expertise (mentioned above) • Forging stronger partnerships with local
communities and development groups
to identify priorities for research and de-
velopment work.
GUPES - re-orienting higher education towards sus-
tainability (UNIR, UNEP).
A new kind of
teaching and research
that benefits and
reaches communities
has emerged.
Chapter 3
© UN Photo/Fred Noy
57
MICA is a network of Pemban fishermen in
ProSPER.Net members have been shar- Tanzania, who represent the 50 shehia (small
ing knowledge, skills, perspectives, ex-
administrative units consisting of 1-3 villages)
periences and values related to sustain-
that use Misali Island Marine Conservation
ability through the network interaction
Area. It works to improve fishers’ quality of
and joint projects, what increases the
potentiality for transformations due to life while working towards natural resource
the mutual learning process and work- protection. It has been working with Pemban
ing together towards common goals. fishing communities for over 12 years and
The networking process enhances col- now has 1,561 active members (821 male, 740
laborative, trans-disciplinary and female) across all four Districts of the Island.
cross-boundaries undertakings with a MICA has facilitated establishment of envi-
multitude of partners, while address- ronmental clubs in over 20 primary and secon-
ing regional sustainability challenges. dary schools, and encourages student partici-
Projects that target integration of sustain- pation in environmentally education as well
ability issues were certainly enriched by dif- mangrove planting (KIS, Tanzania).
ferent perspectives arising out of ProSPER.
Net members’ cultural, social, environmen-
tal and economic backgrounds, making Crossing boundaries between different sectors
partners to work on collaborations that are and forms of education and learning is exciting,
adaptive and flexible enough to incorpo- but not easy, as some respondents pointed out.
rate different views, knowledge, contexts,
teaching methods and experience. How- The biggest barriers from an NGO viewpoint
ever, although this may be perceived as an are the lack of communication among poten-
advantage, it can also pose challenges, es- tial ESD stakeholders. School teachers, in
pecially when trying to accommodate dif- many cases, need assistance from knowled-
ferent stances regarding institutional con- geable experts, local community people, local
straints. companies etc., but teachers are too busy to do
ProSPER.Net - Promotion of Sustainability in Post- so. Many private companies have been expres-
graduate Education and Research Network (UNIR, sing their willingness to support local scho-
UN IAC, Japan). ols, but they don’t know how to do. In order
to overcome such communication problems,
local coordinators can play a significant role
(GMES, Japan).
X Summary Notes
In the second half of the Decade, ESD is taking
place in collaborative, trans-disciplinary, cross-
boundary contexts.
58
© UN Photo/Christopher Herwig
Whole-institution Approaches
This section looks again at the major changes that have come about in the DESD. It focuses on ESD’s role
in bringing about system change or whole system engagement.
Chapter 3
© UN Photo/Kibae Park
59
For the future of ESD, it is important to position
For the time being i.e. consumer education is it in relation to other educations with similar con-
considered as an issue. Also the connection cerns: it serves as the unifying theme.
between natural science education and social
science. The overall goal for work with ESD in
a Danish context is to provide pupils and stu- ESD reflects the local
dents with sufficient knowledge and skills to
make them able to participate in the democra-
environmental, social,
tic debate on distribution of the world’s natu- and economic conditions
ral resources (GMES, Denmark).
as well as the political realities.
© UN Photo/Kibae Park
60
The key message that comes from the story of Eco-Schools success has to be that for change to
happen, power must be disseminated to the point of implementation. Schools are dominated
by students. They are the ones who act as the eyes and ears of behavioural change. Develop the
schools processes and systems to support student led change. Eco-Schools highlight that ESD
is not just about curriculum content, but a whole of school body, whole of school mind set and
whole school action process. The case study also acknowledges that change is slow, incremental
and is only sustainable if genuine models of participatory learning and decision making form the
basis of the process.
The greatest gift a school head teacher can give to his/her students therefore, is the gift of free-
dom for self-directed and purposeful learning, supported by structures and processes that em-
power and engage with real life ecological issues.
The lessons of Eco-Schools also highlight that those who create the ecological footprint need to
have opportunities to reflect and understand what it means to be part of the environment, the
effects one has in all the different interconnected cycles and biomes of life and to be involved in
and control of remedial action or proactive measures.
Ultimately, Eco-Schools are a process that becomes a way of life. A cultural paradigm for school
administrators to master through delegation and a belief in their teachers and students capacity
to change the school from the ground up.
Eco-schools as an example of a whole school approach to sustainability (CS, International NGO).
61
The International Network associated
with the UNESCO Chair on Reorienting
Teacher Education to Address Sustainability
is comprised of teacher education institu-
tions (TEIs) from about 65 nations around
the world. The member institutions work
to incorporate sustainability into their pro-
grams, practices and policies. Each member
institution addresses environmental, social,
and economic contexts within their extend-
ed spheres of influence to create locally
relevant and culturally appropriate teacher
© UN Photo/Albert Gonzalez Farran education programs for both pre-service
and in-service teachers. (UNESCO Chair Re-
port, Canada)
SEdA offers a comprehensive program for
leaders in education across Canada. The
program aims are to inspire, create and sup- Meaningful progress
port a culture of sustainable development
in all aspects of the education system. SEdA towards sustainability
has a national and international group of
advisors who are leaders in ESD to provide can best be achieved
advice and ideas on current and successful when multiple actors engage
practices around the world.
in a whole system redesign.
The Academy’s program was designed by
faculty members at York University’s Schul- In some countries and provinces, the systemic
ich School of Business, the Faculty of Edu- change that has taken place in relation to ESD is
cation, the UNESCO Chair on Reorienting remarkable.
Teacher Education to Address Sustainabil-
ity and the NGO, Learning for a Sustainable With the support from The Prime Minister, the
Future. SEdA originally worked with senior Ministry of Education conducted six interna-
education leaders to reorient entire school tional seminars on GNH in December 2009.
systems to address ESD in five domains: Through the strategies derived from the semi-
1. governance (Board Services); nars, the Ministry conducted five day works-
hops for all the five hundred plus Principals,
2. curriculum/teaching learning (School College Directors and selected lecturers. The
Services); participants formulated Green School For
Green Bhutan concept and expressed their full
3. human capacity building (Human Re- commitment. ESD/GNH has been adopted as a
sources/Employee Services); national priority. Green School concept, GNH/
4. partnerships (Community Outreach Ser- ESD, is an integral part of performance mana-
vices); and gement system that draws a lot of inputs from
the School Self-assessment. The school self-as-
5. facilities (Operations Services). sessment tools have been oriented to take in
GNH/ESD values and process. All schools make
While the flagship offering of the Academy
GNH/ESD plans and review these plans bi-an-
is the 2 ½ day intensive, residential seminar
nually (GMES, Bhutan). See: 1. School Self-As-
SEdA is now working with teacher educa-
sessment 2. Guidelines for Educating for GNH
tors across Canada to identify the curricular
and pedagogical foundations to support in: www.education.gov.bt
the changes that are anticipated as a result
of the systemic/institutional reorienting Clearly these shifts represent a major challenge for
process. existing systems – schools and education systems
The Sustainability and Education Academy at York - and face a number of obstacles. Yet respondents
University, Canada is an example of a whole system refer to windows of opportunity and the early
Chapter 3
62
proponents.
The key barrier for strengthening ESD includes
the change of existing educational paradigm During the course of the DESD, as ESD is incorpo-
- from transfer and learning of facts which rated into educational systems, there is an appar-
does not stimulate creative social activity lea- ent shift towards a more fundamental rethinking
ding towards changes, to education in which of the key principles and assumptions underlying
critical questioning, thinking and making these systems.
conclusions is expected, that is the education
enabling the freedom of thinking, understan-
ding of reality and interrelations among envi-
ronment, society and economic development
(GMES, Croatia).
63
© UN Photo/Kibae Park
CONCLUDING
REMARKS
AND WAYS
FORWARD
“We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we used when we created them.”
Albert Einstein
General findings
Education for Sustainable Development is pears well positioned to play a synergizing role
seen increasingly as a means to renew edu- among a wide variety of sub-fields of educa-
cation, teaching and learning in ways that tion. These include environmental education,
allow schools, universities, vocational edu- global citizenship education and, more re-
cation and training institutes, communities cently, consumer education, climate change
and businesses to face challenges to sustain- education and education for disaster risk re-
ability. These challenges demand we learn to duction.
deal with change, complexity, controversy and
uncertainty. As a result, a wide range of ap- The ‘E’ in ESD is interpreted in different ways
proaches are used in ESD, including systems around the world and varies according to lo-
thinking-based learning, values-based learn- cal conditions. One determining factor is how
ing, problem-based learning, critical thinking- much space is allowed for learner participation
based learning and social learning. In some and self-determination. When this space is nar-
parts of the world, incorporating sustainabil- row, more transmission-oriented, instructional
ity or ESD into the curriculum is accompanied modes of ESD will result. When it is broad, ESD
by a co-evolution of pedagogy towards more will be characterized by autonomous thinking
learner-centred and participatory approaches. and knowledge co-creation. The latter versions
ESD has become a catalyst for educational in- of ESD call for alternative forms of teaching,
novation in certain settings. The discourse has learning and stakeholder interaction.
shifted from ESD as merely an addition to ex-
Boundaries between schools, universities,
isting curricula to ESD as an opportunity for
communities and the private sector are dis-
rethinking education.
solving in many countries. Teaching and re-
ESD is seen as a potential umbrella of edu- search in institutions of higher education have
cation approaches focused on the wellbe- a new focus on sustainability and real-world
ing of the planet and people. ESD is no lon- issues. Contributing trends: the call for lifelong
ger seeking its niche, as it was in the first years learning; globalization and ICT-mediated so-
of the UN Decade of ESD. Given the world’s cial networks; the call for relevance in educa-
Chapter 4
increasing concern with SD issues, ESD ap- tion in general; and the increased interest of
65
the private sector in human resource devel- ful progress comes only when existing prac-
opment. The resulting ‘boundary-crossing’ is tices, goals and values are questioned, and
reconfiguring formal, informal and non-formal new ones created with broad participation.
learning, as well as changing stakeholder roles As many respondents suggest, and indeed
and public-private relationships. This new con- show, this breakthrough can best be achieved
figuration provides a powerful platform for when multiple actors engage in a whole-sys-
ESD. The technical report cites examples of tem redesign. For schools and universities, the
multi-stakeholder social learning in the con- redesign spans curriculum, campus opera-
text of ESD, showing how different societal tions, organizational culture, leadership and
groups find and complement each other in management, community relations, research
creating local ESD and SD responses. and assessment. Today, worldwide interest in
moving towards sustainable ‘green’ growth
Interest is growing in ‘whole institution holds the promise of a major reorientation of
approaches’ or ‘whole system approaches’ our economies and societies. ESD is well-posi-
to ESD and sustainable development. The tioned to play a key role in such a transition.
trend is linked to the realization that meaning-
© UN Photo/Eskinder Debebe
Context-specific findings
ESD has begun to finds its place in Early opment in the world of work. Driven mainly
Childhood Care and Education (ECCE). Con- by economic interests and technological in-
ditions vary greatly around the world, but data novations, companies are beginning to move
provided by representatives of the sector show towards the ‘green economy’ and its related
the promise of ESD in ECCE. ‘green skills’ and ‘green jobs’. The demand for
a ‘green’ workforce is clearly on the rise and vo-
In primary and secondary education, ESD cational schools are adapting their curricula.
is increasingly recognized as a valuable
source of innovation in teaching and learn- Colleges and universities are starting to
ing. Around the world, increased attention make more systemic changes towards sus-
to sustainability-related subjects is coincid- tainability, and developing new relation-
ing with a call for educational innovation and ships with their communities. Institutions of
stronger links between school and commu- higher education (IHEs) are addressing local
nity. These trends may or may not be causally sustainability issues but also using their global
linked, but there is evidence that associating networks to benefit from perspectives and
them can reinforce all three. expertise elsewhere. At the same time, IHEs
are developing and introducing new forms of
The inclusion of ESD is having visible im- learning that can help people understand and
Chapter 4
pact in TVET and human resource devel- engage in sustainable development. This new
66
© UN Photo/Eskinder Debebe
kind of teaching and research, which is aimed some are driven by economic interests which
at community development and problem solv- may be conflicting. In this context, social learn-
ing, is dissolving the boundaries between IHEs ing, discovery learning and problem-based
and communities. learning seem to be the most relevant types,
but more research is needed.
The boundaries between non-formal, infor-
mal and formal learning become increas- Within the UN system ESD is far more part of
ingly vague as education institutions reorient the discourse and project implementation
towards society and refocus learning on real than it was two years ago. Findings suggest
issues that challenge the sustainability of both a paradigm shift towards more inter-sectoral,
local and global communities. Other contrib- cross-boundary and participatory forms of en-
uting factors include the presence of media, gagement. Various agencies are seeing a role
particularly ICT-based media; increased em- for ESD in responding to emerging themes and
phasis on life-long learning; and the rise of the issues like the green economy, climate change,
private sector’s involvement in education and disaster risk reduction, integral water manage-
learning. It remains to be seen whether these ment, sustainable resource governance, etc.
trends will be conducive to strengthening ESD;
Ways forward
The data collected for this report show that many
individuals, schools, NGOs and governments from
local to federal levels are stepping forward to sup-
port the evolution of education to create a more
sustainable future. These successes point to ways
forward for ESD and the DESD.
67
for educational reform, merging actions of various now and in the future. TVET and training with an
stakeholders from a wide range of disciplines and ESD perspective, offering both hard and soft skills,
career backgrounds into a common goal. is needed in green economies and green societies.
Equity of access to education is a pre-condition In tight financial times, UNESCO, and any actor
of ESD. The expanding world of social media and in ESD, should identify key change agents and
open source internet-based platforms is offering strategic leverage points for particular initiatives
new opportunities for access to education. Gov- and then work with those to improve their action,
ernments need to support these new methods reach and efficiency. Of course, everyone works
and link them to ESD to ensure that individuals, within their sphere of influence, so the key change
civil society organizations, and researchers world- agents change with scale. Planning for synergistic
wide can use and benefit from the latest technolo- activities with large multiplier effect will improve
gies and ICTS, as well as exercise their abilities to returns on investment.
create and share new knowledge. New technolo-
gies and ICTs are especially important to today’s Efforts should be made to work within climate
youth and to ESD. ICTs promote student-centred change, biodiversity, and disaster risk reduction
learning and appear to be speeding the rate of education to develop them as concrete examples
educational change. of ESD.
Fostering studies to provide qualitative and quan- Every day ESD becomes more relevant, as we are
titative data will strengthen the evidence base a long way from turning around negative trends
showing ESD can produce academic gains as well (e.g. ecosystem degradation and growing social
as boost people’s capacities to support sustain- and economic inequities). ESD is pertinent to all
able development. As the evidence base expands, challenges to sustainability and to all actors in
policies backing ESD will become more robust and society, not just education stakeholders. Twenty
widespread. This in turn will accelerate curriculum years ago Agenda 21, the official document from
innovation and encourage wider adoption of the the Earth Summit held in Rio de Janeiro, included
learning and processes highlighted in this report. Promoting Education, Public Awareness and Train-
As the research becomes available, governments ing as one of 40 chapters; yet education was also
and ESD stakeholders will have to step up efforts a crosscutting theme in the remaining chapters.
to better communicate the potential of ESD as Each chapter outlines a thematic area that is im-
quality education. portant for progress to create a more sustainable
world (e.g., agriculture and waste). The education
Whole school and whole system responses to ESD community must do its part and so must other
have proven effective at the pilot level: they im- communities (e.g., research, agriculture, finance
prove academic results and bring about positive etc.). Coordination of those efforts is also impor-
behaviour changes linked to sustainable practic- tant, especially as efforts are scaled up. UNESCO
es. Governments need to support these promis- and other UN Agencies can help with the coordi-
ing efforts to scale up and use more widely whole- nating efforts convening and connecting stake-
school and whole-system approaches to ESD. holders and experts as well as capacity-building
and supporting a coherent educational response
As ESD becomes a stronger component of pri- to challenges to sustainability locally and globally.
mary, secondary, higher and TVET education,
governments need to reflect ESD in assessment Although ESD is growing, evolving and maturing,
and evaluation efforts. Traditional assessment it is not implemented evenly across the board. A
and monitoring and evaluation systems must be limited group of ESD stakeholders have given vi-
modified to reflect the greater complexity of sus- tality to ESD through initial stages and thus far in
tainability content and skills in curriculum. The the DESD. Member States need to expand ESD by
balance between components of sustainability linking ESD to (1) the wider educational agenda
must also be maintained (e.g., ensuring the three and (2) the wider development agenda. These
Ps of planet, people, and prosperity are balanced linkages become increasingly important as 2014
in TVET). with the end of the DESD and 2015 with the end of
EFA and the MDGs approach. It is evident that the
Governments are scrutinizing expenditures care- countries of the world need to identify new goals
fully in this time of global financial instability. For and internally agreed upon processes for moving
years, education has been considered one of the forward to confront the educational and sustain-
best investments a country can make in its future. ability challenges of this century. ESD provides
Currently, ESD is seen as a good investment. As many opportunities in this endeavour.
the world discusses green economies, it is evident
Chapter 4
68
© UN Photo/Kibae Park
ESD is pertinent to all challenges
to sustainability and to all actors in society,
not just education stakeholders.
Chapter 4
69
ACRONYMS
70
KIS Key Informant Survey
M&E Monitoring and Evaluation
MDGs Millennium Development Goals
MESA Mainstreaming Environment and Sustainability in African Universities
MEEG Monitoring and Evaluation Expert Group
NEPA National Environment and Planning Agency
NESDJ National ESD Journeys
NGO Non-Governmental Organization
NJESD National Journeys toward Education for Sustainable Development
OMEP Organisation Mondiale pour l’Éducation Préscolaire
PERL Partnership for Education and Research about Responsible Living
RCE Regional Centre of Expertise
REDIES Network of Sustainable Institutions of Higher Education
SD Sustainable Development
SEES School of Environmental and Earth Sciences
SNCAE Sistema Nacional de Certificación Ambiental de Establecimientos Educacionales
TVET Technical and Vocational Education and Training
UG University of Guyana
UN United Nations
UNAIDS United Nations Joint Programme on HIV/AIDS
UNCED United Nations Conference on Environment and Development
UNCBD United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity
UNCCD United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification
UNDP United Nations Development Programme
UNECE United Nations Economic Commission for Europe
UNEP United Nations Environment Programme
UNESCO United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization
UNEVOC UNESCO International Centre for Technical and Vocational Education and Training
UNFCCC United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change
UNICEF United Nations Children’s Fund
UNIR Internal review of the contributions of UN agencies to ESD
UNLD United Nations Literacy Decade
UNU United Nations University
USM University Sains Malaysia
71
REFERENCES
Bird, E., Lutz, R. and Warwick, C. 2008. Media as part- Sterling, S. 2004. Higher education, sustainability,
ners in education for sustainable development: a and the role of systemic learning. Corcoran, P.B. &
training and resource kit. Paris, UNESCO. http://un- Wals, A.E.J. (eds), Higher Education and the Chal-
esdoc.unesco.org/images/0015/001587/158787e. lenge of Sustainability: Problematics, Promise, and
pdf Practice. Dordrecht, Kluwer Academic Press.
Belton, C. (Forthcoming). 2012. A Canadian school Tilbury, D. 2011. Assessing ESD Experiences dur-
experience. N. Nolet and R. McKeown (eds), ing the DESD: An Expert Review on Processes and
Schooling for Sustainable Development. Dordrecht, Learning for ESD. Paris, UNESCO. http://unesdoc.
Springer. unesco.org/images/0019/001914/191442e.pdf
De Haan, G. 2010. The development of ESD related UN. 2002. Plan of Implementation of the World Sum-
competencies in supportive institutional frame- mit on Sustainable Development. A/CONF.165/14,
works. International Review of Education. Vol. 56, Chap. I, Resolution 1, Annex II. http://www.un.org/
No. 2-3, pp.315-328. esa/sustdev/documents/WSSD_POI_PD/English/
WSSD_PlanImpl.pdf
Gendong, S. (ed). 2010. Advance the Construc-
tion of High-Quality Schools in Basic Education by UNEP. 2008. Mainstreaming Environment and Sus-
Education for Sustainable Development. [Project tainability in African Universities Partnership. Sup-
report] Beijing: Chinese National Working Com- porting Universities to Respond to Environment,
mittee for ESD. Sustainable Development and Climate Change
Challenges. 2004-2008 Report. Nairobi, UNON.
GUNi. 2012. Higher education in the world, 4.
Higher Education’s Commitment to Sustainability: UNESCO. 2005. International Implementation
From Understanding to Action. Basingstoke, Pal- Scheme (IIS) for the DESD. Paris, UNESCO.
grave Macmillan. http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0014/001486/
148654e.pdf
Mehlmann, M., McLaren, N. and Pometun, O. 2010.
Learning to live sustainably. Global Environmental UNESCO. 2009a. Review of Contexts and Structures
Research, Vol. 14, pp. 177-186. for ESD (by Wals, A.E.J.) Paris: UNESCO. http://unes-
doc.unesco.org/images/0018/001849/184944e.pdf
Michelsen, G. and Adomssent, M. 2007. Education
for sustainable development strategies in German UNESCO. 2009b. Bonn Declaration UNESCO
universities. Wals, A.E.J. (ed), From cosmetic Reform World Conference on Education for Sustain-
to Meaningful Integration: Implementing Education able Development. 31 March – 2 April 2009.
for Sustainable Development in Higher Education Bonn, UNESCO. http://unesdoc.unesco.org/
Institutes - The State of Affairs in Six European Coun- images/0018/001887/188799e.pdf
tries. Amsterdam, DHO.
UNESCO. 2011a. National Journeys towards Edu-
Peters, S. and Wals, A.E.J. 2012. Learning and know- cation for Sustainable Development 2011. Paris,
ing in pursuit of sustainability: Concepts and tools UNESCO.
for trans-disciplinary environmental research. Dil- http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0019/001921/
lon, J and Krasny, M. (eds), Trans-Disciplinary Envi- 192183e.pdf
ronmental Education Research. London, Taylor and
Francis.
References
72
UNESCO. 2011b. From Green Economies to Green
Societies: UNESCO’s Commitment to Sustainable
Development. http://unesdoc.unesco.org/
images/0021/002111/211136e.pdf
References
73
© UN Photo/Marie Frechon
74
Appendices
APPENDIX 1:
THE UN
CONTRIBUTION
TO THE DESD
Around the world, UNESCO has helped integrate years within the decade, an increasing number
sustainability principles and practices into educa- of Member States are now putting ESD policies
tion plans and programmes. It has reinforced Edu- into effect; the demand for policy advice on ESD
cation for Sustainable Development (ESD) imple- is growing fast. Many UN entities have developed
mentation at national and regional levels. Eight their own substantial contributions to the DESD.
Selected Achievements
75
UNESCO’s ESD and Teacher Education empowerment initiatives within the Basic
UNESCO, supported by Japanese Funds-in- Education and Gender Equality Programme.
Trust, assisted in the implementation of ac- Beneficiaries are all children up to the age of 18
tivities with an impact on 34 Member States. years, teachers, educators, parents, communi-
The main outputs of these activities were 9 ties, employers – in other words, all those who
workshops, 3 networks created, one forum have a role to play in determining the struc-
and 6 manuals and publications. These proj- ture, content and process of education (formal,
ects reached more than 3000 people includ- nonformal and informal). Forty seven countries
ing policy makers, teacher educators, ex- that are adapting the Child Friendly Environ-
perts, trainee teachers and journalists. ment have incorporated climate change and
environmental education into their curricula.
[UNICEF has contributed to ESD through qual- Further emphasis is placed on those most mar-
ity education, gender mainstreaming and girls’ ginalized by climate change.]
Illustration from page 7 ESD Lens: A Policy and Practice Review Tool.
Appendices
76
© UN Photo/Basile Zoma
77
The UN Inter-Agency Committee for the DESD
The UN Inter-Agency Committee (IAC) for the UN to embed the ESD agenda into the work of UN
Decade of Education for Sustainable Develop- agencies, and to emphasize the role of ESD and
ment is a platform and collaboration mechanism its implications for all forms, levels and settings
that brings together 22 UN agencies to support of education. In this context, joint work has been
the Decade. The IAC, focusing on the educational undertaken focusing on education activities, for
aspect of sustainable development, develops a instance in the areas of higher education, climate
common vision, principles, and values on ESD change, biodiversity, sustainable consumption,
and promotes the DESD as a shared objective sustainable urbanization, rural development and
and agenda of the UN system. It seeks to ensure health promotion – to name a few.
coordination of the DESD within the UN system,
Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS United Nations Human Settlements Pro-
(UNAIDS) gramme (UN-HABITAT)
www.unaids.org www.unhabitat.org
United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA)
www.unicef.org
www.unfpa.org
United Nations Convention on Biological Di-
versity (UN CBD) United Nations International Strategy for Di-
www.cbd.int saster Reduction (UNISDR)
www.unisdr.org
United Nations Convention to Combat Desert-
ification (UNCCD) United Nations Institute for Training and Re-
www.unccd.int
search (UNITAR)
United Nations Department of Economic and www.unitar.org
Social Affairs (UN DESA)
www.un.org/en/development/desa United Nations University (UNU)
www.unu.edu
United Nations Development Programme
(UNDP)
World Food Programme (WFP)
www.undp.org
www.wfp.org
United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cul-
tural Organization (UNESCO) World Bank
www.unesco.org www.worldbank.org
United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) World Health Organization (WHO)
www.unep.org
www.who.int
United Nations Framework Convention on Cli-
mate Change (UNFCCC) World Trade Organization (WTO)
Appendices
www.unfccc.int www.wto.org
78
recently collected lessons learned and recom-
mendations related to ESD. They described eight
In advance of the UN Conference on Sus- challenges related to ESD learning and processes
tainable Development the Inter-Agency that reflect the current direction of ESD. They are
Committee for the DESD prepared a com- common to UN Agencies involved in ESD:
prehensive joint input into the Zero Draft
of the outcome document. It is available on Building on existing structures, programmes,
the website of the conference processes and research experience: This has par-
www.uncsd2012.org. ticularly been helpful in Africa, where, for exam-
ple, the Mainstreaming of Environment and Sus-
tainability in African Universities (MESA) initiative
As the DESD progresses and the ESD evolves, the drew from the environmental education work of
IAC has noted changes in ESD leading universities. The Education for Sustainable
Development Innovations Toolkit: Programmes for
Universities in Africa serves as a key learning re-
Initially seen as a separate education entity, source.
ESD is now more than ever seen as a set of
learning skills, perspectives and values to are Participatory processes as opposed to a pre-
intrinsic to quality education and enable cur- scriptive approach: Currently, the SIDA- support-
rent and future generations to live and contri- ed International Training Programme (ITP) for ESD
bute to sustainable and democratic societies in higher education involves university lecturers
and livelihoods. While SD and climate change from several universities (mainly from Africa and
are global issues, the solutions are local and Asia). The lecturers train and are expected to ini-
national and must be addressed through all tiate transformative change projects in their re-
educational mechanisms (formal, informal, spective universities.
non formal). Reorienting education to address Integrated and holistic conception and ap-
sustainability requires understanding local proaches to sustainable development: Starting
contexts, including traditional knowledge points may include the formulation of Sustainable
and ensuring democratic participation. (UNIR, Development Goals to harmonize social, environ-
UNICEF) mental and economic objectives.
The IAC has also noted changes in processes and Recognition of diverse contexts: Initiatives aimed
strategies that are effective for partnering with or- at reorienting higher education to address sustain-
ganizations to promote and advance ESD. UNEP ability need to be appropriate for local contexts.
© UN Photo/John Isaac
Appendices
79
© UN Photo/Fred Noy
Equal attention to both processes and prod- Keeping up-to-date with emerging paradigms
ucts: Results-based management processes and concepts in the sustainability discourse:
make it tempting to focus on easily measurable Relevance is paramount.
products. But underlying processes are often
more important.
Summary Notes
Within the UN system, ESD is far more part behaviour, lifestyles and the way organizations
of the discourse and project implementation work. Developing research and appropriate
than it was two years ago. monitoring, evaluation and indicator schemes is
a constant priority.
The various agencies in the UN system are see-
ing a role for ESD in responding to emerging More research is needed to establish clearly
themes and issues such as green economies, the link between ESD and quality education,
climate change, disaster risk reduction, integral and between ESD and other items on national
water management, sustainable resource gov- education and development agendas. This will
ernance and a range of others. increase ESD’s chances of being mainstreamed.
Here too, findings suggest a paradigm shift to- Communicating the potential of ESD will contin-
wards more inter-sectoral, cross-boundary and ue to be an important task. It will become easier
participatory forms of engagement. as the evidence base of ESD’s benefits grows.
80
APPENDIX 2:
DATA SOURCES
1. An email survey sent to UNESCO National Commissions and Permanent Delegations in April 2011.
81
Email1 Email1
Country GMES Country GMES
Survey Survey
ASIA PACIFIC Georgia X
Afghanistan X X Germany X X
Australia X Hungary X
Bangladesh X Italy X X
Bhutan X Kazakhstan X
China X X Latvia X X
Fiji X X Lithuania X
Indonesia X Malta X X
Japan X Monaco X
Republic of Korea X X Montenegro X
Lao People’s Netherlands X X
X
Democrac Republic Norway X
Maldives X Poland X X
Mongolia X Spain X
Myanmar Slovenia X
New Zealand X Sweden X X
Nepal X Switzerland X
Pakistan X United Kingdom X
Philippines X X
United States X
Sri Lanka X
Uzbekistan X
Thailand
Former Yugoslav
Timor-Leste X Republic X
Tonga X of Macedonia
EUROPE AND
NORTH AMERICA
Armenia X
Austria X X
Belgium X
Bosnia
X X
and Herzegovina
Bulgaria X
Croaa X
Cyprus X
Denmark X
Estonia X
Finland X
France X
Appendices
© UN Photo/F Charton
82
© UN Photo/Basile Zoma
Email1
Email1 Country GMES
Country GMES Survey
Survey
Ecuador X
LATIN AMERICA Guatemala X
AND
THE CARIBBEAN Honduras X X
Angua and Barbuda X Jamaica X
Argenna X X Mexico X X
Bahamas X Panama X
Brazil X Peru X X
Brish Virgin Islands X Saint Kis and Nevis X
Chile X X Trinidad and Tobago X
Colombia X X Uruguay X
Costa Rica X Venezuela (Boliva-
X
rian Republic of)
Cuba X X
Dominican Republic X X
83
Internaonal Associaon of Universies Internaonal based in France
Soka Gakkai Internaonal Japan
Islamic Informaon Centre (IIC) Malaysia
Centro de Invesgaciones Tropicales – Universidad Mexico
Veracruzana
Coordinacion Universitaria para la Sustentabilidad – Mexico
Universidad Veracruzana
Instuto de Invesgaciones en Educacion – Universidad Mexico
Veracruzana
Universidad Veracruzana – Vicerrectoría Región Vera- Mexico
cruz
OPEN Universiteit (OUNL) Netherlands
PERL – The Partnership for Educaon and Research Norway
about Responsible Living
UNESCO Chair Ecologically safe development of the
large region – The Volga Basin of the Nizhny Novgorod Russian Federaon
State University
Drustvo Humanitas Slovenia
Peermariteburg South Africa
Universidad Nacional de Educacion a Distancia. Catedra Spain
UNESCO De Educacion Ambiental y Desarrollo Soste-
nible
Global Acon Plan Internaonal Sweden
OMEP Internaonal based in Sweden
SWEDESD – Swedish Internaonal Centre of Educaon Sweden
for Sustainable Development
Misali Island Conservaon Associaon (MICA) United Republic of Tanzania
Gaia Educaon United Kingdom
Open to Create United Kingdom
SEEd (Sustainability and Environmental Educaon) United Kingdom
The Sustainable MBA United Kingdom
US Partnership for Educaon for Sustainable United States
Development
Faculty of Agriculture – University of Zimbabwe Zimbabwe
Ministry of Agriculture Mechanizaon Zimbabwe
and Irrigaon Development
Mukuvisi Woodland Zimbabwe
Appendices
84
Respondents to Survey for UN Internal Review
of ESD*
UNESCO Oce in San José UNICEF
* IAC members participating in an M&E focus-group discussion included UNICEF, FAO, UNEP, UNECE,
UNU, UNESCO, UNCCD, UNCBD and UN Habitat.
** Additional IAC members completing an ESD survey included UNECE, UNCCD, and UN Habitat.
• Indonesia • Morocco
• Kenya • Sweden
85
© UN Photo/Eskinder Debebe
86
Appendices
APPENDIX 3:
MONITORING
& EVALUATION
EXPERT GROUP
(MEEG)
Members
Special Advisor,
BRENES, Abelardo Earth Charter Internaonal
Costa Rica
NAGATA, Yoshiyuki Associate Professor, University of the Sacred Heart, Tokyo, Japan
Naonal Coordinator
Senior ocer - strategy and informaon
RAAIJ van Roel Secretary of the Naonal Steering Commiee on Learning for Sustai-
nable Development
Ministry of Agriculture, Nature and Food Equality, Netherlands
Dean, School of Mathemacs and Natural Sciences
SHUMBA, Overson
The Copperbelt University, Zambia
Professor
THAMAN, Konai Faculty of Arts and Law School of Educaon
University of the South Pacic, Fiji
TILBURY, Daniella Professor of Sustainability
Director of Academic and Corporate Aairs (Sustainability)
(Chair) University of Gloucestershire, United Kingdom
Member of the Swiss Naonal Commission for UNESCO (2004-2007)
VARCHER, Pierre
Switzerland
Appendices
87
© UN Photo/Kibae Park
88
Appendices
Shaping the Education
n
of Tomorrow
2012 Report on the UN Decade of Education
i
for Sustainable Development, Abridged
As the DESD goes into its final phase, it will be crucial for
UNESCO, its Member States and other stakeholders to ensure
that promotion, support and evolution of ESD continues beyond
2014. Education is our great hope for a sustainable future.