Professional Documents
Culture Documents
C
ystinuria is a disorder of amino acid metabolism through dilution, alkalization, or cystine-binding thiol
that leads to high levels of cystine in the urine. drugs (CBTD). Dilutional therapy with aggressive hydra-
Patients with cystinuria form stones because the tion can reduce stone recurrence,4 but many patients
urinary cystine concentration exceeds the maximum solu- struggle to maintain adequate fluid intake, and new strate-
bility, resulting in the amino acid precipitating out of solu- gies are needed to reduce the substantial burden of this
tion to form crystals and then stones, with most patients condition.
presenting before age 20 years.1 Urolithiasis in patients The selective arginine vasopressin V2-receptor antago-
with cystinuria is a difficult problem to manage, with nist tolvaptan is approved for treatment of hypervolemic
large, recurrent stones, and high rates of surgery as well as and euvolemic hyponatremia (eg, heart failure and Syn-
chronic kidney disease.1-3 Strategies for preventing cystine drome of Inappropriate Antidiuretic Hormone (SIADH)),
stones focus on increasing solubility of cystine in the urine and to slow progression of autosomal dominant polycystic
kidney disease (ADPKD). Tolvaptan increases urinary
excretion of water by blocking vasopressin-mediated water
Funding Source: Study drug for this project was provided at no cost by Otsuka Pharma-
ceuticals, through a grant. Otsuka was otherwise not involved in the research design, exe- reabsorption in the collecting duct. Thus, tolvaptan ther-
cution, analysis, or writing of the manuscript. apy has the potential to improve stone outcomes through
Financial Disclosure: The authors declare that they have no relevant financial interests. augmented dilution and the resultant stimulation of the
Conflicts of Interest: Dr. Baum has the following to report: Medical Advisory for Retro-
phin, provider of tiopronin (Thiola). thirst response, significantly increasing urine output and
From the Department of Urology, Boston Children’s Hospital and Harvard Medical increasing cystine solubility. Although there have been
School, Boston, MA; and the Division of Nephrology, Boston Children’s Hospital and case reports of use of tolvaptan in urolithiasis, it has not
Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA
Address correspondence to: Caleb P. Nelson, M.D., M.P.H., Harvard Medical been investigated rigorously and systematically.
School, Department of Urology, Boston Children's Hospital, 300 Longwood Ave, In this study we sought to characterize the short-term
Boston, MA 02115. E-mail: caleb.nelson@childrens.harvard.edu safety profile, and the effect on urinary risk factors for
Submitted: April 28, 2020, accepted (with revisions): July 5, 2020
Figure 1. Timeline of the study intervention, starting with baseline 24-hour urine evaluation 3-6 days prior to start of tolvap-
tan therapy.
4 subjects reached the positive range capacity on the high-dose elevation of liver enzymes was noted in any subject during or
24-hour urine, and the fourth approached zero with a capacity after the treatment period.
at high-dose of 3. Cystine capacity increased from baseline Subjects did experience severe thirst, with thirst averaging 8.8
to high-dose from 312 to 97, 82 to 111, 353 to 75, of 10 on a visual analog scale at the low dose (range: 8.8-9.0)
and 628 to 3 mg/L for the 4 subjects, respectively (Fig. 2a). and 8.6 of 10 at the high dose (range: 6.8-9.5;
Cystine supersaturation decreased dramatically with tolvaptan Supplementary Figure 1), but all completed treatment and none
therapy, with 3 of 4 subjects achieving conventional cystine terminated or reduced dose due to thirst. All subjects reported
supersaturation < 0.6 (Fig. 2b). Cystine concentration some nocturia, but 3 of 4 reported less than 2 voids per night,
decreased consistently with all 4 subjects at <250 mg/L on even at higher dose (Supplementary Table 1).
high-dose tolvaptan (Fig. 2c).
Urinary volume also increased dramatically with tolvaptan
therapy. Some patients produced extraordinary volumes of urine COMMENT
during treatment. Respectively, 24-hour volume change from
In this pilot study, we have shown that dilutional therapy
baseline to high-dose increased from 1.96 L to 11.74 L, 3.0 L to
6.5 L, 0.91 L to 2.8 L, and 2.1 L to 9.9 L for the 4 subjects,
using the selective arginine vasopressin V2-receptor
respectively (Fig. 3). Of note, the patient with the lowest (least antagonist tolvaptan increases urine output dramatically
favorable) capacity also had the lowest 24-hour volume. Fluid and favorably alters cystine saturation in the urine, such
intake increased correspondingly: self-reported 24-hour fluid that most subjects on treatment reached a positive cystine
intake for the 4 subjects during the low-dose period averaged 9.1 capacity. As expected, response returned to baseline after
L (Patient 1) 8.6 L (patient 2), 3.1 L (Patient 3), and 7.2 L cessation of tolvaptan, suggesting the effects are only seen
(Patient 4), respectively, and during the high-dose period aver- during treatment, and are not cumulative.
aged 10.9 L (Patient 1), 9.7 L (Patient 2), 4.1 L (Patient 3), and Dilutional therapy is the underlying foundation of cys-
9.1 L (Patient 4), respectively. tinuria treatment, based on the principle that adequate
There were no abnormalities in serum electrolytes during the hydration will result in dilution of the fixed cystine load
study period (Table 1). Despite the large urine output and fluid
to a concentration below that at which crystallization typ-
intake, subject sodium, potassium, chloride, and other electro-
lytes all remained in the normal range during and after the treat-
ically occurs (<250 mg/L). While there is longstanding
ment period. No subject stopped or modified the protocol due to recognition that hyper-hydration can be effective in
concerns about serum chemistry perturbations. Liver function reducing stone recurrence,4 in practice adequate oral
tests (aspartate aminotransferase, alanine aminotransferase, alka- hydration is difficult to achieve for many patients and
line phosphatase) were measured at baseline, on low-dose treat- compliance rates are low,14,15 and there are many barriers
ment, on high-dose treatment, and after treatment, and no to successful compliance.16 Similarly, medical therapy
Table 1. Serum electrolytes for each subject before, during, and after tolvaptan treatment (Sodium/Potassium/Chloride in
mmol/L)
Day 2 Day 4 Day 6 Day 8 Day 10
Pretreatment (Low Dose) (Low Dose) (High Dose) (High Dose) (Washout)
Subject 1 (24 yo male) 138/4.2/101 141/4.1/101 141/3.9/102 140/4.1/102 141/4.3/103 137/4.0/101
Subject 2 (17 yo female) 141/3.9/103 142/3.6/102 141/3.8/101 140/4.0/102 142/3.7/102 140/4.0/103
Subject 3 (24 yo female) 140/3.7/102 144/4.0/104 140/3.6/102 143/4.1/104 142/3.8/ 102 140/3.8/101
Subject 4 (13 yo male) 140/4.3/104 140/4.1/101 139/4.2/102 140/3.9/101 139/4.4/101 138/4.8/102