You are on page 1of 39

Mneian]

hau
`a h] panik`ej|ie_]

9
/+. Pejkloeo
/+/ Qn]^]fk u _]hkn
/+0 Bjanc~] ejpanj] u
lnei an] hau `a h]
pani k`ej|i e_]
0,2 Cqj_ekjao `a aop]`k
/+2 Bjp]hle]
kbi`^mÇqril^kqboflobpq^_ib`fjlpnrbi^j^qbof^pb`ljmloq^ab^`rboal`lk`fbo+
/+3 @]i ^eko `a h]o
bqj_ekjao `a aop]`k
/+4 @kabe_eajpao `a
9 q^pobdi^pabkljfk^a^pb`r^`flkbpabbpq^al,?elo^mlabjlpfkf`f^obibpqraflab
i^pobdi^pnrbdl_fbok^kbi`ljmloq^jfbkqlabi^ ajancÄ]+?rknrbklps^iaobjlpmofk+
`fm^ijbkqbabilpd^pbp`ljlbgbjmilp*i^pfab^pabi^qbojlafkÄjf`^pb^mif`^k^`r^i+
&kqha*Qdki okj nrfbopfpqbj^*v^pb^pÑifal*iÇnrfal*d^pl`r^inrfbo`lj_fk^`fÑkabc^pbp,
/+5 J |o ok^na _]l]_e`]`ao J^qbojlafkÄjf`^pbabp^ooliiÑbkprj^vlom^oqbaro^kqbbipfdilTET)abpmrÅpabi^
p}ni e_]o ^`bmq^`fÑkabi^jlabok^qbloÇ^^qÑjf`^abB^iqlk*mbol^kqbpabnrbprodfbo^ki^pfab^p
/+6 @]i ^eko `a b]oa abi^jb`Äkf`^`rÄkqf`^ &il nrbfjmif`^nrbbirkfsbopl jf`olp`Ñmf`labilpÄqljlpv
bib`qolkbppbofdbmloobdi^pafpqfkq^p^^nrbii^p nrbdl_fbok^kbijrkalj^`olp`Ñmf`l
/+.- @]i ^eko mq~i e_ko
abi^p do^kabpj^p^p',Nloilq^kql*i^qbojlafkÄjf`^qfbkbnrbsbocfja^jbkq^ijbkqb
0,// @]i ^ek `a pai lan]pqn] `lkdo^kabp`lkgrkqlpabÄqljlpvjliÅ`ri^p,J^pibvbpabi^qbojlafkÄjf`^plkobdi^p
/+./ Oa]__ekjao ^ekmq~i e_]o i]_nko_Çle_]o+KÄp^aÅi^kqb*^_loa^objlpi^pobdi^p ie_nko_Çle_]o&bpab`fo*i^jb`Äkf`^
/+.0 Oaoqiaj `rÄkqf`^'*mbolmlo^elo^ob`loabjlpnrbi^qbojlafkÄjf`^bpqraf^pfpqbj^pnrbmlab+
jlpsbo*pbkqfo*mbp^ouj^kfmri^o`lkkrbpqo^pmolmf^pj^klp,

/+. Pejkloeo
Nofjbol*abcfkfobjlp qo^_^gl*`^ilovbkbodÇ^ fkqbok^, J^ mofjbo^ibvab i^qbojlaf+
kÄjf`^pb_^p^ bki^obi^`fÑknrbbufpqbbkqobbpq^pqobp `^kqfa^abp, J^bkbodÇ^fkqbo+
k^ `lkpqfqrvb rk bgbjmil ab rk^ crk`fÑk ab bpq^al9 bpq^ Öiqfj^ mlpbb `fboq^p
molmfba^abp nrb* pbdÖk sbobjlp* i^ e^`bk Öqfi, R^j_fÅk bpqraf^objlp i^ bkq^imf^*
lqo^crk`fÑkab bpq^al* ^pÇ `ljlilp`^j _flpnrbbumbofjbkq^ki^pcrk`flkbpab bp+
q^al*vabp^oolii^objlp qÅ`kf`^p m^o^ `^i`ri^o `Ñj l `^j_f^ki^ bkbodÇ^ fkqbok^ vi^
bkq^imf^aro^kqbrkmol`bplcÇpf`llnrÇjf`l,?pfjfpjl*fkqolar`fobjlpbi`lk`bmql
ab `^m^`fa^abp qÅojf`^p v `lbcf`fbkqbp ab Hlrib+Relj plk* ilp `r^ibp pb obi^`flk^k
`lk ilp `^j_flp ab qbjmbo^qro^ bk ilp pfpqbj^p, Alk`irfobjlp bi `^mÇqril ob`lkl+
`fbkalilpiÇjfqbpabmobaf``fÑkabi^mofj bo^ibvabi^qbojlafkÄjf`^vbieb`el ab
nrb pb obnrfbobk lqo^p fab^pñ lqo^p ibvbp ab i^ qbojlafkÄjf`^ñ m^o^ `ljmobkabo
`Ñj li^bkbodÇ^fkqbo^`qÖ^`lki^j^qbof^,

/+/ Ro^_^glt _]hkn


Bbpabrkmrkqlabsfpq^cÇpf`l*pbiibs^^`^_l pn]^]fkpl_obrkl_gbql`r^kal Åpqbpb
abpmi^w^`fboq^afpq^k`f^o`ljl`lkpb`rbk`f^abi^^mS`^`fÑkabrk^crbow^IK^qb+
(*
0,0 Ro^_^gl v `^ilo WP

Ljnd^dÅidid^d\d
=! %]&
Dfdro^ 0,/ Ar^kal oa afan_a qj] crbow^ pl_ob rk l_gbql* k l pb ob^ifw^ qo^_^gle^pq^ nrbbi l_gbql pb
jrbsb* ^'W^nrbi^m^obakl pb jrbsb*kl pb ob^ifw^ kfkdÖk qo^_^gl* ^& Qb ob^ifw^rkqo^_^gl `lj l `lk+
pb`rbk`f^ab nrbi^crbow^^`qÖ^^ili^odlab`fboq^afpq^k`f^,

j Äqf`^j bkqbpbabcfkb`ljlbimolar`qlmrkqlabisb`qlocrbow^Dvbisb`qloafpq^k+
`f^p8

qo^_^gl ;  D äp ;  i\f ypy blpG )! (


Ckbpq^b`r^`fÑk*. bpbiÄkdril bkqobilpsb`qlobp,Ciqo^_^glbprk^`^kqfa^abp`^i^o*
kl rk^ `^kqfa^asb`qlof^i* mlonrb qfbkb j^dkfqra* mbol kl afob``fÑk, J^cfdro^ 0,/
jrbpqo^ ^ rk^ crbow^ nrb ^`qÖ^ pl_ob rk l_gbql, Ck i^ cfdro^ 0 ,i^ * bi l_gbql kl pb
jrbsb*^pÇ nrbi^`^kqfa^aab qo^_^gl bp `bol &^mbp^oab i^crbow^nrbpbbgbo`b',Ck
i^cfdro^ 0 , / _*rkl_gbqlpbjlsfÑ*^pÇ nrbpb ob^ifwÑ qo^_^gl,
J^prkfa^abpm^o^jbafobiqo^_^glplkhk o fkq hao)`lj lbkbi`^plabi^bkbodÇ^,Cp+
ql kl `^ob`b ab cffka^jbkql9 bi qo^_^gl bp rk^ cloj ^ ab qo^kpcbobk`f^ab bkbodÇ^, J^
bkbodÇ^pbabcfkb`ljli^`^m^`fa^aabob^ifw^oqo^_^gl*^pÇnrbqfbkbpbkqfalbieb`el
abnrbi^ bkbodÇ^vbiqo^_^glpbjfa^k`lki^pjfpj^prkfa^abp,
J^cloj ^ab qo^_^gljÄp`ljÖknrbbpqraf^i^qbojlafkÄjf`^_Äpf`^pbobcfbob^i
`^j _fl ab slirjbk ab rkpfpqbj^, Alkpfabobjlp i^ cfdro^ /+/]+ SkmfpqÑk pfk cof`+
`fÑk `ljmofjbrk^jrbpqo^ab d^pbk rkslirjbk fkf`f^i Tì,Cid^pabkqolabi^`Ä+
j ^o^q^j_fÅk qfbkbrk^mobpfÑkfkf`f^il[+?imofk`fmfl*ilnrbj^kqfbkbbimfpqÑkbk
rk^mlpf`fÑkcfg^bpi^mobpfÑkbuqbok^abilp^iobabalobp*
Qf bi mfpqÑk pb bibs^ &cfdro^ /+/^&) bi oeopai ] na]hev] pn]^]fkpl_obilp ^iobabalobp,
Cpqlpfdkfcf`^nrbbipfpqbj^lean` abkbodÇ^bkcloj ^abqo^_^gl,J^`^kqfa^afkcfkfqb+
pfj^iabqo^_^gl` s m q a bipfpqbj^ob^ifw^pl_obilp^iobabalobp`ljlobpriq^alabrk
`^j _flfkcfkfqbpfj^iabslirjbk `S)jfbkqo^pbipfpqbj^^`qÖ^bk`lkqo^abrk^mob+
pfÑkbuqbok^`lkpq^kqb pbabcfkb`ljl9

`s;  * l ] p ` S !0 '0 "

`s: yM[)p`S7 _r : (k)Z)_R7


om\]\ejlp``a`^oÇ\`g om\]\ejlp``a`^oÇ\i
ndno`h\ nj]m` gjn\gm`_`_jm`n gjn\gm`_`_jm`n nj]m`
%`gndno`h\kd`m_``i`mb~\& `gndno`h\%`gndno`h\
b\i\`i`mb~\&

@ 

Dfdro^ / +/ ]& SkmfpqÑkpfk cof``fÑk`lkrkd^pbk`boo^al `lkpqfqrvbrk bgbj milpbk`fiil abiqo^_^gl


n rb ob^ifw^k ilpd^pbp v^ pb^pl_ob pfpqbj^p l pl_obilp ^iobabalobp* ^& Ro^_^gl bcb`qr^al pl_ob ilp ^iob+
abalobp, `' Ro^_^gl bcb`qr^al pl_ob bi pfpqbj^, Ck  ^j _lp `^plp i^ abcfkf`fÑk j^qbjÄqf`^ ab qo^_^gl kl
`^j _f^,
/3 A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofjbo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

Cipfdklkbd^qfslfkaf`^nrbbiqo^_^glbcb`qr^al`lkqof_rvb^ rk^ `eoi ejq_eÇjabi^


`^kqfa^aab bkbodÇ^abi pfpqbj^,% QfbimfpqÑk abp`fbkab &cfdro^0,0`'*bkqlk`bpilp^i+
obabalobp ob^ifw^k qo^_^gl ok^na ah oeopai ] ui^ `^kqfa^a ab bkbodÇ^bk bi pfpqbj^ ^r+
j bkq^, J^ `^kqfa^a fkcfkfqbpfj^iabqo^_^gl nrb pbbcb`qÖ^pl_obbipfpqbj^pb abcfkb
j baf^kqb i^ b`r^`fÑk 0,09 pfkbj_^odl*`lj l bi `^j _fl bk bislirjbk `S pb a^ bk
pbkqfallmrbpql*^elo^biqo^_^glqfbkbrks^ilomlpfqfsl,M_pbosbnrbkrbpqolcl`lab
^qbk`fÑk bp bi pfpqbj^, Ci qo^_^gl bpmlpfqfsl l kbd^qfsl `lk obpmb`ql ^i pfpqbj^* nrb
`lkpqfqrvbi^m^oqbabi rkfsbopl nrbklpfkqbobp^,
Qfprj^jlpqlalpilp`^j_flpfkcfkfqbpfj^ibp&fkcfkfqlp'nrb`lkqof_rvbk^i`^j_fl
dil_^i* l_qbkbjlpbiqlq^iabqo^_^glbcb`qr^al pl_ob l mlobipfpqbj^, Ck`Äi`ril pb
rqfifw^i^fkqbdo^im^o^prj^oilp`^j_flpfkcfkfqbpfj^ibp, Nloq^kql*i^`^kqfa^aqlq^i
abqo^_^gl t*nrbpbSbs^^`^_lbkrk`^j_fl`lj lbinrbobmobpbkq^i^cfdro^ 0 ,0 *bp

&0,1'

Cieb`el ab nrb bpq^fkqbdo^imrba^pfjmifcf`^opb l kl abmbkaboÄabi^p`lkaf`flkbp


abi mol`bpl, Qf i^ mobpfÑk buqbok^ mboj^kb`b `lkpq^kqb `iro^kqb qlal bi mol`bpl* pb
mrbab p^`^oabi^fkqbdo^ivi^bumobpfÑkpb`lksfboqbbk8

;  *[ fl a] ` S : * l ) ô f ` S : ü Ty\%

Ckbpqb `^pl*ilpiÇjfqbpabi^fkqbdo^iplkbislirjbkfkf`f^i Dg vbislirjbkcfk^i Tc


abimol`bpl,Cpql pb obÉbg^bki^ Öiqfj^bumobpfÑk abi^b`r^`fÑk ^kqboflo, Qfbs^ir^+
j lpi^ fkqbdo^iabkqol abbpqlpiÇjfqbp*l_qbkbjlp8

t ;  + ? u q Ç T c +  v*'

T : ä?T, &0,2'

Qfi^ mobpfÑk buqbok^ kl bp `lkpq^kqb ^il i^odl abimol`bpl* bkqlk`bp kb`bpfq^objlp
lqo^ cloj ^abbs^ir^obiqo^_^gl bki^b`r^`fÑk 0,1,
Qfrqfifw^jlpi^^qjÑpcbo^`lj l rkfa^aabmobpfÑkvbiifqol `ljlrkfa^aabsl+
irj bk* l_qbkbjlpJ+^qj `ljl rkfa^aabqo^_^gl,|pq^kl bp rk^rkfa^a`ljÖk ab
qo^_^gl, J^rkfa^aQGm^o^biqo^_^glbpbiglrib*H,?elo^_fbk*ab^`rboal`lkilpaf+
sboplps^ilobpabO)ilp`r^ibppbfkaf`^olkbk bi `^mÇqril ^kqboflo*mlabjlpabjlp+
qo^o nrb / J ä^qj;  /.J10H, Cpqb c^`qlo ab `lksbopfÑk bp jrvÖqfim^o^bumobp^o bi
qo^_^gl bkprp `loob`q^prkfa^abp QG,Qfbislirjbk pbbumobp^o^ bkjbqolp`Ö_f`lpv
i^mobpfÑkbkm^p`^ibp* ilpglribppbl_qbkaoÇ^kafob`q^jbkqbbksfoqraab nrb

N ^ V j ö ;  + \ V j ö ;  L V j  ;  H

Bfailhk !
Alkpfabobjlprkd^pfab^iabkqolabi^`Äj^o^abrkmfpqÑk*`ljlbki^cfdro^0,0*
alkab bislirjbk fkf`f^ibp 0,.. Jvi^mobpfÑkfkf`f^ibp ab 6,.. ^qj, Qrmlkd^jlp
nrbbi mfpqÑkpbbibs^&bpab`fo* nrbbipfpqbj^pbbum^kab' v^i`^kw^rkslirjbkcf+
k^iab 3,3.J*lmlkfÅkalpb^rk^mobpfÑkbuqbok^`lkpq^kqbab /,53^qj,Qrmlkd^+
jlp*^pfjfpjl*nrbi^qbjmbo^qro^bp`lkpq^kqbaro^kqbbimol`bpl,
^' A^i`ribbiqo^_^gl aro^kqbbimol`bpl,
_' A^i`ribi^mobpfÑk cfk^iabid^p,

%P bpr iq^ cÄ`fi a bj lpqo^o nrbi^p alp a bcfk f`flk bp abiqo^ _ ^ gl  p l k  bnrfs^ibk qbp,A l j l i^mobpfÑk
pb a bcfkb `l j l  cffbow^m l o rkfa^a ab Äob^* i^b `r ^ `fÑ k  0 , 0  mrbab obbp`of_ fopb ab i^pfdrfbkqbj ^ k b +
o^8 qo^ _ ^ gl  ; +\0\  V  slir j bk;  crbow^ V  afpq^k`f^* nrb bpi^ b `r ^ `fÑ k  0 ,/,
0,0 Ro^_^gl v `^ilo 05

Qlir`fÉk
^' Nofjbol pbobnrfbobbi`^j_fl bk bislirjbk* nrbabqbojfk^jlp abi^pfdrfbkqb
j^kbo^8

[ S : S by ü S [ :  3,3./ +  0,..J ;  1,3.J

N^o^`^i`ri^obiqo^_^glnrbpbiibs^^`^_l`lkqo^i^mobpfÑkbuqbok^`lkpq^kqb*rp^+
j lpi^b`r^`fÑk0,29

t;  ? v ;  + & / ,5 3 ^qj '&1,3.J' ;  + 4 ,/ 1 J+^qj

Qf nrbobjlp bumobp^o rk^ `^kqfa^a bk rkfa^abp QG abglribp* ab_bjlp bjmib^o bi
c^`qloab `lksbopfÑk^ab`r^al8

( 1 ) , .  F (Y le  Q  i iK ff 8  X X Ẁ Ŭ a  D
J+^qj

Cpab`fo* bipfpqbj^e^mboafal 40/ glribparo^kqbi^bum^kpfÑk,


_' Bb ^`rboal `lki^efmÑqbpfp ab nrb pb qo^q^ ab rk d^p fab^i* mlabjlp ^mif`^o i^
ibvab@lvibm^o^`^i`ri^oi^mobpfÑkcfk^iabid^p,?pÇ*

&0,..J '& 6 , . . ^qj' ;  &3,3. I&wlê&

l b :  0,7/ ^qj

J^ cfdro^ 0,1 firpqo^rk^molmfba^a nrb ^ sb`bp pb mobpbkq^ bk ilp d^pbp8 bi d^p pb
bum^kabvl`rm^rkbpm^`flnrblofdfk^ijbkqbpbbk`lkqo^_^s^`Çl,Ckbpqb`^pl*`l+
j l bid^p pbbum^kab`lkqo^ rk ab `bol*ab^`rboal `lk i^ abcfkf`fÑk ab qo^_^gl
m  !  M m M bki^b`r^`fÑk 0,2* biqo^_^gl nrbbcb`qÖ^ bi d^p bp fdr^i ^ `bol, Bf`elmol`bpl ob`f_b
@ a_ m j Y  - ) .  Mark d^ppbbum^kab u l`r+ biklj _obab atl]joeÇj he^na7
m^rkbpm^`fls^`Çlkl pbiibs^^`^_lk fk +
dÖkqo^_^gl, qo^_^gl; M &bum^kpfÑkif_ob' &0,3'

Bf_ilek /+/
?m^oqfoabi^p `lkaf`flkbpvabcfkf`flkbpabipfpqbj^* abqbojfkb pfbipfpqbj^bcb`+
qÖ^qo^_^gl*pf pbbcb`qÖ^qo^_^glpl_obbipfpqbj^l pfkl pbiibs^^ `^_l kfkdÖkqo^+
_^gl,
^' Sk dil_l pb bum^kab `lkclojb rk^ mfbw^ mbnrbÉ^ ab efbil pb`l &AM 0 pÑifal'
abkqolabidil_lpbpr_ifj^ &dil_l;pfpqbj^',
_'J^pmrboq^pabi`ljm^oqfjfbkqlab`^od^abi^k^sbbpm^`f^ipb^_obkvif_bo^krk
ml`l abi^^qjÑpcbo^obj^kbkqb &`lj m^oqfj fbkql ab`^od^ ; pfpqbj^',
`' CiAF DgA i*rk^jbw`i^obcofdbo^kqb*pb`lj mofj bbkbi`ljmobploabrkpfpqbj^
ab^fob^`lkaf`flk^alm^o^ qo^q^oabif`r^oil &A F DgA i ;pfpqbj^',
a' Qbabp`^od^rk^i^q^ab mfkqro^bk^bolpli &i^q^; pfpqbj^',
b' J^j fpj^pfqr^`fÑknrbbifk`fpl `&)mbol`lkpfabobnrbbi^bolplibpbipfpqbj^,

Qlir`fÉk
^' Cksfoqraab nrb bidil_l ^rjbkq^prslirjbk*pfk ara^bcb`qÖ^qo^_^gl8 bi pfp+
qbj^ob^ifw^biqo^_^gl,
_' Ar^kali^p mrboq^pabi`ljm^oqfjfbkql ab `^od^ abi^k^sb pb^_obk bkbibpm^+
`fl*bi `ljm^oqfjfbkqlpb^_ob^is^`Çl &kl rks^`Çlmbocb`ql'*`lkilnrbqbkbjlp
qj]bum^kpfÑk obi^qfs^jbkqbif_ob,Nloq^kql* j k o a iibs^^`^_lkfkdÖk qo^_^gl,
`' Ar^kal bi AF DgAi pb `ljmofjb* pr slirjbk afpjfkrvb9 ^pÇ* pb bcb`qÖ^ qo^_^gl
pl_obbipfpqbj^,
06 A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

a'*b' Ar^kalrk^i^q^abmfkqro^bk^bolplipbabp`^od^*kloj^ijbkqbklj lafcf+


`^prslirjbk,Nloq^kql*pfpbabcfkb^i^i^q^`lj lbipfpqbj^*i^`^kqfa^aabqo^_^+
gl nrb ob^ifw^ bp `bol, Qfk bj_^odl*bi ^bolpliob^ifw^qo^_^gl `lkclojb pb bum^kab
`lkqo^i^^qjÑpcbo^,Cpqbifiqfjlbgbj miljrbpqo^i^fjmloq^k`f^ababcfkfobipfpqb+
j^q^kbpmb`Çcf`^jbkqb`ljl pb^mlpf_ib,

Qfcrbo^mlpf_ib*mlaoÇ^jlps^of^obislirjbk abid^pabkqolabi^`Äj^o^abimfp+
qÑkbkm^plp fkcfkfqbpfj^ibp*mbojfqfbkalnrbbipfpqbj^ob^``flkb^`^a^`^j _flfk +
cfkfqbpfj^i^kqbpabiibs^o^`^_l bipfdrfbkqb`^j_fl,Ck`^a^m^pl*bipfpqbj^iibd^^i
bnrfif_ofl `lkprp^iobabalobpabq^ij^kbo^nrbqlalbimol`bpl `lkpqfqrvbrkbpq^+
al ab bnrfif_ofl `lkqfkrl, &Ck ob^ifa^a* bpl obnrbofoÇ^ rk^ fkcfkfa^a ab m^plp m^o^
rk^s^of^`fÑkcfkfq^abslirjbk,Jlp`^j_flpprcf`fbkqbjbkqbibkqlp`lkpqfqrvbkrk^
_rbk^^molufj^`fÑk,' Bf`elmol`bplpbabkljfk^ naranoe^ha+Jlpmol`bplpnrbklpb
iibs^k^`^_labbpq^j^kbo^&lnrbklpb^molufj^kabbpq^cloj^' ob`f_bkbikl j +
_obab ennaranoe^hao+Kr`e^pfab^pqbojlafkÄjf`^ppb_^p^kbkpfpqbj^pnrbm^p^kmlo
mol`bplpobsbopf_ibp, J^ps^of^`flkbp ab slirjbkklplkilp Ökf`lpmol`bplpobsbopf+
_ibp,J^ps^of^`flkbpqÅojf`^p*jb`Äkf`^p&bpab`fo*biabpmi^w^jfbkqlabrk^mfbw^ab
j^qbof^'vlqolqfml abs^of^`flkbpmrbabk`lkpfabo^opbobsbopf_ibp lfoobsbopf_ibp,
Jlp pfpqbj^p d^pblplp `lkpqfqrvbk bgbjmilp Öqfibpm^o^ i^qbojlafkÄjf`^*v^ nrb
mlabjlp bjmib^os^of^pibvbp abilp d^pbp m^o^`^i`ri^obiqo^_^gl abi^mobpfÑkvbi
slirjbk `r^kal rk pfpqbj^ j lafcf`^prslirjbk, Cpqlpr`babbpmb`f^ijbkqb^pÇbk
ilp`^j_flpobsbopf_ibp*mrbpqlnrbi^j^vlom^oqbabÅpqlpl`roobk^imboj fqfonrbi^
mobpfÑkbuqbok^bfkqbok^pbfdr^ib8

la];Meppp rk`^j _flobsbopf_ib


Ck pbdrfa^ pbmrbab iibs^o,^ `^_l i^ pfdrfbkqb prpqfqr`fÑk bk bi `^pl abilp `^j_flp
obsbopf_ibp8

t ús ;  ó H É k q a v  &0,4'
?elo^ mlabjlp abqbojfk^o bi qo^_^gl ab rk mol`bpl bk qÅojfklp abi^ mobpfÑk fk+
panj]+
J^mobpfÑkfkqbok^pbmrbabprpqfqrforqfifw^kali^ibvabilpd^pbpfab^ibp*v^nrbpf
bipfpqbj^bpqÄ`ljmrbpqlmlork d^p fab^i*ab_b`rjmifopbaf`e^ibv,Bbbpq^j ^kb+
o^l_qbkbjlp

`r^kalpbprpqfqrvbi^mobpfÑk,?rknrb îvIplk`lkpq^kqbp*i^qbjmbo^qro^ R bprk^


s^of^_ibvmrbab `^j_f^o, Qfk bj_^odl* pf i^ qbjmbo^qro^ mboj^kb`b `lkpq^kqb ar+
o^kqbbimol`bpl*Åpqbpbabkljfk^mol`bpleokp~ni e_kvi^ós^of^_ibòqbjmbo^qro^mrb+
abl_qbkbopbabi^fkqbdo^i,Cislirjbkmboj^kb`babkqolabi^fkqbdo^ibksfoqraab
nrbpbqo^q^abi^s^of^_ibnrbpbfkqbdo^,?pÇ*

; *j O n f[ ` S

Cpq^fkqbdo^iqfbkbrk^cloj^bpqÄka^o*nrbmlabjlpbs^ir^o,J^b`r^`fÑkpb`lksfbo+
qbbk8

;  * j O Q &Gk SY[b&

J^^_obsf^qro^óGkòpbobcfbob^iild^ofqjlk^qro^i*kl^iild^ofqjlab_^pb /. &nrbpb


obmobpbkq^ `lk i^ ^_obsf^qro^óildò', Qf bs^ir^jlp i^ fkqbdo^i abkqol ab prp iÇjfqbp*
l_qbkbjlp8

U%obv ;  ó£ &Gk Tcò  Gk Tì'


0,0 Ro^_^gl v `^ilo )0

nrb*ab^`rboal`lki^pmolmfba^abpabilpild^ofqjlp*bp8

s+)u ;  + jO Q  Gk &0,5'


Tf
bkbi`^plabrk`^j_flfplqÅojf`lobsbopf_ibbki^p`lkaf`flkbpabrkd^pfab^i,?mif+
`^kali^ibvab@lvibm^o^ bid^p*mlabj lpprpqfqrfoi^bumobpfÑklêhlbbkird^oabilp
sliÖjbkbpbkbiild^ofqjlul_pbos^onrb

t*bs ;  ìjO Q Gkñ  / 5


Me
m^o^rkd^pfab^i nrbm^p^mlorkmol`bpl fplqÅojf`l,

Bfailhk /+0
Sk d^p abkqolabi^`Äj^o^ab rkmfpqÑkpbj^kqfbkbabkqolabrk_^Él ^qbjmb+
o^qro^`lkpq^kqb^03,.áAvpbbum^kabab03,.jJ^ 53,.jJjrv*jrvibkq^j bk+
qb* `ljl il firpqo^ i^ cfdro^ 0,2, Qf e^v .,../.. jlibp ab d^p fab^i bk i^ `Äj^o^*
`^i`ribbiqo^_^glnrbbcb`qÖ^bipfpqbj^,

Qlir`fÉk
W^ nrb bi pfpqbj^ pb j^kqfbkb bk rk _^Él ab qbjmbo^qro^ `lkpq^kqb* bi `^j_fl bp
fplqÅojf`l,?pfjfpjl*v^nrbbi`^j _fl bpjrv*jrvibkql*mlabjlpmobprjfonrb
bi`^j_flbpobsbopf_ib,Nloq^kql*mlabj lp^mif`^oi^b`r^`fÑk0,5,?pÇ*

[
;  ñ& . , . . / . . jli' 6,1/2 &076,/3I 'cik
j li+I \  03,.jJ

s )ô ;  + 0 ,5 0 H

Cpab`fo*bipfpqbj^mfboab0*50 H,

Ci`lk`bmqlab`^ilo*obmobpbkq^almloi^ibqo^m)obpriq^jÄpafcÇ`fiababcfkfonrb
biqo^_^gl,Ci`^ilobprk^jbafa^abqo^kpcbobk`f^abbkbodÇ^qÅojf`^nrbmrbabab+
qbojfk^opbmlojbaflabi`^j_flbki^qbjmbo^qro^abrkl_gbql9bpab`fo*bprk^clo+
j^ ab pbdrfoi^ mfpq^ abi _]i ^ek bk i^ bkbodÇ^ bk rk pfpqbj^, W^ nrb bi `^ilo bp rk
`^j _flabbkbodÇ^*rqfifw^jlpi^pjfpj^prkfa^abpm^o^bi`^ilonrbm^o^i^bkbodÇ^8
glribp,
FfpqÑof`^jbkqb* bi`^iloe^pfal rk `lk`bmql afcÇ`fi ab abcfkfo, Qb mbkp^_^ nrb bi
`^ilobo^rk^molmfba^aabrkpfpqbj^prp`bmqf_ibab^fpi^opbvbj_lqbii^opb`ljl pf

=id v fo^  0 , 2  J^`Äj^o^abrkmfpqÑkbkrk ^plir`fÑk^qbj mbo^qro^`lkpq^kqbprcobrk^s^of^+


`fÑkobsbopf_ibabslirjbk wr~]oabgbj mil0 ,1',
1. A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

crbo^ rk^prpq^k`f^,?bpq^prpq^k`f^pbib afl fk`irpl rkklj_ob8ó`^iÑof`lò,?iobab+


aloab /56.*@bkg^jÇkRelj mplk*jÄpq^oab`lkababPrjcloa*obdfpqoÑbi`^ilonrb
dbkbo^_^i^mboclo^`fÑk ab `^Élkbp ab ^oqfiiboÇ^v`lk`irvÑ nrb i^`^kqfa^aab `^ilo
pb obi^`flk^_^ `lk i^ `^kqfa^a ab qo^_^gl ob^ifw^a^ aro^kqb bimol`bpl, Ck i^ aÅ`^a^
ab /62.*`lkprp`rfa^alplpbumbofjbkqlp*bicÇpf`lfkdiÅpH^jbpNobp`lqqHlrib&cfdr+
o^0 ,3 'sbofcf`Ñbpqbeb`el,Qfbkalbkqlk`bprk`bosb`bol*HlribrqfifwÑrk^m^o^ql`l+
j l binrb^m^ob`bbki^cfdro^ 0 , 4 m^o^ob^ifw^obiqo^_^glabjbw`i^ork^`^kqfa^aab
^dr^jbaf^kqbrkmbpl`lil`^albkrk^mlib^,Jibs^kal^`^_ljbaf`flkbp`rfa^al+
p^p ab i^ qbjmbo^qro^ abi ^dr^vabi qo^_^gl bcb`qr^al `ljl `lkpb`rbk`f^ abimbpl
nrb `^Ç^&jbaf^kqbi^b`r^`fÑk 0,/'*Hlrib mral prpqbkq^oi^fab^ab nrbbiqo^_^glv
bi `^ilo bo^k j^kfcbpq^`flkbp abi jfpjl cbkÑjbkl &abeb`el*i^ co^pb8 óbnrfs^ibkqb
j b`Äkf`l abi`^iloò*qla^sÇ^pbrqfifw^bkl`^pflkbp*viba^ Åkc^pfp^ i^obi^`fÑkbkqob
bpqlp alp `lk`bmqlp', J^rkfa^a QG ab i^ bkbodÇ^*bi qo^_^gl vbi`^ilo* biglrib* ob`f_b
prklj _obbkelkloabHlrib,
J^^kqfdr^rkfa^aabbkbodÇ^*`^ilovqo^_^gl*i^`^iloÇ^*pbabcfkb`lj li^`^kqfa^a
ab `^ilo kb`bp^of^ m^o^ bibs^o i^ qbjmbo^qro^ ab bu^`q^jbkqb / jJ ab ^dr^ bk rk
D fd r o^  0 , 3  H^jbpNobp`lqqHlrib &/ 6 / 6 +
/667'*cÇpf`lfkdiÅp*`rvlpbpqraflpbpq^_ib+ o b * ab /3áA^ /4áA, J^obi^`fÑkbkqob`^iloÇ^pvglribpbp8
`fbolk i^ `lksbopfÑk bkqob `^ilo v qo^_^gl
/ `^iloÇ^; 2,/62glribp &0,6'
`lj lcloj ^pabbkbodÇ^vpbkq^olk i^p_ ^ +
pbpabi^mofj bo^ibvab i^qboj lafkÄj f`^,
?rknrbi^rkfa^aQG^`bmq^a^ bpbiglrib*i^`^iloÇ^qla^sÇ^pbrqfifw^`lkcob`rbk`f^,
?rkpfpqbj^mrbab bkqo^obkbodÇ^ bk cloj ^ab`^ilo*vbpqle^`b nrbi^qbjmbo^+
qro^abipfpqbj^^rjbkqb*l_fbki^bkbodÇ^ bkcloj ^ab `^ilomrbabp^ifoabipfpqbj^
vl`^pflk^ork^ afpjfkr`fÑk bki^qbjmbo^qro^, Nlo`lksbk`fÑk*bk `r^inrfbo`^j+

Didqpp%p 0 , 4  HlribrqfifwÑbpqb^m^o^ql m^o^j bafoil nrbrk^sbwp


abklj fkÑóbnrfs^ibkqbj b`Äkf`l abi `^iloò,
0,0 Ro^_^gl v `^ilo 1/

NYZdY - ) ë  =YhY[a\Y\]klyje a[Yk _flalkabbkqo^`^ilobkrkpfpqbj^* mbpmlpfqfsl,Nlolqo^m^oqb*pfp^ib`^iloabipfp+


]kh][z^a[Yk\]\an]jkgk qbj^* mbpkbd^qfsl, Nloq^kql*bipfdklab mfkaf`^i^afob``fÑkabi^qo^kpcbobk`f^ab
e Yl]jaYd]k
`^ilo,
G Yl]jaYd [ #D *_ (E $ N^o^ildo^obi jfpjl `^j_fl ab qbj mbo^qro^bk afsboplpj^qbof^ibppb obnrfbobk
?i .*7.. afcbobkqbp `^kqfa^abp ab `^ilo, Nlo bgbjmil* /. `j ö ab efbool pb `^ifbkq^k jÄp `lk
?G 0 M 1 /,053 jbklp `^iloabi nrbobnrfbobk /. `j\ ab ^dr^,Bbeb`el*i^`^kqfa^aab `^ilokb`b+
AgFp%MF*bq^kli 0,20 p^of^m^o^s^of^oi^qbjmbo^qro^bpmolmlo`flk^i^i^j^dkfqraabi`^j_flabqbjmb+
A gF g*_bk`bkl &s^mlobp' /,.3 o^qro^*?R*v^i^j^p^abipfpqbj^ i7
O F * 2 * cf+ebu^kl /,43
Ar .,163 m]7 i * >Q
Db\ %\ oo* /* + . ,2 3 0 * Alkbicfkab`lksboqfork^molmlo`fÑkbkrk^fdr^ia^a*pbobnrfbobrk^`lkpq^kqbab
D b gM g .,43/ molmlo`flk^ifa^a, Ck i^ bumobpfÑk ^kqboflo* i^ `lkpq^kqb ab molmlo`flk^ifa^a pb ob+
F gÇ d '  %/ 2 ,1 . 2 mobpbkq^mlojbaflabi^ibqo^ `*vob`f_bbiklj _obab _]l ]_e` ]` p~ni e_] aola_Äbe_]7
F gM Çp '  0,.4
m : i * _ * >Q &0,7'
F 0 . & û ' ,0 3 á A  2,/62
F 0 M  &d'* 03áA  /,642 J^`^m^`fa^aqÅojf`^bpmb`Çcf`^bprk^`^o^`qboÇpqf`^fkqbkpfs^abi j^qbof^inrb`lj +
F 0 M*s^mlo* /..áA 0,.2 mlkbbipfpqbj^,Jlpj^qbof^ibp`lkrk^_^g^`^m^`fa^aqÅojf`^bpmb`Çcf`^*`ljlj r+
F d .,/16 `elpjbq^ibp*obnrfbobkml`l`^ilom^o^molar`fork^s^of^`fÑkobi^qfs^jbkqbdo^kab
L^Af .,642 abqbjmbo^qro^,J^q^_i^0,/ `lkqfbkb^idrk^p`^m^`fa^abpqÅojf`^pbpmb`Çcf`^pabaf+
M 9 &d' ]]]]]]]]]] ]]]  .,7/6 sboplp j^qbof^ibp, J^p rkfa^abp ab i^ `^m^`fa^a qÅoj f`^ bpmb`Çcf`^ plk8 &bkbodÇ^'-
&j^p^ £qbjmbo^qro^' l &bkbodÇ^'-&jlibp äqbjmbo^qro^'9^pÇ* ^rknrbi^p rkfa^abp QG
abi `^ilo bpmb`Çcf`l plk8 H-d ä I lH-jli £I* bp `ljÖk bk`lkqo^opb `lk `^m^`fa^abp
qÅojf`^p bpmb`Çcf`^p nrb qfbkbk rkfa^abp ab `^i-jli £ áA* l ^idÖk lqol `lkgrkql ab
rkfa^abp,M_pbosbnrbbksfoqraabnrbi^b`r^`fÑk0,7fjmif`^rk_]i ^ekbki^qbj+
mbo^qro^*klfjmloq^pfÅpq^pbbumobp^bk rkfa^abpabhbisfkldo^alpAbipfrp,
J^_]l ]_e` ]` p~ni e_] @ bprk^molmfba^abuqbkpfs^nrbfk`irvbi^`^kqfa^aabj ^+
qbof^nrbe^vbk bipfpqbj^9^pÇ*i^b`r^`fÑk0 ,7  pbbp`of_foÇ^abi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^8

m : @* >Q

Bfqilhk /+1
^' Qrmlkfbkalnrbpb^mif`^k2..Hab bkbodÇ^^5,3.dabefbool*í`rÄipboÄbi`^j+
_flab qbjmbo^qro^=SqfiÇ`bpb `;.,23.H-däI,
_' Qfi^qbjmbo^qro^fkf`f^iabiefboolbpab43,.óA*í`rÄibpi^qbjmbo^qro^cfk^i=

Ojgp^dÅi
^' Bb^`rboal`lki^b`r^`fÑk0,7*

) 2 . . ,H ;  &5,3.d'&.,23.H-d+I 'Äo

Bbpmbg^kal >Q+
> Q :  )//6I

J^qbjmbo^qro^pbbibs^ //6I*il`r^i`loobpmlkab^rk`^j_flab qbjmbo^qro^ab


//6áA,
_' Alk qj]qbjmbo^qro^fkf`f^iab43,.áA* qj ej _nai aj pk ` a ..5Ö@bibs^i^qbjmb+
o^qro^abi^jrbpqo^^ /61áA,

Alk obpmb`ql ^i ^m^o^ql ab Hlrib ab i^ cfdro^ 0,4* prmlkd^nrb rk mbpl ab 2.,. hd
&nrbbumbofjbkq^ rk^ crbow^ ab 170 kbtqlkpab_fa^ ^ i^ do^sba^a' abp`fbkabrk^
afpq^k`f^ab0,..j,J^pm^ibq^pprjbodfa^pbkbi^dr^qo^kpcfbobki^afpjfkr`fÑkab
/. A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

i^bkbodÇ^mlqbk`f^i^i^dr^*i^`r^ipb`^ifbkq^,Qrmlkfbkalrk^j^p^ab03,.hdab
^dr^bkbiq^knrb*í`rÄibpbi`^j _fl bpmbo^alabqbjmbo^qro^abi^dr^=J^`^m^`f+
a^aqÅojf`^bpmb`Çcf`^abi^dr^bp ab2,/6H-d £I,

Ojgp^dÅi
Bb^`rboal`lki^b`r^`fÑk0,/*mlabjlp`^i`ri^obiqo^_^glnrbbimbpl^i`^bobcb`+
qÖ^pl_obbi^dr^8

qo^_^gl : C * o :  &170 L '&0 ,. . j ' ;  5 6 2 L+j  ;  562H

Ckbpqb`Äi`ril*^mif`^jlpbieb`el abnrb /glrib; / kbtqlk V / jbqol,Qfqlalbi


qo^_^glnrbpbob^ifw^ pfosbm^o^`^ibkq^obi^dr^*qbkbjlpnrb8

&%%%  
562H ;  &03,.hd' &2,/6H-d+I' ? R
S hd v

[ Q :  .,..53. I

|pqbkl bprkdo^k`^j _fl ab qbjmbo^qro^,Bbeb`el*Hlribqrsl nrb^oolg^obimb+


pl jr`e^psb`bp^kqbpab l_pbos^o`^j_flpabqbjmbo^qro^abqb`q^_ibp,

/+0 Bjanc~] fk qbok^ u lneian] hau


`a i^ qboj la fk Äj f`^
Ci qo^_^gl v  bi `^ilo plk j ^kfcbpq^`flkbp ab i^ bkbodÇ^* mbol e^pq^ ^elo^ kl ebjlp
^k^Sw^al afob`q^jbkqb ^ i^ bkbodÇ^, Qfk bj_^odl*^m^oqfoabbpqbj lj bkql i^bkbo+
dÇ^vi^pcÑojri^p obi^`flk^a^p `lk Åpq^ `lkpqfqrfoÄkbicl`l ab ^qbk`fÑk bk krbpqol
bpqrafl abi^qbojlafkÄjf`^,
J^bkbodÇ^qlq^iabrkpfpqbj^pbabcfkb `ljli^ ajancÄ] ejpanj])nrbpbobmobpbkq^
`lki^ibqo^ R+|pq^pb`ljmlkbabafcbobkqbpqfmlpabbkbodÇ^*`lj li^nrÇj f`^*bib`+
qoÑkf`^*kr`ib^ov`fkÅqf`^,W^nrbklmlabjlpjbafo`ljmibq^jbkqbqla^pi^p`i^pbp
ab bkbodÇ^abrkpfpqbj^*kl bpmlpf_ib`lkl`bobkcloj^^_plirq^i^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^
qlq^iabrkpfpqbj^,Ll l_pq^kqb*qlalpilppfpqbj^pmlpbbkrk^bkbodÇ^qlq^i R+
Skoeopai ]]eoh]`kj k mbojfqbi^bkqo^a^lp^ifa^abj^qbof^lbkbodÇ^, &Skoeopai ]
_ann]`k)mlolqo^m^oqb*mbojfqb bim^pl ab bkbodÇ^mbolkl ab j^qbof^,' Qfi^bkbodÇ^
kl mrbab bkqo^ol p^ifo*bkqlk`bpi^bkbodÇ^qlq^i Rabipfpqbj^kl`^j_f^,Cibkrk+
`f^albumiÇ`fql ab bpqbcbkÑjbkl pb`lkpfabo^i^mofjbo^ibvabi^qbojlafkÄjf`^8

Mnei an]hau` ah] panik`ej}ie_]*+Ckrkpfpqbj^^fpi^al*


i^bkbodÇ^qlq^iabipfpqbj^mboj^kb`b`lkpq^kqb,

Cpqlklpfdkfcf`^nrbbipfpqbj^pb^bpqÄqf`llkl`^j_fb,?idlmlaoÇ^bpq^ol`roofbk+
albkbipfpqbj^*`ljl rk^ob^``fÑk nrÇjf`^li^jbw`i^ab alp d^pbp, Qfkbj_^odl*
pfbipfpqbj^pbbk`rbkqo^^fpi^al*i^bkbodÇ^qlq^iabipfpqbj^kl `^j_f^,
Cufpqb rk^ cloj^ j^qbj Äqf`^ ab bumobp^o i^ mofjbo^ ibv qlj^kal bk `rbkq^ i^
bkbodÇ^fkqbok^8

Ckrk pfpqbj^^fpi^al* } +R : - / .- 

Ckbi`^plabrk`^j _flfkcfkfqbpfj^i*i^b`r^`fÑk0,/.mrbabbp`of_fopbabi^pfdrfbk+
qb j^kbo^9 ` R : -+
Cibkrk`f^al abi^b`r^`fÑk 0,/. ab i^mofjbo^ibvbp abml`^rqfifa^a*v^ nrbbk
bibpqraflabilppfpqbj^pkloj ^ij bkqbmbojfqfjlpbifkqbo`^j _flabj^qbof^vbkbo+
dÇ^ bkqob bi pfpqbj^ uprp ^iobabalobpp, Ck m^oqf`ri^o* klp fkqbobp^k ilp `^j _flp ab
bkbodÇ^abipfpqbj^, Ckqla^pi^pfksbpqfd^`flkbpobi^qfs^p^ilp`^j_flpab bkbodÇ^bk
ilppfpqbj^ppbe^bk`lkqo^alnrb`r^kali^bkbodÇ^qlq^iabrkpfpqbj^s^oÇ^*bi`^j +
0,2 Drk`flkbp ab bpq^al 11

_flabbkbodÇ^pb`lksfboqbbkqo^_^gllbk`^ilovk^a^jÄp,Cpqbeb`elmrbabbumob+
p^opbj^qbjÄqf`^jbkqbabi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^8

? Y - ; : g) t  %/+..&

J^b`r^`fÑk0,// bplqo^cloj^abbkrk`f^oi^mofjbo^ibv,Llqbq^kqli^pbk`fiibw`l+
jli^fjmloq^k`f^abbpq^b`r^`fÑk,Ci`^j_flbki^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^abrkmol`bplbp
fdr^i^iqo^_^gl jÄpbi`^ilo, QÑil qo^_^gl l `^iloñ l ^j_lpñ ^`ljm^É^krk `^j +
_fl bki^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^,W^nrbp^_bjlp `Ñjljbafobiqo^_^glvbi`^ilo*mlabjlp
o^pqob^oilp _]i ^ekobki^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^qlq^iabrk pfpqbj^,Cipfdrfbkqbbgbj milil
Ürpqo^,

Bfailhk /+3
Sk^ jrbpqo^ abd^p `^j_f^ prslirjbk ab2,.. J ^ 4,.. J `lkqo^rk^mobpfÑk bu+
qbok^ab/,3.^qj*vpfjriqÄkb^jbkqb^_plo_b /...[ ab`^ilo,íArÄibpbi`^j _flab
bkbodÇ^fkqbok^abipfpqbj^=

Ojgp^dÅi
W^nrbbipfpqbj^^_plo_b`^ilo*prbkbodÇ^pbfk`objbkq^9^pÇ*mlabjlpbp`of_fonrb
m: +c+/...H,Bb^`rboal`lki^b`r^`fÑk0,2obi^`flk^a^`lkbiqo^_^gl8

s: + & / , 3 . ^ q j ' & 4 , . . J + 2,..J'

/. / ,1 0 H
s;  ñ&/,3. ^qj '&0,..J' ;  ñ1,..J+^qj V
J +^qj 

s:  + 1 . 2 H

Ci`^j_flbki^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^bpi^prj^ab t v û99

> R :  m ( s :  /...H +  1.2H

? f 5 ;  474H

Llqbnrb m f s qfbkbkpfdklplmrbpqlpvnrbbi`^j_flqlq^ibki^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^bp
mlpfqfsl, Nloq^kql*i^bkbodÇ^qlq^iabkrbpqolpfpqbj^d^pblpl pbfk`objbkq^,

Qfrkpfpqbj^pbbk`rbkqo^mbocb`q^j bkqb^fpi^al*ÅpqbklmbojfqfoÄi^bkqo^a^lp^+
ifa^ ab `^ilo, Ck bpqb `^pl* m:  -+ Bf`elp pfpqbj^pob`f_bk bi klj _obab ]` e]^}pe_ko+
Ckmol`bplp^af^_Äqf`lp*

= %4 : r %/+./&
Cpq^obpqof``fÑk*bpab`fo*:g;M*bpi^mofjbo^abjr`e^pobpqof``flkbpnrbpfj mifcf`^k
biqo^q^jfbkqlqbojlafkÄjf`l abrkmol`bpl,QboÄkb`bp^ofl`lkpfabo^obpq^pobpqof`+
`flkbp* v^ nrb s^of^p bumobpflkbp* `lj l i^ b`r^`fÑk 0 , / 0 * plk Öqfibp pÑil `r^kal pb
^mif`^kaf`e^pobpqof``flkbp,

0 ,2  Dfj`flkbp bpq^ a l
Ciib`qlol_pbos^oÄnrbebjlp rqfifw^al ibqo^pjfkffp`ri^pm^o^ obmobpbkq^o `lk`bm+
qlp`lj l qo^_^glv`^ilo*vibqo^ j^vffp`ri^ m^o^i^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^, J^ o^wÑk abbiil
bpnrbi^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^`lkpqfqrvbZjbgbjmilabcrk`fÑkabbpq^al*vbiqo^_^glvbi
`^ilo*kl,
J^pfdrfbkqb^k^ildÇ^klpmboj fqfoÄfkqolar`fork^molmfba^aÖqfiabi^pcrk`flkbp
abbpq^al,Alkpfabobjlpi^j lkq^É^abi^cfdro^0,5,Qrmlkd^jlpnrbbiib`qlobprk
bp`^i^alovmobqbkabiibd^o^i^`rj _ob*m^o^il`r^ibufpqbkafsbop^pcloj^pab `lk+
12 A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv a b i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

@ a _ m j Y  - ) 2  ?k^ildÇ^ m^o^i^abcfkf`fÑk ab cfj `fÑk abbpq^al, Ck ^j_lp `^plp* Y$ pr_foafob`q^j bkqb
m l oi^j lk q^É ^v ^& ^p`bkabomlobii^bkbpmfo^i*bi`^j _fl qlq^iab^iqro^bp bij fpj lv*mloq^kql*bpfk +
a bmbkafbkqb abi^qo^vb`qlof^8bi `^j _fl ab ^iqro^ `lkpqfqrvbrk^clk`fÑqfabbpq^al,Ll l_pq^kqb*i^afp+
q^k `f^ ob`loofa^qlq^iabmbkab ab i^ qo^vb`qlof^*mloilnrb klpboÇ^rk^crk`fÑkabbpq^al,

pbdrfoil8 pbmrbabpr_foafob`q^jbkqb i^jlkq^É^* l _fbk* ^p`bkabobk cloj^bpmfo^ 


^iobabaloabbii^, J^sbkq^g^abpr_foafob`q^jbkqbbpnrbi^qo^vb`qlof^bpjÄp`loq^*
^rknrb q^j_fÅkjÄpmolkrk`f^a^,Skob`loofal bk bpmfo^i^iobabaloab i^j lkq^É^
kl obnrfbobpr_fork^mbkafbkqbjÄpmolkrk`f^a^*mbolbpjr`eljÄpi^odl, J^afp+
q^k`f^ ob`loofa^cfk^ijbkqbabmbkababi^qo^vb`qlof^nrbpbpfd^,Cpq^p`^kqfa^abppb
`lkpfabo^k `alaj`eajpao` ah] pn]ua_pkne]+
? elo^_fbk*fkabmbkafbkqbjbkqbabi`^jfklnrbpbpfd^*^icfkpbiibd^oÄ^i^`rj +
_ob,J^afcbobk`f^ab^iqro^pbkqobbimrkqlab fkf`flvabi^`rj_obbpi^jfpj^^icf+
k^iab i^bp`^i^a^pfkfjmloq^onrÅ`^j fklpbbifg^,Ci`^j_flbki^^iqro^pbaf`bnrb
bp ej `alaj `eaj pa` ah] pn]ua_pkne]+
Ci`^j _flab^iqro^^ibp`^i^oi^j lkq^É^mrbab`lkpfabo^opbrk^crk`fÑkabbpq^+
al8 bpfkabmbkafbkqbabi^qo^vb`qlof^,J^ afpq^k`f^ob`loofa^m^o^bp`^i^oi^j lkq^É^
kl `lkpqfqrvbrk^crk`fÑkabbpq^al*v^ nrbabmbkababi^qo^vb`qlof^,
Alkpfabobjlp rk mol`bpl cÇpf`l l nrÇjf`l nrb l`roob bk rk pfpqbj^, |pqb qfbkb
rk^p`lkaf`flkbpfkf`f^ibp*vabpmrÅpabimol`bplqbkaoÄlqo^p`lkaf`flkbpcfk^ibp*mb+
ole^vjr`e^pcloj^p bk nrb bipfpqbj^mrbabm^p^oab prbpq^al fkf`f^i^prbpq^al
cfk^i, Sk^bq j _eÇj ` aaop]`kao`r^inrfbomolmfba^a qbojlafkÄjf`^abipfpqbj^ `rvl
`^j _flaro^kqbbimol`bplbpfkabmbkafbkqbabi^qo^vb`qlof^*bpqlbp*nrbabmbkabpÑ+
ilabibpq^alabipfpqbj^&bkqÅoj fklpabs^of^_ibpabbpq^al`lj ll) T* R* k'*vklab
i^efpqlof^abipfpqbj^ l ab `Ñj l ÅpqbiibdÑ ^ af`el bpq^al, Sk^ molmfba^aqboj laf+
kÄjf`^*`rvl`^j_flaro^kqbbimol`bplabmbkababi^qo^vb`qlof^*kl`lkpqfqrvbrk^
crk`fÑk ab bpq^al, J^p crk`flkbp ab bpq^al pb obmobpbkq^k `lk ibqo^p j^vÖp`ri^p9
i^p crk`flkbp nrb kl plk ab bpq^al pb obmobpbkq^k `lkibqo^pjfkÖp`ri^p, J^ bkbodÇ^
fkqbok^bprk^crk`fÑk abbpq^al9bi qo^_^glvbi`^iloklilplk,
Cufpqb lqo^ afcbobk`f^bkil nrb pb obcfbob ^ i^pcrk`flkbp ab bpq^al, Ck bi `^pl ab
rk^s^of^`fÑkfkcfkfqbpfj^ibkrkpfpqbj^*i^p s^of^`flkbpfkcfkfqbpfj^ibpbkbiqo^_^+
gl*bi`^ilovi^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^pbobmobpbkq^kjbaf^kqbilpqÅoj fklp`s) `mv`R+Ck
rkmol`bpl`ljmibql*bpqlp`^j _flpfkcfkfqbpfj^ibppbfkqbdo^kabpabi^p`lkaf`flkbp
fkf`f^ibpe^pq^i^pcfk^ibp,?elo^_fbk*bufpqbrk^mbnrbÉ^afcbobk`f^bk`r^kql^i^k l +
q^`fÑk, Ar^kal pbfkqbdo^k `s v`m)biobpriq^al bpi^`^kqfa^a^_plirq^abqo^_^gl s
v`^ilo m^pl`f^alp^imol`bpl,Nbol `r^kalpbfkqbdo^`R)biobpriq^alklbpi^ R^_+
plirq^ pfklbi _]i ^ekbk R)>R) abi pfpqbj^ab_fal ^imol`bpl, Cpqbeb`elpbbumobp^
j^qbjÄqf`^jbkqbabi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^8
/+1 Drk`flkbp ab bpq^al 13

`s :  s

E ;  m &0,/1'

kll_pq^kqb* ` R ì > R

J^jfpj^obi^`fÑk bufpqbm^o^i^ j^vloÇ^ ab i^p lqo^p crk`flkbp ab bpq^al &pÑil e^v
rk^ bu`bm`fÑk*nrb^k^ifw^objlp bk bi pfdrfbkqb `^mÇqril',J^p afcbobk`f^ibp ` s u `m
ob`f_bkbiklj_obab `ebanaj_e]haoejat]_p]o)il `r^ipfdkfcf`^nrbprps^ilobpfkqbdo^+
alp s f mabmbkabk abi^qo^vb`qlof^, Nlobi`lkqo^ofl* `R `lkpqfqrvb rk^ `ebanaj _e]h
at]_p])il`r^inrfbobab`fonrbprs^ilofkqbdo^al ? S bpfkabmbkafbkqbabi^qo^vb`+
qlof^,Rlalp ilp `^j_flpbki^p crk`flkbpab bpq^al plkafcbobk`f^ibpbu^`q^p,
Mqo^cloj^abbumif`^oi^p b`r^`flkbp0,/1 `lkpfpqbbk l_pbos^onrb
R b *  Re

mbol8 s TXì sê v m [  mbì m '


J^pb`r^`flkbp0,/1 fjmif`^knrb*m^o^rk`^j _flfkcfkfqbpfj^ibkrkpfpqbj^*

`R :  ` m (  `s

nrb obmobpbkq^i^cloj^fkcfkfqbpfj^i ab i^mofj bo^ibvab i^qbojlafkÄjf`^,?elo^


_fbk*`r^kalfkqbdo^jlpbpq^b`r^`fÑk* l_qbkbjlp8

?à5:  m( s

J^afcbobk`f^bkqob biqo^q^jfbkql ab nv t*vbi ab R)pb ab_b ^nrb Åpq^bp rk^ crk+
`fÑkabbpq^al,Nlabjlp`lkl`boilps^ilobp^_plirqlpab fgvt*mbolÅpqlpabmbkabk
abi^qo^vb`qlof^nrbbipfpqbj^pfdrfÑm^o^foabi^p`lkaf`flkbpfkf`f^ibp^i^pcfk^ibp,
?J\kl abmbkabab i^ qo^vb`qlof^* mbol kl mlabjlp`lkl`bo bis^ilo ^_plirql ab R
m^o^ilpbpq^alp fkf`f^ivcfk^iabrkpfpqbj^,
?rknrb bpq^p abcfkf`flkbp kl m^obw`^k pbo ab rqfifa^a* `lkpfabob nrb `r^inrfbo
`^j _fl^ib^qloflabrkpfpqbj^ d^pblplk l pfbjmobmlaoÄabp`of_fopb`ljlrk mol+
`bplfplqÅojf`l*^af^_Äqf`l*bq`,Lll_pq^kqb*bkjr`elp`^plpmlabjlpm^p^oabi^p
`lkaf`flkbp fkf`f^ibp ^ i^p cfk^ibp bk mbnrbÉlp m^plp fab^ibp9 ^pÇ* bi `^j_fl qlq^i bk
rk^crk`fÑkabbpq^alpboÄi^prj^ab qlalpbpqlpmbnrbÉlpm^plp,W^nrbbi`^j _fl
bk rk^crk`fÑkabbpq^albpfkabmbkafbkqbabi^qo^vb`qlof^*bi`^j _flbki^crk`fÑk
ab bpq^al `^i`ri^al bkm^plp bp bi j fpj l nrbbi `^j_fl abi^crk`fÑk ab bpq^al bk
rkmol`bplabrkplilm^pl,KÄp^abi^kqbsbobjlpbgbjmilpnrb firpqo^kbpq^fab^,
Qfklpbiibs^^`^_lqo^_^gl\aro^kqbrkmol`bpl*bkqlk`bp` R :` m u > R :m+Cufp+
qbk alp `lkaf`flkbp `ljrkbp bki^p nrb biqo^_^gl bp fdr^i^ `bol, J^mofj bo^ qfbkb
nrbsbo`lki^bum^kpfÑkif_ob&bpqlbp*`r^kali^mobpfÑkablmlpf`fÑkbp`bol',J^pb+
drka^pbobcfbob^rkpfpqbj^bkbinrbk l e^vs^of^`fÑkabslirjbkaro^kqbbimol+
`bpl,W^nrb ` S : M*`r^inrfbobumobpfÑk obi^qfs^^i qo^_^gl abimol`bplq^j _fÅkpboÄ
bu^`q^jbkqbfdr^i^`bol,J^cÑoj ri^nrbfk`irvb^i`^ilo_^glbpq^p `lkaf`flkbp^sb+
`bppbbumobp^abi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^8
` R ;  `mu &0,/2'

> R :  mu &0,/3'


alkabbipr_Çkaf`b S bkbiqÅoj fkl mfj mif`^nrbbislirjbkabipfpqbj^mboj^kb`b
`lkpq^kqbaro^kqbbimol`bpl,J^b`r^`fÑk0,/3bpfjmloq^kqbmlonrbbkjr`elpmol+
`bplpmlabjlpjbafoafob`q^jbkqbilps^ilobpab m+Qfbpqlpmol`bplpl`roobk^slir+
j bk`lkpq^kqb*bkqlk`bp `lkl`bjlp?R+

ö\YL, abiR+[ W^nrb bf pfpqbj ^ km  qfb k b  r k  qo ^ _ ^ gl  l r k  `^ il ofk f`f^i* k fr k  qo^ _ ^ gl  l ` ^ il o c fk ^ i
\?rknrb bk  bpq^m ofj bo^ m ^ oqb k lp e b j l p  b k cl ` ^ a l  bk  bi qo^ _ ^ gl  obi^`flk ^al `l k  i^m obpfÑ k v
s lir j bk * bufpqbk l qolp qfm lp ab qo^ _ ^ gl p* ` l j l  bi b iÅ` qof`l v bido^sfq^`flk^i, C k  bpqb `^pl pr m l k b +
j l pnrb k fk dr k l  ab bpqlpqo^ _ ^ gl p bpqÄk m obpbk qbp a r o^k qbbimol`bpl,
03 A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

Bfailhk /+4
Sk^jrbpqo^ab d^pab /,.. J^ /,.. ^qjabmobpfÑkv076 I*pbbum^kabfplqÅojf`^
vobsbopf_ibjbkqb^ /.,.J, BbpmrÅppb`^ifbkq^^3..I*pb`ljmofjb^ /,.. Jvbk+
qlk`bppbbkcoÇ^^03áA, íArÄi bpbis^iloab?ì5m^o^bimol`bplqlq^i=

Ojgp^dÅi
? q-;Mm^o^bimol`bpl qlq^i, Pb`loabjlpnrbrk^crk`fÑkabbpq^al bprk^s^of^+
_ib `rvlps^ilobp abmbkabk abi^p `lkaf`flkbpfkpq^kqÄkb^p abi pfpqbj^,W^ nrbi^p
`lkaf`flkbpfkf`f^ivcfk^iabipfpqbj^plki^pjfpj^p*bipfpqbj^qfbkbbijfpjls^+
ilo^_plirqlabbkbodÇ^fkqbok^&`r^inrfbo^nrbpb^'*^pÇnrbbi`^j _flqlq^iabbkbo+
dÇ^ fkqbok^bp`bol,

/+2 Bjp]hle]
?rknrb i^bkbodÇ^ fkqbok^ obmobpbkq^i^bkbodÇ^qlq^i ab rk pfpqbj^vi^ mofjbo^ibv
abi^qbojlafkÄjf`^pb_^p^bk bi`lk`bmql ab bkbodÇ^fkqbok^*Åpq^ kl pfbjmob bpi^
s^of^_ib`lki^nrbj bglopbmrbabqo^_^g^o, J^b`r^`fÑk0,/3 jrbpqo^nrbbi`^j_fl
bki^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^bpbu^`q^jbkqbfdr^i^ mñ pfbislirjbk abi pfpqbj^mboj^kb`b
`lkpq^kqbbkrkmol`bplm^oqf`ri^o,Qfkbj_^odl*bkjr`elpmol`bplpbpafcÇ`fid^o^k+
qfw^o i^`lkaf`fÑk bumbofjbkq^i abislirjbk `lkpq^kqb,J^mobpfÑk`lkpq^kqb* `lkpf+
abo^kal nrb j r`elp bumbofjbkqlp pb iibs^k ^ `^_l bk `lkq^`ql `lk i^ ^qjÑpcbo^*
obpriq^`lkcob`rbk`f^rkm^oÄjbqolbumbofjbkq^ijÄppbk`fiil,
?i^ ajp]hle]pbibobmobpbkq^`lkbipÇj_lil E+J^abcfkf`fÑk crka^jbkq^iab bk+
q^imf^bp8

F;< R(l S  &0,/4'


CiqÅojfkll bki^b`r^`fÑk0,/4bpi^mobpfÑkabipfpqbj^*mìú*,J^bkq^imf^q^j_fÅkbp
rk^crk`fÑk ab bpq^al,Alj lbkbi`^pl abi^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^*bis^ilo^_plirql ab i^
bkq^imf^kl pbmrbab`lkl`bo*mbolbpmlpf_ibabqbojfk^oprp_]i ^eko) `E7

` E :  ` R (  `%lS & &0,/5'


J^cloj^fkqbdo^a^abbpq^b`r^`fÑkbp8

> E :  }R ( > %l S & &0,/6'

Kbaf^kqb i^ obdi^ ab i^ `^abk^*mlabjlpslisbo ^ bp`of_foi^ b`r^`fÑk 0,/5 abi^ pf+
drfbkqbj^kbo^8

` E :  ` R ( l ` S (  S `l

Ck rkmol`bpl ^mobpfÑk `lkpq^kqb &nrbbp jÄp cob`rbkqb bkilpbumbofjbkqlp abi^+


_lo^qlofl'*biqÅoj fkl S` lbp`bolbksfoqraabnrb`lbp`bol,Bb^`rboal`lki^ab+
cfkf`fÑklofdfk^iab `R)i^b`r^`fÑkpbqo^kpcloj^bk9

` E  :  `m( `s (l ` S

`E  ;  ` m *  l ` S (l ` S

` E  ;  `m &0,/7'

CkqÅojfklp abilp`^j _flpqlq^ibp ab rkpfpqbj^* i^ b`r^`fÑk 0,/7 mrbabfkqbdo^opb


m^o^l_qbkbobipfdrfbkqbobpriq^al8

/4.O
W^ nrbbi mol`bpl l`roob ^ mobpfÑk `lkpq^kqb*i^Öiqfj^ b`r^`fÑk pb bumobp^ `ljl i^
b`r^`fÑk0,/3 abi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^8
? F ; \ &0,0.'
0,3 Ckq^imf^ 15

W^nrbilp`^j_flpabbkbodÇ^abjr`elpmol`bplppbjfabk_^gl`lkaf`flkbpabmob+
pfÑk`lkpq^kqb* ah_]i ^ek ` aaj p]hle]aj qjlnk_aokjkni ]hi aj paaoi }ob} _ eh` ai a`en
mqaah_]i ^ek` aajancÄ]ejpanj]+?pÇ*^rknrbi^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^bpi^s^of^_ibjÄpcrk+
a^jbkq^i*i^bkq^imf^pbmobpbkq^`lkjÄpcob`rbk`f^,

Bfailhk /+5
GkafnrbnrÅcrk`fÑkabbpq^al bpfdr^i^i`^ilobk`^a^mol`bplabp`ofql,
^' J^ `lj_rpqfÑk ab rk^jrbpqo^bk rk`^iloÇjbqol ab_lj_^* rk^`Äj^o^oÇdfa^
jbqÄif`^bki^nrbpbnrbj^kjrbpqo^pm^o^abqbojfk^obi`^ilo^pl`f^al^imol`bpl,
_' J^crpfÑkabrk`r_labefbilbkrk^q^p^,
`'Cibkcof^jfbkqlabifkqbofloabrkobcfofdbo^alo,
a'Cicffbdlbkrk^ `efjbkb^,

Ojgp^dÅi
^'?m^oqfoabi^abp`ofm`fÑk*mlabjlpprmlkbonrbrk`^iloÇjbqolab_lj _^bprk
pfpqbj^`lkrkslirjbk`lkpq^kqb9mloilq^kql*bi`^ilonrbdbkbo^i^`lj_rpqfÑk
abrk^jrbpqo^bpfdr^i^?S,
_' Qfi^q^p^ pb bumlkb ^i^ ^qjÑpcbo^* bpqÄ _^gl i^ mobpfÑk abi ^fob* nrb bp dbkbo^i+
jbkqb`lkpq^kqb*mloilnrbbi`^ilo^pl`f^al^imol`bplbpfdr^i^? I ,
`'Skobcofdbo^alokl`^j _f^abslirjbk^ibkcof^oi^`ljfa^*^pÇnrbi^mÅoafa^ab
`^iloabpabbifkqboflobpfdr^i^?f5,
a' Cicrbdlbkrk^ `efj bkb^kloj^ijbkqbpbbk`rbkqo^bk`lkq^`ql `lki^^qjÑp+
cbo^* ^pÇ nrbbi`^ilodbkbo^al q^j_fÅk`lkpqfqrvbrk^jbafa^ab?F,

Sk `fifkaol* nrb pbiibk^ `lk .,.2.. jlibp ab rk d^p fab^i* pb bum^kab obsbopf_ib+
jbkqb ab 3.,. jJ ^ 153 j J^ rk^qbjmbo^qro^`lkpq^kqb ab 15,.óA, Alkcloj b il
e^`b*^_plo_b0.6HabbkbodÇ^bkcloj ^ab`^ilo,A^i`ribm ) s ) I R u > E m^o^bimol+
`bpl,

Ojgp^dÅi
W^ nrbbkqo^k ^i pfpqbj^ 0.6 H* i^ `^kqfa^a qlq^i ab bkbodÇ^ pb bibs^ 0.6 H9 ^pÇ* m :
)0.6H,Alkbicfkab`^i`ri^obiqo^_^gl*mlabjlp^mif`^oi^b`r^`fÑk0,58

F 153j J
s  ;  + & . ,. 2 . .  j li' 6,1/2 &1/.I'iky
jli%I- 3.,. jJ

s  ;  + 0 . 6  H

W^nrb?&5bpfdr^i ] m (  s)

?JR ; +q+0.6 H +  0.6H

?JR ;  MH

Nlabjlpbjmib^oi^b`r^`fÑk0,/6 m^o^`^i`ri^o?F, mbolkb`bpfq^j lpabqbojfk^o


i^pmobpflkbp fkf`f^ivcfk^im^o^ l_qbkbo?&mT', Bb ^`rboal `lki^ ibvabilp d^pbp
fab^ibp8

&.,.2..j li'&.,.60.3*0 i'& 1 / . I'


.,.3.J

mf ; 0.,1 ^qj
*/ A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

? pfj fpj l9

&.,.2.. j li'&.,.60.3Q y '&1 / .  I'


l ; ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ;  0,5/ ^qj
[ .,153J

N^o^ `^i`ri^o#+%lS&)j riqfmif`^jlpi^mobpfÑkcfk^ivbislirjbk9 bk pbdrfa^obpq^+


j lp bimolar`qlabi^mobpfÑkfkf`f^ivbislirjbk8

[ el S & ;  &0,5/ ^qj '&.,153 J' +  &0.,1 ^qj '&.,.3.. J' ;  M

Cpqbobpriq^alpbbpmbo^_^m^o^ilnrb`lkpqfqrvb_Äpf`^jbkqbrk^bum^kpfÑkabrk
d^pfab^iab^`rboal `lki^ibvab @lvib,Nloq^kql*?F;? Ü 9^pÇ*

?F;  MH

? rknrbilp`^j_flpbki^palpcrk`flkbpabbpq^alplkfdr^ibp&v`bol'bkbpqbbgbj +
mil*Åpqbklpfbjmobbpbi`^pl,

W^nrb?Fbprk^cÇfk`fÑk ab bpq^al`ljÖk*_^p^jlpi^pabcfkf`flkbpab ^idrklp


qÅoj fklp bk i^ bkq^imf^* kl bk i^ bkbodÇ^ fkqbok^, Ci qÅojfkl atkp~ni e_k pb ^mif`^ ^
`r^inrfbomol`bpl bk bi nrb ? F bp kbd^qfsl, Ck bpqb `^pl* i^ bkbodÇ^ p^ib abi pfpqbj^
e^`f^ilp^iobabalobp,CiqÅoj fkl aj`kp~ni e_kpbobcfbob^`r^inrfbomol`bplbkbinrb
? F bpmlpfqfsl, Ckbpqb`^pl*bipfpqbj^^_plo_bbkbodÇ^abilp^iobabalobp,

/+3 @]i^eko `a h]o bqj_ekjao `a aop]`k


?rknrb ebjlp af`el nrb mlabjlp `lkl`bo pÑil bi _]i ^ek bk i^ bkbodÇ^ fkqbok^ l
bkq^imf^* e^pq^ ^elo^ ebjlp qo^_^g^al bu`ir pfs \ bk qb `lk bi `^j _fl qlq^i ab rk
mol`bpl `ljmibql,Ll ebjlp`lkpfabo^al`lkabq^iibilp`^j_flpfkcfkfqbpfj^ibp ab
F l  R+
R^kql i^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^`lj li^bkq^imf^abrkpfpqbj^a^albpqÄk abqbojfk^a^p
mloi^ps^of^_ibpabbpq^alabipfpqbj^,Ckrkd^p*bpqlfjmif`^i^`^kqfa^a*i^mobpfÑk*
bislirjbkvi^ qbjmbo^qro^ abbpqb d^p, Gkf`f^ijbkqbprmlkaobjlp nrbi^ `^kqfa^a
ab d^pk l s^oÇ^ &^rknrb`^j _f^oÄ`r^kalbpqrafbjlpob^``flkbpnrÇj f`^p',?pÇ* R u 
E nrba^kabqbojfk^a^pÖkf`^jbkqbmlol ) S u Q + ?elo^_fbk*l ) S u  Q oaobi^`flk^k
jbaf^kqb i^ ibv ab ilp d^pbp fab^ibp &^mif`^a^ ^ rk d^p fab^i'* ^pÇ nrb pf `lkl`bjlp
alpabbÜ^p*mlabjlpabqbojfk^oi^qbo`bo^,Nloq^kql*a^a^`fboq^`^kqfa^aabd^pbk
rkpfpqbj^*pÑile^valps^of^_ibpabbpq^alfkabmbkafbkqbp,Qfnrbobjlpbkqbkabobi
`^j _fl fkcfkfqbpfj^ibk rk^ crk`fÑk abbpq^al*pÑilkb`bpfq^jlp`ljmobkabo`Ñj l
s^oÇ^ Åpq^ `lkobpmb`ql ^ alp abi^pqobps^of^_ibp ab bpq^al ` al ) S u  Q+ J^ qbo`bo^pb
mrbab`^i`ri^o^m^oqfoabi^p lqo^palp,
íArÄibp alp `^kqfa^abp bibdfobjlp m^o^ i^ bkbodÇ^ fkqbok^ vi^ bkq^imf^= ?rknrb
mlabjlpbibdfoalp `r^ibpnrfbo^*bkilp`Äi`rilpj^qbjÄqf`lpnrbiibs^objlp^`^_l
e^_oÄsbkq^g^ppfbibdfjlprkm^om^o^`^a^crk`fÑkab bpq^al,Ckbi`^plabi^bkbo+
dÇ^fkqbok^*rqfifw^objlpi^qbjmbo^qro^vbislirjbk,Ckbiabi^bkq^imf^*bibdfobjlp
i^qbjmbo^qro^vi^mobpfÑk,
J^afcbobk`f^iqlq^iabrk^crk`fÑkabbpq^alpbbumobp^`ljli^prj^abi^pabof+
s^a^pabi^crk`fÑk`lkobpmb`ql^`^a^rk^abprps^of^_ibp,Nlobgbjmil*` R bpfdr^i
^i`^j _flbk R`lkobpmb`ql^i^qbjmbo^qro^^slirjbk`lkpq^kqb*jÄpbi`^j _flbk
R`lkobpmb`ql^islirjbk^qbjmbo^qro^`lkpq^kqb,Ckbi`^plabi`^j _fl bk R)bu+
mobp^al `ljl S&R* T' ñ< ~ &R )  `Q) S( `S &) bi`^j_fl fkcfkfqbpfj^i bki^bkbodÇ^
fkqbok^bp8

B4;
` R : ` Q ( `S %"%$
S o- f X ` r f)
/+3 A^j_flp ab i^p crk`flkbp ab bpq^al /5

@a_mjY - )3  Sk^firpqo^`fÑkabnrbbi `^j _flqlq^ibk R mrbababp`ljmlkbopbbk rk`^j _fl `lk obp+


mb`qli^ qbjmbo^qro^ &obmobpbkq^al m l o &1A--^G'v' v rk `^j _fl `lk obpmb`ql ^islirjbk &obmobpbkq^al
lknw`Rh`S&Q&+

?pÇ* `R qfbkbrkqÅoj fkl nrbs^oÇ^`lki^qbjmbo^qro^vlqolnrbs^oÇ^ `lk bislir+


jbk,J^palpabofs^a^pm^o`f^ibpobmobpbkq^kmbkafbkqbpbki^doÄcf`^ab ì5 bkcrk`fÑk
` a Q u S +Ci`^j _flfkcfkfqbpfj^iqlq^ibk R)`R)mrbabbumobp^opbbkqÅoj fklpabaf+
`e^pmbkafbkqbp,J^cfdro^0,6 firpqo^rk^doÄcf`^ab Rbki^nrbi^pmbkafbkqbppbbk+
`rbkqo^kobmobpbkq^a^pmloi^pabofs^a^pm^o`f^ibp,
Pb`loabjlp nrb bufpqb lqo^ abcfkf`fÑk m^o^ `R7 `R :  `m( `s  :  ` m *  l  `S+ Qf
fdr^i^jlpbpq^p alp abcfkf`flkbp ab `R7

(D;
` Q ( ` S :  ` m * l ` S
B3 Ss
Bbpmbg^kal bi`^j_flbkbi`^ilo* `m7

`m : ` Q ( `S (l`S
:B3J ?T<
?elo^*^dormbjlpilpalp qÅoj fklpab ` S m^o^l_qbkbo8

D;
`m* ` Q ( (l `S
Rn> ;B5
Qfkrbpqolpfpqbj^d^pblplprcobrk `^j _fl bkbinrbbislirjbk kls^oÇ^*bkqlk`bp
` S bpfdr^i^ `bol*vi^b`r^`fÑk^kqboflopbpfjmifcf`^abi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^9

`m ü `Q "0 '00 #


B3
?pfjfpjl* mlabjlp obbp`of_fo bpq^ bumobpfÑk afsfafbkal ^j_lp j fbj _olp ab i^
b`r^`fÑkbkqob `Q+

; `RY
`Q B3
Ci`^j_flbkbi`^ilo`lkobpmb`ql^i^qbjmbo^qro^*nrbbpfdr^i^i`^j_flbki^bkbo+
dÇ^fkqbok^`lkobpmb`ql ^i^qbjmbo^qro^^slirjbk`lkpq^kqb*pbabcfkb`lj li^ _]*
l ] _ e` ] ` p~ni e_]] rkhqi aj_kjop]jpa` ahpfpqbj^&`ljm^obbpq^abcfkf`fÑk`lki^abi^
b`r^`fÑk0,7*bki^nrbabcfkfjlp bi`^ilobkqÅojfklpabi `^j_fl bki^qbjmbo^qro^
rqfifw^kal rk^ `lkpq^kqb nrb ii^j ^j lp `^m^`fa^a qÅojf`^ bpmb`Çcf`^', Ck qÅoj fklp
abi^abofs^a^m^o`f^i^kqboflo*
õ6R Y
X 1V &0,01'
Y `Q &
?elo^ rqfifw^jlp bi pÇj_lil @um^o^ obmobpbkq^o i^ `^m^`fa^a qÅojf`^ ^ slirjbk
`lkpq^kqb,Nloq^kql*i^b`r^`fÑk0,00mrbabobbp`of_fopbabi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^8
`m:@r`Q &0,02'
2. A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qboj lafk~jf`^

N^o^ bs^ir^o bi `^iloqlq^i* fkqbdo^jlp ^j_lp jfbj_olp ab bpq^ b`r^`fÑk fkcfkfqbpf+
j^im^o^l_qbkbo9
Å%c
mu: f@ u`Q : > R  %/+/2&
3

J^fdr^ia^acfk^ipbabar`babieb`elabnrb> R :  mm^o^rk`^j _fl^slirjbk`lkp+


q^kqb,J^b`r^`fÑk0,03bpi^cloj^jÄpdbkbo^iabrk`^j_fl^slirjbk`lkpq^kqb,Ll
l_pq^kqb*pfi^`^m^`fa^aqÅojf`^bp`lkpq^kqb^ili^odl abifkqbos^ilabqbjmbo^qro^p
&m^o^fkqbos^ilpabqbjmbo^qro^nrbklfjmifnrbk`^j_flpabc^pb'*Åpq^mrbabbuqo^bo+
pbabi^fkqbdo^im^o^l_qbkbo8
P)
? ì5 ;  As ` Q :  @r%Qêy* Rì' ;  @ u > Q &0,04'

Ckbi`^plab jj libpabd^p*bpq^bumobpfÑkmrbabobbp`of_fopbpbk`fii^jbkqbabi^pf+


drfbkqbj^kbo^8

> R :  j@r> Q &0,05'


alkab @ubpi^_]l ]_e` ]` p~ni e_]i kh]n+Qfi^`^m^`fa^aqÅoj f`^s^oÇ^^mob`f^_ibjbk+
qb `lki^ qbjmbo^qro^* qbkaoÄnrb prpqfqrfopb O bki^b`r^`fÑk 0,03 mlork^ bumob+
pfÑkbkqÅoj fklpabi^qbjmbo^qro^vbs^ir^opbbumiÇ`fq^jbkqbi^fkqbdo^i,QfÅpqbbpbi
`^pl*i^pqbjmbo^qro^pabilpiÇjfqbpabfkqbdo^`fÑkab_bkbumobp^opbbkhbisfk,
Qf i^ `^m^`fa^a qÅoj f`^ pb afsfab bkqob i^ j^p^ abi pfpqbj^* qbkaoÄ rkfa^abp ab
[-däIlG-hdäI*i^`r^iob`f_bbiklj _obab _]l]_e`]`p~ni e_] aola_Äbe_]l*^sb`bp*bi
ab _]hknaola_Äbe_k+Qbab_bqbkbo`rfa^al^i^elo^ababqbojfk^oi^prkfa^abpabrk^
`^m^`fa^aqÅoj f`^m^o^abcfkfopfbkob^ifa^apbqo^q^ab rk^`^m^`fa^aqÅojf`^bpmb+
`Çcf`^,

Bfailhk /+.-
Cs^iÖb ?Jbm^o^ /,.. j liab luÇdbkl*M g* nrbm^p^ ab+0 . ,. á A  ^ 15,.áA^slirjbk
`lkpq^kqb*bkilppfdrfbkqbp`^plp\&?A-qbkaoÄrkfa^abpab H',
^' Qb qo^q^ab rkd^pfab^i`lk @u:  0.,56H-o^li+I, ]]
_' Qbqo^q^abrkd^pob^i`lkrks^iloabqbojfk^albumbofjbkq^ijbkqb @u ;  0 J 4 
e+2,/6 V iM\\R+ &/,45 V

Ojgp^dÅi
^' W^ nrb prmlkbjlp nrb i^ `^m^`fa^a qÅojf`^ bp `lkpq^kqb* mlabjlp ^mif`^o i^
b`r^`fÑk/+/.)bki^nrbbi`^j_fl bki^qbjmbo^qro^bpab 35á8

H
? q5;  j@u? R ;  &/,..jli'% 0.,56 &35,.á' ;  //62/
j li%I

Ckbpqb`^pl*bpq^jlprqfifw^kali^rkfa^am^o^ Av*nrbfk`irvbi^rkfa^aj libkbi


abkljfk^alo,
_'W^nrbi^`^m^`fa^aqÅojf`^s^oÇ^`lki^qbjmbo^qro^*fkqbdo^jlpi^bumobpfÑkab
i^b`r^`fÑk0,03,R^j_fÅk`lksboqfjlpkrbpqo^pqbjmbo^qro^p^hbisfk8
R * 1/.I
/45 ...Z
> R : f @u`Q: F 0/,4 )2,/6 V  / . \ o + `Q
R* 031 I \

Gkqbdo^kalqÅoj fkl^ qÅojfkl8


1/.
> R :  0/,4 Q ( V  2,/6 V iM\\o\)
031
vbs^ir^kal bkilpiÇjfqbp*l_qbkbjlp8

>R:: 4474,. ) 0..,.) 316,5 +  3242,6 +  /11,6 +  44.,/ +  //54,6H


0,4 A^j_flp ab i^p crk`flkbp ab bpq^al 2/

M_pbosbi^mbnrbÉ^afcbobk`f^bkqobi^p obpmrbpq^p, Bf`e^p afcbobk`f^pmrbabkmbo+


abopb bk i^p `fco^p pfdkfcf`^qfs^p ab ilp`Äi`rilp &`lj l bk bpqb `^pl'*mbol bkjbaf+
`flkbpjrvmob`fp^p*pÇpbklq^oÇ^k,

Cufpqbrk^`lk`irpfÑk^af`flk^iobi^`flk^a^`lkilp`^j _flpabbkbodÇ^, Alkpfab+


obbi`^j _fl?&Hbkbimol`bplfirpqo^albki^cfdro^0,78rkpfpqbj^^fpi^alnrb`lkp+
q^ ab rk d^p fab^i abkqol ab rk^ `Äj^o^* pb ^_ob rk^sÄisri^ v bi d^p pb bum^kabv
l`rm^rkbpm^`fl s^`Çl, Aljlpbqo^q^abrk^bum^kpfÑkif_ob*biqo^_^glob^ifw^albp
`bol,Ci^fpi^jfbkqlbsfq^bifkqbo`^j_flab`^ilobkqobbipfpqbj^vilp^iobabalobp*^pÇ
nrbq^j_fÅkm:-+Cpqlpfdkfcf`^nrb?J-;Mbkbpqbmol`bpl,Bb^`rboal`lki^b`r^+
`fÑk 0 ,0 / *bpql fjmif`^nrb

M ; Y:' `S
Y ` Q G(< Y`S ê
Q^isl i^mlpf_ib`lfk`fabk`f^ abnrbilp alpqÅojfklpmrafbo^k ^kri^opb rkl ^lqol*
bijfbj_olabob`elabi^b`r^`fÑkpboÄfdr^i^`bolpÑilpf^j _lpqÅoj fklpplk`bol,
J^ abofs^a^ abi mofj bo qÅojfkl %` R F%` õ&[ j k bpfdr^i ^ `bol*v^ nrbi^qbjmbo^qro^
`lkpqfqrvbrk^jbafa^abi^bkbodÇ^abipfpqbj^,Alkclojbi^qbjmbo^qro^s^oÇ^*mlo
prmrbpqlnrbq^j _fÅki^bkbodÇ^`^j_f^9bpqlbpilnrbfj mif`^rk^`^m^`fa^aqÅoj f+
`^afcbobkqbab`bol,Nloq^kql*`"bi`^j_flbki^qbjmbo^qro^*ab_bpbofdr^i^`bol*
vbi mol`bpl bp fplqÅojf`l,?elo^ _fbk* `lkpfabobjlp bi pbdrkal qÅoj fkl, Q^_bjlp
nrb ` S kl bpfdr^i^`bol*v^ nrÅ bid^p fab^i pb bum^kab*v^ie^`boils^oÇ^ prslir+
ûDfdf^o^ 0 , 7  J^ bum^kpfÑk if_ob ^af^_Ä+
qf`^ ab rk d^p fab^i klp mboj fqb buqo^bo jbk,N^o^nrbbipbdrkalqÅoj fklpb^fdr^i^`bol*i^abofs^a^m^o`f^i w` R F%` S xb`a*
^idrk^p `lk`irpflkbp fkqbobp^kqbp obi^`fl+ dapbo`bol8
k^a^p`lk ?q-, &A lkpriqbi^bumif`^`fÑkbk
biqbuql,' `R
:  M m^o^rkd^pfab^i %/+/5&
y`S)
J^abofs^a^fkaf`^nrbbkbi`^plabrkd^pfab^i*bi`^j_flbki^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^`lk
obpmb`ql ^ i^p s^of^`flkbp ab slirjbk ^ pai lan]pqn] _kjop]jpaab_b pbofdr^i ^ `bol,
W^ nrb prmlkbjlp nrb bk rk d^p fab^i i^p m^oqÇ`ri^p fkafsfar^ibp kl fkqbo^`qÖ^k
bkqobpÇ* rk `^j _fl bk bislirjbkabi d^pfab^i &nrb qbkaboÇ^ ^ pbm^o^o jÄpi^p m^o+
qÇ`ri^p*bkmolj bafl'kl^iqbo^i^bkbodÇ^qlq^ipfi^qbjmbo^qro^pbj ^kqfbkb`lkpq^k+
qb,Bbeb`el*i^ b`r^`fÑk 0,06 `lkpqfqrvb rkl abilp alp `ofqboflp nrb ab_b `rjmifo
rkd^pm^o^`lkpfabo^opbrkd^pfab^i*vnrbplk8^'pbofdbmloi^ibvabilpd^pbpfab^+
ibpbumobp^a^bkcloj ^abb`r^`fÑkabbpq^al&`lj lpb^k^ifwÑbkbi`^mÇqril / '*v _ '
nrb mlpbb rk^ bkbodÇ^ fkqbok^ nrb kl `^j_f^ pf i^ qbjmbo^qro^ abi d^p q^jml`l il
e^`b,Ckbi`^plabilpd^pbpob^ibp*i^b`r^`fÑk0,06klpb`rjmibvi^bkbodÇ^qlq^ir]*
ne]n}pfe^vrk`^j _flbkbislirjbk,Cpqlpbab_b^nrbbkilpd^pbp ob^ibppÇ bufpqbk
fkqbo^``flkbpbkqobilpÄqljlpv jliÅ`ri^p,
Nlabjlpmol`baboabi^jfpj^cloj ^`lkrk`^j_flabi^fkcfkfqbpfj^iabi^bk+
q^imf^* `E+W^ebjlpaf`elnrbrqfifw^objlpi^qbjmbo^qro^vi^mobpfÑkbkbi`^plab
i^bkq^imf^,Bb^eÇnrb

Ä` E %` E
` E : ` Q ( &0,07'
T^o ` l , Q

Qfl`roobrk`^j _fl ^mobpfÑk`lkpq^kqb*bkqlk`bp '; . 9^pÇ* qbkbj lpnrb8

Ä`E Y
ÄF ; `Q
Y`Qf
alkabmlabjlpabcfkfork^_]l ]_e` ]` p~nie_]] lnaoeÇj_kjop]jpaA\q^i`ljl`r^kal
abcfkfjlp @u+?elo^mlabjlpabcfkfokrbpqo^`^m^`fa^aqÅojf`^bkqÅoj fklpabE7

&0,1.'
X`Q
2 0 A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofjbo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

J^b`r^`fÑk 0,1. fjmif`^nrbmlabjlpprpqfqrfo Ambki^ b`r^`fÑk ^kqboflom^o^l _ +


qbkbo

` E ;  @l` Q
Cpq^ bumobpfÑk mlabjlp fkqbdo^oi^ m^o^ abqbojfk^obi `^j _fl ab bkq^imf^ obi^qfsl ^
i^s^of^`fÑkabqbjmbo^qro^8

[ E : @l` Q :  m ) &0,1/'

Bbkrbslmlabjlpob`roofo^ieb`elabnrb> E bpfdr^i ^ nbk rk`^j _fl^mobpfÑk


`lkpq^kqb,J^b`r^`fÑk0,1/ ab_bbjmib^opbpfi^`^m^`fa^aqÅoj f`^s^oÇ^`lkobpmb`+
ql ^i^qbjmbo^qro^ wr~]oabibgbjmil0,/.',Qf Ambp `lkpq^kqb^il i^odl abi fkqbos^il
abqbjmbo^qro^*i^b`r^`fÑk 0,1/ mrbabpfjmifcf`^opbabi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^8

> E :@ l> Q:m) &0,10'


Jlp`ljbkq^oflp obpmb`ql ^i^p rkfa^abpab @uplkilpjfpjlpm^o^ Am&bpab`fonrb
biib`qloab_boÇ^ ^klq^opf rk^ `^kqfa^aabqbojfk^a^*bumobp^a^ bkrkfa^abpabdo^+
j lp l jlibp*pb bpmb`fcf`^ l pf bkob^ifa^abkqo^ bkilp`Äi`rilp',R^j_fÅkmlabjlp
abcfkfo rk^`^m^`fa^a qÅoj f`^jli^o Am m^o^ rkmol`bpl nrbl`roob_^gl `lkaf`fl+
kbpab mobpfÑk`lkpq^kqb,
Llpb`lkcrka^i^`^m^`fa^aqÅojf`^^slirjbk`lkpq^kqb`lki^`^m^`fa^aqÅojf+
`^^mobpfÑk`lkpq^kqb,Ckrkpfpqbj^d^pblpl*^j_lp`lk`bmqlpmrbabkpbojrvaf+
cbobkqbp,Ck bi `^pl abilp pÑifalpvilpiÇnrfalp*kl afcfbobk q^kql*mbol i^`^m^`fa^a
qÅoj f`^mrbabs^of^o`lki^qbjmbo^qro^, Ck rk `^j_fl nrb pbmobpbkqbbk rkpfpqb+
j^ d^pblpl* ab_bp^_bopbpfpbqo^q^ ab rk `^j_fl ^ mobpfÑk `lkpq^kqb &abkljfk^al
`^j _fl eok^}ne_k&)lab rk `^j_fl^slirjbk`lkpq^kqb&abklj fk^al`^j _fl eok_Ç*
ne_k&)`lkbicfkababqbojfk^oi^`^m^`fa^aqÅojf`^`loob`q^m^o^bi`Äi`rilabi`^ilo*
?R) >E)k ^j_lp,
Dfk^ijbkqb*q^j _fÅkmrbababjlpqo^opbnrbbk bi`^pl ab rkd^p fab^i*

h`E Y
 M  
`l Q

Cpab`fonrbbi`^j _flbki^bkq^imf^^qbjmbo^qro^`lkpq^kqbq^j _fÅkbpbu^`q^jbk+


qb `bol, Cpqbeb`elbp,^kÄildl^i^pfqr^`fÑknrbpbqfbkb`lk R+

/ +4 @kabe_eajpao `a Hlrib+Relj plk


?rknrbebjlpqo^_^g^al`lkrk^do^ks^ofba^aabb`r^`flkbp*qla^pbii^ppb_^p^k*bk
ÖiqfjlqÅojfkl*bkalpfab^p8 i^pb`r^`flkbpabbpq^alvi^mofjbo^ibvabi^qbojlaf+
kÄjf`^,Cpq^pfab^p* ^prsbw*pbcrka^kbpbk`f^ijbkqbbki^ abcfkf`fÑkabbkbodÇ^qlq^i
vbk afsbop^pcloj^p ab af`e^abcfkf`fÑk,?abjÄp*ebjlppfal qbpqfdlp abs^oflp `^plp
bkilpnrbi^pb`r^`flkbpabi^qbojlafkÄjf`^pbpfjmifcf`^kjbaf^kqbi^bpmb`fcf`^`fÑk
ab`fboq^p`lkaf`flkbp8^af^_Äqf`^p*abbum^kpfÑkif_ob*fpl_Äof`^pbfpl`Ñof`^p`lkpqfqr+
vbk qla^pobpqof``flkbpm^o^ rkmol`bpl nrb pfjmifcf`^ilp `Äi`rilp j^qbjÄqf`lp ab i^
qbojlafkÄjf`^,íF^v^idrk^plqo^pobpqof``flkbpnrbobpriqbkabrqfifa^a=
Mqo^obpqof``fÑkÖqfi_^p^a^bki^mofjbo^ibvabi^qboj lafkÄjf`^nrba^abp`ofq^
mlobibumbofjbkql ab Hlrib+Relj plk* nrb pb firpqo^ bk i^cfdro^0,/.,Qb `lkpqorvb
rkpfpqbj^^af^_Äqf`lvpbiibk^ab d^p rkl abilpi^alppbm^o^almlork^m^obaml+
olp^, Cid^p qfbkb abqbojfk^a^qbjmbo^qro^ R*,rk^ mobpfÑkcfg^m* v rkslirjbkfkf+
`f^i Tg,SkmfpqÑkfjmrip^bid^pvill_ifd^^m^p^omloi^m^obamlolp^*abq^ij^kbo^
nrb bislirjbkcfk^i ab bpqbi^al ab i^ m^oba pb^ `bol, Bbi lqol i^al abi^ m^oba* rk
pbdrkalmfpqÑkpbabpmi^w^e^`f^crbo^`lkclojbbid^ppbmolm^d^e^`f^bilqoli^al*
alkabqbkaoÄrk^qbjmbo^qro^ QĎ)rk^mobpfÑkcfg^m gVrkslirjbk Sf+?imofk`fmfl*
bislirjbkabii^al abob`el ab i^m^obabpfdr^i^`bol,W^nrbbid^pbpfjmrip^al ^
qo^sÅpabi^m^oba*pbbkqfbkabnrbm* < mg+?rknrbi^pmobpflkbp bk `r^inrfbo^abilp
0,5 Albcf`fbkqbp ab glrib+Reljplk 21

L\m`_
H\_j .7 kjmjn\ H\_j/8
o*,N f X Q)) l+
Aiom\_\ O\gd_\
_`gkdno`i J f\ _`gkdnoÅi
C \n
dh kpgn\_j
kjm`gkdnoÅi

Odno`h\\_d\]|od^j

cfd r o ^  0 ,/ .  Cumbofj bkql fplbkqÄÇmÇ`l abHlribvRelj plk,Cfif_olmolmlo`flk^bpq^bumif`^`fÑk,

i^alp pb bk`rbkqo^k cfg^p* ab_bjlp bpq^o `lkp`fbkqbp ab nrb bi d^p bumbofjbkq^ rk^
`^Ça^bki^mobpfÑk `lkcloj bpbibcrbow^^m^p^o abrki^al^lqol,
Ckbii^al fwnrfboal pbiibs^^`^_l qo^_^gl pl_obbid^p*bi `r^i`lkqof_rvbmlpfqf+
s^jbkqb^i`^j _flqlq^ibki^bkbodÇ^,Ckbii^alabob`el*bid^pob^ifw^qo^_^glv`lk+
qof_rvb kbd^qfs^jbkqb^i`^j _flqlq^ibki^bkbodÇ^, Ciqo^_^gl kbql nrbiibs^^
`^_lbipfpqbj^abpmrÅp abnrbpbfjmrip^`ljmibq^jbkqbbimofj bomfpqÑkbp8

<<%úbql ;  NiT%* * M Ď SĎ

W^nrbbipfpqbj^bp^af^_Äqf`l* m : -8^pÇ* ? N\olmlabjlpbumobp^o?R


`ljli^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^abid^pbkbii^al 0 *jbklpi^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^abid^pbkbii^+
al / 8
Uúbil : RĎ *
Gdr^i^kali^palpbumobpflkbp ab qbkbjlp8

NfT* +  MĎ SĎ : | / * R )

Qfobloabk^jlpilpalpj fbj_olp*l_qbkbjlp8

q ) (  m ,v * : R/ ( M Ď SĎ

J^`lj_fk^`fÑk R)l S bpi^ abcfkf`fÑklofdfk^iabE) i^bkq^imf^9 ^pÇ* bk bi `^pl abi
d^p bkbpqbbumbofjbkql abHlrib+Relj plk*

M* bkbi`^pl abi d^pplj bqfal^bpqbmol`bpl*bi _]i ^ekbkE bp `bol8

1 4 0 9
Nrbpql nrb i^ bkq^imf^ abi d^p kl `^j_f^* bi mol`bpl ob`f_b bi klj _ob ab mol`bpl
eokajp}ÄlÄ_k+ íArÄibp plk^idrk^p`lkpb`rbk`f^pabbpqbmol`bpl fplbkqÄÇmÇ`l=
?rknrbbi`^j _flabbkq^imf^bp`bol*bi`^j_flabqbjmbo^qro^klil bp, íArÄibp
bi`^j_flabqbjmbo^qro^nrb^`ljm^É^i^`^Ça^abi^mobpfÑkbkbpqbmol`bplfplbk+
qÄimf`l= Cp ab`fo* í`rÄi bp w ` Q { l & eb Nlabjlp bk ob^ifa^ajbafo bumbofjbkq^ijbkqb
bpq^abofs^a^jbaf^kqb rk ^m^o^ql`ljlbiabi^cfdro^ 0 , / . ,
Ci _kabe_eajpa ` a Gkq ha*Q d ki okj gHfyRpbabcfkb`lj lbi`^j_flbki^qbj mbo^qro^ab
rkd^p`lkmobpfÑkbkrkbpq^alabbkq^imf^`lkpq^kqb8

&0,12'
`l

Sk^^molufj^`fÑkÖqfiabbpq^abcfkf`fÑkbpi^pfdrfbkqb8

õ> QY
Y > l&
22 A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

Ckbi`^plabrkd^pfab^i* bpbu^`q^jbkqb`bol*v^nrbi^bkq^imf^abmbkabbu`irpf+
s^jbkqbabi^qbjmbo^qro^&bpab`fonrb^rkbpq^al abbkq^imf^`lkpq^kqb*i^qbjmb+
o^qro^q^j_fÅkbp`lkpq^kqb',Lll_pq^kqb*bkbi`^plabilpd^pbpob^ibp*bi`lbcf`fbkqb
ab Hlrib+Relj plk kl bp `bol v bi d^p `^j_f^oÄ ab qbjmbo^qro^ ab_fal ^i mol`bpl
fplbkqÄimf`l,Pb`loabjlpi^obdi^`Ç`if`^abi^pabofs^a^pm^o`f^ibp8

g c~ J%i
Xnkx F%G_ P & k Y `E &
Nlabjlp obbp`of_fobpq^ b`r^`fÑk abi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^8
Ä` E Y
%` Q Y
`l,E Ä`E
Y`Q,
Rlj^kal bk`rbkq^bieb`el ab nrbbijfbj_ol fwnrfboal ab GVHRvbiabkljfk^alo
ab i^ co^``fÑk bp pbk`fii^jbkqb i^ `^m^`fa^a qÅoj f`^ ^ mobpfÑk `lkpq^kqb* qbkbjlp
nrb8
%`E Y
`l
&0,13'

Cpq^b`r^`fÑk`lkcfoj^nrb bp`bolbkbi`^pl ab rk d^pfab^i*v^ nrbw ` E h` l &fbp


`bol bk bi `^pl abrkd^p fab^i9pfkbj_^odl*klm^o^ilp d^pbp na]hao+?abjÄp*pf jb+
afjlp yg*gRbkbi`^plabilpd^pbpob^ibpv`lkl`bjlp*^pfjfpjl*prp`^m^`fa^abp qÅo+
jf`^p*mlabjlp^mif`^oi^b`r^`fÑk0,13m^o^`^i`ri^o&1F-1m'g,m^o^rkd^pob^i*nrb
bprk^`^kqfa^a&bi`^j_fÑabbkq^imf^`lkcloj bi^mobpfÑk`^j_f^*^rknrb^qbjmb+
o^qro^`lkpq^kqb' afcÇ`fil fjmlpf_ibabjbafomlobumbofjbkq^`fÑkafob`q^,

Bfailhk /+..
Qf bi `lbcf`fbkqb ab Hlrib+Relj plk m^o^ bi afÑufal ab `^o_lkl* A M g* bp .,4153
I-^qj*`^i`ribi^qbjmbo^qro^cfk^iabiafÑufalab`^o_lkl^0.^qjv/..áA*`r^k+
alpbibfjmrip^^qo^sÅpabrk^m^oba*e^pq^ ^i`^kw^ork^mobpfÑkab / ^qj,

Ojgp^dÅi
Bb^`rboal `lki^cÑojri^^molufj^a^abi `lbcf`fbkqbabHlrib+Reljplk8

%> QY
; N
Ckbpqbmol`bpl*?mbpfdr^i^ò /7^qj&bipfdklkbd^qfslpfdkfcf`^nrbi^mobpfÑkbp+
qÄ ^]f]j ` k .6^qj ',Nloq^kql*qbkbjlp nrb

?R
;  .,4153 I-^qj
* + / 7  ]pi G E 

Qfjriqfmif`^jlp ^j_lpjfbj_olp*l_qbkbjlp8

P   () *
il `r^ipfdkfcf`^nrbi^qbjmbo^qro^pbobar`b ab /..áA^Ç fáA,

Ci`lbcf`fbkqb ab Hlrib+Reljplkabilp d^pbp ob^ibps^oÇ^ `lki^qbjmbo^qro^vi^


mobpfÑk, J^ q^_i^ 0,0 ifpq^ ^idrklp s^ilobp ab ìVg+g+abqbojfk^alp bumbofjbkq^ijbkqb,
@^gl`fboq^p`lkaf`flkbp*bi`lbcf`fbkqbabHlrib+Relj plkbpkbd^qfsl*il`r^ipfdkfcf`^
0,5 Albcf`fbkqbp ab Hlrib+Reljplk 12

R ^_ i^ 0 ,0 A l b cf` fb k q a ilris R e l j pl k a b  afsboplp d^pbp &I-^qj '


l &^ qj ' R +  +/ 3 . áA ŪÜÜ  ` +3 . V . A 3 . óA iM M V /3.V 0..V
?fobpfk^dr^k fafÑufalab `^oÜlffl
.,3673 . ,17/. .+0523 . ,/ 7 3 4 .,/133 .,.74/ .,.423
0. ñ .+35.. .,147. . ,036. . ,/ 6 1 . . ,/ 0 36 .,.661 .,.36.
4. .,.23. .,260. . ,1/73 .,00.. .,/35/ . ,/.40 .,.510 .,.231
iMr .,./63 .,0553 %.,03.3 .,/60. . ,/ 1 / . . ,. 6 6 2 .,.4.. .,.121
/2. + . ,. . 5 . .,/14. .,/603 .,/23. .,/.5. . ,.504 .,.260 .,.03.
/6. + . ,. 0 3 3 .,.433 . */05. M,ifMM . ,. 6 0 7 . ,. 3 6 . .,.154 .,./52
0.. % +. ,. 1 1 ü . 8. 2 2 . .,/.43 .,/.7. . ,.7 3 . ñ ñ +

?odÑk
/ /,6/0 .,64.3 .,374. .,21.5 . ,100. . ,02/1 .,/623 .,/155
0. ñ .,6263 .150. .,2.6. .,1./3 . *0055 . ,/50. .,/06.
%4 . £
 + . ,. . 0 3 .,47.ü *. ,2 7 4 1 . ,1 4 .. ,*.,043. ,.,/753 .,/263 .,//.0
/.. % %+ %. ,. 0 5 5 Ü 8^ \ l . 175. .+1./. . ,0075 . ,û 5 G 3 .*/063 .,.73.
/2. + . ,. 2 . 1 . ,û H1 5 .,0Q2. .,03.o . ,/ 7 2 5 8 .+/27. %.,//01 .,.601
/6. % + . ,. 3 7 3  \ M,MHM M . ,0.15 .,0.3. .,/5.. . ,/10. . ,.776 .,.5/3
0.. + . ,. 4 2 . .,.173 .,/64. .,/661 .,/36. . ,/033 . ,.723 .,.453

B fÑufalab`^ o_ l k l  9
/ , £
 ñ £ 02/1. i  X7.. . ,673. . ,427. . ,2 6 7 . .,155.
0. + . ,. / 2 . f ,2.0. . ,673. . ,4153 .,2473 .,1353
4. ,,,,  , , +. ,. / 3 . .,.15. . ,66.. . ,4.6. . ,22 1 . .,12..
/.. , £ + . ,. / 4 . .,.0/3 . ,3 3 5 . . ,3 2 .3 .,2/33 .,1/3.
/2. * + S ,. û6 1 .,.//3 . ,/50. . ,2 1 0. . ,154. .,067.
f6 . ñ %.+.00@ .,..Q3 . ,/.03 . ,1 . .. .,1/.0 .,04..
0.. ñ ,,,, +. ,0 2 6 .,..23, . ,.71. . ,0 3 33 . ,07/. .,0233

L fqoÑdbkl
/ J 0437 .,427. .,1746 .,0434 .,/633 . ,/ 0 7 0 . ,.646 .,.336
£0 . + +,£/,/024 +£.,3736 £ . ,1512 .,0272 . ,/5.7 . ,/ / 5 1 . ,.554 .,.250
4. *.,.4./ .,23.4 .,1.37 .,0.66 . ,/227 . ,. 7 5 3 .,.406 .,.150
/.. . ,. 0 . 0 . ,0532 .,0110 .,/457 . ,//42 . ,.5 4 6 .,.260 .,.040
/2. * + . ,. . 3 4 .,/151 .,/454 .,/1/4 . ,.7/3 .,.360 . ,.126 .,./46
/6. + . ,. 0 / / .,.543 . ,/ / 0 . .,/./3 .,.510 .,.240 .,.026 .,..72
0.. + . ,. 0 6 2 . ,.365£
£ .,.7.4 .,.67/ .,.444 . ,.2 / 7 .,.006 .,..5.

Fbifl\
bb#Yle $ ,1+E -++E -/+E -3+E .-+E .1+E /++E //+E
: 0.S + . ,. 3 5 2  +. ,. 3 7 2  ++.,.4~ 6 + . ,. 4 / 7  + . ,. 4 0 7  + . ,. 4 1 5  + . ,. 4 2 1  + . ,. 4 2 3 
<  c f,N boovu B ,U ,&Gobbk*Mannu$o @ d ai e_] h Bj*[ ejaano$E ]j}^kkg)4^,ba,*Lrbs^Wloh*K `E o^t +F fii* /762,
óB b_ ^glab0 . ^ qj *s^oÇ^m l`l~ s^iloab m^o^biebifl &^pfj fpj l*l_pbosbnrbilpa^qlpabiebiflbpqÄkbkqbj +
mbo^qro^pIbisfk',

nrb`lkcloj bi^mobpfÑkafpjfkrvb*i^qbjmbo^qro^pb ahar]7 ìbid^p pb `^ifbkq^^ibu+


m^kafopb!?rk^qbjmbo^qro^jÄp_^g^*bi`lbcf`fbkqbabHlrib+Relj plkpbsrbisbml+
pfqfslv*bkqlk`bp*`lkclojbi^ mobpfÑk afpjfkrvb*i^qbjmbo^qro^ abi d^pq^j_fÅkil
e^`b, J^qbjmbo^qro^ ^i^nrb bi `lbcf`fbkqbabHlrib+Relj plkm^p^ ab rks^ilokb+
d^qfsl ^ rkl mlpfqfsl ob`f_b bi klj_ob ab pai lan]pqn] ` a ejranoeÇj+ N^o^ bkcof^o rk
d^pmlojbafl abijÅqlalabHlrib+Reljplk*^`grÅiab_bbk`lkqo^opbmloab_^glab
prqbjmbo^qro^abfksbopfÑk,
Cibcb`qlHlrib+Relj plkpb^mif`^m^o^if`r^od^pbp*v^nrbpbmrbabafpbÉ^orkpfp+
qbj^bkbinrbbid^ppb`ljmofj^vbum^ka^obmbqfa^jbkqb*obar`fbkalprqbjmbo^+
13 A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

qro^ il prcf`fbkqbm^o^ nrb pb `lkabkpb `lksfoqfÅkalpb bk iÇnrfal, Ci kfqoÑdbkl vbi
luÇdbkliÇnrfalpkloj^ijbkqbpbmobm^o^kabbp^j ^kbo^bk`^kqfa^abpfkarpqof^ibp,
Qfk bj_^odl*rkd^pab_bbpq^omloab_^glabpr qbjmbo^qro^ab fksbopfÑk`lkbicfk
abnrbbibcb`qlHlrib+Relj plkcrk`flkbbki^afob``fÑk`loob`q^abafpjfkr`fÑkab
Ç^ qbjmbo^qro^, Jlp d^pbp `lk qbjmbo^qro^p ab fksbopfÑk jrv_^g^p ab_bk bkcof^opb
^kqbp ab ^mif`^o abqbojfk^al qfml ab bum^kpfÑk ab Hlrib+Relj plk m^o^ if`r^oilp,
?kqbp ab nrbbpql pb`lkpfdrfbo^`lkc^`fifa^a*pb `obÇ^nrb ^idrklpd^pbp bo^kód^pbp
mboj ^kbkqbpòbksfoqra abnrbklmlaÇ^k if`r^opb mlo jbaflpóloafk^oflpò &af`elp
d^pbpcrbolkabp`ofqlpmlomofjbo^sbwmloKf`e^biD^o^a^vbk /623*v^nrbÅiklmr+
al if`r^oilp', |pqlp fk`irÇ^kefaoÑdbkl*luÇdbkl*kfqoÑdbkl*Ñufal kÇqof`l*jbq^klv
ilp mofj bolp `r^qol d^pbp kl_ibp, Ci kfqoÑdbkl v bi luÇdbkl pb if`r^olk cÄ`fijbkqb
^mif`^kalpl_obbiilp rk^bum^kpfÑk `Ç`if`^ab Hlrib+Relj plk*vmolkqlpfdrfÑi^if+
`rbc^``fÑk abilp lqolp d^pbp, Qfk bj_^odl* i^p qbjmbo^qro^p ab fksbopfÑk abi efaoÑ+
dbklvabiebiflplkq^k_^g^p&^molufj^a^jbkqb0.0Iv2.I*obpmb`qfs^jbkqb'nrb
qfbkbk nrb bkcof^opb `lkpfabo^_ibjbkqb ^kqbp ab nrb `r^inrfbo bum^kpfÑk ab Hlrib+
R elj plkilp bkcoÇbjÄp, ?i cfk bi cÇpf`l bp`lpÅpH^jbpBbt^oif`rÑ biefaoÑdbkl bk
/676*vbicÇpf`leli^kaÅpFbfhbI^jboifkde+Mkkbpilefwl `lkbiebiflbk /7.6 &vil
bjmibÑm^o^abp`r_ofoi^prmbo`lkar`qfsfa^a',

/+5 J|o ok^na `^m^`fa^abp p}nie_]o


Pb`loabjlpnrbebjlp abcfkfalalp afcbobkqbp`^m^`fa^abpqÅookf`^p*rk^obi^qfs^ ^i
`^j _fl bk rk pfpqbj^j^kqbkfal ^ slirjbk `lkpq^kqb vi^ lqo^m^o^ rk `^j_flbk
rk pfpqbj^ j^kqbkfal ^ mobpfÑk `lkpq^kqb, J^p fabkqfcf`^jlp `lki^p ibqo^p @uV @[+
íOrÅ obi^`fÑkbufpqbbkqobbii^p=
Aljbk`bj lp `lk rk^ b`r^`fÑk nrb cfk^ijbkqb afl `lj l obpriq^al i^ b`r^`fÑk
0,00, J^b`r^`fÑkfjmloq^kqbbp9

` Q ( ( l `S &0,14'
\ ;B3J S Y o r f Q

alkabl  obmobpbkq^ i^ mobpfÑk buqbok^, Fbjlp abcfkfal i^ abofs^a^ w` R h` Q &u @ ki k
@u)^pÇnrbmlabjlpobbp`of_foi^b`r^`fÑk abi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^9

G ;  "TB3
`S

F^pq^^elo^*klebjlpfjmrbpql`lkaf`flkbp^ipfpqbj^^iabar`foi^bumobpfÑk^kqb+
oflo*jÄpnrb bieb`elabnrb i^jrbpqo^`loobpmlkab^ rk d^p fab^i,?elo^fjmlk+
aobjlp i^ `lkaf`fÑk ^af`flk^i ab nrb i^ mobpfÑk pb j^kqbkaoÄ `lkpq^kqb, L^a^
`^j_f^ bksboa^a*v^ nrb bi`^j_flfkcfkfqbpfj^iab`^ilo `mpbbumobp^bkqÅojfklp
abrk `^j_flabqbjmbo^qro^* `Q) u rk `^j_flabslirjbk*`S+ Nloq^kql*mlabjlp
bp`of_foi^b`r^`fÑk ^kqbofmoabi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^9

GRF!!
`%fl @u `[Q c $^ ` S
LRGX Q
bk i^ nrb `m ^elo^ qfbkb bi pr_Çkaf`b N  Qf afsfafjlp ^j _lp jfbj_olp ab i^ b`r^+
`fÑk bkqob `Q)l_qbkbjlp8

B4; B5
;23 ;B3

M_pbosbnrbi^ abofs^a^` S F` Q qfbkbrk pr_Çkaf`bl ab_fal^krbpqo^bpmb`fcf`^`fÑk


abnrbi^mobpfÑkbp`lkpq^kqb,Llqbq^j_fÅknrbi^bumobpfÑk`lkpqfqrvbrk^abofs^+
a^l]n_e]h) bksfoqra abnrbi^p`^kqfa^abpabilpkrjbo^alobp abmbkabk abjr`e^p
0,6 K~p pl_ob `^m^`fa^abp qÄojf`^p 14

s^of^_ibp &lqo^p abofs^a^p q^j_fÅk pbe^k bumobp^al `ljl abofs^a^p m^o`f^ibp', Al+
j l `E : `ml)mlabjlpprpqfqrfobi j fbj_ol fwnrfboalab i^b`r^`fÑkm^o^l_qbkbo8

`E %`R $T
v 5e$
N
`Q 6SG X`Q f

CiqÅoj fkl&1ÇÇ-15.me^pfalabcfkfal`ljli^`^m^`fa^aqÅoj f`^^mobpfÑk`lkpq^kqb*


Am,?elo^ `lkq^jlp`lkrk^obi^`fÑkbkqob 5e;5^'

$%?RY [
"N  "W
$A &0,15'
öPSf

Qf bi pfpqbj^ bpqÄ cloj^al mlo rk d^p fab^i* i^ bumobpfÑk pb bs^iÖ^ afob`q^jbkqb, Ci
`^j_flbki^bofbodÇ^fkqbok^^qbjmbo^qro^`lkpq^kqbbpbu^`q^j bkqb`bol&Åpq^`lkp+
qfqrvb rk^ ab i^p `^o^`qboÇpqf`^p nrb abcfkbk rkd^p fab^i', Nlabjlp*^pfjfpjl*^mif+
`^oi^ibvabilpd^pbp fab^ibpm^o^abqbojfk^oi^abofs^a^ &7T-1R'm8

%` S Y neO
+`Qf A
Qfprpqfqrfjlp bpq^bumobpfÑkbki^b`r^`fÑk0,15* l_qbkbjlp8
j$O
Aú @ u ( % - ( lx ì

5^ v 5e$ \C


Ck bi`^pl ab`^kqfa^abpjli^obp* pbqfbkbnrb8
; O ) P &0,16'
m^o^rk d^p fab^i, |pqbbprkobpriq^aljrvpfjmibvÖqfi,
J^qbloÇ^`fkÅqf`^abilpd^pbp&nrbbpqraf^objlpbkrk`^mÇqrilmlpqboflo'molml+
kbbipfdrfbkqbobpriq^alm^o^bi`^plabrkd^pfab^ij lkl^qÑj f`l8

F
/0,25/ &0,17'
jli+I

Nloq^kql*ab^`rboal`lki^b`r^`fÑk 0,16*

A* ;  ;  0.,563ñ f ñ  &0,2.'


\ 0 j li+I

Jlp d^pbp `lj l bi ^odÑk* kbÑkvebifl mlpbbk `^m^`fa^abp qÅojf`^p ^ mobpfÑk `lkp+
q^kqb ab ^iobabalo 0.,6 H-jli+I* il `r^i kl plomobkab, Jlp d^pbp fkboqbp jÄpifdbolp
`lkpqfqrvbk_rbk^p^molufj^`flkbpabilpd^pbp fab^ibp,\
Jlp d^pbpfab^ibpmlpbbk rk^`^m^`fa^aqÅoj f`^nrbklabmbkababi^qbjmbo^qr+
o^9 m^o^ilpd^pbpob^ibpbpql klcffk`flk^^pÇ,J^j^vloÇ^abilp fkqbkqlpmlobumobp^o
i^`^m^`fa^aqÅoj f`^abilpd^pbpob^ibppbs^ibkabrk^pbofbabmlqbk`f^pbk`r^inrfb+
o^abi^p alp pfdrfbkqbpcloj^p8

@l: ] ( ^ Q ( _ Q [

@l : ] ( ^ Q ( y

alkab]) ^ u _ o k j `lkpq^kqbpabqbojfk^a^pbumbofjbkq^ijbkqb,Cibgbjmil0,/.*gr k +
ql`lki^b`r^`fÑk 0,1/*firpqo^i^cloj^^ab`r^a^ab abqbojfk^o`^j_flp bki^pcrk+
`flkbpab bpq^alrqfifw^kal`^m^`fa^abpqÅojf`^pabbpq^cloj^,

öJ^qbloÇ^`foqÑqf`^abilpd^pbpq^j_fÅkmobaf`bnrbm^o^i^pjliÅ`ri^paf^qÑjf`^pfab^ib\ljl+
iÅ`ri^pifkb^ibp* @u :  yfÇ9mlo`lkpfdrfbkqb*m^o^i^pjliÅ`ri^pklifkb^ibpfab^ibp*O  ç fO+ Am bp
uhO)obpmb`qfs^jbkqb&fk`irfjlpbpqb`^plm^o^firpqo^onrbi^qbojlafkÄjf`^klpÑilpbmrbab^mif+
`^o^ilpd^pbpjlkl^qÑjf`lp',
26 A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

Pb`loabjlpnrbbkbi`^plabrk mol`bpl^af^_Äqf`l*

` R : `s
v^nrbb!`^ilobpbu^`q^jbkqbfdr^i^`bol,Bbi^b`r^`fÑk0,0/*q^j_fÅkp^_bjlpnrb

$` RY
` R : @ q ` Q ( ñ G ` S : @u ` Q  m^o^rkd^pfab^i,
` Sf Q
Ck bpq^ bumobpfÑk* i^ fdr^ia^a cfk^i ob`lkl`b bi eb`el ab nrb i^ abofs^a^ m^o`f^i
%`R ,`S &f+bp fdr^i ^`bol bkbi`^pl ab rk d^p fab^i,Nloq^kql*bkrkmol`bpl^af^_Ä+
qf`lfkcfkfqbpfj^i*
` s : @u ` Q
Qffkqbdo^jlp^ili^odl ab qlalbimol`bpl ^af^_Äqf`l*
R*
@u`Q &0,2/'

Ck bi`^plabrk^`^m^`fa^aqÅoj f`^`lkpq^qb*


s : @r>Q &0,20'
N^o^`r^inrfbo`^kqfa^anrbklpb^fdr^i^ / jli*ab_bjlpbjmib^oi^`^m^`fa^aqÅo+
jf`^jli^o* Av9
t ;kO ? R &0,21'

Qf i^ `^m^`fa^a qÅojf`^ kl bp `lkpq^kqb ^ il i^odl abi fkqbos^il ab qbjmbo^qro^* i^
b`r^`fÑk0,2/ ab_b ^mif`^opb`lki^bumobpfÑk^ab`r^a^m^o^ @u _ k j bicfk`^i`ri^obi
qo^_^glabi `^j_fl,

Bfailhk /+./
Alkpfabob / jliabrkd^pfab^i^rk^mobpfÑkfkf`f^iab /,..^qjvrk^qbjmbo^qr+
o^fkf`f^iab051,/3I,Qrmlkd^jlpnrbÅpqbpbbum^kab^af^_Äqf`^jbkqb`lkqo^rk^
mobpfÑkab.,213^qje^pq^nrbprslirjbkpbarmif`^,A^i`ribbiqo^_^gl*i^qbjmb+
o^qro^cfk^ivbi? /-abimol`bpl,

Qlir`fÉk
Nofjbol ab_b abqbojfk^opbi^s^of^`fÑk abislirjbk bkbimol`bpl,?m^oqfo abi^p
`lkaf`flkbpfkf`f^ibp*mlabjlp`^i`ri^obislirjbkfkf`f^iv*mlpqboflojbkqb*prs^+
of^`fÑk8

& /, . .  ^qj'Tg ;  &/  jli' .,.60.3Ç f \ ' & 0 5 1 , / 3 I ' 


jli+I-
vì ;  00,2J
Qfbislirjbkpbarmif`^aro^kqbbimol`bpl*bislirjbkcfk^ibpab22,6Jvi^s^of^+
`fÑk abslirjbkbpab22,6J+ 00,2J; 00,2J,
Ciqo^_^glob^ifw^alpb`^i`ri^pbk`fii^jbkqbabi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^8

U ;  +Nbuq? v
%/ . / ,1 0
t ;  ñ&.,213^qj '&00,2 J' ;  + 7 6 5 H
J+^qj
Aljl n; M*?Ü ; t*bkqlk`bp

? &- ;  + 7 6 5 [
J^qbjmbo^qro^cfk^imrbab`^i`ri^opb`lkì^^vra^abi^b`r^`fÑk0,21*qlj^kalbk
`rbkq^ nrb bkrk d^p fab^ii^ `^m^`fa^a qÅoj f`^ ^ slirjbk `lkpq^kqb bp abyP* l
/0,25H-jli+I, Nloq^kql*
0,6 K~p pl_ob `^m^`fa^abp qÄojf`^p 16

+ 7 6 5 H ;  &/ >Q

-ZR;+57,/I

Qfi^qbjmbo^qro^fkf`f^ibpab051,/3I*i^qbjmbo^qro^cfk^ibpab^molufj^a^jbk+
qb /72I,

Ck rk mol`bpl ^af^_Äqf`l* i^ `^kqfa^a fkcfkfqbpfj^i ab qo^_^gl bcb`qr^a^ ^elo^
mrbababqbojfk^opb^m^oqfoabalpbumobpflkbp9

`s ;  `S

`s  ;  î O *` Q
Qfi^pfdr^i^jlp* l_qbkbjlp8

D<.L1VD:

Qfbimol`bpl ^af^_Äqf`lbpobsbopf_ib*bkqlk`bp ;mìú&*vmlabjlp^mif`^o i^ ibvab


ilp d^pbp fab^ibp m^o^ prpqfqrfomìúqbk qÅoj fklp ab i^p abjÄp s^of^_ibpab bpq^al,?pÇ*
qbkbjlpnrb8

jO4ó mo
d D < ;  L 1V D :

Qfm^p^jlpi^ps^of^_ibpabqbjmbo^qro^^ij fbj _ol abob`el* bk`lkqo^jlpnrb

J^ s^of^_ib jpb e^`^k`bi^al, Nlabjlpfkqbdo^o ^j _lp jfbj_olp abi^b`r^`fÑk v*


prmlkfbkal nrb @u bp `lkpq^kqb aro^kqb bi `^j _fl* l_qbkbjlp &`lkpfabo^kal nrb
ê . ,t au;  Gkt&7

+ H = i k D y \ %;  O  G k R i Ç %
Bb ^`rboal `lki^p molmfba^abp ab ilpild^ofqjlpvbs^ir^kal `^a^ fkqbdo^i abkqol
ab prpiÇjfqbp*l_qbkbjlpbipfdrfbkqbobpriq^al m^o^ bi`^pl abrkmol`bpl^af^_Äqf+
`lobsbopf_ib9

+f\ ik \ ; O ik y c &0,22'
Tg Qê
Bb krbsl* ob`qfoofbkal ^ i^p molmfba^abp ab ilp ild^ofqjlp* mlabjlp if_o^oklp abi
pfdklkbd^qfslfkqolar`fbkali^bumobpfÑk ob`Çmol`^bkbiild^ofqjl8
Q' ? M%
P ik \ ; O  Gk\
R ) dê

Qfqlj ^j lp bk`rbkq^nrb Am ;  @u( O) obloabk^jlpbpq^bumobpfÑkbk @l ì @u : 


Ovprpqfqrfjlp*
X ? Q' ? +/
%@l ì @u& Fjy  :  @u Gkñ

Qf^elo^afsfafjlpbkqob @u)l_qbkbjlp9

J^bumobpfÑk @l,Avkloj^ijbkqbpbabcfkb`lj lu 7

u &0,23'
2- A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv a b i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

Nlabj lpobloabk^oi^b`r^`fÑknrbobi^`flk^ilpsliÖjbkbpvi^pqbjmbo^qro^p^kqb+
oflobpm^o^l_qbkbo8

, + /  ]  Qe
&0,24'

*i^y bkbi`^pl

%S *7 v-1 Qb
&0,25'
YSb+& Qê
m^o^ rk `^j_fl ^af^_Äqf`l obsbopf_ib ab rk d^p fab^i jlkl^qÑjf`l, Qf obmbqfjlp bi
mol`bafj fbkqlbk qÅojfklpab i^mobpfÑk bkird^oabislirjbk*qbkaobjlp nrb8

55 &0,26'
>8\ :H
Qfi^pb`r^`flkbp0,25v0,26pb`lj_fk^o^k ^idb_o^f`^jbkqb*pbabar`b8

N HS P . N + S P f &0,27'

nrb `lkpqfqrvbrk `^pl bpmb`f^iab i^ibvab @lvibm^o^ilpd^pbpfab^ibp bkrkmol`b+


pl ^af^_Äqf`lvobsbopf_ib,Ll l_pq^kqb*bkbpqb `^plkl pbe^prmrbpql nrb i^qbjmb+
o^qro^pbj^kqrsl `lkpq^kqb,

Bfailhk /+
C k rk`^j_fl^af^_Äqf`lobsbopf_ibbk / jliabrkd^pj lkl^qÑj f`lfkboqb*i^mob+
pfÑks^oÇ^ab0,22^qj^ .,116 ^qj,Qfi^qbjmbo^qro^fkf`f^ibp ab 117I*í`rÄibpi^
qbj mbo^qro^cfk^i=

Ojgp^dÅi
B b^`rboal `lki^b`r^`fÑk0,26*
-O,116^qj \ ò Q)
*0,2 2 ^qj 0 06H
Qf obplisbjlpi^b`r^`fÑk*l_qbkbjlp8
Rc;/32I

! & A^j_flp abc^pb


F^pq^^nrÇ*ebjlp`lkpfabo^alpÑil`^j _flpcÇpf`lpabpfpqbj^pd^pblplp, Llebjlp
^_loa^al ^Ök ilp `^j_flp ab c^pb kf ilp `^j_flp nrÇjf`lp, ?elo^ ^mif`^objlp i^p
fab^p^k^ifw^a^pm^o^af`e^ `i^pbabmol`bplp*`ljbkw^kal `lkilp`^j_flpab c^pb,
Cki^j^vloÇ^abilp `^plp*ilp`^j_flpab c^pb &pÑifal iÇnrfal*iÇnrfal \  d^p*
pÑifal \  d^p' l`roobk_^gl`lkaf`flkbpbumbofjbkq^ibpabmobpfÑk`lkpq^kqb*abj l+
alnrbbi`^ilodbkbo^al* m)q^j_fÅkbpfdr^i^?F,\Nlobgbjmil*m^o^aboobqfobiefb+
il bkprmrkql kloj^iab crpfÑk ab.áA8

F 0M &p*. áA '++++++ <F 0M  &õ*M+A'

pbobnrfbobabqbojfk^a^`^kqfa^aab`^ilomlodo^jllj lim^o^`^j_f^oabc^pb,Qfk
bj_^odl*aro^kqbbi`^j_flabc^pbi^qbjmbo^qro^kls^oÇ^,

ôôAm vAsmlpbbkafpqfkqlps^ilobpm ^ o^ ilp d^pbpm l if^ qÑ j f` l pfab^ibp9^pÇ*5 q^j _ fÅk m lpbbrks^+


il o a fcbobk qb bkaf`e lp`^plp,? nrÇ k l ^ _ l oa ^obj l p j Äpbpqbqbj ^,
ö J l p `^j _ fl pabmobpfÑk  q^ j _ fÅk  m rbabk  m olsl`^o ` ^ j _ fl p ab c^pb, Cpqbcbk Ñ j bk l il  bpqr af^+
ob j l pbk bi `^m Çqr il 4 ,
0,7 A^j_flp ab c^pb 3/

? .áA*biF gM mrbabbufpqfov^`lj lpÑifall`lj liÇnrfal,Cksfoqraabnrbkle^v


?R*i^b`r^`fÑk 0,7 kl pb^mif`^^ bpqb `^pl, KÄp_fbk*i^`^kqfa^aab`^ilodbkbo^a^
bpmolmlo`flk^i^i^ `^kqfa^a abj^qbof^, J^`lkpq^kqbab molmlo`flk^ifa^apbii^j^
_]hkn` abqoeÇj) ab q^icloj^nrbqbkbjlp rk^b`r^`fÑkjÄppfjmib8

l : h *  ; Y )'^z #- )0 + $

J^m^i^_o^-qÇ3 . KbppfkÑkfjlabóaboobqfjfbkqlò,Qfi^`^kqfa^a jpbbumobp^bkdo^+


jlp*?cúgFqfbkbrkfa^abpabH-d,Qfi^`^kqfa^aabj ^qbof^&lprpq^k`f^'pbbumobp^bk
jlibp*i^b`r^`fÑk0,3.pbbp`of_bjÄp^ab`r^a^jbkqbabi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^8

8  àÅ ; ^èB  #- )0 , $

v>+w[E`lkpqfqrvbrk^`^kqfa^ajli^o`lkrkfa^abpabH-jlG,Aljlbi`lkdbi^jfbk+
qlvbiaboobqfjfbkqlplkmol`bplplmrbpqlp*i^pb`r^`flkbp0,3.v0,3/ plksÄifa^pm^+
o^ ^j_lp, Ci mol`bpl jfpjl fkaf`^ pf bp jÄp ^ab`r^al qlj^oil `ljl ab qfml
bulqÅoj f`l l bkalqÅojf`l,Ckbi `^pl abi^ crpfÑk &l  aboobqfjfbkql'*ab_bfkqolar+
`fopb`^ilobkbipfpqbj^*abcloj^nrbbimol`bpl bpbkalqÅoj f`lvbis^iloab ? cÇbk
bimol`bpl bpmlpfqfsl,Ckbi`^pl ab i^`lkdbi^`fÑk*pbab_bbuqo^bo`^iloabipfpqbj^9
^pÇ*bimol`bplbp bulqÅojf`lubis^iloab > E bpkbd^qfsl,

ailhk /+.1
Ci`^iloab crpfÑk? gúF m^o^bi^dr^bpab 112H-d,
^' íArÄkql`^ilopbobnrfbobm^o^aboobqfo37,3dabefbil&^molufj^a^jbkqbrk`r+
_ldo^kab abefbil'=
_' íArÄibpbis^iloab ? F bkbpqbmol`bpl=

Qlir`fÉk
^' Bb^`rboal `lki^b`r^`fÑk0,3.*

m ;  &37,3d'&112H-d'

m :  /,77 V /.óH

_' Alj l ab_b fkqolar`fopb`^ilo ^ipfpqbj^ `lk bi cfk ab m^p^oabi bpq^al pÑifal ^i
iÇnrfal* bi ? F bk bpqbmol`bplab_boÇ^ obcibg^obieb`el ab nrb bp ab k^qro^ibw^bk+
alqÅojf`^, Nloq^kql*? F ; /,77 V iM (',

Jlp`^j _flpabslirjbk`r^kalpbm^p^ abibpq^alpÑifal^iiÇnrfal*labiiÇnrfal


^ipÑifal*kloj^ijbkqbplkfkpfdkfcf`^kqbp9^pÇnrb? F {  ?F&bi^dr^`lkpqfqrvbrk^
bu`bm`fÑk mlo o^wlkbp l_sf^p* mrbp pb bum^kab ^molufj^a^jbkqb / . # `r^kal pb
`lkdbi^', Nlolqo^m^oqb*i^s^of^`fÑk abslirjbk ^im^p^oab rk bpq^aliÇnrfal ^ rk
bpq^ald^pblpl &l abpÑifal ^d^p' bp`lkpfabo^_ib8

F gM  &õ, / . . áA '++++++< F 0M &d* /..áA'

?im^p^oabiÇnrfal^d^p*bimol`bplob`f_bbiklj _obab r]lknev]_eÇj)abkrbsli^qbj +


mbo^qro^mboj^kb`b`lkpq^kqbjfbkqo^ppbmobpbkq^bi`^j _flabc^pb*vi^`^kqfa^aab
`^ilokb`bp^of^bpkrbs^jbkqbmolmlo`flk^i^i^`^kqfa^aabj^qbof^,?elo^* i^`lkp+
q^kqbabmolmlo`flk^ifa^apbabkljfk^ _khkn`ar]lknev]_eÇj)?úgmF*mboli^cloj^ab
i^b`r^`fÑkm^o^`^i`ri^obi`^ilonrbpbobnrfbobbppbjbg^kqb^i^b`r^`fÑk0,3.9

n ;  j ä ?úmF m^o^`^kqfa^abpbkdo^jlp &0,30'

l ^i^b`r^`fÑk0,3/8

m :  j *  ?úmF m^o^`^kqfa^abpbkjlibp &0,31'


30 A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

Ci`^ilo^pl`f^al`lkbimol`bplfksbopl*ii^j^al_kj`ajo]_eÇj)q^j_fÅkpbmrbab`^i+
`ri^o`lki^^vra^ abi^pb`r^`flkbp 0,30v0,31 qlj^kal bk`rbkq^bi eb`el ab nrb
abkrbslqbkaobjlpnrb`lkpfabo^oi^afob``fÑkabicirglabi`^ilo, Ar^kal pbabqbo+
jfk^biqo^_^gl ob^ifw^albkrkmol`bpl abs^mlofw^`fÑkl pr_ifj^`fÑk*bpcob`rbkqb
fdklo^obislirjbkabi^c^pb`lkabkp^a^*nrbkloj^ijbkqbbpfkpfdkfcf`^kqb`lj m^+
o^al `lkbiabi^c^pbd^pblp^, Cipfdrfbkqbbgbjmililfirpqo^,

Bfailhk /+.2
A^i`rib m) s) > E u?A-m^o^ i^s^mlofw^`fÑk ab / d ab FgM ^ /..áAv /,.. ^qj ab
mobpfÑk,Ci? úmÇcabiF gM bpab004.H-d,Qrmlkd^rk`ljmloq^jfbkqlabd^pfab^i,
J^abkpfa^aabiF 0M ^ /..áAbpab.,7366d-`jö ,

Qlir`fÉk
Bb^`rboal`lki^b`r^`fÑk0,30*bi`^ilov> E bkbimol`bplpb`^i`ri^afob`q^jbkqb8

n ;  &/ d'&004.H-d' ;  004. H bkbipfpqbj^

m :  > E  :  ) 004.H
N^o^`^i`ri^obiqo^_^gl*kb`bpfq^jlpi^s^of^`fÑkabslirjbkbki^s^mlofw^`fÑk,Ck
bimol`bpl F gM  &õ' +< F gM  &d'*i^s^of^`fÑk abslirjbkbp8
? s;
Bb^`rboal`lki^ibvabilpd^pbpfab^ibp*`^i`ri^jlpbislirjbkabis^mloab ^dr^
^ /..óA; 151 I9(
&.,.333 j li'&.,.60.3Q ' & 1 5 1  I'
/ ,. .  ^qj

Ci slirjbk abi F gM  bk bpq^al iÇnrfal ^ /..áA bp ab /,.21 `j\ l .,../.21 J, Nlo
q^kql*
> S :  Td** +  Tìì* ;  /,5.J +  .,../.21 J ;  /*5.J ;
Ckbpqbm^pl*abjlpqo^jlpnrbbislirjbkabiiÇnrfal bpfkpfdkfcf`^kqb`ljm^o^al
`lkbislirjbkabid^pv*mloq^kql* `lkpqfqrvbrk^_rbk^^molufj^`fÑk > S :
N^o^`^i`ri^obiqo^_^gl abi^s^mlofw^`fÑk8

T ;  +mbuq?T
R^_ i^ 0 ,1  v m ^ o^ afsbop^p
prpq^k`f^p &H-d'
-/./,10 HZ
t ;  { & /,.. ^qj'&/,5. J'
K ^ qbof^ i ?s^mF Z/ J+^qj-
?G 171,1 / . *6 6 4 s :  +/ 5 0 H
? GN 1 /*.5. W^nrb > R :  m (  s)
AM* /6.,5 351,2
&pr_ifj ^' ? G 5 ;  0 0 4 . H /50H
04,6 61,0
\0
> R :  0.66H
?r 42,. /*5/.
EĎĊ 111,3 0*04. Cpqb bp rk bgbjmil bk bi nrb bi `^j _fl bk i^ bkq^imf^ kl bp fdr^i ^i `^j_fl bk i^
Db 042,2 4*07/ bkbodÇ^fkqbok^,
L^Ai 3/4,5 0*670
O F 3MF *
bq^kli /66*77 616,1 J^q^_i^0,1`lkqfbkb^idrklps^ilobpab>X[)[Ev>ôlE m^o^afsbop^pprpq^k`f^p,Jlp
OF d*_bk`bkl /05,2. 171,6 s^ilobpm^o^ v?úmFfkaf`^k`rÄkq^bkbodÇ^pbobnrfbobm^o^`^j_f^oabc^pb*v
O F ga*ebu^kl /3/,53 113,3 mlobpqlpbobi^`flk^k`lki^crbow^abi^pfkqbo^``flkbpfkqbo^qÑjf`^plfkqboj lib`r+

( YL , abi P,R,[ Qb qo^ q^ ab / dab^dr^*m l o bpql bi obpriq^albp ab . ,. 3 3 3  j li,
0,/. A^j_flp nrÅjf`lp 20

i^obpab ilp j^qbof^ibp, Nlobgbjmil* bi ^dr^ qfbkb rk `^iloabs^mlofw^`fÑk fkrpr^i+
jbkqbdo^kabm^o^rk^jliÅ`ri^q^kmbnrbÉ^*ab_fal^icrboqbbki^`babilpmrbkqbp
abefaoÑdbklbkqobi^pjliÅ`ri^pabi^dr^,Qbkb`bpfq^jr`e^bkbodÇ^m^o^pbm^o^oi^p
jliÅ`ri^pfkafsfar^ibpab^dr^ &nrbbpjÄpljbklpilnrb pr`babaro^kqbbimol`b+
plabs^mlofw^`fÑk'*vbibibs^al`^iloabs^mlofw^`fÑk obcibg^bpqbeb`el,

0,/å à^kofû1ûåp nrÇj f`lp


Ar^kall`roobrk^ob^``fÑknrÇjf`^*i^p fabkqfa^abpnrÇjf`^pabipfpqbj^`^j_f^k,
?rknrbi^j^vloÇ^ab i^pb`r^`flkbpvabcfkf`flkbpnrbebjlp ^k^ifw^al e^pq^^el+
o^ qla^sÇ^ pb mrbabk ^mif`^o afob`q^jbkqb* kb`bpfq^jlp ^jmif^o i^ ^mif`^_fifa^a ab
? Ç-v? F ,
Bb_bjlpbkqbkabonrbqla^pi^pprpq^k`f^p nrÇjf`^pmlpbbkrk^bkbodÇ^qlq^ifk +
qbok^vbkq^imf^,Ar^kal l`roobrk`^j _fl nrÇjf`l*bi`^j_fl bki^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^
l bkq^imf^nrbil ^`ljm^É^ bp fdr^i ^ i^ bkq^imf^qlq^i bki^p `lkaf`flkbp cfk^ibp*ilp
molar`qlp*jbklpi^bkq^imf^qlq^ibki^p `lkaf`flkbpfkf`f^ibp*ilp ob^`q^kqbp &lob^`+
qfslp',Cpab`fonrb*

\ ou k +c\  +\ m ola r `qlp +\ob^`q^kqbp

Pbmobpbkq^jlp`lk?\\Fbi`^j_flbki^bkq^imf^abi^ob^``fÑknrÇjf`^, ?g*ìúA-bpbi
bnrfs^ibkqb m^o^i^ bkbodÇ^ fkqbok^, J^ cfdro^ 0,// firpqo^ bpq^fab^, Ck `^a^ doÄcf`^*
rk^iÇkb^ obmobpbkq^i^bkq^imf^ qlq^iab ilpmolar`qlp9i^ lqo^bpi^ bkq^imf^qlq^i ab
ilp ob^`q^kqbp, J^ afcbobk`f^ bkqobi^p iÇkb^pobmobpbkq^ bi`^j_fl bki^bkq^imf^ ab i^
ob^``fÑk*?*ú*F,Ckrk`^pl*cfdro^0,//^*i^`^kqfa^aabbkq^imf^bkbipfpqbj^afpj f+
krvb*bpab`fonrbbipfpqbj^`babbkbodÇ^^ilp^iobabalobp,Cpqbbprkbgbjmilabm ol+
`bpl bulqÅojf`l, Ck bi lqol `^pl* cfdro^ /+..^) i^ `^kqfa^a ab bkq^imf^ bk bi pfpqbj^
^rjbkq^, Cpql pfdkfcf`^ nrb bi pfpqbj^ ^_plo_b bkbodÇ^9 mlo q^kql* bp rk bgbjmil ab
mol`bpl bkalqÅojf`l,
Ci `^j_fl ab bkbodÇ^ab rk mol`bpl nrÇjf`l abmbkab ab i^p `lkaf`flkbp ab Åpqb*
`lj li^qbjmbo^qro^vi^mobpfÑk,J^`lkaf`fÑkbpqÄka^oabmobpfÑk bpab / _^o &nrb
bp`^pffdr^i^ / ^qj*^pfnrbi^rqfifw^`fÑkab / ^qj`ljl`lkaf`fÑkbpqÄka^oabmob+
pfÑk kl `^rp^ jr`el boolo', Ll bufpqb rk^ qbjmbo^qro^ bpqÄka^o abcfkfa^* ^rknrb
jr`e^p jbafa^p qbojlafkÄjf`^p pb e^`bk ^ 03áA, N^o^ fkaf`^o nrb rk `^j_fl ab

Aio\gkd\ojo\g_`gjn Aio\gkd\ojo\g_`gjn
m`\^o\io`n kmj_p^ojn

Aio\gkd\ojo\g_`êjn Aio\gkd\ojo\g_`gjn
kmj_p^ojn m`\^o\io`n

&^' &_ '

D fd v o ^  0 ,/ /  Gkqbomobq^`fÑkdoÄcf`^abibkrk`f^al8óbk rkmol`bplnrÇjf`l* bp i^afcbobk`f^ bk +


qob i^p bkq^imf^p qlq^ibpabilp molar`qlp*j bklpi^p bkq^imf^p qlq^ibp abflp ob^`q^kqbpò ]& Pb^``fÑk bul +
qÅoj f`^*v^ nrb i^ bkbodÇ^ qlq^i abi pfpqbj^ `^b &il `r^i pfdkfcf`^ nrb i^ bkbodÇ^ bp`bafa^'* ^&  Pb^``fÑk
bkalqÅoj f`^*v^nrbi^bkbodÇ^qlq^i abipfpqbj^ pr_b &il `r^ipfdkfcf`^nrbi^bkbodÇ^fkdobp^^i pfpqbj^',
,+ A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

bkbodÇ^ fjmif`^ `lkaf`flkbp bpqÄka^o* pb ^É^ab ^i pÇj_lil rk prmboÇkaf`b ?pÇ*e^+
_i^j lpab bq`,Nloildbkbo^i*i^pqbjmbo^qro^pq^j_fÅkpbbpmb`fcf`^k,
?rknrbebjlpabcfkfal m^o^ rk mol`bpl nrÇjf`l*ilps^ilobp ab ?\\k\Çkl
pbabqbojfk^kbs^ir^kali^afcbobk`f^E b *  Cpqlpb ab_b ^nrbilps^ilobp^_plir+
qlpm^o^i^bkq^imf^kl mrbabk `^i`ri^opb,QÑil bpmlpf_ib jbafoilp s^ilobp obi^qfslp*
ilp_]i ^ ekobki^bkq^imf^,Jlnrbkb`bpfq^j lpbprk`lkgrkqlabob^``flkbpnrÇjf`^p
`rvlps^ilobp?*uúFpfos^kab m^qoÑkm^o^j bafoilp abjÄps^ilobp ab ?gú*F,
CijÅqlalm^o^abqbojfk^o? *\ F bkrkmol`bplnrÇjf`lpb_^p^bki^pfab^pabinrÇ+
j f`l Eboj^fkFbkofFbpp&/6.0+/63.'*nrfbkk^`fÑbkQrfw^*mbolm^pÑi^j^vlom^o+
qbabprsfa^bkPrpf^,?Fbpp pbibmrbab`lkpfabo^obicrka^aloabi^pr_bpmb`f^ifa^a
abi^qbojlafkÄjf`^abkljfk^a^ pani kmq Äi g]+|ibpqrafÑilp`^j_flpabbkbodÇ^&bk
qÅoj fklpab`^ilomofk`fm^ijbkqb'abi^pob^``flkbpnrÇjf`^p,Dfk^ijbkqb*pbafl`rbk+
q^ `grb e^vs^of^p fab^p cfqka^jbkq^ibp m^o^ bi bpqrafl ab ilp `^j_flp ab bkbodÇ^ nrb
^`ljm^É^k^i^pob^``flkbpnrÇjf`^p, Cumobp^albkrkibkdr^gbjlabokl &FbppsfsfÑ
^kqbpabnrbpb`lkplifa^o^bi`^jmlabi^qbojlafkÄjf`^'*bpq^pfab^pplk8

ä A^j_flp nrÇjf`lp bpmb`Çcf`lp bpqÄk ^`ljm^É^alpmlo`^j_flp `^o^`qboÇpqf`lp


abbkbodÇ^,
ä Qbmrbabkfab^o krbslp `^j_flp nrÇjf`lp`lj_fk^kal `^j_flpnrÇjf`lp `l+
kl`falp,Cpqlpb e^`b ^idb_o^f`^jbkqb,
ä C i`^j_flabbkbodÇ^^pl`f^al^rk^ob^``fÑknrÇjf`^`lj_fk^a^bpi^`lj _f+
k^`fÑk^idb_o^f`^bnrfs^ibkqbabilp `^j _flpabbkbodÇ^ abi^p na]__ekj ao nrÇ+
j f`^pnrbpb`lj_fk^olk,

J^pfab^p^kqboflobp ob`f_bkbk`lkgrkql biklj_obab g u `aEaoou`lkpqfqrvbk bi


crka^j bkql abi^qbojlafkÄjf`^bk `r^kql pr^mif`^`fÑk^i^pob^``flkbp nrÇjf`^p,
Nrbpql nrb bpq^jlpqo^q^kal ^idb_o^f`^jbkqb i^p b`r^`flkbp nrÇjf`^p* kb`bpfq^jlp
qbkbobk`rbkq^i^ppfdrfbkqbpalpfab^p`r^kal`lj_fkbjlpprp`^j_flpab bkbodÇ^
^idb_o^f`^jbkqb,

ä Ar^kalrk^ob^``fÑkpbfksfboqb*bi`^j _fl abbkbodÇ^abi^ob^``fÑk`^j_f^ab


pfdkl,Cpql bp`lj l`lkpb`rbk`f^ab nrbi^bkq^imf^bprk^crk`fÑkab bpq^al,
ä Ar^kalpb`lkpfabo^kilpjÖiqfmilpabrk^ob^``fÑk*pb ab_bk rqfifw^oilp jfp+
j lpjÖiqfmilpabi`^j_fl abbkbodÇ^, Cpqlpbobcfbobq^kql^jÖiqfmilpco^``fl+
k^oflp `ljl ^ jÖiqfmilp bkqbolp, Cpqb eb`el pb ab_b ^ nrb i^ bkq^imf^ bp rk^
molmfba^abuqbkpfs^,

J^ibvabFbppfjmif`^nrb mlabjlpj bafoilp`^j_flpabbkbodÇ^bkob^``flkbpv


`lj_fk^oilpabi^cloj^nrbjÄpklp `lksbkd^*^pÇ `ljl bieb`elab nrbi^bkbodÇ^
bk i^ ob^``fÑk qlq^i bp pbk`fii^jbkqb rk^ prj^ ^idb_o^f`^ ab i^p bkbodÇ^p `lkl`fa^p,
Jlp `^j_flp ab bkbodÇ^ jbafalp bk ob^``flkbp nrÇjf`^p mrbabk q^_ri^opb9 ^pÇ* m^o^
`lj _fk^o^ab`r^a^jbkqbi^pob^``flkbpnrÇjf`^p*pÑilkb`bpfq^jlp`lkpriq^oi^p q^+
_i^pviibs^o^`^_lilp`Äi`rilp^idb_o^f`lpmboqfkbkqbp,J^ibvabFbpp`lkpqfqrvbrk^
`lkpb`rbk`f^afob`q^abieb`el abnrbi^bkq^imf^bp rk^bq j _eÇj  abbpq^al,
?elo^*i^mobdrkq^bp8 ínrÅob^``flkbpab_boÇ^kq^_ri^opb=Cufpqbrk^`^kqfa^afk^+
dlq^_ibabmlpf_ibpob^``flkbpnrÇjf`^p*íBb_bjlpq^_ri^oilp`^j_flpabbkbodÇ^ab
qla^p bii^plpÑililp abrk`lkgrkql pbib`ql=W*í`rÄibp=
Cp kb`bp^ofl q^_ri^o ilp `^j_flp ab bkq^imf^ pÑil rk^ `i^pb ab ob^``fÑk nrÇjf`^
&^rknrbbpcob`rbkqbsboq^_i^p ab `^j_flp abbkq^imf^ab lqo^pob^``flkbp*`ljli^p
ab`lj_rpqfÑk'*Sk^na]__eÇj` abkni ] _eÇ j bp`r^inrfboob^``fÑknrbdbkbo^ / j liab
rk molar`ql rqfifw^kal `ljl ob^`q^kqbp ilp bibjbkqlp nrb cloj^k bi molar`ql bk
prpobpmb`qfslpbpq^alpbpqÄka^o*( CipÇj_lil>êEobmobpbkq^bi`^j_flabbkq^imf^ab

%%Ci bpq^al bpqÄka^o ab r k  bibj bk ql bpÇ^ pr pq^ k `f^ m r o^ ^ / _^o &^kqbp* G ^ qj '*vpfbp kb`bp^ofl*
pb b pm b`fcf`^  f^ cloj ^ ^il qoÑ m f`^ , ? rknrb k l  bufpqb rk ^ qbj m bo^qr o^ bpqÄka^o bpm b`Çcf`^* j r`e ^p
l_o^p ab `lkpriq^bj mib^k  0 3 ,. áA  `l j l  i^ qb j m bo^ qr o^ abpfdk^a^,
0,/. A^j_flp nrÅjf`lp ,,

^cloj ^`fÑkabrk^ob^``fÑk*abkljfk^a^aj p]hl e]` ab kni ] _eÇ j l&bkqÅojfklpjb+


klpofdrolplp' _]hkn`abkni ]_eÇj + Aljl bgbjmil*

GL 0 &d ' ) M ^  & d ' ++++++ <L . 0  &d'

bpi^ob^``fÑkabcloj ^`fÑkabiLM 0, Aljl `lkqo^bgbjmil*

0 LM 0 &d' ) GM 0 & d ' ++++++ < L ? & d '

jkbpi^ob^``fÑkabcloj ^`fÑkabiL 0M 3*v^nrbilpob^`qfslpklplkilpbibjbkqlpnrb


`ljmlkbk biL0M 3, Alkbicfk abq^_ri^oilp*i^ j^vloÇ^abilps^ilobp ab>êEpbj f+
abk`lkobpmb`ql^ibpq^albpqÄka^oabilpob^`qfslp9^pÇ*af`elps^ilobpmloildbkbo^i
pbfkaf`^k`ljl ^ ?cFó &áfkaf`^ bibpq^albpqÄka^o',

Bfailhk /+.3
Bbqboj fkb pf i^p pfdrfbkqbpob^``flkbp `lkpqfqrvbk ob^``flkbp ab cloj^`fÑk9 ab kl
pbo^pÇ*pbÉ^ibi^o^wÑk,Qrmlkd^nrbi^pob^``flkbpl`roobkbk`lkaf`flkbpbpqÄka^o,
^' F 0 &d' ) \ .0  &d' \ F 0M &M
_' A^ &p' ) 0 A/&d' A^Aig &p'
`' 0 Db &p' ) 16 &olj_lfab' )2 . *  &d' Db 0&Q . 2 ' 1  &p'
a' 4 A &p' )  4 F 0 &d' ) 1 M 0 &d' AdFfgMp &p' &dir`lp^'

Qlir`fÉk
^' QÇ*pbqo^q^abi^ ob^``fÑkabcloj ^`fÑkabi ^dr^bkbpq^aliÇnrfal,
_' Ll* i^ócloj^bpqÄka^oò abi`ilol bp rk^jliÅ`ri^ af^qÑjf`^*
`' Ll* i^ócloj^bpqÄka^oòabiluÇdbkl `lj l bibjbkql bpi^jliÅ`ri^af^qÑjf`^,Ci
M 1 bki^cÑojri^bpbilwlkl &rk^cloj ^^ilqoÑmf`^',
a' QÇ*pbqo^q^abi^ob^``fÑkabcloj ^`fÑkabi^dir`lp^,

Llqbnrb*mloabcfkf`fÑk*i^bkq^imf^abcloj ^`fÑkabilpbibjbkqlpbkprpbpq^alp
bpqÄka^obpbu^`q^jbkqbfdr^i^`bol, Cpql pb ab_b ^nrb*pfkfjmloq^o`rÄibp pb^ki^p
bkq^imf^p^_plirq^pabimolar`qlvabiob^`qfsl*prs^ilobpbijfpjl,?pÇ*bi`^j_flbk
i^bkq^imf^abi^ob^``fÑkbp`bol, Nlobgbjmil*

@o 0 & õ ' ++++++ < @ o 0 & Ç '

bpi^ob^``fÑkabcloj ^`fÑkabi_olj lbibjbkq^i,W^nrbkle^v`^j_flabfabkqfa^a


nrÇjf`^ aro^kqb i^ ob^``fÑk* bi `^j_fl ab bkq^imf^ bp `bol v ab`fjlp nrb ?cFá ; M
m^o^bi_olj lbibjbkq^i, Jljfpjlpr`bab bk bi `^pl abqlalpilpbibjbkqlp bkprp
bpq^alpbpqÄka^o,
J^ o^wÑk ab nrb klp `lk`bkqobjlp bk i^p ob^``flkbp ab cloj^`fÑk bp ^ `^rp^ ab
nrbplk ilp `^j_flpab bkq^imf^bk i^p ob^``flkbp ab cloj^`fÑkilpnrb pbq^_ri^kv
pbrqfifw^km^o^abqbojfk^oilp`^j_flpabbkq^imf^abmol`bplpnrÇjf`lp,Cpqlpbab+
_b^nrb`r^inrfboob^``fÑknrÇjf`^mrbabbumobp^opb`ljli^`lj_fk^`fÑk^idb_o^f+
`^ab ob^``flkbp ab cloj^`fÑk, Nloq^kql*i^ibvab Fbpp af`q^ i^ cloj^ab `lj_fk^o
ilps^ilobpab ?cFá,
Aljl bgbjmil*^k^if`bjlpi^pfdrfbkqbob^``fÑknrÇjf`^8

Db0 . 1  &p' ) 1 QM 1 w w & ++++++ <Db 0&Q . 2 '1  &p' &0,32'

íArÄi bp bis^ilo ab ?g\úFá bk bpq^ ob^``fÑk `grÇjf`^= Nlabjlp afsfafo bpq^ ob^``fÑk
bkob^``flkbpabcloj ^`fÑkm^o^`^a^ob^`q^kqbvmolar`qlabimol`bpl8
Db 0 . 1  & p ' +++++ 0Db&p' )GM 0 &d' &^'

1 YQ. 1 & õ ' ++++++ < Q & p ' ) c . 0 &d'[ &_'

0Db&p' ) 1Q &p' ) 4 M 0 & d ' ++++++ < Db 0&QM ú'1 &p' &`'
34 A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

J^ob^``fÑk ^ bpi^ ob^``fÑk fksbop^ abi^ cloj^`fÑk abiDb 0 . 1 9 mloq^kql* bi `^j +
_flabbkq^imf^m^o^^bp ñ?cFá YDAgM g[,J^ob^``fÑk_bpi^ob^``fÑkfksbop^abi^clo+
j^`fÑk abi QM 1 &õ'*vbpqÄjriqfmif`^a^mlo1* Nloq^kql*bi `^j_fl ab bkq^imf^m^o^
_ bp+ 1  ä ? cHRYQ . 1 &õ '[, J^ob^``fÑk `bpi^ob^``fÑk ab cloj ^`fÑk abi pric^ql abefb+
ool &GGG',Ci`^j_flabbkq^imf^ab`bp?cffcYNb0&Q . 2 ' 1[*Pb`ljbka^jlp^iib`qlonrb
sbofcfnrb nrbi^p ob^``flkbp ^*_ v` a^k `ljl obpriq^ali^ b`r^`fÑk 0,32 `r^kal pb
prj^k^idb_o^f`^jbkqb,
J^`lj_fk^`fÑk^idb_o^f`^ abilps^ilobp ab ?cÇNa^ `ljl obpriq^al bi ab
i^b`r^`fÑk0,32,?pÇ*l_qbkbjlp8

8 (;^zzT@]ŬÜŮ5t(  . Å;^BTMÜŮ W!"? $;^BT@]Ŭ#MÜŰ $ŮV

Sksfpq^wl^ilps^ilobpabi^pq^_i^pjrbpqo^nrb?ccÇá YDb 0 . 1 [*èê+êFCePL) &õ'[ v?cFó


YDb 0&Q . 2 ' 1[ plk ab +6 0 3 *+ 2 1 6  v+0 3 6 1  h g mlo jli ab `ljmrbpql* obpmb`qfs^jbkqb,
?pÇ*bi?*gàúFáabi^ ob^``fÑkbki^b`r^`fÑk 0,32bp8

? *ú F á ;  + 2 2 1 hH

m^o^i^cloj ^`fÑkab / j li abD` 0&Q . 2 '1  ^m^oqfoabDb0 . 1 vQM 1 ^mobpfÑk bpqÄka^o,
Ci bgbjmil ^kqboflojrbpqo^ nrbilps^ilobp ab >êEÖ abilpmolar`qlp pb bjmib^k
afob`q^jbkqb*nrbilps^ilobpab }+êEÖabilpob^`q^kqbpe^k`^j_f^alab pfdklvnrb
ilp`lbcf`fbkqbpabi^ob^``fÑknrÇjf`^_^i^k`b^a^pbrqfifw^k`ljlc^`qlobpj riqfmif+
`^qfslp &bijriqfmif`^alo1 ab?cFabiQM 1vbi1 ^kqbpabiQM gbki^ob^``fÑk nrÇjf`^
_^i^k`b^a^kl plk `lfk`fabk`f^', J^ `ljmobkpfÑk ab bpq^p fab^p klp mboj fqb bi^_l+
o^orkjÅqlalpbk`fiilm^o^bs^ir^obi`^j_fl abbkq^imf^bk`r^inrfboob^``fÑknrÇ+
jf`^ &l bk `r^inrfbo crk`fÑk ab bpq^al* bk ob^ifa^a* ^rknrb e^pq^ ^elo^ . / l
`lkq^jlp `lk i^ bkbodÇ^ fkqbok^ `ljl i^ qÇkf`^ crk`fÑk ab bpq^al', Ck rk mol`bpl
nrÇjf`l*

?*,gúÇÇ;  \  ?cF&molar`qlp' +  \  ?cF&ob^`q^kqbp' &0,33'

Ck `^a^prj^ ab_bfk`irfopb bikÖjbol ab jlibpab `^a^molar`qlvob^`q^kqbbki^


b`r^`fÑknrÇjf`^_^i^k`b^a^,J^b`r^`fÑk0,33pb^mif`^^`r^inrfbo`lkgrkqlab`lk+
af`flkbp* ^pÇ `ljl qlalpilps^ilobp?cFm^o^ qla^p i^p bpmb`fbppb ^mif`^k ^ i^p j fp+
j^p `lkaf`flkbp, R^j_fÅk mlabjlp abcfkfo bi `^j_fl ab bkbodÇ^ fkqbok^ bk rk^
ob^``fÑk ab cloj ^`fÑk `lj l >+êR+ Cpqb`^j_fl abbkbodÇ^* i^bkbodÇ^ fkqbok^ abclo+
j^`fÑk*mlpbbi^jfpj^fjmloq^k`f^nrb?cFvq^j_fÅkpbbk`rbkqo^q^_ri^a^,Cufp+
qbfk`irplrk^bumobpfÑkpfjmibabilpmolar`qlpjbklpilpob^`q^kqbpm^o^bi`^j_fl
bki^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^ab`r^inrfbomol`bpl*q^j_fÅk_^p^a^bkilps^ilobp ab>bR7

y 0 [ &molar`qlp' ñ \  >êR&ob^`q^kqbp' &0,34'

Bbkrbsl* i^bumobpfÑk dbkbo^i qfbkbnrbsbo`lk `lkaf`flkbpbpqÄka^obpvkl bpqÄk+


a^obp* ^pÇ `ljl qlalp ilp*s^ilobp pb obcfbobk ^i jfpjl `lkgrkql ab `lkaf`flkbp, Ci
^mÅkaf`b 0  `lkqfbkbrk^^jmif^q^_i^ abbkq^imf^p &bpqÄka^obp' ab cloj ^`fÑk*i^`r^i
ab_b `lkpriq^opb m^o^ obplisbo mol_ibj^p nrb obnrfbobk bkbodÇ^p ab ob^``flkbp ab
cloj^`fÑk, J^p b`r^`flkbp 0*33 v 0,34 bifjfk^k i^ kb`bpfa^a ab ob^ifw^o rk ^kÄifpfp
`ljmibqlabi^ibvabFbppm^o^`^a^ob^``fÑknrÇjf`^,

J^lufa^`fÑk abi^dir`lp^* O F c 0 . 4 *`lkpqfqrvbrkmol`bpl jbq^_Ñif`l crka^j bk+


q^ibk`^pfqlalqfmlabsfa^,Cki^p`Åiri^ppbiibs^^`^_l^qo^sÅpabrk^pbofb`lj +
mibg^abob^``flkbpabbkwfj^p `^q^ifw^alo^p,J^ ob^``fÑkdbkbo^ibpi^pfdrfbkqb8

O F * 0 . *  &p' ) 4 M 0 &d '++++++< 4 AM 0 &d' ) 4 F 0M &õ'


0,/. A^j_flp nrÅjf`lp 35

Qfi^bkq^imf^bpqÄka^oabcloj ^`fÑkabi^dir`lp^bpab+/ 0 5 5 hg-jli*í`rÄibpbis^+


iloab bkbpqbmol`bpl=Qbkb`bpfq^l_qbkboilps^ilobpab>êEÖabi^mÅkaf`b0 ,

Ojgp^dÅi
Jlps^ilobp ab ?cFabi A M g &d' vF gM  &/' plkab+171,3/ v+0 6 3 ,6 1 hH-jli* obpmb`+
qfs^jbkqb, Nloq^kql*ob`roofj lp^i^b`r^`fÑk0,33vbk`lkqo^jlpnrb8

;  4 & +1 7 1 ,3 / '  )4 & + 0 6 3 ,6 1 '  & + / 0 5 5 '  h g bkbimol`bpl


0 ?cÇcá &molar`qlp' 0 >+êEÖ &ob^`q^kqbp'

Ckbumobpflkbppbjbg^kqbp^ bpq^*bpfjmloq^kqbqlj^oklq^abqlalpilp pfdklp kb+


d^qfslp,Cs^ir^kali^bumobpfÑk*l_qbkbjlp8
?ouk+cÇá ;  + 0 5 7 7 hi
?i l_pbos^onrbilp`lbcf`fbkqbpmolsbkfbkqbpabi^ob^``fÑknrÇjf`^_^i^k`b^a^ob+
mobpbkq^k bi kÖjbol ab j libp ab molar`qlp v ob^`q^kqbp* klp abpe^`bjlp ab ilp
jlibpabi abkljfk^alo ab Mqo^ j^kbo^ absboil `lkpfpqbbk ab`fonrb pb
dbkbo^k0577hHab bkbodÇ^`r^kal / j liabdir`lp^ob^``flk^`lk 4 jlibpabluÇ+
dbklm^o^cloj ^o 4 jlibpab afÑufalab `^o_lklv4 jlibpab^dr^,Cpqlbifj fk^i^
mobdrkq^8íjlibpabnrÅ=*nrbpbmi^kqb^oÇ^pfpbrqfifw^o^rk^rkfa^aabhH-jlim^+
o^

J^bpqo^qbdf^abómolar`qlpj bklpob^`q^kqbpòobpriq^jrvÖqfibkqboj lafkÄjf`^,


R^j_fÅk `lkpqfqrvb rk^ fab^ Öqfim^o^ ^_loa^o lqo^p crk`flkbp ab bpq^al8 bi`^f@_fl
bk `r^inrfbo crk`fÑk ab bpq^al bp fdr^i ^i s^ilo cfk^i jbklp bi s^ilo fkf`f^i, Ck bi
bgbjmil0,/5*i^crk`fÑkabbpq^alabfkqboÅpbo^i^bkq^imf^*v^i^mif`^oi^ibvabFbpp
vi^ abcfkf`fÑk ab i^p ob^``flkbp abcloj ^`fÑk*mrafjlp bi^_lo^o rk mol`bafj fbkql
m^o^abqbojfk^oilp`^j_flpabbkq^imf^vbkbodÇ^fkqbok^bk rkmol`bpl nrÇj f`l,
íOrÅ obi^`fÑkbufpqb bkqob ? F u > R aj rk^ob^``fÑknrÇjf`^= Qfp^_bjlpilps^+
ilobp ab?cSv?cFm^o^molar`qlpvob^`q^kqbp*pfjmibjbkqbmlabjlp `ljm^o^oilp
jbaf^kqb bi bpnrbj^ ab molar`qlp jbklp ob^`q^kqbp ab i^p b`r^`flkbp 0,33 v 0,34,
Cufpqblqo^cloj ^abobi^`flk^obpq^p alp crk`flkbp ab bpq^al,Pb`loabjlpi^abcfkf+
`fÑklofdfk^iabF ^m^oqfoabi^ b`r^`fÑk0,/48

E :  R (lS

Bbofs^jlp*^pfjfpjl*rk^bumobpfÑk m^o^ `E7

` E :  ` R (  `%lS &

` E : * `R (l ` S (  S ` l

J^ pbdrka^ b`r^`fÑk ab bpqb pfpqbj^pb l_qrsl^mif`^kali^ obdi^ ab i^ `^abk^, Cufp+
qbkafsbop^pcloj^pabe^`boil,Qfbimol`bplnrÇjf`l l`roob_^gl `lkaf`flkbpabsl+
irjbk `lkpq^kqb* biqÅoj fkll  ` S bp `bol u ` R : ` m r eaj sfoqra ab nrb biqo^_^gl ;
.',Nloq^kql*
` m u ( S ` l  &0,35'

J^cloj^fkqbdo^a^abbpq^b`r^`fÑkbp8

=D t: lt( R = k &0,36'

Aljl `R ; `m _^gl `lkaf`flkbp ab slirjbk `lkpq^kqb* bpql klp molmlo`flk^ rk^
cloj^ ab `^i`ri^o `rÄkql afcfbob ` E ab `R+ Ck `lkaf`flkbp ab mobpfÑk `lkpq^kqb* i^
b`r^`fÑkpb qo^kpcloj^bk8
?Fm ;  > R ( l > S  &0,37'

Bbbpq^j^kbo^*`lkq^jlp`lkrk^pbdrka^cloj^abbs^ir^o>E v?JÇbkrkmol`b+
plnrÇjf`l,
,/ A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofjbo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

Qf bimol`bpl nrÇjf`lbpab k^qro^ibw^fplqÅojf`^*vprmlkbjlp nrbilp d^pbp nrb


fkqbosfbkbkbkÅpqb^`qÖ^kabcloj ^fab^i*

` wl S & :  `wjO Q & [  ` j * H Q

CiqÅoj fkl `jpb obcfbob^i`^j _fl bk bikÖjbol ab jlibp abd^p nrb ^`ljm^É^^i^
ob^``fÑknrÇjf`^,Nrbpql nrbIv R plk`lkpq^kqbp*i^obdi^abi^`^abk^klprjfkfp+
qo^qÅoj fklp^af`flk^ibp,Nloq^kql*bkrkmol`bplnrÇjf`lfplqÅojf`l*i^pb`r^`flkbp
0,36 v0,37mrbabkbumobp^opbabi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^9

i : >R (OQIj &0,4.'

Ck bi `^pl ab i^ b`r^`fÑk 0,4.* kl pb bufdb nrb i^ mobpfÑk v bi slirjbk pb^k `lkp+
q^kqbp,

Bfailhk / .5
Skj liabbq^kl*AgF\*pbnrbj^`lkrkbu`bplabluÇdbkl^mobpfÑk`lkpq^kqbv^
4..áA ,íArÄibpbis^iloab?ì5abimol`bpl=J^`^kqfa^aab`^ilonrbdbkbo^i^`lj +
_rpqfÑkab G jliab bq^kl bpab /34. g f %ao ab`fonrbpbqo^q^abrk^ob^``fÑk bul+
qÅoj f`^',

Qlir`fÉk
Ckbpqbmol`bpl^mobpfÑk`lkpq^kqb*?F; m8^pÇ*> E :+/ 3 4 . hH,Cpqbs^ilobpkbd^+
qfslmlonrbpbbjfqb`^ilo,N^o^abqbojfk^of=R?îkb`bpfq^jlpi^ob^``fÑk nrÇjf`^
_^i^k`b^a^,Ckbi`^pl abi^`lj_rpqfÑk abi bq^kl bk luÇdbkl*af`e^b`r^`fÑk b p 8 ,

A 0F * Ad' )GM 0 & d ' ++++++ < 0 A . g &d' ) 1 F N  &d'

N^o^ _^i^k`b^oi^ b`r^`fÑk pb obnrfbob rk `lbcf`fbkqb co^``flk^ofl m^o^ bi luÇdbkl,
Ci ^dr^`ljl molar`ql pbfkaf`^ `lj l d^p*mrbpql nrbi^qbjmbo^qro^abimol`bpl
pb bk`rbkqo^jrvmlobk`fj ^ ab prmrkql ab b_riif`fÑk, Ci `^j_fl bki^ `^kqfa^a
abj libpabd^p*>j) bp Çqm\ar`flp+ îobîq^kqbp; &0) 1'+  &/  ) 5-0' ; 3+ 2,3 ; .,3 j l+
ibp, Nloilq^kql*

H Gh H
+ / 3 4 . hH ;  ? û- )  &.,3 jli' 1,1/2 &651 I'
jlK:- /.../-

Qfobplisbjlpi^b`r^`fÑk*qbkbjlp8

+\/34.h[ : > R (  /,02hH

?A-; + / 3 4 /  hH

Ckbpqbbgbjmil*?*\úRv? úúF plk^mbk^pafcbobkqbp,Cpql abjrbpqo^nrbl ] n pa abi


`^j _fl bki^bkbodÇ^qlq^ipbe^`lksboqfal bk qo^_^glvbiobpqlbk`^ilo,

0,// A^jf\fl ab qbj m bo^qr o^


Ckrkmol`bplnrbl`roobbk`lkaf`flkbpabmobpfÑk`lkpq^kqb &nrb^_^o`^i^j ^vl+
oÇ^abilpmol`bplpabfkqboÅpm^o^binrÇj f`l'*i^> E abimol`bplbpcÄ`fiabjbafo, Cp
il j fpjl obpmb`ql ^i `^ilo* m) abi mol`bpl, ?elo^ _fbk* i^ qbjmbo^qro^ abi mol`bpl
mrbab s^of^ov bpmbo^jlp nrb ? /-v* ab j^kbo^ jÄp fjmloq^kqb* > E s^oÇbk `lk i^
qbjmbo^qro^* íAÑjl`^i`ri^jlp > E m^o^rk^qbjmbo^qro^afcbobkqb=
W^nrbi^bkq^imf^bprk^crk`fÑkabbpq^al*mlabjlpbibdfo`ff^inrfbo`^j fkl`lk+
sbkfbkqbm^o^abqbojfk^o> E bki^ob^``fÑk^i^ qbjmbo^qro^abpb^a^, Nlabjlp^mif+
`^o rk^ fab^^kÄild^ ^ i^ ab i^ibv ab Fbpp m^o^ abqbojfk^o bi `^j_fl bk i^ crk`fÑk
0,// A^j_fl ab qbjmbo^qro^ 26

ab bpq^al ?Fbkrkmol`bpl nrbl`roob ^rk^qbjmbo^qro^afcbobkqbab i^ab ilpa^+


qlpafpmlkf_ibp &rpr^ijbkqbab 03,.áA',?abjÄpab ?F^03,.áA*kb`bpfq^jlp`lkl+
`boi^p`^m^`fa^abpqÅojf`^pabmolar`qlpvob^`q^kqbp, B^a^bpq^fkcloj^`fÑk*?Fg+*
alkabR obmobpbkq^`r^inrfboqbj mbo^qro^*pbbk`rbkqo^abqbojfk^a^mloi^prj^ab8

/, Ci`^ilo*m)kb`bp^oflm^o^iibs^o^ilpob^`q^kqbp^i^qbjmbo^qro^bpmb`fcf`^a^bk
ilp a^qlp abi^p q^_i^p &rpr^ijbkqb ab 076,/3 I',
0, Ci`^iloab ob^``fÑk*?F* ^af`e^qbjmbo^qro^ &nrbmrbababqbojfk^opb ^m^o+
qfoabilpa^qlpq^_ri^alp',
1, Ci `^ilo* m) kb`bp^ofl m^o^iibs^o abkrbsl ^ilpmolar`qlp ^i^qbjmbo^qro^ ab
ob^``fÑkabpb^a^,

Qf bjmib^jlp ?F** ?Fgv?F 1 m^o^ obmobpbkq^o ilpqobps^ilobp `^iloÇcf`lp j bk`fl+


k^alp^kqboflojbkqb*mlabjlpbp`of_foi^pbumobpflkbpm^o^`^a^m^pl,Cim^pl / `lk+
pfpqbbkrkmol`bplab`^j _flabqbjmbo^qro^nrbpbofdbmlobieb`elabnrb ?Fg ; 
ng* ;  j£ `ä?R,J^`^m^`fa^aqÅoj f`^abbpq^bumobpfÑkbpi^`^m^`fa^aqÅoj f`^`lj +
_fk^a^abqlalpilpob^`q^kqbp*nrbab_bfk`irfopbbpqbnrfljÅqof`^jbkqb,Cpab`fonrb
pfe^v0  jlibpabob^`q^kqb*pr`^m^`fa^aqÅojf`^ab_bfk`irfopbalpsb`bp*v^pfpr`b+
pfs^jbkqb, Bb_bjlp `lkpfabo^opf ?F* obmobpbkq^ rk `^j_fl bulqÅojf`l &p^ifa^ ab
`^ilo, ? e kbd^qfsl' l rk`^j _fl bkalqÅoj f`l &bkqo^a^ab`^ilo* ? F mlpfqfsl',Ckbi
m^pl 0 *?Fgbppbk`fii^jbkqb?guúFá,Ckbim^pl1*?F 1bppfjfi^o^?F**p^islmlonrb
^elo^flpmolar`qlpab_bkiibs^opbabrk^qbjmbo^qro^bpmb`Çcf`^^`r^inrfboqbjmb+
o^qro^cfk^inrbpb^kb`bp^of^ &abkrbsl*qlj^kalbk`rbkq^pfbimol`bplbpbkalqÅo+
jf`l l bulqÅojf`l',Ck bpqbqbo`bom^pl*pbobnrfbobki^p `^m^`fa^abp qÅojf`^p abilp
lnk`q_pko+J^>Ef*qlq^ibpi^prj^abilpqobp`^j_flpabbkq^imf^*pbdÖki^ibvabFbpp
vbieb`elabnrbi^bkq^imf^bpi^crk`fÑkabbpq^alnrbpbobnrfbob,Cipfdrfbkqbbgbj +
mililfirpqo^,

Bfailhk / .6
Bbqbojfkb ?F3..bki^pfdrfbkqbob^``fÑk ^ 3..IvmobpfÑk`lkpq^kqb8

AM &d' E ) -  & d ' ++++++ <AM 0 &d' ) F\ &d'

Qlkkb`bp^oflpilppfdrfbkqbpa^qlp8

Q r p q ^ k ` f^ `, ? cF & 0 7 6  I '

AM 0 7 ,/ 0 +/ / . ,3
F gM 1 1 *3 6 + 0 2 / ,6
AMg 1 5 ,/ / + 1 7 1 ,3
0 7 *6 7 . ,.

alkabi^p rkfa^abp ab AmplkH-jlf+Ivi^p rkfa^abp ab ?cFplk hg-jli, Qrmlkd^


`^kqfa^abpjli^obp,

Qlir`fÉk
Nofjbolqbkbjlpnrbiibs^obiAMvbiF gM ab3..I^076I*rk? R ab+ 0 . 0 I,N^+
o^rkj liab `^a^rkl*bi`^ilo &nrbbpfdr^i^i `^j_fl abbkq^imf^' bpfdr^i^8

?F* ;  d

;  &/ i k h& % /6+./ { + J ' & + 0 . 0 I ' ) &/ j li'û11,36ñ J % ' & + 0 . 0 I'
Z j l i+I 9 jli+I-
?F* ;  + / 0 *4 4 3  H ;  + / 0 ,4 4 3 hH

N^o^bipbdrkalm^plkb`bpfq^jlpbs^ir^o? F m^o^i^ob^``fÑk^076I,Bb^`rboal
`lkbibkclnrbabilpmolar`qlpj bklpilp ob^`q^kqbp*qbkbjlpnrb8
4. A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

? Hû 0 ;  & + 1 7 1 ,3  ).' +  & + / / . ,3  ) + 0 2 / ,6 '  h g

?Fg ;  + 2 / ,0 hH

Dfk^ijbkqb*ilpmolar`qlpabi^ob^``fÑkkb`bpfq^kbibs^opb^3..I9bi`^ilodbkbo^+
albkaf`el m^pl*?F 1*bp8

H H
^ j ( D eK  ì 2 / 2 * { * í  ? K .( D .
:  &/  jli' 15,// £ &) 0 . 0  I' ) &/ jli' 07,67ñ ;5 ñ &) 0.0I'
jli%I- Z jli+I-

Aiamd\hd`i* ?\g`io\h d`i* ?elo^?R bpab0.0 Ilkoeperk7


oj\ /65G $ oj\2--G

> E ) ;  )/1*312H ;  /1,312hH


=OPI
AM) F0 M ++++++ \ A M 0) F0
J^?úúFqlq^ibpi^prj^abi^pqobpm^oqbp9

?F3..;?F*)?F0)?F1 ;  ?F* )>E Ď) ?Fg


D fd r o ^  0 , / 0  Pbmobpbkq^`fÑk doÄcf`^ ab
f^cloj ^bkn rbpbabqboj fk^ ^qb j + ;  + / 0 ,4 4 3  ) & + 2 / ,0 '  ) /1,312hH
mbo^qro^pklbpqÄka^obp,Ci`^j _flqlq^iab
bkq^imf^ bp i^ prj ^ ab ilp `^j _flp ab b k +
? \ F ;  +\2.,1hH
q^imf^abilp qobpm^plp,
J^cfdro^0,/0j rbpqo^rkaf^do^j^abilpmol`bplpbjmib^alpm^o^`^i`ri^o>Eêck*

J^obpmrbpq^abibgbjmil^kqbofloklafcfbobjr`elab mbolbpafcbobkqb,\Cp
fk`irplrk^^molufj^`fÑk*v^nrbprmlkbjlpnrbi^p`^m^`fa^abpqÅojf`^pkls^oÇ^k
`lki^qbjmbo^qro^,Qf`loem^o^jlp bpqbs^ilo`lkbis^ilobumbofjbkq^iab ?F 3..ab
ò 17,62hH*sbjlp nrbkl bpq^jlpjrv^ibg^alpabi^ob^ifa^a,Nloq^kql*bprk^_rb+
k^ ^molufj^`fÑk, N^o^ pbo jÄp bu^`qlp* pb kb`bpfq^ rk^ bumobpfÑk m^o^ @l bk ird^o
abrk^`lkpq^kqb*vab_bbs^ir^opbrk^fkqbdo^ibkqob3..Iv076Im^o^ilpm^plpab
?F[ v ?F 1* pbdÖk il firpqo^ bi bgbjmil 0,/., Ll l_pq^kqb* abpab rk mrkql ab sfpq^
`lk`bmqr^i*bpq^obpmrbpq^kl bpafcbobkqbab i^abibgbjmil^kqboflo,

0 ,/ 0  ib ^ ` ` fl k b p  _flnrÇj f`^p
J^_flildÇ^*bibpqrafl abilppbobpsfslp*pb^mlv^ bki^nrÇjf`^,?rknrbilppfpqbj^p
_fliÑdf`lpplkjrv`ljmibglp*prpob^``flkbp nrÇjf`^p^Ökpbofdbkmloilp`lk`bm+
qlp crka^jbkq^ibp ab i^ qbojlafkÄjf`^,Ck bpq^ pb``fÑk obm^p^objlpi^qboj lafkÄ+
jf`^ab ^idrklpmol`bplp_flnrÇjf`lpfjmloq^kqbp,
Ck bibgbjmil 0,/5*bpqraf^jlpi^lufa^`fÑk abi^dir`lp^8

&p' ) 4 M 0 &d '++++++< 4 AM 0 &d' ) 4 F 0M &õ'

Ci `^j_fl abbkq^imf^ab bpq^ob^``fÑkbpab+0 5 7 7 hHmlojliab dir`lp^lufa^a^,Ci


mofjbomrkql nrb ab_bjlp abpq^`^obp nrbkl fjmloq^pf i^dir`lp^ pb nrbj^ bk bi
^fobl pbjbq^_lifw^ bk krbpqo^p `Åiri^p8 mlo`^a^ /6.,/3 d&;  / j li' ab dir`lp^nrb
ob^``flk^`lkbiluÇdbkl*pbabpmobkabk0577hHabbkbodÇ^,Cipbdrkalmrkql`lkpfp+
qb bkob`lkl`bonrb gbpqlobmobpbkq^rk^do^k `^kqfa^aab bkbodÇ^  Cpprcf`fbkqbm^+
o^ bibs^o i^ qbjmbo^qro^ ab 6.,. hd ab ^dr^ &i^ j^p^ ^molufj^a^ ab rk `rboml
erj^kl' jÄpab 6 áA,Cislirjbkjli^oabi^dir`lp^bpab^iobabaloab //3jJ*il
`r^ifirpqo^nrbkrbpqo^p`Åiri^pbjmib^k rk^cloj^jrv`ljm^`q^abbkbodÇ^,
J^clqlpÇkqbpfpbpbimol`bplmlobi`r^ii^pmi^kq^pbi^_lo^kdir`lp^^m^oqfoabafÑ+
ufal ab`^o_lkl v^dr^, J^ob^``fÑkqlq^ibp8

4 A M 0 &d' ) 4 F m  & õ ' ++++++<O F *?  &p' ) È L Ď &d'


0,/0 Pb^``flkbp _flnrÅjf`^p 4/

+ F *.

MF
(
+Mñ mñ MF
((
M

i\fdfpo^ 0 , / 1  FfaoÑifpfp abiqofclpc^qlab^abklpfk^ &?RN*mloprppfdi^pbkfkdiÅp' m^o^cloj ^oafclpc^+


qlab^abklpfk^ &?BN* mloprp pfdi^p bk fkdiÅp'vclpc^qlfklodÄkf`l,

Cpq^bpi^ob^``fÑk fksbop^ ab i^ob^``fÑk ab i^ lufa^`fÑk-jbq^_lifpjl ab i^ dir`lp^,
Bb^`rboal`lki^ibvabFbpp*bi`^j_flabbkq^imf^abbpq^ob^``fÑkbpbi`^j_flk b +
d^qfsl abi^bkq^imf^bkbimol`bpllofdfk^i8 ;)0577h gmloj liabdir`lp^mol+
ar`fa^, Ck ^j _lp mol`bplp* ilp m^plp fkafsfar^ibp bk i^ `lj mibg^ ob^``fÑk
_flnrÇjf`^qlq^ipb abp`lkl`bk, QÑilpbobnrfbobi^ ob^``fÑkqlq^im^o^abqbojfk^obi
`^j_flabbkq^imf^,
Sk^ob^``fÑk_flnrÇj f`^jrvfjmloq^kqbbpi^`lksbopfÑkabqofclpc^qlab^abkl+
pfk^ &?RN*mloprppfdi^p bk fkdiÅp' bkafclpc^qlab^abklpfk^ &ùBN* mloprppfdi^p bk
fkdiÅp'vsf`bsbop^&cfdro^0,/1',Nlabjlpobprjfobpqbmol`bplabi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^9

\?BN +G+clpc^ql %/+3.&

?nrÇ* óclpc^qlò pb obcfbob ^ `r^inrfbo^ ab afsboplp flkbp ab clpc^ql fklodÄkf`l
&F 0N . 2 {*FN . 2 \ó M  N . 2 \ò '*abmbkafbkal ab i^p`lkaf`flkbp ^j_fbkq^ibp,Cpq^`l k+
sbopfÑk`lkpqfqrvbrkfj mloq^kqbmol`bpl ab^ij^`bk^jfbkql-rqfifw^`fÑk ab bkbodÇ^
^kfsbipr_`biri^o,
Cpq^pob^``flkbpl`roobkbki^p`Åiri^p*klbkc^pbd^pblp^*^pÇnrbi^bpmb`fcf`^`fÑk
abi^p`lkaf`flkbpabi^ob^``fÑkplkafcbobkqbp,Sk aop]`kaop}j `]n^ ekm q Äi e_kfk`ir+
vbbiobnrfpfqlabnrbrk^plir`fÑk^`rlp^pb^kbrqo^ &bpab`fo*kfÄ`fa^kf_Äpf`^'*`lk
rkmF ab4<Cjmib^j lpbipÇj_lil ab Çkaf`bmofjl % bkrk^crk`fÑkab bpq^alm^+
o^pfdkfcf`^onrbpbobcfbob^rk^ob^``fÑkbkbibpq^albpqÄka^o_flnrÇj f`l,Cki^ob^`+
`fÑk ?RN ?BN ab i^ b`r^`fÑk 0,4/* i^ bp ab +0 2 ,1  hH mlo j li ab ?RN
ob^`qfsl,
Cpqbkl`lkpqfqrvbrk `^j _fl`lkpfabo^_ibabbkq^imf^,Lll_pq^kqb*e^vprcf`fbk+
qbbkbodÇ^m^o^ ^ifj bkq^olqo^p ob^``flkbpnrÇjf`^pfjmloq^kqbp abpab rk mrkql ab
sfpq^_flnrÇjf`l, Ck i^ j^vloÇ^ abilp if_olp ab qbuql ab_flnrÇj f`^ pb mrbabk bk+
`lkqo^oilpabq^iibp,

\CG `^mÇqr il 6  `l k qfbk b r k ^ a fp`r pfÑk  j Äp abq^ii^a^ abi mF ,


3/ A ? N ú R S J M 0 Nofj bo^ ibv ab i^ qbojlafk~jf`^

?elo^_fbk* `lk`irfj lp bpq^pb``fÑk `lk rk^^asboqbk`f^, Kr`elpe_olpab qbuql


pfjmifcf`^ki^ob^``fÑkabi^b`r^`fÑk 0,4/ abi^pfdrfbkqbj^kbo^8

?RN Ç; ; Ç  ?BN) clpc^ql ;  + 0 2 ,1  h g &0,40'

&Cp cob`rbkqb bk nrÇj f`^ lodÄkf`^ l _fliÑdf`^nrb ilpmol`bplp nrÇj f`lp `ljmibglp
pb obmobpbkqbkrqfifw^kal bu`irpfs^jbkqbi^p bpmb`fbp nrÇjf`^pfj mloq^kqbp,' N^o^bi
mofk`fmf^kqb*i^ob^``fÑkobmobpbkq^a^bki^b`r^`fÑk0,40prdfbobnrbi^jliÅ`ri^abi
?RN pb afsfa^ bk j liÅ`ri^p ab?BNvab clpc^ql vnrb pbif_bo^k 02,1 hH ab bkbodÇ^,
Qfkbj_^odl*bknrÇj f`^_Äpf`^ab_boÇ^jlp^mobkabonrbpfbjmobpbnamq eanabkbodÇ^
m^o^oljmborkbki^`bnrÇj f`l9bpq^ob^``fÑk ab_boÇ^pbobkalqÅojf`^*klbulqÅojf+
`^, íAÑjlmrbaboljmbopbrkbki^`b nrÇjf`lvabpmobkabopb bkbodÇ^=
J^ o^wÑk abi^`lkcrpfÑko^af`^bk i^^rpbk`f^ ab i^jliÅ`ri^abF gM , Qboljmbk
vpb cloj^k jÄp bki^`bp ab ilp nrb fjmif`^ i^ b`r^`fÑk 0,40 v* `lk i^ fk`irpfÑk abi
^dr^ &`lj lbki^b`r^`fÑk0,4/'*bi`^j_flqlq^iabbkq^imf^abi^`lksbopfÑk?RNñ<
?BN bp kbd^qfsl* J^`lkcrpfÑk prodb `r^kal i^p ob^``flkbp `ljmibg^p pb pfjmifcf`^k
vbiib`qloabp^mbo`f_falklpba^`rbkq^abi^p`lkpb`rbk`f^pabaf`e^pfjmifcf`^`fÑk,
íJ^ ib``fÑk= Gk`irplilpmol`bplp_flnrÇjf`lp`ljmibglppb ofdbk mloilp`lk`bm+
qlpabi^qbojlafkÄjf`^,

0 ,/ 1  ib pr j b k
J^mofjbo^ ibv abi^ qboj lafkÄjf`^ qfbkbnrbsbo `lki^ ajancÄ]+ J^ bkbodÇ^qlq^i ab
rkpfpqbj^^fpi^albp`lkpq^kqb,Qfi^bkbodÇ^qlq^iabrkpfpqbj^`boo^al`^j_f^*mrb+
ab j^kfcbpq^opb `lj l qo^_^gl l `^ilo*kl ablqo^cloj^,W^nrbi^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^ R
klpfbjmobbpi^j bglocloj ^abo^pqob^oi^bkbodÇ^abrkpfpqbj^*abcfkfjlpi^bkq^i+
mf^*E )nrbmrbabpbork^crk`fÑkab bpq^al jÄp`lksbkfbkqb, Alj ljr`elpmol`b+
plp nrÇjf`lp l`roobk bÉ `lkaf`flkbp ab mobpfÑk `lkpq^kqb* i^ bkq^imf^ ^ jbkral
obpriq^jÄp`lksbkfbkqb nrbi^bkbodÇ^fkqbok^,
Cufpqbkjr`e^p cloj^pj^qbjÄqf`^pab o^pqob^oilp`^j_flpab bkbodÇ^ab rk pfp+
qbj^, Jlp bgbjmilpmolmrbpqlpbkbpqb`^mÇqril pb_^p^kbkprqlq^ifa^abki^mofj b+
o^ ibv ab i^ qboj lafkÄjf`^, Kr`elp ab biilp bufdbk abqbojfk^a^ `lkaf`fÑk* `ljl
rk^ mobpfÑk* rkslirjbk l rk^qbjmbo^qro^ `lkpq^kqbp,?rknrb bpql mrafbo^m^ob+
`bofk`lksbkfbkqb*^iabcfkfoilp`^j_flpbkrkpfpqbj^abbpq^j^kbo^*mlabjlp`^i+
`ri^obi`^j_fl bki^bkbodÇ^abkrbpqolpfpqbj^,|pqbbprkl_gbqfslfj mloq^kqbabi^
qbojlafkÄjf`^, Alj lsbobjlpbk bi pfdrfbkqb`^mfqril* bpqbkl bp biÖkf`l l_gbqfsl
ab fjmloq^k`f^,
J^lqo^jfpfÑkabi^qboj lafkÄjf`^pbbk`fboo^bki^mobdrkq^8ínrÅmol`bplpqfbk+
abk ^ mobpbkq^opbmlopÇ jfpjlp*pfkkfkdÖk bpcfqbowl &bpab`fo*pfkqo^_^gl' abkrbp+
qo^ m^oqb= Ck lqo^p m^i^_o^p* ínrÅ mol`bplp plk aolkjp}jako< J^ mofj bo^ ibv ab i^
qbojlafkÄjf`^kl klpmbojfqbobpmlkaboi^mobdrkq^bkcloj^^_plirq^,Cpqlpbab+
_b^nrbjkl q a` ae^`boil,T^of^pfksbpqfd^`flkbpvbumbofjbkqlpe^kabjlpqo^alnrb
i^bkbodÇ^kl`lkpqfqrvbbiÖkf`lfkqboÅpabi^qbojlafkÄjf`^,F^vlqolp qbj^pfdr^i
ab obibs^kqbp*vobpriq^ nrb af`elpqbj^p abpbjmbÉ^k rkm^mbi bpbk`f^ibki^ cloj^
bknrbsbjlpkrbpqolrkfsbopl,

You might also like