You are on page 1of 6

Physical Modelling in Geotechnics – Springman, Laue & Seward (eds)

© 2010 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-59288-8

Establishing a beam centrifuge facility at the Institute


of Technology, Sligo, Ireland

C.D. O’Loughlin & P. Naughton


Institute of Technology Sligo, Ireland

N. Baker & A. Ainsworth


Thomas Broadbent & Sons, Huddersfield, UK

ABSTRACT: A new beam centrifuge facility has recently been established at the Institute of Technol-
ogy, Sligo in Ireland. The centrifuge, designed and manufactured by Thomas Broadbent & Sons, is a
9 g-tonne machine, that can spin two strongboxes at either end of a 0.75 m beam rotor at a maximum
(effective radius) acceleration level of 300 g. Although the centrifuge is relatively small, the functionality is
at least equivalent to the successful approach of using a drum centrifuge in beam mode, where a number
of strongboxes are located within the drum channel. The design of the centrifuge is such that the beam
rotor can be interchanged with a drum channel so that the centrifuge can operate either in beam or drum
mode. Thomas Broadbent & Sons are currently finalising a drum channel and tool table design suitable
for retrofitting to the existing machine.

1 INTRODUCTION • University of Delft small beam centrifuge: sam-


ple base radius = 1.2 m, payload = 9 g-tonne,
Centrifuge modelling has a well-established posi- sample dimensions of 300 × 400 × 450 mm
tion in providing insight into complex geotechnical (Allersma 1994).
problems (Schofield 1980; Taylor 1995; Muir Wood • University of Western Australia drum centrifuge
2004; Gaudin et al. 2006). The number of centri- in beam mode: sample base radius = 0.55 m, pay-
fuges in geotechnical research centres has increased load = 2.5 g-tonne (per sample), sample dimen-
significantly over the last decade; these centrifuges sions of 258 × 150 × 80 mm (White et al. 2005).
vary in size, cost and complexity in accordance with
the needs and resources of each centre. In 2007 the The more attractive features in the above
Institute of Technology, Sligo (ITS), set out to centrifuges were incorporated in a conceptual
establish the first geotechnical centrifuge facility in design for the ITS centrifuge. In 2008 Thomas
Ireland. The facility was conceived to strike a bal- Broadbent & Sons (TBS) were commissioned to
ance between teaching, research and commercial develop this conceptual design and manufacture
opportunity. Early in the design evolution, con- the centrifuge. The centrifuge was installed and
straints were set on the physical dimensions of the commissioned during July and August, 2009. This
centrifuge to minimise costs, infrastructure require- paper provides an overview of the main features
ments and dedicated technical support. ITS consid- of the ITS centrifuge, including control and data
ered existing geotechnical centrifuges that did not acquisition systems.
require substantial housing such as pits and rein-
forced concrete enclosures. Existing designs that
influenced the design process included: 2 BEAM CENTRIFUGE
• University of Dundee mini beam centrifuge: sam-
2.1 Specification
ple base radius = 0.35 m, payload = 0.4 g-tonne,
sample dimensions of 80 × 80 × 80 mm (Newson The ITS geotechnical centrifuge is a 9 g-tonne
et al. 2002). beam centrifuge, with two strongboxes at either
• University of Colorado (teaching) beam cen- end of a 0.75 m beam rotor. A substantial steel
trifuge: sample base radius = 0.61 m, pay- casing with an outer diameter of 1.7 m surrounds
load = 0.6 g-tonne, sample dimensions of the rotating assembly; the wall thickness of the cas-
223 × 165 × 25 mm (Dewoolkar et al. 2003). ing is 12 mm and is sufficient to contain the debris

255
should the strongbox be overloaded such that it
breaks free in flight. The centrifuge is designed such
that a strongbox rather than a swinging platform is
suspended from pivots at either end of the beam
rotor. At the time of writing (September 2009) the
strongboxes in use are plane strain boxes with inter-
nal (sample) dimensions of 300 × 170 × 150 mm.
Each strongbox acts as a counterweight to the
other and doubles the available testing plan area.
Although the centrifuge is rated to 9 g-tonne, the
current strongboxes are designed for a safe working
payload of 6 g-tonne. The strongboxes can be easily
removed through a hinged hatch on the casing lid.
Alternatively the entire casing lid can be removed
using either a portable crane or overhead gantry.
The maximum rotational speed is 638 rpm,
equivalent to an acceleration level of 259 g at the
top of a soil sample (at radius = 0.57 m), 341 g
at the base (at radius = 0.75 m) and 300 g at the
effective radius of the sample = 0.66 m. This cor-
responds to a maximum over stress of ∼12% at
the surface of the sample and ∼14% at the base of
the sample. Further specifications are provided in
Table 1, and schematics and photographs of the
centrifuge are provided in Figures 1 and 2.
Figure 1. Centrifuge general arrangement.
2.2 Centrifuge laboratory
The centrifuge is located in a geotechnical research
laboratory that is home to other geotechnical
research equipment. No specific structural require-
ments were necessary for the centrifuge and the
only service provisions required are those com-
monly supplied to a laboratory environment. The
laboratory has an overall floor space of approxi-
mately 80 m2; the centrifuge, adjacent work sur-
faces and open plan control “room” occupies a

Figure 2. The ITS 9 g-tonne beam centrifuge.


Table 1. Centrifuge specifications.

Strongbox base radius 0.750 m footprint of approximately 25 m2 (i.e. less than ⅓


Effective radius 0.660 m of the laboratory floor space). Model preparation
Pivot radius 0.350 m and other activities related to the centrifuge (e.g.
Maximum rotational speed638 rpm clay mixing, calibrating instruments) are carried
Maximum acceleration 300 g at effective radius out elsewhere in the laboratory.
(0.66 m)
341 g at base of strongbox
(0.75 m) 2.3 Drive and transmission
Maximum size of payload W = 0.170 m
(circumferential in f light) The centrifuge is driven by a 7.5 kW, 380/415 V,
L = 0.300 m 3 phase AC motor. The motor is located on a
(vertical in f light) vertical plate on the centrifuge casing (see Figs 1
H = 0.150 m and 2) and drive is transmitted from the motor
(radial in f light) to the centrifuge drive shaft via multiple V wedge
Maximum payload at each 9 g-tonne (30 kg at 300 g) belts. Variation in the centrifuge rotational speed
end of beam
is achieved using a solid state inverter located in
Maximum unbalance 0.45 g-tonne (1.5 kg at
300 g) the control/drive panel. The inverter is regenerative
and can provide electrical braking to assist aerody-

256
namic drag on the beam to quickly decelerate the
centrifuge.

2.4 Rotary stack


The rotary stack is located centrally on top of the
beam rotor and protrudes through the centre of
the lid (see Figs 1–2). The rotor of the slip ring
stack is installed over an aluminium alloy support
column that is flange mounted to the top of the
beam rotor hub as shown on Figure 3. The power
and data lines originate at connectors attached to a
ring screwed to the top plate of the stator, and are
fed down slots on the outside of the column termi-
nating at connectors attached to the beam rotor.
There are a total of 16 electrical slip rings, 4 rated
to 10 A and 12 rated to 2 A. Although the number Figure 4. Centrifuge control system.
of rings is low, they are not required for data trans-
fer as this is achieved using a wireless data acquisi-
tion system (described later). This leaves the slip logic controller (PLC) controls all normal machine
rings free for providing power to devices in flight functions such as speed and start/stop sequences,
such as the electrical actuator and data acquisition whilst also providing the first level of safety features
system. such as access interlocks, and protection against
A two way fluid rotary union suitable for sup- overspeed and unbalance. Critical machine related
plying both fluid and air (at pressures up to 1 MPa) safety functions such as emergency stop, overspeed
is attached to the top of the support column. Fluid and excessive unbalance are, in addition, hard-
or air from the rotary union passes via O-ring sealed wired independently of the PLC to comply with
transfer spools into a pair of drillings passing down current safety legislation which limits the reliance
the full length of the support column and emerges to be placed on programmable electronic devices.
at tapped holes just above the beam hub. The centrifuge is operated from a local control
panel that houses the PLC, an input/display touch
screen and a series of push buttons for starting and
2.5 Control systems stopping the centrifuge (including emergency stop
and power isolation). The touch screen allows the
The centrifuge control systems are shown sche-
desired centrifuge speed to be input and displays
matically on Figure 4. An industrial programmable
centrifuge status parameters such as current speed,
acceleration level, unbalance and faults.
Centrifuge speed is measured by impulses from
two proximity sensors mounted above a series of
holes drilled through the driven pulley attached
to the bottom of the centrifuge drive shaft. To
guard against faulty speed control, two independ-
ent speed monitoring systems are fitted. In the pri-
mary system pulses from the first proximity sensor
are received by the main PLC via a frequency to
current converter and scaled to centrifuge speed.
Should the centrifuge speed exceed a software limit,
the centrifuge comes to rest in a controlled man-
ner. In the secondary monitoring system, impulses
from the second proximity sensor are received by
a simple overspeed switch. This is a pulse counter
that has a set of contacts that switch when a preset
limiting pulse rate is exceeded. The pulse counter
contacts are connected to the drive contactor, such
that if the pulse speed exceeds the limits, the centri-
fuge comes to rest. This system provides protection
in the event of a failure in the main speed measur-
Figure 3. Rotary stack. ing system or in the inverter.

257
In addition to the above, the inverter is preset
with a software limit on output frequency which
limits the maximum speed of the drive motor.
Out of balance loading on the centrifuge beam
causes small deflections of the centrifuge and the
resultant vibration at the shaft rotational frequency
is sensed by an accelerometer mounted on the con-
nector ring at the top of the rotary stack. The sig-
nal from the accelerometer is received by the main
PLC and is displayed as a vibration velocity on the
local control panel. Software vibration limits initi-
ate an alarm if the unbalance reaches 50% of the
maximum permitted unbalance and a controlled
stop and shutdown if the unbalance exceeds the
maximum permitted unbalance. If the unbalance
exceeds 120% of the maximum permitted unbal-
ance, a trip amplifier wired in the safety relay cir-
cuit removes the inverter run signal causing the
centrifuge to be braked to rest. This is a hardwired
protection feature that guards against PLC faults.
The frequency to current converter also has a
set of contacts that switch when the pulse speed
from the first proximity sensor exceeds the preset
limiting pulse rate. These contacts are connected
in the safety relay circuit in series with the emer-
gency stop button and unbalance vibration sensor.
If any of these contacts are opened the centrifuge
is braked to rest. This system provides protection Figure 5. Schematic of the data acquisition system
in the event of a fault in the PLC. (after Gaudin et al. 2009).

3 DATA ACQUISITION SYSTEM that communicate with the control room via wire-
less Ethernet. Unlike the PC-based DAS typically
A geotechnical centrifuge data acquisition system used in a geotechnical centrifuge, the UWA wireless
(DAS) is typically located “on-board” the rotat- DAS performs the full sequence of amplification,
ing assembly close to the axis of rotation so as to conditioning, digitization and storage on a single
minimise the g level experienced by the electronics. circuit board via an independent micro-controller
In the typical DAS arrangement, analogue data sig- allocated to each pair of instrumented channels
nals are amplified, digitized and multiplexed before (Gaudin et al. 2009). This results in a significantly
transmission through the electrical slip rings. Such more compact hardware unit that is well suited to
an arrangement requires a PC with a hard drive, small centrifuges.
data acquisition card and the associated interface UWA have developed a similar wireless DAS for
buses in addition to separate sensing, condition- the ITS centrifuge, but with 2 units which allows
ing and amplification units. However the limited up to 16 instrument channels to be logged simul-
number of electrical slip rings on the ITS cen- taneously (additional 8 channel logging units can
trifuge and the limited internal physical space to be daisy-chained at a later date if required). 12 V
mount this relatively bulky arrangement prompted DC power is provided to the DAS network switch
consideration of an alternative approach. via the electrical slip rings. The DAS and other test
A wireless DAS has recently been developed by specific control systems are mounted on an instru-
the University of Western Australia (UWA) for mentation chassis plate that is mounted on and
their drum centrifuge (Gaudin et al. 2009). The orthogonal to the beam rotor at the axis of rota-
operation of the UWA wireless DAS is shown tion (not shown on Fig. 1).
schematically on Figure 5. Each logging unit is
contained within a metal box 150 × 60 × 40 mm
in size and is capable of powering and monitoring 4 ELECTRICAL ACTUATOR
8 instrument channels at a sampling rate of up to
1 MHz at 16-bit resolution. Up to 8 logging units An electronic linear actuator has been developed
can be daisy-chained to give a total of 64 channels (by TBS) for conducting sample characterisation

258
and foundation tests (see Figs 6–7). The in-plan 5 IMAGE CAPTURE AND PROCESSING
location of the actuator is controlled manually
prior to testing, whilst in flight the actuator has Optical measurement techniques, such as the adap-
a stroke length of 145 mm and has a loading tation of particle image velocimetry (PIV) from
capability of 2 kN at a maximum actuator speed experimental fluid mechanics have permitted high
of 10 mm/s. The actuator drive motor is a 80 V DC resolution, non-obstructive displacement measure-
brushless servo motor that drives a worm gearbox ments in geotechnical physical models (White et al.
traveling nut screw jack via a toothed belt. Axial 2003, 2005). This technique has particular merit
position is sensed by a non-contacting magneto- in use with small centrifuges as less room is avail-
inductive linear transducer. able for alternative instrumentation. Existing plane
The actuator is currently controlled via a dedi- strain strongboxes for the ITS centrifuge have
cated control panel supplied by TBS. Plans are been designed with PIV applications in mind. The
underway to transfer this to software control as strongbox incorporates removable Perspex side
part of an overall experimental control program. panels which provide viewing windows on either
side of the soil sample. Custom-built brackets can
be attached to either side of the strongbox to mount
cameras and lighting (see Fig. 7). ITS use Canon S
series compact digital cameras (image resolution
of 5 to 8 Mega Pixels at 0.5–1.0 Hz) for “static”
tests and a Mikrotron MotionBlitz EonSens® high
frame rate camera (1.3 Mega Pixels at 500 Hz) for
dynamic tests.
Four miniature pinhole cameras are mounted
at various locations in the centrifuge. The video
signals are transmitted wirelessly from the centri-
fuge to a 4 channel digital video recorder (DVR)
located in the control room, which can output to
a PC screen or allow for remotely viewing over
the internet. Cameras are located on the camera
bracket to view the experiment in-flight, and at
various locations within the centrifuge to check for
potential collisions as the centrifuge is ramped up
and the experiment progresses.

6 CURRENT STATUS AND FUTURE


DEVELOPMENTS

At the time of writing the centrifuge has been suc-


Figure 6. Electrical linear actuator. cessfully commissioned. A number of control and
benchmark experiments are being conducted to ver-
ify performance. Of particular interest is the potential
for unfavourable heat buildup within the centrifuge
casing, due to the dissipation of heat energy from
the drive motor. The rotating beam rotor acts as a
large fan, drawing air through the gap surrounding
the rotary stack and expelling it through the drain
outlet in the base of the casing. Tests are currently
underway to investigate if this is sufficient to main-
tain the temperature within the casing at acceptable
levels, or if a dedicated air-conditioning unit will
need to directly service the centrifuge.
The centrifuge design also permits the beam
rotor to be interchanged with a drum channel, so
that the centrifuge can be used in either beam or
drum mode. ITS have commissioned TBS to design
and manufacture the drum channel and a tool table
Figure 7. Plane strain strongbox in “PIV mode”. than can rotate independently of the drum (with-

259
out the need for a twin concentric shaft). Delivery facilities, or for an established research group that
and commissioning of the drum is expected to take need to reduce demand on their large fixed beam
place in early 2010. centrifuge.

7 SUMMARY ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

This paper has described a new geotechnical cen- Funding for the centrifuge facility was provided
trifuge facility established at the Institute of Tech- by grants from the Institute of Technology Sligo.
nology Sligo in Ireland. The centrifuge, designed Further funding to initiate and support opera-
and manufactured by Thomas Broadbent & Sons, tion of the facility was received from the Institutes
is a 9 g-tonne beam centrifuge, that can spin two of Technology Ireland Office under the Strand 3
strongboxes at either end of a 0.75 m beam rotor at programme.
a maximum (effective radius) acceleration level of
300 g. A substantial steel casing surrounds the rotat-
ing assembly and is designed to contain the debris REFERENCES
in case of catastrophic failure. Although the cen-
Allersma, H.G.B. 1994. The university of Delft geo-
trifuge is small, the two plane strain strongboxes
technical centrifuge. Proc. Int. Conf. Centrifuge 94,
currently in use provide a total testing plan area of Singapore, 47–52.
just over 1000 cm2, which is generally sufficient for Dewoolkar, M.M., Goddery, T. & Dobroslav, D. 2003.
most applications in plane strain mode (e.g. White Centrifuge modeling for undergraduate geotechnical
et al. 2005; Hossain et al. 2005; O’Loughlin & engineering instruction. Geotechnical Testing J., 26(2),
Lehane 2009). The centrifuge is located in a generic 201–209.
engineering laboratory that did not require specific Gaudin, C., Randolph, M.F. & O’Loughlin, C.D. 2006.
structural or service requirements. The centrifuge New insights from model tests of foundation and
and associated work areas occupy less than ⅓ of anchoring systems in offshore geomechanics. Proc. 6th
Int. Conf. on Physical Modelling in Geotechnics, Hong
the 80 m2 laboratory floor space.
Kong, 1, 47–62.
The centrifuge features a rotary stack that allows Gaudin, C., White, D.J., Boylan, N., Breen, J., Brown,
for the passage of fluid, air (2 channels) and elec- T., De Catania, S. & Hortin, P. 2009. A wireless high-
trical signals or power (16 slip rings). An extremely speed data acquisition system for geotechnical centri-
compact and robust wireless data acquisition fuge model testing. Meas. Sci. Technol., 20(9), 1–11.
system, supplied by The University of Western Hossain, M.S., Hu, Y., Randolph, M.F. & White, D.J.
Australia, allows combined low and high speed (up 2005. Limiting cavity depth for spudcan foundations
to 1 MHz) sampling on 16 channels (expandable to penetrating clay. Géotechnique, 55(9), 679–690.
64 channels) at 16 bit resolution. The strongboxes Muir Wood, D.M. 2004. Geotechnical Modelling.
London: SponPress.
currently in use are rectangular plane strain cham-
Newson, T.A., Bransby, M.F. & Kainourgiaki, G. 2002.
bers with removable Perspex side panels, although The use of small centrifuges for geotechnical educa-
alternative strongboxes and testing arrangements tion. Proc. 5th Int. Conf. on Physical Modelling in
can be used. The plane strain strongboxes with Geotechnics: ICPMG ’02, St. Johns, Canada, 215–220.
optical viewing windows either side of the soil O’Loughlin, C.D. & Lehane, B.M. 2009. Nonlinear cone
sample permits optical measurement of planar soil penetration based method for predicting footing set-
deformation using a high resolution digital com- tlements on sand, J. Geotechnical Geoenvironmental
pact camera. A number of wireless pinhole cam- Engrg. ASCE, Published online: 26 August 2009, doi:
eras are mounted at various locations within the 10.1061/(ASCE)GT.1943–5606.0000228.
Schofield, A.N. 1980. Cambridge geotechnical centrifuge
centrifuge, which allows for a visual safety check
operation. Géotechnique, 30(3), 227–268.
against collisions and permits experiments to be Taylor, R.N. 1995. Geotechnical Centrifuge Technology.
viewed in real-time. London: Blackie Academic.
The design of the centrifuge is such that the White, D.J., Take, W.A. & Bolton, M.D. 2003. Soil defor-
beam rotor can be interchanged with a drum chan- mation measurement using particle image velocime-
nel so that the centrifuge can operate either in try (PIV) and photogrammetry. Géotechnique, 53(7),
beam or drum mode. Thomas Broadbent & Sons 619–631.
are currently finalising a drum channel and tool White, D.J., Randolph, M.F. & Thompson, B. 2005. An
table design suitable for retrofitting to the existing image-based deformation measurement system for the
geotechnical centrifuge. Int. J. Physical Modelling in
machine.
Geotechnics, 5(3), 1–12.
The centrifuge described here is a very attractive
and economical solution for expanding geotechni-
cal research groups that require access to centrifuge

260

View publication stats

You might also like