Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Family Intervention for
Ad l
Adolescents with Anorexia Nervosa
t ith A i N
Rhonda M. Merwin, PhD
Rhonda M Merwin PhD
C. Alix Timko, PhD
Nancy L. Zucker, PhD
y ,
Lindsay Martin, BS & Ashley A. Moskovich, BA
• Special
Special thanks to Lisa Honeycutt, MA, James
thanks to Lisa Honeycutt MA James
Herbert, PhD, Rebekah Teetsel
…and to all the families that are teaching us
h
how to do this work
d hi k
An invitation…
An invitation…
• To step into this space,
To step into this space
• in the service of something.
• Mud in a glass
di l
• and mountain climbing…
Dying to be thin? (we think it
Dying to be thin? (we think it’ss
about something else)
• Anorexia nervosa (AN) is a devastating condition
in which behavior is so profoundly narrow, rigid
and disconnected from experience that
d di t df i th t
individuals are not able to meet basic needs
– Highest mortality rate of any psychiatric illness
Highest mortality rate of any psychiatric illness
– 4‐20% of individuals with AN will die
prematurely as a result of self imposed
prematurely as a result of self‐imposed
starvation or suicide
STATE OF THE UNION
Empirically Supported Treatments
(ESTs) for Anorexia Nervosa
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy‐Enhanced
Enhanced
(CBT‐E)
CBT and CBT‐EE for AN
CBT and CBT for AN
• Ego‐syntonic
g y nature of disorder
– Attempts at direct change of thoughts are often met
with resistance
– Often less credible/acceptable
Often less credible/acceptable
• Behavior is rewarding in short‐term
• Relies on very verbal ways of knowing (not
Relies on very verbal ways of knowing (not
experiential)
• Use of distraction and other strategies may
reinforce avoidance
i f id
• In adolescents ‐> no real trials for CBT
And how’ss it going
And how it going
Source: Steinhausen, H‐C. (2002). The Outcome of Anorexia Nervosa in the 20th Century . American Journal of
Psychiatry, 159, 1284‐1293.
Family‐Based
Family Based Treatment
Treatment
• Phase
Phase I: Refeeding
I: Refeeding the patient
the patient
• Phase II: Negotiations for a new pattern of
relationships
• Phase III: Adolescent issues and termination
– e.g., Maudsley Approach
Family‐Based
Family Based Treatment
Treatment
• Effective for many families
Effective for many families
– Exception is those high in expressed emotion
• Best
Best for adolescents with a short duration of
for adolescents with a short duration of
the disorder; LT outcomes unknown
• Lack of focus on underlying etiological or
maintenance factors
Cumulative Prevalance Rates
Cumulative Prevalance Rates
Adolescence: Essential Time to
Intervene
• Decrease in gray matter in prefrontal regions
of the brain
• Changes in dopaminergic activity
• Increase in myelination in pre‐frontal cortex
• Increase in connections across cortical and
sub‐cortical areas
better coordination of emotions and
cognitions over the period of adolescence
Steinberg, 2009
Best time to intervene, ,
but are we intervening
g
in the best way?
• Pause
What it’ss like to be in the room
What it like to be in the room
• Sampling the therapist
Sampling the therapist’ss experience
experience
controlling
resistant
dying
starving difficult
diffi lt
thin
• Reactions
Slip inside the skin…
Slip inside the skin…
• Sample
Sample the experience of a parent of a child
the experience of a parent of a child
with anorexia nervosa
• PAUSE, BREATHE
PAUSE BREATHE
Slip inside the skin…
Slip inside the skin…
• Sample
Sample the experience of the adolescent with
the experience of the adolescent with
anorexia nervosa
Something is really
Something is really
wrong with you
wrong with you.
How do you protect yourself?
How do you protect yourself?
• Being
Being stripped of your armor
stripped of your armor
• Get what it would be like to have something taken
away from you… the only thing that has provided you
y y y g p y
with a sense of pride, comfort, safety, reprieve.
The functional nature of the ED
The functional nature of the ED
• So EDs are coping strategies, they
So EDs are coping strategies, they’re
re functional
functional
• Cope with what? The narratives
• Anorexia, my friend . . . . you are the source of my security,
my guard. . .
• I really need you to provide direction in everything I do.
• You let me hide from things I know that I can’t deal with…
f g
• Anorexia, you make me feel special…
• ‐> AN provides sense of safety, predictability,
mastery and control, eliminates ambiguity, etc ‐>
d l li i bi i
attenuates negative and promotes positive
feelings.
feelings
Racing against the clock
Racing against the clock
• Why
Why you can
you can’tt just treat the adolescent;
just treat the adolescent;
Inclusion of parents in treatment
• Deal w/ safety issue in session with parents,
Deal w/ safety issue in session with parents
allows the therapist to be more present with
the adolescent
the adolescent
Short term health Long term health
consequences consequences
• Weight loss • Osteoporosis/osteopenia
• Amenorrhea • Fertility issues
Fertility issues
• Thinning hair
• Cognitive impairment
• Lanugo
• Carotinemia • Death
• ANS down‐regulation
• Acrocyanosis
• Ed
Edema
• Hyperactivity
• Hypokalemia
• BREAK
Summary
• Effective
Effective treatments sparse without long
treatments sparse without long‐term
term
outcomes
• Know it
Know it’ss important to include parents, but
important to include parents but
unclear how
• Need to address features with prognostic
N d dd f ih i
significance and functional nature of
symptoms
ACT
• Emphasis is on the function of behavior and
workability, including but not limited to, the ED.
• Goal is to increase psychological flexibility, i.e.,
ability to contact the present moment, fully and
without defense, and cease or persist in
b h i
behaviors that would be effective given one’s
h ld b ff i i ’
values and what the environment affords.
ACT in a
question…
q Contact with the a
at thiss time,
e, in thiss
Present Moment
are you willing to situation?
have that stuff,
fully and without of your chosen
defense values
Acceptance Values
if the answer is
“yes” that’s Psychological
Flexibility
AND ddo what
h
takes you in the
direction
Defusion Committed
as it is, and not as Action
what it says it is,
Acceptance Values
psychological
flexibility
Defusion Committed
Action
Self as
Context
Contact with the
Acceptance and
Present Moment
Mi df l
Mindfulness
Processes
Acceptance Values
Defusion Committed
Action
Self as
Context
Contact with the
Present Moment Commitment
and Behavior
Change Processes
A
Acceptance
t Vl
Values
Defusion Committed
Action
Self as
Context
Acceptance‐based Separated Family
Th
Therapy (ASFT)
(ASFT)
– Separated Family treatment
Separated Family treatment
• High EE, caregiver burden, assoc features
• Adolescent and parent have different needs
– Adolescent ACT presented in individual format
– Parent Off the C.U.F.F. parent skills program
ff p p g
(Zucker, 2006) enhanced by ACT
– 20 sessions over 6 mths
• 16 separated
• 4 conjoint (biweekly)
ASFT Overview
ASFT Overview
MODULE 1: Setting the Stage
MODULE 1: Setting the Stage
• Therapeutic relationship in ACT
• Values as compass in the most general sense
• Adolescent:
– Th
Thoughts/feelings about treatment HW
ht /f li b tt t t HW
(begin to facilitate observation/openness)
– Creative representation of self HW
(foundation for values, self‐as‐context)
• Parents:
– Activating
Activating the family, observing values/barriers/urges, and
the family observing values/barriers/urges and
strengthening the parent team
– Teaching ED as coping, the dance of parenting, CUFF style,
targets and principles of behavior change
targets and principles of behavior change
MODULE 2
ED as Avoidance: Tools for Functional
ED as Avoidance: Tools for Functional
Assessment
• Adolescent Timeline
Adolescent Timeline
Positive Negative
Reinforcers Reinforcers
Internal Provided a sense of Reduced painful or
control, safety, uncomfortable affective
predictability, or experiences, such as guilt or
dependability; Organized shame; Reduced ambiguity,
ambiguity
the world; Increased chaos, feelings of
sense of mastery or pride ineffectiveness or low self-
(felt special, moral, or worth
dominant)
External Was the source of Took away uncomfortable
compliments, attention, sexual attention, weight-
envy or adoration of related teasing, isolation, or
others. Lead to increased responsibility
care-taking from others
Assessment is informed by Parents
Assessment is informed by Parents
• A
A key parent tool for
key parent tool for
understanding and
intervening upon
intervening upon
their child’s ED: The
Eating Disorder
Eating Disorder
Wave
Broadening our view
Broadening our view
• Expand
Expand to functional classes
to functional classes of avoided events
of avoided events
and avoidant repertoire.
– Food/eating takes on the psychological function of
Food/eating takes on the psychological function of
other painful content and is thus aversive
– What would you rather think about…
What would you rather think about
• 801, cards exercise/role play, case example
(AL)
Long‐Term
Long Term Costs
Costs
• Explore
Explore the limits of system, how it has gotten
the limits of system how it has gotten
in the way (if it has).
Stuck
Stuck
Difficult thoughts, feelings, Behaviors aimed at decreasing
bodily sensations contact with these private events
(e.g., the thought “I am fat and no (e.g., following dietary rules,
one will like me,” feelings of worthlessness,
ll l k ”f l f hl avoiding social situations
avoiding social situations,
stomach tightness, anxiety) Achieve, achieve, achieve, …)
The System
th t ttraps
that
Short term relief
Short‐term relief
(e.g., Feel successful, a moment
of respite)
Long‐term costs
Refining the Contract
Refining the Contract
• Build
Build a therapeutic contract around
a therapeutic contract around
something that is personally meaningful to
him/her
MODULE 3
Open, Centered, Engaged
d d
ADOLESCENTS
• Teach observation and acceptance of
experience (as it unfolds in the present
experience (as it unfolds in the present
moment), identifying valued‐directions and
active choosing.
active choosing.
• Build a sense of self that is independent of
content.
content
What we
aimingg for,, Contact with the a
at thiss time,
e, in thiss
Present Moment
in each are you willing to situation?
moment… have that stuff,
fully and without of your chosen
defense values
Acceptance Values
if the answer is
“yes” that’s Psychological
Flexibility
AND ddo what
h
takes you in the
direction
Defusion Committed
as it is, and not as Action
what it says it is,
Acceptance Values
psychological
flexibility
Defusion Committed
Action
Self as
Context
“ See….That
See That’ss the stuff I was talking about
about.”
Bad News Radio!
Bad News Radio!
Giving you nothing but the best,
best all
day long, NON-STOP ROCK!
Which Path Will You Choose
in This Moment?
Old, familiar, leads to here. New, feared, but vital, meaningful.
• Pause
PARENT SKILLS
(OFF THE CUFF ACT IFIED)
(OFF THE CUFF ACT‐IFIED)
Core Skills: Surfing
Core Skills: Surfing
Emotiional Intensityy Increases
Ration
nal Cognition Decreases
Staying focused on the value‐guided direction
Values and Self‐Awareness
Values and Self Awareness
Perfectionism and Values
Perfectionism and Values
Values
Reinforcement
Reinforcement
Extinction of Differential
Eating Reinforcement
Disorder of Other
Symptoms Behaviors
Open, Centered, Engaged
PARENTS
• Purpose
– To address ED behaviors
– To be role models
To be role models
– To directly shape healthy (approach‐based) coping
in their child
in their child
Addressing barriers to implementing
parent skills
parent skills
CHOOSE
on, ambigguity…
ehaviorall
s, confusio
mpeting be
MOVE
EXPOSURE
memories, com
Negatiive thoug
predispositions
DEFUSION
ACCEPTANCE
MINDFULNESS
MODULE 4: Behaving Flexibly
MODULE 4: Behaving Flexibly
• Building
Building broader and broader repertoires of effective
broader and broader repertoires of effective
action
– adolescent takes increasing responsibility
g p y
– in‐session symbolic approach activity (S10)
– add healthy coping to parent sheet
add healthy coping to parent sheet
MODULE 3: Conjoint Sessions
MODULE 3: Conjoint Sessions
• Structure and content
Structure and content
• Other issues
– Blind versus nonblind
Bli d bli d weight
i ht
– Function of parents’ “need to know”
– Session order – parent vs. adolescent
• Experiential
Experiential exercise (or role play) with
exercise (or role play) with
discussion of components of the hexaflex,
targets and strategies
targets and strategies
ACT Model of Problems in Living
Contact with the Present Moment
Dominance of the conceptualized
feared future & regretted past
Values
Lack of values clarity;
Acceptance Dominance of pliance and
Experiential
avoidant tracking; values
avoidance
avoidance; values as burden
this
psychological
psychological
inflexibility
space
Attachment to conceptualized
self; Impoverished sense of self
Self as Context
The ACT Therapeutic Model
Contact with the On-going, nonjudgmental
Present Moment contact with psychological &
environmental events as
they occur
Acceptance Values
Active embrace of Chosen qualities
thoughts,
g , feelings,
g , of p
purposeful
p
bodily sensations psychological action, instantiated
`
flexibility moment by moment
Defusion Committed
Decreasing the literal Action
quality of thought; Recognizing Building patterns
the process, not just the product of effective action
linked to chosen values
Self as
Locus or perspective Context
from which private events
are experienced
Hexaflex and AN: Some Unique Issues
and AN: Some Unique Issues
• Values
• Self‐as‐context
• S i i h
Staying in the present moment
• **More at Panel Discussion tomorrow
Conditioned aversives in the
therapy
h room
• Observing behavior in session
– Patient
– Therapist
• Imagine your most difficult patient
ASFT
• Phase I: Development of treatment manuals/materials
p
• Phase II: Recruitment of 6 families to pilot and refine
p
intervention
• Phase III: Recruitment of an additional 16 families to
test effectiveness (incl feasibility, acceptability, effect
size estimates to power larger trial)
ASFT Enrollment
ASFT Enrollment
– Inclusion criteria
• Aged 11‐18
• Meets criteria for AN
• Appropriate for outpatient care
Appropriate for outpatient care
• At least average intellectual functioning
• Living at home
– Exclusion criteria
• Actively suicidal
• Psychosis, current substance abuse
Psychosis current substance abuse
• Learning disability or PDD
Description of First 4 Participants
Description of First 4 Participants
◊ Age range 12
Age range 12‐16
16
◊ Variety of family structures
◊ Treatment familiar and naive
EDE Subscales – Adolescent (Parent Report)
EDE Subscales – Adolescent (Parent Report)
Restraint Eating Weight Shape Global
Concerns Concerns Concerns
801 2 20 (3 60)
2.20 (3.60) 0 20 (1.20)
0.20 (1 20) 0 00 (1 25)
0.00 (1.25) 0 38 (1 50)
0.38 (1.50) 0 69 (1.89)
0.69 (1 89)
804 3.80 (3.80) 1.20 (1.40) 3.60 (3.50) 2.63 (3.25) 2.81 (2.99)
807 4.00 (3.60) 1.20 (0.00) 3.20 (1.50) 3.88 (2.63) 3.07 (1.93)
810 5.80 (4.60) 1.50 (2.40) 1.50 (1.25) 4.63 (3.25) 3.36 (2.88)
801
50
45
40
35
MI Percenttile
30
25
20
BM
15
10
5
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Session Number
804
35
30
25
MI Percenttile
20
15
BM
10
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Session Number
807
70
60
50
BMI Percentile
e
40
30
20
10
0
1 2 3 4 5 6
Session Number
810
45
40
35
BMI Percentiile
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
1 2 3 4 5 6
Session Number
STAY TUNED
STAY TUNED.
Contact us.
Contact us.
Rhonda.merwin@duke.edu
CTimko@Towson.edu
Nancy zucker@duke edu
Nancy.zucker@duke.edu
A review
A review…
• What features of AN are particularly well‐matched to
acceptance‐based strategies?
p g
– Acceptance‐based strategies address avoidance and control of emotions
and other motivational states common among indv with AN. These
strategies might also be well‐matched to this patient population given
the ego‐syntonic
the ego syntonic nature of the symptoms and the emphasis on
nature of the symptoms and the emphasis on
experiential (rather than verbal ways of knowing).
• What are the core components of the protocol designed to
treat adolescents with AN?
– ACT based individual therapy for the adolescent.
– Parent skills training within an ACT framework.
– Setting the stage for treatment, functional assessment,
open/centered/engaged, behaving flexibly, conjoint sessions.
/ t d/ d b h i fl ibl j i t i
• What is one strategy or exercise adapted for use with this
population?
– Timeline used for functional assessment.
Ti li d f f ti l t
– Wave as metaphor for observing internal experience.