Professional Documents
Culture Documents
April, 2021
Contents
1. Introduction.............................................................................................................................................................. 1
2. Objective.................................................................................................................................................................. 2
3. Specific Objectives.................................................................................................................................................... 2
4. scope of the proposal................................................................................................................................................. 2
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
5. Methdology.............................................................................................................................................................. 3
6. Customer Relationship management Model................................................................................................................. 3
6.1. creating good customer relationship management (CRM).........................................................................................4
6.2. Introducing CRM Model for retail and SME banking:..............................................................................................5
7. Relationship Mangment Models of other banks............................................................................................................7
7.1. AB /Awash Bank/................................................................................................................................................. 7
7.1.1. AB and its Retail and SME Business Model/...........................................................................................................7
7.1.2. AB and its WHOLESALE BANKING business Model............................................................................................9
1.1. Dashen Bank...................................................................................................................................................... 10
1.1.1. Retail and SME Banking..................................................................................................................................... 10
1.1.2. Crporate Banking................................................................................................................................................ 11
1.2. WegageN Bank S.C............................................................................................................................................ 12
1.3. Bank of Abyssinia............................................................................................................................................... 13
2. RM model comparison among other private banks.....................................................................................................14
3. RM Engagment criteria............................................................................................................................................ 15
4. REcommendation and conclusion.............................................................................................................................15
4.1. Proposed RM Model for high end retail and SME customers..................................................................................15
4.2. RM model for corporate customers.......................................................................................................................17
4.2.1. General Background........................................................................................................................................... 17
4.2.2. Proposed change on Corporate RM Model............................................................................................................19
4.2.3. Role and responsibility of RMs............................................................................................................................ 20
4.2.4. Role and responsibility of Relationship Officers....................................................................................................22
4.2.5. Role and responsibility of Security administrator...................................................................................................23
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Abstract
Following the implementation of the bank’s 3rd corporate strategic document, NIB is
destined to be the leading commercial bank of Ethiopia by the end of the plan period.
With the aim of accomplishing this objective, the corporate strategic document is also
structured downwards from the five pillars to the specific tasks and activities to be
performed by each work unit of the Bank. Among these, Pillar II- Customer Experience
Excellence and Pillar IV-Operations and technology Excellence were designed to include
activities of enhancing the existing customer relationship model and formulation of a
hybrid structure for centralizing key processes of the Bank. The majority of the activities
under the latter have already been executed with in the plan period including the
centralization of credit activities either at District or HO level as per the Target
Operating Model/TOM/.
Customer segmentation and value prepositions being at the final stage of their
implementation, with the direction of EMC V/P-Customers and Channel has formulated
a team to come up with a proposal of placing a relationship management model for
Retail and SME Customers, and re-designing the Bank’s Corporate Banking model. As
such, the team has gone through best practices of other banks and the model placed so as
to integrate it with the existing way of doing business to come up with workable
recommendations.
After thoroughly looking in to the existing relationship management model of the Bank,
its target operating model and having benchmarked best practices of peer banks, the
study suggested that a relationship management model shall be placed at District Offices
for high value Retail and SME customers which shall further extend to all credit
customers falling above the jurisdiction of District offices.
As per the proposal, Retail & SME Relationship Mangers will be placed at the District
Offices and report to the District Manager. However; the study clearly outlines
conditions that shall be fulfilled for the effective implementation of the model as detail
outlined under.
The study also suggests centralizing Corporate Banking Services by restructuring the
responsible unit in a manner that enables it to provide end to end service to prospective
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
corporate customers. The restructuring takes into account practical challenges faced in
the prevailing workflow and corporate banking strategic goals the Bank aspires to
achieve by the end of the plan period.
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
1. INTRODUCTION
Unlike old times present day banks have greater scope and wider opportunities to serve their
customers in the best possible manner. The technological advancements and the understanding of
customers as the makers and creators of businesses have geared banking business in to a whole
new era. Nowadays banks are more concerned about maintaining existing customers rather than
acquiring new ones. This revolution in Customer Relationship Management (CRM) is considered
as the new “mantra” of marketing. Originally, marketers were concentrating more on acquiring
new customers for the products and services offered by them. This was made possible through
huge investment on advertising and sales promotion activities. But, there is a paradigm shift from
customer acquisition to customer retention. The focus is shifted from acquiring new customers to
retaining the existing ones as relationship marketing through a well-treated and satisfied
customer would highly benefit the bank in acquiring new customers without the need to go
through all the troubles resulting in huge marketing expenditures.
Following the implementation of the 3rd corporate strategic document NIB’s customers are
classified as Corporate, Retail, SME and IFB customers. The corresponding TOM of the bank
also dictates the centralization of some critical banking operations at the Head Office and District
level. In lieu of the above this document is prepared with the intention of proposing a workable
relationship management model for high end Retail and SME Customers and a introducing new
process model to the Bank’s Corporate Banking Department.
Page | 1
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
2. OBJECTIVE
This proposal has an objective of pursuing the strategic direction of the Bank to centralize critical
operations at HO and District level with the aim of increasing the value generated from high end
customers, Bank’s profitability and customer loyalty through formulating and implementing new
customer relationship management model for High end Retail and SME customers and redesigning the
prevailing model for Corporate Customers.
3. SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES
Propose a workable relationship management model for high end Retail and SME Customers;
Propose a single point of contact for high end Retail and SME customers;
Revise the workflow in a manner that insures single point of contact for Corporate customers;
To Instill a swift communication as well as administration route for high end Retail, SME and
Corporate customers;
To instill efficient operational security and good technique of assuring asset quality through an
integrated and closely watched operational environment.
The proposed new and revised Relationship Management models are to be applicable on selected
high end Retail, SME and Corporate Customers of Nib International Bank S.C in any of their
dealings with the Bank.
5. METHDOLOGY
The document employed both primary and secondary data. As a primary data RMs currently
working at other banks was interviewed to get a glance of their current practice, while written
materials on relationship management models of both local and international banks were taken as
a secondary data in formulating this proposal.
Page | 2
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Customer relationship management refers to the art of managing good customer relationships
and prospective customers. It is all about understanding who your customers and potential
customers are, and nurturing the relationships you have with them. It is about identifying
customer expectations and how you meet or go beyond their expectations.
A customer relationship model seeks to improve the relationship between a business and the
customer. For this, they drive new trends and provide profits for current and future operations
and investments.
Awareness It is the first touch point where prospects try to know more about a certain brand
as a whole.
Discovery Then you learn and identify the needs of the prospects and share information to
fulfill their requirements.
Evaluation Moving ahead the prospects compares and evaluates your products/services with
your competitors.
Intent Finally your prospect is convinced and made a decision of buying from you.
Purchase After making the payment the deal is done and the prospect converts into your
customer.
Page | 3
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Loyalty Make a follow-up after purchase to determine customer success with your product
and ask for referrals.
Customers are the heartbeat of all businesses. Therefore, creating good customer relationships is
crucial for business success. Through good and bad times, maintaining a healthy customer
relationship with all your customers will help in sustaining the performance of your business.
This reason is making/forcing businesses to develop an excellent customer relationship for
maintaining good performance. Developing good CRM and marketing helps your business to set
better customer relationship management examples.
Developing good customer relationship management:
Results in good customer experience – CRM is about creating relationships with your
customers so that, they enjoy positive experiences when interacting with your brand.
Results in the growth of customer retention rates – Positive experiences fuels
customer retention. Your customers are loyal towards your brand and turn as brand
advocates.
Results in high level of customer satisfaction – When you meet your customer
expectations with your exceptional service it boosts satisfaction level and they are likely
to return to your business again.
The growth of retail and SME banking is expected to be an important milestone in Ethiopian
banking sector development. It has immense opportunities in growing countries like Ethiopia.
Following their huge economic impact on sub-Saharan countries these segments have become a
major driver in the Ethiopian financial system. Ethiopia being the 2nd largest populous country in
Africa attending to the needs and requests of the retail and SME market would play a greater role
in the economic development of the country.
According to the survey question of Africa Finance Forum Blog that asked African banks about
their focus among Multinational companies, large local companies, retail clients or SMEs, three
Page | 4
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
important results came out. First, SMEs are reported as the main strategic focus by 60% of
banking groups in Africa. This reflected the intensifying competition in many sub-Saharan
Africa banking markets forcing banks to move out of their comfort zone and to maintain
profitability by going after new borrowers.
Retail clients were the next most important strategic focus for banking groups in sub Saharan
Africa/SSA/ and are reported as most strategic by 30% of banking groups. This share has risen
remarkably since 2016, reflecting the growing reliance by banks on deposit financing. This rising
strategic focus on retail clients in return is resulting in a growing tendency of savers to entrust
their savings with banks. It implies an opportunity in terms of helping individuals to save and for
banks to lend more in local currency.
Retail banking is a form of mass banking in which the financial needs of individual consumers
are dealt with. All the products and services are designed and offered to satisfy the financial
needs of the individual customers, though these customers belong to different economic,
educational, cultural and social background.
Hence, the products and services offered are also varied. Throughout the world it has been felt
that main focus of the bank in the retail sector should be customer service. It is the acceptance by
the customers of the banking products and his satisfaction with the services that bring profit for
the banks in this sector. Unlike corporate banking where corporate customers have a well-
defined financial policy and projects, in retail banking the responsibility lies on the banks to
approach the customers, find out their financial needs and problems, designing the products and
services, marketing and selling the products to the satisfaction of the customers.
Studies show that Africa’s population is set to double by 2050 and with it will come a need for
widespread access to financial services. But before we get to this point, banks must tackle low
banking penetration rates within the existing population. To do this, banks need to develop new
approaches and new ways of connecting with their customers, creating sustainable business
models that improve financial inclusion, help them to connect with new market segments,
improve their reach and keep costs down.
Even though it will be neither economical nor wise to assign a personal banker or relationship
manager for all retail and SME customers, managing the relationships of selected high end retail
Page | 5
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
and SME customers through a dedicated personal banker would highly benefit the bank in
various perspectives.
Managing the SME/Retail client relationship, allow banks to move beyond lending to better
capture the SME Banking opportunity. Customer management is a broad concept that essentially
covers: (1) understanding customer needs; (2) matching customer needs to the best offers in
terms of price, product, service level, and delivery channel; and (3) effectively managing the
critical moments during the customer life cycle.
Most of the banks in emerging markets servicing the SME/Retail segment are not fully capturing
the segments opportunity partly due to lack of the necessary capabilities to manage these
customers. Better customer management has been shown to directly affect the profitability of
banking institutions. This might involve improving segmentation and acquisition, actively cross-
selling and up-selling, identifying and retaining retail and SME clients, or improving collection
practices.
According to the International Finance Corporation, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs)
make up 99% of the 125 million companies in the world, and these SMEs contribute a staggering
49% of global GDP.
Despite the market size, banks are missing this opportunity as they are not properly addressing
this highly lucrative and accessible market.
Customers of AIB
Retail Customer
Wholesale (Enterprise
(Individual/personal)
Customer and SME customers
Page | 6
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Retail and SME banking wing is led by Chief which is equivalent to our bank’s VP post.
The incumbent has four departments under his/her supervision and these are: -
Regions/in our case District offices
Small and Medium Banking Department (having 10 RMs)
Personal Banking Department
RMs around nine in numbers
Branch operation on Division level
E-Banking Department
The major responsibility of this wing is supervising branches under its respective geographical
areas. Have a loan discretion limit up to 5 million and FCY allocation authority for importers and
approves travel allowances for oversees travelers.
This wing has around 10 RMs who are responsible for more than 90 Customers each. Theses
RMs have the responsibility of forwarding loan request of customers to Analysis Department for
approval within the range of 5 to 25 million which now has been revised to 10 to 30 million, by
conducting due diligence.
Each RMs has own budgets for Deposit, Loan, Number of customers, times of customer visit,
Referral marketing to personal & corporate wings.
The other main task entrusted for this wing is to search for potential Embassies, NGOs, Micro
Finance institutions & Tour and travel companies and recruit the same as per the pre-established
budget set for each customer type. Each RMs are the first contact point for their assigned
customers request related to FCY, loan & any support from the bank. Apart from this RMs are
also required to give timely reply for requests of their assigned customer by contacting
concerned organs of the bank.
Page | 7
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Individuals with an annual average deposit balance of above birr 1 million/ monthly salary of
birr 90,000.00 and above are given especial attention by this department. Diasporas, Expats,
Pilots, Company CEOs, NGO Directors, individuals having regular dividend payments are some
of the individual or personal customers classified as high Net worth individuals (HNIs).
Requests of consumer loans, mortgage loans, vehicle purchase loans, Travel allowances,
children tuition fees, Medical payments in FCY are handled by this department. Each HNI
his/her own RMs in the Department as a single point of contact in every dealing with the bank.
The other group called Ultra net worth individuals (UNI) who have huge annual income than
HNIs will get bank’s special personal services at their convenience, transport service to and from
Airport when they have business travels in addition to the privileges given to HNIs.
Currently the department has more than 9 RMs and each RM is responsible for 125 HNIs.
As SME Banking RMs, personal RMs has their own budgets for number of customers, loan,
regular visit program, referral marketing, and collaborating in marketing campaigns with
branches.
This wing also conducts due diligence for personal loan requests between 5m to25 million.
This wing is responsible for branch expansion and other activities but not responsible for
resource mobilization.
7.1.1.5. E-Banking Department
This department exclusively works related to electronic payment and agent banking related
activities.
The Awash Bank’s wholesale banking is led by Chief Wholesale Banking Officer at a Vice
president capacity. Under the chief’s office, there are two departments
Corporate Banking Department,
Page | 8
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Under each Department, there are Relationship Managers who are responsible with providing
services to customers. RMs in Business Banking Department handles customers with loan and
advances of more than Birr 30 million up to 70 million, while RMs in Corporate Banking
Department handle loan and advances above Birr 70
Administration of files and disbursement of loans processed at the two Departments is handled at
a separate division, Credit Documentation & Disbursement. The unit is responsible with
preparation of loan contracts, registration, loan as well as security document filing, and
disbursement of loans.
District offices/Directors/
All Branches
Retail customers are individual customers (no legal entity) who make use of individual services
of the bank and personal loans. This are classified in to the following categories based on their
disposable income:
Page | 9
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Page | 10
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
District offices:
District offices have the authority of approving all loans to the extent of Birr
15,000,000.00/except export loans/
For all loans above Birr 10,000,000 the chief Retail and MSME Banking will participate
as a loan committee member.
Retail and SME Head compatible with corporate RM at district level acts as a committee
member
Branches:
Branches have the responsibility of completing due diligence for all loans to the extent of
Birr 15,000,000.00 except export loans which is treated at HO under corporate baking.
RM is assigned for the above purpose and the RM with the Branch Manager have
responsibility of recruiting potential customers to the branch;
No loan sanctioning limit at the branch
The Corporate Banking wing is led by a Chief Corporate Baking Officer. There are three
departments under him:
Page | 11
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Each Department is responsible with handling respective corporate clients’ loan requests of more
than Birr 30 million. The Departments have pool of RMs and ROs working under the RMs. The
relationship managers recruit potential customers, negotiate terms with customers, serve as a
contact person, manage contracts and authorize disbursements. ROs, under the RMs, maintain
documentation, conduct clerical works, maintain records, prepare reports, and assist RMs in
credit management.
Corporate
Commercial customers and
Retail customers
The above classification is made based on a weighted score calculated on aggregate result
of customers’ sales turnover, credit exposure with the bank, income generated from the
customer and customer credit risk grade.
Same way as the Relationship managers in our bank an RM at Wegagen Bank is solely
responsible to loan and advances matters only.
All credit affairs are centralized at head office and district level. Currently District offices have
the mandate of approving loan and advance requests of Birr 10 million and below while any loan
and advance requests above Birr 10 million is approved at Head Office.
District offices have a mandate to approve FCY for traveling purpose and they can also transfer
staffs with in the district.
Branches have no mandate on loans and advances except making follow up on proper
repayments.
As of now the bank has around 16 RMs at head office and three RMs per District who attends to
loan requests of customers. All creditors of the bank are attended through a relationship manager.
Contract signage, registration, loan disbursement and security handlings are currently being done
Page | 12
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
at Head office and District level. All RMs have one officer under for this purpose as well.
Currently a single RM attends to about 40-45 customers at Head office.
The bank is currently undergoing through a study to change the credit value curve under each
category and the responsibility of the RMS.
At BOA RMs are assigned only for credit customers classified based on their loan exposure.
Loan and advance facilities to the extent of Birr 5 million are assigned to be the discretionary
lending limit of District offices. All loan and advances above 5 million are dealt with Credit
Management Department at head office.
The bank classifies its credit customers as commercial credit customers (customers with a loan
exposure up to birr 50 million) and Corporate Credit Customers (loan exposure limit above Birr
50 million)
Due to the restructuring being undertaken and the shortage of man power, currently an RM
administrates and follows up to 100 customers.
Relationship Managers are also assigned to credit customers at District office and the office has a
discretionary lending limit up to Birr 5,000,000.00.
This Department appraises credit files forwarded from the credit management Department.
Page | 13
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Branches:
Branches are tasked with the responsibility of resource mobilization and other operational
matters outside credit matters.
3. RM ENGAGMENT CRITERIA
Value preposition being a unique sentiment to be given to selected and priority customers only, ,
RMs are only assigned to corporate Customers and the newly proposed RM model is to be
applied to the list of high end Retail and SME customers satisfying the under listed criteria;
Page | 14
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Retail and SME Customers with an average yearly deposit balance ranging from 10-20
million;
Retail and SME customers with a foreign currency generating capacity of USD 300,000
to USD 700,000.00/annum
Retail and SME customers with an outstanding loan of above Birr 5 million and less or
equal to Birr 20 million.
Corporate customers with an outstanding or new loan request of above Birr 20 million,
Corporate customers with a foreign currency generating capacity above USD 700/annum
or any currency equivalent to it;
Corporate customer with an average annual Deposit balance above Birr 20 million
With the aim of filling current practice gaps, in lieu of the Bank’s target operating model and
benchmarking the practices of peer banks, the team has proposed the below captioned RM
Model for high end Retail and SME customers of the bank.
Without the need to make a major structural change, the bank may assign Retail and SME
Relationship Manager who reports to the District Manager at the District Office.
Page | 15
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
District Office
Retail and
SME RM (Job
Grade XII)
Customer
Relationship
Officer
Page | 16
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
It has been more than eight years since the Bank adopted customer relationship management
concepts in one of its core operational functions. The concept was adopted at the time as it was
found mandatory to have advanced banking product retailing system that completely transforms
the prevailing working system so that the Bank stays competitive and achieve strategic goals in
the modern dynamic business environment.
The limited effort made till now affirmed that having a clearly identified work process flow that
specifically target high value clients is highly essential to develop a customer-friendly system,
short waiting/delivery time and efficient use of the Bank’s human and time resources, that brings
about customer satisfaction, customer retention, better market share and brand image.
However, as time goes by, due to various reasons, the department was not able to graduate to its
aspired level. Hence, the Bank was not able to fully reap the benefits the business model could
generate. The basic practical shortcomings encountered by the Bank after the adoption of the
Page | 17
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
CRM concept emanate from its limited scope in the adoption of the concept, constricted capacity
of the established unit and limited IT support.
These factors have crippled the effort towards building an end-to-end customer service for the
segregated high value market segment. As a result re-designing the corporate banking process is
essential to bring about structural change and attain strategic targets.
Page | 18
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
4.2.2. PROPOSED CHANGE ON CORPORATE RM MODEL
Director -Corporate
Banking Department
Corporate Security
RMs Administrator
Relationship
Officers
RMs are expected to develop and maintain up to date knowledge of financial industry,
economy, market conditions, rates, vendors, competitions, among others. They should
Page | 19
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
treat people with respect; keep commitments; inspire the trust of others; work ethically
with integrity; uphold organizational values; accept responsibility for own actions;
The proposed revision on the RM model for Corporate Customers looks like;
RMs to be RMs are responsible for but
Customers assigned not limited to Budget
Corporate Customers At Head office, Centrally maintain and manage Loan and
Corporate Banking security documents, manage advances, Deposit,
Role and responsibility of RMs shall include but not be limited to;
Create strategies and closely work with customers to boost the Bank’s brand;
Help promote and maintain a positive company image with in the society;
Create and enforce plans that will help meet the needs of customers;
Page | 20
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Gather and analyze all information necessary to present a financing request to Senior
Management or Loan Committee for approval; meet with existing or potential customers;
visiting sites of loans; negotiate loan terms and conditions with customers, and refers or
comes up with proposals for decision;
Ensure that credit inquires and all mandatory filings are researched to determine credit
worthiness and appropriate collateral positioning are achieved;
Attempts to ensure that individual loans are risk rated correctly when reviewing loans for
loan committee submission;
Page | 21
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Ensures that appropriate insurance policies are maintained on loans and/or collaterals
held to secure loans at all times,
Cross sells and up sells the Bank's other products and services;
Timely and periodically recognizes appropriate interest incomes on loans and advances
when they are earned and/or paid;
Page | 22
RM Model for Retail, SME and Corporate Customers
Ensures that signed loan, guarantee, mortgage or other contracts are complete and within
terms in accordance with approval conditions,
Arranges for and ensures the proper registration of all securities offered as collateral at
the proper governmental registrar body and payment of stamp duty charges finalized, if
necessary;
Ensures that all loans handled have proper hazard/risk insurance and follow-up for timely
inform responsible organs for renewal of insurance policies;
Ensures that all security documents are collected based on approval terms and are kept
confidentially in a safe custody,
Ensures that all contracts are in line with their statutory period requirements and timely
demand responsible organs for re-signing, if necessary,
Page | 23