You are on page 1of 8

Community Environmental

Health Concerns and the


Nursing Process
FOUR ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH
NURSING CARE PLANS
by Christine King, BSN, BA, RN, and Philip Harber, MD. MPH

nvironmental health problems are gaining occupational environmental health problems. Communi-

E increased recognition. Nurses can playa key role in


the multi-disciplinary approach to these problems.
Experience and education in counseling, along with sen-
ty environmental health problems generally result from a
specific environmental health threat within a geographi-
cally defined area. Industrial spills and toxic waste
sitivity to client needs and beliefs. make nurses particu- releases near residential areas may lead to exposures.
larly valuable environmental health team members. Vari- Conversely, occupational risk is defined by employment
ous authors have discussed the nurse's role in environ- rather than geography.
mental health (Phillips, 1995; Pope, 1995; Rogers, 1994; Exposure in community settings is often less well
Salazar, 1994). Because nurses are pivotal in providing defined than in occupational settings, where industrial
ongoing care in ambulatory care settings, the need to be hygiene measurements describing the levels of exposure
actively involved in providing care to clients with envi- are frequently available. In addition, particularly suscep-
ronment health issues is paramount. The environmental tible individuals-the elderly, children, and persons with
health nursing care plans presented here provide general significant diseases-are present more often in commu-
guidelines for ways in which the nurse can effectively nity settings than in worksites. Because exposures are
approach community environmental health problems. defined geographically, the population is often less well
defined than in worksites. Finally, exposure levels in
BACKGROUND community settings are usually lower than in occupa-
Community environmental health problems may be tional settings; however, the duration of exposure usual-
defined as the potential exposure of multiple members of ly is greater than in occupational settings. For example,
a community to a chemical, biological, radioactive, or a work exposure may last 8 hours a day for 5 days a
other hazard. Table 1 summarizes several ways in which week. but the community member's exposure is for 24
community environmental health problems differ from hours a day, 7 days a week.
Nurses can and should take responsibility for clients
with environmental health needs (Lipscomb, 1994). As in
ABOUT THE AUTHORS: other areas of nursing practice, nursing diagnoses and
Ms.. King is formerly Nursing Coordinator, Del- care plans can define methods to help nurses provide care
for clients with environmental health issues. This article
Amo Montrose Project, and Dr. Harber is includes nursing diagnoses approved by the North Amer-
ican Nursing Diagnoses Association (NANnA) (Rantz,
Professor of Medicine, UCLA Occupational- 1995). Nursing diagnoses and nursing care plans help the
Environmental Medicine, Department of nurse organize goals and plans, and document and vali-
date the importance of nursing care. Although aspects of
Medicine, University of California, Los Angeles. environmental health may be unfamiliar to some, the
approach outlined in this article integrates various
aspects of environmental health and nursing into the eas-

AAOHNJOURNAL
20
ily accessible and applicable format of a nursing care
plan. Use of nursing care plans demonstrates areas in
which situation specific information needs to be obtained TABLE 1
(e.g., from textbooks or health departments).
Differences Between
DEVELOPMENT OF NURSING CARE PLANS Community and
The community environmental health nursing care
plans outlined in this article were developed with the use Occupational
of several information sources. The authors participated Environmental Health
in the operation of the Del AmolMontrose Environmen-
tal Health Clinic, a large, community oriented evaluation Exposure Situations
and counseling program established to address the needs
of a community with potential exposure to chemical Community Occupational
agents. The chemicals came from two industrial plants. Who is Geographically Defined by
One plant produced synthetic rubber and may have at risk defined employment
released a variety of chemicals such as benzene, ethyl- history
benzene, naphthalene, and others. The other industrial Information Often poorly Better defined,
plant produced the pesticide DDT. Although the plants about exposure defined often with
have closed, many community members and elected rep- industrial
resentatives expressed concerns about residential conta- hygiene
mination of air, soil, and water. measures
Other contributions to the development of the care Susceptible Common Unusual
plans included experience with other environmental persons
health projects in which the UCLA Environmental/Occu-
Identification of Imprecise More precise
pational Medicine unit participated, and conversations
at risk persons
with environmental health nurse leaders. The information
obtained from these experiences was synthesized and Level of Generally low Often higher
organized into the format of nursing care plans. exposure
Environmental health concerns were divided into
four categories, by types of concern:
• Physiological. as a separate client entity. The most obvious environ-
• Behavioral. mental health concerns are those related to physiological
• Emotional. symptoms. At the Del AmolMontrose Environmental
• Knowledge deficit. Health Clinic, a majority of clients stated their own
The categorization helps the nurse identify various health problems motivated them to seek care through the
types of concerns that need to be addressed in communi- clinic. While not measured directly, anecdotal experience
ty exposure situations. reflected that a number of people knew about the clinic
and potential chemical exposure for over a year. Howev-
NURSING CARE PLANS er, these individuals did not come to the clinic until they
Four nursing care plans were developed. Each care experienced worrisome symptoms.
plan focuses on a different aspect of the human response Physiological environmental health concerns cover a
to an environmental hazard including physiological, broad spectrum. Table 2 lists appropriate assessments,
behavioral, and emotional. Knowledge deficit regarding nursing diagnoses, plans/interventions, and evaluations.
environmental health also is addressed in a separate care Concerns range from specific and serious health prob-
plan because of the key role information plays in human lems (cancer, asthma) to less well defined entities such as
responses. Common problems in each category are intro- skin problems and fatigue. The nurse needs to determine
duced and discussed. Assessment guidelines, lists of rel- if the problems are related to an environmental exposure
evant potential NANDA nursing diagnoses, interven- by careful assessment of the situation, including assess-
tions, and evaluation criteria are included. ment of both the individual's factors and the community
exposure factors.
Physiological Concerns and Symptoms Stress response to the threat of environmental conta-
Associated with Community Environmental mination also may cause physiological symptoms
Health Concerns (Bowler, 1994; Dayal, 1994; Neutra, 1991). Stress
These nursing care plans are focused on the individ- response symptoms can be similar to nonspecific envi-
ual client. Because the client is a member of a communi- ronmental symptoms such as skin problems and fatigue.
ty of concerned persons, the plans indicate means to Again, thorough and thoughtful assessment by the nurse
explain community concerns to the individual client and is necessary.
to use community resources as appropriate. Although not Sensitivity is required when exploring the cause of
the focus of these four plans, nurses also can play impor- physiologic health complaints. Community members
tant roles in communicating with the community partner may believe that exploring non-environmental causes of

JANUARY 1998, VOL. 46, NO.1 21


TABLE 2
Nursing Care Plan: Physiological Concern
Nursing Plan!
Assessment Diagnoses Interventions Evaluation
Symptom history (focus on Potential for injury Identify potential irritanV Irritant or toxin
those relevant to exposure) related to exposure toxic agent (e.g., from identified or
county or state health removed?
departments)

Exposure history (e.g., Fatigue Identify exposure pathway Symptom relieved?


history of contact with soil, and obtain a risk assessment
water, or other sources (Arenson, 1995)
of exposure)
Inspection (for skin Alteration in skin Strategize with client Public health or
rashes, etc.) integrity (may how to eliminate hazard resolved
increase dose) or minimize exposure being addressed?
(Sandman, 1986)
Appropriate physiological Alteration in protection Administer appropriate Steps taken to
testing (may increase or screening and/or bio prevent such
decrease exposure) marker tests (e.g., blood exposure in the
lead or DOE levels, future (e.g,
spirometry, etc.) policies,
protocols)?

Presence of environmental , Recommend treatmenV Clear document-


toxins (amount of materials further evaluation as ation of potential
specific agents involved) appropriate (follow up exposure and
testing, etc.) health for future
reference

Monitor client's health


(long term) as appropriate
(e.g., blood lead testing
every 6 months; arrange
for future follow up)
Review as part of larger
community (e.g., is this
agent affecting others?)
Collect information in a
standardized format.

their problems is an attempt to deny there is an environ- program illustrates the use of biomarkers. Blood or bone
mental health threat. The client deserves an explanation lead concentrations are specific measures of exposure.
of the rationale for the nurse's plan of action. Exposure assessment, such as asking what year a child's
Another physiological consideration in environmen- house was painted or evaluating a client's occupational
tal health is the presence of exposure biomarkers. A bio- history,.is an important element for helping to determine
marker is a biologic indicator of exposure or effect of if a blood lead test should be performed.
exposure measured in a bodily fluid or exhaled air (Que- Assessment includes evaluating the presence of
Hee, 1993). Exposed clients may have toxins in their physiologic problems. In addition, assessment for com-
bodies without awareness of any noticeable physiological munity environmental health clients involves determin-
effect. In this case, known potential for exposure is the ing if there are any factors that would increase dosage.
only indication to test for a biomarker. A lead screening For example, alterations in skin integrity may increase

22 AAOHN JOURNAL
TABLE 3
Nursing Care Plan: Behavioral Concern
Nursing Plan!
Assessment Diagnoses Interventions Evaluation
Barriers to desired Noncompliance Have client participate Client taking steps
behavior (e.g. economic, in planning how to to minimize
exposure?
geographic, etc.) minimize exposure
(individual action: e.g.,
physical avoidance,
wash fruits, etc.)
Resources available (e.g., Ineffective coping Refer for support services Client taking care of
family, social services, etc) (denial vs. over- as necessary (financial, own health?
reaction) housing, etc.)
(Pope, 1995)
Cultural aspects Alteration in health Lobby for needed Client's basic needs
of behavior maintenance (e.g., services/funding being met?
balanced diet, exercise) (educate client about
community action groups)
Stress symptoms Denial Encourage general health Client is making
promoting activities (e.g, informed decisions?
balanced diet, regular
exercise)
Health promoting activities High risk for injury Resources are
(e.g., increasing household ("environmental equity" available that can
cleaning practices) [Soliman, 1993], higher meet client needs?
than average risk of
exposure)
Coping mechanisms (denial Identify successful
vs. over-reaction) coping strategies and
encourage these

the client's dose of toxins if there is contact with soil and/or disease processes. These clinical interventions are
toxins, etc. unique to specific types of exposures and are not
The main intervention for many environmentally described in detail here. However, depending on the route
related health problems or health threats usually is to of exposure, certain common methods can be used. For
minimize exposure. Minimizing exposure is performed example, the nurse can teach the client about soil meth-
on two levels: individual actions and environmental ods such as washing home grown vegetables thoroughly
remediation. The nurse and the community members (or not using them).
may be involved in both aspects of minimizing exposure.
The nurse has a particularly important role in individual Behavioral Patterns Relatedto Community
efforts to control exposure by helping the individual Environmental Health Concerns
client understand the need to take personal actions to In environmental health, the client's behavior relat-
minimize exposure if necessary. This is discussed in ed to potential exposure is of primary concern to the
more depth in subsequent sections of this article. nurse. Behavioral concerns are addressed by the nursing
Environmental remediation includes measures that care plans shown in Table 3. As mentioned earlier, two
limit the entire community's exposure to the hazard. main behavioral aspects are important to minimizing
Such measures include actions such as physically remov- exposure: individual action and environmental remedia-
ing the toxins and putting a barrier between the commu- tion. Individual action includes activities such as physi-
nity and the contamination. Other possible interventions cal avoidance of exposure sources, efforts to remove the
include treatments to remove the toxin from the body toxin, and increasing household cleaning practices. The
(e.g., chelation) and treatments to manage symptoms nurse needs to be aware of the factors surrounding client

JANUARY 1998, VOL. 46, NO.1 23


TABLE 4
Nursing Care Plan: Emotional Concern
Nursing Plan!
Assessment Diagnoses Interventions Evaluation
"Outrage" factors Fear Encourage client to participate Client makespositive
(Sandman et at, 1986) in remediation efforts (in statements about
(most importantly order to restore control) self/situation, exhibits
sense of loss of control) a positiveattitude
Subjective statements Anger Encourage communication Client is successful in
about emotions and with other community social performances
concerns (assess members (create network) (e.g.holdinga job,
individual concerns) schoolwork, parenting,
etc.)
Emotional stressors (e.g., Anxiety Therapeutic listening Client verbalizes feelings
finances, health, litigation) (nonjudgmental)
Cultural expressions Powerlessness Referfor professional Client seeks support
of emotions counseling if necessary when needs it (e.g.
from family, counselor,
religious group)
Social support network
(e.g., family, social services, etc.)

behavior which may include emotional, social, cultural, partner while showing community members how to
and economic factors. A client may be concerned about advocate for themselves (pope, 1995).
emissions from a local industry, but cannot afford to Ineffective coping mechanisms related to environ-
move. A family's tradition of fishing may be threatened mental health hazards can lead to unhealthy behaviors in
by contaminated waterways or a tradition of raising dealing with environmental related problems. Addition-
chickens may be impacted by soil contamination. Denial ally, the individual may have difficulty coping with
of a hazard may lead to continuation of dangerous expo- problems in other areas of life.
sure. Thus, the need for thorough assessment and plan-
ning of exposure avoidance is essential. Alternatively, Emotional Responses to Community
the nurse needs to encourage the client not to over-react Environmental Health Concerns
if a true threat does not exist. A nursing care plan for working with clients with
In addition, it is important to emphasize general emotional concerns is provided in Table 4. Revelation of
health maintenance. A healthy body is less susceptible to and inquiry into community environmental health haz-
many environmental insults. Assessment of general ards can evoke strong emotional responses. This is so
health maintenance practices is crucial. This is especial- common that researchers have identified the factors that
ly true in populations most likely affected by environ- can influence the public's emotional response in such sit-
mental hazards, such as minorities and low-income peo- uations. These factors have been termed as "outrage" fac-
ple (Pope, 1995; Soliman, 1993). In addition to focusing tors and are related to the risk perceived by the public
on behaviors related to environmental health concerns, (Arenson, 1995; Sandman, 1986). Risk is perceived as
the nurse may need to help the client gain access to greater with each of the following characteristics:
resources to meet basic needs. • Involuntary.
In attempting to decrease exposure to environmental • Unfamiliar.
hazards, the nurse deals with larger issues of "environ- • Uncontrollable.
mental equity." For example, hazardous waste sites are • Controlled by others.
disproportionately located near minority communities • Unfair.
(Soliman, 1993). Disadvantaged populations receive dis- • Memorable.
proportionate amounts of exposure. Thus, behavioral • Fatal, delayed.
concerns also may include consideration of community • Artificial.
and political activism. The nurse may act as a role • Undetectable (Arenson, 1995).
model, advocating for the disadvantaged community Other factors may contribute to perceived risk in spe-

24 AAOHN JOURNAL
TABLE 5
Nursing Care Plan: Educational Needs
Nursing Plan!
Assessment Diagnoses Interventions Evaluation
Knowledge of basic Knowledge deficit Explain basic environmental Demonstrates knowledge
environmental health health principles (e.g. of environmental
principles and specific exposure pathways, health principles?
situation (see plan) variability in (e.g., Does client know
susceptibility, etc.) whether drinking water
supply is a concern
locally?)

Educational leveV Potential for injury Educate about toxicology Aware of the specific,
developmental stage related to knowledge of chemical of concern local environmental
of learning (keep deficit (e.g., will and steps to be taken health concerns and how
it simple) continue to eat in regards to specific to minimize exposure as
unwashed vegetables environmental health necessary? (can
even if soil is hazard give precautions hel
contaminated) she should take)

Language best Explain importance of dose Expresses understanding


understood by client in determining risk of individual risk
assessment? (e.g., Is
client's exposure higher
or lower than those of
other community
members?)
Discuss with client individual Can name information
risk assessment (e.g., resources?
personal risk of specific
future diseases)
Provide culturally sensitive Can client identify which
education in appropriate disease(s) may be
language (both written caused by the chemical
and oral formats) agent and which
are never related?
Encourage client to
ask questions and
to seek answers; inform
client about resources
(e.g., library, Poison
Control Center, etc.)

cific situations. However, those characteristics are com- Community environmental health threats are viewed as
monly associated with enhanced emotional response of "exotic" because the chemical cannot be visualized.
community exposures to environmental contamination. Other factors to consider in community exposure are
Therefore, community environmental health threats are the emotional stressors evoked by residential relocation ,
more likely to induce severe emotional responses. Con- loss of property value, and litigation pressure (Ostry,
versely, the threat of injury from motor vehicle accidents 1993). Again, the nurse must carefully identify the actu-
is perceived as less threatening because it is familiar and al concerns of each individual client.
immediate. Clients also are less emotionally affected by One particularly effective intervention in dealing with
threats they personally chose (e.g., downhill skiing). such emotional upheaval is to increase the community

JANUARY 1998, VOL. 46, NO.1 25


TABLE 6
Useful Resources for Community Environmental
Health Concerns
Environmental Health Resources Community Contacts
Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Community organizations
Registry
1600 Clifton Rd., N.E. Civic groups
Atlanta, GA 30333 Schools
(404) 639-6360 Ethnic groups
Environmental Protection Agency Local low cost health care providers
401 M St., SW Local social service agencies
Washington, D.C. 20460 Social advocacy groups
(202) 260-2080 Environmental advocacy groups
State/county health departments
Environmental health research centers (e.g., universities)
Occupational health resources
National Institute for Occupational Safety and
Health
1600 Clifton Rd.
Atlanta, GA 30333
Mail stop 0-32
(404) 639-3691

See Pope (1995) for a more comprehensive list of available environmentalhealth resources.

members ' involvement in mitigation efforts. Many of the The intake interview process at the Del Amo/Mon-
outrage factors described above relate to a perceived lack trose Clinic allowed for the client to indicate desire for
of control. Thus, increasing client control over the situa- additional information. Many clients were concerned
tion can help positively direct emotional energies. Active about issues not directly related to a current health com-
participation in developing individual health care plans is plaint, but to the future. Common concerns were related to
one way to increase the client's feeling of control. Active children's health and future cancer risk. Aubin (1994) stud-
involvement is related to social support (Bowler, 1994). ied participants in a clinic established in response to PCB
The nurse also can encourage participation in com- (polychlorinated biphenyl) exposure. Researchers found
munity efforts to work with the environmental health sit- there was considerable interest in learning about future
uation and to prevent future exposures. The client can effects, rather than a sole focus on current problems.
become involved with environmental remediation. Com- Education may be the main intervention available to
munity members may be able to attend community meet- deal with concerns . Clients need to understand the basis
ings, lobby local politicians, and help inform others in the for environmental health effects and interventions. This is
community about potential and actual health concerns. also the case when the effects of the potential exposure are
Individuals also may want to get involved in even larger partially unknown. For example, the combined impact of
environmental health issues, such as industrial waste reg- multiple and varied exposures over a lifetime may be
ulations and land allocation. impossible to predict. Also, much of what is known about
the effects of toxic exposures are from laboratory testing
Educational Needs In Community and occupational studies. The differences in community
Environmental Health Concerns exposure may limit the application of previous research. In
Knowledge deficits are common in environmentally addition to explaining what is known, the nurse also must
affected communities. Stress related symptoms may carefully explain the limits of current knowledge and why
decrease with increased knowledge. Feelings of empow- such limitations exist. This helps prevent clients from
erment and esteem can improve with increased knowl- receiving and believing incorrect information.
edge . Health promoting activities can be encouraged with The basics of environmental health must not be
increased knowledge. Specifics related to meeting educa- overlooked during client education. The nurse needs to
tional needs are provided in Table 5. ensure that the client understands exposure pathways,

26 AAOHN JOURNAL
variation in susceptibility, the effects of dosage, as well
as the specifics surrounding individual exposure prior to
discussing specific exposure minimizing recommenda-
tions and communicating individual health risk (Brooks,
1995; Lipscomb, 1994; Neufer, 1994). Community Environmental
Health Concerns and the
ROLE OF NURSING CARE PLANS
Nursing care plans are integral to professional care Nursing Process
regardless of the role the nurse is assuming. Established
care plans and protocols already exist for many disease
Four Environmental Health
processes and some chemical exposures. These should be Nursing Care Plans.
used when appropriate. Although much variation of King, C., & Harber, P.
potential community environmental health hazards
exists, there are distinctive common issues in community AAOHN Journal 1998; 46(1), 20-27.
environmental health hazards. By definition, these are
not isolated incidents or concerns. Thus, when develop-
ing a client's plan of care, both individual and communi-
ty issues need to be addressed. The general care plans
1. Many clients have concerns about envi-
ronmental exposures.

presented can be modified for specific exposure concerns


and integrated with existing protocol.
Nurses must playa major role in responding to com-
2. Nursing care plans can be adapted to
guide practice related to environmental
health issues including physiologic, behav-
munity environmental health concerns. Some aspects of ioral, emotional concerns, and educational
care for such clients may require specialized technical needs.
knowledge. However, with proper nursing care plans,
nurses can provide appropriate care for clients with whom
they work. The plans serve as guides to practice. To effec- 3. Experience and education in counseling,
along with sensitivity to client needs and
beliefs, make nurses particularly valuable
tively implement these plans, nurses need to collect neces-
members of the environmental health team.
sary information about the exposures in the specific situa-
tion. For example, if the concern is about a specific chem-
ical (such as mercury or DDT), the nurse needs to become
familiar with the possible effects of the specific agent. Neufer, L., & Narkunas , D. (1994). Hazardous substance releases at the
The nursing process is applicable across all nursing community level: A practical approach to analyzing potential health
practice, and nursing care plans are tailored to meet var- threats. AAOHN Journal, 42(7), 329-335
ious client needs. Nurses inexperienced in environmen- Neutra, R., Lipscomb, J., Satin, K., & Shusterman, D. (1991). Hypothe-
ses to explain the higher symptom rates observed around hazardous
tal health can easily access the appropriate specialists waste sites. Environmental Health Perspective, 94, 31-38.
with the skills and knowledge needed in a particular sit- Ostry, A.S., Hertzman, C., & Teschke, K. (1993). Community risk per-
uation. Nurses with advanced education in these areas ception: A case study in a rural community hosting a waste site
can serve as valuable resources. Many other resources used by a large municipality. Canadian Journal of Public Health ,
(see Table 6) also are available to assist nurses in gain- 84,415-418.
Phillips , L. (1995). Chattanooga Creek : Case study of the public health
ing skills and knowledge to work with environmental nursing role in environmental health . Public Health Nursing , 12,
health problems. 335-340.
Pope, A.M., Snyder, M.A., & Mood, L.H., eds. (1995). Nursing, health,
REFERENCES and the environment. Washington, DC : National Academy Press.
Arenson , C. (1995). Commun icating about environmental health risks. Que Hee, S., ed. (1993). Biological monitoring: An introduction. New
Berkeley, CA: Public Health Foundation . York: Van Nostrand Reinhold .
Aubin , J., Potvin, L., Beland , E , & Pineault , R. (1994). Utilization of Rantz, M.I ., & LeMone, P., eds . (1995 ). Classification of nursing
a specialized clinic following an ecological accident. Medical diagnoses. Proceedings ofthe North American Nursing Diagnosis
Care, 32, 1-14. Association 11th Conference. Glendale, CA :CINAHL Information
Brooks, S.M., Gochfeld, M., Herzstein, J., Jackson, R.I. , & Schenker, Systems .
M.B., eds. (1995). Environmental medicine. Chicago: Mosby Year- Rogers B. (1994). Linkages in environmental and occupational health:
book, Inc. Assessing, detecting, and containing exposure sources. AAOHN
Journal , 42(7), 336-343 .
Bowler, A.M., Mergler, D., Huel, G., & Cone, J.E. (1994) . Psychologi-
Salazar, M.K., & Primomo , J. (1994 ). Taking the lead in environmen-
cal, psychosocial, and psychophy siological sequelae in a communi-
tal health : Defining a model for practice . AAOHN Journal, 42(7 ),
ty affected by a railroad chemical disaster. Journal of Traumatic
317-324.
Stress, 7, 1-2.
Sandman , P.M., ed. (1986). Expla ining environmental risk: Some notes
Dayal, H.H., Bavanowski , T., Li, Y., & Morri s, R. (1994). Hazardous
on environmental risk communication. New Brunswick, N.J.: Rut-
chemicals: Psychological dimensions of the health sequelae of a
gers University Environmental Research Program.
community exposure in Texas. Journal ofEpidemiology & Commu-
Soliman, M.R.I., De Rosa, C.T., Mielke, H.W., & Bota, K. (1993). Haz-
nity Health, 48, 560-568.
ardous wastes, hazardous materials and environmental health equi-
Lipscomb, J. (1994). Environmental health : Assuming a leadership role
ty. Toxicology and Industrial Health , 9, 901-912.
(Editorial). AAOHN Journal , 42(7), 314-315.

JANUARY 1998, VOL. 46, NO.1 27

You might also like