Professional Documents
Culture Documents
88-95 (2021)
Prospects for studyıng bats of Karabakh as part of the Lesser Caucasus fauna
N.A. Hasanov
Institute of Zoology, Azerbaijan National Academy of Sciences, A.Abbaszade Str., 504 Block, 1128 Pass.,
Baku AZ 1004, Azerbaijan
For correspondence: hasnijat1212@gmail.com
Received: September 29, 2021; Received in revised form: October 17, 2021; Accepted: October 19, 2021
The article highlights the gap in studying the bat fauna in Mountainous-Karabakh and adjacent ar-
eas within the Lesser Caucasus as no research studies were conducted in this part because of the
prolonged territorial occupation. Comparative description of bat fauna is being provided between
Mountainous-Karabakh and the Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic (AR) which reveals a close fau-
nal similarity, one of the reasons of which is the local movements of bats between these sides. Nine
species of regional bat fauna (19 species or 58% of local bat fauna) carry local conservation status.
Most species tend to decline in global populations. The importance of studying the bat fauna of the
Lesser Caucasus, including the bats in Karabakh, in more modern approaches and using stationary
and mobile detectors which are already being applied in house by the author as well as other modern
equipment (using acoustic and remote tracking methods) remains necessary for studying certain eco-
logical peculiarities of bats. This article presents echo spectrograms of four bats as examples.
88 http://dx.doi.org/10.29228/jlsb.26
Available online 30 December 2021
Prospects for studyıng bats of Karabakh as part of the Lesser Caucasus fauna
a gap for a faunal overview of the overall Natural MATERIALS AND METHODS
Province within Azerbaijan. The investigation of
the Nakhchivan AR bat fauna occurred recently Field surveys and collation of materials in Na-
(Raxmatulina, Hәsәnov 2009) when analogical re- khchivan AR were conducted in 2006-2008 jointly
search studies are not applicable to the bat fauna of with Dr. I.K.Rakhmatulina and in 2013 inde-
Mountainous Karabakh (seven long-term occupied pendently.
surrounding districts) and the available info in this The study area mainly covered the central and
sphere dates back to the before 1980's (Сатунин, eastern regions of Nakhchivan, ranging from the
1912; Верещагин, 1959; Гаджиев, 1967; distinctive semi-arid landscape of the Aras valley
Дубовченко, 1969; Алекперов, 1966; up to the alpine meadows. The main target was to
Алекперов, Рахматулина, 1975); Фаттаев, 1978; revisit already known bat shelters, colonies as well
Рахматулина, 1970, 1980, 2005). as to reveal new roosts (hibernation sites, summer
In addition to the changed natural conditions shelters). Over the study period we have recorded
that occurred over time, we assume that still un- 14 bat species, 153 individuals captured (Mehely's
known to us various anthropogenic changes that and greater horseshoe bats, lesser mouse-eared bat,
occurred during the occupation period have not brown long-eared bat, eastern barbastelle,
gone beyond the bat fauna. Considering the time Schreiber's bent-winged bat) were banded and re-
difference and the changes it is important to re-ex- leased back to nature.
plore the bat fauna in Karabakh as an integral part Generally accepted methods of observation
of regional biodiversity. It also should be noted that and counting were applied during the field surveys
the Lesser Caucasus bat fauna is the least studied (Кузякин, 1950; Громов, Гуреев, 1963; Horacek
compared to other natural provinces in Azerbaijan. et al., 2000; Kunz et al., 1996). Via using the ultra-
Scientific literature also contains no or occasional sound detectors, we have recorded many synan-
information on bat species inhabiting the regions thropic bat species among which the predominant
such as Gedabek, Dashkesen, Goygel, Goranboy, ones were common and Kuhl’s pipistrelles. This
Tartar, Ganja and its surroundings. Over the last 40 article also covers the materials from collections of
years, no required research studies have been car- ANAS Institute of Zoology, the Zoological Mu-
ried out in the territories of Nakhchivan and the seum of Moscow's State University, and the Russia
Lesser Caucasus bordering with the former front Institute of Zoology (based on Rakhmatulina,
line as well as Armenia as it was not safe. In view 2005). We physically inspected those areas (natu-
of all of this, for the detailed study of the Lesser ral and manmade structures) which could poten-
Caucasus chiropterofauna within Azerbaijan, there tially be suitable as summer or winter roosts for
is a need for deeper investigation of bats in Moun- bats. All captured individuals were identified to
tainous Karabakh covering about 30% of all mam- species level, age, sex and reproductive status were
mal species via application of newer technol- determined, measured (weight, length of body,
ogy/methodologies. forearm, and tail), banded and released back. Day-
To understand the work scope of bats fauna time surveys were based on visual observations
investigation in the Lesser Caucasus we have com- (shelter designation), and night surveys on field-
pared in this paper the faunal composition of Na- routes with active bat detectors (Pettersson D200).
khchivan (own investigation data for 2006-2008, Bats were recorded directly in their shelters or cap-
2013 years) and Mountainous Karabakh with sur- tured and identified with nets. All methods were
rounded territories (based on literature data dated aimed at determining the species composition of
back to 1880s). Along with a comparative study of bats and compiling the transect records on the
chiropterofauna, it also provides a general impres- flight intensity of bats.
sion of how rich the bat fauna is in these two areas Bat fauna composition related info is based on
with a distinct specific climate and orographic con- only literature materials dated back to 1980s
ditions. (Рахматулина, 2005).
89
N.A. Hasanov
90
Prospects for studyıng bats of Karabakh as part of the Lesser Caucasus fauna
new species, Hypsugo savii, was found in October 16 bat species in Nakhchivan and 19 in Mountain-
2006 in the village of Kalaki, Ordubad district. ous Karabakh. Future comprehensive investiga-
The number of speleofil bat species here in tions would clarify and reveal a more precise com-
different seasons ranged from 120 individuals for position for both areas. As shown in Table 1, nine
R. ferrumequinum, up to 60 for R. mehelyi, more of these species are registered in the 2nd edition of
than 500 for M. blythii, and up to 500 for M. the Red Book of the Azerbaijan Republic. Only 6
schreibersii. of all bat species recorded are with the stable trend,
The largest breeding colony of M. blythii and 3 unknown, and only one with the increasing
M. shreibersii was revealed in the “Bat's Nest” global population trend. The rest of the species
cave in the Bilav village of the Ordubad district have a decreasing population trend globally. De-
(Figure 3) with the total number of individuals of spite recording of T. teniotis (European free-tailed
more than 1,000. bat) only once near Shusha city back in 1950) there
It was impossible to monitor the border zone is a probability to register these species also in Na-
of the Nakhchivan AR with Armenia – this is the khchivan and even the Greater Caucasus. Figure 1
site where the Kotam-Kilit cave system which is is a schematic map of recorded bat locations in the
home to a number of the priority species such as Lesser Caucasus covering Nakhchivan and
Blasius's horseshoe bat, mediterranian horseshoe Karabakh.
bat and greater horseshoe bat as well as the eastern Local seasonal movements (change of sum-
barbastelle is located. It should be noted that more mer and hibernation roosts) occur between the
interesting groups of bats, as well as large breeding caves of Nakhchivan and Karabakh caves (Rakh-
colonies of Schreiber's bent-winged bat and Lesser matulina, Hasanov 2001).
mouse-eared bat species, are inhabiting the Or- Studying of bats by application of new meth-
dubad National Park. ods. Bats have a hidden lifestyle, roosts are not
Unfortunately, the Maralik Cave in the easily reachable in most cases, hibernation and
Shahbuz district, one of the dynamic shelters and breeding colonies are very vulnerable to be dis-
previously recorded for Blasius's horseshoe bat, turbed, from health and safety perspective of
mediterranean horseshoe bat, greater horseshoe bat known and emerging zoonotic diseases (Kuzmin,
(10) has lost its important role as a shelter for bats Bozick, et al., 2011; Hasanov, Guliyeva, 2020) it
after being used by shepherds. is necessary to reduce as much physical contact as
Among the explored shelters, it is important to possible with all wild animals including bats and
highlight the Sirab Cave. This place is known as it is recommendable to investigate various ecolog-
the wintering roost for horseshoe bat species (R. ical aspects of bats by application of newer and
mehelyi, R.ferrumequinum), which have been pro- remote methods particularly taking into account
tected since the middle of the XX century. The first the uneven and difficult relief of the Lesser Cau-
species has not yet been obtained, however, in casus. With the use of remote equipment, bat’s
summer and autumn seasons the Schreiber's bent- ethology can be studied in detail such as long-dis-
winged bat and the lesser mouse-eared bat become tance migration as well as local movements be-
very common here. This cave is one of the main bat tween hibernation and summer roosts, patterns of
shelters in the central part of Nakhchivan AR. It is pathways and foraging routes, etc. Stationary
recommended to protect this site by declaring it a (passive) and mobile detectors can be used to de-
natural monument. It is recommended to give sim- termine the relative number and activity intensity
ilar status to the "Bat's Nest" cave (Figure 3) in of transects and stations. Recording and pro-
Bilav village of Ordubad district. This cave is a cessing of ultrasounds with dedicated programs
shelter for large breeding colonies of two locally allow determining the species without capturing
and internationally protected species - M. blythii them physically. One of the priorities is to create
and M. schreibersii. an ultrasound library of the Lesser Caucasus’s
Similarity between Mountainous Kara- bats via obtaining spectrograms, specific for vari-
bakh and Nakhchivan bat faunas. Via compar- ous species (Figure 2) and can be used for species
ing species composition of both areas’ bat fauna it determination remotely.
was revealed very close similarity between them –
91
N.A. Hasanov
Fig. 1. Bat registration locations in the Lesser Caucasus - Nakhchivan (2006-2008, 2013) and
Karabakh (literature data covering the period over 1900-1980)
92
Prospects for studyıng bats of Karabakh as part of the Lesser Caucasus fauna
Fig. 2. Spectrograms of four bat species obtained by echo-meters in the Lesser Caucasus.
Note: each spectrogram is specific to the species and recognizable particularly for the species from various genera
“Bat Nest”, Bilav village, Ordubad district - 2009 Myotis blythii individuals – Nakhchivan city - 2009
Application of passive detectors into the bat Muxtar Respublikasının yarasaları (Mammalia,
surveys has been started since 2020 in the Greater Chiroptera) vә onun mühafizә problemlәri. AMEA
Caucasus. Remote control (distant) tools for the in- Naxçıvan Bölmәsinin Xәbәrәlәri. Tәbiәt vә Texniki
vestigation of various ecological peculiarities of elmlәr seriyası, 2: 194-205.
small size mammals including bats have not been Талыбов Т.H. (2001) Naxçıvan MR-nın biomüx-
practiced in Azerbaijan yet. tәlifliyinin antropogen transformasiyası. Nax. Re-
gional Elm Mәrkәzinin әsәrlәri, 6: 81-84.
REFERENCES Алекперов Х.М. (1966) Млекопитающие юго-
западного Азербайджана. Баку: АН Аз.ССР,
Babayev S.U. (1999) Naxçıvan Muxtar Respub- 144 с.
likasının coğrafiyası. Bakı: Elm, 199 s. Алекперов Х.М., Рахматулина И.К. (1975) К
Raxmatulina İ.K., Hәsәnov N.Ә. (2009) Naxçıvan фауне рукакрылых Азербайджана. Матер. по
93
N.A. Hasanov
Qarabağda yarasaların Kiçik Qafqaz faunasının tәrkib hissәsi kimi öyrәnilmә perspektivlәri
N.Ә. Hәsәnov
Mәqalәdә Kiçik Qafqazın yarasalar faunasının tәfәrrüatlı tәdqiqi perspektivindәn Dağlıq Qarabağ vә әtraf
rayonların uzun müddәt tәddqiq olunmaması ucbatından bir boşluq kimi qaldığı vurğulanır. Әdәbiyyat mә-
lumatları әsasında Dağlıq Qarabağ vә müәllif tәdqiqatları әsasında Naxçıvan MR xireptofaunasının növ
tәrkibinin müqayisәsi verilir vә nә onlar arasındakı bәnzәrliyә diqqәt çәkilir ki, bunun sәbәblәrindәn biri
dә yarasaların bu iki әrazi arasında lokal yerdәyişmәlәrin olmasıdır. Region yarasalar faunasının (19 növ
94
Prospects for studyıng bats of Karabakh as part of the Lesser Caucasus fauna
vә ya yerli yarasa növlәrinin 58%-i) 9-növü yerli qorunma statusuna malikdir. Növlәrin böyük әksәriyyә-
tinin qlobal populyasiya trendi azalandır. Kiçik Qafqaz vә o cümlәdәn Qarabağ xirepterofaunsının daha
müasir üsullarla tәdqiq olunması vә ölkәdә müәllif tәrәfindәn artıq tәtbiq olunan stasionar vә sәyyar detek-
torlar, digәr avadanlıqlar vasitәsilә yarasaların akustik vә mәsafәdәn izlәmә metodları ilә bir-sıra ekoloji
xüsusiyyәtlәrinin araşdırılmasının vacibliyi bildirilir. Dörd yarasa növünә aid exo-spektoqaramlar әyani
nümunә olaraq mәqalәdә tәqdim olunur.
Перспективы изучения летучих мышей Карабаха, как части фауны Малого Кавказа
Н.А. Гасанов
Ключевые слова: Малый Кавказ, летучие мыши, хирептерофауна, биоразнообразие, новые методы
95