wuer Blé-acrt yaddié ce eee = WR/Phone > 91-22-6656 4071 am wawiFax : 91-22-2961 7721 Mumbai Port Trust Qo - €Fevermail: emambyrmailom a Estate Division, 3rd floor. Viaydeep, 8.V. Marg, Ballard Estate, Mumbai - 400 001, Wo. EMVAS (GV/RTT To, Shri Param Patel Patel Studio, Limda Choke Bardoli, Near Bardoli Police Stati Surat. Pin: 394601. State: Gujarat. Es- SoDe+/Reqds f. Cpto sir, Sub; Your application dated 16.12.2018 under Right to Information Act 2005, received in this Division on-line on 16.12.2018 and 03.01.2019 from CPIO, Shri. N. G. Mirajkar. With reference to your application under RTI Act referred above, It Is to state that as per the guidelines for Public Authorities under RTI Act 2005, it is not required to create information, or to interpret information, or to solve problems raised by the applicant or to furnish replies to hypothetical questions. The information sought by you vide your subject application dated 16.12.2018 may be held by another CPIO of MbPT i.e.Shri S. B. Lagwankar-Suptdg. Engineer to whom the application is already transferred on-line on 28/12/2018 for further necessary action in the matter. If you are aggrieved by the reply/ decision, you may prefer an appeal within 30 days from receipt of this reply to the Appellate Authority i.e. Smt. . G, Patwardhan, Sr. Deputy Secretary (GAD) & Appellate Authority, ‘Mumbai Port Trust, Port House, 2" Floor, ‘S.V. Mare, Mumbai 400 001. E-mail id: spatwardhan@mbpt Tel No. 66564047, Yoursaithtuly, sdf— (Shri H. P. Kulkarni) Central Public Information Officer & Estate Manager- (I/C) )/)\0 Tel.No.022-66564452 -to.pte 3847 &7JAN cc. to Shri. S. B. Lagwankar,CPIO and Suptdg Engineer.C&'s Department, fr ~ Forinforrnation (shot kur) CPIO & Estate Manager- (1/C) Tel.No.022-66564452a RYT REQUEST DETAILS (smtetang arte faaxoy > BRAY] oP Registration Number (iofteeor eam : ‘Type of Receipt GA BT WER) : Name (IA) : Address (W5T) : State RTE) : Phone Number (®t ay) : D Aes ¢ Status FRAA(Rural/Urban) = Is Requester Below Poverty Line ? slit 2s Email Amount Paid (CRT BT UTA) : Request Pertains wv (SigGae Fraferfeac daftra @) : Information Sought (TMT FA): swe 02 JAN 2019 et Ot ne MUMBAI PORT 08 4 amare er MPTRS/R/2018/50072/1 Date of Receipt 16/12/2018 fea et arte : Online Receipt Language of Request English corre array = param patel Gender (fa): Male PATEL STUDIO, LIMDA CHOKE BARDOLI, Near bardoli police station, SURAT, Pin:394601 Gujarst Country RN Indie Details not provided Mobile Number +91 ‘saz; 8141006997 parampatel69@gmail.com Rural Education Status : Graduate » j India Me Citizenship Status“ camera) Mac iaanttm! —— Medeortamen PH recipient) - ¢ il ) - S.B. Lagwankur Respected Sir/madam, Jam Param Patel architecture student from Ramun Bhakta Schoo! fof Architecture college) Surat Gujarat. Tam in my 1th currently doing my thesis, I am designing a Symphony orchestra Cone Hall along with western classical music Academy for my thesis, Note: all this is hypothetical and not real Academically tor the thesis, we need to identify a site on paper. The design will be best in class, with foreign standard which will not compromise any aspect of Western classical music. it is a need of the hour to build a Symphony orchestra Concert Hall in India which Indian lacks, Lam proposing it in Mumbai keeping in mind the high demund the long queue for concert of Zubin Mehta in Mumbai Mumbai has a Bollywood background too. For th ye justification and rough idea for what it will look like I am sendi data from my research, Thaye identified a tan near prineess Dock in Mumbai port trust to propose my in my colleve. There are three main tnetors to keep in mind for psing the sitehy shee aaj. jp dann. ples dart! ee cag ap roe oT. A diss pe Re. tim. F Z Hoe he Yn x. ape ty OF OW website Th may chommcbsad Te Sere. Fe May hes inlenahs b yan aye When catiy Ae taki des By D = ) 4. Ce Ghee Is Fhe hele wenn te be provided fo The priced voles 0) Dye Ire Teper a THs os anvelahd fo Fae) feck toaok -E atconrtowy Si mas " Nsalen esadicahon { large an also uae youmin oun, ite 7 etled a 3 sarvia eq +" Bd Ww PES Het) Kaun law 2b by bev. Para Laks a “19 oat mevevite pInformation- Exempted SE document is available with PIO) S.No. | Questions Reply Court/€IC decision 1 a Information to be denied under section 7(9) 1. | Whether voluminous: No Central Board of Secondary Education and Information to be provided? Anr. v. Aditya Bandopadhyay and Ors, | (inspection should be CIVIL APPEAL NO.6454 OF 2011, Supreme given te | Comets SUP [C] No,7526/2009, Dated 09.08.2011. http://imi.ac.in/upload/menuuploed/rti_ SC -CBSE.pef Indiscriminate and impractical demands or directions under ATI Act for disclosure of all and sundry information (unrelated to transparency and accountability in the functioning of public authorities and eradication of corruption) would be counter-productive as it will adversely affect the efficiency of the administration and result in the executive getting bogged down with the non-productive work of collecting and furnishing information. The ‘Act should not be allowed to be misused or abused, to become a tool to obstruct the national development and integration, or to destroy the peace, tranquility ond harmony ‘among its citizens, The nation does not want a scenario where 75% of the staff of public authorities spends 75% of their time in collecting and furnishing information to applicants instead of discharging their regular duties. The threat of penalties under the RTI Act and the pressure of the authorities under the RTI Act should not lead to employees of a public authorities prioritizing ‘information furnishing’, at the cost of their normal and regular duties. Compiled by Corporate Affairs Desp gn) FulaInformation- Exempted —————— 2. | information regarding No M Sushil Kumar v. TOCL: 63 LPG trucks, mileage detail CIC/SS/A/2013/002695/SH Sand amount paid in each cade, fimath ise, Dated 30.10.2014, for the period 01.01.2009 to ttre //wwwartisindiens 30.5.2013 sought from IOCL. oe Being voluminous information, it was denied under 7(9) of the RTI Act, 2005. 3. [The appellant ~— sought No Girish Nautiyel vs TOCL: verification of domestic/ CIC/LS/A/2013/001174/SS, commercial LPG connections Dated 27.01.2014, in respect of two gas agencies, Number of ing isiong/CIC Ls connections -A2013 001174 SS M_123883.pdF cancelled/locked, and details lok corishicieed Soaked Unis Information denied on the grounds of evlinders during April 2005 to voluminous information under the November 2011 for home Provisions of Section 7(9) of the RTI Act. aWeey However, inspection of documents should be allowed. 4, |The Applicant filed 4 No Nitesh Kumar ‘Tripathi vs application seeking following Ministry of Youth Affairs & Sports information:- cIc/Ls/a/2012/000938 + The number of Class A and Dated 14.03.13 Class B officers who had 7 ce hite://rtiindia.gov.in/cic_decisions/CIC LS not been transferred as ROSE per the Company's transfer policy. * The number of Doctors who had been appointed in the — Company —_ under physically challenged quota since 1995, + Copies of rules and regulations for punishment of dealers of LPG and Demand for vague and omnibus information does not serve any purpose. Besides, applicant has also to keep in mind that collection, collation and transmission of information takes time and impinges on resources of the public authority, Compiled by Corporate Affairs eS‘28018 RTI Datats he new international Cruise terminal which is being built, 2. Development of eastem riverfront for residential. commercial, ‘ecreational activities over $00ha of Mumbai Port Trust land by the | architectural from HCP, Yew Goa Munibai Cruise. The project will attract The Cruise passenger when is other foreign | artist to perform in India. design can be so iconic that it will be | ‘come the highlight for the city. The approximate land area required | is 15000 to.20000 meter square. Avain all this is hypothetical Following are the information 1 am secking For my thesis project: hr land is not 1)L want to know trom the Mumbai Port Trust that whi under the HCPs (architectural firm designing the eastern “Waterffoni) Tastoin Waterfront development master plan as well as not being majorly used by MBPT so I can use for my thesis, 2)List of land parcel of MbPT not being majorly used by MbPT, 3)Manual/CAD drawing’ Picture demarking the above required area. 4)1 have uploaded a file showing an area which I have identified for my thesis projectymy question is is the demarked land arca which T have uploaded being majorly used by Mbpt. S)How many and where are the Entry and exits points are there in MbPT near Princess and Victoria dock 6)Basic details/draft of CPs Waterfront development master plan which shows the land use category like commercial residential open spaces ¢te. J ean assure you that the data obtained will be used purely for academic purpose Thanking you, Wailing for an early reply. Original RTI Text (ART ARATE Respected Sir/madam, * Tam Param Patel architecture student from Raman Bhakta School of Architecture(college) Surat Gujarat. Tam in my 10th currently doing my thesis. | am designing a Symphony orchestra Concert Hall along with western classical music Academy for my thesis, Noi 11 this is hypothetical and not real.compromise any aspect of Western classical music. it isa need of the hour to build a Symphony orchestra Concert Hall in India which Indian lacks. Iam proposing it in Mumbai keeping in mind the high demand the long queue for concert of Zubin Mehta in Mumbai Mumbai has « Bollywood background too. For the justification and | rough idea for what it will look like I am sending a few data from my research. Thave identified a land near princess Dock in Mumbai port trust to propose my in my college. There are three main factors to keep in mind for choosing the site. 1. The new intemationat Cruise terminal which is being built. 2. Development of castera riverfront for residential, commercial, recreational activities over 500ha of Mumbai Port Trust land by the architectural from HCP. 3. New Goa Mumbai Cruise. The project will attract The Cruise passenger when is other forcign artist to perform in India. design can be so iconic that it will be come the highlight for the city, The approximate land area requi is 15000 to 20000 meter square, ed Again all this is hypothetical Following are the information | am seeking For my thesis project: 1) want to know ftom the Mumbai Port Trust that which land is not under the HCPs (architectural firm designing the eastern Waterfront) Eastern Waterfront development master plan as well as not heing majorly used by MbPT so T can use for my thesis. 2)List of land parcel of MbPT not being majorly used by MbPT. 3)Manual/CAD drawing/Picture demarking the above required area, 4)! have uploaded a file showing an area which I have identified for ny thesis projectamy question is is the demarked land area which 1 have uploaded being majorly used by Mbpt. S)How many and where are the Entry and exits points are there in MbPT near Princess and Victoria dock sic details/draft of HCPs Waterfront development master plan which shows the land use eategory like commercial residential open spaces ete. {can assure you that the datt obtained will be used purely for academic purpose . THinnbteie cine MEMSUPERINTENDING ENGINEER aed OE gae afters gira Port House, MUMBAI PORT TRUST oe waa ‘Shoon Vallabhaas Marg, ‘garars sibeifich fear at aromas af Bollard Estato, CIVIL ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT Were xx2q ‘Mumbai - 400 001. ‘re 4000001. Tol. No. : 8656 4040 quat Fax No, : 22616004 cea Email: sblagwankar@ eae mpptmati.com mbptmail.com Website : mumbaiport gov.in aaremiz : mumbaiport.gov.in No. CE BI6-A(RIAY 5G Date To, ‘Shri Param Patel, Patel Studio, Limda Choke Bardoli, Near Bardoli Police St Surat, Pin - 394601 Gujarat, India ‘Sub :- Information i JAM 2019 ‘sought under RT! Act 2005, Ref :- Your application dated 16.12.2018 received in this office ‘on 02.01.2019. With reference to above, the information sought by you is as under: Sr No. RTI Queries ‘Answers, Which land is not under the HCP’s (architectural firm designing the Eastern Waterfront) Eastern Waterfront Development Master Plan as well as not being majorly used by MbPT, so | can use for my thesis, Reporis and Plans are published on MbPT website. List of land parcel of MbPT not being majorly used by MbPT. This is huge data which may not be given Manual’ CAD Drawings’ Picture demarking the above required area. The Auto Cad drawings are given to applicant personally Thave uploaded a file showing an area which | have identified for my thesis project "Is demarked land area which has been uploaded, being used by MOPT. ‘This is not a question How many and where are the Entry and Exits points are there in MbPT near Princess and Victoria Dock. Basic details!) Draft of HCP’s Waterfront Development Master Plan which shows the land use category ike commercial, residential open spaces etc. The respective plans are uploaded on MbPT website. Master Plan iS uploaded on MbPT website, www.mumbaiport.gov.in2. you are not Satisfied with the information given as above, you may prefer an appeal to the Mrs. §.G. Patwarchan, Sr. Dy. Secretary, GAD and First Appellate Authority, Mumbai Port Trust, 2” Floor, Port Bhavan, Shor Vallabhdas Marg, Fort, Ballard Estate, Mumbai - 400 001, within 20 days. seat fhe. ('S. B, LAGWANKAR } D.A: Nil. SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER RRY & CENTRAL PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER MUMBAI PORT TRUST Mob. No. 9869575395 cc. to the Shri H.P. Kulkarni, CPIO & Estate Manager(tic) Ref. No. EM/AS(G)/IRTI3847 dated 07.01.2018. spd yi) (S. B. LAGWANKAR ) DA: Nil SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER,RRY & CENTRAL PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER: 4 c_ MUMBA! PORT TRUST