Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JEONG-AH KIM, SANG-YOON LEE, KI HO PARK, YOUNG SUK YU, AND JIN WOOK JEOUNG
PURPOSE: To evaluate the long-term incidence and risk patients. (Am J Ophthalmol 2019;208:265–272. Ó
of glaucoma after bilateral congenital cataract surgery in 2019 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)
microphthalmic eyes.
DESIGN: Retrospective, observational case series.
M
METHODS: SUBJECTS: Children with microphthalmic ICROPHTHALMIA IS A RARE CONGENITAL MAL-
eyes who had undergone surgery for bilateral congenital formation resulting from abnormalities in the
cataract within 6 months of birth and been followed up development of the primary optic vesicle.1 It
for at least 5 years. PROCEDURES: Review of medical re- has an incidence of 0.2-9 per 10,000 births, affects
cords at our institution. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Prob- 3%-11% of blind children, and is associated with a high
ability of an eye’s developing glaucoma after bilateral prevalence of congenital cataract.2–5 Even for children
congenital cataract surgery and associated risk factors. with microphthalmic eyes, early cataract surgery is
RESULTS: Thirty-eight eyes of 19 children with bilat- essential in order to prevent amblyopia and improve
eral congenital cataract were included. The mean age at visual outcomes, including stereopsis.6–9 However, despite
surgery was 3.2 ± 1.7 months, and the mean follow-up recent advances in pediatric cataract microsurgical
duration was 7.79 ± 2.61 years. After cataract surgery, techniques, early surgical treatment in children with
11 eyes (29.0%) developed glaucoma at the age of 4.0 microphthalmia remains challenging owing to several
± 1.4 years. Three of these eyes underwent Ahmed glau- intraoperative difficulties attributable to the crowded
coma valve implantation surgery. The probability of an anterior segment and the risk of postoperative
eye’s developing glaucoma was estimated to be 32.0% complications such as glaucoma.10–12
by 10 years after surgery. In a multivariate analysis, axial Glaucoma is one of the vision-threatening complica-
length was significantly associated with glaucoma devel- tions after congenital cataract surgery.13,14 However, its
opment (odds ratio [ 0.364, P [ .025). Age at the incidence varies widely in the previous reports in the
time of cataract surgery, corneal diameter, and aphakia literature, owing to differences among study populations
did not affect the risk of glaucoma (P > .10). Eyes (eg, race, age at cataract surgery, etc) and in follow-up pe-
without glaucoma had a better final visual outcome than riods.15–21 Especially in rare cases of microphthalmia, the
those with glaucoma (0.75 ± 0.60 and 1.47 ± 1.10 long-term risk of glaucoma development after congenital
logMAR, respectively, P [ .049). cataract surgery has not been well studied, and so disease
CONCLUSIONS: The long-term cumulative risk of post- risk and the associated factors are still unclear. Since devel-
operative glaucoma development was 32.0% by 10 years opment of glaucoma after cataract surgery takes consider-
after bilateral congenital cataract surgery. Because the able time, even in cases of microphthalmia, long-term
risk of developing glaucoma persists for several years after study is needed to evaluate the incidence of glaucoma
surgery, careful monitoring and control of intraocular development and its risk factors after congenital cataract
pressure is needed to preserve vision in such surgery in microphthalmic eyes.
In the present study, we investigated the long-term risk
of glaucoma development and associated factors in micro-
Supplemental Material available at AJO.com. phthalmic eyes of Korean children who had undergone
Accepted for publication Aug 16, 2019. bilateral congenital cataract surgery within 6 months of
From the Department of Ophthalmology, Hallym University College of birth.
Medicine, Chuncheon Sacred Heart Hospital, Chuncheon, South Korea
(J.A.K.); Department of Ophthalmology, Seoul National University
College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea (J.A.K., K.H.P., Y.S.Y.,
J.W.J.); Department of Ophthalmology, Jeju National University
College of Medicine, Jeju City, South Korea (S.Y.L.); and Department
of Ophthalmology, Seoul National University Hospital, Seoul, South METHODS
Korea (K.H.P., Y.S.Y., J.W.J.).
Inquiries to Jin Wook Jeoung, Department of Ophthalmology, Seoul PATIENTS DIAGNOSED WITH MICROPHTHALMIA WHO HAD
National University Hospital, Seoul National University College of
Medicine, 101 Daehak-ro, Jongno-gu, Seoul 03080, South Korea; undergone bilateral congenital cataract surgery within
e-mail: neuroprotect@gmail.com 6 months of birth at Seoul National University Children’s
Variables Value
Sex (%)
Male 57.9%
Female 42.1%
Family history of congenital cataract 52.6%
Type of cataract (eyes), n (%)
Nuclear 21 (52.5%)
Total 15 (37.5%)
Anterior subcapsular 2 (5.0%) FIGURE. Kaplan-Meier plot of glaucoma-free survival in chil-
Age at initial visit (months) 2.6 6 1.6 dren with microphthalmic eyes after bilateral congenital cata-
Age at cataract extraction surgery (months) 3.2 6 1.7 ract surgery.
Preoperative ocular parameters
Axial length (mm) 16.49 6 1.76
Corneal diameter (mm) 8.28 6 0.93
Secondary IOL insertion surgery 12 eyes of were 18% and 32%, respectively.20 When we applied the
6 patients disease definition used in IATS to our data, the incidence
Age at surgery (years) 2.3 6 0.5
of glaucoma plus glaucoma suspect was 36.8%, which,
IOP
though higher than the IATS result, was not significantly
Preoperative IOP (mm Hg) 11.0 6 4.5
Mean IOP after cataract surgery (mm Hg) 15.4 6 4.1
different. In a study by Vasavada and associates,18 the
Final IOP (mm Hg) 17.3 6 3.8 risk of glaucoma development was 30.9% in 21 infants
Eyes diagnosed with glaucoma (eyes), n (%) 11 (29.0%) followed up for 25.6 6 11.3 months postoperatively,
Age at glaucoma diagnosis (years) 4.0 6 1.4 whereas Prasad and associates17 reported a lower incidence
Glaucoma surgery (eyes)a 3 (7.9%) of glaucoma: 13.5% of 37 microphthalmic eyes followed up
Age at glaucoma surgery (years) 6.3 6 1.5 for 18 6 5.1 months. This discrepancy might reflect differ-
Final BCVA (logMAR) 0.6 6 0.8 ences in the follow-up duration and patient population be-
Follow-up time (years) 7.8 6 2.6 tween the studies.
In our study, all of the patients with glaucoma had late-
BCVA ¼ best-corrected visual acuity; IOL ¼ intraocular lens;
IOP, intraocular pressure.
onset open-angle glaucoma and those with shorter axial
a
All cases underwent Ahmed valve implantation. length had a higher risk for developing glaucoma. Glau-
coma after congenital cataract surgery has a bimodal
onset33,34; early-onset glaucoma develops within a year of
cataract surgery, and late-onset open-angle glaucoma arises
much later.19,30 The mechanism of early-onset glaucoma
congenital cataract surgery. Although eyes without glau- might be related to genetic predisposing factors13,14,30,35
coma had better visual outcomes than those with glau- along with angle closure caused by pupillary block or
coma, glaucomatous eyes with well-controlled IOP had a inflammatory peripheral anterior synechiae (PAS)36–38;
comparable visual outcome to those without glaucoma. when glaucoma occurs, it tends to develop in both eyes
This study included patients on whom bilateral congen- (ie, bilaterally).14,30 In late-onset glaucoma, although the
ital cataract surgery had been performed, using modern sur- angle is usually open on gonioscopy, many cases have
gical techniques, by 1 experienced pediatric surgeon in abnormal pigment deposition and micro-PAS39 that might
order to exclude bias such as surgeon performance. More- be the result of early intermittent pupillary block and
over, only patients followed up for at least 5 years were chronic inflammation by remnant lens materials after sur-
included to achieve representative long-term results; in gery.33 Two possible mechanisms of late-onset glaucoma
our study, 10 of the 11 cases of glaucoma were diagnosed have been suggested. The first is the chemical theory that
within 5 years of surgery and the remaining 1 patient was may be associated with unique susceptibility of filtration
diagnosed at 8 years. Thus, this study can be considered angle to postoperative inflammation13 or toxic chemical
to have had a sufficient follow-up period for evaluation of factors from vitreous fluid38,40 to induce chronic
the long-term incidence of glaucoma development. trabeculitis15 that alter the microstructure of the trabecular
The incidence of glaucoma after congenital cataract sur- meshwork and may impair the normal maturation of angle
gery has been reported to be between 3% and 41%.15–20 In or acquire micro-PAS.39 The second is a mechanical the-
the recent prospective Infant Aphakia Treatment Study ory; loss of support to the trabecular meshwork in the
(IATS), the incidences of glaucoma and glaucoma plus aphakic eye induces a disorganization or collapse of the
glaucoma suspect after surgery by 5 years of follow-up trabecular meshwork that results in diminished function
Number of eyes 27 11
Male (%) 15 (55.6%) 7 (63.6%) .729
Right:left (% of right eye) 13:14 (48.1%) 6:5 (54.5%) 1.00
Age at cataract surgery (months) 3.3 6 1.7 3.0 6 1.7 .660
Corneal diameter (mm) 8.37 6 0.99 8.05 6 0.76 .334
Axial length (mm) 15.11 6 1.38 16.95 6 1.66 .036*
Secondary IOL implantation 11 eyes (40.7%) 1 eye (9.1%) .121
Intraocular surgery after cataract surgery 14 eyes (51.9%) 3 eyes (27.27%) .486
IOP
Max IOP (mm Hg) 19.9 6 4.6 36.9 6 9.1 <.001*
Mean IOP (mm Hg) 13.5 6 2.2 20.1 6 4.1 <.001*
Final IOP (mm Hg) 16.4 6 3.7 19.3 6 3.3 .034*
Final BCVA (logMAR) 0.75 6 0.60 1.47 6 1.10 .049*
Follow-up period (years) 7.31 6 2.09 8.96 6 3.46 .278
BCVA ¼ best-corrected visual acuity; IOL ¼ intraocular lens; IOP, intraocular pressure.
Asterisk (*) indicates statistical significance.
a
P values of continuous variables from Mann-Whitney U test, and those of categorical variables from Fisher exact test.
TABLE 3. Risk Factors Associated With Development of Glaucoma After Cataract Surgery
Variables Odds Ratio (95% CI) P Value Odds Ratio (95% CI) P Value
of trabecular meshwork as a filter and an active metabolic study, the age at surgery tended to be younger in the
tissue.41 Extremely early onset of cataract, subsequent sur- glaucoma than in the nonglaucoma group, but it was not
gery in such young microphthalmic eyes, and associated statistically significant. This could have been due to the
anomalies of the angle structures with peripheral crowding facts that only 5 of 19 infants underwent surgery within
might be risk factors for the development of glaucoma.42 2 months of birth and that the number of eyes was too
These theories can be possible pathophysiological mecha- small to conduct a meaningful statistical analysis.
nisms for the higher prevalence of postoperative glaucoma Glaucoma after congenital cataract surgery remains a
in infants with microphthalmic eyes, and support the result major concern for microphthalmic eyes, and it needs timely
that eyes with shorter axis length had higher risk of glau- management to prevent optic nerve damage and subse-
coma after surgery in the present study. quent vision loss. Although early surgery is associated
Among the known risk factors for development of glau- with a higher risk of subsequent glaucoma,21,33,35 timely
coma after cataract surgery in children, surgery at an early intervention is important to visual outcomes for the
age has been frequently identified in both normal and following reasons: surgery after 6 weeks of age can
microphthalmic eyes.17,18,20,21,33,35 However, in our deprive the neonatal visual system of vital stimuli during
Number of eyes 27 6 5
Mean IOP (mm Hg) 13.51 6 2.22 17.73 6 2.06 22.90 6 4.34 <.001* A < Bs < Bf
Final BCVA (logMAR) 0.75 6 0.60 0.69 6 0.42 2.40 6 0.89 .007* A ¼ Bs < Bf
the critical period,43 and cataract surgery before 2 months relevant only to patients who have surgery for bilateral
of age has produced the best visual outcomes.44,45 In our congenital cataracts. Therefore, further study with
study, the surgeon’s concern about postoperative unilateral congenital cataract surgery in microphthalmia
glaucoma did not delay cataract surgery, even in patients is needed.
with bilateral cataracts. The surgery was performed at 3.2 This study has several limitations. First, it is a retrospec-
6 1.7 months, similarly to the findings reported by tive review of a small sample size without a control group.
Vasavada and associates (4.0 6 2.6 months)18 and Prasad Second, we analyzed the long-term outcomes for a homoge-
and associates (3.8 6 2.3 months).17 Most of the patients neous cohort of microphthalmic eyes that had undergone
in the current study underwent surgery within 2 weeks of bilateral congenital cataract surgery within 6 months of
initial diagnosis of the disease, regardless of their age, and birth; all of the patients were Korean. Though the results
they were more likely to be operated on earlier when from this cohort can provide useful data for this population,
referred earlier. However, some patients who had a delayed it may not apply as accurately to other racial or ethnic
parental consent underwent cataract surgery later. groups. Therefore, further prospective study with a larger
The present study included children with microphthal- sample size and a more diverse study population, along
mia who underwent bilateral congenital cataract surgery with comparison of these eyes with nonmicrophthalmic
because there were no patients with unilateral disease eyes, is needed. Third, given the present study’s limitations
who met our inclusion criteria. Because the number of pa- in terms of the capacity to evaluate glaucomatous anatomic
tients who performed surgery was not correlated with the and functional damage, the mechanism of glaucoma and
prevalence of the disease, we speculate that the reasons the severity of glaucomatous structural and functional dam-
for this are as follows: (1) infants with unilateral disease age could not be comprehensively evaluated. Lastly,
might be diagnosed and operated on later than those because we included patients who were followed up for at
with bilateral cases because visual signs (ie, decrease in vi- least 5 years postoperatively, some cases, especially uncom-
sual acuity) in preverbal infants are less helpful for early plicated ones, could not be included owing to insufficient
detection of cataract in cases of unilateral disease; and follow-up. Thus, there is a possibility that our data overes-
(2) the most frequent ocular abnormality in cases of unilat- timate the risk of developing glaucoma.
eral cataract and microphthalmia is persistent fetal vascu- In summary, the long-term cumulative risk of glau-
lature.2,46,47 In such condition, patients’ parents often coma development by 10 years after bilateral congenital
refuse to consent to surgery owing to its poor prognosis, cataract surgery was 32.0% in patients with microphthal-
especially when fellow eyes are normal. Since bilateral mia. Since the risk of glaucoma development persists for
congenital cataracts in microphthalmia are more likely to many years after surgery, regular IOP monitoring and
be syndromic or have other systemic findings that could thorough IOP controls are needed in order to preserve
influence the prevalence of glaucoma, our findings are patients’ vision.
FUNDING/SUPPORT: THIS STUDY WAS SUPPORTED BY GRANT NUMBER 0420170680 (2017-1182) FROM THE SNUH RESEARCH FUND.
Financial Disclosures: All authors have no financial disclosures. All authors attest that they meet the current ICMJE criteria for authorship.