Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Regional analgesia and evidence that potentially cause harm with no benefit at all.
Surgeons and Anaesthetists continue to add drugs to long
orthopaedic surgery acting local anaesthetic agents, continue to give epidurals for
lower limb arthroplasty surgery and continue to refuse regional
techniques because of perceived but disproven risks of
Andrew T Wilson complications.
Pharmacokinetics
Abstract An in depth knowledge of LA pharmacology is not essential,
Regional anaesthesia and analgesia is a growing subspeciality which however the basic principles are required to understand the
impacts on all orthopaedic procedures. Advances continue to be mechanism of action of LA, toxicity, choice of agent and future
made in techniques which will influence patient outcomes. It is there- developments.
fore essential that all practising anaesthetists and orthopaedic sur- Regional anaesthesia and regional analgesia can be consid-
geons understand the background principles and practices of ered the same entity, anaesthesia being a more profound and
regional anaesthesia to aid in the team treatment plan decision mak- denser block than analgesia. Regional anaesthesia makes the
ing. All regional procedures have potential to facilitate postoperative operative site insensate for the duration of the surgery and is
recovery however all have inherent risks and if “overdone” may inhibit influenced by LA concentration. Regional analgesia decreases the
early rehabilitation. Only with the understanding of the techniques operative site pain for a period well beyond the operative period.
available can an informed choice be made. This duration of action is influenced by choice, concentration
This review examines pharmacology of current local anaesthetics and volume of LA, additives and/or continuous catheter
and additives, the pros and cons of central axial blocks and differing techniques.
techniques including LIA local infiltration analgesia and ultrasound With the exception of the ultra short acting chloroprocaine
guided blocks for major joint surgery in the upper and lower limbs. It (Procaine) all local anaesthetic agents now in use are amides, the
is not intended as a literature review of all the latest esoteric tech- original ester agents having high incidences of allergic reactions.
niques but as a background essential reading of what is currently All local anaesthetics produce their effects by blocking
happening in orthopaedic anaesthesia. voltage-gated sodium channels. Unfortunately, this is true of all
Keywords orthopaedic surgery; regional analgesia types of nerve fibres and to date no LA is available which can
truly differentiate between motor and sensory fibres. Agents such
as ropivacaine had been suggested to produce less motor block3
than other equipotent agents such as bupivacaine but motor
block still occurs and so the clinical significance of this remains
Introduction
small if at all. More recent developments may allow the goal of
It is 130 years since Koller1 first described the use of cocaine to specific sensory fibre sodium channels to be selected4 but despite
produce local anaesthesia for an ophthalmic surgical proce- this being a reality no agent is as yet clinically available.
dure. Following on from this 1884 landmark case was a decade This motor block is now of greater relevance than previous
of trials whereby cocaine was applied topically, injected sub- reviews because of the pressures, both economic and medical,
cutaneously, around specific nerves and then centrally most to get patients mobilized and discharged as quickly as possible.
notably by Bier2 in 1899. Techniques have all developed It must be recognized that all regional techniques have a risk
around this basic principle of bathing the nerves supplying the benefit ratio. In deed it is this risk benefit ratio which has
surgical site with Local Anaesthetic (LA). Has the speciality resulted in the adoption of the new surgical technique of Local
moved on? The answer is of course yes. Over the last century Infiltration Arthroplasty5 surgery (LIA) because of the previous
advances have been made in LA potency, safety and efficacy, over reliance of epidural analgesia in lower limb arthroplasty
nerve localization techniques, central axial blockade, ultra- surgery. This technique will be discussed in greater detail later
sound guided regional analgesia and more recently liposomal in the review.
LA. There is now a greater understanding as to how Regional The choice of LA to use is often dictated by the duration of
anaesthesia/analgesia (RA) affects surgical outcome and may action as differing surgical procedures have differing intra and
even reduce cancer recurrence. postoperative analgesic requirements. For example the pain after
A basic knowledge of these principles, practices and de- a surgical procedure on the shoulder compared with the hand is
velopments is not only a requirement for the anaesthetic trainee generally more intense and of a greater duration. The choice for
but also for any practising surgeon as there is no surgical site that hand units is often therefore for shorter acting agents even
is not amenable to RA. though both shoulder and hand surgery may of the same oper-
Unfortunately there are practices continuing which have no ative duration and both are day case procedures under regional
evidence base and in deed, some which continue despite alone.
The duration of action is dependent on both the protein
binding and the clearance from the injection site. Both of these
elements can be manipulated pharmacologically to increase the
Dr Andrew T Wilson MBChB FRCA FICM Consultant Anaesthetist and longevity of the block but clinically only clearance can be
Intensivist, United Leeds Teaching Hospitals Trust, Leeds, UK. altered. Protein binding of the longer acting agents such as
Conflict of interest: none declared. bupiviacaine and ropivicaine is approximately 95% whereas
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 30:3 254 Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
þÿDownloaded for Manuel Azael Rodrÿýguez Cigala (manuel_azael_rc@hotmail.com) at Autonomous University of Guadalajara from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on October 13, 2020.
For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
BASIC SCIENCE
that of the shorter acting lidocaine is only 65%. The clearance remaining plexus. This has been given the term differential
from the injection site is dependent upon local blood flow and blockade.
some LA, such as lidocaine; also have intrinsic vasodilator
properties that potentiate this. This flow can be manipulated by Other additives
vasopressors such as adrenaline or felypressin but since the For peripheral nerve blocks there have been many agents added
protein binding of the longer acting agents is so high local blood to an LA to increase its effectiveness but few until now have
flow has little if any effect on the duration of action on these been shown to be of significant benefit.6 Even those that have
agents. However, the practice of adding adrenaline to these long previously been shown to be beneficial have additional side
acting agents unfortunately continues despite the lack of any effects. As with the addition of vasopressors it does not make
pharmacological basis. good clinical sense to try and add any additive to a short
The onset time of local anaesthetics is dependent upon three duration LA to improve its duration of action when longer
factors; molecular weight (all are similar), pKa and diffusibility. acting agents are freely available. Likewise in peripheral nerve
Only pKa can be manipulated. A detailed understanding of blocks the general rule was not to add any additive to an
molecular pKa is not required save to say the further the pKa of already long acting agent although this rule was often ignored
the molecule from the acid pH solution (all LA pKa are alkaline) with many centres routinely adding opioids or clonidine (and to
the more ionized it is and therefore the less able it is to cross a less frequent extent NSAIDs, midazolam, ketamine, neostig-
the lipid membrane. Again however, only the shorter acting mine and relaxants) to agents such as bupivicaine and ropi-
agents are amenable to manipulation as the very high pKa of vacaine despite the lack of evidence. Until recently the alpha-2
the longer agents makes a small increase in non-ionized mol- receptor agonist clonidine was the only adjuvant to be used
ecules (by warming or alkalinization with bicarbonate) of little routinely in the UK but there are as many papers refuting its
significance. pKa is not therefore routinely manipulated as the benefits as there are showing it to improve quality and duration
short acting agents already have a quick onset time. of block. It is likely that it does improve the duration and
It should be noted that the agents with quickest onset time quality of short acting plexus blocks but has no significant ef-
tend to be the same as those with the shortest duration of action fect on longer acting LA.
and lowest potency. More recently two more adjuvants have not only suggested an
increase in length of block but for the first time these are in long
Additive agents and phospholipid encapsulation acting local anaesthetics. Both dexamethasone7 and dexmedeta-
(liposomal) tomidine8 have significant promise but only the former has
become routinely used. Dexamethasone has been shown to
Adrenaline significantly increase the duration of both sensory and motor
The use of vasopressors, as noted above, is only of use with short block of long acting LA by up to 90%9 although some authors
acting agents. They increase duration of action by decreasing have questioned its superiority over systemic dexamethasone.10
clearance secondary to local blood flow. The addition of a vaso- There are still some concerns regarding potential nerve toxicity
pressor will also allow an increased dose of the non-potent short but clinically there have been no adverse side effects.11
acting drugs to be used before reaching toxic levels as plasma For central axial blocks the addition of opioids or cloni-
levels will not peak rapidly. This has little or no influence on dine is far more evidence based. They produce prolonged
plasma levels of the longer agents, in deed ropivacaine has been analgesia or an improvement in block quality because of their
shown to have an intrinsic vasoconstrictor action of its own. direct action on the dorsal and ventral horns, respectively.
There is some evidence that adrenaline may have specific The addition of diamorphine or morphine to a spinal anaes-
analgesic properties acting on alpha 2 receptors but the signifi- thetic is a now a routine procedure to provide excellent
cance of this is again minor in long acting blocks. Putting it analgesia for up to 24 hours without the residual motor
simply; if a long duration of action is required a long acting agent block. Side effects such as pruritis are common but also
without an additive should be used not a short acting one with include the far more serious late respiratory depression. Late
adrenaline added. Vasopressors are not without their potential respiratory depression is far more common in the hydrophilic
complications as they may reduce blood flow to the target nerves long acting agents such as morphine compared with the short
which may potentiate any risk of axonotmesis. acting lipophilic agents such as fentanyl. Many centres insist
Of course superficial infiltration with adrenaline containing on an HDU bed postoperatively or at least a ratio of nurses to
LA is given for local vasoconstrictor actions to decrease blood patient infrequently found on a busy orthopaedic ward and
loss and nothing to do with duration of block but unfortunately this often precludes their use.
this practice continues for nerve blocks as well.
Mixing two agents, one short acting but rapid onset (such Liposomal LA
as Lidocaine or Prilocaine) and one long acting slow onset The idea of encapsulating LA in a phospholipid barrier to prolong
(such as Bupivacaine or Ropivacaine), is common place but duration of action and reduce toxicity is not new12 and has been
has little pharmacological basis. However, ultrasound has researched for more than 25 years. Recent publications have
allowed specific nerves to be targeted for postoperative been favourable in wound infiltration techniques looking at
analgesia with long acting agents whilst anaesthesia of the safety and tolerability13 as well as effect on wound healing14 but
whole limb is produced with short acting agents to the not RCTs comparing analgesia scores with non-liposomal
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 30:3 255 Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
þÿDownloaded for Manuel Azael Rodrÿýguez Cigala (manuel_azael_rc@hotmail.com) at Autonomous University of Guadalajara from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on October 13, 2020.
For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
BASIC SCIENCE
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 30:3 256 Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
þÿDownloaded for Manuel Azael Rodrÿýguez Cigala (manuel_azael_rc@hotmail.com) at Autonomous University of Guadalajara from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on October 13, 2020.
For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
BASIC SCIENCE
the block can be established incrementally to achieve the desired inevitable. If subsequent hypotension is well controlled (or no
height and also kept topped up well beyond the few hours of a sympathectomy occurs) central axial blocks, particularly low
single shot. The disadvantages though are potential patchy blocks, are a very safe alternative to general anaesthesia in the
blocks with “missed segments”, time to achieve adequate block presence of cardiovascular disease. Significant aortic stenosis is a
height and misplacement of the catheter. Epidurals are therefore relative contraindication to spinal anaesthesia as the fixed car-
rarely used for anaesthesia but more as a method of achieving diac output will not respond well in the presence of
excellent intra and postoperative analgesia. Unfortunately it is vasodilatation.
this excellent postoperative analgesia with its concomitant motor It can be seen therefore that spinal or epidural anaesthesia are
block which often produces a pain free but relatively immobile ideal for patients with respiratory disease but less so for those
patient with a potential subsequent delay in discharge. Other with significant cardiac disease. Of course many patients pre-
secondary effects include the requirement of urinary catheteri- senting for orthopaedic procedures have both lung and cardiac
zation and a potential increase in DVT and chest infections sec- disease and therefore the decision is usually not quite so clear
ondary to immobility. cut.
Hyperbaric solutions are not used in epidural blocks as Major complications of CNB have recently been the subject
altering baricity has no influence on epidural spread. As with of a UK national audit15 the results of which were that per-
spinal anaesthesia, block height can be influenced and the manent nerve injury was approx three per 100 000 spinals and
greatest influences of epidural spread and height of block are site paraplegia or death was approximately one per 100 000 spinal
of injection and volume of injectate used. For orthopaedic anaesthetics. Notably two-thirds of initially disabling injuries
anaesthesia a lumbar epidural will always suffice for lower limb resolved fully.
and pelvic surgery as height of block does not need to extend
beyond the lower thoracic dermatomes. Further influences are Anticoagulants: postoperative thromboprophylaxis for major
similar to those in spinal anaesthesia. orthopaedic surgery is now standard therapy because of the high
risk of DVT and PE following this type of surgery in an already at
Safety and adverse effects: there is a common misconception risk group.
that CNB is safer than general anaesthesia but this is not sup- However because of the cohort of patients for arthroplasty
ported in the literature. There are specific examples of periop surgery many preoperatively are already on anticoagulants or
survival being influenced positively by spinal anaesthesia but antiplatelet therapy secondary to comorbidities. Unfortunately
survival rates beyond the immediate operative period are with central axial blocks and deep peripheral nerve blocks this
comparable. Whilst it may appear intuitive that avoidance of increases the risk of local/spinal haematoma with subsequent
general anaesthesia must be advantageous this does not take risk of neurological deficit. AAGBI (UK)16 European and
into account both the adverse effects of regional anaesthesia American17 guidelines have been published, differing slightly,
and the overall stress effects of surgery. There has been a lot of principally because of the differing techniques of administering
recent literature regarding best practice in fracture neck of thromboprophylaxis. Most regional centres have adopted their
femur patients. Whilst most authors recommend spinal anaes- own adaptation of these national guidelines but aspirin is never
thesia plus or minus a fascia iliaca block, all recommend the a contraindication to RA. The choice of whether to still do a
avoidance of significant and prolonged hypotension. Hypoten- regional technique on a patient who is anticoagulated or on
sion secondary to sympathetic block is the biggest drawback to antiplatelet therapy such as clopidogrel becomes a risk benefit
spinal anaesthesia and is compounded by the addition of gen- analysis. If the patient’s anticoagulation does not preclude
eral anaesthesia. This combination is therefore best avoided but surgery it is unlikely to preclude regional anaesthesia but
this is not always possible in the agitated disorientated patient. medico-legally it becomes difficult to justify as it is rarely
The commonest adverse effect of a central axial block is hy- essential.
potension because when a block extends above T10 a sympa-
thetic block occurs with subsequent vasodilatation. Height of Compartment syndrome: acute compartment syndrome (ACS)
block is the greatest influence of how much sympathectomy requires prompt recognition, diagnosis and treatment. The
occurs but the degree of cardiovascular compromise is further question is does RA influence time of diagnosis and subsequent
influenced by pre-existing hypovolaemia, hypotension, treated outcome? A recent systematic review18 examined whether
hypertension, age and the addition of general anaesthesia. Pre- modern acute pain management techniques contributed to a
existing hypovolaemia is therefore an absolute contraindication delay in diagnosis. They found no good evidence of any adverse
to central axial blockade. influence of RA on compartment syndrome diagnosis but did
Normal respiratory function is not affected by a normal low acknowledge that under-reporting is common and no compara-
spinal anaesthetic however patients with severe obstructive lung tive trials have been published. There is evidence to the contrary
disease who rely on accessory muscles of respiration may well be in that in the presence of RA if significant break through pain
compromised. The risk benefit ratio of spinal versus general occurs ACS must be considered and may aid diagnosis.
anaesthesia in patients with severe pulmonary disease will usu- A note of caution however; a dense block of either a CNB or
ally still come down on the side of spinal. PNB will delay diagnosis with its complete sensory and motor
Cardiovascular function is however affected by spinal anaes- block. Anaesthesia with long acting agents or analgesia with high
thesia as already mentioned and therefore patients with signifi- concentration LA should therefore be avoided. Withholding
cant cardiac disease may well do better with general anaesthesia analgesia (PCA or RA) has no evidence of benefit and is
if the height of block is such that significant sympathetic block is inhumane.
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 30:3 257 Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
þÿDownloaded for Manuel Azael Rodrÿýguez Cigala (manuel_azael_rc@hotmail.com) at Autonomous University of Guadalajara from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on October 13, 2020.
For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
BASIC SCIENCE
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 30:3 258 Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
þÿDownloaded for Manuel Azael Rodrÿýguez Cigala (manuel_azael_rc@hotmail.com) at Autonomous University of Guadalajara from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on October 13, 2020.
For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
BASIC SCIENCE
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 30:3 259 Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
þÿDownloaded for Manuel Azael Rodrÿýguez Cigala (manuel_azael_rc@hotmail.com) at Autonomous University of Guadalajara from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on October 13, 2020.
For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
BASIC SCIENCE
needle directly towards a nerve and placing it as close as It should be noted that because of a series of five serious
possible, to now aiming next to nerves but in to the same tissue untoward incidents in the United States, the ISB is the only block
plane. This will improve block success rates and enable better that the ASRA guidelines say must be done on awake patients.
teaching of techniques and therefore risk benefit ratio should There is no such consensus in Europe and these guidelines did
improve. Ultrasound has also allowed new techniques and ap- not take in to account ultrasound.
proaches to be described. There is some evidence that a suprascapular nerve block
alone provides analgesia of the shoulder but it is inferior to the
Upper limb interscalene block and cannot therefore be recommended. Intra-
articular or subacromial LA appears to have little benefit over
All regional anaesthesia requires a detailed knowledge of the
placebo.
nerve distribution of the limb and this is especially true of the
The ISB will not block the lower trunk (C8 and T1) and its
upper limb. There is no blanket block which is all encompassing
divisions. It cannot therefore be used alone for surgery of the
and so the regional anaesthetist has to have a detailed knowledge
hand or elbow (Figure 2a and b).
of the brachial plexus and its surrounding anatomy.
The brachial plexus and its terminal branches are easy to Elbow and distal arm
visualize and identify with ultrasound and this is therefore For surgery below the shoulder a supra-clavicular, SCB, or
becoming the gold standard for brachial plexus blockade. axillary brachial plexus block, ABPB, are ideal and again are
aided by ultrasound. The infra-clavicular approach is now less
The shoulder
commonly used because of its proximity to the pleura but is
The innervation of the shoulder is from the axillary and supra-
similar to the SCB. The SCB has been named the “spinal of the
scapular nerves derived from the upper trunk of the brachial
arm” as it is the only site where all of the trunks and divisions are
plexus. The area medial to deltoid is however innervated by the
in close proximity lying superior lateral to the subclavian artery.
supra-clavicular branches of the superficial cervical plexus and
Even here it is a two injection technique. The C8/T1 lower trunk
will require additional LA if the surgical site extends medial to
has to be identified separately as it begins its descent behind the
the delto-pectoral groove.
1st rib by passing behind the subclavian artery to become the
For shoulder surgery there is only one block that will reli-
medial cord (and subsequently the ulna nerve).
ably anaesthetize/analgize the shoulder and that is the inter-
The SCB does carry a small risk of pneumothorax and
scalene, ISB. C5 and 6 roots are blocked as the upper trunk lies
vascular puncture and this makes ultrasound an invaluable aid.
between the middle and anterior scalene muscles in the neck.
Because of ultrasound, the use of the SCB has become much
Lower brachial plexus blocks near the clavicle are possible but
more popular in hand units where previously it was out of favour
do not reliably block the suprascapular nerve as it arises from
(Figure 3a and b).
the upper trunk fairly high in the neck and gives a sensory
The axillary block has become at least a three if not four in-
innervation to the posterior capsule of the shoulder. A single
jection technique because of the unacceptable levels of missed
shot nerve block gives up to 17 hours analgesia and is therefore
terminal branches with the original single shot technique. LA is
excellent for many day case procedures. Unfortunately shoul-
placed around the ulna, median and radial nerves separately as
der surgery is particularly painful and this pain often exceeds
well as the musculo-cutaneous nerve as it lies away from the
24 hours.23 This has led to the development of interscalene
artery between the biceps and coracobrachialis muscles. Recent
catheters which, providing there is robust support in the com-
studies have refuted this suggestion however, and single shot
munity, are safe to be continued out of hospital following early
blocks deep to the artery have been shown to be as successful as
discharge.24 However this level of support has proved difficult
multi injection techniques albeit with large volumes.
to obtain in the UK and may not now be necessary as the
A recent development with ultrasound is the selective block-
addition of dexamethasone has been shown to extend the block
ing of nerves supplying the operative site with long acting LA,
to more than 24 hours.
Figure 2 (a and b) Ultrasound image of interscalene space using Sonosite S nerve portable ultrasound machine.
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 30:3 260 Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
þÿDownloaded for Manuel Azael Rodrÿýguez Cigala (manuel_azael_rc@hotmail.com) at Autonomous University of Guadalajara from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on October 13, 2020.
For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
BASIC SCIENCE
Figure 3 (a and b) Ultrasound image of supraclavicular region using Sonosite S nerve portable ultrasound
machine.
such as the ulna and median nerves for hand surgery, and mentioned above the principle problem with any lower limb RA
blocking the remaining nerves with short acting LA to cover the is the associated motor block preventing early mobilization.
period of operation and tourniquet only. However peripheral nerve blocks have been shown to improve
Rescue blocks of peripheral nerves are easy to achieve at or perioperative outcomes after lower limb arthroplasty surgery so
below the elbow if a partial brachial plexus block is insufficient should not be totally excluded.26 This lack of ambulation is far
for surgery. less of a problem with soft tissue knee surgery such as ACL
repairs and indeed peripheral nerve blocks may facilitate early
discharge by minimizing parenteral opiates and their associated
Key points in upper limb RA
side effects of postoperative nausea and vomiting.
Bilateral lower limb procedures are a particular problem for
C All approaches are aided by Ultrasound.
RA as even single side procedures require near maximum LA
C All carry the risk of vascular puncture.
doses. CNB therefore remains the mode of analgesia most
Shoulder commonly used for bilateral lower limb arthroplasty.
C Interscalene is the only reliable block but area medial to deltoid is
innervated by cervical plexus. The femoral nerve block, FNB: is easy to achieve and success
C Significant postoperative pain extends beyond the duration of rates have improved with the use of ultrasound. With ultrasound
single shot block (consider interscalene catheter or the fascial plane between the fascia iliaca and the iliacus muscle
dexamethasone). is easy to visualize and lateral spread of LA towards the lateral
cutaneous nerve confirms that a large volume FNB is a two in
Elbow and distal arm/hand
one block not three in one. There is little difference between a
C Supra-clavicular or axillary blocks are suitable.
“fascia Iliaca block” and a femoral nerve block, the former being
C SCB is a two injection technique because of lack of spread of LA
used in the preoperative setting of fractured neck of femur pa-
to the lower trunk.
tients. In some centres catheters have been placed in this fascial
C ABPB is a multiple injection technique as a single injection does
plane to prolong the block. Despite the use of low concentration
not reliably spread around all terminal branches.
LA, motor block is still a potential problem with catheters but
discharge home only one day post TKR has been achieved with a
catheter in situ.27 It is true to say that because of the mobilization
issue, femoral nerve blocks are becoming confined to soft tissue
Lower limb surgery only in many centres(Figure 4a and b).
The sensory innervation of the lower limb arises from both the The adductor canal block, ACB: is a recently popularized block
lumbar and sacral plexus which though joined, are impossible to that is still finding its place in regional analgesia for orthopaedic
anaesthetize with a single plexus block. It is for this reason that surgery. After the femoral nerve splits the saphenous nerve fol-
central neuraxial block became the principal anaesthetic tech- lows the superficial femoral artery in to the adductor canal and is
nique for lower limb surgery and until recently epidural catheters visualized with ultrasound. The advantage of this block, which is
for postoperative analgesia were common. There is little evi- predominantly a saphenous nerve block, is that if done with
dence however that the preconception of CNB being safer or small volumes (less than 10 ml) little or no motor block occurs.
more effective than GA has any basis as per a 2016 review.25 Of course only the medial and anterior knee (as well as antero-
It is now more commonly the practice to provide anaesthesia medial lower leg) is analgized but the advantage of no motor
with CNB or GA but postoperative analgesia with spinal opiates block may outweigh the disadvantage of less analgesia in knee
and/or peripheral nerve blocks or LIA, i.e. no epidural. As surgery.
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 30:3 261 Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
þÿDownloaded for Manuel Azael Rodrÿýguez Cigala (manuel_azael_rc@hotmail.com) at Autonomous University of Guadalajara from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on October 13, 2020.
For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
BASIC SCIENCE
Figure 4 (a and b) Ultrasound image using a GE LOGIQ E machine of in plane femoral nerve block showing LA
spread under the fascia Iliaca.
The sciatic nerve block, SNB: is less easy to achieve in inex- The knee
perienced hands. Above the popliteal fossa it is less easy to The innervation of the knee is from the femoral and the sciatic
define using ultrasound and access to the nerve can be difficult. nerves. Historically it is believed that the obturator nerve gives a
Despite its significant innervation of the posterior capsule of the variable sensory innervation to the medial knee however the
knee and the tibial plateau, most studies have failed to show its clinical evidence for this is poor. Unlike the hip, complete anal-
efficacy following TKR perhaps because of the high failure rate of gesia of the knee is possible with just two peripheral nerve blocks
this block. It is not therefore recommended in the PROSPECT although the addition of a sciatic nerve block to a femoral nerve
review.28 However in experienced hands the SNB is an excellent block remains contentious as discussed above. The PROSPECT
block for analgesia for a large area of the lower limb. In combi- working group review, published in 2008, supported the use of
nation with a FNB, complete knee analgesia is achieved with no GA plus a single shot femoral nerve block or spinal anaesthesia
opiate requirement. Again the prolonged nature of this block plus spinal opiates. Unfortunately, this group has not considered
makes early mobilization difficult if high concentration long LIA in their review.
acting LA is used. The combination of a relatively high failure Total knee replacement surgery generally is more painful than
rate, the lack of evidence of efficacy and the inevitable delay in total hip arthroplasty. The dose of intrathecal morphine required
mobilization has virtually led to the abandonment of this pro- is significantly higher than for hip surgery and as the concomi-
cedure for surgery at or above the knee except for amputations. tant side effects increase so does the risk benefit ratio.
A distal SNB at the popliteal fossa causes far less problems It does appear that analgesia is more difficult to obtain with
with mobilization is easier to visualize and do with ultrasound knee arthroplasty and hence the continued popularity of pe-
and it therefore remains the main stay for analgesia for major ripheral nerve blocks (femoral or adductor canal) for this type of
foot and ankle surgery. surgery. For the anaesthetist it is a balancing act between
adequate analgesia to allow mobilization and too much analgesia
The hip preventing it. The concept of no pain after major joint surgery
The innervation of the hip joint is from the sciatic, obturator and should perhaps be replaced with pain control adequate enough to
femoral nerves and the overlying skin lateral to the joint the facilitate early ambulation in relative comfort rather than the
lateral cutaneous nerve of the thigh (LCN). Because of this, search for zero pain.
multiple innervation peripheral nerve blocks are not ideal for hip Analgesia and early discharge for soft tissue knee recon-
surgery although significant analgesia is achieved with a lumbar structive surgery can be facilitated by a femoral nerve block
plexus block when combined with a high sciatic nerve block. alone. Some centres in the US discharge ACL patients with
The lumbar plexus block is a facial plane block of the lumbar femoral catheters but in the UK a single shot femoral block is the
plexus roots within the confines of the psoas muscle. It has the norm and this does not prevent discharge on day of surgery
advantage of being a single shot block for femoral, obturator and despite the loss of motor function.
LCN. However it has the significant disadvantages of high vol-
ume of LA required and unpredictable epidural spread. Foot and ankle surgery
Spinal anaesthesia, with or without LIA, when combined with The innervation of the foot and ankle is predominantly from the
spinal opiates is likely to become the gold standard for hip sur- terminal branches of the sciatic nerve. There is a small variable
gery analgesia as it provides excellent analgesia without pro- but never the less significant supply from the saphenous branch
longed motor block. However similar results for fast track of the femoral nerve from the medial malleolus to the base of the
surgery with discharge on day one have been achieved with short first metatarsal. Excellent analgesia is therefore achieved either
term epidural analgesia in hip arthroplasty surgery.29 It is quite by blocking the sciatic nerve in the popliteal fossa or for foot
possible therefore that early mobilization and discharge can be surgery by blocking the terminal branches at the ankle. The
achieved in hip surgery what ever technique is employed as long popliteal block is amenable to catheter placement to prolong
as long acting motor block is avoided. analgesia. The saphenous nerve can be blocked medial to the
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 30:3 262 Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
þÿDownloaded for Manuel Azael Rodrÿýguez Cigala (manuel_azael_rc@hotmail.com) at Autonomous University of Guadalajara from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on October 13, 2020.
For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
BASIC SCIENCE
knee or at the ankle adjacent to the saphenous vein and more 6 Forster JG, Rosenberg Per H. Clinical useful adjuvants in regional
recently by ultrasound in the adductor canal. Major foot surgery anaesthesia16: 477e86.
can therefore be achieved as day case procedures and can be 7 Cummings III KC, Napierkowski DE, Parra-Sanchez I, et al. Effect
done under block alone with little motor block delaying of dexamethasone on the duration of interscalene nerve blocks
discharge. with ropivacaine or bupivacaine. Br J Aneasth 2011; 107: 446e53.
8 Marhofer C, kettner SC, Marhofer P, Pils S, Weber M, Zeitlinger M.
Dexmedetomidine as an adjuvant to ropivacaine prolongs pe-
ripheral nerve block: a volunteer study. Br J Anaesth 2013; 110:
Key points in lower limb RA
438e42.
9 Choi S, Rodseth R, McCartney CJL. Effects of dexamethasone as
C All procedure possible under GA or central neuraxial block.
a local anaesthetic adjuvant for brachial plexus block: a systemic
C Innervation of all major joints is from lumbar and sacral plexus
review and meta-analysis of randomized trials. Br J Anesth 2014;
making single plexus block inadequate.
112: 427e39.
Hip 10 Martinez V, Fletcher D. Dexamethasone and peripheral nerve
C Because of multiple innervation spinal anaesthesia opiates blocks: on the nerve or intravenous. Br J Anaesth 2014; 113:
LIA is the preferred technique by many. 340e3.
C Alternatives include lumbar plexus block. 11 Noss CD, Mackenzie LD, Kostash MA. Adjuvant dexamethasone:
C Early ambulation and discharge possible in most cases if long innovation, farce, or folly? Reg Anesth Pain Med 2014; 39: 540e5.
acting LA avoided. 12 Duncan L, Wildsmith JAW. Editorial 11: liposomal local anaes-
thetics75: 260e1.
Knee
13 Viscusi ER, Sinatra R, Onel E, Ramamoorthy SL. The safety of
C TKR generally more painful than THR.
liposome bupivacaine, a novel local analgesic formulation. Clin J
C RA presents a more difficult balance between adequate analgesia
Pain 2014; 30: 102e10.
to facilitate mobilization and too much motor block inhibiting it.
14 Baxter R, Bramlett K, Onel E, Daniels S. Clin therapeutics35:
C Adductor canal block has the advantage over a femoral block of
312e20.
no motor block despite significant knee analgesia.
15 Cook TM, Counsell D, Wildsmith JAW. Major complications of
central neuraxial block: report on the third project of the Royal
Conclusion College of anaesthetists. Br J Anaesth 2009; 102: 179e90.
16 AAGBI guidelines: regional anaesthesia and patients with abnor-
RA in orthopaedic surgery has moved to become more efficient,
malities of coagulation. 2013, https://www.aagbi.org/sites/
safer and evidence based. There is now a realization that simply
default/files/rapac_2013_web.pdf.
giving a general anaesthetic is no longer the best technique for
17 Guidelines from the American Society of Regional Anaesthesia
the vast majority of major orthopaedic procedures as regional
and Pain Medicine. Interventional spine and pain procedures in
analgesia will improve surgical outcome as well as patient
patients on antiplatelet and anticoagulant medications. Reg
satisfaction. However, particularly in lower limb surgery, long
Anesth Pain Med 2015; 40: 182e212.
acting RA may well be detrimental to the patient if early post-
18 Mar GJ, Barrington MJ, McGuirk BR. Acute compartment syn-
operative mobilization is inhibited by a dense regional block. RA
drome of the lower limb and the effect of postoperative analgesia
must therefore be considered a balance both by the surgeon and
on diagnosis. Br J Anaesth 2009; 102: 3e11.
anaesthetist. It therefore is essential that both members of the
19 Kehlet H, Wilmore DW. Multimodal strategies to improve surgical
team have a treatment plan that includes intra- and post-
outcome. Am J Surg 2002; 183: 630e41.
operative needs and aims and neither is blinded to the other’s
20 Kehlet H, Wilmore DW. Evidence-based surgical care and the
requirements. A
evolution of fast-track surgery. Ann Surg 2008; 248: 189e98.
21 Kerr D, Kohan L. Local infiltration analgesia: a technique for the
REFERENCES control of acute postoperative pain following knee and hip sur-
1 Koller C. On the use of cocaine for producing anaesthesia on the gery. Acta Orthop 2008; 79: 174e83.
eye. Lancet 1884; 2: 990. 22 Liu SS, YaDeau JT, Shaw PM, Wilfred S, Shetty T, Gordon M.
2 Bier A. Versuche uber coacinisirung des ruckenmarkes. Dtsch Z Incidence of unintentional intraneural injection and postoperative
Chir 1899; 5151: 361. neurological complications with ultrasound-guided interscalene
3 Borgeat A, Kalberer F, Jacob H, et al. Patient-controlled inter- and supraclavicular nerve blocks. Anaesthesia 2011; 66: 168e74.
scalene analgesia with ropivicaine 0.2% versus bupivicaine 23 Wilson AT, Nicholson E, Burton L, Wild C. Analgesia for day-case
0.15% after major open shoulder surgery: the effects on hand shoulder surgery. Br J Anaesth 2004; 92: 414e5.
motor function. Anesth Analg 2001; 92: 218e23. 24 Swenson JD, Bay N, Loose E, et al. Outpatient management of
4 Ilfeld BM, Yaksh TL. The end of postoperative pain-A fast- continuous peripheral nerve catheters placed using ultrasound
approaching possibility? And, if so, will we be ready? Reg Anesth guidance: an experience of 620 patients. Anesth Analg 2006; 183:
Pain Med 2009; 34: 85e7. 630e41. 1436e1443.
5 Rostund T, Kehlet H. High-dose local infiltration analgesia after 25 Johnson RL, Kopp SL, Burkle CM, et al. Neuraxial vs general
hip and knee replacement-what is it, why does it work, and what anaesthesia for total hip and total knee arthroplasty: a systemic
are the future challenges? Acta Orthop 2007; 78: 159e61. review of comparative-effectiveness research. Br J Anaesth 2016;
116: 163e76.
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 30:3 263 Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
þÿDownloaded for Manuel Azael Rodrÿýguez Cigala (manuel_azael_rc@hotmail.com) at Autonomous University of Guadalajara from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on October 13, 2020.
For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
BASIC SCIENCE
26 Hebl JR, Dilger JA, Byer DE, et al. A pre-emptive multimodal 28 Fischer HB, Simanski CJ, Sharp C, et al. A procedure-specific
pathway featuring peripheral nerve block improves perioperative systematic review and consensus recommendations for post-
outcomes after major orthopaedic surgery. Reg Anesth Pain Med operative analgesia following total knee arthroplasty. Anaesthesia
2008; 33: 510e7. 2008; 63: 1105e23.
27 Ilfeld BM, Gearden PF, Enneking F, et al. Total knee arthroplasty 29 Berger RA, Sanders SA, Thill ES, Sporer SM, Della Valle C. Newer
as an overnight-stay procedure using continuous femoral nerve anaesthesia and rehabilitation protocols enable outpatient hip
blocks at home: a prospective feasibility study. Anesth Analg replacement in selected patients. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2009;
2006; 102: 87e90. 467: 1424e30.
ORTHOPAEDICS AND TRAUMA 30:3 264 Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
þÿDownloaded for Manuel Azael Rodrÿýguez Cigala (manuel_azael_rc@hotmail.com) at Autonomous University of Guadalajara from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on October 13, 2020.
For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2020. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.