Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Body Image Dissatisfaction and Its Relationships With Psychiatric Symptomatology, Eating Female Adolescents
Body Image Dissatisfaction and Its Relationships With Psychiatric Symptomatology, Eating Female Adolescents
35
Vol. 16 No.1 January 2009 Current Psychiatry [Egypt]
36
Vol. 16 No.1 January 2009 Current Psychiatry [Egypt]
who reported satisfaction with their present because of the absence of answers for some
figures was found19. Also self-esteem was questions, the data of 24 subjects were
not a correlate of body-esteem, size excluded. 416 students finally constituted
overestimation, or eating disturbance20. the sample of this study. The students
Thus, research examining the relationships ranged from 15 to 18 years in age, with a
between psychological well-being variables mean age of 16.55 (SD=0.66).
and perceptions of body image has not The anonymous questionnaire took
resulted in any conclusive understanding of approximately 45 min to complete.
the nature or extent of relationship between Students were given the option of receiving
these constructs. the results of their assessment if they gave a
The purposes of this study are: (1) to telephone number and coded name. Data
describe the prevalence and levels of body were collected in November and December
image dissatisfaction among Egyptian 2007.
female adolescents (2) to examine the Measures: All participants completed the
relationship of Psychiatric symptomatology following questionnaire:
and negative Eating beliefs with Body Socio Demographic Questionnaire: This
image dissatisfaction and (3) to examine the questionnaire collected demographic
effects of perceived body image variables (age, self-reported, marital status,
dissatisfaction on self-esteem in high school as it measures the social class classification
population in Egypt. by measuring the level of education of
SUBJECTS AND METHODS subjects and their parents and the average
family income and family index per room
Subjects and sampling method: The
and electric and sanitary services)21.
subjects of the study were from first,
second and third years of secondary school Body Image Distortion Questionnaire:
students of 2 public and 2 private secondary BIDQ is an Arabic questionnaire22 that
schools across Cairo; Egypt. Hence consists of a 34 item scale with scores
increasing the representativeness of the between 1 (never) to 5 (always) for each
sample with regard to demographic item. It measures the cognitive and
variables including socioeconomic status behavioral symptoms which associated with
(i.e. annual income of household), personal body dissatisfaction. A lower
birthplace and geographic location. Prior to score less than 112 indicates more body
data collection, the purpose of the study dissatisfaction while higher score more than
was described, and consent was obtained. 140 indicate high self body image
Approval was obtained from the School satisfaction and between 112 and 140
authorities and oral informed consent was scores indicates Average Body satisfaction.
obtained from the parents of students. The Eating Disorder Belief Questionnaire
Participants were assured of anonymity and (EDBQ): Self-report questionnaire was to
confidentiality. The questionnaires were assess assumptions and beliefs associated
administered in the females' classrooms with eating disorders23. Factor analyses
supervised by first author. The
suggested a replicable four factor over
questionnaire was applied to 110 students
eating. The subscales possess good
of each school of total 440. No subject
psychometric properties and significant
refused to participate in the study. But
37
Vol. 16 No.1 January 2009 Current Psychiatry [Egypt]
correlations were found between the Statistical analysis: The data were analyzed
subscales and other measures of the specific statistically using the software Statistical
and general psychopathology of eating Package for Social Science (SPSS) version
disorders. Structure consisting of the 1127. The rates of disordered scales in the
following dimensions: negative self-beliefs; subjects were determined, and descriptive
weight and shape as a means to acceptance statistics were used (frequencies,
by others; weight and shape as a means to percentages) exploration of the
self-acceptance using the Arabic version22. relationships between variables was
Higher score more than 90 means negative conducted using Pearson Chi square test for
Eating disorders beliefs. categorical variables. The association
among the scales was evaluated by Pearson
Psychiatric Symptomatology: The mental
correlation coefficients. P value<0.05 (2
health of the sample was assessed using the
tailed) is considered significant and <0.01 is
Symptom Check List 90 Revised (SCL-90-
highly significant.
R)24 and the Arabic version25. It consists of
is a 90-item self-report symptom inventory RESULTS
designed to screen for a broad range of The study included 416 female adolescent.
Psychiatric problems. It is a self-rating The students ranged from 15 to 18 years in
scale with 90 items scored on 5-point scales age, with a mean age of 16.55±0.66. The
ranging from 0 (not at all) to 4 (extremely). social class distribution of the female
It consists of 9 clinical scales: for students was high in 75% (312 student),
somatization, obsessive compulsive, middle in 17.3 % (72 student), and low in
interpersonal Ssensitivity, depression, 7.7% (32 student).
anxiety, hostility, phobic anxiety, paranoid
ideation, and psychoticism. In addition, a Table (1) shows the prevalence of self body
global severity index is obtained by satisfaction where 28.8% show low
dividing the total score by the number of satisfaction while high satisfaction was
items. We examined the 90 questions that found in 39.4%. Table (2) shows the
gauge all the dimensions of prevalence of psychiatric symptoms in the
psychopathology. The Global Severity study group where high prevalence was
Index (GSI) indicates the level of found in psychoticism (21.2%), anxiety
psychological distress for each individual. (20.2%) and paranoid ideation (20.2%).
The internal consistency is between 0.81 Table (1): Results of self body image
and 0.90. Higher score more than 60 means satisfaction questionnaire:
higher psychological distress.
Self body image
Index of self esteem: it measures the degree,
Number Percentage
satisfaction
severity and magnitude of a client’s High 164 39.4%
problem in the area of self esteem26. This Average 132 31.7%
25 item self report inventory, rated on one Low 120 28.8%
to seven continuums yielding scores
On comparing the students with low self body
between 35 and 53 is average self esteem image satisfaction to those with high self body
and higher scores over 53 indicating higher image satisfaction; it was found that
self esteem and lower scores below 35 somatization (30% vs. 12.2%, p=0.000),
indicating lower self esteem. obsessive compulsive (23.3% vs. 8.1%,
38
Vol. 16 No.1 January 2009 Current Psychiatry [Egypt]
p=0.000), anxiety (30% vs. 16.2%, p=0.002) esteem with self body image satisfaction shows
and low self esteem (46.7% vs. 6.8%, p=0.000) that there was highly significant correlation
were significantly more frequent in the students between low body image satisfaction and;
with low self body image satisfaction as shown obsessive compulsive (r=-0.24, p=0.000),
in table 4. The correlation between psychiatric anxiety (r=-0.24, p=0.000) and self esteem (r=-
symptoms, eating disorder beliefs and self 0.53, p=0.000) as shown in table (5).
Table (2): Symptoms checklist 90 revised (SCL-90-R) in the study sample
Number Percentage
Somatization 72 17.3%
Obsessive Compulsive 52 12.5%
Interpersonal sensitivity 40 9.6%
Depression 64 15.4%
Anxiety 84 20.2%
Hostility 100 24%
Phobic Anxiety 36 8.7%
Paranoid Ideation 84 20.2%
Psychoticism 88 21.2%
High Global Sensitivity Index 64 15.4%
Table (3): Eating disorder beliefs and self esteem in the study sample
Number Percentage
Eating disorder beliefs
◊ Negative 36 8.7%
◊ Positive 380 91.3%
Self esteem
◊ High 204 49%
◊ Average 136 32.7%
◊ Low 76 18.3%
Table 4: Comparison of scores of SCL-90-R, Eating disorder beliefs & self esteem for
Self body image satisfaction
Low (n = 120) Average and high (n=296) p
Self body image satisfaction
score <112 Score≥112 value
Symptoms checklist 90 revised:
◊ Somatization 36 (30%) 36 (12.2%) 0.000
◊ Obsessive Compulsive 28 (23.3%) 24 (8.1%) 0.000
◊ Interpersonal sensitivity 12 (10%) 28 (9.5%) NS
◊ Depression 24 (20%) 40 (13.5%) 0.097
◊ Anxiety 36 (30%) 48 (16.2%) 0.002
◊ Hostility 36 (30%) 64 (21.6%) NS
◊ Phobic Anxiety 8 (6.7%) 28 (9.5%) NS
◊ Paranoid Ideation 28 (23.3%) 56 (18.9%) NS
◊ Psychoticism 28 (23.3%) 60 (20.3%) NS
◊ High Global Sensitivity
28 (23.3%) 36 (12.2%) 0.004
Index
Eating disorder beliefs 18 (15%) 18 (6.1%) NS
Self esteem (low) 56 (46.7%) 20 (6.8%) 0.000
Data are expressed as number (percent); NS=non-significant
39
Vol. 16 No.1 January 2009 Current Psychiatry [Egypt]
Table (5): Significant correlations between measures the level of social class according
SCL-90-R, Eating disorder beliefs & Self to education of subjects and their parents
esteem with Self body image satisfaction and the average family income and family
scores (n=416): index per room and electric and sanitary
Self body image services. As shown in some of the studies,
satisfaction socioeconomic status did not emerge as a
r value p value
significant factor as in our study32. This
SCL-90-R
◊ Somatization -0.15 0.002 may well be due to the effects of
◊ Obsessive Compulsive -0.24 0.000 globalization and mass media on the
◊ Depression -0.15 0.002 attitudes and behaviors of young people
◊ Anxiety -0.24 0.000 irrespective of their socioeconomic status.
◊ High Global In our study, the rates of those who
-0.14 0.002
Sensitivity Index
Eating disorder beliefs -0.11 0.025
evaluated themselves as having low self
Self esteem -0.53 0.000 body image satisfaction were 28.8% and
this finding was similar to the rates
DISCUSSION observed from other Arab countries with
rates ranging from 29.4% for Omani
In Western countries, it has been well teenage girls29 and 24.6% for secondary
documented that significant concerns about school girls in Saudi Arabia28. However,
body weight and shape leading to dieting in past studies with other cultural groups
order to be slim are present in preadolescent found that over 80% of females were
as well as in adolescent girls8. In Egypt and dissatisfied with their body4, and another
Arab countries however, there are few study which reported that 68% of females
studies on eating attitudes and behaviors in and 57% of males in their Chilean sample
pre-adolescent boys and girls28-30. Perceived were dissatisfied with their body
body image dissatisfaction is an important size/shape33. This difference suggested that
component of a variety of prevalent health girls may be experiencing more
problems in females such as eating sociocultural pressures in relation to their
disorders, depression, obesity, and self body size and shape.
esteem. Body image dissatisfaction refers
not only to eating disorder beliefs but also A total of 8.7% of 416 female secondary
to psychiatric psychopathology, excessive school students displayed negative eating
cognitively investment in one’s physical beliefs as measured by EDBQ and This rate
appearance in defining one’s sense of self31. was concordant with the previous work
The present study focuses on the potential which found that 11.4% of a population of
consequences of such negative body secondary school girls in Cairo had
evaluation in our society. negative eating beliefs34, and the results of
studies from Western societies, which have
In the present study included a relatively shown the rate of disordered eating
homogenous sample, as all the participants attitudes to be 7% to 20% among female
were females, aging 15-18 years and they college students35, and similar to the rates
were rating themselves as high (75%) to reported in Turkey were 6.1% and 9.9%
middle (17%) social class and this results respectively36-37, and in Japan it to was
according to the scale we used21 as it 5.4%38. The background to these results is
40
Vol. 16 No.1 January 2009 Current Psychiatry [Egypt]
an abrupt increase in dieting among non- dimensions of the SCL-90, in the studied
obese people preoccupied with thinness39. group with negative body image and eating
disorders41.
Our study showed that there was significant
correlation between students with low body The present study showed a significant
image satisfaction and those with negative correlation between obsessive compulsive
eating beliefs (r=-0.11, p=0.025). These symptoms and low body image satisfaction
findings suggest that incorrect self-body (r=-0.24, p=0.000), several studies have
perception causes eating problems among often reported an association between
girls. Analysis of the relationship between obsessive–compulsive disorder (OCD) and
eating disorder beliefs, and self body image eating disorders. The obsessive fear of
dissatisfaction, assessed by EDBQ, showed gaining weight, extreme preoccupations
that core beliefs and schema were strongly with food and body image and an
related to self body image. This study irresistible compulsion to binge and vomit
provides a first step towards outlining a have been seen as a manifestation of
specific core belief and schema profile for obsessive–compulsive symptom32. Also it
those with high levels of eating disorders- was proposed that eating disorder is a
related symptomatology. This was modern variant of OCD in Western
explained as prominent cognitive processes cultures42. It has been shown that OCD
are involved in the internalization of the symptoms persist after recovery from
slender beauty ideal, development of beliefs bulimia nervosa (BN)43. Recovered female
that constitute a thinness schema and a patients with BN and anorexia nervosa
tendency to compare one’s weight and (AN) have a greater perfectionism than
shape to the bodies of various other people, controls and their most common
such as peers and celebrities40. Thompson obsessional target symptoms are the need
recommended programs to decrease these for symmetry and ordering. A hypothesis
risk factors while increasing healthy that eating disorders should be included in
attitudes and behavior related specifically to obsessive–compulsive (OC) spectrum
body image and to healthy eating and disorders was supported by the finding that
exercising. the morbidity risk for OC spectrum
disorders was significantly higher among
Moreover, our study showed that
the relatives of patients with eating
adolescent females with low body image
disorders than comparison individuals44.
satisfaction had significantly higher levels
of somatization (30% vs. 12.2%, p=0.000), There was also a significant correlation
obsessive compulsive (23.3% vs. 8.1%, between low body image satisfaction and
p=0.000), anxiety (30% vs. 16.2%, anxiety (r=-0.24, p=0.000). This finding
p=0.002) and low self esteem (46.7% vs. was supported by reports of previous
6.8%, p=0.000) compared to those with studies where they also found that high
average and high body image satisfaction. levels of body image dissatisfaction were
These results were in agreement with the associated with high levels of anxiety and
study which found more elevated lifetime negative affect particularly in females, and
rates of agoraphobia and higher scores in they concluded that body dissatisfaction
the somatization, obsessive-compulsive, was not only moderated by cognitive-
anxiety, hostility, and psychoticism rational evaluations of one's body size, but
41
Vol. 16 No.1 January 2009 Current Psychiatry [Egypt]
42
Vol. 16 No.1 January 2009 Current Psychiatry [Egypt]
not necessarily representative of young addition, health care providers need to help
Egyptian women as a whole. them attain a realistic, positive perception
of their weight in order to prevent
Third, the study design was cross-sectional.
depression and lowered self-esteem. There
Therefore, any discussion of causality can
are still few studies in developing societies
only be tentative. There is an obvious need
and in the rural areas of these societies on
in the literature for more studies using a
the characteristics and frequencies of
prospective or longitudinal design in order
disordered eating behavior. Further data
to explore whether, for example, self-
from developing countries will make it easy
esteem variations coincide with variations
to understand the cultural aspect of
in body image dissatisfaction or whether
developing an eating disorder and to
one precedes the other. To date longitudinal
compare the societies with each other.
studies in this area have been limited,
including only three that have been REFERENCES
concerned with the adolescent population7, 1. Halliwell E & Harvey M. Examination of a
53-54
. Although these studies have sociocultural model of disordered eating among
highlighted the importance of variables male & female adolescents. Br J Health Psychol
such as body image dissatisfaction as being 2006;11:235–48.
2. Muris P, Meesters C, van den Blom W et al.
predictive of future eating problems,
Biological, Psychological & sociocultural correlates
unfortunately these studies in themselves of body change strategies & eating problems in
have been limited due to small sample size adolescent boys & girls. Eat Behav 2006;6:11–22.
(e.g. N=87)53, restricted socioeconomic 3. Shroff H & Thompson JK. The tripartite
status (e.g. white upper-middle-class girls)7, influence model of body image & eating
or short follow-up. disturbance: A replication with adolescent girls.
Body Image 2006;3:17–23.
CONCLUSION 4. Duncan MJ, Al-Nakeeb Y, Nevill et al. Body
dissatisfaction, body fat and physical activity in
In this study around one-third of the British children. Int J Ped Obesity 2006;1:89–95.
secondary school girls in Cairo, Egypt have 5. Rukavina T & Pokrajac–Bulian A. Thin-ideal
Body image dissatisfaction, there were internalization, body dissatisfaction & symptoms of
eating disorders in Croatian adolescent girls. Eat
significant relationship with obsessionality, Weight Disord 2006;11:31–37.
somatization, depression and anxiety. 6. Luciano L. Muscularity & masculinity in the
Negative eating beliefs and low self-esteem United States: A historical overview. In J. K.
were also correlated with disordered body Thompson & G. Cafri (Eds.), the muscular ideal:
image among adolescents. Psychiatric Psychological, social, & medical perspectives
2007;(41–65).Washington, DC, US: American
researches should be more concerned about
Psychological Association.
issues of body image and concurrent 7. Attie I & Brooks-Gunn J. Development of
psychiatric morbidity and aim to develop eating problems in adolescent girls: A longitudinal
preventative as well as therapeutic study. Dev Psychol 1989;25:70-79.
treatment methods. Awareness about the 8. Maude D, Wertheim EH, Paxton S et al. Body
dissatisfaction, weight loss behaviours, and bulimic
possible risk factors should help authorities
tendencies in Australian adolescents with an
to plan preventive strategies including estimate of female data representativeness. Aust
efforts to reduce societal, peer and cultural Psychol 1993;28:128-32.
pressures that result in thin body 9. Davis C, Shapiro C et al. Personality and other
preoccupation and internationalization of correlates of dietary restraint: An age by sex
comparison. Pers Individ Diff 1993;14:297-305.
the thin ideal among adolescent girls. In
43
Vol. 16 No.1 January 2009 Current Psychiatry [Egypt]
10. Wertheim EH, Paxton SJ et al. Psychosocial 25. El Behery A. Symptom Check List 90 Revised
predictors’ of weight loss behaviours and binge (Arabic version), Series of Egyptians Psychological
eating in adolescent girls and boys. Internat. J. Dis. tests. El-Nahda Egyptian Publications 1984.
Eating 1992;12:151-60. 26. Hudson WW. The WALMYR assessment scale
11. Rodin J, Silberstein L, Streigel-Moore R. scoring manual. Tempe.AZ: WALMYR 1992.
Women and weight: A normative discontent. 27. SPSS for Windows Statistical Package for the
Nebraska Symposium on Motivation 1984:267-307. Social Sciences, version 11.0.1. Chicago: SPSS Inc.
12. Paxton SJ, Wertheim EH, Gibbons K et al. 2001.
Body image satisfaction, dieting beliefs & weight 28. Al-Subaie, A. Eating attitudes test in Arabic:
loss behaviors in adolescent girls & boys J. Youth Psychometric features and normative data.
Adolesc 1991;20:361-79. Neuroscience 1999;4(1):46–52.
13. Shore RA & Porter JE. (1990): Normative & 29. Al-Adawi S, Dorvlo AS, Burke DT et al.
reliability data for 11±18-year-olds on the Eating Presence & severity of anorexia & bulimia among
Disorder Inventory. Internat J Dis Eating male & female Omani & non-Omani adolescents. J
1990;9:201-07. Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry
14. McCarthy M. The thin ideal, depression and 2002;41(9):1124–30.
eating disorders in women. Behav Res Ther. 30. Valsamma E, Abdel Azem M, Salem B.
1990;28:205-15. Disordered eating attitudes and symptomatology
15. Eisele J, Hertsgaard D, Light HK. Factors among adolescent girls in the United Arab Emirates.
related to eating disorders in young adolescent girls. Eat Behav 2006;(7):53–60.
Adolescence 1986;21:283-90. 31. Cash TF. Cognitive-behavioral perspectives on
16. Kaplan SL, Busner J & Pollack S. Perceived body image. In T. F. Cash & T. Pruzinsky (Eds.),
weight, actual weight & depressive symptoms in a Body image: A handbook of theory, research &
general adolescent sample. Internat. J. Dis. Eating clinical practice. New York: Guilford Press.
1988;7:107-33. 2002;38-46.
17. Rierdan J, Koff E, Stubbs ML. A longitudinal 32. Jones JM, Bennett S, Olmsted et al. Disordered
analysis of body image as a predictor of the onset & eating attitudes and behaviors in teenage girls: A
persistence of adolescent girls' depression. J Early school based study. CMAJ 2001;165(5):547–52.
Adolescence 1989;9:454-66. 33. McArthur LH, Holbert D & Pena N. An
18. Allgood-Merten B, Lewinsohn P, Hops H. Sex exploration of the attitudinal & perceptual
differences and adolescent depression. J Abnorm dimensions of body image among male & female
Psychol. 1990;99:55-63. adolescents from six Latin American cities.
19. Silberstein LR, Streigel-Moore RH, Timko C et Adolescence 2005;40:801–16.
al. Behavioural & psychological implications of 34. Nasser M. Screening for abnormal eating
body dissatisfaction: Do men & women differ? Sex attitudes in a population of Egyptian secondary
Roles 1988;19:219-31. school girls. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol.
20. Fabian LJ & Thompson JK. Body image & 1994;29(1):25-30.
eating disturbance in young females. Internat. J. Dis. 35. Celikel FC, Cummureu BE, Koc M et al.
Eating 1989;8:63-74. Psychological correlates of eating attitudes in
21. Fahmy M & El-Sherbini O. The Egyptian Turkish female college students. Compr Psychiatry.
classification of Fahmy and El Sherbini. Faculty of 2008;49:188–94.
Medicine, Tanta University, Egypt 1986. 36. Atila E, Guclser T, Fadime Y. Psychological &
22. El Desoki M. Eating disorder Handbook, Series physical correlates of disordered eating in male &
of Arabic Psychiatric Disorders, The Anglo female Turkish college students. Psychiatry Clin
Egyptian Bookshop. 2006. Neurosci 2006;60:551–57.
23. Cooper M, Cohen E, Todd G et al. The Eating 37. Elal G. Abnormal eating attitudes and disorders
Disorder Belief Questionnaire (EDBQ): Preliminary in Turkey: feminine attractiveness or liberal
Development Behav Res Ther 1997;35(4):381-88. modernity? In: Ruggiero GM (ed.). Eating Disorders
24. Derogatis L. SCL-90-R. Administration, scoring in the Mediterranean Area: An Exploration in
& procedures Manual for revised version of the Transcultural Psychology. Nova Biomedical Books,
SCL-90. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press New York 2003;57–78.
Baltimore 1977.
44
Vol. 16 No.1 January 2009 Current Psychiatry [Egypt]
م ا
رة ا و
اض ا
و ا ات اا و ا
ااه ت ات
.!"#$رة ا%"& '" "(* م ا+ ( أت ارات ا أن ااه ات ه اة اآ
" "س9 و أ,"ت6"! " ااه"ت ا#$رة ا%"& '" "("* "م ا2 "ر34 را" "ى ا/"0ا ا1ي ه-أ
أ
ت ا
ر416 &' $ أ"! ارا.
اض ا و ا
ات اا و ا
م ا
ات إآ ام
س. !م18
إ15 اوح ا!ره,
ا
-')اض )ر8 و
س ا,34 ,
س ا،, -ا/0
ات ا1+ * اام
س ا+ آ.!"رة ا%&
' ()'م ا
&' (* 'م ا+, و"د#$% أت ا. آ ارا ا ارات
اول ا. (90
ااض, آ أ
ت ارا أن ى ا
ت ا
ا. ا%28.8
-/0رة ا2
1
ط#3د ار0
و- آ
أ)(ت ارا ا.
س ااض ا#$اب ا%& و ا, اآ
ب,
ا ا ا
. رة ا وااب اات اا وآ ااب
م ا5
&م ا
45