oO @ books.google.com.pk/book
Chapter 1
Natural Antioxidants: An Overview
F. Shahidi
Department of Biochemistry, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John's,
Newfoundland, Canada.
Introduction
Antioxidants are substances that when present in foods or in the body at low con-
centrations compared with that of an oxidizable substrate markedly delay or pre-
‘ent the oxidation of that substrate (1). Food manufacturers have used food-grade
antioxidants to prevent quality deterioration of products and to maintain their
nutritional value, Antioxidants have also been of interest to biochemists and health
professionals because they may help the body protect itself against damage caused
by reactive oxygen species and degenerative diseases.
Antioxidants are known to act at different levels in the oxidative sequence
involving lipid molecules. They may act by decreasing oxygen concentration,
intercepting singlet oxygen, preventing first-chain initiation by scavenging initial
radicals such as hydroxy! radicals, binding metal ion catalysts, decomposing pri-
mary products to non-radical compounds, and chain-breaking to prevent continued
hydrogen abstraction from substrates. The extent to which oxidation of lipids
occurs also depends on the chemical structure of the fatty acids involved as well as,
other factors related to the storage of foods and reaction conditions
Natural antioxidants from dietary sources include phenolic and polyphenolic
compounds, chelators, antioxidant vitamins and enzymes, as well as carotenoids
and camosine. The mechanism by which these antioxidants are involved in the
control of food autoxidation and rancidity prevention may be different, However,
their presence in the live plants may be for the sake of protecting tissues from inju-
rious damage, Furthermore, the beneficial effects of consuming plant foods have
been ascribed, in part, to the presence of antioxidants in the plant, which is associ-
ated with counteracting risk of most cardiovascular diseases, cancer, and cataracts,
among other degenerative diseases of aging.
‘The process of autoxidation and development of rancidity in foods involves a
free radical chain mechanism proceeding via initiation, propagation, and termina-
tion steps (2). While radicals are produced in the “initiation” step, they react with
unsaturated fatty acids by abstracting a hydrogen atom from their molecules in the
“propagation” step. The reactions in the propagation make up a chain reaction until
“termination” reaction occurs.oO @ books.google.com.pk/book
2 F. Shahid
Initiator
Initiation; LH Loe
Pp
Propagation: L'+0; > LOO"
LOO" + LH > LOOH + L*
‘Termination: LOO" + LOO" +
LOO’ +L* > non-radical products
+L
Antioxidants (AH) interfere with the above process by different mechanisms
‘These involve inactivation of prooxidants in the medium, such as carotenoids that
scavenge singlet oxygen or chelators that inactivate metal catalysts. These reac-
tions lead to a delay in the onset of oxidation and the extension of the induction
period. Antioxidants may also donate a hydrogen atom or an electron to radicals
formed from unsaturated lipids, thus imparting stability to food lipi
LOO* + AH + LOOH + A*
A‘ + LOO +
non-radical products
A+ ATS
In the body, free radicals may be involved in a number of diseases and tissue
injuries such as those of the lungs, heart and cardiovascular system, kidneys, liver,
gastrointestinal tract, blood, eye, skin, muscle, brain, and the process of aging
(3-5), Oxidants and radicals which mediate various disorders are mainly reactive
species which are formed from triplet oxygen, water, and unsaturated lipid mole-
cules (Fig. 1.1)
Therefore, lipid peroxidation is a problem not only in the edible oil and the
food industry, but also in the human body. Excess production of oxygen radical
species, particularly hydroxyl radicals, can affect lipid cell membranes to produce
lipid peroxides and reactive oxygen species (ROS) which are linked to a variety of
diseases as well as acceleration of the aging process (Fig. 1.2)
While hydroperoxides, referred to as primary oxidation products, are colorless
and odorless when present in foods, they are labile and readily produce a number
‘of secondary products such as alkanes, alcohols, aldehydes, and acids, some of
which are highly odor-active and have low threshold values. In addition, polymers
and other undesirable compounds that could affect the sensory characteristics asoO @ books.google.com.pk/book
[Natural Antioxidants: An Overview 3
toe
Or Me 0,
00H LL ont
“ edt hw Sear “e
10" ue 0
tow
Fig. 1.1. Formation of oxidant and radical species in food and biological systems and
their inactivation,
well as the safety of food products may be formed (see Fig. 1.3). Many of these
secondary oxidation products are highly reactive themselves, ¢.g., malonaldchyde
(MDA) and 4-hydroxynonenal (4-HN) (6,7). Both MDA and 4-HN are known to
interact with biological and food components such as proteins, amino acids,
amines, and DNA; the latter reactions are implicated in aging, mutagenesis, and
carcinogenesis in the body (8-11). In foods, the above reactions are involved in
changes in flavor, texture, color, and other sensory attributes as well as nutritional
value of products and may lead to the destruction of essential fatty acids and lipid-
soluble vitamins, in addition to being toxic by themselves. Thus, use of antioxi-
dants in foods is recommended for controlling rancidity with its deleterious conse-
quences. In addition, consumption of antioxidants in foods or as dietary supple-
‘ments may be advised in order to influence the primary causes of atherosclerosis,
cancer and degenerative diseases of the aging (12) (see Fig. 1.4)
Atherosclerosis
Inflammation
Arthritis
‘Shock Cancer
Frost bite Infection; malaria, entamoeba, AIDS
‘Aging
Parkinsonism
Radiation damage
Fig. 1.2. Diseases and damages caused by reactive oxygen species; courtesy of Dr.
M.-T. Huang.ESV Acl 4s)
oO @ books.google.com.pk/book 3
4 Shahid
ui
ant O
oy S40, Son Abra oH tem
Fe re Tnitiators:
snonn | smart oy mt eat te
0 ip re eal Termination
| Q\,
rm dhe sation ogee, presi,
stn DNA, stamine,
ut
Palymeneatn products oH
(dark alread poably tx compounds) pid alsded
Fig. 1.3, The mechanism and consequences of lipid oxidation in food and in the
body and their possible neutralization by enzyme antioxidants
Antioxidants from Natural Sources
Plant-Based Antioxidants
Plants provide a rich source of natural antioxidants (13). These include tocopherols,
vitamin C, carotenoids, and phenolic compounds. Plant phenolics are thought to pro-
tect the plants against tissue injuries as they oxidize and combine with proteins and
‘other components. In addition, phenolic compounds in plants may serve as defense
systems against herbivory (14). By-produets of photosynthesis may also produce high
levels of oxygen, free radicals, and reactive oxygen species (ROS) in profusion. Thus,
plants use a myriad of antioxidant compounds to deal with these in order to survive.
Many of these compounds have basic molecular similarities in that all have at least
‘one aromatic ring and a hydroxyl group. These include phenolic acids, flavonoids and
isoflavones, gallate esters (hydrolyzable tannins), lignans, coumarines, stilbenes,
flavonones, and oligomeric proanthrocyanidins. Together, these compounds produce
an array of antioxidants, which may act by different mechanisms, to confer an effec-@ books.google.com.pk/book
Natural Antioxidants: An Overview 7
TABLE 1.2
Antioxidant Activity of Selected Amino Acids!
Concentration. M.
0.001 0.01
Glutamic acid 092 074
Methionine 0.88 072
Alanine 093
Asparagine oss 0.66
Valine 08: 057
Aspartic acid 086 056
Serine oat 0.47
Lysine 069 037
Tryptophan 045 031
Histidine ot 0.17
"Values represent oxygen uptake in herring oil emul to samples devoid of any amino acid. From
Ref. 11
hydrophobic amino acids, namely, valine and leucine at the N-terminal position
and proline, histidine, or tyrosine in their sequence (see Table 1.3). These
sequences were also confirmed to be present in the B-conglycinin as deduced from
the nucleotide sequence. These authors did not observe any antioxidative activity
when the constituent amino acids were mixed (in proportions present in the pep-
tides) and tested in their assay media, and thus concluded that the characteristic
amino acid sequences of peptides were required for them to manifest antioxidant
effects. The antioxidant activity of P, was similar to that of BHA when tested at
10° and 104 M.
TABLE 1.3
Antioxidative Peptides of Soy 75 Protein and Egg White Albumin Hydrolyzates!
Peptide ‘Amino acid sequence
SOY 7S PROTEIN
P, Val-Asn-Pro-His-Asp-His-Glu-Aso
P, Leu-Val-Asn-Pro-His-Asp-His-Glu-Asn
P Lew-Leu-Pro-His-His,
Py Leu-Leu-Pro-His-His-Ala-Asp-Ala-Asp-Tyr
Ps Val-lle-Pro-Ala-Gily-Tyr-Pro
% Lew-Gln-Ser-Gily-Asp-Ala-Lew-Arg-Val-Pro-
Ser-Gly-Thr-The-TyrTyr
EGG WHITE ALBUMIN
1 Ala-His
2 Val-His-His
3 Val-His-His-His-Ala-Asn-Glu-Asn
‘From Refs. 32 and 33,@ > books.google.com.pk/book
8 F. Shahidi
‘The antioxidant activity of histidine-containing peptides has also been report-
ed by Uchida and Kawakishi (34) and Murase et al. (35). The activity of peptides
examined was thought to be related to their metal-chelating ability as well as the
lipid radical-trapping potential of the imidazole ring. Furthermore, the antioxidant
activity of histidine-containing peptides was higher than that of histidine itself, per-
hhaps due to the increased hydrophobicity of peptides which leads to their increased
interaction with lipid fatty acids. Tyrosine moieties present in some other active
peptides are thought to offer strong hydrogen donating ability
The antioxidant peptides isolated from egg white albumin hydrolyzates were
recently analyzed and confirmed the presence of histidine moieties in their struc-
tures (See Table 1.3). Recently, we have isolated a number of peptides arising from
the hydrolysis of capelin, seal meat, and shrimp proteins and have found that com-
pounds with moderate hydrophobicity were active antioxidants (e.g., 36)
However, the presence of prooxidative peptides was also noted in these prepara-
tions. When added to a meat emulsion system, all hydrolyzates were effective in
protecting meat against oxidation, although to different degrees
Other effective histidine-containing antioxidative dipeptides are carnosine,
homocamosine, and anserine. Carnosine and anserine are found in relatively high
amounts in muscles, and their dominance is in the white tissues where high levels
of anaerobic metabolism are common (37). The antioxidant role of carnosine and
anserine seems t olve singlet oxygen and free radical scavenging as well as
metal chelation (38-40).
Antioxidants Activity of Phytates
Phytates are strongly negatively charged compounds found in many cereal-based
foods. They are associated with proteins or metal ions and as such are capable of
imparting antioxidant activity to many food systems, presumably by chelation of
prooxidant metal ions. Antioxidant activity of phytic acid has been demonstrated in
several model and food systems (41-43).
Phospholipids as Antioxidants
Phospholipids are obtained as by-products of oil-refining, especially from soybean.
Phospholipids are known to affect lipid oxidation, Soybean lecithin and the ethanol-
soluble fraction of a phospholipid are particularly effective in stabilizing lard and
sunflower oil when used at a 0.1~1% level. Swift (44) found that purified phos-
phatidylethanolamine from cottonseed oil was a good antioxidant and increased the
antioxygenic action of a-tocopherol. Later, Dalton ef al. (45) suggested that the
antioxygenic action of phospholipids was due in part to the metal-scavenging effect
of the fat-soluble phosphoric acid. Therefore, use of lecithin and other phospho-
lipids as antioxidants has been practiced (46). Liliger and Saucy (47) have patented
4 process in which a mixture of tocopherols, ascorbates, and lecithin was used for
stabilization of bulk oils. However, use of such mixtures in emulsion-type productsa @ books.google.com.pk/book
Natural Antioxidants: An Overview 9
was ineffective (48). Many other specialized applications of phospholipids remain
proprietary within the industry,
Vitamins and Enzyme Antioxidants
Vitamins may act as antioxidants in foods and in the body, both individually and in
combination. Fat-soluble vitamins, such as vitamin E and vitamin A, and water-
soluble vitamins such as vitamin C as well as B-carotene (vitamin A precursor) are
known to exert antioxidant activity. In addition, regeneration of a-tocopherol by
vitamin C is a well-known phenomenon, Due to the importance of this topic, chap-
ter 14 has been devoted to vitamin antioxidants.
Enzyme antioxidants of interest to food and biological systems include super-
oxide dismutase (SOD) in different sources, catalase, glutathione and glutathione
peroxidase, glutathione reductase, glutathione-5-transferase and phenol oxidase.
Involvement of selenium in exerting antioxidant activity in conjunction with some
enzyme antioxidants is well documented. Details of enzyme antioxidants are sum-
marized in chapter 15.
Methodologies for Assessing Lipid
Oxidation and Antioxidant Activity
Methods to assess lipid oxidation are manifold, and these may also depend on the
system under investigation. Chemical, sensory, and instrumental methods are fre
quently employed. Therefore, monitoring of superoxide-, hydrogen peroxide
hydroxyl radical- and peroxyl radical-scavenging effects of antioxidants is common-
place (e.g., 49-51). Assay media used may vary, depending on the type of study. In
foods, both chemical and instrumental procedures are used; these include determina-
tion of peroxide value, individual peroxides, conjugated dienes, para-anisidine value,
and 2-thiobarbituric acid (TBA) value (51). Sensory analysis of foods as well as
analysis of total and selected volatile decomposition products of lipids may be per-
formed (52). To monitor lipid oxidation, the loss of polyunsaturated fatty acids, espe-
cially in marine or some vegetable oils with highly unsaturated lipids, may also be
followed. Meanwhile, use of novel techniques involving electron spin resonance
(ESR), nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), and infrared (IR) is of interest. In addi-
tion, employing oxygen uptake and weight gain, and use of the Rancimat, Oxidative
Stability Instrument (OSE, and Oxidograph have been traditionally practiced
Several chapters in this monograph are devoted to the application of different
methodologies for assessing lipid oxidation and antioxidant activity
References
1, Halliwell, B.. Aeschbach, R., Loliger, J., and Aruoma, 0.1. (1995) Food Chem.
Toxicol. 33, 601
2. Shahid, F., and Nacek, M, (1995) in Food Phenolics: Sources, Chemistry, Effects and
Applications, Technomic Publ. Co., Lancaster and Basel, pp. 235-277