Professional Documents
Culture Documents
catering industry
D. Gleeson
Southern Health Board and Employment Health Advisors, Cork, Ireland
There is evidence that the catering industry has high levels of work-related injury and
disease. This study examined the incidence, nature and causes of work-related injury
and disease among 315 catering students, at a large school of catering in the west of
Ireland, over a 10 month academic year. A high incidence of accidents that caused
injury was found. Cuts and lacerations, arising from accidents with knives, were the
most common injuries seen, followed by burns and scalds from handling hot liquids.
A significant level of work-related dermatitis was also recorded. Trainee chefs were
identified as an occupational group with a high risk of occupational injury and disease.
This group would benefit from vaccination against tetanus. Work-related injuries and
disease generated a significant workload for the student health unit, which in itself
is a good reason for catering establishments to make use of occupational health
services. Health and safety procedures need to be audited and constantly reviewed
at a local level. Further research is necessary to more accurately determine the
incidence, nature and leading causes of work-related injury and disease in the
catering industry in Ireland. This would help in the planning and implementation
of an effective health and safety management system.
Key words: Catering industry; disease; injury; occupational injury incidence rate;
workplace hazards.
hazards, there is evidence that in many catering establish- Figure 1. CSO data on employment in the hotel and restaurant
ments in Ireland health and safety procedures are not sector at mid-year [25].
always given the priority they deserve, and that many
establishments have no formal occupational health
services [22]. In 1996, the HSA reported that only 37%
of hotels and restaurants inspected had a safety statement
prepared and only 13% had selected a safety represen-
tative [23]. CERT, the state tourism and training agency,
has acknowledged these problems and targeted training
in health and safety as a priority for the new millennium
[22,24].
In addition, there are features of employment in the
catering industry in Ireland that have particular impli-
cations for workers’ health, safety and well-being. Surveys health unit for assessment; however, very minor injuries
on employment trends in the catering industry in Ireland, or illnesses may not present for treatment. Nurses and
conducted by CERT and the Central Statistics Office general practitioners, who are trained in occupational
(CSO), illustrate that Ireland’s recent economic growth health, staff the unit. The student health unit provides a
has led to a rapid expansion of the catering industry primary health care service to the student community.
[22,24,25]. Figure 1 illustrates this rapid growth in The student year begins in September and ends in
employment. A report by CERT confirms high levels of June, with short breaks for Christmas and Easter. Some of
staff shortages, skills deficits and staff turnover in all the courses involve time off-campus in industrial place-
sectors of the catering industry. The rapid growth in ments; furthermore, the courses vary in length. These
employment has involved many untrained workers. factors were taken into account when calculating the
CERT estimates that only 32% of permanent staff in the statistics.
catering industry are formally trained [22,24]. In add- The aim of this study was to determine the incidence,
ition, as in other EU countries, there are high proportions nature and causes of work-related injury and disease
of seasonal workers, temporary workers and young among catering students in a large school of catering, over
workers in catering in Ireland. The net effect of these a 10 month academic year. In addition, the study was
employment trends is that many catering workers in designed to ascertain the workload generated for the
Ireland are overworked and lack experience, training and student health unit by occupational injury and disease.
job security, and therefore are at increased risk of work- The results of this study will help to predict the health
related injury and disease [22,24,26]. and safety needs of this and other catering establishments
in Ireland and thereby aid in the implementation of
The catering establishment in this study effective health and safety management systems.
episode of injury or disease caused or aggravated by visits to the student health unit for treatment and review.
exposure to a hazard in the working environment. Visits to Eight students suffered more than one episode, one
the student health unit for work-related injury or disease student had five separate episodes and many episodes
were recorded and analysed for the following: required more than one visit to the student health unit for
treatment and follow-up.
· The occupational injury plus disease incidence rate.
There were 43 injuries arising from accidents in the
·· The occupational
The injury plus disease frequency rate.
occupational injury incidence rate.
workplace. Eight episodes of work-related disease were
recorded: five cases of dermatitis and three fainting spells.
· The occupational injury frequency rate.
The number of students presenting for treatment, the
·· The age
The and sex of students attending for treatment.
nature of the injury or disease.
number of episodes of work-related injury and disease
combined and separately, and the number of visits to the
· the
The workplace hazards responsible and the history of
accident or illness.
student health unit required for treatment are presented
in Table 2 according to each occupational group.
· Treatment
The severity of the occupational injury or disease.
The occupational injury incidence rate and the occupa-
· The numberreceived. tional injury frequency rate for each group are presented
· required. of surgery visits (to doctor or nurse) in Table 3. Statistics were calculated for episodes of injury
and disease combined and for injury alone.
· Hospital or specialist referral.
The occupational injury incidence rate refers to the
· The outcome.
total number of injuries per 100 workers over a specific
time period. In this study, the time period varies for each
occupational group according to the length of time spent
Results training on campus. The occupational injury frequency
rate refers to the total number of injuries per 1000 days
Incidence and frequency of occupational disease worked.
and injury recorded for each occupational group The 1997 Irish Labour Force Survey of all occupations
Thirty-seven of the total population of 315 students published an occupational injury incidence rate of 12.4
(12%) received treatment for 51 episodes of work-related per 1000 workers per annum, or 0.05 per 1000 work days
injury or disease. These 51 episodes required 70 separate [1]. This figure applied to injuries leading to three or
more working days lost; minor injuries were therefore not
Table 1. Breakdown of occupational groups according to their size
included. Furthermore, due to problems with reporting,
and the time period under study this figure probably underestimates the true incidence of
occupational injury in Ireland. However, the Labour
No. of Force Survey provides the only useful national bench-
Occupational group students Weeks in college Days worked mark and is included in Table 3 for comparison.
Table 2. Record of occupational disease and injury for each occupational group
Professional cookery 1 52 27 37 31 6
Professional cookery 2 14 10 10 8 2
Bar skills 2 2 2 2 0
Advanced bar skills 2 2 2 2 0
Advanced restaurant services 0 0 0 0 0
All groups 70 41 51 43 8
388 Occup. Med. Vol. 51, 2001
Table 3. Occupational disease and injury statistics for each occupational group
Occupational disease
and injury frequency Occupational injury
Occupational disease and rate per 1000 days Occupational injury incidence frequency rate per
Occupational group injury incidence rate worked rate 1000 days worked
and injury) were predominantly male. This was sig- Table 4. Age–sex profile
nificantly different from the sample population of 315
(χ2 = 3.92, df = 1, P < 0.025). There was no difference Students with
occupational All students in the
in the age range between the students presenting with
Demographics disease/injury cohort
occupational ill-health (disease and injury) and those with
no recorded episodes. Average age 21 22
Age range (years) 18–41 18–41
% male 71 56
The nature of occupational disease and injury % female 29 44
Cuts/lacerations/amputations 21 20 knives, 1 oyster shell Struck by moving articles including hand tools
Scalds 9 1 tea, 2 hot oil, 6 soup Exposure to hazardous substances, hot surfaces and steam
Burns 5 1 chemical dye, 1 chilli burn, 3 dry heat Exposure to hazardous substances, hot surfaces and steam
Contact dermatitis 5 5 allergy/irritant (Disease)
Back strain 3 3 manual handling accidents Handling
Faint 3 1 heat fatigue, 1 heat fatigue and (Disease)
tonsillitis, 1 menses and heat fatigue
Blunt injury 2 2 falling objects Handling
Foreign body 1 1 embedded fish bone Struck by moving articles including hand tools
Wrist sprain 1 1 lifting heavy pot Handling
Shoulder injury 1 1 fall on wet floor Falls
Table 6. Leading causes of accidents in the school of catering the student health services, particularly for work-related
problems. Secondly, there may have been minor inci-
This study HSE data [2] dents, which did not present for treatment and therefore
Relative importance (%) (%)
were not recorded. Thirdly, the healthy worker effect,
Slips and trips 1 30 whereby workers who suffer ill-health leave the industry,
Handling 14 29 so that only healthy workers are left behind, is an unlikely,
Exposure to hazardous substances, 33 16 but possible source of bias in this young population.
hot surfaces and steam None of the students left or transferred to other courses
Struck by moving articles including 51 10
during the study period.
hand tools
Walking into objects 0 4 The study sample was young, the average age being
Machinery 0 3 22 years. An older population would be expected to have
Falls 2 1.8 more allergic disease due to sensitization and more
Fire and explosion 0 1.6 musculoskeletal problems, but probably lower injury rates
Electric shock 0 0.5
Transport 0 0.3
as a consequence of their experience and training.
Of the cohort under study, 77% were trainee chefs and
therefore handled knives and hot liquids, and worked
with ovens, hobs and grills. This partly explains the high
The workload generated for the student health proportion of accidents caused by moving articles (hand
services tools) and exposure to hazardous substances (hot surfaces
Occupational injury and disease created a significant and liquids), as demonstrated in Tables 5 and 6.
workload for the student health services during the time The study population had a high occupational injury
period studied. In fact, 14% of the total primary care plus disease incidence rate and a high occupational injury
consultations to the student health unit among the study plus disease frequency rate. The statistics referring to
sample were for the treatment of occupational injury or injury alone can be compared with the Irish Labour
illness. Force data (1997) [1], as shown in Table 3. The high
Nearly half (45%) of the 51 work-related episodes of occupational injury incidence rate recorded in this study
ill-health (injury and disease) required more than one exceeds the national benchmark, which indicates that
visit to the student health unit, over one-third (37%) were catering in Ireland, as in other countries, is a hazardous
managed by the nursing staff alone. industry [2,3].
Given their high risk of cuts/lacerations and burns/
scalds, it would be sensible to offer chefs and catering
assistants vaccination against tetanus. Furthermore,
Discussion occupational first-aiders working in the catering industry
A high incidence of occupational disease/injury was should be offered vaccination against hepatitis B. Other
recorded for the cohort of catering students over the authors have identified bar workers as being at risk for
10 month period of study. However, the true incidence is hepatitis B infection, owing to injury caused by glassware
probably higher. First, only disease and injury presenting [27].
to the student health unit were recorded. It is possible, Comparison of injury/disease incidence and frequency
but unlikely, that students may have received medical rates between the different occupational groups in
attention elsewhere. The students were encouraged to use Tables 2 and 3 shows that the first-year trainee chefs
390 Occup. Med. Vol. 51, 2001
carried the highest rates of disease and injury. It must be following a faint in the workplace. All of these were trainee
noted, however, that the first-year chefs were the only chefs. All three mentioned excessive heat and workloads
group to spend 10 full months training on campus, thus as factors leading to their collapse at work. High temper-
giving more opportunity to record their episodes of injury atures, crowds and physical exertion contribute to heat
and disease. However, more likely reasons for their higher fatigue. The workloads in catering can be unpredictable,
incidence and frequency of work-related ill-health (both with periods of high work activity, which are physically
disease and injury) are first, that kitchen work is prob- and mentally demanding. In addition, the working times
ably more hazardous than bar or restaurant work; and are unsociable, with most workers working through
secondly, that this group was the youngest and least normal mealtimes. All of these factors may contribute to
experienced of the five groups studied. This is an im- vasovagal episodes.
portant fact, bearing in mind that many catering workers Catering establishments would benefit from access to
in Ireland are young and lack training and experience, and occupational health services, not only to provide treat-
therefore would be quite similar to this group [22,24]. ment of injury and disease, but also for advice in the
It is interesting to see in Tables 2 and 3 the sharp decline implementation of an effective health and safety manage-
in injury and disease statistics from the first-year chefs to ment system. In this study, work-related injury and
the second-year chefs. This is probably a benefit of their disease generated a significant workload for the student
training and experience. health unit and, although most episodes recorded were of
There is evidence from this study that some workers a minor nature, 5.8% of episodes were regarded as severe
are more accident prone than others. Some students had (career change being recommended in one case). This is
more than one injury. Accident reporting and investiga- a significant finding in terms of litigation, insurance and
tion helps to identify such at-risk individuals, who may other costs.
require extra supervision and training. Interestingly, Sickness absence was not recorded; however, students
significantly more male students suffered occupational with cuts, dressings, rashes or difficulties with manual
injury and disease. handling are not permitted to work. The school’s policy is
Each catering establishment needs to assess its own that students certify themselves fit or unfit and do not
health and safety needs rather than rely entirely on data require a certificate from the student health unit.
from outside sources, which may not reflect local needs. In Ireland, as in other EU countries, a comprehensive
legal framework exists for preventing and managing
This is demonstrated in Table 6, where the leading causes
health, safety and welfare in the workplace, under The
of accidents in the catering school studied differ widely
Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act (1989) and
from the HSE data. The low incidence of slips, trips and
subsequent Regulations [29,30]. Although there is no
falls, electric injury, gas injury and manual handling
legislation specific to the catering industry, there are
accidents, for example, suggests that certain health and
industry-specific guidelines and quality management
safety procedures in the school are effective.
procedures [5]. There is a constant need for vigilance and
The study period was limited to a 10 month academic
the regular review of health and safety procedures in every
year. Due to the latency period for many occupational
catering establishment, in order to ensure compliance
diseases, a longer time frame would probably reveal
with these guidelines.
greater numbers and types of diseases. However, the first
year of exposure to a sensitizer is recognized as being a
high-risk period for the development of allergic disease.
This may explain why four of the five cases of dermatitis Conclusion
occurred among the class of first-year chefs. The catering industry has many workplace hazards that
Working in the catering industry increases the risk of can lead to injury and disease. Young, untrained workers
dermatitis by 3-fold [28]. The prevalence of work-related are most at risk of occupational injury and disease. In the
skin disease (irritant and contact dermatitis, protein catering establishment studied, many of the workers were
contact urticaria) in the industry is estimated to be ~15% young, inexperienced and untrained. They were found to
[6]. Five of the 315 students in this study developed have high occupational injury and disease incidence rates
dermatitis; all of these were trainee chefs whose work and occupational injury and disease frequency rates.
involved daily exposure to irritants (e.g. water, temper- Cuts, lacerations, burns and scalds were the most
ature extremes) and allergens (e.g. citrus fruits, spices, frequent injuries recorded in this study.
proteinaceous foods). In view of this, kitchen workers, particularly chefs and
Skin scrapings were positive for fungal infection in two their assistants, should be offered vaccination against
of the five dermatitis cases, and there was a high second- tetanus. Occupational first-aiders in the catering industry
ary infection rate of skin injuries. These findings probably should be offered vaccination against hepatitis B.
reflect the wet nature of catering work. Occupational disease and injury in this study gener-
Three of the students attended the student health unit ated a significant workload for the occupational health
D. Gleeson: Health and safety in the catering industry 391
services. Occupational health practitioners can offer 11. Ono Y, Shimaoka M, Hiruta S, Takeuchi Y. Low back pain
clinical expertise and advice to catering establishments in among cooks in nursery schools. Ind Health 1997; 35:
order to improve health, safety and well-being. There is 194–201.
significant potential for litigation against employers in the 12. Baldasseroni A, Tartaglia R, Carnevale F. The risk of carpal
catering industry. tunnel syndrome in some work activities. Med Lav 1995;
There is a lack of quality data on injury and disease 86: 341–351.
statistics in catering in Ireland. A larger study involving a 13. Silverstein B, Welp E, Nelson N, Kalat J. Claims of work
related disorders of the upper extremities: Washington
wider spectrum of catering establishments would more
State, 1987 to 1995. Am J Public Health 1998; 88:
accurately determine the incidence, nature and causes of 1827–1833.
work-related disease in the catering industry in Ireland.
14. Buckle P. Fortnightly review: work factors and upper limb
This would benefit the planning and implementation of disorders. Br Med J 1997; 315: 1360–1363.
an effective health and safety management system. 15. Hussain SF, Tjeder-Burton S, Campbell IA, Davies PD.
Every catering establishment would benefit from aud- Attitudes to smoking and smoking habits among hospital
iting its own injury and disease statistics, in order to staff. Thorax 1993; 48: 174–175.
identify its health and safety needs. A system of hazard 16. Harrison WA. The occupations of drink drivers: using
identification, risk assessment, control measures and occupational information to identify targetable character-
ongoing surveillance should be in place in every catering istics of offenders. Accid Anal Prev 1998; 30: 119–132.
workplace. 17. Kjaerheim K, Mykletun R, Aasland OG, Haldorsen T,
Andersen A. Heavy drinking in the restaurant business: the
role of social modelling and structural factors of the
Acknowledgements work-place. Addiction 1995; 90: 1487–1495.
I am grateful to the head of catering operations for permission 18. Nicholson P, D’Auria D. Shift work, health, the working
time regulations and health assessments.Occup Med 1999;
to conduct a study in his department and to the students for
49: 127–137.
their cooperation. I wish to thank Dan MacCarthy, Dr Des
19. Coggan D, Wield G. Mortality of butchers and cooks
Bluett, Professor Andrew Murphy, Dr Martin Hogan and
identified from the 1961 census of England and Wales.
Dr John Gallagher for their advice.
Occup Environ Med 1995; 52: 157–159.
20. Li S, Pan D, Wang G. Analysis of polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons in cooking oil fumes. Arch Environ Health
References 1994; 49: 119–122.
1. HSA. Annual Report. Dublin: HSA, 1998. 21. Coggon D, Wield G. Mortality of army cooks. Scand J Work
2. HSE. Key Fact Sheet on Injuries within the Hotel and Catering Environ Health 1993; 19: 85–88.
Industry, Reported to the Local Authorities. Liverpool: HSE 22. CERT. Executive Summary of the 1998 Employment Survey
publications, 1991–1997. of the Irish Hotel, Restaurant and Guesthouse Sector. Dublin:
3. HSE. Priorities for Health and Safety in the Catering Industry. CERT, 1999.
Liverpool: HSE publications, 1999. 23. HSA. Annual Report. Dublin: HSA, 1997.
4. HSE. Managing Health and Safety in the Catering Industry 24. CERT. Employment survey of the tourism industry in Ireland.
Pays. Liverpool: HSE publications, 1999. Dublin: CERT, 1996.
5. IBEC. Health and Safety at Work. Hotel, Catering and
25. Central Statistics Office. Employment by economic sector.
Restaurants; an Information Pack. Dublin: IBEC, 1998.
Cork: ILO, 1998.
6. Douglas E, Rushton L, Williams C. Is occupational
26. O’Sullivan K. Language problems mean safety risks in the
dermatitis being taken seriously by UK industries? Occup
food trade. The Irish Times 20/11/1999.
Med 1999; 42: 85–91.
7. Wood BP, Greig DE. Occupational dermatitis—what’s 27. McLean W, Shepherd J, Brann C, Westmoreland D. Risks
new? Catering industry. Clin Dermatol 1997; 15: 567–571. associated with occupational glass injury in bar staff with
8. Jeffrey P, Griffin P, Gibson M, Curran A. Small bakeries—a special consideration of hepatitis B infection. Occup Med
cross sectional study of respiratory symptoms, sensitization 1999; 47: 147–150.
and dust exposure. Occup Med 1999; 49: 237–241. 28. Brisman J, Meding B, Jarvholm B. Occurrence of self
9. Ross DJ, Keynes HL, McDonald JC. SWORD ’97: reported hand eczema in Swedish bakers. Occup Environ
surveillance of work related occupational respiratory Med 1998; 55: 750–754.
disease in the UK. Occup Med 1998; 48: 481–485. 29. Cusack D. Safety and health at work legislation. Forum
10. Matsumura Y, Niitsuma T, Ito H. A study of factors 1995; 4: 26–27.
contributing to bakers’ allergy symptoms. Arerugi 1994; 43: 30. Cusack D. Health and hazards in the workplace. Forum
625–633. 1995; 5: 25–26.