You are on page 1of 5

Open Eng.

2019; 9:139–143

Research Article Open Access

Eduardo Linhares Qualharini*, Luiz Henrique Costa Oscar, and Maiane Ramos da Silva

Rehabilitation of buildings as an alternative to


sustainability in Brazilian constructions
https://doi.org/10.1515/eng-2019-0017 ety. However, in order to be achieved in the civil construc-
Received July 17, 2018; accepted April 8, 2018 tion aiming at mitigating such impacts, it needs specific
studies, since these impacts can occur in every phase of
Abstract: Rehabilitation and Sustainability complement
the life cycle of a building, whether they are: design, con-
each other insofar as new uses are defined for the existing
struction activity, use and operation, and, finally, actions
constructions, avoiding the disposal and consequent en-
of maintenance of the constructed facility [2].
vironmental impact of this action. In Brazil, the culture of
The rehabilitation of buildings is one of the areas with
new construction still prevails, even with the relevant in-
a growing market in the country, especially in large urban
ventory of existing buildings, as indicated in studies con-
centers where there is a low inventory of land available
ducted in Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo. Dissemination of
for new constructions. In 2000, the age distribution of the
knowledge of rehabilitation techniques can encourage the
properties in the city of Rio de Janeiro was determined. In
development of strategies for the implementation of these
this survey, it was evidenced that only 39% of the build-
practices in brazilian market. Therefore, this paper will try
ings analyzed were less than 20 years old, which results in
to indicate techniques that may be improved and incor-
61% of properties already old enough to be intervened [3].
porated into the rehabilitation of Brazilian constructions,
Still in this context, considering that the service life of
aiming aspects of sustainability and reinsertion of contem-
the buildings is around 80 years [4], it can be concluded
porary construction in urban heritage.
that there is a large number of buildings capable of suf-
fering some kind of intervention, and it is relevant to con-
sider that the inventory of real estate that demand rehabil-
1 Introduction itation has the natural tendency to increase over time in
cases of lack of permanent care. Thus, the young cities in
Civil construction is one of the most important sectors of Brazil face today what European major cities have experi-
Brazilian economy and its growth brings along a chain of enced before: a reality of degradation established by the
companies linked to the production of inputs, services and natural process of aging.
equipment for this sector. Consequently, this macro-sector Another survey carried out in 2016 brings up a point
is accountable for producing large environmental impacts, that strengthens this demand, indicating that in the city
since they depend, in a summarized way, on the extrac- of São Paulo, there are over two million square meters of
tion of raw materials, the production and transportation of unused or underused buildings and undeveloped land [5].
materials and components, conception and design, execu- Taking into account that rehabilitated properties promote
tion (construction), use and maintenance practices and, at improvements in their surroundings, it is justified that
the end of its life cycle, the demolition or dismantling, be- studies conducted in this scenario may be relevant when
sides the destination given to the waste generated during promoting rehabilitation actions aiming at the territorial
the building service life [1]. improvement in the long term.
In a similar way, the search for sustainability presents However, stock of buildings alone is not the only justi-
itself as a necessity in a global scope, since it acts directly fication to intervene. Thus, the decision to perform an in-
in the social, economic and environmental spheres of soci- tervention aimed at rehabilitation is conditioned by a pre-
diagnosis, i.e., an assessment “in situ” is required, which
will establish the status of existing structures, in addition
to an investigation of documents and designs which will
*Corresponding Author: Eduardo Linhares Qualharini: Universi-
indicate the characteristics of the construction [6]. In this
dade Federal do Rio de Janeiro Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil,
E-mail: qualharini@poli.ufrj.br way, diagnostic tools should be used to support the vi-
Luiz Henrique Costa Oscar, Maiane Ramos da Silva : Universi- ability of actions, which may be indicated, for example:
dade Federal do Rio de Janeiro Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

Open Access. © 2019 E.L. Qualharini et al., published by De Gruyter. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attri-
bution alone 4.0 License.
140 | E.L. Qualharini et al.

MER HABITAT – Méthodes d’Evaluation Rapides, TEST


HABITARE e EPIQR [7].
Therefore, the executed diagnosis will guide the plan-
ning of the building to be recovered. At this stage, param-
eters for sustainability should be incorporated, leading to
incremental gains in projects, where actions are carried
out in order to find synergy with the environmental val-
ues that exist in the current society, and also contribute
to minimize the impact they generate in the built environ-
ment [8].
Also, the sustainability parameters for civil construc-
tion aim not only to protect the rights of the ecosystem as
a whole, but objectively seek the construction of a healthy
building, which provides protection and comfort for its Figure 1: Rehabilitation of buildings in the civil construction sector
and its activities [12].
users [9].
In this way, the present article aims at exploring the
current view in Brazil for the valorization of remodeling with or without a change of function, other than main-
practices of buildings as an alternative to reduce the im- tenance [14];
pacts caused by the sector, contributing to the consolida- • Maintenance: the activities to be carried out to con-
tion of sustainable practices in the preservation of the fa- serve or recover the functional capacity of the build-
cility, promoting the improvement of the environmental ing and its constituent systems, so that they satisfy the
conditions and the quality of life of the region intervened. needs and safety of its users [15];
• Retrofitting: it consists of the union of the term "retro",
from Latin, which means to move backwards and of
the English term "fit", which means to adjust, result-
2 Rehabilitation of buildings
ing in the concept of "reconversion". That is, it is about
the renovation of a building, an intervention on an
The term rehabilitation has two connotations: it can be
estate so that the old one is reformulated into a new
seen as an action in the building itself, or in a more com-
one [16].
prehensive way, an action involving the urban restructur-
ing of the region where the building is located [10]. Thus,
The processes for rehabilitation, besides being an ally
the rehabilitation of buildings can be understood as the set
with sustainability, must also meet the functional require-
of operations which aim to increase the level of quality of
ments. Thus, they are strategies to adapt the building to
building systems, so as to achieve compliance with func-
new uses, the preservation of the city’s historical heritage
tional requirement standards which are stricter than those
and the improvement of the performance of buildings in
planned [11].
the requirements of comfort, energy efficiency and water
Schematically (Figure 1), it can be said that urban re-
consumption. In addition, one must analyze the motiva-
habilitation is inserted in the context of civil construction
tion of the intervention in favor of other construction solu-
and that the rehabilitation of buildings, in turn, refers to a
tions and the following factors, which justify the practice
wide range of actions which seek to recover the usability
of rehabilitation of buildings, are also highlighted [17]:
of a certain facility [12].
• Use of existing infrastructure in the environment and
Restoration, renovation, maintenance and retrofitting
its location;
are the main concepts of the Rehabilitation of Buildings,
• Impact on urban landscape;
and they can be defined as:
• Housing deficit and environmental sustainability
• Restoration: the set of actions whose objective is to
• More economy and efficiency than demolition solu-
preserve and reveal the aesthetic and historical values
tions followed by rebuilding.
of the monument, based on the respect for the original
material and authentic documents [13];
In a situation of economic instability, the interest in the
• Renovation: the alteration of the conditions of an ex-
preservation of the facility is recurrent, since the cost of
isting building, aiming at recovering, improving or in-
improvements and their respective impacts on the envi-
creasing its habitability, usability or safety conditions,
Rehabilitation of buildings as an alternative to sustainability in Brazilian constructions | 141

ronment are lesser than the cost of disposal of the con- • Application of sustainable components and systems;
struction waste. Another point to be highlighted is the le- • Landscaping intervention;
gal issues demanded by heritage institutes which aim to • Improvement of energy active controls.
preserve the historical and cultural aspects that old build-
ings bring with them in their features. Rehabilitation is part of the scope of sustainable solutions
because of its own vocation to reuse the existing build-
ing, which is expanded and improved rather than demol-
ished and abandoned. The useful space recovered can be
3 Sustainability in Rehabilitation converted into a more efficient and healthy space, promot-
ing savings in energy costs, avoiding the creation of tons
Sustainable or "green" construction can be understood as
of discarded waste and also avoiding the intensive con-
the set of techniques and practices of design, construction
sumption of new material that would be required for a new
and maintenance which minimize the total environmental
structure, for example [18]. In addition, rehabilitation be-
impact of a building [18]. The materials used to build, ren-
comes an opportunity to benefit the space with more effi-
ovate and maintain the building are also impacting, as the
cient equipment, from the water, energy and duration per-
amount of water and energy used throughout its service
spectives, whose knowledge about adequate maintenance
life (Figure 2).
can be widespread.

4 Good Practices in Sustainable


Rehabilitation of Buildings
The Sustainable Rehabilitation of Buildings has multiple
aspects because it transits in the knowledge of the con-
structive techniques and in the supply of the materials
used in the construction. Furthermore, it considers the
knowledge of the local constructive culture versus the in-
sertion of the facility in the historical heritage and the
Figure 2: The construction of a building produces several environ-
choice of how it should be rehabilitated. In this context,
mental effects [18].
actions should be considered for systems of a building
as rehabilitated. It’s important to enhance that these ac-
The renovation of the facility constructed can be con- tions are already consolidated for new constructions, and
sidered a more intensive and laborious activity than a new should be improved so that they can be adopted with ef-
construction, since it requires more knowledge and expe- ficiency, observing aspects of how to consider sustainable
rience on constructive techniques from the time of the con- actions presented in the previous item. Among them, can
struction of the facility. On the other hand, it brings with it be mentioned [18]:
professional, cultural and knowledge advancement ben- • In the scope of insulation and sealing, the materi-
efits in terms of learning sustainable construction tech- als and the installation method must be considered
niques which are adapted to the old scenario. Thus, re- respecting the parameters of the climate where the
habilitation practices when incorporated by a sustainable structure is found, luminescence, skill and know-how
modeling should take into account, among other consid- of the team and the budget destined for its execution.
erations [18]: One of the important points is the roof, where the
• Improvement of thermal insulation greatest loss of energy occurs in a building.
• Improvement of air permeability; • For foundation structures, durability is a critical item.
• Improvement of the performance of the window Water and excessive soil moisture are factors that gen-
frames or use of a double system which promotes bet- erate recurring structural and maintenance problems.
ter insulation for heat and sound; Protecting the building through an internal and ex-
• Improvement of coatings aiming to increase the ser- ternal waterproofing system may keep the foundation
vice life; dry, extending its service life.
142 | E.L. Qualharini et al.

• The walls and floors in rehabilitation depend on fac- installing efficient equipment generate a lower cost in
tors such as the weather and the availability of the energy consumption.
material on site. There is a wide range of materials • Old buildings often waste water through inefficient fit-
ranging from wood to high efficiency systems such tings, leaks and long pipes. In addition to repairing,
as the Structural Insulated Panel (SIP). Each system replacing the sanitary ware with modern accessories,
has unique characteristic, durability, energy efficiency implement water reuse techniques and flow control
and cost. Thus, it is the responsibility of the people in- valves increase the efficiency of water consumption.
volved to identify the characteristics necessary to bet- • The HVAC system that reduces air infiltration and
ter serve the building. One must remember that it is al- maintains pressure uniformity requires appropriate
ways possible to combine local alternative solutions, designs for better energy utilization and installation
such as the use of mud and hay bale with traditional method in rehabilitated buildings. The compatibility
solutions such as masonry brick. of new components with the existing ones is one of
• In the renovations, the more complex the roof design, the challenges of this system, that is, it requires spe-
the more difficult the drainage of rainwater will be. cific design and adaptation in order not to affect other
Despite the use of sealing materials of acknowledged construction systems.
quality, a fast and continuous flow must be projected,
avoiding the accumulation of moisture. It should be noted that Sustainability and Retrofit are of-
• The frames are part of the envelope of a construction. ten outdated in legal standards and technical criteria, as
Thus, in the renovations, the replacement of the exter- they are not committed to the qualification of the work-
nal frames should guarantee sealing parameters, ther- force, and also due to the inexistence of courses disclos-
mal insulation, spatial orientation of the structure and ing the constructive solutions found for sustainability in
adopted materials. The selection of frames is essential rehabilitation [19].
for a high-performance building in its service life. Another important aspect is the concern with the ser-
• In rehabilitations that affect the external finishing, vice life of the proposed intervention, together with the fu-
some questions must be raised. Initially, must be ver- ture need for the incorporation of new technologies. In this
ified if the building is protected by heritage institutes context, it is common not to convince users of the use of
and where can be found materials equivalent to the innovative materials, giving rise to mistrust in the appli-
existing ones. In some cases, the paint may contain cability of new constructive processes due to the lack of
harmful elements such as asbestos or lead, and their knowledge of their pathologies and the life cycle that will
removal and disposal must have adequate planning. follow [20].
The choice of finishing should be beyond the aesthetic
concepts, considering also the effect of the waterproof-
ing protection, its recyclability, the risks of the compo-
sition of the material and, in indoor environments, the
5 Final Considerations
effects on the health of the occupants.
The alignment proposed by the adoption of rehabilita-
• The choice of an interior finishing should follow the
tion in an economy that rewards heritage actions makes
criteria of durability, recyclability, environmental im-
buildings efficient as long as the prospective scenarios are
pact, use of renewable resources and climate suitabil-
created to present results that are appealing to the soci-
ity.
eties. Therefore, indicating the real long-term advantages
• The patios, balconies and decks are spaces of exter-
in adopting this set of actions, the opportunities to stabi-
nal interaction in a building, where there is a better
lize or even reduce emissions from the construction sector
circulation of air. In rehabilitation, the spaces unpro-
and the adoption of sustainable measures are challenges
tected against external agents must be made of mate-
for a retrofitting strategy of the existing built inventory.
rials suitable for this purpose. One should be aware of
It is important to emphasize that, in Brazil, diagnos-
the influence of the external area on the internal el-
tic techniques that guide the decision to rehabilitate are
ements of the rehabilitated building, as these spaces
not yet consolidated in comparison with the European re-
can become openings in the building for the entrance
ality. This is a point of relevance so the concepts presented
of water, dust, biological agents, among others.
can be applied, and the dissemination of European’s good
• The choice for an adequate lighting is a relevant fac-
practices should be encouraged, in order to contribute to
tor in the electrical system of a rehabilitated building.
Harnessing the external lighting when possible and
Rehabilitation of buildings as an alternative to sustainability in Brazilian constructions | 143

Brazilian market reach international standards for perfor- [6] Barrientos, M.I.G.G.; Qualharini, E.L. Retrofit de construções:
mance and development in this area. metodologia de avaliação. In: Encontro Nacional de Tecnologia
do Ambiente Construído, 2004, São Paulo.
In addition, commercial advantages of these interven-
[7] J.C.G. Lanzinha. Reabilitação de Edifícios:: metodologia de di-
tions already indicate that there are technical knowledge
agnóstico e intervenção. Editora Nova Europa, 2009.
available internalized in companies. This makes it possi- [8] Vale, M.S. Diretrizes para racionalização e atualização das ed-
ble for each building produced or reformed to reach more ificações: Segundo o conceito da qualidade e sob a ótica do
efficient indicators than the current ones, since they al- Retrofit. 2006. Dissertação (Mestrado) – Programa de Pós-
low permanent adequate use of water, new consumption graduação em Arquitetura, Faculdade de Arquitetura e Urban-
ismo, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro,
reductions associated with the adoption of sustainable
2006.
equipment and the promotion of conscious consumption [9] Cianciardi, G.; Monteiro, R. Z.; Bruna, G. C. Parâmetros de sus-
by the society. tentabilidade ecológicos na recuperação, manutenção e restau-
However, it is important to emphasize that there are ração de edifícios. IV Seminário Internacional da Lares Latim
disadvantages that must be studied in order to make sense America Real Estate Society, São Paulo, Brasil, 2004.
[10] Oliveira, A. B. F.; Manzin, T.; Giacaglia, M. E.; Oliveira, C. T. A.;
with the real feasibility of facility’s interventions. There-
Melhado, S. B. Projeto Integrado Aplicado a Projetos de Reabil-
fore, one should analyze the risks of the solutions encoun-
itação. XVI Encontro Nacional de Tecnologia do Ambiente Con-
tered, how long they will last, how much material they will struído, São Paulo, Brasil, 2016.
save, how much energy will be consumed, whether the so- [11] J. A. Appleton. Reabilitação de edifícios antigos: patologias e
lutions are cost-effective, how much facilities will be incor- tecnologias de intervenção. 2ª Edição, Editora Orion, 2011.
porated, whether there will be proper use and operation [12] Marques de Jesus, C. R. M. Análise de Custos para Reabilitação
de Edifícios para Habitação. 2008. Dissertação (Mestrado) – Es-
management of the building.
cola Politécnica da Universidade de São Paulo, Universidade de
Considering the concepts discussed, one may verify São Paulo, São Paulo, 2008.
that when observing cities that already award solutions in [13] Carta de Veneza, 1964. http://portal.iphan.gov.br/uploads/
rehabilitation of buildings with sustainable tools and tech- ckfinder/arquivos/Carta%20de%20Veneza%201964.pdf
niques, it is possible to find purposes that are already con- (17/08/2017)
[14] Associação Brasileira De Normas Técnicas. NBR 16280: Reforma
solidated guidelines for Brazilian solutions, allowing the
em edificações - Sistema de gestão de reformas - Requisitos. Rio
adaptation to the needs of the country and progress in ef-
de Janeiro, Brasil, 2015.
ficient ways. [15] Associação Brasileira De Normas Técnicas. NBR 15575: Edi-
ficações habitacionais – Desempenho - Parte 1: Requisitos
gerais. Rio de Janeiro, Brasil, 2013.
[16] Conselho Brasileiro de Construção Sustentável (CBCS).
References Retrofit: Requalificação de edifícios e espaços construí-
dos, 2013. http://www.cbcs.org.br/_5dotSystem/userFiles/
[1] V. Agopyan; V. M. John. O desafio da sustentabilidade na con- comitetematico/projetos/CBCS_CTProjeto_Retrofit_folder.pdf
strução civil. Volume 5, Editora Blucher, 2011. (17/08/2017)
[2] Moraes, V. T. F.; Quelhas, O. L. G. A Metodologia do Processo do [17] Croitor, E. P. N. A gestão de projetos aplicada à reabilitação de
Retrofit e os Limites da Intervenção. VII Congresso Nacional de edifícios: estudo da interface entre projeto e obra. 2008. Disser-
Excelência em Gestão, Rio de Janeiro, Brasil, 2011. tação (Mestrado) – Escola Politécnica da Universidade de São
[3] Instituto Pereira Passos (IPP). Armazém de Dados do IPP - Paulo, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo, 2008.
Tabela 7.1.6 - Imóveis prediais e área construída, por faixa de [18] A. Kruger; C. Seville. Construção verde: princípios e práticas
idade, segundo suas tipologias nas Áreas de Planejamento e em construção residencial. Adaptação de S. H. Obata. Cengage
Regiões Administrativas. Rio de Janeiro, Brasil, 2000. Learning, São Paulo, 2016.
[4] Qualharini, E.L.; Ducap, V.; Oriolli, A., Considerações sobre [19] Barrientos, M.I.G.G.; Qualharini, E.L. - Retrofit de construções:
Manutenção e Reabilitação Predial frente às Questões de Auto- metodologia de avaliação. In: Conferência Latino-americana de
Sustentabilidade. Congresso Construção 2000, Portugal, 2000. Construção Sustentável: ENTAC, S. Paulo, Brasil, 2004.
[5] Pereira, P. Cidade de São Paulo tem 2 milhões de m2 de imóveis [20] Qualharini, E.L., Ducap, V.M.B., Oriolli, A. - Considerações sobre
sem uso. http://sao-paulo.estadao.com.br/noticias/geral, manutenção e reabilitação predial frente as questões de auto-
cidade-de-sao-paulo-tem-2-milhoes-de-m2-de-imoveis-sem- sustentabilidade. In: Congresso Construção, Lisboa, Portugal,
uso,10000022553 (10/08/2017) 2001.

You might also like