Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The AD HOMINEM
~EXAMPLE~
First, a direct attack against the character of a person making the claim, her
circumstances, or her actions is made (or the character, circumstances, or actions
of the person reporting the claim).
Second, this attack is taken to be evidence against the claim or argument the
person in question is making (or presenting).
Argument:
M: Well, the Khilafah is not a late construct but something all Muslims have
articulated since the beginning. It’s from the Qur’an and Hadith.
R: I don’t care! Like I said, you’re an Islamist so you would argue that
the Khilafah is a classical notion because you’re an Islamist who weaves his
interpretation in to scripture and you call for the death of millions of non-
Muslims!
Points:
What has being an Islamist got to do with the truth of the argument? Nothing
whatsoever! Neither does being a salafi, Ikhwani, jihadi, modernist, secularist,
and liberalist having any bearing.
s.z.c.
London 2003