Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Penal Code article makes no distinction such claim. Considering that Rosario equally claims
between a couple whose cohabitation is sanctioned that Atty. Adriano wished to be buried in the
by a sacrament or legal tie and another who are Adriano family plot in Novaliches, it becomes
husband and wife de facto. But this view cannot apparent that the supposed burial wish of Atty.
even apply to the facts of the case at bar. Adriano was unclear and indefinite. Considering
this ambiguity as to the true wishes of the
deceased, it is the law that supplies the
Valino v. Adriano presumption as to his intent.
The spouses Atty. Adriano Adriano and It cannot be surmised that just because
Rosario Adriano had been separated for more than Rosario was unavailable to bury her husband when
20 years. At the time of his death, Atty. Adriano she died, she had already renounced her right to do
was cohabiting with his common-law wife, Fe so. Should there be any doubt as to the true intent
Valino. of the deceased, the law favors the legitimate
As none of the family members was around, family.
Valino took it upon herself to shoulder the funeral
and burial expenses for Atty. Adriano. The remains Form of Funeral
of Atty. Adriano were then interred at the The dispositions or wishes of the deceased
mausoleum of the family of Valino at the Manila in relation to his funeral must not be contrary to law.
Memorial Park. They must not violate the legal and reglamentary
The law gives the right and duty to make provisions concerning funerals and the disposition
funeral arrangements to Rosario, she being the of the remains, whether as regards the time and
surviving legal wife of Atty. Adriano. The fact that manner of disposition, the place, or the ceremony.
she was living separately from her husband and However, the law recognizes that a certain
was in the United States when he died has no right of possession over the corpse exists, for the
controlling significance. To say that Rosario had purpose of a decent burial, and for the exclusion of
waived or renounced, expressly or impliedly, her the intrusion by third persons who have no
right and duty to make arrangements for the funeral legitimate interest in it. This quasi-property right,
of her deceased husband is baseless. The right arising out of the duty of those obligated by law to
and duty to make funeral arrangements, like any bury their dead, also authorizes them to take
other right, will not be considered as having been possession of the dead body for purposes of burial
waived or renounced, except upon clear and to have it remain in its final resting place, or to even
satisfactory proof of conduct indicative of a free and transfer it to a proper place where the memory of
voluntary intent. the dead may receive the respect of the living. This
While there was disaffection between Atty. is a family right. There can be no doubt that
Adriano and Rosario and their children when he persons having this right may recover the corpse
was still alive, the Court also recognizes that from third persons.
human compassion, more often than not, opens the
door to mercy and forgiveness once a family Disposition of Human Remains
member joins his Creator. As soon as they came to Under the Organ Donation Act of 1991, or
know about Atty. Adriano's death in the morning of Republic Act No. 7170, as amended by Republic
December 19, 1992 (December 20, 1992 in the Act No. 7885, any of the following persons, in the
Philippines), the respondents immediately order stated hereunder, in the absence of actual
contacted Valino and the Arlington Memorial notice of contrary intentions by the decedent or
Chapel to express their request. actual notice of opposition by a member of the
Other than Valino's claim that Atty. Adriano immediate family of the decedent, may donate all or
wished to be buried at the Manila Memorial Park, any part of the decedent’s body for education,
no other evidence was presented to corroborate research, advancement of medical or dental
PERSONS AND FAMILY RELATIONS – TITLE X: FUNERALS