Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ENLIGHTMENT:
Rationality ---- science / technology
Individuality ---- freedom / democracy
Enlightenment Romanticism
reason Emotion
objectivity Subjectivity
future Past
science Art
knowledge Stories
Light of easo , the e lighte > f o da k ess to the light, illumination / liberation /
ele atio . I a uel Ka t: U ü digkeit = inability to use one's reason without guidance
Leitu g from another ode E lighte e t Des a tes, Rousseau, Ka t rooted in
G eek E lighte e t So ates, Plato, A istotle .
Page 35-60
The Greeks limited idea of the ea th s situatio : the o side ed the Medite a ea to e
literally, the center of all lands. Europe as the Greek sphere of influence was the most
civilized and strongest region, because there was a balance of power (political and cultural).
The identity of Hellas: cultural community (a civilization) sharing same language, Greek, and
same cultural and religious traditions.
As a cultural community of independent states, the Greek cities differed greatly from the
othe o ld , f o Asia, he e the e e e la ge political systems encompassing numerous
communities and luxury-indulging despots who ruled these vast territorial unities with brutal
force. >> Ide tifi atio is al a s diffe e tiatio , as ell us / the .
Bar aria s : those ho did t speak the G eek language > no Greek
G eek f eedo e sus o ie tal despotis > the s all G eek it -states proved in the long
run not to be strong enough to effectively resist the expansionist politics of adjoining
(=aangrenzende) states. The Persians greatly helped to eate a atio al G eek ide tit .
The a e Eu ope a e f o a thi al sto a out a Phoe i ia p i ess Eu opa a d
Zeus, transformed into a bull.
Alexander the Great was the Macedonian king and educated by Aristotle. He wanted heroic
power of a post-bellum utopia, but this came with a price; the carnage of hundreds of
thousands of soldiers and civilians.
Large empire, because of conquering the Greece proper and the Greek world of Asia
Minor, the trading cities of the Levant, Egypt and large parts of the Persian Empire.
Hellenistic ultu e: a i t igui g i tu e e e ged of ele e ts f o G eek ultu e
and the pre-e isti g t aditio s of those egio s. Be ause afte Ale a de s death his
generals divided the spoils)
New world: from polis (local city) to cosmopolis u i e sal it > the itize of the
o ld
Ale a d ia: i te atio al po t , i te ultu al i te fa e
Museion (museum, library, university came to existance), science (Euclid,
Archimedes)
They conquered Rome in the 7th Century, where they ruled Rome for more than a century
with their Kings, in an often tense partnership with a local aristocracy which was united in an
advisory board, the Senate. The aristocrats, known as patricians, based their power on
property ownership.
509 BC: the patricians forcibly expelled their Etruscan overlords and Rome became an
oligarchic republic, a republic ruled by small elite (two magistrates, or consuls).
Rome mainly guaranteed the rights and the property of the aristocracy. Rome also began to
establish colonies in strategic positions in conquered areas, to relieve the pressure of a
growing population in the city itself.
5th,4th,3rd century BC: begin Process of Romanization; imposed cultural elements on
the entire region, in 2nd e tu AD o pleted
How did the Roman Empire hold together?
They had an intricate legal-administrative apparatus, a good infrastructure (the
famous roman roads, bridges) and a strong institutional structure > ith a e pe o
ult Ale a de .
From 1st century AD onwards important changes in the empire: August + successors
increasingly controlled the entire system of government > direct control over a large
number of the most prosperous provinces in the empire> increase their power.
The emperors provided soldiers with pension promises of farms after they retired
from the army to win their support.
Basic principles codified in a legal system
Juridical-institutional pyramid: in the administration of justice, the emperor was the
final court appeal. > The Senate + consuls had to yield most of their power
Austi e s o fessio s
Autobiography, but not as a self-glo ifi atio …
Account of becoming and being a Christian
Co fessio o igi all ea t o fessio , late also : confession of sin and guilt,
profession of faith praise of God
Th ee pa ts of the ook: A s histo o e sio
his present condition (mission)
his reading of the Word (explanation)
Saint Augustine
• I po ta e of ou i e self
• Creator stands outside and above the cosmos
• Influence of Plato (via Plotinus): two worlds> the world of the imperfect body in
which people operate with their impressions and senses, and which they can
therefore know, and the orld of ideas, the higher principles which, although man is
partly unaware of them, exist in every human being.
• Life on earth only a preparation for the afterlife
Mind set
• Idelogy and education: specific curriculum, taught in Latin
• Based on traditional forms and content
• Roman Christianity more and more a religion and culture of ordinary people
• But, also criticism, dissent and heterodoxy manifested itself
• Crucial for the spread of Christian ideology was the monastery
• Praying, working, contemplating, studying, scholarship as the fundamentals of
Benedictine life
• Monasteries became centres of learning, with important libraries, and centres of
education > producing scholars who have been influential in almost all fields in
Europe.
• Many monasteries became grand agricultural enterprises , often worked by
u e ous te a t fa e s ho fu the i eased the a e s ealth ith thei e ts
Human perspective
» > more individualistic view, no longer as an anonymous member of the mass
of God s o edie t eatu es, ut as a u i ue ei g, sup e e i his atio al
and creative capacities > marked as an individual. Mathematical science
athe tha a t .
Art in the 14 and 15th century (in the first phases): reality rather than represent
th
preconceived ideas of what was morally or religious acceptable. > Woman as an individual
pe so , i hose od the pe fe tio of God s eatio as ade as isi le as i the ale ,
no longer ad an untouchable whore.
16th century: Because of Renaissance and Humanism, Spain and German states became
wealthy > material conditions for a new flowering of culture were abundantly present here >
the ideas about the world and God changed dramatically.
Renaissance in Europe
Protestantism
The break-up of the religious unity > Reformation (a religious and political movement that
affected the practice of Christianity across most of Europe during this period).The kings in
Europe (like the kings of Fran e a d Spai edu ed Ro e s i flue e i thei states he
they went over to the Reformation > increase their own power. Luther: broke with the
traditions of the Catholic Church, because they were no longer founded on the oldest
Christian texts as scientifi all esta lished. > The o e of God s e elatio is o l fou d i the
Holy Scripture. (He observed that Christians had whatsoever no notion of the norms and
alues p ese ted i the i le, si pl a epti g, u iti all a d e e supe stitiousl , the
priests pe fo ed agi a tio s Free will: man himself does not determine whether he will
be blessed with salvation. God has already predetermined this.
• 1517: Martin Luther nails his theses to the door of the church in Wittenberg
• P otest agai st the out a d p a ti es of the Catholi hu h
• Need for a turn inward: back to the basics of Christian religion
• Luther disputed the concept of the free will
• Debate with Erasmus about this (1520)
• John Calvin, teaching in Geneva, presented similar ideas as Luther
• Spread of these critical ideas stimulated by printing and the support of European
royalty
Immanuel Kant (1783) in Was ist Aufklärung?: Enlightenment is man's emergence from his
self-imposed immaturity
U ü digkeit is the inability to use one's reason without guidance from another. But also:
He argued for an acceptance of religion on ethical grounds (p. 327)
Enlightenment Romanticism
Reason emotion
Objectivity subjectivity
Future past
Science art
Knowledge stories
Scientific spirit
• Critical, investigative, explorative attitude
• Growing gap between the visible and the invisible world (the microscope opened up
the i isi le o ld
• Rational understanding versus accepted belief
• Cases of Copernicus a d Galilei, ad o ated the stud of the ook of atu e , a gui g
that it as atu e hi h e ealed = ope aa de God s g eat ess, the e s ie e
a d the e easo ed a d easo a le la guage of u e s a d figu es e da ge ed
(=bedreigde) the Christian tradition. > Many felt that if nature were a power in itself
and man could by his own capacity understand it, God and his saving grace would
lost their power and significance.
• 1543 - On the revolution of the heavenly spheres
• Heliocentric world-view (sun as the centre of the Solar System, not the earth as the
Church claimed)
• 1623 - the big book of the universe is written in the language of mathematics
Unbelievers?
• Cope i us uestio s the Bi le s autho it o l as a ook f o hi h s ie tifi
knowledge can be deduced
• For Galilei the Bible was a sacred book, but an allegory only, meant for those who
could not read the book of nature
• Scientific spirit: chemistry, mineralogy, alchemy
• Natu e as a o ple a hi e
• Man only a cog(=tandwiel) in the machine
• Collision of two world-views: the world of matter, a natural world that could be
known, and meta-physics, a world that one could speculate about but not known in
the same way as the physical world.
• p. 316: Galilei s ideas o the atu e of atte e sus atholic doctrine of
transsubstantiation = the doctrine that the substance of the bread and the wine
used in the sacrament of the Eucharist is changed, not merely as by a sign or a figure,
but also in reality, into the substance of the Body and the Blood of Jesus
The self
• Protestantism and Catholicism: self-investigation and spiritual exercises
• Co ept of the i e self
• Descartes: cogito ergo sum = I think, therefore I am
• Discours on Method (1637): learn how to use your reason
• Everybody has rational capacities
• We need to learn how to use them
• I thi k, the efo e I a : it should e e ho is thi ki g a d is d a i g p ope
conclusions
Isaac Newton
• Physicist, 1642 - 1727
• Co i es spi it of dou t a d t ust i alue of e pi i al esea h
• 1687 - Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy
• The world as a dynamic mechanism
• Functions according to law(s) of nature
• Wants to build a sound system based on quantitative, physical arguments
Conspicuous consumption
• Consumerism as elite phenomenon
Two types of elite: the old nobility, its wealth largely based on landed income
A small number of top bureaucrats grown rich in the service of the State as well as
the plutocrats who had had amassed their fortunes in trade and banking.
Convergence of elites
• 16th century: establishment of a well-to-do middle class urban elite
Two elites groups: the intellectual scholarly elite, increasingly from the middle class
and the elite made up both of land-owning nobility and the non- o le ou geois
• 16th &17th century: old aristoc a lost its ole as the p i iple a ie of the e
centralized states.
• Increased emphasis on education and knowledge by the prosperous bourgeoisie >
people ealized that k o ledge ea t po e
• Members of the old aristocracy realized that service to the state ith this ode ,
bureaucratic-technical government was the means to maintain their economic,
political and social position. Education, specialization became necessary for them
too.
• th & th e tu : i po ta t ole of the salo s i Pa is > one of the places where
the sociocultural progress outlined above became visible: artists and scientists from
the middle-class mixing with the lords from the court nobility of Versailles.
Political revolution
Growing revulsion at princely claims to absolute power
New ideas on politics: people - balance of power, between government and
the rights of subjects on the other. Montesquieu – separation of powers
Rousseau – social contract of equal citizens
I F a e the le g a d the o ilit e e p i ileged . F o the th century
onwards they had been allowed to pay little or no taxes.
The French kings retrained almost absolute authority they had won during the
16th and 17th century in their continuous struggles with the nobility, the Church
and the towns > undoing of the ancien régime.
1776 – Declaration of Independence
1789 – Start French Revolution
Start of a reconstruction of society in European states >the power of the old
elites was broken; they lost their legally privileged position. In most countries
every citizen (educated, taxpaying, male citizen) was given the vote and legal
barriers between social classes were demolished. Not for women!
Industrial revolution
Very slow process
Starts in England
Restructuring of production in the factory system
Urbanisation: larges cities, new cities
Often horrible working and living conditions: growing number of working
hours per day, work instead of leisure, working children and women, self –
exploitation as a marked rise in output per worker increased the household
income and altered the demand pattern in the direction of manufacturing.
Growing income was spent on consumption, on a market supplying both good
and services
Women obtained a strategic position in the household economy: taking on the
role of consumers and spending money on consumer goods
Production of ever more consumer goods >mass production > lu u fo all
No longer sufficient jobs in the agriculture, but enough work opportunities in
the closely related industries >people became more mobile, moving to the
industries for work
Human rights
• American Revolution and French Revolution
• Déclaration des droits de l'homme et du citoyen (1789)
Me a e o a d e ai f ee a d e ual i ights…
…these ights a e li e t , p ope t , se u it , a d esista e to opp essio
• Contemporary versions of the UN and the European Council
• Still a p oje t…
Time management
• Industrialization, urbanization: people moving from the countryside to the towns
• Change of life-rhythm
• Fo atu al h th to lo k-rhythm: clocks were introduced everywhere to
remind people that time was money.
• Clock as regulator: regulating work both in factories and offices, dictating the long
hours now put by men and women and children alike, under conditions that were
often horrific.
• Women especially now constituted a huge, flexible workforce: underpaid, liable to be
fired without any warning, they often had to leave their children and other relatives
unattended to go out for to work.
• E e thi g e a e outi e, o ditio ed the otio s a d the speed de a ded
by the clock- at hi g a hi es .
• The division between rich and poor neighborhoods became more visible then ever:
the outskirts of towns as the areas of poverty, immorality and the police often did
ot da e to e te he iots oke out > da ge ous lasses .
• New sense of time
New devide
• Es ape f o the o oditizatio t ap : e o o i offe i gs that a e e e
o odities, othi g spe ial
• E pe ie e e o o : goods/se i es e o e pa t of staged e pe ie es
The gap between the rural and the urban world is replaced by the divide between
ordinary and scientific understanding (p. 442)
E a ple: the e e t No el p ize fo the o k o the Higgs oso
- The WHAT? -
Second World War as a cataclyst of science
Nuclear fusion, computer technology, DNA, biotechnology, brain research, etc.
There is a downside... But are we able we understand it?
Fo fa il a to sala a
F o g oup ide tit to i di idual ide tit ?
Individualism, key idea of European modernity
I di idual f eedo , e a ipatio , Wo e s Li
New forms of relationships
Rise of single-person households
From class struggle to consumption for all?
Rietbergen: to a la ge e te t, Eu opea so iet has become o e ig iddle lass
p.464
Individualism or mass-culture?
Another divide: growing discrepancy between the European cultural ideal of the free,
autonomous person and a culture of the asses o su e is p.
And a othe , that of the ulti ultu al so iet : et ee ati es a d alie s ?
Rietbergen: No. Despite the problems, tolerence is growing p. 466
And: the most important dimension of individual identity is not the nation, but
athe a pe so s o it or region p. 466
Our culture is dominated by youth p. 469
Globalization
What is globalization?
• Blurring/transgression of borders
• Sh i ki g of ti e a d spa e
• The glo al illage M Luha
• The et o k so iet Castells
• Growing mobility, of goods, people, information
Social media