You are on page 1of 14

GLOBAL PRACTICE GUIDES

Definitive global law guides offering


comparative analysis from top-ranked lawyers

Project
Finance
Portugal
Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira
Cuatrecasas

chambers.com 2020
PORTUGAL
Law and Practice
Contributed by:
Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira
Cuatrecasas see p.14

Contents
1. Project Finance Panorama p.3 5. Structuring and Documentation
1.1 Recent Trends and Developments p.3 Considerations p.8
1.2 Sponsors and Lenders p.3 5.1 Registering or Filing Financing of Project
Agreements p.8
1.3 Public-Private Partnership Transactions p.4
5.2 Licence Requirements p.8
1.4 Structuring the Deal p.4
5.3 Agent and Trust Concepts p.8
2. Guarantees and Security p.4 5.4 Competing Security Interests p.9
2.1 Assets Available as Collateral to Lenders p.4 5.5 Local Law Requirements p.9
2.2 Charges or Interest over All Present and
Future Assets of a Company p.5 6. Bankruptcy and Insolvency p.9
2.3 Registering Collateral Security Interests p.5 6.1 Company Reorganisation Procedures p.9
2.4 Granting a Valid Security Interest p.5 6.2 Impact of Insolvency Process p.10
2.5 Restrictions on the Grant of Security or 6.3 Priority of Creditors p.10
Guarantees p.5 6.4 Risk Areas for Lenders p.11
2.6 Absence of Other Liens p.6 6.5 Entities Excluded from Bankruptcy
2.7 Releasing Forms of Security p.6 Proceedings p.11

3. Enforcement p.6 7. Insurances p.11


3.1 Enforcement of Collateral by Secured Lender p.6 7.1 Restrictions, Controls, Fees and/or Taxes on
Insurance Policies p.11
3.2 Foreign Law p.7
7.2 Foreign Creditors p.11
3.3 Judgments of Foreign Courts p.7
3.4 A Foreign Lender’s Ability to Enforce p.7 8. Tax p.11
8.1 Withholding Tax p.11
4. Foreign Investment p.7
8.2 Other Taxes, Duties, Charges p.12
4.1 Restrictions on Foreign Lenders Granting Loans p.7
8.3 Limits to the Amount of Interest Charged p.13
4.2 Restrictions on the Granting of Security or
Guarantees to Foreign Lenders p.8
9. Applicable Law p.13
4.3 Foreign Investment Regime p.8
9.1 Project Agreements p.13
4.4 Restrictions on Payments Abroad or
9.2 Financing Agreements p.13
Repatriation of Capital p.8
9.3 Domestic Laws p.13
4.5 Offshore Foreign Currency Accounts p.8

2
PORTUGAL Law and Practice
Contributed by: Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira, Cuatrecasas

1. Project Finance Panorama and contractual provisions foreseeing the right to financial
rebalance were suspended during the emergency period.
1.1 Recent Trends and Developments
The 2011 external financial assistance programme provided to No other amendments or new legislative/regulatory develop-
Portugal had a great impact on project finance transactions in ments regarding the legal framework for project finance are
Portugal, with a significant decrease in the launch of new pro- expected to come into force. Therefore, the PCC continues to
ject finance transactions and the suspension of all major pro- be the main legal regime.
jects that were in the pipeline. However, in 2019, a new mood
was brought to the Portuguese market, with the announce- Finally, Decree-Law 10-J/2020, of 26 March, as amended, estab-
ment by the Portuguese government of the 2030 infrastructure lishes a broad and comprehensive regime pertaining to a mora-
investment plan (the PNI 2030), which consists of several new torium on credits during the COVID-19 crisis. Subject to the
greenfield projects in different sectors, such as railway, roads requirements legally foreseen, which apply both to the entities
and highways, mobility and public transport, airports, environ- and to the type of facility granted (including project finance),
ment and energy. Although the socio-economic impacts of the this regime established several mechanisms for the protection
COVID-19 pandemic remain uncertain, the government has of facilities, such as the extension of the credits under facili-
not announced any intention to amend the PNI 2030 nor the ties with bullet repayments or the temporary suspension of the
projects foreseen therein. Furthermore, the explanatory note to payment of principal and interest, in the case of facilities with
the 2020 State Budget states that the priority for the upcoming periodic repayments.
years shall be the transport segment.
1.2 Sponsors and Lenders
In relation to recent private investment in project finance, the Construction and operating companies used to be the typical
main trends continue to be in the roads and highway sector sponsors of project finance transactions. However, in the last
and the renewable energy sector, particularly solar and wind few years, mainly due to the crisis that led to the break-up of
projects. The first hydrogen bid will be launched in 2021, and is a significant portion of Portuguese construction companies,
expected to capture significant private funds. there has been a substantial change with respect to sponsors in
these transactions, with former sponsors’ shareholdings being
Key Public Entities acquired by infrastructure funds, which are clearly more active
In addition to the Portuguese government, the Council of in the Portuguese market.
Europe Development Bank and the European Investment Bank
also support investments through the financing of Instituição Although there is no general restriction on foreign investments
Financeira de Desenvolvimento (IFD), a State-owned finan- in project companies, certain specific authorisations need to be
cial company that exercises on-lending activity to Portuguese obtained within regulated sectors.
banks, thus contributing to the financing of several projects in
Portugal. As further detailed in 4.1 Restrictions on Foreign Lenders
Granting Loans, the granting of loans or financing on a pro-
Regulation fessional basis is a regulated activity in Portugal. As such, only
One of the singularities of the contractual framework regarding credit institutions or financial companies that are duly author-
project agreements entered into with public entities is the right ised by the regulator or that benefit from the EU passport estab-
to financial rebalance (reposição do equilíbrio financeiro), legally lished in the Banking Directive and are registered with the Bank
foreseen in the Portuguese Public Contracts Code (the PCC), of Portugal to carry out the credit activity under the freedom to
approved by Decree-Law 18/2008, of 29 January, as amended, provide services (ie, on a cross-border basis without any local
which transposed Directives 2004/17/EC and 2004/18/CE of presence in Portugal) may act as lenders, as well as alternative
the European Parliament and of the Council of 31 March 2004, investment funds specialising in loans (the “Loan Funds”) (sub-
establishing the legal regime applicable to public contracts and ject to several restrictions). In this context, most project finance
the material regime applicable to administrative nature con- transactions in Portugal are financed by duly authorised credit
tracts. institutions.

Invoking the circumstances arising from the COVID-19 pan- Nevertheless, in recent years, particularly due to the banking
demic, the Portuguese government approved an exceptional and crisis, investment funds have become active in this type of trans-
temporary regime in respect of the financial rebalance under action, namely through alternative funding structures, as is the
Decree-Law 19-A/2020, of 30 April. Pursuant to this regime, case for bond issuances (see 1.4. Structuring the Deal and 4.1
which applies to long-term agreements, among others, all legal Restrictions on Foreign Lenders Granting Loans).

3
Law and Practice PORTUGAL
Contributed by: Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira, Cuatrecasas

1.3 Public-Private Partnership Transactions action, the Portuguese-domiciled client contacts the non-EU-
The PPP legal framework is contained within the PCC and domiciled banking entity and requests a determined banking
Decree-Law 111/2012, of 23 May (the PPP Legislation), which service on its own initiative without any prior solicitation
sets forth the regime for the preparation, launch and implemen- and marketing of such a service by the banking entity (ie, the
tation of, and changes to, PPP in Portugal. “reverse-solicitation principle”).

PPP projects are typically project finance structures with a BOT Loan Funds were recently introduced in the Portuguese legal
model, where the concession agreement and its annexes regulate order, by means of Decree-Law 144/2019, of 23 September, and
the major contractual issues – namely, the terms on which the are further regulated by Regulation of the Portuguese Securi-
project company will construct the project and operate it, and ties Market Commission no. 3/2015, as amended by Regulation
the remuneration of the PPP. 5/2020, with a view to boosting capital markets and providing
a greater variety of funding sources. However, its legal frame-
The process usually starts with the issue of the environmental work provides for several limitations pertaining to, inter alia,
impact declaration and urban planning licences, as well as any the scope of credit operations and the entities being financed.
environmental licence that may be required for the respective
project. A good alternative method to raise financing (other than by
means of a loan) is by way of the issuance and subscription of
Under PPP legislation, the risks of the project shall be clearly bonds integrated in a Portuguese clearing system, given that this
and contractually identified, and its allocation shall be made activity is not qualified as a credit activity. This structure also
in accordance with each partner’s ability to manage such risks, presents certain tax advantages.
despite the fact that the partnership should imply a significant
and effective transfer of risk to the private partner, particularly
the financing risk, which shall always be on the private partner’s 2. Guarantees and Security
side.
2.1 Assets Available as Collateral to Lenders
As the main mechanism covering project risks, the financial The typical Portuguese collateral package includes:
rebalance remains with the public contracting entity.
• pledges over the shares of the project company;
Following the execution of the PPP contract, and prior to its • pledges over fixed movable assets (ie, stock, equipment or
entry into force, the Court of Auditors will review the agree- inventory);
ment to verify that the acts, contracts or other instruments that • pledges over the project bank accounts;
generate expenditure or represent direct or indirect financial • pledges over intercompany receivables;
liabilities are in accordance with the laws in force. The acts, con- • assignments of receivables; and
tracts and other instruments subject to the previous auditing by • assignments or pledges over insurance policies and, in some
the Court of Auditors may produce effects prior to the issuance cases (although less frequent), intellectual property rights
of the respective visa by the Court of Auditors, except in respect (ie, patents, trade marks).
to payments resulting therefrom.
In respect of real estate assets, security is less frequent and is
1.4 Structuring the Deal only relevant if the real estate is the only asset to be encum-
As mentioned above, besides the Loan Funds, only credit insti- bered, or when it is a relevant asset of the guarantor or financed
tutions and financial companies that have been previously reg- company. If the legal requirements are met, lenders may use
istered with the Bank of Portugal can engage in activity related the financial collateral regime to the extent it can be applicable
to credit operations on a professional basis, including the grant- to the security and the assets over which said security is being
ing of guarantees and other commitments, financial leasing and granted, such as financial pledges over bank accounts’ balance
factoring. or over securities.

If, however, the credit operation is an isolated transaction and It is quite common for public project documents to contain
there is no further transaction in the future, it can be upheld that restrictions regarding the granting of security over project assets,
this is not an exercise of a credit activity on a professional basis. which need to be fully considered when granting financing.

In addition, the registration/authorisation with the Bank of


Portugal will not be required if, in respect of a concrete trans-

4
PORTUGAL Law and Practice
Contributed by: Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira, Cuatrecasas

Formalities By way of example, the registration of a mortgage costs EUR250


The applicable formalities vary depending on the type of secu- and the registration of pledges over quotas costs EUR100.
rity that is being taken. In terms of documentation, mortgages
over real estate require a public deed or a document authenti- 2.4 Granting a Valid Security Interest
cated by a notary, while bank account pledges and share pledges Under Portuguese law, any guarantee or security must guarantee
only require a simple private document. Public deeds or notarial or secure another obligation to which it is ancillary, and that
terms of authentication are usually recommended for certain obligation as well as the asset being granted as security needs
types of security as they can be used afterwards as judicial to be identified in the guarantee or security agreement. Accord-
enforcement titles. ingly, the guarantee or security will always follow the underly-
ing secured obligation, as a result of which the invalidity of the
As for possessory or other similar actions, the creation of underlying obligation entails the invalidity of the guarantee or
pledges over movable assets requires the delivery of the asset security, and termination of the underlying obligation entails
to the creditor (unless the pledge at stake is a banking pledge). termination of the guarantee or security.
The assignment of receivables or the pledge of credits requires a
notice of the assignment or the pledge to the respective debtors. 2.5 Restrictions on the Grant of Security or
Guarantees
Registration Requirements Under the Portuguese Companies Code, approved by Decree-
The registration requirements also vary depending on the type Law 262/86, of 2 September, as amended, Portuguese companies
of security at stake. Pledges over bank accounts require a reg- can only grant guarantees or security for third parties’ obliga-
istration with the bank with which the account is held. Con- tions if the company has a justified corporate interest, or if the
versely, pledges over shares are subject to registration with the company is in a controlling or group relationship with the legal
issuer (registration in the share register book and inscription entity or person whose obligations are being secured pursuant
of the pledge in the share certificate), or to registration with to the guarantees or security.
the relevant depositary bank in the case of deposited shares, or
with the relevant financial intermediary with which the shares “Controlling relationship” is defined in the Portuguese Compa-
are registered in the case of dematerialised shares (whether they nies Code as the relationship between Portuguese companies
are integrated in a centralised clearing system or not). where one has a dominant influence over the other, directly
or indirectly. The Portuguese Companies Code contains a legal
Pledges over quotas are also subject to registration with the presumption that such dominant influence exists when one of
commercial registry department. the companies holds, directly or indirectly, the majority of the
capital or voting rights in the other company or the right to
Mortgages over real estate or registrable movable assets – such appoint the majority of the members of the board of directors
as aircrafts, vessels or vehicles – are subject to registration with or supervisory board of the company. The same code defines
the competent registry office (real estate or other), whose reg- “group relationships” as the relationships between Portuguese
istry is public. companies where one of the companies holds, directly or indi-
rectly, 100% of the other, or where the companies have entered
2.2 Charges or Interest over All Present and into a group or a subordination agreement whereby one of them
Future Assets of a Company is subject to the instructions or management of the other.
Portuguese law does not allow for the granting of floating charg-
es or any other universal or similar security interest over all If there is no group or controlling relationship, the guarantee
present and future assets of a company; security is granted over will only be valid if there is a justified corporate interest, with-
specific assets that need to be identified. Security over future out which it can be challenged and considered null and void.
assets can be granted to the extent that they are identifiable, However, Portuguese jurisprudence has been very flexible in
although there are further limitations depending on the type the analysis of this requirement, considering, in the majority of
of security. However, some authors have recently argued the the cases, that it is enough for the company to allege having a
admissibility of floating charges, even if in a limited way. justified corporate interest.

2.3 Registering Collateral Security Interests The Portuguese Companies Code also includes a prohibition
Notarial costs are not material and vary from notary to notary. relating to financial assistance. The guarantees or security grant-
Stamp duty may be a relevant cost (see 8.2 Other Taxes, Duties, ed by a Portuguese company cannot guarantee any obligations
Charges). related to financing incurred for the acquisition of either the
shares representing the share capital of such company or the

5
Law and Practice PORTUGAL
Contributed by: Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira, Cuatrecasas

shares representing the share capital of its direct or indirect the return of share certificates, the cancellation of registrations
parent company. Such guarantees or security would constitute and others, depending on the type of security that is being
unlawful financial assistance, and thus would be considered null released (eg, assignment of receivables).
and void. Breach of the financial assistance prohibition can trig-
ger the liability of the directors of the target company.
3. Enforcement
In order to limit the impact of stamp duty that needs to be paid
in respect of the granting of such guarantees or security, it is 3.1 Enforcement of Collateral by Secured Lender
advisable for the secured obligations to be limited to an agreed Security interests are usually enforced either by the secured
maximum amount, usually related – in the case of security – to parties directly (if no rule of majority applies to enforcement
the value of the asset being encumbered, or to the intrinsic value and the lenders hold the security directly and retain the right
of the Portuguese target or subsidiary company in the case of a to enforce), or by the security agent upon the occurrence of an
guarantee. As a result, Portuguese companies limit their liability enforcement event following an instruction of the majority of
to that maximum amount and will not have a direct obligation lenders, in accordance with the provisions of the intercreditor
to repay any amounts that exceed the agreed threshold. agreement.

Aside from this tax issue, if the assets of the Portuguese com- Although early termination clauses based exclusively on the
panies are covered by legal immunities, namely public domain declaration of insolvency are legally deemed null and void, it is
assets of the Portuguese Republic (domínio público do Estado), generally accepted that they can be allowed in credit agreements
or are allocated to any public service purposes, such companies granted to corporate entities, on the basis of customary practice.
can claim immunity from suit, attachment or other legal pro- In addition, the default that triggers enforcement needs to be
cesses in respect of this. material (such as payment obligations, relevant cross-defaults),
or the early termination of the loan may be considered abusive.
2.6 Absence of Other Liens
Apart from assets that are subject to registration requirements, The procedures for enforcement vary significantly, depending
as is the case for mortgages over real estate or registrable mov- on the type of security.
able assets (such as aircrafts, vessels or vehicles), or pledges over
quotas, which are subject to registration with the competent The enforcement of mortgages is subject to a judicial enforce-
registry office (real estate, commercial or other) and whose reg- ment proceeding, and no private or extrajudicial enforcement is
istry is public, with respect to which any existing liens may be allowed. As a general rule, appropriation by the creditor is not
verified, there is no further central registry where liens may be allowed, so enforcement requires a court sale or an extrajudicial
searchable. Notices to the relevant debtors with respect to the sale. There is an exception to these rules for financial pledges
assignment of receivables is also a mechanism through which over shares and bank accounts, and other financial collateral
to protect the creditors, as the relevant debtor becomes aware arrangements that allow for an appropriation of the asset and
of the assignment and may only be discharged upon payment for an extrajudicial sale, provided that the agreement sets forth
to the notified creditor. rules for the evaluation of the asset (which in the case of bank
accounts is obvious), and for a disposal establishing the under-
2.7 Releasing Forms of Security lying asset even before enforcement. In addition, Decree-Law
As referred to above, under Portuguese law, guarantees and 75/2017, of 26 June, allows for the appropriation of an asset
security are ancillary to the guaranteed or secured obligation, pledged under a certain type of commercial pledge. However,
so the repayment, satisfaction or cancellation in full of such the pledgee is under the obligation to repay the pledgor the
obligations automatically determines the release of the guar- difference between the value of the appropriated asset and the
antees or security. secured amount owed. Finally, the assignment of receivables
only requires a notification to the debtor/client of the borrower
Although the release is automatic, it is market practice to exe- or guarantor to make payments directly to the secured parties.
cute a formal release agreement in order to obtain all necessary
documentation from the lenders, which allows perfection of As a final observation, borrowers or guarantors usually grant a
the release of the security with the relevant authorities. This is power of attorney in favour of the security agent in order for the
particularly relevant if the security had been registered with the latter to have the necessary powers to create additional security
real estate or commercial registration department (in the case over the new asset or to enforce security and sell the assets upon
of mortgages or pledges) or with a bank (in the case of bank the occurrence of an event of default.
pledges). Other actions may also be required, such as notices,

6
PORTUGAL Law and Practice
Contributed by: Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira, Cuatrecasas

3.2 Foreign Law notification (citação), and with respect for the principle of
The choice of a foreign law is valid, recognised and enforceable equal treatment of the parties.
under Portuguese law, unless there is a mandatory provision
that determines the competence of Portuguese law in accord- The request for recognition of a judgment rendered by a court
ance with Regulation (EC) No 593/2008, of 17 June 2008, on the of competent foreign jurisdiction may be challenged if the party
law applicable to contractual obligations (Rome I). against whom the judgment was rendered is a Portuguese citi-
zen or a Portuguese company and the result of the judgment
The submission to a foreign EU jurisdiction is also valid, recog- would be more favourable to that party if the foreign court
nised and enforceable under Portuguese law, provided that the had applied Portuguese law (assuming that the Portuguese law
exclusive jurisdiction provisions set forth in Council Regulation would be applicable according to the Portuguese rules of con-
(EC) No 1215/2012, of 12 December 2012, are complied with. flict of laws).

A waiver of immunity is also recognised, except where, as In respect of foreign arbitral awards, the enforcement scenarios
mentioned above, the assets are in the public domain (bens do may vary depending on the situation. Foreign arbitral awards
domínio público) or are allocated to public interests, or in the that are covered by the New York Convention (the 1958 Con-
case of states and diplomatic sectors. vention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbi-
tral Awards) or by any bilateral agreement between Portugal and
3.3 Judgments of Foreign Courts a foreign state are recognised and can be enforced in Portugal
As mentioned above, Regulation (EC) No 1215/2012, of 12 under the New York Convention or pursuant to the terms of
December 2012, is applicable in Portugal, so judgments ren- the respective bilateral agreement. Foreign arbitral awards that
dered by EU Member State courts are enforceable in Portugal are not covered by the New York Convention or any bilateral
in accordance with the terms of that regulation. agreement are enforceable in Portugal pursuant to the terms of
the internal arbitral legislation.
Assuming that there is no bilateral treaty, judgments ren-
dered by foreign courts outside the EU will be recognised and 3.4 A Foreign Lender’s Ability to Enforce
enforced in Portugal according to the procedures set out in the There are no further matters that might affect a foreign lender’s
Portuguese Code of Civil Procedure, approved by Law 41/2013, ability to enforce its rights under a loan or security agreement,
of 26 June 26, as amended, for the recognition of foreign judg- except that all the documents are required to be translated into
ments, provided that they meet the following requirements: Portuguese, including any enforcement titles.

• the judgment must be final, translated into Portuguese and


apostilled without any doubts as to the authenticity of the 4. Foreign Investment
document and the contents of the judgment;
• the judgment shall not be contrary to Portuguese public 4.1 Restrictions on Foreign Lenders Granting
policy, and the obligation that the petitioner is attempting to Loans
execute has to be lawful in Portugal; Under the Legal Regime of Credit Institutions and Financial
• there shall be no proceeding pending between the same par- Companies approved by Decree-Law 298/92, of 31 December,
ties and in relation to the same issues in Portugal; as amended (the LRCIFC), the granting of loans or financ-
• there shall be no judgment rendered between the same ing – including factoring, financial leasing and the granting of
parties and for the same cause of action in Portugal or in guarantees – on a professional basis is a regulated activity. In
another country; principle, non-banks are not authorised to provide financing to
• the matters under discussion shall not be related to matters a company that is organised in Portugal, unless they are incor-
in which the Portuguese courts consider themselves exclu- porated as one of the credit institutions, financial companies or,
sively competent, and the competency of such foreign courts under certain circumstances, Loan Funds that is duly authorised
shall not have been obtained by unlawfully circumventing by the relevant regulator to exercise such activity.
applicable rules; and
• the defendant’s rights of defence should have been pro- EU-domiciled banks, however, may benefit from the EU pass-
tected when rendering the foreign judgment (princípio do port established in the Banking Directive and be registered with
contraditório), including but not limited to a proper service the Bank of Portugal to carry out credit activity, enjoying the
of process carried out with sufficient time for the defend- freedom to provide services on a cross-border basis without any
ant to prepare its defence and appear before the courts and local presence in Portugal. This registration is made by means
of the credit institution or financial company making a notifica-

7
Law and Practice PORTUGAL
Contributed by: Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira, Cuatrecasas

tion in its home country indicating the activities that it wants 4.4 Restrictions on Payments Abroad or
to render in Portugal, which is then sent by that entity to the Repatriation of Capital
Bank of Portugal to make the respective registration. After such In a broad manner, there are no restrictions on the expatriation
a notification, the credit institution or financial company may of dividends or investments abroad. There are reporting obliga-
start providing its services in Portugal under the EU passport. tions to the Bank of Portugal in respect of certain finance trans-
actions (namely, the transfer of certain amounts of funds), and
However, a non-EU-domiciled entity is only allowed to carry there are also the standard general rules on money laundering.
out banking activities in Portugal through setting up a branch or
incorporating a subsidiary, both of which are subject to specific However, following the COVID-19 crisis, Portuguese financ-
authorisation procedures with the Bank of Portugal. ing supervising authorities have recommended that the corre-
sponding supervised entities should seriously and cautiously
4.2 Restrictions on the Granting of Security or consider the payment of dividends or, in some cases, temporar-
Guarantees to Foreign Lenders ily refraining from dividend distributions.
The granting of security or guarantees is not restricted in terms
of credit activity. However, as a result of generic corporate law 4.5 Offshore Foreign Currency Accounts
rules, as referred to in 2.5 Restrictions on the Grant of Security There are no restrictions regarding the maintenance of offshore
or Guarantees, there are relevant limitations on the granting foreign currency accounts by a project company, although pro-
of guarantees or security, regardless of whether the lenders are ject finance agreements usually contain certain contractual
foreign or domestic. limitations with respect to the opening of accounts other than
the project accounts.
4.3 Foreign Investment Regime
Other than Regulation (EU) 2019/452 of the European Parlia-
ment and of the Council, of 19 March 2019, which established 5. Structuring and Documentation
a framework for the screening of foreign direct investments in Considerations
the EU (the “FDI Screening Regulation”) and will be applicable
from 11 October 2020, there are no general restrictions or con- 5.1 Registering or Filing Financing of Project
trols regarding foreign investment in Portugal as compared to Agreements
the investments of Portuguese entities. There is no registry or filing requirement regarding the validity
and enforceability of project financing agreements, except for
However, Decree-Law 138/2014, of 15 September, establishes security creation formalities. It is advisable for the financing
a safeguard regime regarding key strategic assets to ensure the agreement to be authenticated by a notary or other competent
security of national defence and safety, and the provision of fun- authority in order to grant an enforceable nature (título execu-
damental services in the national interest in the areas of energy, tivo) to the acknowledgment of payment.
transport and communications, and sets out specific restrictions
on foreign investment by overseas entities (outside the EU and 5.2 Licence Requirements
the European Economic Area). Except for public domain assets, which are not capable of being
appropriated by private entities, the ownership of land or natu-
Such restrictions are considered on a case-by-case basis, ral resources does not require a licence, nor does the undertak-
through the verification of certain criteria, following which the ing of a business of ownership or the operation of such assets.
Portuguese Council of Ministers may oppose the completion of However, in some cases, the exercise of a specific economic
the relevant transaction over such key strategic asset. activity, by either domestic or foreign entities, may require a
licence or a right of use.
Although lacking a hard law value, on 26 March 2020 the Euro-
pean Commission, in connection with the COVID-19 crisis, 5.3 Agent and Trust Concepts
provided guidance to the Member States concerning, inter alia, Contrary to other jurisdictions, Portuguese law does not rec-
foreign direct investment, aimed at protecting Europe’s strategic ognise the concept of parallel debt or trusteeship, except for a
assets, such as healthcare capacities or related industries, ahead very specific regime in the Madeira Free Trade Zone. Therefore,
of the application of the FDI Screening Regulation. the beneficiary of the security needs to have a valid underlying
obligation duly secured by the security and, accordingly, if the
lenders want to be able to enforce security directly they will
need to appear and be registered as holders of the security with
the competent registration department.

8
PORTUGAL Law and Practice
Contributed by: Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira, Cuatrecasas

Typically, the security agreement and/or the indenture, as well 5.5 Local Law Requirements
as the intercreditor agreement, provides that only the security As a general rule, there is no restriction on project companies
agent has the right to enforce the security documents in its being incorporated in other jurisdictions, but the concession-
capacity as agent (mandatário com representação), and also as aire must be incorporated as a Portuguese company for public
a joint and several creditor (credor solidário), and will thus be concession projects, usually as a share limited liability company
the only entity registered as a beneficiary of the security and the (sociedade anónima).
only entity legally entitled to enforce it.

Accordingly, the guarantee or security is usually enforced by the 6. Bankruptcy and Insolvency
security agent after the occurrence of an event of default and
following instructions from the lenders in accordance with the 6.1 Company Reorganisation Procedures
provisions of the intercreditor agreement or the relevant secu- Currently, there are two main rescue or reorganisation proce-
rity agreement (or the indenture, as the case may be). dures outside of insolvency proceedings:

Alternatively, the banks may request to have the security regis- • RERE – Regime Extrajudicial de Recuperação de Empresas
tered in their own name, and have the ability to enforce it upon (Out of Court Recovery Proceeding); and
the occurrence of an event of default. This structure is more • PER – Processo Especial de Revitalização (Special Revitalisa-
common when Portuguese banks are involved. tion Proceeding).

5.4 Competing Security Interests The RERE is an extrajudicial voluntary mechanism that aims
Under Portuguese law, the priority of competing security inter- to allow a company in financial difficulties or imminent insol-
ests is determined by the date of registration of the security vency to achieve recovery through negotiations with (one or
interest if the security is subject to registration, such as in the more) creditors in order to reach an agreement (as a general
cases of mortgages over real estate, vessels, aircrafts, factory and rule, a confidential agreement) leading to its revitalisation. If
car mortgages, pledges over quotas, pledges over bank accounts the negotiations produce the effects provided for in the RERE,
and pledges over deposited and dematerialised shares. Con- the company and the creditors, representing at least 15% of the
versely, if no registration is required and there only needs to company’s liabilities (non-subordinated), must sign a negotia-
be an act of transfer of possession, priority is determined by tion protocol and promote its deposit at the commercial regis-
the date on which the relevant perfection requirements of the try office. Should the legal requirements be met, the agreement
security are completed – namely, the act of possession by the reached will have the same effects as if it was approved in the
creditor or similar (eg, notification to debtors in the assignment context of a Special Revitalisation Proceeding. The company
of receivables). may benefit from the intervention of a corporate recovery
mediator.
Contractual subordination is allowed under Portuguese law:
creditors are able to qualify their debt as subordinated and have Conversely, at a time prior to insolvency, the PER aims to allow
it treated as such in an insolvency proceeding. However, con- a debtor that is in financial difficulties or imminent insolven-
tractual subordination is only recognised if it is made before all cy, but whose recovery is still feasible, to enter into negotia-
creditors (eg, deeply subordinated debt) and not just before cer- tions with creditors in order to reach an agreement with them,
tain creditors (eg, mezzanine debt). This is because insolvency leading to its revitalisation. The PER basically allows for the
law has general categories of creditors, such as secured creditors, debtor to have a moratorium from creditors whilst trying to
common creditors and subordinated creditors. Therefore, the agree a recovery plan with them. The approval of the recovery
waterfall provisions of intercreditor agreements are not recog- plan requires a vote to be held among creditors whose claims
nised in an insolvency proceeding and, as such, distributions represent at least one-third of the total voting-related credits
need to be corrected amongst creditors after the proceeds have contained in the list of credits, which results in a favourable
been received in an insolvency proceeding based on the pay- vote of more than two-thirds of the votes cast and more than
ment provisions of the intercreditor agreement. half of the votes cast corresponding to non-subordinated claims;
alternatively, it is necessary to obtain a favourable vote of credi-
Structural subordination with financing made to holding com- tors whose claims represent more than half of the total vot-
panies or legal subordination that results from law is also per- ing rights and more than half of these votes corresponding to
mitted under Portuguese law. non-subordinated claims. Sometimes this plan may be agreed
beforehand with the necessary majority of the creditors for the

9
Law and Practice PORTUGAL
Contributed by: Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira, Cuatrecasas

revitalisation plan to be approved, which facilitates the revitali- • personal guarantees, sub-guarantees, sureties and credit
sation process considerably. mandates made within six months prior to the beginning of
the insolvency proceeding; and
Furthermore, the Legal Framework for Conversion of Debt • the granting of in rem guarantees simultaneously to the
into Equity, approved by Law 7/2018, of 2 March, aims to allow creation of the secured obligations within 60 days prior to
companies that are in a negative equity position to restructure the beginning of the insolvency proceeding.
their balance sheet and strengthen their equity, assuming that a
majority of creditors proposes a conversion of debt into equity. These automatic claw-back actions do not apply to financial col-
This framework is reserved for situations that are objectively lateral arrangements, such as financial pledges.
justified by an independent professional and require the pro-
posing creditors to hold claims of an amount which, in other In addition, any enforcement of guarantees and security will
conditions, would allow them to approve a recovery plan in need to be lodged within the insolvency proceeding of the
insolvency proceedings. guarantor, except for certain types of security, such as financial
collateral arrangements. Therefore, all future enforcement pro-
Due to the economic impacts sustained by companies arising ceedings are no longer allowed and the ones currently pending
from the COVID-19 pandemic, the Portuguese government has will be suspended, and the creditors will need to lodge their
announced a legislative initiative pertaining to a new and excep- claims in the insolvency proceeding and wait for the liquidation
tional reorganisation procedure: the Companies Extraordinary of the assets and payment to creditors within that proceeding.
Viability Procedure (Processo Extraordinário de Viabilização de
Empresas – the PEVE). Although the legal framework has yet to 6.3 Priority of Creditors
be published, it has been disclosed that the PEVE is intended to The Portuguese Insolvency Code, approved by Decree-Law
serve as a temporary judicial proceeding to which companies in 53/2004, of 18 August, as amended, outlines the following cat-
financial difficulties or in an insolvency situation (either actual egories and ranking of credits:
or imminent) may recur, provided such difficulties or insol-
vency are caused by COVID-19. Throughout this procedure, • credits over the insolvency estate, which are credits acquired
the legal effects arising therefrom are similar to those of the PER by the debtor after the insolvency declaration as well as the
and, upon its conclusion and subject to the legal requirements, necessary amounts to pay the expenses related to the insol-
the agreement reached by the debtor and its creditors regard- vency proceedings (eg, judicial costs);
ing the reorganisation of the former shall be judicially certified. • guaranteed credits, which are credits benefiting from
guarantees in rem, including special creditor’s privilege
Finally, the transposition deadline for Directive (EU) 2019/1023 (privilégios creditórios especiais), paid out of the proceeds of
of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 June the sale of the secured asset once the sale expenses and any
2019, on preventative restructuring frameworks, on discharge amount allocated to credits over the estate are deducted. If
of debt and disqualifications, and on measures to increase the the secured assets are insufficient to pay all debts owed to
efficiency of procedures concerning restructuring, insolvency guaranteed creditors, any remaining debt is treated and paid
and discharge of debt, is tointroduce several amendments to as common credits (eg, state credits related to real estate
the company reorganisation procedures legal framework, which property tax – IMI);
will depend largely on the national legislative options. • privileged credits, which are credits benefiting from general
creditor’s privilege (privilégios creditórios gerais) over assets
6.2 Impact of Insolvency Process comprising the insolvent estate, up to the amount cor-
If contractually foreseen, the declaration of insolvency triggers, responding to the value of the assets that are the object of
in principle, the automatic acceleration of the liabilities of the the guarantees or of the general privileges (eg, employment
insolvent entity and, as such, an automatic acceleration of the credits), and real estate general statutory liens;
loan. • common credits, which are all credits not included in other
categories; and
In respect of guarantees, the declaration of insolvency deter- • subordinated credits, which are interests and credits held
mines the automatic claw-back of the following actions: by persons with special relations with the debtor (eg,
controlling shareholder, the directors, and members of the
• the granting of in rem guarantees ancillary to pre-existing supervisory board).
obligations, or others that replace them, within six months
prior to the beginning of the insolvency proceeding;

10
PORTUGAL Law and Practice
Contributed by: Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira, Cuatrecasas

6.4 Risk Areas for Lenders and/or Taxes on Insurance Policies. In any case, a review of the
Aside from the risks regarding claw-back actions and automatic respective insurance policy is always advisable.
acceleration, all security over the assets of the insolvent entity
(except for financial collateral arrangements) will need to be
enforced in the respective insolvency proceeding and, accord- 8. Tax
ingly, the creditors will need to wait for the liquidation of the
assets and respective payment to creditors. Furthermore, any 8.1 Withholding Tax
pending judicial enforcement proceedings will be suspended, Under the Portuguese Corporate Income Tax (the CIT) rules
and the creditors will need to lodge their claims in the insol- currently in force, interest owed by Portuguese residents to non-
vency proceeding and wait for the liquidation of the assets and resident entities is liable to final withholding tax thereon, at the
payment to creditors in such proceeding. domestic rate of 25%, over the interest gross amount.

In addition, and from a practical perspective, it should also be However, the domestic withholding tax rate may be reduced
noted that the insolvency proceeding can jeopardise the day- pursuant to the provisions of a double taxation agreement con-
to-day functioning of the company (debtor; guarantor or other) cluded between Portugal and the country of residence of the
and, as such, the value of the company and recoveries of the lender, typically to 10% or 15%.
lender. Also, the special recovery processes referred to above
depend on the will of the debtor, which makes it more difficult Notwithstanding, interest derived from loans granted by non-
to initiate a recovery proceeding based on an agreement exclu- resident financial institutions to resident credit institutions is
sively between creditors. exempt from withholding tax to the extent that the interest is
not allocated to a local permanent establishment of the non-
6.5 Entities Excluded from Bankruptcy resident creditor.
Proceedings
As a general rule, bankruptcy proceedings will apply to any Non-residents may also benefit from a withholding tax exemp-
person or legal entity, except the Portuguese Republic and tion on interest derived from listed bonds, pursuant to the
public entities. Insurance companies, credit institutions and regime set forth in Decree-Law 193/2005, of 7 November, as
financial companies, amongst others, are also excluded from amended (this regime also provides for a capital gains exemp-
these type of proceedings, to the extent their submission to a tion upon disposal of the bonds). Please see 8.2 Other Taxes,
bankruptcy proceeding is not compatible with the relevant legal Duties, Charges regarding the treatment of funding obtained
frameworks. The LRCIFC specifically governs the insolvency of through the issue of bonds.
credit institutions.
In summary, and to the extent that the necessary requirements
regarding the beneficiaries (ie, holders of the bonds) are met,
7. Insurances no withholding tax applies over the interest, to the extent that:

7.1 Restrictions, Controls, Fees and/or Taxes on • all the necessary formalities are duly fulfilled – namely,
Insurance Policies proof is provided of the non-residence status of the benefi-
It is not common to have restrictions, controls, fees and/or taxes ciaries and the required data regarding the debt securities
on insurance policies over project assets provided or guaran- and the beneficiaries; and
teed by insurance companies. Nevertheless, third party liability • the bonds are integrated in a centralised system for securi-
insurance policies receivables, for instance, are not assignable. ties managed by an entity resident in Portugal for tax
Additionally, it is common for public project agreements to con- purposes (ie, Interbolsa), or an international clearing system
tain restrictions regarding the assignment of receivables that managing entity established in another EU Member State
may be required for the repair of the subject of the concession (ie, Euroclear and Clearstream Luxembourg) or in an EEA
if repairable. Member State, provided it is bound by an administrative
co-operation in tax matters similar to the one established
7.2 Foreign Creditors within the EU or integrated in other centralised systems as
The assignment of insurance receivables is part of the typical long as, in this last case, the competent government member
Portuguese collateral package so there are no specific restric- authorises the application of the special tax regime.
tions with respect to the payment of insurance policies over
project assets to foreign creditors or Portuguese creditors, apart Finally, it should be noted that the Court of Justice of the Euro-
from the ones referred to in 7.1 Restrictions, Controls, Fees pean Union found that the Portuguese domestic CIT rules

11
Law and Practice PORTUGAL
Contributed by: Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira, Cuatrecasas

imposing withholding tax over interest obtained by non-resi- The extension of the term of the contract is considered as a new
dents are in breach of EU Law, considering that the withholding granting of credit, and so raises additional taxation. Stamp Duty
is imposed on the gross amount of the interest, whereas resident is borne by the borrower.
financial institutions are (only) taxed on their net income (deci-
sion of 13 July 2016 on Brisal - Auto Estradas do Litoral SA, No Stamp Duty applies to funding obtained through the issue
KBC Finance Ireland v Fazenda Publica - Case C-18/15). This of bonds over the principal or interest (see comments below
decision was expected to raise amendments to the Portuguese regarding the taxation of interest).
tax rules, but this has not yet occurred.
The granting of security is also subject to Stamp Duty in the
The reimbursement of the principal and other payments to the following circumstances:
lender are not liable to Portuguese withholding tax.
• if it is granted in the Portuguese territory;
8.2 Other Taxes, Duties, Charges • if it is for the benefit of a Portuguese-resident entity; or
Value Added Tax (VAT) • if it is presented to produce legal effects, with exceptions
As a rule, financial operations are exempt from VAT under made if it is a material accessory to a taxable Stamp Duty
domestic VAT law. This exemption notably covers the grant- event, and granted simultaneously with it.
ing and negotiation of credit, the respective administration and
management by the entity granting the credit, the negotiation Stamp Duty is borne by the entity required to present the guar-
and granting of security and guarantees, and operations, includ- antee (ie, the debtor).
ing negotiation, related to deposits of funds, current accounts,
payments, transfers, collections and cheques. Accordingly, where security is granted within the context of a
loan agreement, it tends not to be subject to Stamp Duty as the
The VAT treatment of bank commissions and fees has to be use of credit under the loan agreement will be by itself subject
determined on a case-by-case basis, depending on their actual to taxation (provided that the above conditions are met), such
features, although those commissions corresponding to the as in the case where a Portuguese company borrows funds from
operations referred to above shall be VAT-exempt in principle. a non-resident bank. In funding through the issue of bonds, the
security granted for the benefit of the relevant bondholders may
Other commissions or fees charged by the banks – eg, for con- trigger Portuguese Stamp Duty.
sultancy, certain structuring and settlement services – are, in
principle, outside the scope of the exemption, so are liable to When due, the Stamp Duty taxable basis is the value of the
VAT taxation. If these fees are charged by non-resident banks to underlying security (ie, maximum secured amount), being the
Portuguese VAT taxpayers, Portuguese VAT will apply by means effective tax rate dependent on the applicable term, as follows:
of the reverse charge mechanism.
• security with a term lower than one year: 0.04% per month
Financial operations that are subject to but exempt from VAT or fraction thereof;
are liable to Stamp Duty, as referred to below. • security with a term equal to one year and up to five years:
0.5%; and
Stamp Duty • security with a term equal to or longer than five years, or
Portuguese Stamp Duty is due on a list of specified taxable without any specific term: 0.6%.
events, when deemed as occurring in Portugal, including a
number of operations, contracts, acts and documents, as out- In the case of operations undertaken by or with the intermedia-
lined in the Stamp Duty Chart, including financial operations. tion of credit institutions, financing companies or other entities
legally equated to them, or by any other financial institutions,
The granting of credit is liable to Stamp Duty, which is levied interest is also liable to Stamp Duty (over the respective amount,
over the principal at rates that depend on the term during which at a rate of 4%), as well as commissions and other bank fees, over
the credit is used, as follows: the respective amount at a rate of 3% (commissions for guaran-
tees) or 4% (other commissions and fees for financial services).
• credit for less than one year: 0.04% per month or fraction;
• credit for one or more years: 0.5%; and As anticipated above, no Stamp Duty is levied over operations
• credit for five or more years: 0.6%. that are subject to and not exempt from VAT – eg, those bank
commissions subject to and not exempt from VAT.

12
PORTUGAL Law and Practice
Contributed by: Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira, Cuatrecasas

Notwithstanding the above, an exemption applies to interest and 9. Applicable Law


commissions charged, security granted, and the use of credit
granted by credit institutions, financial companies and financial 9.1 Project Agreements
institutions to venture capital companies, as well as to compa- Portuguese law is mandatorily applicable to concession agree-
nies or entities whose form and object correspond to those of ments and other project documents related thereto entered into
credit institutions, financial companies, financial institutions with public entities. With respect to agreements entered into
foreseen in EU Law, both domiciled in EU Member States or with private entities, parties are free to choose the governing
in other States with the exception of jurisdictions with a more law, pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 of the European
favourable tax regime, as defined by Order no 150/2004, of 13 Parliament and of the Council, of 17 June 2008, on the law
February, of the Ministry of Finance (as amended by Order no applicable to contractual obligations (Rome I), and Portuguese
291/2011, of 8 November, of the Ministry of Finance). courts will uphold the applicability of the law specified as gov-
erning such agreements, unless such applicability would be ille-
8.3 Limits to the Amount of Interest Charged gal or would contravene Portuguese public policy principles, or
Although Portuguese law includes several provisions regard- unless it relates to foreclosure procedures occurring in Portugal,
ing the amount of interest that may be charged in Portugal, in which case Portuguese law shall apply to such procedures
such provisions are mainly applicable to credit relations with regardless of the foreign law contractually designated.
consumers, and are therefore not applicable to project finance
agreements entered into with Portuguese companies, with 9.2 Financing Agreements
respect to which few provisions shall be applicable, namely Parties are free to choose the governing law of the financing
regarding default surplus interest rate, which is subject to a agreements, although, there has been a growing trend to impose
maximum amount of 3% over the agreement interest rate. Portuguese law as the governing law within tender documents,
with respect to public projects. However, the choice of English
law is quite common, particularly regarding projects involving
international lending syndicates or projects financed by Portu-
guese banks to favour future syndication.

9.3 Domestic Laws


Regardless of the law governing the financing or project agree-
ment, Portuguese conflict of law rules determine that the crea-
tion of security interests over assets located in Portugal shall be
governed by Portuguese law.

13
Law and Practice PORTUGAL
Contributed by: Manuel Requicha Ferreira and Margarida Leal Oliveira, Cuatrecasas

Cuatrecasas is a leading Iberian law firm with its main offices funds, supervisory authorities and governmental entities. The
in Portugal and Spain, and an international presence through firm offers high-standard advice in the context of clients’ inter-
offices in 12 other countries. Clients include companies in national strategies.
all commercial and industrial sectors, financial institutions,

Authors
Manuel Requicha Ferreira is a partner in Margarida Leal Oliveira is a counsel in
the banking, finance and capital markets the banking, finance and capital markets
practice of Cuatrecasas. The main projects practice of Cuatrecasas. With extensive
on which he has advised in recent years experience and in-depth knowledge in the
include banking law and regulatory banking and finance area, she has rendered
matters, structured finance, corporate advice in banking acquisitions, debt
finance and financing operations, through restructurings, structured finance,
simple or structured debt issues from public or private entities corporate finance, privatisations, and project finance
and public offers of distribution or takeovers. transactions, on the side of either the corporates or the
financing entities, with her main focus being on road
concessions, health and the energy PPP sector.

Cuatrecasas
Praça Marquês de Pombal 2
1250-160 Lisboa
Portugal

Tel: +351 21 355 38 00


Fax: +351 21 353 23 62
Email: manuel.requichaferreira@cuatrecasas.com;
mlealoliveira@cuatrecasas.com
Web: www.cuatrecasas.com

14

You might also like